Malate-permeable channels and cation channels activated by aluminum in the apical cells of wheat roots

Aluminum (Al(3+))-dependent efflux of malate from root apices is a mechanism for Al(3+) tolerance in wheat (Triticum aestivum). The malate anions protect the sensitive root tips by chelating the toxic Al(3+) cations in the rhizosphere to form non-toxic complexes. Activation of malate-permeable channels in the plasma membrane could be critical in regulating this malate efflux. We examined this by investigating Al(3+)-activated channels in protoplasts from root apices of near-isogenic wheat differing in Al(3+) tolerance at a single locus. Using whole-cell patch clamp we found that Al(3+) stimulated an electrical current carried by anion efflux across the plasma membrane in the Al(3+)-tolerant (ET8) and Al(3+)-sensitive (ES8) genotypes. This current occurred more frequently, had a greater current density, and remained active for longer in ET8 protoplasts than for ES8 protoplasts. The Al(3+)-activated current exhibited higher permeability to malate(2-) than to Cl(-) (P(mal)/P(Cl) > or = 2.6) and was inhibited by anion channel antagonists, niflumate and diphenylamine-2-carboxylic acid. In ET8, but not ES8, protoplasts an outward-rectifying K(+) current was activated in the presence of Al(3+) when cAMP was included in the pipette solution. These findings provide evidence that the difference in Al(3+)-induced malate efflux between Al(3+)-tolerant and Al(3+)-sensitive genotypes lies in the differing capacity for Al(3+) to activate malate permeable channels and cation channels for sustained malate release.     

A wheat gene encoding an aluminum-activated malate transporter

The major constraint to plant growth in acid soils is the presence of toxic aluminum (Al) cations, which inhibit root elongation. The enhanced Al tolerance exhibited by some cultivars of wheat is associated with the Al-dependent efflux of malate from root apices. Malate forms a stable complex with Al that is harmless to plants and, therefore, this efflux of malate forms the basis of a hypothesis to explain Al tolerance in wheat. Here, we report on the cloning of a wheat gene, ALMT1 (aluminum-activated malate transporter), that co-segregates with Al tolerance in F2 and F3 populations derived from crosses between near-isogenic wheat lines that differ in Al tolerance. The ALMT1 gene encodes a membrane protein, which is constitutively expressed in the root apices of the Al-tolerant line at greater levels than in the near-isogenic but Al-sensitive line. Heterologous expression of ALMT1 in Xenopus oocytes, rice and cultured tobacco cells conferred an Al-activated malate efflux. Additionally, ALMT1 increased the tolerance of tobacco cells to Al treatment. These findings demonstrate that ALMT1 encodes an Al-activated malate transporter that is capable of conferring Al tolerance to plant cells.     

The BnALMT1 and BnALMT2 genes from rape encode aluminum-activated malate transporters that enhance the aluminum resistance of plant cells

The release of organic anions from roots can protect plants from aluminum (Al) toxicity and help them overcome phosphorus (P) deficiency. Our previous findings showed that Al treatment induced malate and citrate efflux from rape (Brassica napus) roots, and that P deficiency did not induce the efflux. Since this response is similar to the malate efflux from wheat (Triticum aestivum) that is controlled by the TaALMT1 gene, we investigated whether homologs of TaALMT1 are present in rape and whether they are involved in the release of organic anions. We isolated two TaALMT1 homologs from rape designated BnALMT1 and BnALMT2 (B. napus Al-activated malate transporter). The expression of these genes was induced in roots, but not shoots, by Al treatment but P deficiency had no effect. Several other cations (lanthanum, ytterbium, and erbium) also increased BnALMT1 and BnALMT2 expression in the roots. The function of the BnALMT1 and BnALMT2 proteins was investigated by heterologous expression in cultured tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) cells and in Xenopus laevis oocytes. Both transfection systems showed an enhanced capacity for malate efflux but not citrate efflux, when exposed to Al. Smaller malate fluxes were also activated by ytterbium and erbium treatment. Transgenic tobacco cells grew significantly better than control cells following an 18 h treatment with Al, indicating that the expression of BnALMT1 and BnALMT2 increased the resistance of these plant cells to Al stress. This report demonstrates that homologs of the TaALMT1 gene from wheat perform similar functions in other species.     

Probing the “malate hypothesis” of differential aluminum tolerance in wheat by using other rhizotoxic ions as proxies for Al

An Al-stimulated efflux of malate from the root apex has been proposed as the primary mechanism whereby some wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) genotypes demonstrate marked resistance to the rhixotoxic metal Al. Appealing in its simplicity, the model has not been unequivocally validated, and suffers from some significant discrepancies between estimated, steady-state concentrations of malate at the root surface and concentrations that are necessary to explain the resistance of the superior genotypes. Using two other rhizotoxic ions that are also chelated by malate, Cu(II) and La(III), we specifically probed whether the quantities of malate released by tolerant genotypes could effectively detoxify Al. Experiments with exogenous additions of malate to solution showed that ≥200 μM malate is required to account for the difference between Scout 66 (Al-sensitive) and Atlas 66 (Al-tolerant) wheats, and that this level of malate can also partially alleviate the toxicities of Cu and La. When simultaneously exposed to a mildly rhizotoxic level of Al (25 μM) to induce malate efflux, Atlas exhibited a pronounced reduction in sensitivity to Cu. When, La was used as the proxy ion, however, no such Al-induced tolerance to La was observed, a result that refutes the significance of malate efflux to Al tolerance. Additional experiments using Al, Cu, and La in combination suggested that a trivalent ion can alleviate Cu toxicity directly (i.e. via competition for apoplastic binding), providing an alternative explanation for the ability of Al to detoxify Cu in Atlas. Using a weight-of-evidence approach, we argue that malate efflux plays at most a minor role in the differential Al tolerance of wheat, and that a more integrative, multifaceted model of tolerance is needed. Received: 14 August 1997 / Accepted: 26 November 1997     

Cytotoxic thio-malate is transported by both an aluminum-responsive malate efflux pathway in wheat and the MAE1 malate permease in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

Aluminum (Al) tolerance in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) is mainly achieved by malate efflux, which is regulated by the expression of the recently identified gene, presumably encoding an Al-activated malate efflux transporter (ALMT1). However, the transport mechanism is not fully understood, partly as a result of the rapid turnover of its substrate. We developed a tool to study malate transport in wheat by screening biological compounds using the well-characterized Schizosaccharomyces pombe malate transporter (SpMAE1). Expression of SpMAE1 in both S. pombe and Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which has no SpMAE1 homologue, caused hypersensitivity to thio-malic acid. This hypersensitivity was prominent at pH 3.5, but not pH 4.5, and was accompanied by an increase in thiol content, indicating that SpMAE1 mediates the uptake of thio-malic acid at a specific low pH. In wheat, root apices were able to accumulate thio-malic acid without growth reduction at pH values above 4.2. Pretreatment of root apices with thio-malic acid followed by Al treatment induced thio-malate efflux. Al-induced thio-malate efflux was much higher in Al-resistant cultivars/genotypes than in Al-sensitive ones, and was accompanied by a decrease in thiol-content. Thio-malate efflux in the Al-resistant cultivar was slightly activated by lanthanum or ytterbium ion. Thio-malic acid did not alleviate the Al-induced inhibition of root elongation in wheat. Taken together, our results suggest that thio-malate acts as an analogue for malate in malate transport systems in wheat and yeast, and that it may be a useful tool for the analysis of malate transport involved in Al-tolerance and of other organic ion transport processes.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at and is accessible for authorized users.     

Al-induced efflux of organic acid anions is poorly associated with internal organic acid metabolism in triticale roots

The secretion of organic acid anions from roots has been identified as a mechanism of resistance to Al. However, the process leading to the secretion of organic acid anions is poorly understood. The effect of Al on organic acid metabolism was investigated in two lines of triticale (xTriticosecale Wittmark) differing in Al-induced secretion of malate and citrate and in Al resistance. The site of Al-induced secretion of citrate and malate from a resistant line was localized to the root apices (terminal 5 mm). The levels of citrate (root apices and mature root segments) and malate (mature segments only) in roots increased during exposure to Al, but similar changes were observed in both triticale genotypes. The in vitro activities of four enzymes involved in malate and citrate metabolism (citrate synthase, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, malate dehydrogenase, and NADP-isocitrate dehydrogenase) were similar for sensitive and resistant lines in both root apices and mature root segments. The response of these enzymes to pH did not differ between tolerant and sensitive lines or in the presence and absence of Al. Moreover, cytoplasmic and vacuolar pH were not affected by exposure to Al in either line. Together, these results indicate that the Al-dependent efflux of organic acid anions from the roots of triticale is not regulated by their internal levels in the roots or by the capacity of the root cells to synthesize malate and citrate.     

Possible Involvement of Al-Induced Electrical Signals in Al Tolerance in Wheat

The relationship between Al-induced depolarization of root-cell transmembrane electrical potentials (Em) and Al tolerance in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) was investigated. Al exposure induced depolarizations of Em in the Al-tolerant wheat cultivars Atlas and ET3, but not in the Al-sensitive wheat cultivars Scout and ES3. The depolarizations of Em occured in root cap cells and as far back as 10 mm from the root tip. The depolarization was specific to Al3+; no depolarization was observed when roots were exposed to the rhizotoxic trivalent cation La3+. The Al-induced depolarization occurred in the presence of anion-channel antagonists that blocked the release of malate, indicating that the depolarization is not due to the electrogenic efflux of malate2-. K+-induced depolarizations in the root cap were of the same magnitude as Al-induced depolarizations, but did not trigger malate release, indicating that Al-induced depolarization of root cap cell membrane potentials is probably linked to, but is not sufficient to trigger, malate release.     

Wheat genotypes differing in aluminum tolerance differ in their growth response to CO2 enrichment in acid soils

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is a major factor limiting plant growth in acid soils. Elevated atmospheric CO₂ [CO₂] enhances plant growth. However, there is no report on the effect of elevated [CO₂] on growth of plant genotypes differing in Al tolerance grown in acid soils. We investigated the effect of short‐term elevated [CO₂] on growth of Al‐tolerant (ET8) and Al‐sensitive (ES8) wheat plants and malate exudation from root apices by growing them in acid soils under ambient [CO₂] and elevated [CO₂] using open‐top chambers. Exposure of ET8 plants to elevated [CO₂] enhanced root biomass only. In contrast, shoot biomass of ES8 was enhanced by elevated [CO₂]. Given that exudation of malate to detoxify apoplastic Al is a mechanism for Al tolerance in wheat plants, ET8 plants exuded greater amounts of malate from root apices than ES8 plants under both ambient and elevated [CO₂]. These results indicate that elevated [CO₂] has no effect on malate exudation in both ET8 and ES8 plants. These novel findings have important implications for our understanding how plants respond to elevated [CO₂] grown in unfavorable edaphic conditions in general and in acid soils in particular.     

Aluminium triggers malate-independent potassium release via ion channels from the root apex in wheat

The regulatory mechanisms for the aluminium (Al)-induced efflux of K(+) and malate from the root apex of Al-resistant wheat ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Atlas) were characterized. Treatment with 20 mM tetraethylammonium (TEA) chloride, a K(+)-channel inhibitor, blocked the Al-induced K(+) efflux by 65%, but blocked the Al-induced malate efflux only slightly. Lanthanum (La(3+)) or ytterbium (Yb(3+)) strongly inhibited the K(+) efflux, but slightly increased malate efflux. These lanthanides applied together with Al did not affect the Al-induced malate efflux, but reduced the Al-induced K(+) efflux by 57% for La(3+) and by 35% for Yb(3+). By contrast, pretreatment with 50 microM niflumic acid, an anion-channel inhibitor, strongly suppressed the Al-induced malate efflux, but did not affect the Al-induced K(+) efflux. The efflux of K(+) uncoupled with that of malate resulted in the alkalization of intracellular pH in the root apex, suggesting that the release of K(+) coupled with malate plays an important role in stabilizing intracellular pH. Copper (Cu(2+)) induced the release of K(+) via a TEA-insensitive pathway without the release of malate in both Al-resistant and Al-sensitive (cultivar Scout) wheat. Simultaneous application of Al and Cu(2+) to the root apices resulted in TEA-sensitive K(+) efflux in Atlas but not in Scout, suggesting that Al competes with Cu(2+) for K(+) efflux. Taken together, these results suggest that Al-induced K(+) efflux is mediated by both TEA- and lanthanide-sensitive K(+) channels, although this induction is not a prerequisite for the induction of the release of malate.     

Molecular characterization and mapping of ALMT1, the aluminium-tolerance gene of bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.).

The major aluminum (Al) tolerance gene in wheat ALMT1 confers. An Al-activated efflux of malate from root apices. We determined the genomic structure of the ALMT1 gene and found it consists of 6 exons interrupted by 5 introns. Sequencing a range of wheat genotypes identified 3 alleles for ALMT1, 1 of which was identical to the ALMT1 gene from an Aegilops tauschii accession. The ALMT1 gene was mapped to chromosome 4DL using 'Chinese Spring' deletion lines, and loss of ALMT1 coincided with the loss of both Al tolerance and Al-activated malate efflux. Aluminium tolerance in each of 5 different doubled-haploid populations was found to be conditioned by a single major gene. When ALMT1 was polymorphic between the parental lines, QTL and linkage analyses indicated that ALMT1 mapped to chromosome 4DL and cosegregated with Al tolerance. In 2 populations examined, Al tolerance also segregated with a greater capacity for Al-activated malate efflux. Aluminium tolerance was not associated with a particular coding allele for ALMT1, but was significantly correlated with the relative level of ALMT1 expression. These findings suggest that the Al tolerance in a diverse range of wheat genotypes is primarily conditioned by ALMT1.     

LaALMT1 mediates malate release from phosphorus-deficient white lupin root tips and metal root to shoot translocation

Under phosphorus (P) deficiency, Lupinus albus (white lupin) releases large amounts of organic acid anions from specialized root structures, so-called cluster or proteoid roots, to mobilize and acquire sparingly soluble phosphates from a restricted soil volume. The molecular mechanisms underlying this release and its regulation are, however, poorly understood. Here, we identified a gene belonging to the aluminium (Al)-activated malate transporter (ALMT) family that specifically contributes to malate, but not citrate release. This gene, LaALMT1, was most prominently expressed in the root apices under P deficiency, including those of cluster roots and was also detected in the root stele. Contrary to several ALMT homologs in other species, the expression was not stimulated, but moderately repressed by Al. Aluminium-independent malate currents were recorded from the plasma membrane localized LaALMT1 expressed in Xenopus oocytes. In composite lupins with transgenic roots, LaALMT1 was efficiently mutated by CRISPR-Cas9, leading to diminished malate efflux and lower xylem sap malate concentrations. When grown in an alkaline P-deficient soil, mutant shoot phosphate concentrations were similar, but iron and potassium concentrations were diminished in old leaves, suggesting a role for ALMT1 in metal root to shoot translocation, a function that was also supported by growth in hydroponics.     

Differential aluminum tolerance in soybean: An evaluation of the role of organic acids

The role of organic acids in aluminum (Al) tolerance has been the object of intensive research. In the present work, we evaluated the roles of organic acid exudation and concentrations at the root tip on Al tolerance of soybean. Exposing soybean seedlings to Al³⁺ activities up to 4.7 μ M in solution led to different degrees of restriction of primary root elongation. Al tolerance among genotypes was associated with citrate accumulation and excretion into the external media. Citrate and malate efflux increased in all genotypes during the first 6 h of Al exposure, but only citrate efflux in Al-tolerant genotypes was sustained for an extended period. Tolerance to Al was correlated with the concentration of citrate in root tips of 8 genotypes with a range of Al sensitivities (r²=0.75). The fluorescent stain lumogallion indicated that more Al accumulated in root tips of the Al-sensitive genotype Young than the Al-tolerant genotype PI 416937, suggesting that the sustained release of citrate from roots of the tolerant genotype was involved in Al exclusion. The initial stimulation of citrate and malate excretion and accumulation in the tip of all genotypes suggested the involvement of additional tolerance mechanisms. The experiments included an examination of Al effects on lateral root elongation. Extension of lateral roots was more sensitive to Al than that of tap roots, and lateral root tips accumulated more Al and had lower levels of citrate.     

Aluminum Tolerance in Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) (II. Aluminum-Stimulated Excretion of Malic Acid from Root Apices)

We investigated the role of organic acids in conferring Al tolerance in near-isogenic wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) lines differing in Al tolerance at the Al tolerance locus (Alt1). Addition of Al to nutrient solutions stimulated excretion of malic and succinic acids from roots of wheat seedlings, and Al-tolerant genotypes excreted 5- to 10-fold more malic acid than Al-sensitive genotypes. Malic acid excretion was detectable after 15 min of exposure to 200 [mu]M Al, and the amount excreted increased linearly over 24 h. The amount of malic acid excreted was dependent on the external Al concentration, and excretion was stimulated by as little as 10 [mu]M Al. Malic acid added to nutrient solutions was able to protect Al-sensitive seedlings from normally phytotoxic Al concentrations. Root apices (terminal 3-5 mm of root) were the primary source of the malic acid excreted. Root apices of Al-tolerant and Al-sensitive seedlings contained similar amounts of malic acid before and after a 2-h exposure to 200 [mu]M Al. During this treatment, Al-tolerant seedlings excreted about four times the total amount of malic acid initially present within root apices, indicating that continual synthesis of malic acid was occurring. Malic acid excretion was specifically stimulated by Al, and neither La, Fe, nor the absence of Pi was able to elicit this response. There was a consistent correlation of Al tolerance with high rates of malic acid excretion stimulated by Al in a population of seedlings segregating for Al tolerance. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that the Alt1 locus in wheat encodes an Al tolerance mechanism based on Al-stimulated excretion of malic acid.     

Two functionally distinct members of the MATE (multi‐drug and toxic compound extrusion) family of transporters potentially underlie two major aluminum tolerance QTLs in maize

Crop yields are significantly reduced by aluminum (Al) toxicity on acidic soils, which comprise up to 50% of the world’s arable land. Al‐activated release of ligands (such as organic acids) from the roots is a major Al tolerance mechanism in plants. In maize, Al‐activated root citrate exudation plays an important role in tolerance. However, maize Al tolerance is a complex trait involving multiple genes and physiological mechanisms. Recently, transporters from the MATE family have been shown to mediate Al‐activated citrate exudation in a number of plant species. Here we describe the cloning and characterization of two MATE family members in maize, ZmMATE1 and ZmMATE2, which co‐localize to major Al tolerance QTL. Both genes encode plasma membrane proteins that mediate significant anion efflux when expressed in Xenopus oocytes. ZmMATE1 expression is mostly concentrated in root tissues, is up‐regulated by Al and is significantly higher in Al‐tolerant maize genotypes. In contrast, ZmMATE2 expression is not specifically localized to any particular tissue and does not respond to Al. [¹⁴C]‐citrate efflux experiments in oocytes demonstrate that ZmMATE1 is a citrate transporter. In addition, ZmMATE1 expression confers a significant increase in Al tolerance in transgenic Arabidopsis. Our data suggests that ZmMATE1 is a functional homolog of the Al tolerance genes recently characterized in sorghum, barley and Arabidopsis, and is likely to underlie the largest maize Al tolerance QTL found on chromosome 6. However, ZmMATE2 most likely does not encode a citrate transporter, and could be involved in a novel Al tolerance mechanism.     

Aluminum Tolerance in Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) (I. Uptake and Distribution of Aluminum in Root Apices)

We investigated the uptake and distribution of Al in root apices of near-isogenic wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) lines differing in Al tolerance at a single locus (Alt1: aluminum tolerance). Seedlings were grown in nutrient solution that contained 100 [mu]M Al, and the roots were subsequently stained with hematoxylin, a compound that binds Al in vitro to form a colored complex. Root apices of Al-sensitive genotypes stained after short exposures to Al (10 min and 1 h), whereas apices of Al-tolerant seedlings showed less intense staining after equivalent exposures. Differential staining preceded differences observed in either root elongation or total Al concentrations of root apices (terminal 2-3 mm of root). After 4 h of exposure to 100 [mu]M Al in nutrient solution, Al-sensitive genotypes accumulated more total Al in root apices than Al-tolerant genotypes, and the differences became more marked with time. Analysis of freeze-dried root apices by x-ray microanalysis showed that Al entered root apices of Al-sensitive plants and accumulated in the epidermal layer and in the cortical layer immediately below the epidermis. Long-term exposure of sensitive apices to Al (24 h) resulted in a distribution of Al coinciding with the absence of K. Quantitation of Al in the cortical layer showed that sensitive apices accumulated 5- to 10-fold more Al than tolerant apices exposed to Al solutions for equivalent times. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that Alt1 encodes a mechanism that excludes Al from root apices.     

Possible involvement of protein phosphorylation in aluminum-responsive malate efflux from wheat root apex

In many plants, efflux of organic anions from roots has been proposed as one of the major Al resistance mechanisms. However it remains unknown how plants regulate efflux of organic anions in response to Al. In this study, the regulatory mechanisms of Al-responsive malate efflux in wheat (Triticum aestivum) were characterized focusing on the role of protein phosphorylation. Al-resistant wheat (cv Atlas) initiated malate efflux at 5 min after addition of Al, and this response was sensitive to temperature. K-252a, a broad range inhibitor of protein kinases, effectively blocked the Al-induced malate efflux accompanied with an increased accumulation of Al and intensified Al-induced root growth inhibition. A transient activation of a 48-kD protein kinase and an irreversible repression of a 42-kD protein kinase were observed preceding the initiation of malate efflux, and these changes were canceled by K-252a. Malate efflux was accompanied with a rapid decrease in the contents of organic anions in the root apex, such as citrate, succinate, and malate but with no change in the contents of inorganic anions such as chloride, nitrate, and phosphate. These results suggest that protein phosphorylation is involved in the Al-responsive malate efflux in the wheat root apex and that the organic anion-specific channel might be a terminal target that responds to Al signaling mediated by phosphorylation.