Multiple pathways used for the targeting of thylakoid proteins in chloroplasts

The assembly of the chloroplast thylakoid membrane requires the import of numerous proteins from the cytosol and their targeting into or across the thylakoid membrane. It is now clear that multiple pathways are involved in the thylakoid-targeting stages, depending on the type of protein substrate. Two very different pathways are used by thylakoid lumen proteins; one is the Sec pathway which has been well-characterised in bacteria, and which involves the threading of the substrate through a narrow channel. In contrast, the more recently characterised twin-arginine translocation (Tat) system is able to translocate fully folded proteins across this membrane. Recent advances on bacterial Tat systems shed further light on the structure and function of this system. Membrane proteins, on the other hand, use two further pathways. One is the signal recognition particle-dependent pathway, involving a complex interplay between many different factors, whereas other proteins insert without the assistance of any known apparatus. This article reviews advances in the study of these pathways and considers the rationale behind the surprising complexity.     

Mechanisms of protein import into thylakoids of chloroplasts

The thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts contains the major photosynthetic complexes, which consist of several either nuclear or chloroplast encoded subunits. The biogenesis of these thylakoid membrane complexes requires coordinated transport and subsequent assembly of the subunits into functional complexes. Nuclear-encoded thylakoid proteins are first imported into the chloroplast and then directed to the thylakoid using different sorting mechanisms. The cpSec pathway and the cpTat pathway are mainly involved in the transport of lumenal proteins, whereas the spontaneous pathway and the cpSRP pathway are used for the insertion of integral membrane proteins into the thylakoid membrane. While cpSec-, cpTat- and cpSRP-mediated targeting can be classified as 'assisted' mechanisms involving numerous components, 'unassisted' spontaneous insertion does not require additional targeting factors. However, even the assisted pathways differ fundamentally with respect to stromal targeting factors, the composition of the translocase and energy requirements.     

Multiple pathways for the targeting of thylakoid proteins in chloroplasts

The assembly of the photosynthetic apparatus requires the import of numerous cytosolically synthesised proteins and their correct targeting into or across the thylakoid membrane. Biochemical and genetic studies have revealed the operation of several targeting pathways for these proteins, some of which are used for thylakoid lumen proteins whereas others are utilised by membrane proteins. Some pathways can be traced back to the prokarytoic ancestors of chloroplasts but at least one pathway appears to have arisen in response to the transfer of genes from the organelle to the nucleus. In this article we review recent findings in this field that point to the operation of a mechanistically unique protein translocase in both plastids and bacteria, and we discuss emerging data that reconcile the remarkable variety of targeting pathways with the natures of the substrate precursor proteins.     

Novel mechanisms for the targeting of proteins into and across chloroplast membranes

The assembly of the photosynthetic apparatus requires the translocation of numerous proteins from the cytosol, initially into the stroma and thereafter into or across the thylakoid membrane. Recent studies have shown that proteins are transported into this membrane by a variety of mechanisms, some of which are derived from a cyanobacterial-type ancestor, whereas others have evolved in response to the more complex transport pathway used by cytosolically synthesized chloroplast proteins. It is now apparent that some of the targeting pathways are used exclusively by hydrophobic thylakoid membrane proteins; here we review recent progress in our understanding of the biogenesis of this important class of protein.     

Multiple pathways for protein transport into or across the thylakoid membrane.

Many thylakoid proteins are cytosolically synthesized and have to cross the two chloroplast envelope membranes as well as the thylakoid membrane en route to their functional locations. In order to investigate the localization pathways of these proteins, we over-expressed precursor proteins in Escherichia coli and used them in competition studies. Competition was conducted for import into the chloroplast and for transport into or across isolated thylakoids. We also developed a novel in organello method whereby competition for thylakoid transport occurred within intact chloroplasts. Import of all precursors into chloroplasts was similarly inhibited by saturating concentrations of the precursor to the OE23 protein. In contrast, competition for thylakoid transport revealed three distinct precursor specificity groups. Lumen-resident proteins OE23 and OE17 constitute one group, lumenal proteins plastocyanin and OE33 a second, and the membrane protein LHCP a third. The specificity determined by competition correlates with previously determined protein-specific energy requirements for thylakoid transport. Taken together, these results suggest that thylakoid precursor proteins are imported into chloroplasts on a common import apparatus, whereupon they enter one of several precursor-specific thylakoid transport pathways.     

Multiple fates of non‐mature lumenal proteins in thylakoids

Most proteins found in the thylakoid lumen are synthesized in the cytosol with an N–terminal extension consisting of transient signals for chloroplast import and thylakoid transfer in tandem. The thylakoid‐transfer signal is required for protein sorting from the stroma to thylakoids, mainly via the cpSEC or cpTAT pathway, and is removed by the thylakoidal processing peptidase in the lumen. An Arabidopsis mutant lacking one of the thylakoidal processing peptidase homologs, Plsp1, contains plastids with anomalous thylakoids and is seedling‐lethal. Furthermore, the mutant plastids accumulate two cpSEC substrates (PsbO and PetE) and one cpTAT substrate (PsbP) as intermediate forms. These properties of plsp1‐null plastids suggest that complete maturation of lumenal proteins is a critical step for proper thylakoid assembly. Here we tested the effects of inhibition of thylakoid‐transfer signal removal on protein targeting and accumulation by examining the localization of non‐mature lumenal proteins in the Arabidopsis plsp1‐null mutant and performing a protein import assay using pea chloroplasts. In plsp1‐null plastids, the two cpSEC substrates were shown to be tightly associated with the membrane, while non‐mature PsbP was found in the stroma. The import assay revealed that inhibition of thylakoid‐transfer signal removal did not disrupt cpSEC‐ and cpTAT‐dependent translocation, but prevented release of proteins from the membrane. Interestingly, non‐mature PetE2 was quickly degraded under light, and unprocessed PsbO1 and PsbP1 were found in a 440‐kDa complex and as a monomer, respectively. These results indicate that the cpTAT pathway may be disrupted in the plsp1‐null mutant, and that there are multiple mechanisms to control unprocessed lumenal proteins in thylakoids.     

Proton gradient-driven import of the 16 kDa oxygen-evolving complex protein as the full precursor protein by isolated thylakoids

The biogenesis of the lumenal 16 kDa protein of the photosynthetic oxygen-evolving complex was analysed using an assay for the import of proteins by isolated thylakoids. The precursor protein is imported with high efficiency in the light in both the presence and absence of stromal extract. Import is almost completely blocked in the dark or if the uncoupler nigericin is present in the light. The data indicate that transport across the thylakoid membrane is driven by a proton motive force in which the proton gradient is the dominant component, and that the full precursor protein can be transported across the thylakoid membrane without prior cleavage by the stromal processing peptidase.     

Targeting of proteins to the thylakoids by bipartite presequences: CFoII is imported by a novel, third pathway.

The CFoII subunit of the ATP synthase is an integral component of the thylakoid membrane which is synthesized in the cytosol with a bipartite, lumen-targeting presequence similar in structural terms to those of imported lumenal proteins such as plastocyanin. This presequence is shown to possess a terminal cleavage site for the thylakoidal processing peptidase, but no intermediate site for the stromal processing peptidase. The integration of CFoII into the thylakoid membrane of Pisum sativum has been analysed using in vitro assays for the import of proteins into intact chloroplasts or isolated thylakoids. Efficient integration into thylakoids is observed in the light and dark, and the integration process does not require the presence of either stromal extracts or nucleoside triphosphates. The uncoupler nigericin inhibits integration only very slightly, indicating that the thylakoidal delta pH does not play a significant role in the integration mechanism. In each of these respects, the requirements for CFoII integration differ notably from those determined for integration of the light-harvesting chlorophyll-binding protein of photosystem II. The integration mechanism also differs significantly from the two mechanisms involved in the translocation of lumenal proteins across the thylakoid membrane, since one of these processes requires the presence of stromal protein factors and ATP, and the other mechanism is dependent on the thylakoidal delta pH. This conclusion is reinforced by the finding that saturation of the translocation system for the precursor to the lumenal 23 kDa oxygen-evolving complex protein does not affect integration of CFoII into thylakoids.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Different lumen-targeting pathways for nuclear-encoded versus cyanobacterial/plastid-encoded Hcf136 proteins

Lumenal proteins are transported across the thylakoid membrane by two very different pathways: Sec-dependent or twin-arginine translocase (Tat)-dependent, where the substrate protein can be transported in a folded state. We present the first evidence that a given protein can be targeted by different pathways in different organisms. Arabidopsis Hcf136 is targeted exclusively by the Tat pathway in pea chloroplasts and no Sec-dependent transport is evident even when the twin-arginine is replaced by twin-lysine. However, twin-arginine motifs are absent from the presequences of Hcf136 proteins encoded by plastid or cyanobacterial genomes, strongly implying translocation by another pathway (presumably Sec). We suggest that the Hcf136 protein was transferred to the Tat pathway when the gene became incorporated into the nuclear genome, possibly due to the tighter folding associated with the more involved, post-translational targeting pathway.     

The presequence of a chimeric construct dictates which of two mechanisms are utilized for translocation across the thylakoid membrane: evidence for the existence of two distinct translocation systems.

The translocation of plastocyanin across the thylakoid membrane in Pisum sativum has been studied in reconstitution assays and using chimeric constructs. The reconstitution assays demonstrate that plastocyanin translocation is absolutely dependent on the presence of a stromal factor(s) and nucleotide triphosphates (NTPs), whereas neither element is required for the translocation of the 23 or 16 kDa proteins of the oxygen-evolving complex. Previous studies had revealed that the transthylakoidal delta pH is essential for translocation of the 23 and 16 kDa proteins but unnecessary for plastocyanin translocation. The basis for these mechanistic differences has been tested by analysing the translocation of a chimeric construct consisting of the presequence of the 23 kDa protein linked to the mature plastocyanin sequence. This construct is efficiently imported into thylakoids in the absence of stromal extracts or NTPs and translocation across the thylakoid membrane within intact chloroplasts is totally inhibited by the uncoupler nigericin: the translocation requirements are thus identical to those of the pre-23 kDa protein and diametrically opposite to those of pre-plastocyanin. Transport across the thylakoid membrane of a second fusion protein, consisting of the presequence of the 16 kDa protein linked to mature plastocyanin, is also dependent on a delta pH. The data suggest that two distinct systems are involved in the translocation of proteins across the thylakoid membrane, with each system recognizing specific signals within the presequences of a subset of lumenal protein precursors.     

Full-length plastocyanin precursor is translocated across isolated thylakoid membranes

In higher plants, the chloroplastic protein plastocyanin is synthesized as a transit peptide-containing precursor by cytosolic ribosomes and posttranslationally transported to the thylakoid lumen. En route to the lumen, a plastocyanin precursor is first imported into chloroplasts and then further directed across the thylakoid membrane by a second distinct transport event. A partially processed form of plastocyanin is observed in the stroma during import experiments using intact chloroplasts and has been proposed to be the translocation substrate for the second step (Smeekens, S., Bauerle, C., Hageman, J., Keegstra, K., and Weisbeek, P. (1986) Cell 46, 365-375). To further characterize this second step, we have reconstituted thylakoid transport in a system containing in vitro-synthesized precursor proteins and isolated thylakoid membranes. This system was specific for lumenal proteins since stromal proteins lacking the appropriate targeting information did not accumulate in the thylakoid lumen. Plastocyanin precursor was taken up by isolated thylakoids, proteolytically processed to mature size, and converted to holo form. Translocation was temperature-dependent and was stimulated by millimolar levels of ATP but did not strictly require the addition of stromal factors. We have examined the substrate requirements of thylakoid translocation by testing the ability of different processed forms of plastocyanin to transport in the in vitro system. Interestingly, only the full-length plastocyanin precursor, not the partially processed intermediate form, was competent for transport in this in vitro system.     

Phylogenetic transfer of organelle genes to the nucleus can lead to new mechanisms of protein integration into membranes

Subunits CFo-I and CFo-II of ATP synthase in chloroplast thylakoid membranes are two structurally and functionally closely related proteins of bitopic membrane topology which evolved from a common ancestral gene. In higher plants, CFo-I still originates in plastid chromosomes (gene: atpF), while the gene for CFo-II (atpG) was phylogenetically transferred to the nucleus. This gene transfer was accompanied by the reorganization of the topogenic signals and the mechanism of membrane insertion. CFo-I is capable of integrating correctly as the mature protein into the thylakoid membrane, whereas membrane insertion of CFo-II strictly depends on a hydrophobic targeting signal in the transit peptide. This requirement is caused by three negatively charged residues at the N-terminus of mature CFo-II which are lacking from CFo-I and which have apparently been added to the protein only after gene transfer has occurred. Accordingly, the CFo-II transit peptide is structurally and functionally equivalent to typical bipartite transit peptides, capable of also translocating hydrophilic lumenal proteins across the thylakoid membrane. In this case, transport takes place by the Sec-dependent pathway, despite the fact that membrane integration of CFo-II is a Sec-independent, and presumably spontaneous, process.     

Chloroplast precursor proteins compete to form early import intermediates in isolated pea chloroplasts

In order to ascertain whether there is one site for the import of precursor proteins into chloroplasts or whether different precursor proteins are imported via different import machineries, chloroplasts were incubated with large quantities of the precursor of the 33 kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex (pOE33) or the precursor of the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b-binding protein (pLHCP) and tested for their ability to import a wide range of other chloroplast precursor proteins. Both pOE33 and pLHCP competed for import into chloroplasts with precursors of the stromally-targeted small subunit of Rubisco (pSSu), ferredoxin NADP(+) reductase (pFNR) and porphobilinogen deaminase; the thylakoid membrane proteins LHCP and the Rieske iron-sulphur protein (pRieske protein); ferrochelatase and the gamma subunit of the ATP synthase (which are both associated with the thylakoid membrane); the thylakoid lumenal protein plastocyanin and the phosphate translocator, an integral membrane protein of the inner envelope. The concentrations of pOE33 or pLHCP required to cause half-maximal inhibition of import ranged between 0.2 and 4.9 microM. These results indicate that all of these proteins are imported into the chloroplast by a common import machinery. Incubation of chloroplasts with pOE33 inhibited the formation of early import intermediates of pSSu, pFNR and pRieske protein.     

Two nuclear mutations disrupt distinct pathways for targeting proteins to the chloroplast thylakoid.

Results of in vitro experiments have suggested the existence of at least three pathways by which nuclear-encoded proteins are targeted to the chloroplast thylakoid membrane. However, few components of the targeting machinery have been identified and the relationship between the three pathways is not clear. To investigate mechanisms underlying thylakoid protein targeting, we identified nuclear mutations in maize that cause targeting defects. We found two mutations, tha1 and hcf106, that disrupt the localization of different sets of proteins to the thylakoid lumen. The tha1 mutation interferes with the targeting of one chloroplast-encoded protein, cytochrome f, and three nuclear-encoded proteins, plastocyanin, the psaF gene product and the 33 kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex. The hcf106 mutation interferes with the targeting of the 16 and 23 kDa subunits of the oxygen-evolving complex. The tha1 and hcf106 phenotypes provide the first in vivo evidence supporting the existence of two distinct thylakoid-targeting pathways. Their phenotypes also provide evidence that one chloroplast-encoded protein, cytochrome f, engages the 'tha1' pathway, indicating that nuclear- and chloroplast-encoded proteins can be targeted via common machinery.     

One signal is enough: Stepwise transport of two distinct passenger proteins by the Tat pathway across the thylakoid membrane

The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway, one of four protein transport pathways operating at the thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts, shows remarkable substrate flexibility. Here, we have analyzed the thylakoid transport of chimeric tandem substrates that are composed of two different passenger proteins fused to a single Tat transport signal. The chimera 23/23-EGFP in which the reporter protein EGFP is connected to the C-terminus of the OEC23 precursor shows that a single Tat transport signal is sufficient to mediate transport of two distinct passenger proteins in a row. Replacing the transit peptide of OEC23 in 23/23-EGFP by its homolog from OEC16 yields the chimera 16/23-EGFP, which can likewise be fully translocated by the Tat pathway across the thylakoid membrane. However, transport of 16/23-EGFP is retarded at specific steps in the transport process leading to the temporary and consecutive accumulation of three translocation intermediates with distinct membrane topology. They are associated with two oligomeric membrane complexes presumably representing TatBC-receptor complexes. The composition of the translocation intermediates as determined by immunoprecipitation experiments suggests that the two passenger proteins are translocated in a stepwise manner across the membrane.     

Targeting of proteins to the thylakoid lumen by the bipartite transit peptide of the 33 kd oxygen-evolving protein.

Various chimeric precursors and deletions of the 33 kd oxygen-evolving protein (OEE1) were constructed to study the mechanism by which chloroplast proteins are imported and targeted to the thylakoid lumen. The native OEE1 precursor was imported into isolated chloroplasts, processed and localized in the thylakoid lumen. Replacement of the OEE1 transit peptide with the transit peptide of the small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase, a stromal protein, resulted in redirection of mature OEE1 into the stromal compartment of the chloroplast. Utilizing chimeric transit peptides and block deletions we demonstrated that the 85 residue OEE1 transit peptide contains separate signal domains for importing and targeting the thylakoid lumen. The importing domain, which mediates translocation across the two membranes of the chloroplast envelope, is present in the N-terminal 58 amino acids. The thylakoid lumen targeting domain, which mediates translocation across the thylakoid membrane, is located within the C-terminal 27 residues of the OEE1 transit peptide. Chimeric precursors were constructed and used in in vitro import experiments to demonstrate that the OEE1 transit peptide is capable of importing and targeting foreign proteins to the thylakoid lumen.     

Chloroplast proteases: possible regulators of gene expression?

A wide range of proteolytic processes in the chloroplast are well recognized. These include processing of precursor proteins, removal of oxidatively damaged proteins, degradation of proteins missing their prosthetic groups or their partner subunit in a protein complex, and adjustment of the quantity of certain chloroplast proteins in response to changing environmental conditions. To date, several chloroplast proteases have been identified and cloned. The chloroplast processing enzyme is responsible for removing the transit peptides of newly imported proteins. The thylakoid processing peptidase removes the thylakoid-transfer domain from proteins translocated into the thylakoid lumen. Within the lumen, Tsp removes the carboxy-terminal tail of the precursor of the PSII D1 protein. In contrast to these processing peptidases which perform a single endo-proteolytic cut, processive proteases that can completely degrade substrate proteins also exist in chloroplasts. The serine ATP-dependent Clp protease, composed of the proteolytic subunit ClpP and the regulatory subunit ClpC, is located in the stroma, and is involved in the degradation of abnormal soluble and membrane-bound proteins. The ATP-dependent metalloprotease FtsH is bound to the thylakoid membrane, facing the stroma. It degrades unassembled proteins and is involved in the degradation of the D1 protein of PSII following photoinhibition. DegP is a serine protease bound to the lumenal side of the thylakoid membrane that might be involved in the chloroplast response to heat. All these peptidases and proteases are homologues of known bacterial enzymes. Since ATP-dependent bacterial proteases and their mitochondrial homologues are also involved in the regulation of gene expression, via their determining the levels of key regulatory proteins, chloroplast proteases are expected to play a similar role.     

Pathway specificity for a delta pH-dependent precursor thylakoid lumen protein is governed by a ''Sec-avoidance'' motif in the transfer peptide and a ''Sec-incompatible'' mature protein.

Cleavable N-terminal targeting signals direct the translocation of lumenal proteins across the chloroplast thylakoid membrane by either a Sec-type or delta pH-driven protein translocase. The targeting signals specify choice of translocation pathway, yet all resemble typical bacterial 'signal' peptides in possessing a charged N-terminus (N-domain), hydrophobic core region (H-domain) and more polar C-terminal region (C-domain). We have previously shown that a twin-arginine motif in the N-domain is essential for targeting by the delta pH-dependent pathway, but it has remained unclear why targeting signals for this system (transfer peptides) are not recognized by the Sec apparatus. We show here that the conserved charge distribution around the H-domain in the 23K transfer peptide (twin-Arg in the N-domain, Lys in the C-domain) constitutes a 'Sec-avoidance' signal. The C-domain Lys, while not important for delta pH-dependent targeting, is the only barrier to Sec-dependent translocation; its removal generates an apparently perfect signal peptide. Conversely, insertion of twin-Arg into the N-domain of a Sec substrate has little effect, as has insertion of a C-domain Lys, but the combined substitutions almost totally block transport. We also show that the 23K mature protein is incapable of being targeted by the Sec pathway, and it is proposed that the role of the Sec-avoidance motif in the transfer peptide is to prevent futile interactions with the Sec apparatus.     

叶绿体硫氧还蛋白系统的调节机制

硫氧还蛋白(Trx)属于巯基-二硫键氧化还原酶家族, 通过作用于底物蛋白侧链2个半胱氨酸残基之间的二硫键(还原、异构和转移)来调控胞内蛋白的结构和功能。叶绿体Trx系统包括Trx及Trx类似蛋白、铁氧还蛋白(Fd)依赖的硫氧还蛋白还原酶(FTR)和还原型烟酰腺嘌呤二核苷磷酸(NADPH)依赖的硫氧还蛋白还原酶C (NTRC)。除了基质蛋白酶类活性变化及叶绿体蛋白的转运受Trx系统调控之外, 在叶绿体中还存在1条跨类囊体膜的还原势传递途径, 把基质Trx的还原势经跨膜转运蛋白介导, 最终传递给类囊体腔蛋白。FTR和NTRC共同作用维持叶绿体的氧化还原平衡。该文对叶绿体硫氧还蛋白系统的调节机制进行了综述, 同时讨论了叶绿体硫氧还蛋白系统对维持植物光合效率的重要意义。     

Function of a chloroplast SRP in thylakoid protein export.

Protein export systems derived from prokaryotes are used to transport proteins into or across the endoplasmic reticulum, the mitochondrial inner membrane, and the chloroplast thylakoid membrane. Signal recognition particle (SRP) and its receptor are essential components used exclusively for cotranslational export of endomembrane and secretory proteins to the endoplasmic reticulum in eukaryotes and export of polytopic membrane proteins to the cytoplasmic membrane in prokaryotes. An organellar SRP in chloroplasts (cpSRP) participates in cotranslational targeting of chloroplast synthesized integral thylakoid proteins. Remarkably, cpSRP is also used to posttranslationally localize a subset of nuclear encoded thylakoid proteins. Recent work has begun to reveal the basis for cpSRP's unique ability to function in co- and posttranslational protein localization, yet much is left to question. This review will attempt to highlight these advances and will also focus on the role of other soluble and membrane components that are part of this novel organellar SRP targeting pathway.