Molecular modeling reveals binding interface of γ‐tubulin with GCP4 and interactions with noscapinoids

The initiation of microtubule assembly within cells is guided by a cone shaped multi‐protein complex, γ‐tubulin ring complex (γTuRC) containing γ‐tubulin and atleast five other γ‐tubulin‐complex proteins (GCPs), i.e., GCP2, GCP3, GCP4, GCP5, and GCP6. The rim of γTuRC is a ring of γ‐tubulin molecules that interacts, via one of its longitudinal interfaces, with GCP2, GCP3, or GCP4 and, via other interface, with α/β?tubulin dimers recruited for the microtubule lattice formation. These interactions however, are not well understood in the absence of crystal structure of functional reconstitution of γTuRC subunits. In this study, we elucidate the atomic interactions between γ‐tubulin and GCP4 through computational techniques. We simulated two complexes of γ‐tubulin‐GCP4 complex (we called dimer1 and dimer2) for 25 ns to obtain a stable complex and calculated the ensemble average of binding free energies of ?158.82 and ?170.19 kcal/mol for dimer1 and ?79.53 and ?101.50 kcal/mol for dimer2 using MM‐PBSA and MM‐GBSA methods, respectively. These highly favourable binding free energy values points to very robust interactions between GCP4 and γ‐tubulin. From the results of the free‐energy decomposition and the computational alanine scanning calculation, we identified the amino acids crucial for the interaction of γ‐tubulin with GCP4, called hotspots. Furthermore, in the endeavour to identify chemical leads that might interact at the interface of γ‐tubulin‐GCP4 complex; we found a class of compounds based on the plant alkaloid, noscapine that binds with high affinity in a cavity close to γ‐tubulin‐GCP4 interface compared with previously reported compounds. All noscapinoids displayed stable interaction throughout the simulation, however, most robust interaction was observed for bromo‐noscapine followed by noscapine and amino‐noscapine. This offers a novel chemical scaffold for γ‐tubulin binding drugs near γ‐tubulin‐GCP4 interface. Proteins 2015; 83:827–843. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

How do Plants Organize Microtubules Without a Centrosome？

A microtubule nucleates from a γ-tubuUn complex, which consists of γ-tubulin, proteins from the SPC971SPC98 family, and the WD40 motif protein GCP-WD. We analyzed the phylogenetic relationships of the genes encoding these proteins and found that the components of this complex are widely conserved among land plants and other eukaryotes. By contrast, the interphase and mitotic arrays of microtubules in land plants differ from those in other eukaryotes. In the interphase cortical array, the majority of microtubules nucleate on existing microtubules in the absence of conspicuous microtubule organizing centers （MTOCs）, such as a centrosome. During mitosis, the spindle also forms in the absence of conspicuous MTOCs. Both poles of the spindle are broad, and branched structures of microtubules called microtubule converging centers form at the poles. In this review, we hypothesize that the microtubule converging centers form via microtubule-dependent microtubule nucleation, as in the case of the interphase arrays. The evolutionary insights arising from the molecular basis of the diversity in microtubule organization are discussed.     

NMR secondary structure and interactions of recombinant human MOZART1 protein,a component of the gamma‐tubulin complex

Mitotic‐spindle organizing protein associated with a ring of γ‐tubulin 1 (MOZART1) is an 8.5 kDa protein linked to regulation of γ‐tubulin ring complexes (γTuRCs), which are involved in nucleation of microtubules. Despite its small size, MOZART1 represents a challenging target for detailed characterization in vitro. We described herein a protocol for efficient production of recombinant human MOZART1 in Escherichia coli and assessed the properties of the purified protein using a combination of size exclusion chromatography coupled with multiangle light scattering (SEC‐MALS), dynamic light scattering (DLS), and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments. MOZART1 forms heterogeneous oligomers in solution. We identified optimal detergent and buffer conditions for recording well resolved NMR experiments allowing nearly full protein assignment and identification of three distinct alpha‐helical structured regions. Finally, using NMR, we showed that MOZART1 interacts with the N‐terminus (residues 1–250) of GCP3 (γ‐tubulin complex protein 3). Our data illustrate the capacity of MOZART1 to form oligomers, promoting multiple contacts with a subset of protein partners in the context of microtubule nucleation.     

Fission yeast Pcp1 links polo kinase‐mediated mitotic entry to γ‐tubulin‐dependent spindle formation

The centrosomal pericentrin‐related proteins play pivotal roles in various aspects of cell division; however their underlying mechanisms remain largely elusive. Here we show that fission‐yeast pericentrin‐like Pcp1 regulates multiple functions of the spindle pole body (SPB) through recruiting two critical factors, the γ‐tubulin complex (γ‐TuC) and polo kinase (Plo1). We isolated two pcp1 mutants (pcp1‐15 and pcp1‐18) that display similar abnormal spindles, but with remarkably different molecular defects. Both mutants exhibit defective monopolar spindle microtubules that emanate from the mother SPB. However, while pcp1‐15 fails to localise the γ‐TuC to the mitotic SPB, pcp1‐18 is specifically defective in recruiting Plo1. Consistently Pcp1 forms a complex with both γ‐TuC and Plo1 in the cell. pcp1‐18 is further defective in the mitotic‐specific reorganisation of the nuclear envelope (NE), leading to impairment of SPB insertion into the NE. Moreover pcp1‐18, but not pcp1‐15, is rescued by overproducing nuclear pore components or advancing mitotic onset. The central role for Pcp1 in orchestrating these processes provides mechanistic insight into how the centrosome regulates multiple cellular pathways.     

Detection of the Microtubule Cytoskeleton of the Coccidian Toxoplasma gondii and the Hemoflagellate Leishmania donovani by Monoclonal Antibodies Specific for β-Tubulin1

Seven monoclonal antibodies specific for mammalian β-tubulin demonstrate the microtubule cytoskeleton of Toxoplasma gondii and Leishmania donovani by indirect immunofluorescence microscopy. Immunoblots of T. gondii and L. donovani proteins separated by SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis confirm the specificity of the monoclonal antibodies for tubulin. Differential staining of flagellar and subpellicular microtubule populations was not seen in L. donovani with these antibodies. All seven antibodies also detected the subpellicular microtubules of T. gondii, but the polar ring and conoid of this organism was not visualized by any of them. This technique provides a rapid and specific way to assess microtubular organization in whole organisms.     

γ‐Tubulin Ring Complexes and EB1 play antagonistic roles in microtubule dynamics and spindle positioning

γ‐Tubulin is critical for microtubule (MT) assembly and organization. In metazoa, this protein acts in multiprotein complexes called γ‐Tubulin Ring Complexes (γ‐TuRCs). While the subunits that constitute γ‐Tubulin Small Complexes (γ‐TuSCs), the core of the MT nucleation machinery, are essential, mutation of γ‐TuRC‐specific proteins in Drosophila causes sterility and morphological abnormalities via hitherto unidentified mechanisms. Here, we demonstrate a role of γ‐TuRCs in controlling spindle orientation independent of MT nucleation activity, both in cultured cells and in vivo, and examine a potential function for γ‐TuRCs on astral MTs. γ‐TuRCs locate along the length of astral MTs, and depletion of γ‐TuRC‐specific proteins increases MT dynamics and causes the plus‐end tracking protein EB1 to redistribute along MTs. Moreover, suppression of MT dynamics through drug treatment or EB1 down‐regulation rescues spindle orientation defects induced by γ‐TuRC depletion. Therefore, we propose a role for γ‐TuRCs in regulating spindle positioning by controlling the stability of astral MTs.     

CDK5RAP2 stimulates microtubule nucleation by the gamma-tubulin ring complex

CDK5RAP2 is a human microcephaly protein that contains a γ-tubulin complex (γ-TuC)-binding domain conserved in Drosophila melanogaster centrosomin and Schizosaccharomyces pombe Mto1p and Pcp1p, which are γ-TuC-tethering proteins. In this study, we show that this domain within CDK5RAP2 associates with the γ-tubulin ring complex (γ-TuRC) to stimulate its microtubule-nucleating activity and is therefore referred to as the γ-TuRC-mediated nucleation activator (γ-TuNA). γ-TuNA but not its γ-TuC-binding-deficient mutant stimulates microtubule nucleation by purified γ-TuRC in vitro and induces extensive, γ-TuRC-dependent nucleation of microtubules in a microtubule regrowth assay. γ-TuRC bound to γ-TuNA contains NME7, FAM128A/B, and actin in addition to γ-tubulin and GCP2-6. RNA interference-mediated depletion of CDK5RAP2 impairs both centrosomal and acentrosomal microtubule nucleation, although γ-TuRC assembly is unaffected. Collectively, these results suggest that the γ-TuNA found in CDK5RAP2 has regulatory functions in γ-TuRC-mediated microtubule nucleation.     

Mitosis-specific anchoring of gamma tubulin complexes by pericentrin controls spindle organization and mitotic entry

Microtubule nucleation is the best known function of centrosomes. Centrosomal microtubule nucleation is mediated primarily by gamma tubulin ring complexes (gamma TuRCs). However, little is known about the molecules that anchor these complexes to centrosomes. In this study, we show that the centrosomal coiled-coil protein pericentrin anchors gamma TuRCs at spindle poles through an interaction with gamma tubulin complex proteins 2 and 3 (GCP2/3). Pericentrin silencing by small interfering RNAs in somatic cells disrupted gamma tubulin localization and spindle organization in mitosis but had no effect on gamma tubulin localization or microtubule organization in interphase cells. Similarly, overexpression of the GCP2/3 binding domain of pericentrin disrupted the endogenous pericentrin-gamma TuRC interaction and perturbed astral microtubules and spindle bipolarity. When added to Xenopus mitotic extracts, this domain uncoupled gamma TuRCs from centrosomes, inhibited microtubule aster assembly, and induced rapid disassembly of preassembled asters. All phenotypes were significantly reduced in a pericentrin mutant with diminished GCP2/3 binding and were specific for mitotic centrosomal asters as we observed little effect on interphase asters or on asters assembled by the Ran-mediated centrosome-independent pathway. Additionally, pericentrin silencing or overexpression induced G2/antephase arrest followed by apoptosis in many but not all cell types. We conclude that pericentrin anchoring of gamma tubulin complexes at centrosomes in mitotic cells is required for proper spindle organization and that loss of this anchoring mechanism elicits a checkpoint response that prevents mitotic entry and triggers apoptotic cell death.     

Spatial regulation of the spindle assembly checkpoint and anaphase‐promoting complex in Aspergillus nidulans

The spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) plays a critical role in preventing mitotic errors by inhibiting anaphase until all kinetochores are correctly attached to spindle microtubules. In spite of the economic and medical importance of filamentous fungi, relatively little is known about the behavior of SAC proteins in these organisms. In our efforts to understand the role of γ‐tubulin in cell cycle regulation, we have created functional fluorescent protein fusions of four SAC proteins in Aspergillus nidulans, the homologs of Mad2, Mps1, Bub1/BubR1 and Bub3. Time‐lapse imaging reveals that SAC proteins are in distinct compartments of the cell until early mitosis when they co‐localize at the spindle pole body. SAC activity is, thus, spatially regulated in A. nidulans. Likewise, Cdc20, an activator of the anaphase‐promoting complex/cyclosome, is excluded from interphase nuclei, but enters nuclei at mitotic onset and accumulates to a higher level in mitotic nuclei than in the surrounding nucleoplasm before leaving in anaphase/telophase. The activity of this critical cell cycle regulatory complex is likely regulated by the location of Cdc20. Finally, the γ‐tubulin mutation mipAD159 causes a nuclear‐specific failure of nuclear localization of Mps1 and Bub1/R1 but not of Cdc20, Bub3 or Mad2.     

G protein β subunit is closely associated with microtubules

Previously, we have identified the association of G protein β subunit (Gβ) with mitotic spindles in various mammalian cells. Since microtubules are the main component of mitotic spindles, here we have isolated bovine brain microtubules and purified Gβ subunit to identify the close association of Gβ subunit with purified brain microtubules and have shown the direct incorporation of Gβ subunit into the microtubules both in vitro and in vivo. It was found that: (1) microtubular fraction isolated from bovine brain contained Gβ subunit, (2) coimmunoprecipitation demonstrated that Gβ subunit could be coprecipitated with tubulin, (3) addition of purified Gβ subunit into cytosolic extract for microtubule assembly caused direct incorporation of Gβ subunit into assembled microtubules and increased the association of microtubule-associated proteins with microtubules, and (4) incubation of exogenous Gβ subunit with detergent-permeabilized cells resulted in direct incorporation of Gβ subunit into microtubule fibers and depolymerized tubulin molecules. We conclude that G protein β subunit is closely associated with microtubules and may play an important role in the regulation of microtubule formation in addition to its regulatory role in cellular signal transduction. J. Cell. Biochem. 70:553–562, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

β‐Tubulin mutations that cause severe neuropathies disrupt axonal transport

Microtubules are fundamental to neuronal morphogenesis and function. Mutations in tubulin, the major constituent of microtubules, result in neuronal diseases. Here, we have analysed β‐tubulin mutations that cause neuronal diseases and we have identified mutations that strongly inhibit axonal transport of vesicles and mitochondria. These mutations are in the H12 helix of β‐tubulin and change the negative charge on the surface of the microtubule. This surface is the interface between microtubules and kinesin superfamily motor proteins (KIF). The binding of axonal transport KIFs to microtubules is dominant negatively disrupted by these mutations, which alters the localization of KIFs in neurons and inhibits axon elongation in vivo. In humans, these mutations induce broad neurological symptoms, such as loss of axons in the central nervous system and peripheral neuropathy. Thus, our data identified the critical region of β‐tubulin required for axonal transport and suggest a molecular mechanism for human neuronal diseases caused by tubulin mutations.     

TgICMAP1 Is a Novel Microtubule Binding Protein in Toxoplasma gondii

The microtubule cytoskeleton provides essential structural support for all eukaryotic cells and can be assembled into various higher order structures that perform drastically different functions. Understanding how microtubule-containing assemblies are built in a spatially and temporally controlled manner is therefore fundamental to understanding cell physiology. Toxoplasma gondii, a protozoan parasite, contains at least five distinct tubulin-containing structures, the spindle pole, centrioles, cortical microtubules, the conoid, and the intra-conoid microtubules. How these five structurally and functionally distinct sets of tubulin containing structures are constructed and maintained in the same cell is an intriguing problem. Previously, we performed a proteomic analysis of the T. gondii apical complex, a cytoskeletal complex located at the apical end of the parasite that is composed of the conoid, three ring-like structures, and the two short intra-conoid microtubules. Here we report the characterization of one of the proteins identified in that analysis, TgICMAP1. We show that TgICMAP1 is a novel microtubule binding protein that can directly bind to microtubules in vitro and stabilizes microtubules when ectopically expressed in mammalian cells. Interestingly, in T. gondii, TgICMAP1 preferentially binds to the intra-conoid microtubules, providing us the first molecular tool to investigate the intra-conoid microtubule assembly process during daughter construction.     

Cytoplasmic dynein-mediated assembly of pericentrin and gamma tubulin onto centrosomes

Centrosome assembly is important for mitotic spindle formation and if defective may contribute to genomic instability in cancer. Here we show that in somatic cells centrosome assembly of two proteins involved in microtubule nucleation, pericentrin and gamma tubulin, is inhibited in the absence of microtubules. A more potent inhibitory effect on centrosome assembly of these proteins is observed after specific disruption of the microtubule motor cytoplasmic dynein by microinjection of dynein antibodies or by overexpression of the dynamitin subunit of the dynein binding complex dynactin. Consistent with these observations is the ability of pericentrin to cosediment with taxol-stabilized microtubules in a dynein- and dynactin-dependent manner. Centrosomes in cells with reduced levels of pericentrin and gamma tubulin have a diminished capacity to nucleate microtubules. In living cells expressing a green fluorescent protein-pericentrin fusion protein, green fluorescent protein particles containing endogenous pericentrin and gamma tubulin move along microtubules at speeds of dynein and dock at centrosomes. In Xenopus extracts where gamma tubulin assembly onto centrioles can occur without microtubules, we find that assembly is enhanced in the presence of microtubules and inhibited by dynein antibodies. From these studies we conclude that pericentrin and gamma tubulin are novel dynein cargoes that can be transported to centrosomes on microtubules and whose assembly contributes to microtubule nucleation.     

Interaction of CK1δ with γTuSC ensures proper microtubule assembly and spindle positioning

Casein kinase 1δ (CK1δ) family members associate with microtubule-organizing centers (MTOCs) from yeast to humans, but their mitotic roles and targets have yet to be identified. We show here that budding yeast CK1δ, Hrr25, is a γ-tubulin small complex (γTuSC) binding factor. Moreover, Hrr25''s association with γTuSC depends on its kinase activity and its noncatalytic central domain. Loss of Hrr25 kinase activity resulted in assembly of unusually long cytoplasmic microtubules and defects in spindle positioning, consistent with roles in regulation of γTuSC-mediated microtubule nucleation and the Kar9 spindle-positioning pathway, respectively. Hrr25 directly phosphorylated γTuSC proteins in vivo and in vitro, and this phosphorylation promoted γTuSC integrity and activity. Because CK1δ and γTuSC are highly conserved and present at MTOCs in diverse eukaryotes, similar regulatory mechanisms are expected to apply generally in eukaryotes.     

Tubulin assembly protein: immunochemical and immunofluorescent studies on its function and distribution in microtubules and cultured cells.

Cytoplasmic microtubule assembly from tubulin monomers requires an accessory protein or proteins present is isolated microtubules. These proteins have been designated "tau" factors. One such factor, tubulin assembly protein (TAP), has been purified to homogeneity from calf brain microtubules. A precipitating, monospecific antibody against the protein has been prepared. The antibody has been used to investigate the mechanism of TAP action in microtubule assembly and the distribution of TAP in cellular microtubules. Immunochemical, immunofluorescent and electron microscopic studies indicate that TAP functions stoichiometrically by binding physically to tubulin to form a complex active in microtubule assembly. TAP is an elongation protein which is required throughout the growth of a microtubule and which is actually present along the entire microtubule. Immunofluorescence microscopy has been used to demonstrate that TAP is distributed throughout the cytoplasmic microtubule network of cultured human, hamster and rat cells-both normal and virally transformed. Immunofluorescence of cells in mitosis shows that TAP is present in the mitotic spindle. These results demonstrate the biological importance of tubulin assembly protein and suggest that it or immunologically related "tau" proteins represent ubiquitous cofactors in cytoplasmic microtubule assembly.     

Microtubule nucleation: The waltz between γ-tubulin ring complex and associated proteins

Microtubules are essential cytoskeletal elements assembled from αβ-tubulin dimers. In high eukaryotes, microtubule nucleation, the de novo assembly of a microtubule from its minus end, is initiated by the γ-tubulin ring complex (γ-TuRC). Despite many years of research, the structural and mechanistic principles of the microtubule nucleation machinery remained poorly understood. Only recently, cryoelectron microscopy studies uncovered the molecular organization and potential activation mechanisms of γ-TuRC. In vitro assays further deciphered the spatial and temporal cooperation between γ-TuRC and additional factors, for example, the augmin complex, the phase separation protein TPX2, and the microtubule polymerase XMAP215. These breakthroughs deepen our understanding of microtubule nucleation mechanisms and will link the assembly of individual microtubules to the organization of cellular microtubule networks.     

A kinetoplastid-specific kinesin is required for cytokinesis and for maintenance of cell morphology in Trypanosoma brucei

Kinesins are motor‐based transport proteins that play diverse roles in various cellular processes. The trypanosome genome lacks the homologues of many conserved mitotic kinesins, but encodes a number of trypanosome‐specific kinesins with unknown function. Here, we report the biochemical and functional characterization of TbKIN‐C, a trypanosome‐specific kinesin, which was initially identified through an RNAi screen for cytokinesis genes in T. brucei. TbKIN‐C possesses in vitro ATPase activity and associates with cytoskeletal tubulin microtubules in vivo. It is distributed throughout the cytoskeleton with a focal enrichment at the posterior end of the cell during early cell cycle stages. RNAi of TbKIN‐C resulted in distorted cell shape with an elongated posterior filled with tyrosinated tubulin microtubules. Silencing of TbKIN‐C impaired the segregation of organelles and cytoskeletal structures and led to detachment of the new flagellum and a small portion of the cytoplasm. We also show that RNAi of TbKIN‐C compromised cytokinesis and abolished the trans‐localization of TbCPC1, a subunit of the chromosomal passenger complex, from the central spindle to the initiation site of cytokinesis. Our results suggest an essential role of TbKIN‐C in maintaining cell morphology, likely through regulating microtubule dynamics at the posterior end of the cell.     

Isolation of a subpellicular microtubule protein from Trypanosoma brucei that mediates crosslinking of microtubules

The cell body of Trypanosomatidae is enclosed in densely packed, crosslinked, subpellicular microtubules closely underlying the plasma membrane. We isolated the subpellicular microtubules from bloodstream Trypanosoma brucei parasites by use of a zwitterion detergent. These cold stable structures were solubilized by a high ionic strength salt solution, and the soluble proteins that contained tubulin along with several other proteins were further fractionated by Mono S cation exchange column chromatography. Two distinct peaks were eluted containing one protein each, which had an apparent molecular weight of 52 kDa and 53 kDa. (Mr was determined by SDS-gel electrophoresis). Only the 52 kDa protein showed specific tubulin binding properties, which were demonstrated by exposure of nitrocellulose-bound trypanosome proteins to brain tubulin. When this protein was added to brain tubulin in the presence of taxol and GTP, microtubule bundles were formed with regular crosslinks between the parallel closely packed microtubules. The crosslinks were about 7.2 nm apart (center to center). Under the same conditions, but with the 53 kDA protein or without trypanosome derived proteins, brain tubulin polymerized to single microtubules. It is thus suggested that the unique structural organization of the subpellicular microtubules is dictated by specific parasite proteins and is not an inherent property of the polymerizing tubulin. The in vitro reconstituted microtubule bundles are strikingly similar to the subpellicular microtubule network of the parasite.     

The core of the mammalian centriole contains γ-tubulin

Background: The microtubule network, upon which transport occurs in higher cells, is formed by the polymerization of α and β tubulin. The third major tubulin isoform, γ tubulin, is believed to serve a role in organizing this network by nucleating microtubule growth on microtubule-organizing centers, such as the centrosome. Research in vitro has shown that γ tubulin must be restored to stripped centrioles to regenerate the centrosomal functions of duplication and microtubule nucleation.Results We have re-examined the localization of γ tubulin in isolated and in situ mammalian centrosomes using a novel immunocytochemical technique that preserves antigenicity and morphology while allowing increased accessibility. As expected, α tubulin was localized in cytoplasmic and centriolar barrel microtubules and in the associated pericentriolar material. Foci of γ tubulin were observed at the periphery of the organized pericentriolar material, as reported previously, often near the termini of microtubules. A further and major location of γ tubulin was a structure within the proximal end of the centriolar barrel. The distributions were complementary, in that α tubulin was excluded from the core of the centriole, and γ tubulin was excluded from the microtubule barrel.Conclusion We have shown that γ tubulin is localized both in the pericentriolar material and in the core of the mammalian centriole. This result suggests that γ tubulin has a role in the centriolar duplication process, perhaps as a template for growth of the centriolar microtubules, in addition to its established role in the nucleation of astral microtubules.     

Regulation of Tubulin Organization During Meiosis

Meiotic spindle formation in Spisula solidissima oocytes hasbeen studied in vivo and in vitro. Measurements were made ofpolymerized tubulin content during the first meiotic division.The amount of polymer was high prior to activation of the eggs,fell to a minimum of about 5 min after activation and at 15min (metaphase) returned to approximately its initial value.The polymerized tubulin in the unactivated eggs appears to beorganized into granular spheres about 10–20 microns indiameter attached to the egg cortex. This particle containsfew microtubules but is composed primarily of a granular matrixand fibrous material. The granular matrix may be a polymorphicaggregate of tubulin and could be a storage form of tubulinor an intermediate in microtubule assembly. The polymerization and organization of microtubules has beenstudied in vitro, using crude homogenates of Spisula oocytes.Microtubules can be formed in homogenates of both activatedand unactivated eggs; however, in homogenates of eggs in whichnuclear membrane breakdown has occurred, microtubules form arounda central phase dense particle resulting in a structure whichresembles a spindle aster. The central particle appears to bea microtubule organizing center (MTOC). The MTOC can be pelleledby centrifugation and will induce aster formation when remixedwith the supernatant. Aster formation can be obtained usingsupernatants prepared from either activated or unactivated eggs,while the pellet must be obtained from activated eggs. Thus,tubulin subunits appear to be capable of spindle formation atall stages, while MTOC formation or activation does not occuruntil about the time of nuclear membrane breakdown.