A ubiquitous beta-tubulin disrupts microtubule assembly and inhibits cell proliferation

Vertebrate tubulin is encoded by a multigene family that produces distinct gene products, or isotypes, of both the alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits. The isotype sequences are conserved across species supporting the hypothesis that different isotypes subserve different functions. To date, however, most studies have demonstrated that tubulin isotypes are freely interchangeable and coassemble into all classes of microtubules. We now report that, in contrast to other isotypes, overexpression of a mouse class V beta-tubulin cDNA in mammalian cells produces a strong, dose-dependent disruption of microtubule organization, increased microtubule fragmentation, and a concomitant reduction in cellular microtubule polymer levels. These changes also disrupt mitotic spindle assembly and block cell proliferation. Consistent with diminished microtubule assembly, there is an increased tolerance for the microtubule stabilizing drug, paclitaxel, which is able to reverse many of the effects of class V beta-tubulin overexpression. Moreover, transfected cells selected in paclitaxel exhibit increased expression of class V beta-tubulin, indicating that this isotype is responsible for the drug resistance. The results show that class V beta-tubulin is functionally distinct from other tubulin isotypes and imparts unique properties on the microtubules into which it incorporates.     

Free intermingling of mammalian beta-tubulin isotypes among functionally distinct microtubules

Mammalian cells express a spectrum of tubulin isotypes whose relationship to the diversity of microtubule function is unknown. To examine whether different isotypes are segregated into functionally distinct microtubules, we generated immune sera capable of discriminating among the various naturally occurring beta-tubulin isotypes. Cloned fusion proteins encoding each isotype were used first to tolerogenize animals against shared epitopes, and then as immunogens to elicit a specific response. In experiments using these sera, we show that there is neither complete nor partial segregation of beta-tubulin isotypes: both interphase cytoskeletal and mitotic spindle microtubules are mixed copolymers of all expressed beta-tubulin isotypes. Indeed, a highly divergent isotype normally expressed only in certain hematopoietic cells is also indiscriminately assembled into all microtubules both in their normal context and when transfected into HeLa cells.     

Posttranslational modification of brain tubulins from the Antarctic fish Notothenia coriiceps: reduced C-terminal glutamylation correlates with efficient microtubule assembly at low temperature

We have shown previously that the tubulins of Antarctic fish assemble into microtubules efficiently at low temperatures (-2 to +2 degrees C) due to adaptations intrinsic to the tubulin subunits. To determine whether changes in posttranslational glutamylation of the fish tubulins may contribute to cold adaptation of microtubule assembly, we have characterized C-terminal peptides from alpha- and beta-tubulin chains from brains of adult specimens of the Antarctic rockcod Notothenia coriiceps by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry and by Edman degradation amino acid sequencing. Of the four fish beta-tubulin isotypes, nonglutamylated isoforms were more abundant than glutamylated isoforms. In addition, maximal glutamyl side-chain length was shorter than that observed for mammalian brain beta tubulins. For the nine fish alpha-tubulin isotypes, nonglutamylated isoforms were also generally more abundant than glutamylated isoforms. When glutamylated, however, the maximal side-chain lengths of the fish alpha tubulins were generally longer than those of adult rat brain alpha chains. Thus, Antarctic fish adult brain tubulins are glutamylated differently than mammalian brain tubulins, resulting in a more heterogeneous population of alpha isoforms and a reduction in the number of beta isoforms. By contrast, neonatal rat brain tubulin possesses low levels of glutamylation that are similar to that of the adult fish brain tubulins. We suggest that unique residue substitutions in the primary structures of Antarctic fish tubulin isotypes and quantitative changes in isoform glutamylation act synergistically to adapt microtubule assembly to low temperatures.     

HDAC-6 interacts with and deacetylates tubulin and microtubules in vivo

Microtubules are cylindrical cytoskeletal structures found in almost all eukaryotic cell types which are involved in a great variety of cellular processes. Reversible acetylation on the epsilon-amino group of alpha-tubulin Lys40 marks stabilized microtubule structures and may contribute to regulating microtubule dynamics. Yet, the enzymes catalysing this acetylation/deacetylation have remained unidentified until recently. Here we report that beta-tubulin interacts with histone deacetylase-6 (HDAC-6) in a yeast two-hybrid assay and in vitro. We find that HDAC-6 is a micro tubule-associated protein capable of deacetylating alpha-tubulin in vivo and in vitro. HDAC-6's microtubule binding and deacetylation functions both depend on the hdac domains. Overexpression of HDAC-6 in mammalian cells leads to tubulin hypoacetylation. In contrast, inhibition of HDAC-6 function by two independent mechanisms--pharmacological (HDAC inhibitors) or genetic (targeted inactivation of HDAC-6 in embryonic stem cells)--leads to hyperacetylation of tubulin and microtubules. Taken together, our data provide evidence that HDAC-6 might act as a dual deacetylase for tubulin and histones, and suggest the possibility that acetylated non-histone proteins might represent novel targets for pharmacological therapy by HDAC inhibitors.     

Generation of antisera that discriminate among mammalian alpha- tubulins: introduction of specialized isotypes into cultured cells results in their coassembly without disruption of normal microtubule function

To assay the functional significance of the multiple but closely related alpha-tubulin polypeptides that are expressed in mammalian cells, we generated three specific immune sera, each of which uniquely recognizes a distinct alpha-tubulin isotype. All three isotypes are expressed in a tissue-restricted manner: one (M alpha 3/7) only in mature testis, one (M alpha 4) mainly in muscle and brain, and the third (M alpha 6) in several tissues at a very low level. A fourth specific antiserum was also generated that distinguishes between the tyrosinated and nontyrosinated form of a single alpha-tubulin isotype. Because individual tubulin isotypes cannot be purified biochemically, these sera were raised using cloned fusion proteins purified from host Escherichia coli cells. To suppress the immune response to shared epitopes, animals were first rendered tolerant to fusion proteins encoding all but one of the known mammalian alpha-tubulin isotypes. Subsequent challenge with the remaining fusion protein then resulted in the elicitation of an immune response to unique epitopes. Three criteria were used to establish the specificity of the resulting sera: (a) their ability to discriminate among cloned fusion proteins representing all the known mammalian alpha-tubulin isotypes; (b) their ability to uniquely detect alpha-tubulin in whole extracts of tissues; and (c) their capacity to stain microtubules in fixed preparations of cells transfected with sequences encoding the corresponding isotype. The transfection experiments served to demonstrate (a) the coassembly of M alpha 3/7, M alpha 4, and M alpha 6 into both interphase and spindle microtubules in HeLa cells and NIH 3T3 cells, and (b) that the M alpha 4 isotype, which is unique among mammalian alpha-tubulins in that it lacks an encoded carboxy-terminal tyrosine residue, behaves like other alpha-tubulin isotypes with respect to the cycle of tyrosination/detyrosination that occurs in most cultured cells.     

Sperm axoneme: a tale of tubulin posttranslation diversity

Two microtubule-containing structures are assembled during spermiogenesis: a transient manchette and a stable axoneme. Both structures contain microtubules enriched in posttranslationally modified tubulins. Despite the existence of a spectrum of tubulin isotypes postulated by the multi-tubulin hypothesis, further extended by an elaborated array of posttranslational modifications, it is unknown how this diversity influences microtubule function. There is increasing evidence that different alpha beta-tubulin isotypes can affect the structure and function of microtubules. It is also becoming increasingly clear that eukaryotic cells encode other tubulin proteins expressed by the tubulin superfamily: gamma, delta epsilon, zeta eta, and FtsZ have been identified so far. Although the role of gamma-tubulin in the nucleation of microtubule assembly is well established, the function of delta-, epsilon-, zeta-, eta-, and FtsZ-tubulins is less understood. The members of the tubulin superfamilies found in spermatids include the alpha beta-tubulin dimer, in addition to gamma-tubulin in the centrosome, and delta-tubulin in the perinuclear ring region of the mouse spermatid manchette, the centrosome region, and flagellum. Posttranslational modifications in tubulin isotypes are predominant in the C-terminus exposed on the outside surface of the microtubule. This target site may influence the interaction of microtubule-associated proteins, including motor proteins, and therefore determine the functional specificity of tubulin isotypes. It remains to be determined whether other newcomers to the superfamily of tubulins contain sites prone to posttranslational modification.     

Individual expression of recombinant alpha- and beta-tubulin from Haemonchus contortus: polymerization and drug effects

Three tubulin isotypes from the parasitic nematode Haemonchus contortus were individually expressed in Escherichia coli, purified, and induced to polymerize into microtubules in the absence of microtubule-associated proteins. The effect of different conditions on the rate of polymerization of pure tubulin was assessed. This is the first time that recombinant alpha-tubulin has been shown to be capable of polymerization into microtubule-like structures when incubated with recombinant beta-tubulin. In addition, the present study has shown that: (1) microtubule-associated proteins are not required for tubulin polymerization; and (2) pure beta-tubulin isotype, beta12-16, alone was capable of forming microtubule-like structures in the absence of alpha-tubulin. Polymerization of the recombinant invertebrate tubulin, as measured by a spectrophotometric assay, was found to be enhanced by a concentration of tubulin >0.25 mg/mL; temperature > or =20 degrees C; 2 mM GTP; glycerol; EGTA; and Mg(2+). Polymerization was inhibited by GTP (>2 mM) and albendazole. Calcium ions and a pH range of 6 to 8.5 had no measurable effect on polymerization. Individual isotypes of tubulin polymerized to approximately the same extent as an alpha-/beta-tubulin mixture. Samples of tubulin assembled under the above conditions for 60 min were also examined under a transmission electron microscope. Although the spectrophotometric assay indicated polymerization, it did not predict the structure of the polymer. In many cases tubulin sheets, folded sheets, and rings were observed in addition to, or instead of, microtubule-like structures.     

Expression of cold-adapted beta-tubulins confer cold-tolerance to human cellular microtubules

Isolated microtubule proteins from the cold-adapted fish, Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua), assemble at temperatures between 8 and 30 degrees C, while avian and mammalian microtubules normally do not assemble at temperatures below 20 degrees C. Tubulin, the main component in microtubules, is expressed as many isotypes. Microtubules with different isotype composition have been shown to have different dynamic properties in vitro. Our hypothesis was that cold-tolerance of microtubules is caused by tubulin isotypes that differ in the primary sequence compared to mammalian tubulins. Here we show that transfection of human HepG2 cells with cod beta-tubulin induced cold-adaptation of the endogenous microtubules. Incorporation of one single tubulin isotype can induce cold-tolerance to cold-intolerant microtubules. Three cod beta-tubulin isotypes were tested and two of these (beta1 and beta2) transferred cold-tolerance to HepG2 microtubules, thus not all cod beta-tubulins were able to confer cold-stability.     

Different reactivities of brain and erythrocyte tubulins toward a sulfhydryl group-directed reagent that inhibits microtubule assembly

There is considerable evidence that tubulin exists in multiple isotypes, differing in amino acid sequence and tissue distribution. Little is known, however, about the functional significance of these isotypes. Chicken erythrocyte beta-tubulin has been shown by peptide mapping to differ significantly from chicken brain beta-tubulin (Murphy, D. B., and Wallis, K. T. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 7870-7875). We now find that when the two tubulins, in their native states, are incubated with N,N'-ethylenebis(iodoacetamide) (EBI), a bifunctional sulfhydryl-directed reagent, microtubule assembly by brain tubulin is much more sensitive to inhibition by EBI than is erythrocyte tubulin assembly. The resistance of erythrocyte microtubule assembly to inhibition by EBI is correlated with a low reactivity of erythrocyte tubulin with [14C]EBI. This difference is most marked in the beta subunit which reacts 15 and 17% as well, respectively, with [14C]EBI as do the beta 1 and beta 2 subunits of brain tubulin. Also, erythrocyte beta reacts about 33% as well as does brain beta with iodo[14C]acetamide. These results suggest that a reactive sulfhydryl group, whose oxidation prevents microtubule assembly, is present in brain tubulin but absent or inaccessible in erythrocyte tubulin. Since purified erythrocyte tubulin self-aggregates much more readily than does brain tubulin, it is conceivable that erythrocyte and brain tubulin may differ in that the latter may have its assembly subject to a complex regulation, while erythrocyte tubulin assembly may be regulated by a simpler mechanism.     

Localization of the antimitotic peptide and depsipeptide binding site on beta-tubulin

Several naturally occurring peptides and depsipeptides which include the cryptophycins, dolastatin 10, hemiasterlin, and phomopsin A have been found to be potent antimitotic agents, causing cell death at picomolar or low nanomolar concentrations. These compounds inhibit microtubule growth, modulate the dynamics of microtubules, and induce the self-association of tubulin dimers into single-walled rings and spirals. These peptides exhibit mutual competitive inhibition in binding to beta-tubulin, while noncompetitively inhibiting the binding of vinblastine and vincristine to beta-tubulin. Despite the abundance of biochemical information, the details of their molecular interactions with tubulin are not known. In this study, using a combination of molecular dynamics simulations and molecular docking studies, a common binding site for cryptophycin 1, cryptophycin 52, dolastatin 10, hemiasterlin, and phomopsin A on beta-tubulin has been identified. Application of these same methods to alpha-tubulin indicated no interaction between alpha-tubulin and any of the peptides. On the basis of the docking results, a model for the mechanism of microtubule disruption and formation of aberrant nonmicrotubule structures is proposed. Both the active site and mechanism of microtubule depolymerization predictions are in good agreement with experimental findings.     

Retention of autoregulatory control of tubulin synthesis in cytoplasts: demonstration of a cytoplasmic mechanism that regulates the level of tubulin expression

Virtually all animal cells rapidly and specifically depress synthesis of new alpha- and beta-tubulin polypeptides in response to microtubule inhibitors that increase the pool of depolymerized subunits, or in response to direct elevation of the cellular tubulin subunit content through microinjection of exogenous tubulin subunits. Collectively, these previous findings have documented the presence of an apparent eucaryotic, autoregulatory control mechanism that specifies the level of expression of tubulin in cultured animal cells. Mechanistically, this regulation of tubulin synthesis is achieved through modulation of tubulin mRNA levels. To dissect further the molecular pathway that underlies this autoregulatory phenomenon, we have now investigated whether enucleated cells still retain the requisite regulatory machinery with which to alter tubulin synthetic levels in response to fluctuations in the pool size of unpolymerized tubulin subunits. Using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis to analyze the patterns of new polypeptide synthesis, we have determined that such cytoplasts can indeed respond to drug-induced microtubule depolymerization by specific repression of new beta-tubulin synthesis. Moreover, the response of cytoplasts is, if anything, greater in magnitude than that of whole cells. We conclude that autoregulatory control of beta-tubulin gene expression must derive principally, if not exclusively, from a cytoplasmic control mechanism that modulates beta-tubulin mRNA stability. For alpha-tubulin, although the response of cytoplasts after drug-induced microtubule depolymerization is quantitatively less dramatic than that of whole cells, at least part of the regulatory machinery must also be activated through a cytoplasmic regulatory event.     

Tubulin isotypes and their interaction with microtubule associated proteins

Summary To assay the functional significance of the multiple but closely related - and -tubulin polypeptides (termed isotypes) that are expressed in mammalian cells, we have generated a number of sera that uniquely discriminate among these isotypes. These sera have been used to demonstrate that there is no subcellular sorting of either - or -tubulin isotypes among microtubules of diverse function, either in cells growing in culture or in tissues consisting of cell types that contain specialized kinds of microtubule. In spite of this failure to segregate between functionally distinct kinds of microtubule, the fact that isotype-specific amino acid sequences have been strictly conserved over extensive periods of evolutionary time argues persuasively for a functional role for the different tubulin gene products. One possibility is that they are required for specific interactions with microtubule associated proteins (MAPs), and that tubulin isotypes have coevolved with different cell type-specific MAPs with which they must interact. We have tested this hypothesis by examining the distribution of -tubulin isotypes in mammalian cerebellum in relationship to the known patterns of expression of a number of MAPs, and find that these patterns correlate in the case of M 2 and MAP 3, and M 6 and MAP 1 a. These data, plus emerging data based on a structural analysis of tau, MAP 1 b and MAP 2 obtained via sequence determination of cloned cDNAs, are discussed in terms of the possible functional significance of tubulin isotype/MAP interactionsin vivo.     

Review: postchaperonin tubulin folding cofactors and their role in microtubule dynamics

The microtubule cytoskeleton consists of a highly organized network of microtubule polymers bound to their accessory proteins: microtubule-associated proteins, molecular motors, and microtubule-organizing proteins. The microtubule subunits are heterodimers composed of one alpha-tubulin polypeptide and one beta-tubulin polypeptide that should undergo a complex folding processing before they achieve a quaternary structure that will allow their incorporation into the polymer. Due to the extremely high protein concentration that exists at the cell cytoplasm, there are alpha- and beta-tubulin interacting proteins that prevent the unwanted interaction of these polypeptides with the surrounding protein pool during folding, thus allowing microtubule dynamics. Several years ago, the development of a nondenaturing electrophoretic technique made it possible to identify different tubulin intermediate complexes during tubulin biogenesis in vitro. By these means, the cytosolic chaperonin containing TCP-1 (CCT or TriC) and prefoldin have been demonstrated to intervene through tubulin and actin folding. Various other cofactors also identified along the alpha- and beta-tubulin postchaperonin folding route are now known to have additional roles in tubulin biogenesis such as participating in the synthesis, transport, and storage of alpha- and beta-tubulin. The future characterization of the tubulin-binding sites to these proteins, and perhaps other still unknown proteins, will help in the development of chemicals that could interfere with tubulin folding and thus modulating microtubule dynamics. In this paper, current knowledge of the above postchaperonin folding cofactors, which are in fact chaperones involved in tubulin heterodimer quaternary structure achievement, will be reviewed.     

A monoclonal antibody to alpha-tubulin: purification of functionally active alpha-tubulin isoforms

Both alpha- and beta-tubulin exist as numerous isotypic forms that originate from different primary sequences as well as a variety of posttranslational modifications. Recent studies show that tubulin dimers differing in the beta-subunit differ significantly in their subcellular distribution as well as in their functional properties such as assembly, dynamics, conformation, and interaction with antimitotic drugs; however, very little is known about the functional significance of the different alpha-tubulin isoforms and their posttranslational modifications. In an effort to get a better understanding about the alpha-tubulin isoforms, a monoclonal antibody, AYN.6D10, was prepared against the mammalian alpha-tubulin C-terminal sequence Glu-Glu-Gly-Glu-Glu-Tyr. Using an immunoaffinity column, bovine brain tubulin was fractionated into three functionally active alphabeta heterodimers which were identified by immunoblotting with alpha-tubulin-specific antibodies and sequence analysis. Assembly studies in the presence of glycerol and Mg2+ show that one of the fractions, that contains mainly the tyrosinated form of alpha1/2, assembled poorly, while the nontyrosinated form assembled normally. The results indicate that tubulin dimers differing in their alpha-tubulin may differ in their functional properties. Future studies with the isoforms may yield valuable information regarding the role of alpha-tubulin and its posttranslational modifications in regulating microtubule assembly and function in vivo.     

A novel step in beta-tubulin folding is important for heterodimer formation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Undimerized beta-tubulin is toxic in the yeast S. cerevisiae. It can arise if levels of beta-tubulin and alpha-tubulin are unbalanced or if the tubulin heterodimer dissociates. We are using the toxicity of beta-tubulin to understand early steps in microtubule morphogenesis. We find that deletion of PLP1 suppresses toxic beta-tubulin formed by disparate levels of alpha- and beta-tubulin. That suppression occurs either when alpha-tubulin is modestly underexpressed relative to beta-tubulin or when beta-tubulin is inducibly and strongly overexpressed. Plp1p does not affect tubulin expression. Instead, a significant proportion of the undimerized beta-tubulin in plp1Delta cells is less toxic than that in wild-type cells. It is also less able to combine with alpha-tubulin to form a heterodimer. As a result, plp1Delta cells have lower levels of heterodimer. Importantly, plp1Delta cells that also lack Pac10, a component of the GimC/PFD complex, are even less affected by free beta-tubulin. Our results suggest that Plp1p defines a novel early step in beta-tubulin folding.     

Identification by mass spectrometry of a new alpha-tubulin isotype expressed in human breast and lung carcinoma cell lines

The extensive C-terminal molecular heterogeneity of alpha- and beta-tubulin is a consequence of multiple isotypes, the products of distinct genes, that undergo several posttranslational modifications. These include polyglutamylation and polyglycylation of both subunits, reversible tyrosination and removal of the penultimate glutamate from alpha-tubulin, and phosphorylation of the beta III isotype. A mass spectrometry-based method has been developed for the analysis of the C-terminal diversity of tubulin from human cell lines. Total cell extracts are resolved by SDS--PAGE and transferred to nitrocellulose, and the region of the blot corresponding to tubulin (approximately 50 kDa) was excised and digested with CNBr to release the highly divergent C-terminal tubulin fragments. The masses of the human alpha- and beta-tubulin CNBr-derived C-terminal peptides are all in the 1500--4000 Da mass range and can be analyzed directly by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry in the negative ion mode without significant interference from other released peptides. In this study, the tubulin isotype diversity in MDA-MB-231, a human breast carcinoma cell line, and A549, a human non-small lung cancer cell line, is reported. The major tubulin isotypes present in both cell lines are k-alpha 1 and beta 1. Importantly, we report a previously unknown alpha isotype present at significant levels in both cell lines. Moreover, the degree of posttranslational modifications to all isotypes was limited. Glu-tubulin, in which the C-terminal tyrosine of alpha-tubulin is removed, was not detected. In contrast to mammalian neuronal tubulin which exhibits extensive polyglutamylation, only low-level monoglutamylation of the k-alpha 1 and beta 1 isotypes was observed in these two human cell lines.     

Protection from Free β-Tubulin by the β-Tubulin Binding Protein Rbl2p

Free beta-tubulin not in heterodimers with alpha-tubulin can be toxic, disrupting microtubule assembly and function. We are interested in the mechanisms by which cells protect themselves from free beta-tubulin. This study focused specifically on the function of Rbl2p, which, like alpha-tubulin, can rescue cells from free beta-tubulin. In vitro studies of the mammalian homolog of Rbl2p, cofactor A, have suggested that Rbl2p/cofactor A may be involved in tubulin folding. Here we show that Rbl2p becomes essential in cells containing a modest excess of beta-tubulin relative to alpha-tubulin. However, this essential activity of Rbl2p/cofactorA does not depend upon the reactions described by the in vitro assay. Rescue of beta-tubulin toxicity requires a minimal but substoichiometric ratio of Rbl2p to beta-tubulin. The data suggest that Rbl2p binds transiently to free beta-tubulin, which then passes into an aggregated form that is not toxic.