Revascularized periosteal grafts--a new method to produce functional new bone without bone grafting

Rib periosteum was transplanted to the groins of 9 dogs. In half of the periosteal grafts, no microvascular anastomoses were done (free grafts); at 6 weeks after grafting they had become resorbed. The other periosteal grafts were revascularized by microvascular anastomoses of the intercostal vessels to local muscular vessels; at 6 weeks those with confirmed vascular patency had all formed substantial amounts of new bone. Five cm, full-thickness defects were created in the tibias of 10 dogs. The control animals (without grafting) did not heal in two months. However, the experimental dogs, with vascularized periosteal grafts in the defects regenerated their tibias with healthy new bone by 6 weeks--and were walking on them then.     

Bone scintigraphy of experimental composite bone grafts revascularized by microvascular anastomoses.

In these experiments the reliability of bone scintigraphy with 99mTc diphosphonate, to assess anastomotic patency and the viability of revascularized composite fibular grafts, was studied. It was shown that bone scintigraphy is very useful for the diagnosis of anastomotic patency, but only in the first postoperative weeks. Bone scintigraphy gives no information on the viability of bone grafts.     

Growth in revascularized bone grafts in young puppies.

The results of microvascular transfers of growing ulnas in puppy forelegs have been studied. These transfers were carried out both heterotopically and orthotopically. The growth in the revascularized bone grafts has been compared to that in heterotopic, nonvascularized ulna transfers and to normal ulnar growth. The growth in the vascularized bone grafts was significantly greater than in the nonvascularized grafts, but significantly less than in normal ulnar growth. A metaphyseal contribution to the blood supply of the growing portion of long bones is suggested.     

Bone grafts: a radiologic, histologic, and biomechanical model comparing autografts, allografts, and free vascularized bone grafts

We developed an experimental model to compare the efficacy of free vascularized bone grafts, conventional segmental autografts, matchstick autografts, and fresh segmental allografts in terms of their ability to reconstruct a 7-cm segmental diaphyseal defect created in the canine femur. Forty-five adult mongrel dogs were studied and followed for 6 to 12 months prior to sacrifice. Evaluation included radiologic assessment of graft incorporation and hypertrophy, histology, and biomechanical testing. These studies indicated that microsurgically revascularized autografts were superior to all other groups in terms of early incorporation, hypertrophy, and the highest mechanical strength to failure. Union of the bone graft to the recipient femur was achieved by 6 months in 25 of 26 autografts, and no difference in union rate was seen within the autograft group. However, only two of five allografts achieved bony union during this time interval. Arteriography, microangiography, fluorochrome, and histologic studies all supported the concept that microsurgically revascularized grafts, when successful, maintain their viability. However, the premise that all osteocytes survive in a successfully revascularized bone graft is open to question. While decalcified sections showed that all microsurgically revascularized grafts maintained normal viability in the central marrow and cancellous portions compared with the other three groups, the viability of cortical bone in the vascularized autografts was less clear. Undecalcified fluorochrome sections suggested that circulation was not preserved in all portions of the cortex. Revascularization of the nonvascularized autografts was complete at 3 months, while, in the avascular allografts, the process was not complete at 6 months.     

Effect of isolation of periosteum and dura on the healing of rabbit calvarial inlay bone grafts

Little is understood about the role of the recipient site in the revascularization and incorporation of autogenous inlay bone grafts in the craniofacial skeleton. Clinical experience demonstrates that secondary complex cranial vault reconstruction performed with scarred avascular dura or poor soft-tissue coverage may undergo significant resorption, thus compromising the aesthetic outcome. This study was designed to determine the effect of isolating autogenous orthotopic inlay calvarial bone grafts from the surrounding dura and/or periosteum on graft revascularization, healing, and volume maintenance in the adult rabbit. Adult rabbits were randomized into four groups (n = 10 per group); in each rabbit, the authors created a circular, 15-mm in diameter, full-thickness cranial defect followed by reconstruction with an autogenous calvarial bone graft, which was replaced orthotopically and held with microplate fixation. Silicone sheeting (0.5 mm thickness) was used to isolate the dura (group II), the periosteum (group II), or both dura and periosteum (group IV) from the graft interface. No silicone was placed in group I. Animals were killed 10 weeks postoperatively, and calvaria were harvested to assess graft surface area, morphology, quantitative histology, fluorochrome staining, and revascularization. Grafts isolated from both the dura and periosteum exhibited significant decreases in total bone (cortical and trabecular) surface area, blood vessel count, and interface healing compared with nonisolated control grafts. Isolation of either the dura or periosteum significantly (p < 0.05) decreased blood vessel count but had no significant effect on interface healing. Isolation of the dura alone was associated with a significant (p < 0.05) decrease in graft cross-sectional surface area and dural cortical thickness compared with nonisolated control grafts, but this effect was not observed when the periosteum alone was isolated. Quantitative histology performed 10 weeks after surgery indicated that graft isolation was associated with increased marrow fibrosis and necrosis compared with nonisolated controls; it also demonstrated evidence of increased activity in bone remodeling (osteoblast and osteocyte count, new trabecular bone, and surface resorption). Triple fluorochrome staining suggested increased bone turnover in the nonisolated grafts compared with isolated grafts at 1 and 5 weeks postoperatively. This study demonstrates that isolating a rabbit calvarial inlay autogenous bone graft from the dura and/or periosteum results in significantly (p < 0.05) decreased revascularization, interface healing, and cross-sectional areas of amount of mature bone compared with nonisolated control grafts 10 weeks after surgery. At this time point, histologic examination demonstrates a paradoxical increase in bone remodeling in isolated bone grafts compared with controls. It is possible that the inhibition of revascularization results in a delayed onset of the remodeling phase of graft incorporation. However, in the model studied, it is not known whether the quantitative histologic and morphometric parameters measured in these isolated grafts exhibit a "catch-up" phenomenon at time points beyond 10 weeks after surgery. The results of this study emphasize the importance of a healthy recipient site in the healing and incorporation of calvarial bone grafts but stress the need for further investigation at later time points.     

Postoperative irradiation of fresh autogenic cancellous bone grafts

Discontinuity defects were created in the mandibles of dogs and then reconstructed immediately with fresh autogenic cancellous bone grafts and Dacron-urethane prostheses. The grafts were irradiated to a total dose of 5000 rads after waiting intervals of between 3 and 12 weeks. Nonirradiated grafts served as controls. The grafts were evaluated clinically, radiographically, and histologically. There was complete incorporation of all grafts, regardless of the interval between surgery and radiotherapy. There were no soft-tissue complications. The controls were distinguishable from the irradiated grafts only by the presence of hematopoietic bone marrow. Fibrofatty marrow was observed in the irradiated grafts. Theoretical support for this technique is found in the biology of cancellous bone grafting and the pathology of radiation injury. In view of the difficulties associated with mandibular bone grafting in preoperatively irradiated patients, a new method of reconstructing selected cancer patients who require both mandibular resection and radiotherapy is suggested.     

Iliac crest bone graft harvesting techniques: a comparison

This study was undertaken to compare the morbidity of traditional iliac bone graft harvesting techniques for grafting alveolar clefts to minimally invasive techniques. Fifty-five age-matched patients, ages 6.5 to 16 years (mean, 11.2 years), 22 girls and 33 boys, were divided into three groups. The traditional bone window open harvesting technique served as the control group. Two different minimally invasive techniques, one that used a bone grinder and another that used a trephine, for bone harvesting were compared with the control. Both invasive techniques were statistically superior, p < 0.05, in terms of total time pain medication was necessary (mean of 12.0 hours for bone grinder, 17.6 hours for trephine, 26.0 hours for control), operative time for bone harvest (mean of 11 minutes for bone grinder and trephine, 20 minute for control), and mean incision length (2 cm for bone grinder and trephine, 5 cm for control). Patients exposed to the minimally invasive techniques had fewer complications, a trend toward earlier ambulation, and shorter hospital stays when compared with the bone grinder technique. The patients exposed to the bone grinder demonstrated earlier ambulation and fewer requirements for analgesia when compared with the trephine technique, although these results did not reach statistical significance. The trephine technique was useful when maxillary osteotomies were combined with alveolar bone grafting, because it provided structural bone grafts and cancellous bone. On the basis of these findings, the bone grinder is the preferred technique for harvesting alveolar bone grafts when no structural support is required. These authors no longer use the traditional bone window open harvesting technique.     

Volume maintenance of inlay bone grafts in the craniofacial skeleton

Although the clinical use of inlay bone grafts is widespread in craniofacial surgery, the dynamics of inlay bone grafting to the craniofacial skeleton have never been well characterized. Previous work demonstrated that volume maintenance of bone grafts in the onlay position is a consequence of their microarchitectural features, rather than their embryological origins. The purpose of this study was to investigate whether the properties determining the volume maintenance of bone grafts in the onlay position in the craniofacial skeleton could be extended to bone grafts in the inlay position. It was hypothesized that volume maintenance of an inlay bone graft could be better explained on the basis of the microarchitectural features of the graft (cortical versus cancellous composition), rather than its embryological origin (membranous versus endochondral), and that the primary determinant of bone graft behavior is the interaction between the microarchitectural features of the bone graft and the local mechanical environment in which the bone graft is placed. Cortical and cancellous bone grafts were harvested from the iliac crest (endochondral origin) of 25 New Zealand white rabbits, and cortical bone was harvested from the mandible (membranous origin) of each rabbit. Four 7-mm trephine holes were made in the cranium of each rabbit, posterior to the coronal suture. Each defect was filled with endochondral cortical bone, endochondral cancellous bone, or membranous cortical bone or was left as an ungrafted control specimen. Animals were killed at 3, 8, or 16 weeks. Crania were subjected to micro-computed tomographic and histological assessments. Micro-computed tomographic analysis demonstrated significant increases in actual bone volume from time 0 to the time of death for all types of grafts. Cortical bone demonstrated significant increases in space-occupying volume at all time points. By 16 weeks, no statistically significant difference in either the actual bone volume or the space-occupying volume according to graft type could be detected. There was no resorption of the inlay bone grafts; in fact, all bone types exhibited increased volume. Cancellous bone demonstrated the greatest capacity to increase actual bone volume. All bone graft types seemed to reach a steady-state bone volume, as if controlled by a local regulator. The regulator is likely the local mechanical environment in which the grafts were placed, as corroborated by the findings that the bone grafts seemed to recapitulate the characteristics of the bone in which they were placed, rather than maintaining their native characteristics.     

Distraction osteogenesis of costochondral bone grafts in the mandible

Costochondral grafting for reconstruction of the Pruzansky type III mandible has given variable results. Lengthening of the rib graft by means of distraction had been advocated when subsequent growth of the grafted mandible is inadequate. This retrospective study reviews a series of patients with mandibular costochondral grafts who underwent subsequent distraction osteogenesis of the graft. A retrospective review identified two patient groups: group 1 consisted of individuals (n = 9) who underwent costochondral rib grafting of the mandible followed by distraction osteogenesis several months later at a rate of 1 mm/day. Group 2 consisted of patients with Pruzansky type II mandibles who had distraction osteogenesis without prior rib grafting (n = 9). The biomechanical parameters, orthodontic treatment regimens, and complications were examined versus patient age and quality of the rib graft. Distraction osteogenesis was successfully performed in six of the rib graft patients (group 1) and in all of the group 2 individuals. On the basis of the Haminishi scale, the computed tomographic scan appearance of the regenerate was classified as "standard or external" in six of the group 1 patients and as either "agenetic" or "pillar" (fibrous union) in the remaining three patients. In group 1, the average device was expanded 23 mm (range, 20 to 30 mm). Group 2 mandibular distraction results were all classified as either standard or external, and there was an average device expansion of 22.4 mm (range, 16 to 30 mm). The length of consolidation averaged 12.6 weeks in group 1, compared with 8.5 weeks in the traditional mandibular distraction patients (group 2). The mean shift of the dental midline to the contralateral side was 2.5 mm in group 1 versus 4.0 mm in group 2. Complex multiplanar and transport distractions were successfully performed on grafts of adequate bony volume. All four patients in group 1 with tracheostomies were successfully decannulated after consolidation. Rib graft distraction complications included pin tract infections in two patients, hardware failure with premature pin pullout in one patient, and evidence of fibrous nonunions in three young patients with single, diminutive rib grafts. In group 2, there were no distraction failures. Distraction osteogenesis can be successfully performed on costochondral rib grafts of the mandible; however, the complication rate is higher than in non-rib-graft patients. Performing the technique on older, more cooperative individuals seems to reduce this risk. In addition, placement of a double rib graft or an iliac bone graft of sufficient volume to create a neomandible with greater bone stock is an absolute requirement to decrease the risk of fibrous nonunion and provide a bone base of sufficient size for retention of the distraction device and manipulation of the regenerate.     

The survival of free nonvascularized bone grafts in irradiated areas by wrapping in muscle flaps

In this paper, the concept of vascularizing the bed as opposed to the bone was tested with regard to bone grafting in irradiated areas. Thirteen rabbits underwent cross-transfer of a healthy rib into a bed that received 4500 rads of orthovoltage radiation. Eight of these grafts were wrapped in rotated, nonirradiated latissimus dorsi muscle. At 3 months, these grafts were evaluated radiologically, grossly, and histologically. Seven of eight grafts wrapped in muscle demonstrated evidence of union and survival (88 percent), whereas only one of five of those grafts placed directly into the irradiated bed demonstrated union and survival (20 percent). Statistical analysis showed this to be significant to 97.5 percent, with a lambda 2 value of 5.9.     

Growth potential in onlay bone grafts: a comparison of vascularized and free calvarial bone and suture bone grafts

Vascularized bone grafts are characterized by a viable cell population with osteogenic potential. These features suggest that continued growth can be anticipated following vascularized membranous bone transfer in a growing craniofacial skeleton. The present paper compares the potential for appositional bone growth in vascularized and free calvarial onlay bone grafts. In seven 8-week-old beagles, growth was assessed by direct caliper measurements of graft dimensions intraoperatively and 16 weeks postoperatively. Vascularized grafts demonstrated a 50 to 60 percent increase in size in all dimensions compared to 10 to 20 percent growth in free grafts (p less than 0.01). Microradiography revealed preservation of calvarial bony architecture and minimal resorption in vascularized grafts, while triple-fluorochrome labeling confirmed subperiosteal appositional bone formation. Free grafts were characterized by significant resorption and a delay in subperiosteal bone formation.     

Reconstruction of mandibular defects with revascularized free rib grafts.

Two cases of hemimandibular reconstructions with revascularized free rib grafts are presented. The viability of the transplants was confirmed by bone scans and biopsy, even though the main nutrient vessels providing the intramedullary blood flow were not included in these grafts (and only the periosteal circulation was utilized). The removal of a rib graft without the nutrient vessel eliminates the need for a complicated posterior dissection, close to the costovertebral joint. Revascularized free bone grafts have a greater chance of survival, provide more rapid healing, offer less risk of absorption, and are more resistant to infection than conventional bone grafts.     

The early revascularization of membranous bone

The experimental finding that membranous onlay bone grafts maintain volume and viability to a greater extent than do endochondral grafts may be related to the more rapid vascularization of membranous bone. Microangiographic techniques were used to study the rates of vascularization of membranous and endochondral bone grafts in adult white New Zealand rabbits at 1, 3, 7, 14, and 21 days after bone grafting. Vascularization patterns were quantified microscopically using a modified point-counting technique. At 3 days, membranous bone grafts demonstrated vessel ingrowth from both soft tissue and host bone. Little ingrowth was seen in endochondral grafts. By day 7, 2.5 vessels per square were identified entering membranous grafts, while an average of 0.6 vessels per square were counted for endochondral bone grafts. At day 14, there was an average of greater than 20 vessels per square for membranous grafts versus 1.8 for their endochondral counterparts. At 21 days, the endochondral grafts demonstrated persistent avascular central areas not seen in membranous grafts. Membranous onlay bone grafts in the rabbit are more rapidly vascularized than endochondral grafts. This factor may affect the greater volume maintenance seen in experimental membranous grafts.     

New biomaterials and methods for craniofacial bone defect: chondroid bone grafts in maxillary alveolar clefts

The purpose of this study was to evaluate autogenous osteogenic marrow within chondroid bone grafts in simulated alveolar defects of mice in order to determine the ability of the graft material to effectively close the cleft from an osseous standpoint and to observe the effect of the grafting procedure. Critical-sized defects were made in the premaxillary bones of male mice using a surgical trephine and a low-speed dental engine as a model of the maxillary alveolar cleft for testing bone-inductive agents. Premaxillary trephine defects were not repaired by fibrous tissue or bone formation 30 days after operation. This nonhealing bony wound of the premaxilla in mice may be useful as a model for studying the effect of bone-inductive agents on the healing of alveolar clefts. Distraction osteogenesis is a recently advanced principle of bone lengthening in which a long bone separated by osteotomy is subjected to slow progressive distraction using an external fixation device. The osteotomy site was surrounded by an external callus consisting of hyaline cartilage. The callus contained a lot of chondroid bone. The transplant bone within chondroid bone was characterized by bone formation and remodeling 30 days after transplantation. Throughout the experiment, our findings demonstrated, for the first time, that the transplant bone that contains chondroid bone may be used clinically in relation to craniofacial bone defects to improve the treatment of bone grafts.     

Temporal fossa bone grafts: a new technique in craniofacial surgery

The calvarium has become an increasingly popular bone-graft donor site. Previously described harvesting techniques are often difficult to perform and may produce unsatisfactory bone fragments. However, full-thickness bone grafts taken from the region of the temporal fossa, beneath the temporaiis muscle, have proven to be of high quality and technically easy to obtain. In our experience with eight patients, temporal fossa bone grafts were used primarily around the orbit, including reconstruction of the orbital floor, frontal bone, and zygoma. The procedure begins with a hemicoronal or bicoronal incision; the temporalis muscle is reflected, and an underlying bone plate up to 4 X 6 cm is removed. The resulting bone graft is consistently 3 to 4 mm in thickness. The cranial defect is packed with bone debris, and the muscle is replaced. This technique has proven to be safe, technically simple, consistently productive of high-quality bone grafts, and within discernible donor-site deformity.     

The role of primary bone grafting in complex craniomaxillofacial trauma

The role of craniofacial surgical techniques and immediate bone grafting in the management of complex craniofacial trauma has been reviewed. Four hundred and one patients with complex facial injuries have been treated. Two hundred and forty-one primary bone and cartilage grafts have been performed in 66 patients. Complex facial injuries should be managed by direct exposure, reduction, and fixation of all fractures utilizing interfragmentary wiring. Very comminuted or absent bone is replaced by immediate bone grafting, producing a stable skeleton without the need for external fixation devices. Associated mandibular fractures are managed with rigid internal fixation utilizing A-O technique. Results of immediate bone grafting have been excellent, and complications are rare. All deformities should be corrected, whenever possible, during the initial operation. This one-stage reconstruction of even the most complex facial injuries will prevent severe postoperative traumatic deformity and disability that may be extremely difficult or impossible to correct secondarily.     

The effect of rigid fixation on the survival of onlay bone grafts: an experimental study

Much attention has recently been focused on rigid fixation as a method of improving fracture healing. Whether such fixation, when applied to onlay grafting, improves graft take and volume is unknown. To examine this question, we compared survival of both endochondral and membranous grafts fixed rigidly and nonrigidly in areas of low motion (snout) and high motion (femur) in a rabbit model. Gross morphology, histologic analysis, and graft volume kinetics were evaluated. Findings demonstrate that in areas of high motion, the application of rigid fixation improves graft survival, whereas in a low-motion region, no differences in graft volume retention as a function of fixation were observed. Histologically, no differences with the method of fixation employed were seen, and similar revascularization patterns were noted. By kinetic analysis, rigid fixation appears to exert its most profound effect early in the postgraft period. Membranous bone grafts remain superior to endochondral grafts under all circumstances. From these studies, we conclude that rigid fixation is the method of choice in all circumstances where onlay bone grafts may be exposed to motion, shear, and torsional forces.     

Nasal reconstruction with full-thickness cranial bone grafts and rigid internal skeleton fixation through a coronal incision

The use of iliac and rib bone as onlay grafts to the nasal dorsum often fails because endochondral grafts resorb unpredictably. Membranous cranial bone grafts are less likely to resorb, especially when used with rigid internal fixation techniques. However, when split, they are often too thin and can be difficult to contour. Full-thickness cranial bone grafts were used to achieve nasal augmentation in 26 patients with end-stage nasal skeleton deficiency. All procedures were carried out using only a coronal incision. Grafts were harvested through a craniotomy, carved meticulously, and secured rigidly with miniplates or bicortical screws. Donor sites were reconstructed with split cranial grafts, leaving an intact cranial vault. No graft was lost to infection, and there was no significant donor-site morbidity. In carefully selected patients this method of full-thickness cranial bone graft reconstruction yields good results.     

Midface fractures: advantages of immediate extended open reduction and bone grafting

Experience with 240 midface (Le Fort and zygoma) fractures in multiple trauma patients has emphasized that superior aesthetic results are obtained by immediate extended open reduction with primary bone grafting. Internal fixation of 110 zygomatic and 130 Le Fort fractures was performed in the lower midface (zygomaticomaxillary and nasomaxillary buttresses). Open reduction of the condyle was employed in five concomitant Le Fort and subcondylar fractures with a loss of ramus height to prevent superior and posterior displacement of the middle and lower face. Bone grafts were utilized in 74 patients. They were most frequently employed in the orbit and less frequently in the lower midface. Bone graft survival paralleled that observed under elective conditions, and a slightly higher infection rate was observed. Extended open reduction and immediate bone grafting adds a new dimension to the aesthetic results obtained from facial fracture treatment. Structural bony integrity and pre-injury facial architecture may be restored in the absence of soft-tissue contracture. Restoration of the pre-injury facial architecture (the essence of facial fracture treatment) is more accurately accomplished when these techniques are utilized.     

Induction of unresponsiveness to bone marrow grafts.

Unresponsiveness to Hh incompatible bone marrow grafts was induced in mice by single or multiple injections of various tissues from a prospective donor before irradiation and bone marrow grafting. The results show that lymph node cells and splenocytes (both adherent and nonadherent) were the most effective in inducing unresponsiveness; thymocytes showed only a marginal effect in female and no effect in male mice, and hepatocytes had no effect. There was a direct relationship between the number of cells required for unresponsiveness induction and the strength of incompatibility between donor and recipient, i.e., the stronger the donor-recipient incompatibility, the more cells were required to induce unresponsiveness. The rapidity of unresponsiveness induction and its duration were also dependent on the number of cells in the "immunizing" inoculum. In general, unresponsiveness was induced sooner and persisted longer when larger cell doses were used. The unresponsiveness was highly specific with regard to donor antigens.