Mismatch cleavage by single-strand specific nucleases

We have investigated the ability of single-strand specific (sss) nucleases from different sources to cleave single base pair mismatches in heteroduplex DNA templates used for mutation and single-nucleotide polymorphism analysis. The TILLING (Targeting Induced Local Lesions IN Genomes) mismatch cleavage protocol was used with the LI-COR gel detection system to assay cleavage of amplified heteroduplexes derived from a variety of induced mutations and naturally occurring polymorphisms. We found that purified nucleases derived from celery (CEL I), mung bean sprouts and Aspergillus (S₁) were able to specifically cleave nearly all single base pair mismatches tested. Optimal nicking of heteroduplexes for mismatch detection was achieved using higher pH, temperature and divalent cation conditions than are routinely used for digestion of single-stranded DNA. Surprisingly, crude plant extracts performed as well as the highly purified preparations for this application. These observations suggest that diverse members of the S₁ family of sss nucleases act similarly in cleaving non-specifically at bulges in heteroduplexes, and single-base mismatches are the least accessible because they present the smallest single-stranded region for enzyme binding. We conclude that a variety of sss nucleases and extracts can be effectively used for high-throughput mutation and polymorphism discovery.     

Optimized PCR fragments for heteroduplex analysis of the whole human mitochondrial genome with denaturing HPLC

Denaturing high pressure liquid chromatography (dHPLC) is an efficient method for discovery of unknown mutations by heteroduplex analysis of PCR fragments. For comprehensive mutation scanning of the whole 16.569 bp human mitochondrial genome, we developed a set of 67 primer pairs defining overlapping PCR fragments that are well suited for heteroduplex analysis. The aim of our optimization efforts was to ensure that point mutations are detectable at every nucleotide position of each amplicon. Some GC-rich regions of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) were found to have unfavourable melting profiles in all possible amplicons, therefore requiring GC-clamps at the end of one or both oligonucleotide PCR primers. Following detection of a heteroduplex pattern by dHPLC, our primers can also be employed for DNA sequencing to identify the underlying mutation. In case of heteroplasmic mutations with a low proportion of mutant mtDNA, a fragment collector is useful to recover the heteroduplex peak, which contains mutant and wildtype DNA molecules in a 1:1 ratio.     

Incision at nucleotide insertions/deletions and base pair mismatches by the SP nuclease of spinach

Spinach leaves contain a highly active nuclease called SP. The purified enzyme incises single-stranded DNA, RNA, and double-stranded DNA that has been destabilized by A-T-rich regions and DNA lesions [Strickland et al. (1991) Biochemistry 30, 9749-9756]. This broad range of activity has suggested that SP may be similar to a family of nucleases represented by S1, P1, and the mung bean nuclease. However, unlike these single-stranded nucleases that require acidic pH and low ionic strength conditions, SP has a neutral pH optimum and is active over a wide range of salt concentrations. We have extended these findings and showed that an outstanding substrate for SP is a mismatched DNA duplex. For base-substitution mismatches, SP incises at all mismatches except those containing a guanine residue. SP also cuts at insertion/deletions of one or more nucleotides. Where the extrahelical DNA loop contains one nucleotide, the preference of extrahelical nucleotide is A > T approximately C but undetectable at G. The inability of SP to cut at guanine residues and the favoring of A-T-rich regions distinguish SP from the CEL I family of neutral pH mismatch endonucleases recently discovered in celery and other plants [Oleykowski et al. (1998) Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 4597-4602]. SP, like CEL I, does not turn over after incision at a mismatched site in vitro. Similar to CEL I, the presence of a DNA polymerase or a DNA ligase allows SP to turn over and stimulate its activity in vitro by about 20-fold. The possibility that the SP nuclease may be a natural variant of the CEL I family of mismatch endonucleases is discussed.     

Denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography is a suitable method for PMM2 mutation screening in carbohydrate-deficient glycoprotein syndrome type IA patients

The phosphomannomutase 2 gene (PMM2; MIM 601785) has been identified as the carbohydrate-deficient glycoprotein syndrome type 1A gene (CDGS type 1A; MIM 212065). The gene spans 8 exons and 741 bp of coding DNA. Previously, we have identified 20 different mutations in the PMM2 gene using mutation screening with single-stranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP) and sequencing of DNA from 61 CDGS type 1A patients. Because eight of these could not be detected by SSCP, we were not satisfied with the sensitivity of the mutation detection technique used. Thus, we wanted to investigate if denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) was a more suitable mutation screening method for PMM2. DHPLC was set up for PMM2 by optimizing eight different PCR fragments, one for each exon. The mutation detection was optimized empirically with PCR fragments from controls. First, control samples were run at a universal gradient and after modification and shortening of the gradient, also run at 10 different temperatures, 50-70 degrees C with 2-degree intervals, to enable setting of the temperature with the highest resolution. Then, PCR products with known mutations from the previous study were analyzed, and the results were compared to the control chromatograms for aberrations. We detected 19/20 mutations with DHPLC, and several mutations not detected by earlier screening techniques were readily detected by DHPLC. We conclude that DHPLC is a suitable detection technique for a rapid and reliable first scan of CDGS type 1A patients.     

Efficient discovery of DNA polymorphisms in natural populations by Ecotilling

We have adapted the mutation detection technology used in Targeting Induced Local Lesions in Genomes (TILLING) to the discovery of polymorphisms in natural populations. The genomic DNA of a queried individual is mixed with a reference DNA and used to amplify a target 1-kbp region of DNA with asymmetrically labeled fluorescent primers. After heating and annealing, heteroduplexes are nicked at mismatched sites by the endonuclease CEL I and cut strands are visualized using Li-cor gel analyzers. Putative polymorphisms detected in one fluorescence channel can be verified by appearance of the opposite cut strand in the other channel. We demonstrated the efficiency of this technology, called Ecotilling, by the discovery in 150+ individuals of 55 haplotypes in five genes, ranging from sequences differing by a single nucleotide polymorphism to those representing complex haplotypes. The discovered polymorphisms were confirmed by sequencing and included base-pair changes, small insertions and deletions, and variation in microsatellite repeat number. Ecotilling allows the rapid detection of variation in many individuals and is cost effective because only one individual for each haplotype needs to be sequenced. The technology is applicable to any organism including those that are heterozygous and polyploid.     

Enzymatic mutation detection technologies

Mutation is as necessary for life as fidelity is in DNA replication. The study of mutations reveals the normal functions of genes, messages, proteins, the causes of many diseases, and the variability of responses among individuals. Indeed, recent mutations that have not yet become polymorphisms are often deleterious and pertinent to the disease history of afflicted individuals. This review discusses the principles behind a variety of methods for the detection of mutations and factors that should be considered in future methods design. One enzymatic approach in particular using orthologs of the CEL I nuclease that show high specificity for all mismatches, appears to be easy and robust. Further developments of this and other methods will allow mutation detection to become an integral component of individualized medicine.     

Rapid and direct detection of the most frequent Mediterranean beta-thalassemic mutations by multiplex allele-specific enzymatic amplification.

A rapid nonradioactive method for the diagnosis of the most frequent Mediterranean beta-thalassemic mutations is described based on a multiplex allele-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR). This method allows direct detection of normal or mutated alleles on genomic DNA. We have used this approach to detect the most frequent Mediterranean mutations: IVS-1 nt 110 (G----A) and 39 nonsense (C----T). For each mutation three allele-specific oligonucleotides were used: one common upstream primer and two downstream primers differing in their terminal 3' nucleotide (one specific for the normal allele and one for the mutant allele). For each sample two PCR reactions were performed in parallel using in one case IVS-1 nt 110 and codon 39 normal primers and in the second case using the corresponding mutated primers. In both cases the different PCR fragments were visualized. After optimization these primers directed only amplification of their complementary allele. A single blind study was performed on the DNA of 18 individuals who were homozygous or heterozygous for these mutations. In comparison with a parallel investigation, using oligonucleotide probes, all the results were unambiguous. This diagnosis method, which is rapid, easy, direct, and inexpensive, allows the screening of a population group, including heterozygotes, which is required from an epidemiological and anthropological point of view. It could be extended to the large series screening of haplotypes before targeted diagnosis of various genetic diseases.     

Chemical cleavage of mismatch (CCM) to locate base mismatches in heteroduplex DNA

This protocol describes the use of the chemical cleavage of mismatch (CCM) method to assess whether a region of DNA contains mutations and to localize them. Compared with other mutation-detection techniques (such as single strand-conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis, denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE)) that detect mutations in short DNA fragments and require highly specific melting temperatures, CCM has a higher diagnostic sensitivity suited to the detection of mutations in tumor genes, and can analyze amplicons < or = 2 kb in length. To detect mutations, PCR heteroduplexes are incubated with two mismatch-specific reagents. Hydroxylamine modifies unpaired cytosine and potassium permanganate modifies unpaired thymine. The samples are then incubated with piperidine, which cleaves the DNA backbone at the site of the modified mismatched base. Cleavage products are separated by electrophoresis, revealing the identity and location of the mutation. The CCM method can efficiently detect point mutations as well as insertions and deletions. This protocol can be completed in 10 h.     

Genetic identity of clones and methods to explore DNA

Cloning by nuclear transfer has made it possible to produce genetically identical animals in terms of nuclear DNA content. Recent molecular biology tools are offering scientific ways to get an insight into the identity issues, by exploring and comparing genomes of cloned animals in order to test their genetic identity and methylation differences. We have initiated a study to compare genomic DNA of bovine adult clones, of normal phenotype. We have used, in parallel, the AFLP technique (amplification fragment length polymorphism) and one of its variant, MSAP (methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism). We are also investigating other techniques leading to the detection of sequence polymorphisms between two genomes based on genomes hybridisation. We chose the representational difference analysis (RDA) methods that can be combined with mismatch-specific recognition or mismatch binding property of some proteins (CEL I, MutS). We plan to use these RDA methods for genome-wide detection of subtle mutations, then to focus on changes affecting the methylation status of promoting genomic regions in abnormal clones. This will be achieved using MSAP with NotI and applying, in parallel, the RLGS (restriction landmark genome scanning) technique. This study will hopefully improve the molecular and functional characterizations of these "new animals."     

Novel amplification of DNA in a hairpin structure: towards a radical elimination of PCR errors from amplified DNA

Errors introduced during PCR amplification set a selectivity limit for microsatellite analysis and molecular mutation detection methods since polymerase misincorporations invariably get confused with genuine mutations. Here we present hairpin-PCR, a new form of PCR that completely separates genuine mutations from polymerase misincorporations. Hairpin-PCR operates by converting a DNA sequence to a hairpin following ligation of oligonucleotide caps to DNA ends. We developed conditions that allow a DNA hairpin to be efficiently PCR-amplified so that, during DNA synthesis, the polymerase copies both DNA strands in a single pass. Consequently, when a misincorporation occurs it forms a mismatch following DNA amplification, and is distinguished from genuine mutations that remain fully matched. Error-free DNA can subsequently be isolated using one of many approaches, such as dHPLC or enzymatic depletion. We present feasibility for the main technical steps involved in this new strategy, conversion of a sequence to a hairpin that can be PCR-amplified from human genomic DNA, exponential amplification from picogram amounts, conversion of misincorporations to mismatches and separation of homoduplex from heteroduplex hairpins using dHPLC. The present hairpin-PCR opens up the possibility for a radical elimination of PCR errors from amplified DNA and a major improvement in mutation detection.     

Genome-wide detection of unknown subtle mutations in bacteria by combination of MutS and RDA

We propose a procedure for detecting unknown, subtle DNA changes throughout the entire bacterial genome by a combination of MutS and RDA. Current techniques detect subtle mutations after PCR amplification of the target regions, so the mutation detection is done between amplified PCR fragments. In this paper, genome-wide subtle mutation scanning in bacteria was performed by combining the MutS and RDA techniques. Our strategy for cloning a small mutation region is composed of two steps: an enrichment of fragments containing subtle mutations using MutS, followed by an RDA subtraction procedure for further enrichment. We successfully identified small mutations such as a four-base insertion, a two-base insertion, and transition mutations in bacteria.     

Mutation detection using Surveyor nuclease

We have developed a simple and flexible mutation detection technology for the discovery and mapping of both known and unknown mutations. This technology is based on a new mismatch-specific DNA endonuclease from celery, Surveyor nuclease, which is a member of the CEL nuclease family of plant DNA endonucleases. Surveyor nuclease cleaves with high specificity at the 3' side of any mismatch site in both DNA strands, including all base substitutions and insertion/deletions up to at least 12 nucleotides. Surveyor nuclease technology involves four steps: (i) PCR to amplify target DNA from both mutant and wild-type reference DNA; (ii) hybridization to form heteroduplexes between mutant and wild-type reference DNA; (iii) treatment of annealed DNA with Surveyor nuclease to cleave heteroduplexes; and (iv) analysis of digested DNA products using the detection/separation platform of choice. The technology is highly sensitive, detecting rare mutants present at as low as 1 in 32 copies. Unlabeled Surveyor nuclease digestion products can be analyzed using conventional gel electrophoresis or high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), while end labeled digestion products are suitable for analysis by automated gel or capillary electrophoresis. The entire protocol can be performed in less than a day and is suitable for automated and high-throughput procedures.     

Simultaneous detection of multiple mutations in epidermal growth factor receptor based on fluorescence quenching of quantum dots

We have developed a simultaneous detection method for two common mutations in the epidermal growth factor receptor gene based on the fluorescence quenching phenomenon caused by aggregation of CdSe quantum dots. For detection of the in-frame deletion in exon 19 and the L858R point mutation in exon 21, water-soluble CdSe quantum dots with two sizes were functionalized using four different types of probe oligonucleotides. Addition of target oligonucleotides with the deletion mutation in exon 19 into the suspensions caused crosslinking-induced aggregation of green-emitting quantum dots, followed by the fluorescence quenching while that with the L858R point mutation resulted in aggregation of yellow-emitting quantum dots. In addition, targets with both deletion and point mutations caused aggregation of both green- and yellow-emitting quantum dots. This method allows a simultaneous detection of mutations in exon 19 and 21 of EGFR gene in a single experiment. We found that minimum mutant concentration that could be detected by this method was as low as 2% for deletion mutation, and 5% for point mutation. PCR products of EGFR gene were also used to confirm that our method could be used to detect mutation in amplified DNA fragments.     

Single nucleotide polymorphism genotyping using allele-specific PCR and fluorescence melting curves

We present a PCR method for identification of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), using allele-specific primers designed for selective amplification of each allele. Matching the SNP at the 3' end of the forward or reverse primer, and additionally incorporating a 3' mismatch to prevent amplification of the incorrect allele, results in selectivity of the allele-specific primers. DNA melting analysis with fluorescent SYBR Green affords detection of the PCR products. By incorporating a GC-rich sequence into one of the two allele-specific primers to increase the melting temperature, both alleles can be measured simultaneously at their respective melting temperatures. Applying the DNA melting analysis to SNPs in ApoE and ABCA1 yielded results identical to those obtained with other genotyping methods. This provides a cost-effective, high-throughput method for amplification and scoring of SNPs.     

The use of resolvases T4 endonuclease VII and T7 endonuclease I in mutation detection

Mutation and polymorphism detection is of increasing importance in the field of molecular genetics. This is reflected by the plethora of chemical, enzymatic, and physically based methods of mutation detection. The ideal method would detect mutations in large fragments of DNA and position them to single base-pair (bp) accuracy. Few methods are able to quickly screen kilobase lengths of DNA and position the mutation at the same time. The Enzyme Mismatch Cleavage (EMC) method of mutation detection is able to reliably detect nearly 100% of mutations in DNA fragments as large as 2 kb and position them to within 6 bp. This method exploits the activity of a resolvase enzyme from T4, T4 endonuclease VII, and more recently, a second bacteriophage resolvase, T7 endonuclease I. The technique uses these enzymes to digest heteroduplex DNA formed by annealing wild-type and mutant DNA. Digestion fragments indicate the presence, and the position, of any mutations. The method is robust and reliable and much faster and cheaper than sequencing. These attributes have resulted in its increasing use in the field of mutation detection.     

DNA fingerprinting based on microsatellite-anchored fragment length polymorphisms,and isolation of sequence-specific PCR markers in lupin (Lupinus angustifolius L.)

We report a method of microsatellite-anchored fragment length polymorphisms for DNA fingerprinting. The method combines the concept of AFLP and the microsatellite-anchor primer technique. Genomic DNA was digested by one restriction enzyme MseI. One AFLP adaptor (MseI adaptor) was ligated onto the restriction fragments. DNA fingerprints were produced by PCR using one microsatellite-anchor primer in combination with one MseI-primer. The method allows co-amplification of over 100 DNA fragments containing microsatellite motifs per PCR. Polymorphisms detected from lupin by this method included those arising from variation in the number of microsatellite repeat units targeted by the microsatellite-anchor primers, from variation on the annealing sites for the SSR-anchor primers, from insertions/deletions outside the SSR region, and from variation in restriction sites. The first three types of polymorphisms were readily converted into sequence-specific PCR markers suitable for marker-assisted breeding.     

Automated band mapping in electrophoretic gel images using background information

Some popular methods for polymorphism and mutation discovery involve ascertainment of novel bands by the examination of electrophoretic gel images. Although existing strategies for mapping bands work well for specific applications, such as DNA sequencing, these strategies are not well suited for novel band detection. Here, we describe a general strategy for band mapping that uses background banding patterns to facilitate lane calling and size calibration. We have implemented this strategy in GelBuddy, a user-friendly Java-based program for PC and Macintosh computers, which includes several utilities to assist discovery of mutations and polymorphisms. We demonstrate the use of GelBuddy in applications based on single-base mismatch cleavage of heteroduplexed PCR products. Use of software designed to facilitate novel band detection can significantly shorten the time needed for image analysis and data entry in a high-throughput setting. Furthermore, the interactive strategy implemented in GelBuddy has been successfully applied to DNA fingerprinting applications, such as AFLP. GelBuddy promises to make electrophoretic gel analysis a viable alternative to DNA resequencing for discovery of mutations and polymorphisms.     

Detection of simple mutations and polymorphisms in large genomic regions

We have developed a novel technology that makes it possible to detect simple nucleotide polymorphisms directly within a sample of total genomic DNA. It allows, in a single Southern blot experiment, the determination of sequence identity of genomic regions with a combined length of hundreds of kilobases. This technology does not require PCR amplification of the target DNA regions, but exploits preparative size-fractionation of restriction-digested genomic DNA and a newly discovered property of the mismatch-specific endonuclease CEL I to cleave heteroduplex DNA with a very high specificity and sensitivity. We have used this technique to detect various simple mutations directly in the genomic DNA of isogenic pairs of recombinant Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli and Salmonella isolates. Also, by using a cosmid DNA library and genomic fractions as hybridization probes, we have compared total genomic DNA of two clinical P.aeruginosa clones isolated from the same patient, but exhibiting divergent phenotypes. The mutation scan correctly detected a GA insertion in the quorum-sensing regulator gene rhlR and, in addition, identified a novel intragenomic polymorphism in rrn operons, indicating very high stability of the bacterial genomes under natural non-mutator conditions.     

Fluorescence-based directed termination PCR: direct mutation characterization without sequencing

We describe a fluorescence-based directed termination PCR (fluorescent DT–PCR) that allows accurate determination of actual sequence changes without dideoxy DNA sequencing. This is achieved using near infrared dye-labeled primers and performing two PCR reactions under low and unbalanced dNTP concentrations. Visualization of resulting termination fragments is accomplished with a dual dye Li-cor DNA sequencer. As each DT–PCR reaction generates two sets of terminating fragments, a pair of complementary reactions with limiting dATP and dCTP collectively provide information on the entire sequence of a target DNA, allowing an accurate determination of any base change. Blind analysis of 78 mutants of the supF reporter gene using fluorescent DT–PCR not only correctly determined the nature and position of all types of substitution mutations in the supF gene, but also allowed rapid scanning of the signature sequences among identical mutations. The method provides simplicity in the generation of terminating fragments and 100% accuracy in mutation characterization. Fluorescent DT–PCR was successfully used to generate a UV-induced spectrum of mutations in the supF gene following replication on a single plate of human DNA repair-deficient cells. We anticipate that the automated DT–PCR method will serve as a cost-effective alternative to dideoxy sequencing in studies involving large-scale analysis for nucleotide sequence changes.     

Diagnosis of haemophilia B using the polymerase chain reaction

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to amplify specific DNA sequences within the factor IX gene of haemophilia B patients and their relatives. Three of the amplified fragments contain polymorphic sites, which can be used as markers in segregation analyses. These restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) were until recently detected by Southern blotting after digestion with the restriction enzymes Taq I, Dde I and Xmn I. All three RFLP's are located in introns of the factor IX gene and together are informative in approximately 70% of all cases. Each of the polymorphisms was successfully used in carrier detection studies after amplification of the relevant fragments. This method is also suitable for rapid antenatal diagnosis. Additionally we were able to amplify all eight exons of the factor IX gene including the splice junctions and a part of the 5'-region. Large deletions or insertions can be detected without further analysis. Several possibilities for the rapid detection of point mutations after DNA amplification have been described recently. The complete amplification of all functional parts of the Factor IX gene in combination with these new techniques should enable us to detect the majority of mutations leading to haemophilia B.