Vascular endothelial cells have impaired capacity to present immunodominant, antigenic peptides: a mechanism of cell type-specific immune escape

Vascular endothelial cells (EC) are an exposed target tissue in the course of CTL-mediated alloimmune diseases such as graft-vs-host disease (GVHD) or solid organ transplant rejection. The outcome of an interaction between CTL and target cells is determined by the amount of Ag presented and the costimulatory signals delivered by the target cells. We compared human EC with leukocytes and epithelial cells as targets for peptide-specific, MHC class I-restricted CTL clones. EC were poor targets for immunodominant CTL. Both endogenously processed antigenic proteins and exogenously added antigenic peptides are presented at 50- to 5000-fold lower levels on EC compared with any other target cell analyzed. This quantitative difference fully explained the poor CTL-mediated killing of EC. There was no evidence that lack of costimulation would contribute significantly to this cell type-specific difference in CTL activation. An HLA-A2-specific CTL clone that killed a broad selection of HLA A2-positive target cells equally well, killed EC less efficiently. Our data suggest that EC present a different Ag repertoire compared with other cell types. By this mechanism, these cells may escape an attack by effector CTL, which have been educated by professional APCs and are specific for immunodominant antigenic peptides.     

Human vascular endothelial cells favor clonal expansion of unusual alloreactive CTL.

We have shown previously that cultured HUVEC or mixtures of endothelial cells (EC) and B lymphoblastoid cells (BLC) induce the differentiation of purified CD8+ PBL into allospecific, class I MHC-restricted CTL that lyse EC, but not BLC autologous to EC. Furthermore, these EC-selective CTL lines secrete little IFN-gamma after target cell contact. In the present study, we have analyzed these polyclonal populations at a single cell level by cloning at limiting dilution and propagating the resulting CTL clones in the absence of EC. Phenotypically stable, alloreactive EC-selective CTL preferentially emerge from cocultures in which EC or EC + BLC are the initial stimulating cell types compared with cocultures stimulated by BLC alone (p = 0.005). Compared with BLC-stimulated CTL, EC-stimulated CTL clones often fail to secrete IFN-gamma after target cell contact (p = 0.0006) and constitutively express CD40 ligand (CD40L) at rest (p = 0.0006). The absence of IFN-gamma secretion does not result from a switch to IL-4 secretion. The expression of CD40L inversely correlates with the secretion of IFN-gamma after target cell contact (p = 0.0001), but correlations of CD40L expression and failure to secrete IFN-gamma with EC-selective killing did not reach statistical significance. We conclude that in a microenvironment in which allogeneic EC are in close contact with infiltrating CD8+ T cells, such as within a graft arterial intima, CTL subsets may emerge that display EC selectivity or express CD40L and secrete little IFN-gamma after Ag contact.     

IL-4 diminishes perforin-mediated and increases Fas ligand-mediated cytotoxicity In vivo

CTL have evolved two major mechanisms for target cell killing: one mediated by perforin/granzyme secretion and the other by Fas/Fas ligand (L) interaction. Although cytokines are integral to the development of naive CTL into cytolytic effectors, the role of cytokines on mechanisms of CTL killing is just emerging. In this study, we evaluate the effects of IL-4 in Fas(CD95)/FasL(CD95L)-mediated killing of Fas-overexpressing target cells. Recombinant vaccinia viruses (vv) were constructed to express respiratory syncytial virus M2 Ag alone (vvM2) or coexpress M2 and IL-4 (vvM2/IL-4). MHC-matched Fas-overexpressing target cells (L1210Fas+) were used to measure both perforin- and FasL-mediated killing pathways. In contrast to Fas-deficient (L1210Fas-) target cells, effectors from vvM2/IL-4-immunized mice were able to lyse L1210Fas+ target cells with similar magnitude as vvM2-infected mice. Addition of EGTA/Mg2+ revealed that effectors from vvM2/IL-4-infected mice primarily lyse targets by a Ca2+-independent Fas/FasL pathway. Analysis of FasL expression by flow cytometry showed that IL-4 increased cell surface FasL expression on CD4+ and CD8+ splenocytes, with peak expression on day 4 after infection. These data demonstrate that IL-4 increases FasL expression on T cells, resulting in a shift of the mechanism of CTL killing from a dominant perforin-mediated cytolytic pathway to a dominant FasL-mediated cytolytic pathway.     

BCR engagement induces Fas resistance in primary B cells in the absence of functional Bruton's tyrosine kinase

B cell susceptibility to Fas-mediated apoptosis is regulated in a receptor-specific fashion. CD40 engagement produces marked sensitivity to Fas killing, whereas surface Ig (sIg) engagement blocks Fas signaling for cell death in otherwise sensitive, CD40-stimulated B cell targets, and thus, induces a state of Fas resistance. The signaling mediator, Bruton's tyrosine kinase (Btk), is required for certain sIg-triggered responses, and Btk is reported to directly bind Fas and block Fas-mediated apoptosis. For these reasons, the role of Btk as a mediator of sIg-induced Fas resistance was examined. Dysfunction of Btk through mutation, and absence of Btk through deletion did not interfere with induction of Fas resistance by anti-Ig. This may be due, at least in part, to induction of Btk-dependent Bcl-2 family members by anti-Ig after CD40 ligand treatment. However, the susceptibility to Fas-mediated apoptosis of B cell targets stimulated by CD40 ligand alone was increased in the absence of Btk. These results indicate that Fas resistance produced by sIg triggering does not require Btk, but suggests that in certain situations Btk modulates B cell susceptibility to Fas killing.     

Immunosensitization of melanoma tumor cells to non-MHC Fas-mediated killing by MART-1-specific CTL cultures

The discovery of human melanoma rejection Ags has allowed the rational design of immunotherapeutic strategies. One such Ag, MART-1, is expressed on >90% of human melanomas, and CTL generated against MART-1(27-35) kill most HLA A2.1(+) melanoma cells. However, variant tumor cells, which do not express MART-1, down-regulate MHC, or become resistant to apoptosis, will escape killing. Cytotoxic lymphocytes kill by two main mechanisms, the perforin/granzyme degranulation pathway and the TNF/Fas/TNF-related apoptosis-inducing ligand superfamily of apoptosis-inducing ligands. In this study, we examined whether cis-diaminedichloroplatinum (II) cisplatin (CDDP) sensitizes MART-1/HLA A2.1(+) melanoma and melanoma variant tumor cells to non-MHC-restricted, Fas ligand (FasL)-mediated killing by CTL. MART-1(27-35)-specific bulk CTL cultures were generated by pulsing normal PBL with MART-1(27-35) peptide. These CTL cultures specifically kill M202 melanoma cells (MART-1(+), HLA A2.1(+), FasR(-)), and MART-1(27-35) peptide-pulsed T2 cells (FasR(+)), but not M207 melanoma cells (MART-1(+), HLA A2.1(-), FasR(-)), FLU(58-66) peptide-pulsed T2 cells, or DU145 and PC-3 prostate cells (MART-1(-), HLA A2.1(-), FasR(+)). CDDP (0.1-10 microg/ml) sensitized non-MART-1(27-35) peptide-pulsed T2 to the CD8(+) subset of bulk MART-1-specific CTL, and killing was abolished by neutralizing anti-Fas Ab. Furthermore, CDDP up-regulated FasR expression and FasL-mediated killing of M202, and sensitized PC-3 and DU145 to killing by bulk MART-1-specific CTL cultures. These findings demonstrate that drug-mediated sensitization can potentiate FasL-mediated killing by MHC-restricted CTL cell lines, independent of MHC and MART-1 expression on tumor cells. This represents a novel approach for potentially controlling tumor cell variants found in primary heterogeneous melanoma tumor cell populations that would normally escape killing by MART-1-specific immunotherapy.     

Fas-ligand-mediated lysis of erbB-2-expressing tumour cells by redirected cytotoxic T lymphocytes

A chimeric receptor, consisting of the single-chain variable (scFv) domains of an anti-erbB-2 mAb linked via a CD8 membrane-proximal hinge to the Fc receptor γ chain, was expressed in the mouse cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) hybridoma cell line, MD45. This cell line was grafted with the additional specificity to recognise and bind erbB-2-expressing breast carcinoma target cells T47D, MCF-7 and BT-20 in a non-MHC-restricted manner. Tumour cell lysis was antigen-specific since erbB-2-negative tumours were insensitive to lysis by MD45-scFv-anti-erbB-2-γ clones, and lysis of erbB-2⁺ tumour targets was inhibited in the presence of an anti-erbB-2 mAb. Furthermore, target cell death correlated with the level of chimeric receptor expression on the effector MD45 subclones. Redirected MD45 CTL utilised Fas ligand to induce target cell death since soluble Fas-Fc fusion protein completely inhibited cytolysis. The sensitivity of tumour target cells to Fas ligand was further enhanced by treating them with interferon-γ, a regulator of Fas and downstream signalling components of the Fas pathway. Overall, this study has demonstrated the requirement for successful activation of Fas ligand function in conjunction with cytokine treatment for effective lysis of breast carcinoma target cells mediated by redirected CTL. Received: 23 July 1998 / Accepted: 5 October 1998     

Persistent infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus enhances expression of MHC class I glycoprotein on cultured mouse brain endothelial cells

Brain endothelial cells (EC) represent a major component of the blood/brain barrier, which activated CTL cross to enter the central nervous system. Several viruses also penetrate the central nervous system through the blood stream via the brain EC. The studies reported here focus on understanding the principles and consequences of interactions among viruses, lymphocytes, and EC in the brain. As shown persistent but not acute infection by lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus enhances the expression of MHC class I glycoproteins on the brain EC of mice. This increase in MHC expression during viral infection does not seem to result from the release of cytokines. However, replicative virus is required, because UV inactivated virus fails to enhance MHC expression. Viral determinants appear on EC surfaces after infection and serve as targets for CTL directed lysis. In contrast, neurons (OBL 21 neuronal cell line), which express negligible amounts of MHC class I glycoproteins, show no gain in MHC markers during persistent viral infection and are not targets for virus-specific CTL killing.     

Irradiation of tumor cells up-regulates Fas and enhances CTL lytic activity and CTL adoptive immunotherapy

CD8(+) CTL play important roles against malignancy in both active and passive immunotherapy. Nonetheless, the success of antitumor CTL responses may be improved by additional therapeutic modalities. Radiotherapy, which has a long-standing use in treating neoplastic disease, has been found to induce unique biologic alterations in cancer cells affecting Fas gene expression, which, consequently, may influence the overall lytic efficiency of CTL. Here, in a mouse adenocarcinoma cell model, we examined whether exposure of these tumor cells to sublethal doses of irradiation 1) enhances Fas expression, leading to more efficient CTL killing via Fas-dependent mechanisms in vitro; and 2) improves antitumor activity in vivo by adoptive transfer of these Ag-specific CTL. Treatment of carcinoembryonic Ag-expressing MC38 adenocarcinoma cells with irradiation (20 Gy) in vitro enhanced Fas expression at molecular, phenotypic, and functional levels. Furthermore, irradiation sensitized these targets to Ag-specific CTL killing via the Fas/Fas ligand pathway. We examined the effect of localized irradiation of s.c. growing tumors on the efficiency of CTL adoptive immunotherapy. Irradiation caused up-regulation of Fas by these tumor cells in situ, based on immunohistochemistry. Moreover, localized irradiation of the tumor significantly potentiated tumor rejection by these carcinoembryonic Ag-specific CTL. Overall, these results showed for the first time that 1) regulation of the Fas pathway in tumor cells by irradiation plays an important role in their sensitization to Ag-specific CTL; and 2) a combination regimen of tumor-targeted irradiation and CTL promotes more effective antitumor responses in vivo, which may have implications for the combination of immunotherapy and radiation therapy.     

Virally infected hepatocytes are resistant to perforin-dependent CTL effector mechanisms

Cell-mediated cytotoxicity plays an important role in the clearance of noncytopathic viruses from infected tissues. Perforin-dependent cytotoxic mechanisms have been noted to play an important role in the clearance of infections from multiple extrahepatic organs. In contrast, mice with defects in the Fas/Fas ligand (FasL)-mediated cytotoxicity pathway exhibit delayed clearance of adenovirus from the liver without apparent delay in the clearance of viral infections from extrahepatic organs. The present studies examined the role of cytotoxic effector mechanisms in intrahepatic immune responses to a replication-defective, recombinant beta-galactosidase-encoding adenovirus (AdCMV-lacZ). Delayed clearance of AdCMV-lacZ from the livers of FasL-defective B6.gld mice, but not perforin-deficient B6.pfp(-/-) mice, was noted despite no significant differences in initial hepatic CD8(+) T cell IFN-gamma or TNF responses or in activation of intrahepatic cytotoxic lymphocytes cells capable of killing AdCMV-lacZ-infected fibroblast targets. In contrast, AdCMV-lacZ-infected hepatocyte targets were far more sensitive to killing by intrahepatic cytotoxic lymphocytes from B6.pfp(-/-) than from B6.gld mice, and residual levels of virus-specific killing of hepatocyte targets by FasL-defective B6.gld CTL were blocked by TNF inhibition. These results suggest that inherent resistance of hepatocytes to cytotoxicity mediated by perforin-dependent mechanisms leaves Fas/FasL-dependent, cell-mediated cytotoxicity as the major pathway for CTL-mediated killing of virally infected hepatocytes and accounts for the more prominent role of perforin-independent anti-viral mechanisms in immune responses in the liver.     

Target specificity and cell surface structures involved in the human cytolytic T lymphocyte response to endothelial cells

Two long-term cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) lines derived from the peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of a single donor were analyzed for target specificity and involvement of cell surface molecules in CTL-target interactions. One line, AH2, was generated after stimulation with B lymphoblastoid cells. Cytolysis by these cells was restricted to targets expressing the appropriate HLA-A2 specificity and was blocked by mAb recognizing CD2, CD3, CD8, LFA-1, and LFA-3. The second line, AE1, was generated after stimulation with cultured endothelial cells derived from human newborn preputial microvessels. These CTL lysed all human target cells tested, except autologous cells and the Class I negative cell line Daudi. In addition, mAb specific for CD2, CD3, and CD8 did not affect cytolysis. Anti-LFA-1 and -LFA-3 mAb blocked cytolysis of B lymphoblastoid targets but not endothelial targets. These results indicate that some CTL utilize as yet uncharacterized cell surface structures for CTL-target interactions.     

Fas-independent cytotoxicity mediated by human CD4+ CTL directed against herpes simplex virus-infected cells

The present study was undertaken to clarify the mechanisms of cytotoxicity mediated by virus-specific human CD4+ CTLs using the lymphocytes of family members with a Fas gene mutation. CD4+ CTL bulk lines and clones directed against HSV-infected cells were established from lymphocytes of a patient with a homozygous Fas gene mutation and of the patient's mother. HSV-specific CD4+ CTLs generated from lymphocytes of the patient and her mother exerted cytotoxicity against HSV-infected cells from the patient (Fas-/-) and from her mother (Fas+/-) to almost the same degree in an HLA class II-restricted manner. mRNAs for the major mediators of CTL cytotoxicity, Fas ligand, perforin, and granzyme B, were detected in these CD4+ CTLs using the RT-PCR and flow cytometry. The cytotoxicity of the HSV-specific CD4+ CTLs appeared to be Ca2+-dependent and was almost completely inhibited by concanamycin A, a potent inhibitor of the perforin-based cytotoxic pathway. Although the Fas/Fas ligand system has been reported to be the most important mechanism for CD4+ CTL-mediated cytotoxicity in the murine system, the present findings strongly suggest that granule exocytosis, not the Fas/Fas ligand system, is the main pathway for the cytotoxicity mediated by HSV-specific human CD4+ CTLs.     

Lack of galactose-alpha-1,3-galactose expression on porcine endothelial cells prevents complement-induced lysis but not direct xenogeneic NK cytotoxicity

The galactose-alpha-1,3-galactose (alphaGal) carbohydrate epitope is expressed on porcine, but not human cells, and therefore represents a major target for preformed human anti-pig natural Abs (NAb). Based on results from pig-to-primate animal models, NAb binding to porcine endothelial cells will likely induce complement activation, lysis, and hyperacute rejection in pig-to-human xenotransplantation. Human NK cells may also contribute to innate immune responses against xenografts, either by direct recognition of activating molecules on target cells or by FcgammaRIII-mediated xenogeneic Ab-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC). The present study addressed the question as to whether the lack of alphaGal protects porcine endothelial cells from NAb/complement-induced lysis, direct xenogeneic NK lysis, NAb-dependent ADCC, and adhesion of human NK cells under shear stress. Homologous recombination, panning, and limiting dilution cloning were used to generate an alphaGal-negative porcine endothelial cell line, PED2*3.51. NAb/complement-induced xenogeneic lysis of PED2*3.51 was reduced by an average of 86% compared with the alphaGal-positive phenotype. PED2*3.51 resisted NK cell-mediated ADCC with a reduction of lysis ranging from 30 to 70%. However, direct xenogeneic lysis of PED2*3.51, mediated either by freshly isolated or IL-2-activated human NK cells or the NK cell line NK92, was not reduced. Furthermore, adhesion of IL-2-activated human NK cells did not rely on alphaGal expression. In conclusion, removal of alphaGal leads to a clear reduction in complement-induced lysis and ADCC, but does not resolve adhesion of NK cells and direct anti-porcine NK cytotoxicity, indicating that alphaGal is not a dominant target for direct human NK cytotoxicity against porcine cells.     

Matrix attachment regulates Fas-induced apoptosis in endothelial cells: a role for c-flip and implications for anoikis

Survival of endothelial cells is critical for cellular processes such as angiogenesis. Cell attachment to extracellular matrix inhibits apoptosis in endothelial cells both in vitro and in vivo, but the molecular mechanisms underlying matrix-induced survival signals or detachment-induced apoptotic signals are unknown. We demonstrate here that matrix attachment is an efficient regulator of Fas-mediated apoptosis in endothelial cells. Thus, matrix attachment protects cells from Fas-induced apoptosis, whereas matrix detachment results in susceptibility to Fas-mediated cell death. Matrix attachment modulates Fas-mediated apoptosis at two different levels: by regulating the expression level of Fas, and by regulating the expression level of c-Flip, an endogenous antagonist of caspase-8. The extracellular signal-regulated kinase (Erk) cascade functions as a survival pathway in adherent cells by regulating c-Flip expression. We further show that detachment-induced cell death, or anoikis, itself results from activation of the Fas pathway by its ligand, Fas-L. Fas-L/Fas interaction, Fas-FADD complex formation, and caspase-8 activation precede the bulk of anoikis in endothelial cells, and inhibition of any of these events blocks anoikis. These studies identify matrix attachment as a survival factor against death receptor-mediated apoptosis and provide a molecular mechanism for anoikis and previously observed Fas resistance in endothelial cells.     

Two preferentially expressed proteins protect vascular endothelial cells from an attack by peptide-specific CTL

Vascular endothelial cells (EC) are an exposed tissue with intimate contact with circulating Ag-specific CTL. Experimental in vitro and clinical data suggested that endothelial cells present a different repertoire of MHC class I-restricted peptides compared with syngeneic leukocytes or epithelial cells. This endothelial-specific peptide repertoire might protect EC from CTL-mediated cell death. The HLA-A*02-restricted peptide profile of human EC and syngeneic B lymphoblastoid cells was biochemically analyzed and compared. For EC selective peptides, source protein expression, peptide binding affinity, and peptide-HLA-A*02 turnover were measured. The significance of abundant peptide presentation for target cell recognition by immunodominant CTL was tested by small interfering RNA treatment of EC to knock down the source proteins. High amounts of two peptides, PTRF(56-64) and CD59(106-114), were consistently detected in EC. This predominance of two endothelial peptides was explained by cell type-specific source protein expression that compensated for poor HLA-A*02 binding affinity and short half-live of peptide/HLA-A*02 complexes. Knocking down the source proteins containing the abundant endothelial peptide motifs led to a nearly 100-fold increase of surface expression of SMCY(311-319), an immunodominant minor histocompatibility Ag, as detected by cytotoxicity assays using SMCY(311-319)-specific CTL. We conclude that EC express and present preferentially two distinct HLA-A*02-restricted peptides at extraordinary high levels. These abundant self-peptides may protect EC from CTL-mediated lysis by competing for HLA-A*02 binding sites with immunodominant scarcely expressed antigenic peptides.     

Porcine UL16-binding protein 1 expressed on the surface of endothelial cells triggers human NK cytotoxicity through NKG2D

Cellular rejection mechanisms, including NK cells, remain a hurdle for successful pig-to-human xenotransplantation. Human anti-pig NK cytotoxicity depends on the activating receptor NKG2D. Porcine UL16-binding protein 1 (pULBP1) and porcine MHC class I chain-related protein 2 (pMIC2) are homologues of the human NKG2D ligands ULBP 1-4 and MICA and B, respectively. Although transcribed in porcine endothelial cells (pEC), it is not known whether pULBP1 and pMIC2 act as functional ligands for human NKG2D. In this study, surface protein expression of pULBP1 was demonstrated by flow cytometry using a novel pULBP1-specific polyclonal Ab and by cellular ELISA using NKG2D-Fc fusion protein. Reciprocally, pULBP1-Fc bound to primary human NK cells, whereas pMIC2-Fc did not. Transient and stable down-regulation of pULBP1 mRNA in pEC using short-interfering RNA oligonucleotide duplexes and short hairpin RNA, respectively, resulted in a partial inhibition of xenogeneic NK cytotoxicity through NKG2D in (51)Cr release assays. In contrast, down-regulation of pMIC2 mRNA did not inhibit NK cytotoxicity. Human NK cytotoxicity against pEC mediated by freshly isolated or IL-2-activated NK cells through NKG2D was completely blocked using anti-pULBP1 polyclonal Ab. In conclusion, this study suggests that pULBP1 is the predominant, if not only, functional porcine ligand for human NKG2D. Thus, the elimination of pULBP1 on porcine tissues represents an attractive target to protect porcine xenografts from human NK cytotoxicity.     

Differential sensitivity of endothelial cells of various species to apoptosis induced by gene transfer of Fas ligand: role of FLIP levels

BACKGROUND: Fas ligand expression by cells of the vessel wall has been proposed to play a role in normal and pathologic conditions. Genetic engineering of vascularized organs for endothelial cell (EC) expression of FasL could protect the endothelium and underlying tissues from infiltrating Fas+ leukocytes. Nevertheless, the endogenous expression of FasL by ECs of different species and the potential deleterious effects of enforced FasL expression by ECs are largely unknown. In human ECs, levels of FLICE/caspase 8-inhibitory protein (FLIP) have been shown to control apoptosis mediated by Fas. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Cell surface expression of FasL in rat, mouse, human, and pig ECs was obtained using recombinant adenoviruses or transient plasmid transfection assays. FasL expression was evaluated by FACS analysis and cytotoxicity assays. Apoptosis was evaluated using annexin V, TUNEL, and cytotoxicity assays. FLIP levels were evaluated by Western blot analysis and overexpression was obtained by transient transfection. RESULTS: Analysis of ECs from different species showed that FasL was predominantly present in the cytoplasm, and depending on the species, little or no cell surface expression was detected. Enforced cell surface expression of FasL on rat or mouse ECs, either in culture or within the vessel wall resulted in massive apoptosis. In contrast, porcine or human ECs were completely resistant to apoptosis mediated by Fas-FasL interaction. Markedly reduced FLIP levels were observed in rat and mouse ECs compared to human and porcine ECs. Overexpression of FLIP in rat ECs conferred protection against cell surface expression of FasL. CONCLUSIONS: The consequences of FasL overexpression depend on the subcellular compartment and species in which FasL enforced expression is targeted and this is at least partially related to FLIP levels.