The relative contribution of electrostatic interactions to stabilization of collagen fibrils

Electrostatic energies of interaction between type I collagen molecules were calculated, using models developed by Timasheff and Hill. These energies, along with a contribution from hydrophobic forces, were then incorporated into an equation due to Flory that described phase equilibria of rod-like polymers. The Flory formalism in turn permitted a calculation of the overall free energy of fibril formation (delta Ff), and an assessment of the relative contribution of electrostatic and hydrophobic forces to delta Ff. Lastly, delta Ff was used in a nucleation-growth model relating halftimes of fibril formation (t1/2) to ionic strength (I) and temperature. Because the theory provided no basis for setting absolute levels of the energetic contributions, five parameters in the model had to be derived from experimental data. Based on the fit of theory to experimental results both for intact and pepsinized collagen, it was found that very low electrostatic energies (about -1 kcal/mole per collagen molecule) were sufficient to explain experimental t1/2 vs I relationships. This energy is equivalent to 1 close charge-pair interaction per molecule and appears to be lower than the energy assignable to hydrophobic interactions.     

The stabilization of in vivo assembled collagen fibrils by proteoglycans/glycosaminoglycans

The effects of proteoglycans/glycosaminoglycans on the thermal stability of in vivo assembled collagen fibrils have been examined. The shrinkage temperature of tendon collagen was found to be linearly dependent on the concentration of chondroitin sulphate in the surrounding fluid. Enzymic pretreatment of articular cartilage, to reduce its glycosaminoglycan content, resulted in decreased stability of the collagen present. The stability of the collagen in hyaluronidase-treated cartilage was found to be higher when measured in a solution of chondroitin sulphate (30 g/dl) than in buffer alone. The results of this study demonstrate that the proteoglycans stabilize collagen fibrils in tissues such as articular cartilage.     

The C-terminal extrahelical peptide of type I collagen and its role in fibrillogenesis in vitro

The formation in vitro of fibrils from type I acid-soluble calf skin collagen has been studied before and after removal of the extrahelical peptides with carboxypeptidase and with pepsin. Turbidimetric studies show that the mechanism of fibril growth in undigested collagen is similar to that in pepsin-digested collagen; following carboxypeptidase digestion, however, a different growth mechanism was apparent. The two mechanisms have been further characterized by electron microscopy. In the course of formation of fibrils from undigested collagen, “early fibrils” (short D-periodic fibrils that have both ends visible) occurred in the lag phase under the precipitating conditions employed here. After pepsin or carboxypeptidase digestion of the collagen no “early fibrils” were seen. In carboxypeptidase-digested collagen, lateral assembly was inhibited; after pepsin digestion, linear assembly was inhibited. Complete removal of the extrahelical peptides prevented fibril formation under the conditions used here. Electron-optical examination of segment-long-spacing (SLS) dimers established a more complete removal of the C-terminal peptide after carboxypeptidase digestion than after pepsin digestion. Analyses of staining patterns of SLS dimers and fibrils from undigested and digested samples showed that the C-terminal peptide in SLS crystallites and fibrils formed from undigested collagen is in a condensed conformation. A proposed conformation, in which condensation occurs predominantly in a hydrophobic region at the proximal end of the C-terminal peptide, is discussed in terms of a dual role for the C-terminal peptide in fibrillogenesis. One role, shared with the N-terminal peptide, is to participate in interactions between the 4D-staggered molecules leading to the formation of linear aggregates; the other is to participate in interactions between these linear aggregates giving rise to D-periodic aggregates and lateral (as well as linear) growth.     

Failure of mineralized collagen fibrils: modeling the role of collagen cross-linking

Experimental evidence demonstrates that collagen cross-linking in bone tissue significantly influences its deformation and failure behavior yet difficulties exist in determining the independent biomechanical effects of collagen cross-linking using in vitro and in vivo experiments. The aim of this study is to use a nano-scale composite material model of mineral and collagen to determine the independent roles of enzymatic and non-enzymatic cross-linking on the mechanical behavior of a mineralized collagen fibril. Stress–strain curves were obtained under tensile loading conditions without any collagen cross-links, with only enzymatic cross-links (modeled by cross-linking the end terminal position of each collagen domain), or with only non-enzymatic cross-links (modeled by random placement of cross-links within the collagen–collagen interfaces). Our results show enzymatic collagen cross-links have minimal effect on the predicted stress–strain curve and produce a ductile material that fails through debonding of the mineral–collagen interface. Conversely, non-enzymatic cross-links significantly alter the predicted stress–strain response by inhibiting collagen sliding. This inhibition leads to greater load transfer to the mineral, which minimally affects the predicted stress, increases modulus and decreases post-yield strain and toughness. As a consequence the toughness of bone that has more non-enzymatically mediated collagen cross-links will be drastically reduced.     

A role for glycosaminoglycans in the development of collagen fibrils

Extensive data on the glycosaminoglycan (GAG) composition and the collagen fibril diameter distribution have been collected for a diverse range of connective tissues. It is shown that tissues with the smallest diameter collagen fibrils (mass-average diameter less than 60 nm) have high concentrations of hyaluronic acid and that tissues with the largest diameter collagen fibrils (mass-average diameter approximately 200 nm) have high concentrations of dermatan sulphate. It is suggested that the lateral growth of fibrils beyond a diameter of about 60 nm is inhibited by the presence of an excess of hyaluronic acid but that this inhibitory effect may be removed by an increasing concentration of chondroitin sulphate and/or dermatan sulphate. It is also postulated that high concentrations of chondroitin sulphate will inhibit fibril growth beyond a mass-average diameter of approximately 150 nm. Such an inhibition may in turn be removed by an increasing concentration of dermatan sulphate such that it becomes the dominant GAG present in the tissue.     

The C-terminal extrahelical peptide of type I collagen and its role in fibrillogenesis in vitro: effects of ethylurea

Ethylurea was used to weaken hydrophobic interactions during collagen fibrillogenesis in vitro. Intact and enzyme-digested type I collagen was studied. In all preparations, ethylurea decreased the extent and rate of fibril formation, inhibition being greatest in the enzyme-digested collagens. With intact collagen (and probably also with carboxypeptidasedigested collagen), there was no evidence the ethylurea altered the mechanism of fibril growth; in pepsin-digested collagen, however, the growth mechanism was altered by ethylurea, possibly reflecting a conformational change of the “hydrophobic cluster” in the C-terminal peptide. Such a structural change could occur in a hydrophobic environment once the distal portion of the C-terminal peptide (presumed to be essential for its structural stability) is removed by pepsin. The results further emphasize the importance of hydrophobic interactions in collagen fibril nucleation and growth in vitro.     

The precipitation of toroidal collagen fibrils

The morphology of aggregates of calf-skin tropocollagen, precipitated by continuous injection into neutral phosphate buffers at 35 degrees , has been studied by electron microscopy. Although most of the collagen is precipitated as normal native fibrils, a small proportion forms closed toroidal structures having the usual native band-interband pattern. Theoretical considerations, based on elastic energies in a general microfibril model, predict that the toroids should have a simple super-helical structure, and this is not inconsistent with the observations. From the theoretical energies it was possible to estimate a crude lower limit of 3kcal./mole for the free energy of association of the tropocollagen macromolecules.     

To achieve self‐assembled collagen mimetic fibrils using designed peptides

It has proven challenging to obtain collagen‐mimetic fibrils by protein design. We recently reported the self‐assembly of a mini‐fibril showing a 35 nm, D‐period like, axially repeating structure using the designed triple helix Col108. Peptide Col108 was made by bacterial expression using a synthetic gene; its triple helix domain consists of three pseudo‐identical units of amino acid sequence arranged in tandem. It was postulated that the 35 nm d‐period of Col108 mini‐fibrils originates from the periodicity of the Col108 primary structure. A mutual staggering of one sequence unit of the associating Col108 triple helices can maximize the inter‐helical interactions and produce the observed 35 nm d‐period. Based on this unit‐staggered model, a triple helix consisting of only two sequence units is expected to have the potential to form the same d‐periodic mini‐fibrils. Indeed, when such a peptide, peptide 2U108, was made it was found to self‐assemble into mini‐fibrils having the same d‐period of 35 nm. In contrast, no d‐periodic mini‐fibrils were observed for peptide 1U108, which does not have long‐range repeating sequences in its primary structure. The findings of the periodic mini‐fibrils of Col108 and 2U108 suggest a way forward to create collagen‐mimetic fibrils for biomedical and industrial applications.     

The intermolecular space of reconstituted collagen fibrils

The extent, geometry and heterogeneity of the intermolecular space of hydrated, purified and reconstituted steer skin collagen fibrils has been characterized. The extent of the space has been assessed experimentally by an X-ray diffraction method and a new physical chemical technique, and found to be 1.14 ml per gram collagen. A theoretical model relating the intermolecular space to X-ray diffraction parameters has been presented, and this suggests that the geometry of the intermolecular space arises from a near-hexagonal packing of the collagen molecules. On the basis of an assumed microfibrillar packing model and a geometric construction of the shape of a collagen molecule, the distribution of the space within reconstituted collagen fibrils has been characterized as follows: 0.13 ml of the intermolecular space/g collagen can be attributed to the helical groove of the collagen molecules per se and 1.01 ml/g is interstitial; 0.66 ml/g is present in the form of “pores” (hexagonally-closed packed spaces), whereas 0.48 ml/g is present in the form of “holes” (hexagonal volume defects); 0.73 ml/g of the intermolecular space is associated with a region of the collagen fibrils where holes are localized and 0.41 ml/g is attributable to the regions of the fibril in which pores only are present.     

Crystalline regions in collagen fibrils

A new image processing technique, content-dependent anisotropic spatial frequency filtering, has been developed to visualize the location and orientation of crystalline regions in collagen fibril cross-sections. The results show that most crystalline regions are oriented with their approximately 4 nm periodicity directed radially from the fibril centre. This periodicity corresponds to the separation between rows of molecular ends in the quasi-hexagonal molecular packing scheme. The extent of crystallinity increases with radius and frequently the lattice is either continuously distorted or interrupted by sharp discontinuities.     

The crystalline structure of collagen fibrils in tendon.

New data have been collected on the crystalline structure of collagen fibrils in tendon. The unit cell in decrimped tendon has been determined by measurements of the Bragg reflections in the X-ray diffraction pattern. The results are consistent with a triclinic cell with $\text{b = 75.5}\text{A}\text{?}$, β = 93 °, $\text{a =}\text{b}\text{sin}\text{β}$, a = 90 °, $\text{c = n × 668}\text{A}\text{?}$, where n is probably 4 and γ = 90 °. A selection rule observed for prominent reflections is explicable either in terms of a specific orientation of the microfibrils on the lattice, or by a helical distortion of the microfibril axis. The cell parameter β can be varied by changing the ionic envirionment.     

Mechanical properties of collagen fibrils

The formation of collagen fibers from staggered subfibrils still lacks a universally accepted model. Determining the mechanical properties of single collagen fibrils (diameter 50-200 nm) provides new insights into collagen structure. In this work, the reduced modulus of collagen was measured by nanoindentation using atomic force microscopy. For individual type 1 collagen fibrils from rat tail, the modulus was found to be in the range from 5 GPa to 11.5 GPa (in air and at room temperature). The hypothesis that collagen anisotropy is due to the subfibrils being aligned along the fibril axis is supported by nonuniform surface imprints performed by high load nanoindentation.     

Silver staining of collagen fibrils in cartilage

Summary Direct visualization of individual collagen fibrils by light microscopy in human cartilage was achieved by applying a periodic acid-silver methenamine stain on plastic sections. Collagen fibrils, 100 nm in diameter or thicker, were delineated individually by light microscopy and were easily traced for a length beyond 100m. Thinner fibrils not readily visible optically were identified if arranged in compact bundles as occurring in the superficial zone of articular cartilage.     

Stabilization of collagen fibrils by hydroxyproline

The substitution of hydroxyproline for proline in position Y of the repeating Gly-X-Y tripeptide sequence of collagen-like poly(tripeptide)s (i.e., in the position in which Hyp occurs naturally) is predicted to enhance the stability of aggregates of triple helices, while the substitution of Hyp in position X (where no Hyp occurs naturally) is predicted to decrease the stability of aggregates. Earlier conformational energy computations have indicated that two triple helices composed of poly(Gly-Pro-Pro) polypeptide chains pack preferentially with a nearly parallel orientation of the helix axes [Nemethy, G., & Scheraga, H.A. (1984) Biopolymers 23, 2781-2799]. Conformational energy computations reported here indicate that the same packing arrangement is preferred for the packing of two poly(Gly-Pro-Hyp) triple helices. The OH groups of the Hyp residues can be accommodated in the space between the two packed triple helices without any steric hindrance. They actually contribute about 1.9 kcal/mol per Gly-Pro-Hyp tripeptide to the packing energy, as a result of the formation of weak hydrogen bonds and other favorable noncovalent interatomic interactions. On the other hand, the substitution of Hyp in position X weakens the packing by about 1.7 kcal/mol per Gly-Hyp-Pro tripeptide. Numerous published experimental studies have established that Hyp in position Y stabilizes an isolated triple helix relative to dissociated random coils, while Hyp in position X has the opposite effect. We propose that Hyp in position Y also enhances the stability of the assembly of collagen into microfibrils while, in position X, it decreases this stability.     

Viscoelastic properties of isolated collagen fibrils

Understanding the viscoelastic behavior of collagenous tissues with complex hierarchical structures requires knowledge of the properties at each structural level. Whole tissues have been studied extensively, but less is known about the mechanical behavior at the submicron, fibrillar level. Using a microelectromechanical systems platform, in vitro coupled creep and stress relaxation tests were performed on collagen fibrils isolated from the sea cucumber dermis. Stress-strain-time data indicate that isolated fibrils exhibit viscoelastic behavior that could be fitted using the Maxwell-Weichert model. The fibrils showed an elastic modulus of 123 ± 46 MPa. The time-dependent behavior was well fit using the two-time-constant Maxwell-Weichert model with a fast time response of 7 ± 2 s and a slow time response of 102 ± 5 s. The fibrillar relaxation time was smaller than literature values for tissue-level relaxation time, suggesting that tissue relaxation is dominated by noncollagenous components (e.g., proteoglycans). Each specimen was tested three times, and the only statistically significant difference found was that the elastic modulus is larger in the first test than in the subsequent two tests, indicating that viscous properties of collagen fibrils are not sensitive to the history of previous tests.