Measuring human disturbance using terrestrial invertebrates in the shrub–steppe of eastern Washington (USA)

Hanford Nuclear Reservation in eastern Washington is an ideal place to study biological responses to diverse human activities because minimally disturbed areas of native shrub–steppe exist in close proximity to areas that have been substantially altered. This range of conditions provides an opportunity to test which attributes of terrestrial invertebrate assemblages change systematically along a gradient of human influence and to select from these a set of biological metrics that can be used for site assessment. We sampled invertebrates at 25 sites at or near the Hanford Reservation: some sites showed past or present influence from agriculture, waste disposal, urbanization, or construction; others had a history of minimal human disturbance.We evaluated 57 attributes of terrestrial invertebrate assemblages to determine if they varied systematically with the intensity of human disturbance. Attributes were measured as taxa richness or percentage relative abundance of key taxonomic, trophic, or ecological groups. Ten attributes were consistently associated with disturbance in 3 years of independent sampling, and another 12 attributes were significant in 2 out of 3 years. Those selected as metrics were total number of invertebrate families (1) number of Diptera families (2) taxa richness of Acarina (3) predators (4) detritivores (5) ground-dwellers (6) and percentage relative abundance of detritivores (7); all declined with increasing disturbance. The percentage relative abundance of Collembola (8) and taxa richness (9) and relative abundance (10) of polyphagous Carabidae increased with disturbance. Two metrics (7 and 10) were excluded from further consideration because they were redundant with other metrics (6 and 9).We transformed the remaining eight metrics to a standard scale and added them to yield a multimetric index—a single value summarizing the biological condition of each site. Undisturbed sites had the highest index values; sites with physical disturbance related to construction or waste disposal ranked next; and agricultural sites had the lowest values, indicating the most severe changes in their resident biota. Index values were lower for more frequently disturbed sites, although the time since last disturbance produced no differences in index values. Repeat sampling at five sites indicated that index values varied little across years and that year-to-year differences were smaller at undisturbed than disturbed sites.This first effort to develop a terrestrial monitoring approach modeled after the aquatic index of biological integrity (IBI) shows promise, but validation of the metrics at other places will be needed before a terrestrial index of biological integrity (T-IBI) can reliably guide management, restoration, or policy decisions.     

天津滨海滩涂湿地鸟类丰富度与环境因子的关系研究

由于湿地生态系统的重要性、脆弱性和复杂性,湿地生态系统的保护与修复是当今世界的热点与难点问题之一。本研究选取天津滨海新区的3处湿地生态系统作为参考场地,1处湿地生态系统作为验证场地,通过量化4处场地不同类型栖息地的7个环境因素,综合鸟类对各类型栖息地的使用情况,并采用逐步回归分析,结果表明植被覆盖率、植物水平斑块丰富度及人为干扰程度与鸟类物种丰富度呈显著相关,并建立模型1;植物香农－威纳指数、植物水平斑块丰富度及人为干扰程度与鸟类共位群丰富度呈显著相关关系,并建立模型2。最后,利用验证场地的数据进行模型验证,得出所建立的模型能够较为准确地对栖息地内的鸟类丰富度进行预测。该研究构架了1种利用栖息地类型预测场地鸟类丰富度的方法,以期供相关研究或实际规划设计工作参考。     

Validation of ecological status concepts in UK rivers using historic diatom samples

We assessed the feasibility of using herbarium specimens to validate reference conditions in the UK by comparing diatom community composition of river sites with both recent and historic diatom samples. The question of substrate specificity was addressed by comparing epilithon (stone-derived) and epiphyton (plant-derived) samples from a number of rivers. No significant differences were found between the Trophic Diatom Index (TDI), species richness, species diversity, and percentage of motile valves between paired diatom samples (epilithic and epiphytic) from contemporary samples. Significant differences were recorded between a number of indices derived from analysis of the historic diatom samples on plant material sampled pre-1930 compared with diatoms from stones collected post-1990 from the same river location. The TDI, mean species richness, and species diversity and percentage of motile valves and nutrient tolerant valves were all significantly greater in the contemporary samples (p ≤ 0.05). The percentage of nutrient sensitive valves was significantly lower in the contemporary samples (p ≤ 0.05).The relative abundance of Achnanthidium minutissimum and Cocconeis placentula var. lineata was significantly greater on the herbarium material compared to matched contemporary samples. Calculated values for the TDI (43 ± 3) expected at reference conditions were similar to the observed TDI values derived from herbarium material (44 ± 12) showing no significant deviation in ecological status.     

武汉市城区苔藓植物多样性和分布及与环境因子的关系

对武汉市7个中心城区和部分远郊城区共26个样点73个样地的苔藓群落进行调查,采集苔藓植物样本共431份。经鉴定调查区内共有苔藓植物20科35属91种,其中狭叶小羽藓（Haplocladium angustifolium（Hampe et C.Muell.）Broth.）和钝叶绢藓（Entodon obtusatus Broth.）等为优势种,分布于其中的24个样点。多样性指数分析结果显示,位于青龙山国家森林公园的α多样性Patrick和Shannon-Wiener指数最高,说明该样点苔藓植物群落的复杂程度高,群落所含信息量大。Patrick指数与环境因子的Pearson相关性分析结果显示,土壤含水率和与主要干道距离是显著影响地面生苔藓植物多样性的环境因子,而显著影响树附生苔藓植物多样性的环境因子仅与距主要干道距离相关。用典范对应分析法（CCA）研究26个样点中苔藓植物的盖度与主要环境因子的关系,结果发现人为干扰程度、草本盖度、与城市主要干道的距离等对地面生和树附生苔藓植物的分布都有显著影响。其中地面生苔藓植物的分布受人为干扰和草本盖度影响最为显著;而树附生苔藓植物的分布受附生树干胸径及与主要干道距离影响最为显著。研究结果表明武汉市区苔藓植物的多样性和分布受人为干扰较大,树附生苔藓对汽车尾气等因素更为敏感。     

Diatom ecological guilds display distinct and predictable behavior along nutrient and disturbance gradients in running waters

Three diatom ecological guilds were distinguished based on their potential to tolerate nutrient limitation and physical disturbance, i.e. a low profile, high profile, and motile guild. The guild distributions were examined along nutrient and flow disturbance gradients and across habitats in two extensively sampled streams. The guilds showed distinct distributional patterns, i.e. the low profile guild was favored in nutrient-poor and high disturbance habitats; the high profile guild reached a maximum in nutrient-rich sites and in conditions of low flow disturbance; and the motile guild increased along the nutrient gradients and decreased along the disturbance gradient. Guild distribution was habitat-specific: the low profile guild dominated the epipsammon, the high profile guild showed preference for epilithon and epiphyton, and the motile guild—for epipelon. The highest guild diversity was observed at high nutrient levels across all habitats, at higher flow disturbance levels, and in the epipelon and epiphyton. Comparisons of species, guild, and environmental distances, derived from species counts, guild abundance, and physico-chemical data, respectively, revealed high congruence between species–environment and guild–environment correlations. The predictable behavior of the three ecological guilds along nutrient and disturbance gradients, and across major benthic habitats elucidates the functional value of different diatom growth morphologies in species–environment interactions and suggests a potential use in ecological assessments of human-impacted ecosystems.     

Testing of the applicability of European diatom indices in the tropical rift valley lake,Lake Hawassa,in Ethiopia

Quantitative ecological monitoring of African lakes is needed to understand growing human pressures on ecosystems. Diatom-based indices are routinely used for this purpose elsewhere in the world, but have not yet been produced for the flora of African freshwater lakes. Here we tested the applicability of the European diatom indices on the biomonitoring system of Lake Hawassa, Ethiopia. Physico-chemical and benthic diatom sampling was done at nine sites with different degrees of human disturbance along the lakeshore area from February to November 2015 and 2016. A percentage disturbance score (PDS) was calculated at each site and categorised from no evident disturbance (0–25%) to high disturbance (75–100%). Based on this criterion and selected physico-chemical parameters, the sampling sites categorized into minimal, moderate and high disturbance. Seventeen diatom indices were calculated using Omnidia software version 5.3. Out of a total of 17 indices that were calculated using the Omnidia software, six were selected as potential metrics. The diatom indices had a high discrimination efficiency and were significantly correlated with most the environmental parameters (r > 0.6; p < 0.05). Among these, the trophic diatom index (TDI) and generic diatom index (IDG) showed the best potential to discriminate the three clustered sites, based on their ecological classification. Accordingly, although robust locally based indices are needed, the TDI and IDG diatom indices could be used in monitoring of water quality in tropical African rift lakes.     

Understory spider diversity in two remnants of tropical montane cloud forest in Chiapas, Mexico

We evaluated the spider diversity of a tropical montane cloud forest understory in two nearby sites with different degree of human disturbance at the Biosphere Reserve Volcán Tacaná, Chiapas, Mexico. The study was conducted over a 24 days period distributed in 6 months in 2009, covering dry and rainy seasons. A total of 8,370 spiders (1,208 adults and 7,162 juveniles) were collected. Determined specimens (7,747) represented 112 species and morphospecies, 71 genera and 22 families. The results showed that human disturbance has an influence on spider communities: species richness was significantly higher in the preserved site as regards to the disturbed site. Despite their proximity, the composition of spider communities showed only a moderate similarity between the two sites. No differences in abundance were found among sites when considering the whole sample, but sites differed clearly when seasons were analyzed separately. The rainy season had a negative effect on the abundance of spiders in the preserved site. Although the spider community structure was very similar between sites, there was a trend towards a greater species evenness in the preserved site for the whole sampling period and for the dry season.     

Diatom flora of an Australian river system:spatial patterns and environmental relationships

SUMMARY. 1. Qualitative diatom samples from various microhabitatswere collected at fifty-three sites on the La Trobe River. Victoria, and itstributaries in late summer and early autumn. Measurements of severalphysico-chemical variables of likely significance to diatom distributionwere also made.
2. Principal components analysis of the physico-chemical data showedthat the dominant environmental pattern in the river system was agradient from cool, dilute upland streams to warmer, more turbid andenriched lowland waters.
3. A total of 267 diatom species was recorded; most were cosmopolitan and Navicula and Nitzschia were the dominant genera. Clusteranalysis allowed the sampling sites to be divided into six groups on the basis of their floras. These groupings corresponded closely to flow. landuse and wastewater discharge patterns and there were clearphysico-chemical differences between the groups. Multiple discriminant analysisfound thataltitude. temperature. biochemical oxygen demand. turbidity, non-filterable residue, pH. major ions, phosphorus and nitrogenwere important factors in distinguishing between site groups.
4. Diatom species richness was lowest in relatively undisturbed, forested upland streams, probably as a result of nutrient limitation. Forthe catchment as a whole significantcorrelations were establishedbetween species richness and altitude, temperature, biochemical oxygendemand, turbidity. non-filterable residue, conductivity, calcium, alkalinity, organic nitrogen and phosphorus.     

Predicting diatom communities at the genus level for the rapid biological assessment of rivers

1. Diatoms were sampled in the spring of 1994 and the autumn of 1995 at 137 pristine or near-pristine reference sites on large and small streams at various altitudes in eastern New South Wales and Victoria. Scrapings were taken from five firm substrata across a range of microhabitat conditions at each site on each occasion. For each substratum, 100 valves were identified to genus level. 2. Multivariate statistical models were constructed to predict the probability of occurrence of each genus at a given site under near-pristine conditions on the basis of physical features of the site that are not affected by human activity. Model predictions were compared with the flora observed at the reference sites and at 55 test sites affected by varying degrees of human disturbance. 3. Test sites were characterized more by the presence of genera not predicted by the model than by the absence of predicted genera. The degree of departure from model predictions was related mainly to increasing alkalinity, electrical conductivity, hardness and pH of river water. We therefore conclude that the main effect of human activity on the composition of diatom communities in the rivers of coastal south-eastern Australia has been to increase genus richness through enrichment with alkaline salts. 4. The models did not perform as well as similar models applied to river macroinvertebrates at the family level, perhaps because of greater temporal variability in diatom communities and differences in the environmental variables to which diatoms and macroinvertebrates respond. Means of improving the current models are discussed.     

Diatom Assemblages and their Associations with Environmental Variables in Oregon Coast Range Streams, USA

The Oregon Coast Range, rich in natural resources, is under increasing pressure from rapid development. The purpose of this study was to examine diatom species patterns in relation to environmental variables in streams of this region. Diatoms, water quality, physical habitat and watershed characteristics were assessed for 33 randomly selected stream sites. Watershed size, elevation, geology, vegetation and stream morphology varied substantially among sites. Streams were characterized by dilute water chemistry and a low percent of fine substrate. A total of 80 diatom taxa were identified. Taxa richness was low throughout the region (median 15, range 10–26). Assemblages were dominated by two adnate species, Achnanthidium minutissimum and Achnanthes pyrenaicum. Diatoms sensitive to organic pollution dominated the assemblages at all sites (median 85%). Non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) and correlational analysis showed quantitative relationships between diatom assemblages and environmental variables. NMDS axes were significantly correlated with watershed area, watershed geology, conductivity, total nitrogen, total solids and stream width. Diatom-based site classification (Two-way Indicators Species Analysis, (TWINSPAN)) yielded 4 discrete groups that displayed weak correlations with environmental variables. When stream sites were classified by dominant watershed geology, overall diatom assemblages between groups were significantly different (Analysis of Similarity (ANOSIM) global R = 0.19, p < 0.05). Our results suggest that streams in the coastal region are in relatively good condition. High natural variability in stream conditions in the Oregon Coast Range ecoregion may obscure quantitative relationships between environmental variables and diatom assemblages. A bioassessment protocol that classifies sites by major landscape variables and selects streams along the major human disturbance gradient might allow for detection of early signs of human disturbance in environmentally heterogeneous regions, such as the Pacific Northwest.     

DIATOM ASSEMBLAGES OF STREAMS INFLUENCED BY WILDFIRE1

The Greater Yellowstone Area ecosystem experienced major wildfires in 1988, resulting in a substantial number of catchments being burned. We studied diatom assemblage structure at 14 sites over 5 years in catchments ranging from 0 to over 90% burned. Coefficients of variation for selected physical measures provided a good assessment of the degree of disturbance experienced by the various sites and correlated highly with percentage of catchment burned. Principal components analysis quantitatively estimated the degree of temporal change in diatom assemblages at a site. The more extensively burned catchments showed the greatest amount of structural change in diatom taxa among years. Navicula permitis Hust. and Nitzschia inconspicua Grun. were predominant in the heavily disturbed systems, whereas Achnanthes minutissima Kuetz., A. lanceolata (Breb.) Grun., Rhoicosphenia curvata (Kuetz.) Grun. ex Rabh., and Diatoma hiemale var. mesodon (Ehr.) Grun. were common in less disturbed streams. The results demonstrate that recovery trajectories of lotic diatom assemblages following major landscape-scale disturbances are a function of disturbance intensity resulting from differences in catchment characteristics.     

THE POTENTIAL INDICATOR VALUE OF RARE TAXA RICHNESS IN DIATOM‐BASED STREAM BIOASSESSMENT1

Despite their recognized contribution to species richness, the importance of rare taxa richness in bioassessment is unclear. This study aimed to characterize the environmental factors affecting the number of rare diatom taxa in western U.S. streams and rivers, and to evaluate whether this number can be used to differentiate streams with contrasting human disturbance. Three different categories of rare taxa were used: satellite (taxa with low occurrence and low abundance), rural (taxa with high occurrence and low abundance), and urban (taxa with low occurrence and high abundance). Common taxa were included as a separate category of core taxa (taxa with high occurrence and high abundance). We analyzed 987 diatom samples collected over the period of 5 years (2000–2004) for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Western Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program (WEMAP). The results showed that rural taxa richness (number of rural taxa per site) increased along a longitudinal gradient from mountainous, fast‐flowing oligotrophic streams with fewer fine substrates to large, slow‐moving, nutrient‐rich rivers with abundance of fine substrates. Rural taxa richness was the only rarity metric that distinguished least disturbed (reference) sites from the most disturbed (impacted) sites, but it was significantly different only in the mountains ecoregion. Core taxa richness distinguished reference from impacted sites in the West and in each one of the three ecoregions (mountains, plains, and xeric). Our findings revealed that rural taxa richness can be used as an indicator of human disturbance in streams/rivers, especially in the mountains ecoregion, and that rarity definition is important in bioassessment.     

Vegetation changes in blown-down and scorched forests 10–26 years after the eruption of Mount St. Helens,Washington, USA

We examine patterns of vegetative change in blown-down and scorched forests in the blast zone of Mount St. Helens (USA), 10–26 years after the eruption. We compare trends in community attributes in four post-eruption environments, or site types, defined by severity of disturbance, presence/absence of a protective snowpack at the time of eruption, and seral state (previously clearcut vs. mature/old forests). Permanent plots established in 1980 at 16 sites were sampled at 5- to 6-year intervals between 1989 and 2005. Data on species presence and abundance were used to characterize changes in total plant cover, life-form spectra, species diversity, species turnover, and community composition. Due to the magnitude and heterogeneity of disturbance, vegetation re-establishment was gradual and highly variable among sites. Total plant cover averaged 36–70% after 26 years. Early-seral forbs were dominant except in snow-protected sites, where surviving shrubs were most common. Tree regeneration remained sparse after 26 years (<?6% cover in all but two sites). Species richness increased in all site types, reflecting greater species gain than loss, although rates of gain declined with time. Species heterogeneity, integrating the number and abundance of taxa, did not increase. Successional trajectories were distinct, but parallel among sites, reflecting legacies of pre-eruption composition, variation in disturbance severity, and differences in composition of early-seral colonists. Slow re-colonization by forest herbs and trees likely reflects seed limitations and abiotic stress rather than competition from early-seral species. Succession following this major eruption is both slow and contingent on pre-conditions, nuances of the disturbance, and species’ life histories.     

杭州市区土生苔藓植物分布与生态因子的关系

在杭州市区设立的21个样点中,记录到土生苔藓植物22科31属47种.基于样点中苔藓植物种类的生态重要值和样点生态因子数据进行典范对应分析.结果表明:人为干扰和土壤pH是影响杭州市区土生苔藓植物分布的主要生态因子.在市区平原地势的公园和绿地,人为干扰较大,土壤呈碱性,苔藓植物种类以小羽藓属、真藓属和丛藓科为主;而在海拔较高的丘陵地区,人为干扰较小,土壤呈酸性,苔藓植物种类相对丰富,侧蒴藓类和苔类较多.对47种土生苔藓植物进行生态位宽度计测,多数苔藓植物的生态位宽度较窄.其中,东亚拟鳞叶藓的生态位宽度最大(0.3510),广泛分布在西湖西南的丘陵地区;平叶毛口藓和细叶小羽藓的生态位宽度次之,分别为0.2239和0.2185,是市区平原地势的公园和绿地中的常见种.     

Benthic diatom assemblages in mountain streams: community structure in relation to environmental and human pressures

The objective of this study was to determine the environmental factors that best explain the distribution and community composition of benthic diatoms in undisturbed mountain streams in the Eastern Highlands of Zimbabwe. Benthic diatoms were sampled during the dry season from 21 sampling sites established along altitudinal gradient of the study rivers. A total of 119 diatom species belonging to 38 genera and twelve families were recorded for all the 21 sites sampled. No significant differences were observed in species diversity and equitability amongst the three river systems. However, species richness, diversity and equitability decreased significantly along the longitudinal gradient of the rivers, with the highest richness, diversity and evenness being recorded in the upper reaches. Temperature, velocity, NO₃^? and Ca²⁺ levels were strongly associated with changes in diatom communities in the three rivers. Inventory of diatom communities has applications in many fields of biological research including conservation and biological monitoring of ecosystem changes.     

Testing species–stone area and species–bryophyte cover relationships in riverine macroinvertebrates at small scales

1. The species–area relationship is considered amongst the few genuine laws in ecology. Although positive species richness–stone area relationships have been found previously in stream systems, very few studies have simultaneously examined species–individuals, individuals–area, species–bryophyte biomass and individuals–bryophyte biomass relationships. We examined these relationships based on temporally replicated assessments of macroinvertebrates on stones at two river sites. 2. We found only one significant species–area relationship out of six relationship tested, and two significant individuals–area relationships. Even these significant relationships were weak, however. By contrast, we detected significant and rather strong relationships between species richness and the number of individuals at both river sites on all three sampling dates. We also found significant relationships of both species richness and the number of individuals with bryophyte biomass at both river sites on all sampling occasions. One of the river sites was disturbed by a bulldozer, and the species–bryophyte biomass relationships were somewhat stronger after the disturbance event. 3. Our findings are quite surprising, given that there were very weak species–area relationships on stream stones. By contrast, our results suggest a pivotal role for bryophyte biomass in determining the species richness and the number of individuals of stream macroinvertebrates at this small scale. The most probably origin of these relationships begins with bryophyte cover, which determines the number of individuals, and subsequently passively affects species richness. Thus, there is not necessarily a direct mechanism that determines the variability of species richness on stream stones. 4. Experimental studies are needed to disentangle the various mechanisms (e.g. passive sampling, provision of more food, more niche space, flood disturbance refugia) by which bryophyte biomass affects stream macroinvertebrates.     

From Forest to Ffarmland: Butterfly Diversity and Habitat Associations Along a Gradient of Forest Conversion in Southwestern Cameroon

Worldwide, tropical landscapes are increasingly dominated by human land use systems and natural forest cover is decreasing rapidly. We studied frugivorous butterflies and several vegetation parameters in 24 sampling stations distributed over near-primary forest (NF), secondary forest (SF), agroforestry and annual culture sites in the Northeastern part of the Korup region, SW Cameroon. As in other studies, both butterfly species richness and abundance were significantly affected by habitat modification. Butterfly richness and abundance were highest in SF and agroforestry sites and significantly lower in NF and annual crop sites. Butterfly species richness increased significantly with increasing tree density, but seemed to decrease with increasing herb diversity and density in annual crop farms. A significant negative correlation was found between butterfly geographic range and their preference for NF sites. Our results also showed that agroforestry systems, containing remnants of natural forest, can help to sustain high site richness, but appear to have low complementarity through loss of endemic species confined to more undisturbed habitats. Our study also indicated that the abundance of selected restricted-range butterflies, particularly in the family Nymphalidae, appears to be a good indicator to assess and monitor forest disturbance.     

The intermediate disturbance hypothesis does not explain fire and diversity pattern in fynbos

The intermediate disturbance hypothesis is a widely accepted generalization regarding patterns of species diversity, but may not hold true where fire is the disturbance. In the Mediterranean-climate shrublands of South Africa, called fynbos, fire is the most importance disturbance and a controlling factor in community dynamics. The intermediate disturbance hypothesis states that diversity will be highest at sites that have had an intermediate frequency of disturbance and will be lower at sites that have experienced very high or very low disturbance frequencies. Measures of diversity are sensitive to scale; therefore, we compared species richness for three fire regimes in South African mountain fynbos to test the intermediate disturbance hypothesis over different spatial scales from 1 m² to 0.1 hectares. Species diversity response to fire frequency was highly scale-dependent, but the relationship between species diversity and disturbance frequency was opposite that predicted by the intermediate disturbance hypothesis. At the largest spatial scales, species diversity was highest at the least frequently burned sites (40 years between fires) and lowest at the sites of moderate (15 to 26 years between fires) and high fire frequency (alternating four and six year fire cycle). Community heterogeneity, measured both as the slope of the species-area curve for a site and as the mean dissimilarity in species composition among subplots within a site, correlated with species diversity at the largest spatial scales. Community heterogeneity was highest at the least frequently burned sites and lowest at the sites that experienced an intermediate fire frequency.     

Response of carnivores to existing highway culverts and underpasses: implications for road planning and mitigation

Roads with high traffic volumes are a source of animal mortality, can disrupt normal animal movements and dispersal, and may represent a potentially serious threat to wildlife population stability and viability. Retrofitting existing structures built for other purposes (e.g., drainage culverts or small below-grade access roads) to facilitate wildlife crossing by animals and to reduce mortality may be expensive if modifications to the existing structures themselves were involved. However, the environmental context surrounding these structures may influence the willingness of animals to cross, and management of some of these attributes may enhance the attractiveness of these structures. Culverts and underpasses are two common structures along roads in Portugal. We quantified the response of small and medium-sized carnivores to the presence of both types of existing passages by determining: (1) frequency of use; (2) whether use differed by type of passage, and if so; (3) by examining if associated environmental attributes might explain the differences observed. We surveyed 57 different passages along 252 km of highway with a total sampling effort of 2,330 passage trap-days. The mean passage rate for carnivores combined was 0.7 complete passages per crossing structure per day. Crossings by weasel, polecat, otter, and wildcat were infrequent or absent. Red fox, badger, genet and Egyptian mongoose used the crossing structures regularly and without obvious preference; stone marten preferred underpasses. Regression analyses showed the frequency of use by carnivores varied with structural, landscape, road-related features, and human disturbance with 17 of 26 (65%) attributes being significant. Larger passages with vegetation close to the passage entrances, favorable habitat in the surrounding area, and low disturbance by humans were important key features to regular use by the guild of species studied. Mitigation planning in areas with ecological significance for carnivores will be beneficial. Structural attributes and human disturbances are more difficult or expensive to change, even though related significantly to crossing use. Management of vegetation at passage entrances and restricting human use near passages in carnivore suitable areas may substantially improve crossing attractiveness for the guild of carnivore species.