Site-directed mutagenesis of firefly luciferase active site amino acids: a proposed model for bioluminescence color.

Under physiological conditions firefly luciferase catalyzes the highly efficient emission of yellow-green light from the substrates luciferin, Mg-ATP, and oxygen. In nature, bioluminescence emission by beetle luciferases is observed in colors ranging from green (approximately 530 nm) to red (approximately 635 nm), yet all known luciferases use the same luciferin substrate. In an earlier report [Branchini, B. R., Magyar, R. M., Murtiashaw, M. H., Anderson, S. M., and Zimmer, M. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 15311-15319], we described the effects of mutations at His245 on luciferase activity. In the context of molecular modeling results, we proposed that His245 is located at the luciferase active site. We noted too that the H245 mutants displayed red-shifted bioluminescent emission spectra. We report here the construction and purification of additional His245 mutants, as well as mutants at residues Lys529 and Thr343, all of which are stringently conserved in the beetle luciferase sequences. Analysis of specific activity and steady-state kinetic constants suggested that these residues are involved in luciferase catalysis and the productive binding of substrates. Bioluminescence emission spectroscopy studies indicated that point mutations at His245 and Thr343 produced luciferases that emitted light over the color range from green to red. The results of mutational and biochemical studies with luciferase reported here have enabled us to propose speculative mechanisms for color determination in firefly bioluminescence. An essential role for Thr343, the participation of His245 and Arg218, and the involvement of bound AMP are indicated.     

Mutagenesis evidence that the partial reactions of firefly bioluminescence are catalyzed by different conformations of the luciferase C-terminal domain

Firefly luciferase catalyzes two sequential partial reactions resulting in the emission of light. The enzyme first catalyzes the adenylation of substrate luciferin with Mg-ATP followed by the multistep oxidation of the adenylate to form the light emitter oxyluciferin in an electronically excited state. The beetle luciferases are members of a large superfamily, mainly comprised of nonbioluminescent enzymes that activate carboxylic acid substrates to form acyl-adenylate intermediates. Recently, the crystal structure of a member of this adenylate-forming family, acetyl-coenzyme A (CoA) synthetase, was determined in complex with an unreactive analogue of its acyl-adenylate and CoA [Gulick, A. M., Starai, V. J., Horswill, A. R., Homick, K. M., and Escalante-Semerena, J. C. (2003) Biochemistry 42, 2866-2873]. This structure presented a new conformation for this enzyme family, in which a significant rotation of the C-terminal domain brings residues of a conserved beta-hairpin motif to interact with the active site. We have undertaken a mutagenesis approach to study the roles of key residues of the equivalent beta-hairpin motif in Photinus pyralis luciferase (442IleLysTyrLysGlyTyrGlnVal449) in the overall production of light and the individual adenylation and oxidation partial reactions. Our results strongly suggest that Lys443 is critical for efficient catalysis of the oxidative half-reaction. Additionally, we provide evidence that Lys443 and Lys529, located on opposite sides of the C-terminal domain and conserved in all firefly luciferases, are each essential for only one of the partial reactions of firefly bioluminescence, supporting the proposal that the superfamily enzymes may adopt two different conformations to catalyze the two half-reactions.     

The influence of insertion of a critical residue (Arg356) in structure and bioluminescence spectra of firefly luciferase

The firefly bioluminescence reaction, which uses luciferin, Mg-ATP, and molecular oxygen to yield an electronically excited oxyluciferin, is carried out by luciferase and visible light is emitted. The bioluminescence color of firefly luciferases is determined by the luciferase structure and assay conditions. Among different beetle luciferases, those from Phrixothrix railroad worm emit either yellow or red bioluminescence colors. Sequence alignment analysis shows that the red-emitter luciferase from Phrixothrix hirtus has an additional Arg residue at 353, which is absent in firefly luciferases. We report here the construction and purification of a mutant at residue Arg(356), which is not conserved in beetle luciferases. By insertion of an additional residue (Arg(356)) using site-specific insertion mutagenesis in a green-emitter luciferase (Lampyris turkestanicus) the color of emitted light was changed to red and the optimum temperature of activity was also increased. Insertion of this Arg in an important flexible loop showed changes of the bioluminescence color and the luciferase reaction took place with relatively retention of its basic kinetic properties such as Km and relative activity. Comparison of native and mutant luciferases using homology modeling reveals a significant conformational change of the flexible loop in the red mutant. Movement of flexible loop brought about a new ionic interaction concomitant with a change in polarity of the emitter site, thereby leading to red emission. It is worthwhile to note that the increased optimum temperature and emission of red light might make mutant luciferase a suitable reporter for the study of gene expression and bioluminescence imaging.     

A mutagenesis study of the putative luciferin binding site residues of firefly luciferase

Firefly luciferase catalyzes the highly efficient emission of yellow-green light from substrate firefly luciferin by a sequence of reactions that require Mg-ATP and molecular oxygen. We had previously developed [Branchini, B. R., Magyar, R. A., Murtiashaw, M. H., Anderson, S. M., and Zimmer, M. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 15311-15319] a molecular graphics-based working model of the luciferase active site starting with the first X-ray structure [Conti, E., Franks, N. P., and Brick, P. (1996) Structure 4, 287-298] of the enzyme without bound substrates. In our model, the luciferin binding site contains 15 residues that are within 5 A of the substrate. Using site-directed mutagenesis, we made changes at all of these residues and report here the characterization of the corresponding expressed and purified proteins. Of the 15 residues studied, 12 had a significantly (>or=4-fold K(m) difference) altered binding affinity for luciferin and seven residues, spanning the primary sequence region Arg218-Ala348, had substantially (>or=30 nm) red-shifted bioluminescence emission maxima when mutated. We report here an interpretation of the roles of the mutated residues in substrate binding and bioluminescence color determination. The results of this study generally substantiate the accuracy of our model and provide the foundation for future experiments designed to alter the substrate specificity of firefly luciferase.     

Orthologous gene of beetle luciferase in non-luminous click beetle, Agrypnus binodulus (Elateridae), encodes a fatty acyl-CoA synthetase

A homologous gene of beetle luciferase, AbLL (Agrypnus binodulusluciferase-like gene) was isolated from a Japanese non-luminous click beetle, A. binodulus, and its gene product was characterized. The identity of amino acid sequence deduced from AbLL with the click beetle luciferase from the Jamaican luminous click beetle, Pyrophorus plagiophthalmus, is 55%, which is higher than that between click beetle luciferase and firefly luciferase (approximately 48%). Phylogenetic analysis indicated that AbLL places in a clade of beetle luciferases, suggesting that AbLL is an orthologous gene of beetle luciferase. The gene product of AbLL (AbLL) has medium- and long-chain fatty acyl-CoA synthetase activity, but not luciferase activity. The fatty acyl-CoA synthetic activity was slightly inhibited in the presence of beetle luciferin, suggesting that AbLL has poor affinity for beetle luciferin. By comparing the amino acid residues of the catalytic domains in beetle luciferases with AbLL, the key substitutions for the luminescence activity in beetle luciferase will be proposed.     

The structural origin and biological function of pH-sensitivity in firefly luciferases.

Firefly luciferases are called pH-sensitive because their bioluminescence spectra display a typical red-shift at acidic pH, higher temperatures, and in the presence of heavy metal cations, whereas other beetle luciferases (click beetles and railroadworms) do not, and for this reason they are called pH-insensitive. Despite many studies on firefly luciferases, the origin of pH-sensitivity is far from being understood. This subject is revised in view of recent results. Some substitutions of amino-acid residues influencing pH-sensitivity in firefly luciferases have been identified. Sequence comparison, site-directed mutagenesis and modeling studies have shown a set of residues differing between pH-sensitive and pH-insensitive luciferases which affect bioluminescence colors. Some substitutions dramatically affecting bioluminescence colors in both groups of luciferases are clustered in the loop between residues 223-235 (Photinus pyralis sequence). A network of hydrogen bonds and salt bridges involving the residues N229-S284-E311-R337 was found to be important for affecting bioluminescence colors. It is suggested that these structural elements may affect the benzothiazolyl side of the luciferin-binding site affecting bioluminescence colors. Experimental evidence suggest that the residual red light emission in pH-sensitive luciferases could be a vestige that may have biological importance in some firefly species. Furthermore, the potential utility of pH-sensitivity for intracellular biosensing applications is considered.     

Thr226 is a key residue for bioluminescence spectra determination in beetle luciferases

The comparison of click beetle and railroadworm luciferases (pH-insensitive) with firefly luciferases (pH-sensitive) showed a set of conserved residues differing between the two groups which could be involved with the bioluminescence spectra pH sensitivity. The substitution C258V in Pyrocoelia miyako (Pml) firefly luciferase and V255C in Ragophthalmus ohbai railroad worm luciferase (Rol) had no effect on the bioluminescence spectra. Substitution of Thr226 in the green-light-emitting luciferases of Rol and Pyrearinus termitilluminans (Pyt) click beetle luciferases resulted in red-shifts (12 to 35 nm), whereas the substitution T226N in the red-light-emitting luciferase of Phrixothrix hirtus (PhRE) railroadworm resulted in a 10 nm blue-shift. In PmL the substitution N230S resulted in a typical red mutant (lambda(max) = 611 nm). The bioluminescence spectrum of all these luciferase mutants did not show altered pH-sensitivity nor considerably changed half-bandwidth in relation to the wild-type luciferases. Altogether present data suggest that Thr226 is an important residue for keeping active-site core in both groups of beetle luciferases. The mechanism for bioluminescence color determination between pH-sensitive and pH-insensitive luciferases could be different.     

Crystal structure of native and a mutant of Lampyris turkestanicus luciferase implicate in bioluminescence color shift

Firefly bioluminescence reaction in the presence of Mg^2 +, ATP and molecular oxygen is carried out by luciferase. The luciferase structure alterations or modifications of assay conditions determine the bioluminescence color of firefly luciferase. Among different beetle luciferases, Phrixothrix hirtus railroad worm emits either yellow or red bioluminescence color. Sequence alignment analysis shows that the red-emitter luciferase from Phrixothrix hirtus has an additional arginine residue at 353 that is absent in other firefly luciferases. It was reported that insertion of Arg in an important flexible loop350–359 showed changes in bioluminescence color from green to red and the optimum temperature activity was also increased. To explain the color tuning mechanism of firefly luciferase, the structure of native and a mutant (E354R/356R/H431Y) of Lampyris turkestanicus luciferase is determined at 2.7 Å and 2.2 Å resolutions, respectively. The comparison of structure of both types of Lampyris turkestanicus luciferases reveals that the conformation of this flexible loop is significantly changed by addition of two Arg in this region. Moreover, its surface accessibility is affected considerably and some ionic bonds are made by addition of two positive charge residues. Furthermore, we noticed that the hydrogen bonding pattern of His431 with the flexible loop is changed by replacing this residue with Tyr at this position. Juxtaposition of a flexible loop (residues 351–359) in firefly luciferase and corresponding ionic and hydrogen bonds are essential for color emission.     

Bioluminescence and chemiluminescence literature: 1987 literature,part III

In studying beetle bioluminescence in the early 1960s, Dr McElroy and his colleagues found that the Jamaican click beetle, Pyrophorus plagiophthalamus, was capable of emitting different colours of light. They further found that the luciferin substrate used by this beetle was the same as that in the firefly, demonstrating that the different colours of bioluminescence were due to differences in the structure of the luciferases. We have recently cloned cDNAs from this beetle species which code for at least four different luciferases. The luciferases are distinguishable by their different colours of bioluminescence when expressed in Escherichia coli. The sequence differences between these different luciferases are few, so the amino acids responsible for the different colours of emission must also be few. Through the construction of hybrid luciferases, by rearranging fragments of the original cDNA clones, we have identified some of these amino acid determinants of colour.     

The role of lysine 529, a conserved residue of the acyl-adenylate-forming enzyme superfamily, in firefly luciferase

Firefly luciferase catalyzes the highly efficient emission of yellow-green light from the substrates luciferin, Mg-ATP, and oxygen in a two-step process. The enzyme first catalyzes the adenylation of the carboxylate substrate luciferin with Mg-ATP followed by the oxidation of the acyl-adenylate to the light-emitting oxyluciferin product. The beetle luciferases are members of a large family of nonbioluminescent proteins that catalyze reactions of ATP with carboxylate substrates to form acyl-adenylates. Formation of the luciferase-luciferyl-AMP complex is a specific example of the chemistry common to this enzyme family. Site-directed mutants at positions Lys529, Thr343, and His245 were studied to determine the effects of the amino acid changes at these positions on the individual luciferase-catalyzed adenylation and oxidation reactions. The results suggest that Lys529 is a critical residue for effective substrate orientation and that it provides favorable polar interactions important for transition state stabilization leading to efficient adenylate production. These findings as well as those with the Thr343 and His245 mutants are interpreted in the context of the firefly luciferase X-ray structures and computational-based models of the active site.     

Synergistic mutations produce blue-shifted bioluminescence in firefly luciferase

Light emission from the North American firefly Photinus pyralis, which emits yellow-green (557 nm) light, is widely believed to be the most efficient bioluminescence system known, making this luciferase an excellent tool for monitoring gene expression. In a previous study designed to produce luciferases for simultaneously monitoring two gene expression events, we identified a very promising blue-shifted emitter (548 nm) that contained the mutations Val241Ile, Gly246Ala, and Phe250Ser [Branchini, B. R., Southworth, T. L., Khattak, N. F., Michelini, E., and Roda, A. (2005) Red- and green-emitting firefly luciferase mutants for bioluminescent reporter applications, Anal. Biochem. 345, 140-148]. To establish the basis of the unusual blue-shifted emission, we determined that a simple additive effect of the three individual mutations did not account for the spectral properties of the triple mutant. Instead, the bioluminescence emission spectra of two double mutants containing Phe250Ser and either Val241Ile or Gly246Ala very closely resembled that of the triple mutant. Additional mutagenesis results confirmed that the blue-shifted emission of the double mutants was determined by the synergistic behavior of active site residues. Molecular modeling studies of the Gly246Ala and Phe250Ser double mutant supported the notion that the blue-shifted emission was due to localized changes that increased the hydrophobicity at the emitter site as a result of the addition of a single methyl group at position 246. Moreover, the modeling data suggested that the Ala246 side chain remained close to the emitter through an additional H-bond between Ala246 and the hydroxyl group of Phe250, providing a possible structural basis for the synergistic behavior.     

The role of active site residue arginine 218 in firefly luciferase bioluminescence

Firefly luciferase catalyzes the highly efficient emission of yellow-green light from substrate firefly luciferin by a sequence of reactions that require Mg-ATP and molecular oxygen. We had previously developed a working model of the luciferase active site based on the X-ray structure of the enzyme without bound substrates. In our model, the side chain guanidinium group of Arg218 appears to be located in close proximity to the substrate's hydroxyl group at the bottom of the luciferin binding pocket. A similar role for Arg337 also has been proposed. We report here the construction, purification, and characterization of mutant luciferases R218A, R218Q, R218K, R337Q, and R337K. Alteration of the Arg218 side chain produced enzymes with 15-20-fold increases in the Km values for luciferin. The contrasting near-normal Km values for luciferin determined with the Arg337 enzymes support our proposal that Arg218 (and not Arg337) is an essential luciferin binding site residue. Bioluminescence emission studies indicated that in the absence of a positively charged group at position 218, red bioluminescence was produced. Based on this result and those of additional fluorescence experiments, we speculate that Arg218 maintains the polarity and rigidity of the emitter binding site necessary for the normal yellow-green emission of P. pyralis luciferase. The findings reported here are interpreted in the context of the firefly luciferase X-ray structures and computational-based models of the active site.     

Red-emitting luciferases for bioluminescence reporter and imaging applications

North American firefly Photinus pyralis luciferase, which emits yellow-green light (557 nm), has been adapted for a variety of applications, including gene reporter assays, whole-cell biosensor measurements, and in vivo imaging. Luciferase variants with red-shifted bioluminescence and high specific activity can be paired with green-emitting counterparts for use in dual-color reporter assays or can be used alone for in vivo imaging. Beginning with a previously reported red-emitting thermostable mutant and using mutagenesis techniques, we engineered two luciferases with redder emission maxima while maintaining satisfactory specific activities and thermostability. The novel enzymes were expressed in HEK293 cells, where they performed similarly to Promega’s codon-optimized click beetle red luciferase in model reporter assays. When the firefly luciferase variants were codon-optimized and retested using optimized substrate concentrations, they provided 50- to 100-fold greater integrated light intensities than the click beetle enzyme. These results suggest that the novel enzymes should provide superior performance in dual-color reporter and in vivo imaging applications, and they illustrate the importance of codon optimization for assays in mammalian cells.     

Introduction to beetle luciferases and their applications

All beetle luciferases have evolved from a common ancestor: they all use ATP, O₂, and a common luciferin as substrates. The most studied of these luciferases is that derived from the firefly Photinus pyralis, a beetle in the superfamily of Cantharoidea. The sensitivity with which the activity of this enzyme can be assayed has made it useful in the measurement of minute concentrations of ATP. With the cloning of the cDNA coding this luciferase, it has also found wide application in molecular biology as a reporter gene. We have recently cloned other cDNAs that code for luciferases from the bioluminescent click beetle, Pyrophorus plagiophthalamus, in the superfamily Elateroidea. These newly acquired luciferases are of at least four different types, distinguishable by their ability to emit different colours of bioluminescence ranging from green to orange. Unique properties of these luciferases, especially their emission of multiple colours, may make them additionally useful in applications.     

A new blue-shifted luciferase from the Brazilian Amydetes fanestratus (Coleoptera: Lampyridae) firefly: molecular evolution and structural/functional properties

Firefly luciferases usually produce bioluminescence in the yellow-green region, with colors in the green and yellow-orange extremes of the spectrum being less common. Several firefly luciferases have already been cloned and sequenced, and site-directed mutagenesis studies have already identified important regions and residues for bioluminescence colors. However the structural determinants and mechanisms of bioluminescence colors turned out to be elusive, mainly when comparing luciferases with a high degree of divergence. Thus comparison of more similar luciferases producing colors in the two extremes of the spectrum could be revealing. The South-American fauna of fireflies remains largely unstudied, with some unique taxa that are not found anywhere else in the world and that produce a wide range of bioluminescence colors. Among them, fireflies of the genus Amydetes are especially interesting because its taxonomical status as an independent subfamily or as a tribe is not yet solved, and because they usually produce a continuous bright blue-shifted bioluminescence. In this work we cloned the cDNA for the luciferase of the Atlantic rain forest Amydetes fanestratus firefly, which is found near Sorocaba municipality (S?o Paulo, Brazil). Despite showing a higher degree of identity with the South-American Cratomorphus, the European Lampyris and the Asiatic Pyrocoelia, phylogenetical analysis of the luciferase sequence support the inclusion of Amydetes as an independent subfamily. Amydetes luciferase displays one of the most blue-shifted emission spectra (λ(max) = 538 nm) among beetle luciferases, with lower pH-sensitivity and higher affinity for ATP when compared to other luciferases, making this luciferase attractive for sensitive ATP and reporter assays.     

GroEL chaperone binding to beetle luciferases and the implications for refolding when co-expressed

The folding of many proteins including luciferase in vivo requires the assistance of molecular chaperone proteins. To understand how a chaperone targets luciferase, we took three luciferases that give different bioluminescence with the same luciferin substrate and with differences in homology. The three luciferase genes, firefly luciferase (FF-Luc) (from Pyrocoelia miyako), and red (RE-Luc) and green (GR-Luc) bioluminescence-emitting luciferases (from Phrixothrix railroad-worms), were expressed in Escherichia coli to produce fusion proteins with predicted molecular masses. Subsequently, we observed that DnaK and GroEL were co-purified along with recombinant luciferase. Although the amount of co-purified DnaK was almost the same compared to FF-Luc, GroEL was 25 and 32 times higher in GR-Luc and RE-Luc respectively. Furthermore, co-expression of GroEL/GroES along with luciferase substantially refolded RE-Luc and GR-Luc compared to FF-Luc.     

Interaction of firefly luciferase with substrates and their analogs: a study using fluorescence spectroscopy methods.

The results of the author's laboratory on the interaction of Luciola mingrelica firefly luciferase with substrates and their analogs using both steady-state and time resolved fluorescence are reviewed. The contribution of fluorescence of Trp and Tyr residues of the protein to its intrinsic fluorescence spectrum was estimated. Studies of quenching of Trp and Tyr fluorescence by luciferin and ATP allowed one to determine binding constants of the luciferase with substrates and to show that the binding of one substrate to the luciferase decreases the affinity of the enzyme for the other one. Fluorescence of oxyluciferin and its analogs (dimethyl- and monomethyloxyluciferins) was shown to be a good model of native firefly bioluminescence. A comparison of the fluorescence spectra of oxyluciferin and its analogs in aqueous solutions and in the presence of the luciferase revealed specific and nonspecific effects of the microenvironment on the equilibrium between different ionic forms of oxyluciferin. An approach based on photo-physical concepts of the correlation between luminescence spectra and structure of the emitter and its microenvironment was proposed and this approach was used to analyze bioluminescence spectra of wild-type and mutant luciferases.     

Suitability of Macrolampis firefly and Pyrearinus click beetle luciferases for bacterial light off toxicity biosensor

Bioluminescence is widely used in biosensors. For water toxicity analysis, the naturally bioluminescent bacteria Vibrio fischeri have been used extensively. We investigated the suitability of two new beetle luciferases for Escherichia coli light off biosensors: Macrolampis firefly and Pyrearinus termitilluminans click beetle luciferases. The bioluminescence detection assay using this system is very sensitive, being comparable or superior to V. fischeri. The luciferase of P. termitilluminans produces a strong and sustained bioluminescence that is useful for less sensitive and inexpensive assays that require integration of the emission, whereas Macrolampis luciferase displays a flash-like luminescence that is useful for fast and more sensitive assays. The effect of heavy metals and sanitizing agents was analyzed. Zinc, copper, 1-propanol, and iodide had inhibitory effects on bioluminescence and growth assays; however, in these cases the bioluminescence was not a very reliable indicator of cell growth and metabolic activity because these agents also inhibited the luciferase. On the other hand, mercury and silver strongly affected cell bioluminescence and growth but not the luciferase activity, indicating that bioluminescence was a reliable indicator of cell growth and metabolic activity in this case. Finally, bioluminescent E. coli immobilized in agarose matrix gave a more stable format for environmental assays.     

Theoretical insights into the effect of pH values on oxidation processes in the emission of firefly luciferin in aqueous solution

To elucidate the emission process of firefly d ‐luciferin oxidation across the pH range of 7–9, we identified the emission process by comparison of the potential and free‐energy profiles for the formation of the firefly substrate and emitter, including intermediate molecules such as d ‐luciferyl adenylate, 4‐membered dioxetanone, and their deprotonated chemical species. From these relative free energies, it is observed that the oxidation pathway changes from d ‐luciferin → deprotonated d ‐luciferyl adenylate → deprotonated 4‐membered dioxetanone → oxyluciferin to deprotonated d ‐luciferin → deprotonated d ‐luciferyl adenylate → deprotonated 4‐membered dioxetanone → oxyluciferin with increasing pH value. This indicates that deprotonation on 6′OH occurs during the formation of dioxetanone at pH 7–8, whereas luciferin in the reactant has a 6′OH‐deprotonated form at pH 9.