From heavy metal‐binders to biosensors: Ciliate metallothioneins discussed

Metallothioneins (MTs) are ubiquitous proteins with the capacity to bind heavy metal ions (mainly Cd, Zn or Cu), and they have been found in animals, plants, eukaryotic and prokaryotic micro‐organisms. We have carried out a comparative analysis of ciliate MTs (Tetrahymena species) to well‐known MTs from other organisms, discussing their exclusive features, such as the presence of aromatic amino acid residues and almost exclusive cysteine clusters (CCC) present in cadmium‐binding metallothioneins (CdMTs), higher heavy metal‐MT stoichiometry values, and a strictly conserved modular–submodular structure. Based on this last feature and an extensive gene duplication, we propose a possible model for the evolutionary history of T. thermophila MTs. We also suggest possible functions for these MTs from consideration of their differential gene expressions and discuss the potential use of these proteins and/or their gene promoters for designing molecular or whole‐cell biosensors for a fast detection of heavy metals in diverse polluted ecosystems.     

The metal-binding properties of the blue crab copper specific CuMT-2: a crustacean metallothionein with two cysteine triplets

Most crustacean metallothioneins (MTs) contain 18 Cys residues and bind six divalent metal ions. The copper-specific CuMT-2 (MTC) of the blue crab Callinectes sapidus with 21 Cys residues, of which six are organized in two uncommon Cys-Cys-Cys sequences, represents an exception. However, its metal-binding properties are unknown. By spectroscopic and spectrometric techniques we show that all 21 Cys residues of recombinant MTC participate in the binding of Cu(I), Zn(II), and Cd(II) ions, indicating that both Cys triplets act as ligands. The fully metallated M₈ ^II–MTC (M is Zn, Cd) form possesses high- and low-affinity metal binding sites, as evidenced by the formation of Zn₆–MTC and Cd₇–MTC species from M₈ ^II–MTC after treatment with Chelex 100. The NMR characterization of Cd₇–MTC suggests the presence of a two-domain structure, each domain containing one Cys triplet and encompassing either the three-metal or the four-metal thiolate cluster. Whereas the metal–Cys connectivities in the three-metal cluster located in the N-terminal domain (residues 1–31) reveal a Cd₃Cys₉ cyclohexane-like structure, the presence of dynamic processes in the C-terminal domain (residues 32–64) precluded the determination of the organization of the four-metal cluster. Absorption and circular dichroism features accompanying the stepwise binding of Cu(I) to MTC suggest that all 21 Cys are involved in the binding of eight to nine Cu(I) ions (Cu_8–9–MTC). The subsequent generation of Cu₁₂–MTC involves structural changes consistent with a decrease in the Cu(I) coordination number. Overall, the metal-binding properties of MTC reported here contribute to a better understanding of the role of Cys triplets in MTs.     

Mammalian metallothionein

Chemical, spectroscopic, and structural studies have established the metallothioneins (MTs) to be a widely occurring family of polypeptidic bioinorganic structures. They are distinguished by an extremely high metal (Zn, Cd, Cu) and Cys content and by the arrangement of these components in metal-thiolate clusters. By structural criteria the MTs have recently been subdivided into three classes (Fowler et al.,Experientia Suppl. 52, 19–22, 1987). Class I MTs include mammalian MTs and related forms. Class II MTs display no such relationships, and Class III MTs are atypical polypeptides made up of repetitive γ-glutamylcysteinyl units. Amino acid sequences of over 50 MTs are now known. In mammals, over 55% of the residues, including the 20 Cys, are conserved. Mammalian MTs are genetically polymorphous. Thus, in human tissues and cell lines closely related structures of ten functional isoMTs have been determined either by amino acid or nucleotide sequencing. A comparable degree of polymorphism also exists in the rabbit. Mammalian MTs have been inferred to bind a total of seven bivalent metal ions (Me) through thiolate coordination in two separate clusters, i.e., Me(II)₃(Cys)₉ and Me(II)₄(Cys)₁₁. This two-cluster model has now fully been confirmed by the spatial structures of rat MT-2 and rabbit MT-2a determined by 2D NMR spectroscopy in aqueous solution.     

Metal–Organophosphine Framework‐Derived N,P‐Codoped Carbon‐Confined Cu3P Nanopaticles for Superb Na‐Ion Storage

Metal–organic framework derived approaches are emerging as a viable way to design carbon‐confined transitional metal phosphides (TMPs@C) for energy storage and conversion. However, their preparation generally involves a phosphorization using a large amount of additional P sources, which inevitably releases flammable, poisonous PH₃. Therefore, developing an efficient strategy for eco‐friendly synthesis of TMPs@C is full of challenges. Here, a metal–organophosphine framework (MOPF) derived strategy is developed to allow an eco‐friendly design of TMPs@C without an additional P source, avoiding release of PH₃. To illustrate this strategy, 1,3,5‐triaza‐7‐phosphaadamantane (PTA) ligands and Cu(NO₃)₂ metal centers are employed to construct Cu/PTA‐MOPFs nanosheets. Cu/PTA‐MOPFs can be directly converted to carbon‐confined Cu₃P nanoparticles by annealing. Benefiting from high heteroatom content in PTA, a high doping content of 3.92 at% N and 8.26 at% P can also be achieved in the carbon matrix. As a proof‐of‐concept application, N,P‐codoped carbon‐confined Cu₃P nanoparticles as anodes for Na‐ion storage exhibit a high initial reversible capacity of 332 mA h g^?1 at 50 mA g^?1, and superb rate and cyclic performance. Due to rich coordination modes of organophosphine, MOPFs are expected to become a promising molecular platform for design of various heteroatom‐doped TMPs@C for energy storage and conversion.     

Distinct functions of serial metal‐binding domains in the Escherichia coli P1B‐ATPase CopA

P_1B‐ATPases are among the most common resistance factors to metal‐induced stress. Belonging to the superfamily of P‐type ATPases, they are capable of exporting transition metal ions at the expense of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) hydrolysis. P_1B‐ATPases share a conserved structure of three cytoplasmic domains linked by a transmembrane domain. In addition, they possess a unique class of domains located at the N‐terminus. In bacteria, these domains are primarily associated with metal binding and either occur individually or as serial copies of each other. Within this study, the roles of the two adjacent metal‐binding domains (MBDs) of CopA, the copper export ATPase of Escherichia coli were investigated. From biochemical and physiological data, we deciphered the protein‐internal pathway of copper and demonstrate the distal N‐terminal MBD to possess a function analogous to the metallochaperones of related prokaryotic copper resistance systems, that is its involvement in the copper transfer to the membrane‐integral ion‐binding sites of CopA. In contrast, the proximal domain MBD2 has a regulatory role by suppressing the catalytic activity of CopA in absence of copper. Furthermore, we propose a general functional divergence of tandem MBDs in P_1B‐ATPases, which is governed by the length of the inter‐domain linker.     

Functional comparision between truncated MTT1 and truncated MTT2 from Tetrahyemna thermophila

Metallothioneins (MTs) are low-molecular-weight proteins with high Cys content and high metal-chelating ability. CdMT and CuMT subfamilies present different characteristics in Tetrahymena. To explore the effect of the cysteine arrangement and sequence length of MTs for binding different metal ions, MTT1, truncated MTT1 (TM1), MTT2, and truncated MTT2 (TM2) were expressed in E. coli. The half-maximal inhibiting concentrations (IC₅₀) of Cd²⁺ and Cu⁺ for the recombinant strains were different. Furthermore, E. coli cells expressing MTT1 and TM1 exhibited higher accumulating ability for Cd²⁺ than cells expressing MTT2 and TM2. However, the opposite is true for Cu⁺. The binding ability of the different recombinant proteins to Cd²⁺ and Cu⁺ were also different. MTT1 and truncated mutant TM1 were the preference for Cd²⁺, whereas MTT2 and truncated mutant TM2 were the preference for Cu⁺ coordination. These results showed that metal ion tolerance and accumulation ability not only depended on cysteine arrangement pattern but also on sequence length of MT in Tetrahymena.     

Combined Two‐Stage Xanthate Processes for the Treatment of Copper‐Containing Wastewater

Heavy metal removal is mainly conducted by adjusting the wastewater pH to form metal hydroxide precipitates. However, in recent years, the xanthate process with a high metal removal efficiency, attracted attention due to its use of sorption/desorption of heavy metals from aqueous solutions. In this study, two kinds of agricultural xanthates, insoluble peanut‐shell xanthate (IPX) and insoluble starch xanthate (ISX), were used as sorbents to treat the copper‐containing wastewater (Cu concentration from 50 to 1,000 mg/L). The experimental results showed that the maximum Cu removal efficiency by IPX was 93.5 % in the case of high Cu concentrations, whereby 81.1 % of copper could rapidly be removed within one minute. Moreover, copper‐containing wastewater could also be treated by ISX over a wide range (50 to 1,000 mg/L) to a level that meets the Taiwan EPA's effluent regulations (3 mg/L) within 20 minutes. Whereas IPX had a maximum binding capacity for copper of 185 mg/g IPX, the capacity for ISX was 120 mg/g ISX. IPX is cheaper than ISX, and has the benefits of a rapid reaction and a high copper binding capacity, however, it exhibits a lower copper removal efficiency. A sequential IPX and ISX treatment (i.e., two‐stage xanthate processes) could therefore be an excellent alternative. The results obtained using the two‐stage xanthate process revealed an effective copper treatment. The effluent (C_e) was below 0.6 mg/L, compared to the influent (C₀) of 1,001 mg/L at pH = 4 and a dilution rate of 0.6 h^–1. Furthermore, the Cu‐ISX complex formed could meet the Taiwan TCLP regulations, and be classified as non‐hazardous waste. The xanthatilization of agricultural wastes offers a comprehensive strategy for solving both agricultural waste disposal and metal‐containing wastewater treatment problems.     

Copper binding in IscA inhibits iron‐sulphur cluster assembly in Escherichia coli

Among the iron‐sulphur cluster assembly proteins encoded by gene cluster iscSUA‐hscBA‐fdx in Escherichia coli, IscA has a unique and strong iron binding activity and can provide iron for iron‐sulphur cluster assembly in proteins in vitro. Deletion of IscA and its paralogue SufA results in an E. coli mutant that fails to assemble [4Fe‐4S] clusters in proteins under aerobic conditions, suggesting that IscA has a crucial role for iron‐sulphur cluster biogenesis. Here we report that among the iron‐sulphur cluster assembly proteins, IscA also has a strong and specific binding activity for Cu(I) in vivo and in vitro. The Cu(I) centre in IscA is stable and resistant to oxidation under aerobic conditions. Mutation of the conserved cysteine residues that are essential for the iron binding in IscA abolishes the copper binding activity, indicating that copper and iron may share the same binding site in the protein. Additional studies reveal that copper can compete with iron for the metal binding site in IscA and effectively inhibits the IscA‐mediated [4Fe‐4S] cluster assembly in E. coli cells. The results suggest that copper may not only attack the [4Fe‐4S] clusters in dehydratases, but also block the [4Fe‐4S] cluster assembly in proteins by targeting IscA in cells.     

Hints for Metal-Preference Protein Sequence Determinants: Different Metal Binding Features of the Five Tetrahymena thermophila Metallothioneins

The metal binding preference of metallothioneins (MTs) groups them in two extreme subsets, the Zn/Cd- and the Cu-thioneins. Ciliates harbor the largest MT gene/protein family reported so far, including 5 paralogs that exhibit relatively low sequence similarity, excepting MTT2 and MTT4. In Tetrahymena thermophila, three MTs (MTT1, MTT3 and MTT5) were considered Cd-thioneins and two (MTT2 and MTT4) Cu-thioneins, according to gene expression inducibility and phylogenetic analysis. In this study, the metal-binding abilities of the five MTT proteins were characterized, to obtain information about the folding and stability of their cognate- and non-cognate metal complexes, and to characterize the T. thermophila MT system at protein level. Hence, the five MTTs were recombinantly synthesized as Zn²⁺-, Cd²⁺- or Cu⁺-complexes, which were analyzed by electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), circular dichroism (CD), and UV-vis spectrophotometry. Among the Cd-thioneins, MTT1 and MTT5 were optimal for Cd²⁺ coordination, yielding unique Cd₁₇- and Cd₈- complexes, respectively. When binding Zn²⁺, they rendered a mixture of Zn-species. Only MTT5 was capable to coordinate Cu⁺, although yielding heteronuclear Zn-, Cu-species or highly unstable Cu-homometallic species. MTT3 exhibited poor binding abilities both for Cd²⁺ and for Cu⁺, and although not optimally, it yielded the best result when coordinating Zn²⁺. The two Cu-thioneins, MTT2 and MTT4 isoforms formed homometallic Cu-complexes (major Cu₂₀-MTT) upon synthesis in Cu-supplemented hosts. Contrarily, they were unable to fold into stable Cd-complexes, while Zn-MTT species were only recovered for MTT4 (major Zn₁₀-MTT4). Thus, the metal binding preferences of the five T. thermophila MTs correlate well with their previous classification as Cd- and Cu-thioneins, and globally, they can be classified from Zn/Cd- to Cu-thioneins according to the gradation: MTT1>MTT5>MTT3>MTT4>MTT2. The main mechanisms underlying the evolution and specialization of the MTT metal binding preferences may have been internal tandem duplications, presence of doublet and triplet Cys patterns in Zn/Cd-thioneins, and optimization of site specific amino acid determinants (Lys for Zn/Cd- and Asn for Cu-coordination).     

Chiral copper(I)—thiolate clusters in metallothionein and glutathione

Metallothionein (MT) is a ubiquitous mammalian protein comprising 61 or 62 nonaromatic amino acids of which 20 are cysteine residues. The high sulfhydryl content imparts to this protein a unique and remarkable ability to bind multiple metal ions in structurally significant metal–thiolate clusters. MT can bind seven divalent metal ions per protein molecule in two domains with exclusive tetrahedral metal coordination. The domain stoichiometries for the M₇S₂₀ structure are M₄(S_cys)₁₁ (α domain) and M₃(S_cys)₉ (β domain). Up to 12 Cu(I) ions can displace the 7 Zn²⁺ ions bound per molecule in Zn₇–MT. The incoming Cu(I) ions adopt a trigonal planar geometry with domain stoichiometries for the Cu₁₂S₂₀ structure of Cu₆(S_cys)₁₁ and Cu₆(S_cys)₉ for the α and β domains, respectively. The circular dichroism (CD) spectra recorded as Cu⁺ is added to Zn₇–MT to form Cu₁₂–MT directly report structural changes that take place in the metal binding region. The spectrum arises under charge transfer transitions between the cysteine S and the Cu(I); because the Cu(I)–thiolate cluster units are located within the chiral binding site, intensities in the CD spectrum are directly related to changes in the binding site. The CD technique clearly indicates stoichiometries of several Cu(I)–MT species. Model Cu(I)–thiolate complexes, using the tripeptide glutathione as the sulfhydryl source, were examined by CD spectroscopy to obtain transition energies and the Cu(I)–thiolate coordination geometries which correspond to these bands. Possible structures for the Cu(I)–thiolate clusters in the α and β domains of Cu₁₂–MT are proposed. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Structure and interactions of the C‐terminal metal binding domain of Archaeoglobus fulgidus CopA

The Cu⁺‐ATPase CopA from Archaeoglobus fulgidus belongs to the P_1B family of the P‐type ATPases. These integral membrane proteins couple the energy of ATP hydrolysis to heavy metal ion translocation across membranes. A defining feature of P_1B‐1‐type ATPases is the presence of soluble metal binding domains at the N‐terminus (N‐MBDs). The N‐MBDs exhibit a conserved ferredoxin‐like fold, similar to that of soluble copper chaperones, and bind metal ions via a conserved CXXC motif. The N‐MBDs enable Cu⁺ regulation of turnover rates apparently through Cu‐sensitive interactions with catalytic domains. A. fulgidus CopA is unusual in that it contains both an N‐terminal MBD and a C‐terminal MBD (C‐MBD). The functional role of the unique C‐MBD has not been established. Here, we report the crystal structure of the apo, oxidized C‐MBD to 2.0 Å resolution. In the structure, two C‐MBD monomers form a domain‐swapped dimer, which has not been observed previously for similar domains. In addition, the interaction of the C‐MBD with the other cytoplasmic domains of CopA, the ATP binding domain (ATPBD) and actuator domain (A‐domain), has been investigated. Interestingly, the C‐MBD interacts specifically with both of these domains, independent of the presence of Cu⁺ or nucleotides. These data reinforce the uniqueness of the C‐MBD and suggest a distinct structural role for the C‐MBD in CopA transport. Proteins 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Isoform‐specific responses of metallothioneins in a marine pollution biomonitor,the green‐lipped mussel Perna viridis,towards different stress stimulations

Metallothioneins (MTs) are commonly used as biomarker for metal pollution assessment in marine ecosystems. Using integrated genomic and proteomic analyses, this study characterized two types of MT isoform in the digestive gland of a common biomonitor, the green‐lipped mussel Perna viridis, towards the challenges of a metal (cadmium; Cd) and a non‐metal oxidant (hydrogen peroxide; H₂O₂) respectively. The two isoforms differed in their deduced protein sequences, with 73 amino acids for MT10‐I and 72 for MT10‐II (a novel type), but both consisted of a high percentage (27.4 to 29.2%) of cysteine. Two‐dimensional gel and Western blot showed that the MT proteins were present in multiple isoform spots, and they were further validated to be MT10‐I and MT10‐II using MS analysis coupled with unrestricted modifications searching. Expression of mRNA revealed that MT10‐I responded promptly to Cd but had a lagged induction to H₂O₂ treatments, while MT10‐II was exclusively induced by Cd treatment over the course of exposure. Expression of the MT proteins also showed a delayed response to H₂O₂, compared to Cd treatments. This study uncovered the potential different functional roles of various MTs isoforms in P. viridis and thus advances the resolution of using MTs as biomarkers in future applications.     

Isolation of highly copper‐tolerant fungi from the smelter of the Naganobori copper mine,an historic mine in Japan

Aims: Copper is a critical metal of modern industry, and is the most widespread heavy metal contaminant in wastewater. Therefore, isolation of copper‐tolerant microbes having the potential as biosorbent is fascinating not only from an environmental microbiology, but also from a biotechnology view point. In this study, we attempted to isolate highly copper‐tolerant microbes from soil samples of the Nabanobori copper mine, the oldest mine in Japan. Methods and Results: As a result of an enrichment culture, two fungal strains were isolated from soil of the smelter remains. The isolates could grow in a maximum of 200 mmol l^?l Cu²⁺, and grew under a wide pH range. The Cu²⁺‐binding capacity of nontreated biomass of the isolates was around 35 mg Cu²⁺ g^?1‐biomass. Analysis of 18S rDNA suggested that the isolates belong to the Aspergillus/Penicillium clade, but they represented a distinct lineage against known neighbours. Conclusion: The isolates were highly copper‐tolerant, and their Cu²⁺‐binding capacity was comparable to well‐studied fungal sorbents. The isolates were implied as novel species. Soil of the historic old mine under weather‐beaten conditions might be a suitable source for metal‐tolerant microbes. Significance and Impact of the Study: The present results advance our understanding of metal‐tolerant microbes, and offer a new tool for both environmental control and metal recovery operations.     

Synergetic DNA‐Cleaving Activities of the Metal Complexes of a Polyether‐Tethered Pyrrole‐polyamide Dimer

A simple polyether‐tethered pyrrole‐polyamide dimer 1 was synthesized in 50% yield from the reaction of 2,2,2‐trichloro‐1‐(1‐methyl‐4‐nitro‐1H‐pyrrol‐2‐yl)ethanone with 2,2′‐[1,2‐ethanediylbis(oxy)]bisethanamine, and fully characterized on the basis of ¹H‐ and ¹³C‐NMR, MS, HR‐MS, and IR data. Agarose gel‐electrophoresis study of the cleavage of plasmid pBR322 DNA by the complexes of compound 1 with seven metal ions indicated that most of the metal complexes were capable of efficiently cleaving DNA at pH 7.0 and 37°. Among them, the Cu^II complex exhibited the highest activity, with the maximal catalytic rate constant k_max and Michaelis constant K_M being 5.61 h^?1 and 7.30 mM , respectively. Spectroscopic, ESI‐MS, ethidium‐bromide (EB) displacement, and viscosity experiments indicated that compound 1 could form a 1 : 1 complex with Cu^II ion, and that this complex showed moderate binding affinity toward calf‐thymus DNA.     

Extracellular synthesis of cuprous selenide nanospheres by a biological‐chemical coupling reduction process in an anaerobic microbial system

Biosynthesis of metal nanoparticles represents a clean, eco‐friendly and sustainable “green chemistry” engineering. Lately, a number of metal selenides were successfully synthesized by biological methods. Here, cuprous selenide (Cu₂Se) nanospheres were prepared under mild conditions by a novel biological‐chemical coupling reduction process. The simple process takes place between EDTA‐Cu and Na₂SeO₃ in presence of an alkaline solution containing NaBH₄ and a selenite‐reducing bacteria, Pantoea agglomerans. It is noteworthy that the isolated Pantoea agglomerans and Cu⁺ ions, where the latter are obtained from reducing Cu²⁺ ions by NaBH₄, play a key role, and Cu⁺ ions not only can promote the generation of Se^2? ions as a catalyst, but also can react with Se^2? ions to form Cu₂Se. XRD pattern, SEM, and TEM images indicated that Cu₂Se nanoparticles were tetragonal crystal structure and the nanospheres diameter were about 100 nm. EDX, UV–vis, and FTIR spectra show that the biosynthesized Cu₂Se nanospheres are wrapped by protein and have a better stability. This work first proposes a new biosynthesis mechanism, and has important reference value for biological preparation of metal selenide nanomaterials. © 2016 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:1264–1270, 2016     

2‐Hydroxynaphthalene‐1‐carbaldehyde‐ and 2‐(Aminomethyl)pyridine‐Based Schiff Base CuII Complexes for DNA Binding and Cleavage

Three mononuclear Cu^II complexes, [CuCl(naph‐pa)] ( 1 ), [Cu(bipy)(naph‐pa)]Cl ( 2 ), and [Cu(naph‐pa)(phen)]Cl ( 3 ) ((naph‐pa)=Schiff base derived from the condensation of 2‐hydroxynaphthalene‐1‐carbaldehyde and 2‐picolylamine (=2‐(aminomethyl)pyridine), bipy=2,2′‐bypiridine, and phen=1,10‐phenanthroline) were synthesized and characterized. Complex 1 exhibits square‐planar geometry, and 2 and 3 exhibit square pyramidal geometry, where Schiff base and bipy/phen act as NNO and as NN donor ligands, respectively. CT (Calf thymus)‐DNA‐binding studies revealed that the complexes bind through intercalative mode and show good binding propensity (intrinsic binding constant K_b: 0.98×10⁵, 2.22×10⁵, and 2.67×10⁵ M ^?1 for 1 – 3 , resp.). The oxidative and hydrolytic DNA‐cleavage activity of these complexes has been studied by gel electrophoresis: all the complexes displayed chemical nuclease activity in the presence and absence of H₂O₂. From the kinetic experiments, hydrolytic DNA cleavage rate constants were determined as 2.48, 3.32, and 4.10 h^?1 for 1 – 3 , respectively. It amounts to (0.68–1.14)×10⁸‐fold rate enhancement compared to non‐catalyzed DNA cleavage, which is impressive. The complexes display binding and cleavage propensity to DNA in the order of 3 > 2 > 1 .     

Formation of CuInSe2 and CuGaSe2 Thin‐Films Deposited by Three‐Stage Thermal Co‐Evaporation: A Real‐Time X‐Ray Diffraction and Fluorescence Study

Thin film solar cells based on co‐evaporated Cu(In,Ga)Se₂ absorber films present the highest efficiencies among current polycrystalline thin‐film technologies. Thanks to the development of a novel experimental setup for in situ growth studies, it was possible to follow the formation of the crystalline phases during such deposition processes for the first time. This synchrotron‐based energy‐dispersive X‐ray diffraction and fluorescence setup is suited for real‐time studies of thin film vapor deposition processes. Focusing on the growth of CuInSe₂ and CuGaSe₂ fabricated by three‐stage processing, we find that the phase transitions in the Cu‐In‐Se system follow the reported pseudo‐binary In₂Se₃‐Cu₂Se phase diagram. This requires a transformation of the Se sublattice during the incorporation of Cu‐Se into the In₂Se₃ precursor film from the first process stage. In the Cu‐Ga‐Se system, besides an increase in the lattice spacings, we observe no transformation of the Se sublattice. Furthermore, the structural defects of the Ga‐Se precursor film are preserved until the CuGaSe₂ stoichiometry is reached. By means of model calculations of the fluorescence signals, we confirm in both systems the segregation of Cu₂Se at the surface near a concentration of 25 at.% Cu shortly after the recrystallization of the films. The modeling also reveals that Cu₂Se penetrates into the CuInSe₂ film, whereas it remains at the surface of the CuGaSe₂ film.