Multiple disordered loops function in corepressor-induced dimerization of the biotin repressor

Cooperative association of the Escherichia coli biotin repressor with the biotin operator is allosterically activated by binding of the corepressor, bio-5'-AMP. The corepressor function of the adenylate is due, in part, to its ability to induce repressor dimerization. Since a high-resolution structure of only the apo or unliganded repressor is currently available, the location of the dimerization interface on the protein structure is not known. Here, five mutants in the corepressor-binding domain of the repressor have been analyzed with respect to their DNA-binding and self-assembly properties. Results of these studies reveal that four of the mutant proteins exhibit defects in DNA binding. These same proteins are compromised in self-assembly. Furthermore, in the three-dimensional structure of the apo protein the mutations all lie in partially disordered surface loops, one of which is known to participate directly in corepressor binding. These results suggest that multiple disordered surface loops function in the corepressor-induced dimerization required for sequence-specific DNA binding by the biotin repressor.     

Coupling of protein assembly and DNA binding: biotin repressor dimerization precedes biotin operator binding

The kinetics of coupling of protein dimerization and DNA binding have been investigated in the biotin repressor system. Two repressor monomers bind to the 40 base-pair biotin operator sequence. In previous analyses of equilibrium-binding data the weak dimerization of the repressor has justified using a model in which two protein monomers bind cooperatively to the operator site. Here, rapid kinetic methods have been used to directly determine the binding mechanism. Results of rapid-mixing DNaseI footprinting measurements of association of the repressor with operator indicate that the binding process involves at least two steps. Results of measurements of the unimolecular dissociation of the complex reveal a half-life of approximately 400 seconds. Analysis of the data using a combination of simulation and global non-linear least-squares analysis provides support for a binding model in which a preformed repressor dimer associates with the biotin operator. This kinetic model is consistent with the previously proposed model for regulation of the functional switch in the repressor from enzyme to site-specific DNA-binding protein.     

Ligand-linked structural changes in the Escherichia coli biotin repressor: the significance of surface loops for binding and allostery.

The Escherichia coli repressor of biotin biosynthesis (BirA) is an allosteric site-specific DNA-binding protein. BirA catalyzes synthesis of biotinyl-5'-AMP from substrates biotin and ATP and the adenylate serves as the positive allosteric effector in binding of the repressor to the biotin operator sequence. Although a three-dimensional structure of the apo-repressor has been determined by X-ray crystallographic techniques, no structures of any ligand-bound forms of the repressor are yet available. Results of previously published solution studies are consistent with the occurrence of conformational changes in the protein concomitant with ligand binding. In this work the hydroxyl radical footprinting technique has been used to probe changes in reactivity of the peptide backbone of BirA that accompany ligand binding. Results of these studies indicate that binding of biotin to the protein results in protection of regions of the central domain in the vicinity of the active site and the C-terminal domain from chemical cleavage. Biotin-linked changes in reactivity constitute a subset of those linked to adenylate binding. Binding of both bio-5'-AMP and biotin operator DNA suppresses cleavage at additional sites in the amino and carboxy-terminal domains of the protein. Varying degrees of protection of the five surface loops on BirA from hydroxyl radical-mediated cleavage are observed in all complexes. These results implicate the C-terminal domain of BirA, for which no function has previously been known, in small ligand and site-specific DNA binding and highlight the significance of surface loops, some of which are disordered in the apoBirA structure, for ligand binding and transmission of allosteric information in the protein.     

Role of residue 147 in the gene regulatory function of the Escherichia coli purine repressor.

The crystal structures of corepressor-bound and free Escherichia coli purine repressor (PurR) have delineated the roles of several residues in corepressor binding and specificity and the intramolecular signal transduction (allosterism) of this LacI/GalR family member. From these structures, residue W147 was implicated as a key component of the allosteric response, but in many members of the LacI/GalR family, position 147 is occupied by an arginine. To understand the role of this tryptophan at position 147, three proteins, substituted by phenylalanine (W147F), alanine (W147A), or arginine (W147R), were constructed and characterized in vivo and in vitro, and their structures were determined. W147F displays a decreased affinity for corepressor and is a poor repressor in vivo. W147A and W147R, on the other hand, are super repressors and bind corepressor 13.6 and 7.9 times more tightly, respectively, than wild-type. Each mutant PurR-hypoxanthine-purF operator holo complex crystallizes isomorphously to wild-type. Whereas the apo corepressor binding domain (CBD) of W147F crystallizes under those conditions used for the wild-type protein, neither the apo CBD of W147R nor W147A crystallizes, although screened extensively for new crystal forms. Structures of the holo repressor mutants have been solved to resolutions between 2.5 and 2.9 A, and the structure of the apo CBD of W147F has been solved to 2.4 A resolution. These structures provide insight into the altered biochemical properties and physiological functions of these mutants, which appear to depend on the sometimes subtle preference for one conformation (apo vs holo) over the other.     

Stabilization of the biotinoyl domain of Escherichia coli acetyl-CoA carboxylase by interactions between the attached biotin and the protruding "thumb" structure

We previously reported (Chapman-Smith, A., Forbes, B. E., Wallace, J. C., and Cronan, J. E., Jr. (1997) J. Biol. Chem. 272, 26017-26022) that the biotinylated (holo) species of the biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP) biotinoyl domain is much more resistant to chemical modification and proteolysis than the unbiotinylated (apo) form. We hypothesized that the increased stability was due to a conformational change engendered by interaction of the domain with biotin protein ligase, the enzyme that attaches the biotin moiety. We now report that a BCCP-87 species to which the biotin moiety was attached by chemical acylation rather than by biotin protein ligase showed the characteristically greater stability of the holo biotinoyl domain. This result demonstrates that our hypothesis was incorrect; the attached biotin is solely responsible for the increased stability. The bacterial and chloroplast multisubunit acetyl-CoA carboxylases are unusual in that the highly symmetrical and conserved structure of the biotinoyl domain of the BCCP subunit is disrupted by a structured loop called the "thumb" that protrudes from body of the domain. Prior structural work showed that the thumb interacts with uriedo ring of the attached biotin moiety. We have tested whether the thumb-biotin interactions are responsible for the greater holo form stability by examination of two BCCP-87 species that lack the thumb. These BCCP species were produced in both the apo and holo forms, and their sensitivities to trypsin digestion were compared. The holo forms of these proteins were found to be only marginally more stable than their apo forms and much more sensitive to trypsin digestion than the wild type holo-BCCP-87. Therefore, removal of the thumb has an effect similar to lack of biotinylation, indicating that thumb-biotin interactions are responsible for most (but not all) of the increased stability of the holo biotinoyl domain. In the course of these experiments we demonstrated that treatment of Escherichia coli with the peptide deformylase inhibitor, actinonin, results in the expected (but previously unreported) accumulation of an N-formylated protein species.     

Allosteric signaling in the biotin repressor occurs via local folding coupled to global dampening of protein dynamics

The biotin repressor is an allosterically regulated, site-specific DNA-binding protein. Binding of the small ligand bio-5′-AMP activates repressor dimerization, which is a prerequisite to DNA binding. Multiple disorder-to-order transitions, some of which are known to be important for the functional allosteric response, occur in the vicinity of the ligand-binding site concomitant with effector binding to the repressor monomer. In this work, the extent to which these local changes are coupled to additional changes in the structure/dynamics of the repressor was investigated using hydrogen/deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry. Measurements were performed on the apo-protein and on complexes of the protein bound to four different effectors that elicit a range of thermodynamic responses in the repressor. Global exchange measurements indicate that binding of any effector to the intact protein is accompanied by protection from exchange. Mass spectrometric analysis of pepsin-cleavage products generated from the exchanged complexes reveals that the protection is distributed throughout the protein. Furthermore, the magnitude of the level of protection in each peptide from hydrogen/deuterium exchange correlates with the magnitude of the functional allosteric response elicited by a ligand. These results indicate that local structural changes in the binding site that occur concomitant with effector binding nucleate global dampening of dynamics. Moreover, the magnitude of dampening of repressor dynamics tracks with the magnitude of the functional response to effector binding.     

Protein function annotation by local binding site surface similarity

Hundreds of protein crystal structures exist for proteins whose function cannot be confidently determined from sequence similarity. Surflex‐PSIM, a previously reported surface‐based protein similarity algorithm, provides an alternative method for hypothesizing function for such proteins. The method now supports fully automatic binding site detection and is fast enough to screen comprehensive databases of protein binding sites. The binding site detection methodology was validated on apo/holo cognate protein pairs, correctly identifying 91% of ligand binding sites in holo structures and 88% in apo structures where corresponding sites existed. For correctly detected apo binding sites, the cognate holo site was the most similar binding site 87% of the time. PSIM was used to screen a set of proteins that had poorly characterized functions at the time of crystallization, but were later biochemically annotated. Using a fully automated protocol, this set of 8 proteins was screened against ～60,000 ligand binding sites from the PDB. PSIM correctly identified functional matches that predated query protein biochemical annotation for five out of the eight query proteins. A panel of 12 currently unannotated proteins was also screened, resulting in a large number of statistically significant binding site matches, some of which suggest likely functions for the podorly characterized proteins. Proteins 2014; 82:679–694. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Conformational and dynamics changes induced by bile acids binding to chicken liver bile acid binding protein

The correlation between protein motions and function is a central problem in protein science. Several studies have demonstrated that ligand binding and protein dynamics are strongly correlated in intracellular lipid binding proteins (iLBPs), in which the high degree of flexibility, principally occurring at the level of helix-II, CD, and EF loops (the so-called portal area), is significantly reduced upon ligand binding. We have recently investigated by NMR the dynamic properties of a member of the iLBP family, chicken liver bile acid binding protein (cL-BABP), in its apo and holo form, as a complex with two bile salts molecules. Binding was found to be regulated by a dynamic process and a conformational rearrangement was associated with this event. We report here the results of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations performed on apo and holo cL-BABP with the aim of further characterizing the protein regions involved in motion propagation and of evaluating the main molecular interactions stabilizing bound ligands. Upon binding, the root mean square fluctuation values substantially decrease for CD and EF loops while increase for the helix-loop-helix region, thus indicating that the portal area is the region mostly affected by complex formation. These results nicely correlate with backbone dynamics data derived from NMR experiments. Essential dynamics analysis of the MD trajectories indicates that the major concerted motions involve the three contiguous structural elements of the portal area, which however are dynamically coupled in different ways whether in the presence or in the absence of the ligands. Motions of the EF loop and of the helical region are part of the essential space of both apo and holo-BABP and sample a much wider conformational space in the apo form. Together with NMR results, these data support the view that, in the apo protein, the flexible EF loop visits many conformational states including those typical of the holo state and that the ligand acts stabilizing one of these pre-existing conformations. The present results, in agreement with data reported for other iLBPs, sharpen our knowledge on the binding mechanism for this protein family.     

Coupled energetics of lambda cro repressor self-assembly and site-specific DNA operator binding II: cooperative interactions of cro dimers

The bacteriophage lambda relies on interactions of the cI and cro repressors which self assemble and bind the two operators (O(R) and O(L)) of the phage genome to control the lysogenic to lytic switch. While the self assembly and O(R) binding of cI have been investigated in detail, a more complete understanding of gene regulation by phage lambda also requires detailed knowledge of the role of cro repressor as it dimerizes and binds at O(R) sites. Since dimerization and operator binding are coupled processes, a full elucidation of the regulatory energetics in this system requires that the equilibrium constants for dimerization and cooperative binding be determined. The dimerization constant for cro has been measured as a prelude to these binding studies. Here, the energetics of cro binding to O(R) are evaluated using quantitative DNaseI footprint titration techniques. Binding data for wild-type and modified O(R) site combinations have been simultaneously analyzed in concert with the dimerization energetics to obtain both the intrinsic and cooperative DNA binding energies for cro with the three O(R) sites. Binding of cro dimers is strongest to O(R)3, then O(R)1 and lastly, O(R)2. Adjacently bound repressors exhibit positive cooperativity ranging from -0.6 to -1.0 kcal/mol. Implications of these, newly resolved, energetics are discussed in the framework of a dynamic model for gene regulation. This characterization of the DNA-binding properties of cro repressor establishes the foundation on which the system can be explored for other, more complex, regulatory elements such as cI-cro cooperativity.     

Dynamics of cellular retinoic acid binding protein I on multiple time scales with implications for ligand binding

Cellular retinoic acid binding protein I (CRABPI) belongs to the family of intracellular lipid binding proteins (iLBPs), all of which bind a hydrophobic ligand within an internal cavity. The structures of several iLBPs reveal minimal structural differences between the apo (ligand-free) and holo (ligand-bound) forms, suggesting that dynamics must play an important role in the ligand recognition and binding processes. Here, a variety of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy methods were used to systematically study the dynamics of both apo and holo CRABPI at various time scales. Translational and rotational diffusion constant measurements were used to study the overall motions of the proteins. Both apo and holo forms of CRABPI tend to self-associate at high (1.2 mM) concentrations, while at low concentrations (0.2 mM), they are predominantly monomeric. Rapid amide exchange rate and laboratory frame relaxation rate measurements at two spectrometer field strengths (500 and 600 MHz) were used to probe the internal motions of the individual residues. Several residues in the apo form, notably within the ligand recognition region, exhibit millisecond time scale motions that are significantly arrested in the holo form. In contrast, no significant differences in the high-frequency motions were observed between the two forms. These results provide direct experimental evidence for dynamics-induced ligand recognition and binding at a specifically defined time scale. They also exemplify the importance of dynamics in providing a more comprehensive understanding of how a protein functions.     

Co-repressor induced order and biotin repressor dimerization: a case for divergent followed by convergent evolution

BirA catalyzes the adenylation and subsequent covalent attachment of biotin to the biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP). In the absence of apo-BCCP, biotin-5'-AMP acts as a co-repressor that induces BirA dimerization and binding to the bio operator to repress biotin biosynthesis. The crystal structures of apo-BirA, and BirA in complex with biotin have been reported. We here describe the 2.8A resolution crystal structure of BirA in complex with the co-repressor analog biotinol-5'-AMP. It was previously shown that the structure of apo-BirA is monomeric and that binding of biotin weakly induces a dimeric structure in which three disordered surface loops become organized to form the dimer interface. The structure of the co-repressor complex is also a dimer, clearly related to the BirA.biotin structure, but with several significant conformational changes. A hitherto disordered "adenylate binding loop" forms a well-defined structure covering the co-repressor. The co-repressor buttresses the dimer interface, resulting in improved packing and a 12 degrees change in the hinge-bending angle along the dimer interface relative to the BirA.biotin structure. This helps explain why the binding of the co-repressor is necessary to optimize the binding of BirA to the bioO operator. The structure reveals an unexpected use of the nucleotide-binding motif GXGXXG in binding adenylate and controlling the repressor function. Finally, based on structural analysis we propose that the class of adenylating enzymes represented by BirA, lipoate protein ligase and class II tRNA synthetases diverged early and were selected based on their ability to sequester co-factors or amino acid residues, and adenylation activity arose independently through functional convergence.     

Dimerization of the operator binding domain of phage lambda repressor

Dimerization of lambda repressor is required for its binding to operator DNA. As part of a continuing study of the structural basis of the coupling between dimer formation and operator binding, we have undertaken 1H NMR and gel filtration studies of the dimerization of the N-terminal domain of lambda repressor. Five protein fragments have been studied: three are wild-type fragments of different length (1-102, 1-92, and 1-90), and two are fragments bearing single amino acid substitutions in residues involved in the dimer interface (1-102, Tyr-88----Cys; 1-92, Ile-84----Ser). The tertiary structure of each species is essentially the same, as monitored by the 1H NMR resonances of internal aromatic groups. However, significant differences are observed in their dimerization properties. 1H NMR resonances of aromatic residues that are involved in the dimer contact allow the monomer-dimer equilibrium to be monitored in solution. The structure of the wild-type dimer contact appears to be similar to that deduced from X-ray crystallography and involves the hydrophobic packing of symmetry-related helices (helix 5) from each monomer. Removal of two contact residues, Val-91 and Ser-92, by limited proteolysis disrupts this interaction and also prevents crystallization. The Ile-84----Ser substitution also disrupts this interaction, which accounts for the severely reduced operator affinity of this mutant protein.