Proteomic study of the Arabidopsis thaliana chloroplastic envelope membrane utilizing alternatives to traditional two-dimensional electrophoresis

With the completion of the sequencing of the Arabidopsis genome and with the significant increase in the amount of other plant genome and expressed sequence tags (ESTs) data, plant proteomics is rapidly becoming a very active field. We have pursued a high-throughput mass spectrometry-based proteomics approach to identify and characterize membrane proteins localized to the Arabidopsis thaliana chloroplastic envelope membrane. In this study, chloroplasts were prepared from plate- or soil-grown Arabidopsis plants using a novel isolation procedure, and "mixed" envelopes were subsequently isolated using sucrose step gradients. We applied two alternative methodologies, off-line multidimensional protein identification technology (Off-line MUDPIT) and one-dimensional (1D) gel electrophoresis followed by proteolytic digestion and liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (Gel-C-MS/MS), to identify envelope membrane proteins. This proteomic study enabled us to identify 392 nonredundant proteins.     

Analysis of curated and predicted plastid subproteomes of Arabidopsis. Subcellular compartmentalization leads to distinctive proteome properties

Carefully curated proteomes of the inner envelope membrane, the thylakoid membrane, and the thylakoid lumen of chloroplasts from Arabidopsis were assembled based on published, well-documented localizations. These curated proteomes were evaluated for distribution of physical-chemical parameters, with the goal of extracting parameters for improved subcellular prediction and subsequent identification of additional (low abundant) components of each membrane system. The assembly of rigorously curated subcellular proteomes is in itself also important as a parts list for plant and systems biology. Transmembrane and subcellular prediction strategies were evaluated using the curated data sets. The three curated proteomes differ strongly in average isoelectric point and protein size, as well as transmembrane distribution. Removal of the cleavable, N-terminal transit peptide sequences greatly affected isoelectric point and size distribution. Unexpectedly, the Cys content was much lower for the thylakoid proteomes than for the inner envelope. This likely relates to the role of the thylakoid membrane in light-driven electron transport and helps to avoid unwanted oxidation-reduction reactions. A rule of thumb for discriminating between the predicted integral inner envelope membrane and integral thylakoid membrane proteins is suggested. Using a combination of predictors and experimentally derived parameters, four plastid subproteomes were predicted from the fully annotated Arabidopsis genome. These predicted subproteomes were analyzed for their properties and compared to the curated proteomes. The sensitivity and accuracy of the prediction strategies are discussed. Data can be extracted from the new plastid proteome database (http://ppdb.tc.cornell.edu).     

Physcomitrella patens as a model for the study of chloroplast protein transport: conserved machineries between vascular and non-vascular plants

A single general import pathway in vascular plants mediates the transport of precursor proteins across the two membranes of the chloroplast envelope, and at least four pathways are responsible for thylakoid protein targeting. While the transport systems in the thylakoid are related to bacterial secretion systems, the envelope machinery is thought to have arisen with the endosymbiotic event and to be derived, at least in part, from proteins present in the original endosymbiont. Recently the moss Physcomitrella patens has gained worldwide attention for its ability to undergo homologous recombination in the nuclear genome at rates unseen in any other land plants. Because of this, we were interested to know whether it would be a useful model system for studying chloroplast protein transport. We searched the large database of P. patens expressed sequence tags for chloroplast transport components and found many putative homologues. We obtained full-length sequences for homologues of three Toc components from moss. To our knowledge, this is the first sequence information for these proteins from non-vascular plants. In addition to identifying components of the transport machinery from moss, we isolated plastids and tested their activity in protein import assays. Our data indicate that moss and pea (Pisum sativum) plastid transport systems are functionally similar. These findings identify P. patens as a potentially useful tool for combining genetic and biochemical approaches for the study of chloroplast protein targeting. Abbreviations: EST, expressed sequence tag; LHCP, light-harvesting chlorophyll-binding protein; NIBB, National Institute for Basic Biology; OE17, 17 kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex; PC, plastocyanin; PEP, Physcomitrella EST Programme; SPP, stromal processing peptidase; SRP, signal recognition particle; Tat, twin-arginine translocation; Tic, translocon at the inner membrane of the chloroplast envelope; Toc, translocon at the outer membrane of the chloroplast envelope; TPP, thylakoid processing peptidase; TPR, tetratricopeptide repeatSupplementary material to this paper is available in electronic form at .This revised version was opublished online in July 2005 with corrected page numbers.     

New functions of the thylakoid membrane proteome of Arabidopsis thaliana revealed by a simple, fast, and versatile fractionation strategy

Identification of membrane proteomes remains challenging. Here, we present a simple, fast, and scalable off-line procedure based on three-phase partitioning with butanol to fractionate membrane proteomes in combination with both in-gel and in-solution digestions and mass spectrometry. This should help to further accelerate the field of membrane proteomics. Using this new strategy, we analyzed the salt-stripped thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts of Arabidopsis thaliana. 242 proteins were identified, at least 40% of which are integral membrane proteins. The functions of 86 proteins are unknown; these include proteins with TPR, PPR, rhodanese, and DnaJ domains. These proteins were combined with all known thylakoid proteins and chloroplast (associated) envelope proteins, collected from primary literature, resulting in 714 non-redundant proteins. They were assigned to functional categories using a classification developed for MapMan (Thimm, O., Blasing, O., Gibon, Y., Nagel, A., Meyer, S., Kruger, P., Selbig, J., Muller, L. A., Rhee, S. Y., and Stitt, M. (2004) Plant J. 37, 914-939), updated with information from primary literature. The analysis elucidated the likely location of many membrane proteins, including 190 proteins of unknown function, holding the key to better understanding the two membrane systems. The three-phase partitioning procedure added a new level of dynamic resolution to the known thylakoid proteome. An automated strategy was developed to track possible ambiguous identifications to more than one gene model or family member. Mass spectrometry search results, ambiguities, and functional classifications can be searched via the Plastid Proteome Database.     

Physcomitrella patens as a model for the study of chloroplast protein transport: conserved machineries between vascular and non-vascular plants

A single general import pathway in vascular plants mediates the transport of precursor proteins across the two membranes of the chloroplast envelope, and at least four pathways are responsible for thylakoid protein targeting. While the transport systems in the thylakoid are related to bacterial secretion systems, the envelope machinery is thought to have arisen with the endosymbiotic event and to be derived, at least in part, from proteins present in the original endosymbiont. Recently the moss Physcomitrella patens has gained worldwide attention for its ability to undergo homologous recombination in the nuclear genome at rates unseen in any other land plants. Because of this, we were interested to know whether it would be a useful model system for studying chloroplast protein transport. We searched the large database of P. patens expressed sequence tags for chloroplast transport components and found many putative homologues. We obtained full-length sequences for homologues of three Toc components from moss. To our knowledge, this is the first sequence information for these proteins from non-vascular plants. In addition to identifying components of the transport machinery from moss, we isolated plastids and tested their activity in protein import assays. Our data indicate that moss and pea (Pisum sativum) plastid transport systems are functionally similar. These findings identify P. patens as a potentially useful tool for combining genetic and biochemical approaches for the study of chloroplast protein targeting.     

Conservative sorting in the muroplasts of Cyanophora paradoxa: a reevaluation based on the completed genome sequence

After primary endosymbiosis, massive gene transfer occurred from the genome of the cyanobacterial endosymbiont to the nucleus of the protist host cell. In parallel, a specific protein import apparatus arose for reimport of many, but not all products of the genes moved to the nuclear genome. Presequences evolved to allow recognition of plastid proteins at the envelope and their translocation to the stroma. However, plastids (and cyanobacteria) also comprise five other subcompartments. Protein sorting to the cyanobacterial thylakoid membrane, the thylakoid lumen, the inner envelope membrane, the periplasmic space, and the outer envelope membrane is achieved by prokaryotic protein translocases recognizing, e.g., signal sequences. The “conservative sorting” hypothesis postulates that these translocases remained functional in endosymbiotic organelles and obtained their passengers not only from imported proteins but also from proteins synthesized in organello. For proteins synthesized in the cytosol, a collaboration of the general import apparatus and the former prokaryotic translocase is necessary which is often reflected by the use of bipartite presequences, e.g., stroma targeting peptide and signal peptide. For plants, this concept has been experimentally proven and verified. The muroplasts from Cyanophora paradoxa, that have several features more in common with cyanobacteria than with plastids, were analyzed with the availability of the recently completed nuclear genome sequence. Interesting findings include the absence of the post-translational signal recognition particle pathway, dual Sec translocases in thylakoid and inner envelope membranes that are produced from a single set of genes, and a co-translational signal recognition pathway operating without a 4.5S RNA component.     

Identification, expression, and functional analyses of a thylakoid ATP/ADP carrier from Arabidopsis

In plants the chloroplast thylakoid membrane is the site of light-dependent photosynthetic reactions coupled to ATP synthesis. The ability of the plant cell to build and alter this membrane system is essential for efficient photosynthesis. A nucleotide translocator homologous to the bovine mitochondrial ADP/ATP carrier (AAC) was previously found in spinach thylakoids. Here we have identified and characterized a thylakoid ATP/ADP carrier (TAAC) from Arabidopsis.(i) Sequence homology with the bovine AAC and the prediction of chloroplast transit peptides indicated a putative carrier encoded by the At5g01500 gene, as a TAAC. (ii) Transiently expressed TAAC-green fluorescent protein fusion construct was targeted to the chloroplast. Western blotting using a peptide-specific antibody together with immunogold electron microscopy revealed a major location of TAAC in the thylakoid membrane. Previous proteomic analyses identified this protein in chloroplast envelope preparations. (iii) Recombinant TAAC protein specifically imports ATP in exchange for ADP across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli. Studies on isolated thylakoids from Arabidopsis confirmed these observations. (iv) The lack of TAAC in an Arabidopsis T-DNA insertion mutant caused a 30-40% reduction in the thylakoid ATP transport and metabolism. (v) TAAC is readily expressed in dark-grown Arabidopsis seedlings, and its level remains stable throughout the greening process. Its expression is highest in developing green tissues and in leaves undergoing senescence or abiotic stress. We propose that the TAAC protein supplies ATP for energy-dependent reactions during thylakoid biogenesis and turnover in plants.     

Further progress towards a catalogue of all Arabidopsis genes: analysis of a set of 5000 non-redundant ESTs

Nearly 7000 Arabidopsis thaliana -expressed sequence tags (ESTs) from 10 cDNA libraries have been sequenced, of which almost 5000 non-redundant tags have been submitted to the EMBL data bank. The quality of the cDNA libraries used is analysed. Similarity searches in international protein data banks have allowed the detection of significant similarities to a wide range of proteins from many organisms. Alignment with ESTs from the rice systematic sequencing project has allowed the detection of amino acid motifs which are conserved between the two organisms, thus identifying tags to genes encoding highly conserved proteins. These genes are candidates for a common framework in genome mapping projects in different plants.     

Genes encoding calmodulin-binding proteins in the Arabidopsis genome.

Analysis of the recently completed Arabidopsis genome sequence indicates that approximately 31% of the predicted genes could not be assigned to functional categories, as they do not show any sequence similarity with proteins of known function from other organisms. Calmodulin (CaM), a ubiquitous and multifunctional Ca(2+) sensor, interacts with a wide variety of cellular proteins and modulates their activity/function in regulating diverse cellular processes. However, the primary amino acid sequence of the CaM-binding domain in different CaM-binding proteins (CBPs) is not conserved. One way to identify most of the CBPs in the Arabidopsis genome is by protein-protein interaction-based screening of expression libraries with CaM. Here, using a mixture of radiolabeled CaM isoforms from Arabidopsis, we screened several expression libraries prepared from flower meristem, seedlings, or tissues treated with hormones, an elicitor, or a pathogen. Sequence analysis of 77 positive clones that interact with CaM in a Ca(2+)-dependent manner revealed 20 CBPs, including 14 previously unknown CBPs. In addition, by searching the Arabidopsis genome sequence with the newly identified and known plant or animal CBPs, we identified a total of 27 CBPs. Among these, 16 CBPs are represented by families with 2-20 members in each family. Gene expression analysis revealed that CBPs and CBP paralogs are expressed differentially. Our data suggest that Arabidopsis has a large number of CBPs including several plant-specific ones. Although CaM is highly conserved between plants and animals, only a few CBPs are common to both plants and animals. Analysis of Arabidopsis CBPs revealed the presence of a variety of interesting domains. Our analyses identified several hypothetical proteins in the Arabidopsis genome as CaM targets, suggesting their involvement in Ca(2+)-mediated signaling networks.     

A novel bioinformatics approach identifies candidate genes for the synthesis and feruloylation of arabinoxylan

Arabinoxylans (AXs) are major components of graminaceous plant cell walls, including those in the grain and straw of economically important cereals. Despite some recent advances in identifying the genes encoding biosynthetic enzymes for a number of other plant cell wall polysaccharides, the genes encoding enzymes of the final stages of AX synthesis have not been identified. We have therefore adopted a novel bioinformatics approach based on estimation of differential expression of orthologous genes between taxonomic divisions of species. Over 3 million public domain cereal and dicot expressed sequence tags were mapped onto the complete sets of rice (Oryza sativa) and Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) genes, respectively. It was assumed that genes in cereals involved in AX biosynthesis would be expressed at high levels and that their orthologs in dicotyledonous plants would be expressed at much lower levels. Considering all rice genes encoding putative glycosyl transferases (GTs) predicted to be integral membrane proteins, genes in the GT43, GT47, and GT61 families emerged as much the strongest candidates. When the search was widened to all other rice or Arabidopsis genes predicted to encode integral membrane proteins, cereal genes in Pfam family PF02458 emerged as candidates for the feruloylation of AX. Our analysis, known activities, and recent findings elsewhere are most consistent with genes in the GT43 families encoding beta-1,4-xylan synthases, genes in the GT47 family encoding xylan alpha-1,2- or alpha-1,3-arabinosyl transferases, and genes in the GT61 family encoding feruloyl-AX beta-1,2-xylosyl transferases.     

Plastids contain a second sec translocase system with essential functions

Proteins that are synthesized on cytoplasmic ribosomes but function within plastids must be imported and then targeted to one of six plastid locations. Although multiple systems that target proteins to the thylakoid membranes or thylakoid lumen have been identified, a system that can direct the integration of inner envelope membrane proteins from the stroma has not been previously described. Genetics and localization studies were used to show that plastids contain two different Sec systems with distinct functions. Loss-of-function mutations in components of the previously described thylakoid-localized Sec system, designated as SCY1 (At2g18710), SECA1 (At4g01800), and SECE1 (At4g14870) in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), result in albino seedlings and sucrose-dependent heterotrophic growth. Loss-of-function mutations in components of the second Sec system, designated as SCY2 (At2g31530) and SECA2 (At1g21650) in Arabidopsis, result in arrest at the globular stage and embryo lethality. Promoter-swap experiments provided evidence that SCY1 and SCY2 are functionally nonredundant and perform different roles in the cell. Finally, chloroplast import and fractionation assays and immunogold localization of SCY2-green fluorescent protein fusion proteins in root tissues indicated that SCY2 is part of an envelope-localized Sec system. Our data suggest that SCY2 and SECA2 function in Sec-mediated integration and translocation processes at the inner envelope membrane.     

Analysis of expressed sequence tags from Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis

Non-redundant expressed sequence tags (ESTs) were generated from six different organs at various developmental stages of Chinese cabbage, Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis. Of the 1,295 ESTs, 915 (71%) showed significantly high homology in nucleotide or deduced amino acid sequences with other sequences deposited in databases, while 380 did not show similarity to any sequences. Briefly, 598 ESTs matched with proteins of identified biological function, 177 with hypothetical proteins or non-annotated Arabidopsis genome sequences, and 140 with other ESTs. About 82% of the top-scored matching sequences were from Arabidopsis or Brassica, but overall 558 (43%) ESTs matched with Arabidopsis ESTs at the nucleotide sequence level. This observation strongly supports the idea that gene-expression profiles of Chinese cabbage differ from that of Arabidopsis, despite their genome structures being similar to each other. Moreover, sequence analyses of 21 Brassica ESTs revealed that their primary structure is different from those of corresponding annotated sequences of Arabidopsis genes. Our data suggest that direct prediction of Brassica gene expression pattern based on the information from Arabidopsis genome research has some limitations. Thus, information obtained from the Brassica EST study is useful not only for understanding of unique developmental processes of the plant, but also for the study of Arabidopsis genome structure.     

Identification of novel families of membrane proteins from the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana

MOTIVATION: The completion of the Arabidopsis genome offers the first opportunity to analyze all of the membrane protein sequences of a plant. The majority of integral membrane proteins including transporters, channels, and pumps contain hydrophobic alpha-helices and can be selected based on TransMembrane Spanning (TMS) domain prediction. By clustering the predicted membrane proteins based on sequence, it is possible to sort the membrane proteins into families of known function, based on experimental evidence or homology, or unknown function. This provides a way to identify target sequences for future functional analysis. RESULTS: An automated approach was used to select potential membrane protein sequences from the set of all predicted proteins and cluster the sequences into related families. The recently completed sequence of Arabidopsis thaliana, a model plant, was analyzed. Of the 25,470 predicted protein sequences 4589 (18%) were identified as containing two or more membrane spanning domains. The membrane protein sequences clustered into 628 distinct families containing 3208 sequences. Of these, 211 families (1764 sequences) either contained proteins of known function or showed homology to proteins of known function in other species. However, 417 families (1444 sequences) contained only sequences with no known function and no homology to proteins of known function. In addition, 1381 sequences did not cluster with any family and no function could be assigned to 1337 of these.     

Proteome map of the chloroplast lumen of Arabidopsis thaliana.

The thylakoid membrane of the chloroplast is the center of oxygenic photosynthesis. To better understand the function of the luminal compartment within the thylakoid network, we have carried out a systematic characterization of the luminal thylakoid proteins from the model organism Arabidopsis thaliana. Our data show that the thylakoid lumen has its own specific proteome, of which 36 proteins were identified. Besides a large group of peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerases and proteases, a family of novel PsbP domain proteins was found. An analysis of the luminal signal peptides showed that 19 of 36 luminal precursors were marked by a twin-arginine motif for import via the Tat pathway. To compare the model organism Arabidopsis with another typical higher plant, we investigated the proteome from the thylakoid lumen of spinach and found that the luminal proteins from both plants corresponded well. As a complement to our experimental investigation, we made a theoretical prediction of the luminal proteins from the whole Arabidopsis genome and estimated that the thylakoid lumen of the chloroplast contains approximately 80 proteins.     

Prediction of the plant beta-barrel proteome: a case study of the chloroplast outer envelope

In the postgenomic era, the transformation of genetic information into biochemical meaning is required. We have analyzed the proteome of the chloroplast outer envelope membrane by an in silico and a proteomic approach. Based on its evolutionary relation to the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria, the outer envelope membrane should contain a large number of beta-barrel proteins. We therefore calculated the probability for the existence of beta-sheet, beta-barrel, and hairpin structures among all proteins of the Arabidopsis thaliana genome. According to the existence of these structures, a number of candidates were selected. This protein pool was analyzed by TargetP to discard sequences with signals that would direct the protein to other organelles different from chloroplasts. In addition, the pool was manually controlled for the presence of proteins known to function outside of the chloroplast envelope. The approach developed here can be used to predict the topology of beta-barrel proteins. For the proteomic approach, proteins of highly purified outer envelope membranes of chloroplasts from Pisum sativum were analyzed by ESI-MS/MS mass spectrometry. In addition to the known components, four new proteins of the outer envelope membranes were identified in this study.     

Proteomics of chloroplast envelope membranes

Proteomics is a very powerful approach to link the information contained in sequenced genomes, like Arabidopsis, to the functional knowledge provided by studies of plant cell compartments, such as chloroplast envelope membranes. This review summarizes the present state of proteomic analyses of highly purified spinach and Arabidopsis envelope membranes. Methods targeted towards the hydrophobic core of the envelope allow identifying new proteins, and especially new transport systems. Common features were identified among the known and newly identified putative envelope inner membrane transporters and were used to mine the complete Arabidopsis genome to establish a virtual plastid envelope integral protein database. Arabidopsis envelope membrane proteins were extracted using different methods, that is, chloroform/methanol extraction, alkaline or saline treatments, in order to retrieve as many proteins as possible, from the most to the less hydrophobic ones. Mass spectrometry analyses lead to the identification of more than 100 proteins. More than 50% of the identified proteins have functions known or very likely to be associated with the chloroplast envelope. These proteins are (a) involved in ion and metabolite transport, (b) components of the protein import machinery and (c) involved in chloroplast lipid metabolism. Some soluble proteins, like proteases, proteins involved in carbon metabolism or in responses to oxidative stress, were associated with envelope membranes. Almost one third of the newly identified proteins have no known function. The present stage of the work demonstrates that a combination of different proteomics approaches together with bioinformatics and the use of different biological models indeed provide a better understanding of chloroplast envelope biochemical machinery at the molecular level.