Comparison of the transposon-like structures encoding clindamycin resistance in Bacteroides R-plasmids

The R-plasmids pBF4, pBFTM10, and pBI136 encode transmissible clindamycin resistance (Ccr) in Bacteroides spp. These plasmids are distinct replicons but the regions implicated in Ccr share some homology and appear to have a transposon-like structure. To better understand the mechanism of dissemination and to locate the Ccr determinant(s), the genetic and structural properties of the Ccr regions of each plasmid were compared and contrasted. For this work a single EcoRI restriction fragment containing the Ccr region from each plasmid was cloned into pBR322 in Escherichia coli. Results of restriction mapping and heteroduplex experiments showed that the pBF4 EcoRI-D and pBFTM10 EcoRI-B fragments shared more than 90% base sequence homology but that the EcoRI-C fragment of pBI136 had diverged significantly. The pBI136 fragment also did not confer tetracycline resistance in E. coli as shown for the pBF4 EcoRI-D fragment (D.G. Guiney, P. Hasegawa, and C. E. Davis, 1984, Plasmid 11, 248-252). Heteroduplex experiments showed that the pBI136 EcoRI-C and pBF4 EcoRI-D fragments shared a 1.2-kb region of homology attributed to a directly repeated sequence which bounds the Ccr region. Southern hybridization studies indicated that an additional 0.85 kb of the pBI136 EcoRI-C fragment was homologous to the EcoRI-D fragment of pBF4. This region was characterized by its sequential restriction endonuclease sites for HindIII, AvaII, and DdeI, and it is proposed that the Ccr gene(s) resides in this area.     

Development and use of cloning systems for Bacteroides fragilis: cloning of a plasmid-encoded clindamycin resistance determinant.

Chimeric plasmids able to replicate in Bacteroides fragilis or in B. fragilis and Escherichia coli were constructed and used as molecular cloning vectors. The 2.7-kilobase pair (kb) cryptic Bacteroides plasmid pBI143 and the E. coli cloning vector pUC19 were the two replicons used for these constructions. Selection of the plasmid vectors in B. fragilis was made possible by ligation to a restriction fragment bearing the clindamycin resistance (Ccr) determinant from a Bacteroides R plasmid, pBF4;Ccr was not expressed in E. coli. The chimeric plasmids ranged from 5.3 to 7.3 kb in size and contained at least 10 unique restriction enzyme recognition sites suitable for cloning. Transformation of B. fragilis with the chimeric plasmids was dependent upon the source of the DNA; generally 10(5) transformants micrograms-1 of DNA were recovered when plasmid purified from B. fragilis was used. When the source of DNA was E. coli, there was a 1,000-fold decrease in the number of transformants obtained. Two of the shuttle plasmids not containing the pBF4 Ccr determinant were used in an analysis of the transposon-like structure encoding Ccr in the R plasmid pBI136. This gene encoding Ccr was located on a 0.85-kb EcoRI-HaeII fragment and cloned nonselectively in E. coli. Recombinants containing the gene inserted in both orientations at the unique ClaI site within the pBI143 portion of the shuttle plasmids could transform B. fragilis to clindamycin resistance. These results together with previous structural data show that the gene encoding Ccr lies directly adjacent to one of the repeated sequences of the pBI136 transposon-like structure.     

Characterization of Bacteroides ovatus plasmid pBI136 and structure of its clindamycin resistance region.

Genetic and physical analyses were used to characterize the Bacteroides ovatus R plasmid pBI136. Results from restriction endonuclease cleavage studies were used to construct a physical map of the plasmid for the enzymes EcoRI, BamHI, ClaI, XbaI, SalI, and SmaI. Based on the sizes of restriction fragments generated in these studies, the plasmid was estimated to be 80.6 kilobase pairs (kb). A 7.2-kb region of the plasmid required for resistance to lincosamide and macrolide (LM) antibiotics was mapped by analysis of spontaneously occurring LM-sensitive deletion derivatives. Hybridization studies showed that this region and an adjoining 2.9-kb EcoRI fragment were responsible for the previously reported homology among Bacteroides plasmids pBF4, pBFTM10, and pBI136. Within this region of homology, 0.5 kb was attributed to a directly repeated sequence thought to bound the LM resistance determinant on pBF4 and pBFTM10. Two pBI136 EcoRI fragments spanning the putative LM resistance region were cloned in Escherichia coli, and heteroduplex analysis of these recombinant plasmids revealed the presence of a 1.2-kb directly repeated sequence. These results suggested that the pBI136 LM resistance determinant resides on an 8.4-kb segment of DNA containing 6.0 kb of intervening DNA sequences bounded by a 1.2-kb directly repeated sequence.     

Expression in Escherichia coli of cryptic tetracycline resistance genes from Bacteroides R plasmids

The putative clindamycin resistance region of the Bacteroides fragilis R plasmid pBF4 was cloned in the vector R300B in Escherichia coli. This 3.8-kb EcoRI D fragment from pBF4 expressed noninducible tetracycline resistance in E. coli under aerobic but not anaerobic growth conditions. The fragment does not express tetracycline resistance in Bacteroides, a strict anaerobe. The separate tetracycline resistance transfer system in the Bacteroides host strain V479-1 has no homology to the cryptic determinant on pBF4. In addition, this aerobic tetracycline resistance determinant is not homologous to the three major plasmid mediated tetracycline resistance regions found in facultative gram-negative bacteria, represented by R100, RK2, and pBR322. A similar cryptic tetracycline resistance fragment was cloned from pCP1, a separate clindamycin resistance plasmid from Bacteroides that shares homology with the EcoRI D fragment of pBF4. This study identifies cryptic drug resistance determinants in Bacteroides that are expressed when inserted into an aerobically growing organism.     

Physical characterization of Bacteroides fragilis R plasmid pBF4

Bacteroides fragilis V479-1 has previously been shown to harbor a self-transmissible 27 X 10(6)-dalton plasmid (pBF4) which confers lincosamide-macrolide resistance. The present study has focused on the physical properties of pBF4. The plasmid was found to be present in 1 to 2 copies per chromosomal equivalent. pBF4 was genetically stable, although spontaneously occurring plasmidless segregants could be detected at low frequency (approximately 1%). This frequency was unaffected by growth of cells in ethidium bromide. About one-third of all spontaneously occurring macrolide-lincosamide-sensitive clones of strain V479-1 were found to contain pBF4 molecules that carried deletions. Ten independently obtained deletion derivatives of pBF4 from lincosamide-macrolide-sensitive strains were compared with the parental pBF4 by restriction endonuclease cleavage analysis. A restriction site map of pBF4 was constructed, and the location of the deletions was approximated. Self-annealed pBF4 molecules, examined by electron microscopy, revealed the presence of two pairs of inverted repeat (IR) sequences on the plasmid. IR-1 was about 400 base pairs in length, and its two component members were separated by an intervening sequence of about 15 kilobases. IR-2 was about 75 base pairs in length, and its component members were separated by 4.2 kilobases. Each of the deletions of pBF4 studied had a terminus at or near the same IR-2 sequence.     

Evidence that the clindamycin-erythromycin resistance gene of Bacteroides plasmid pBF4 is on a transposable element.

We constructed a shuttle vector, pE5-2, which can replicate in both Bacteroides spp. and Escherichia coli. pE5-2 contains a cryptic Bacteroides plasmid (pB8-51), a 3.8-kilobase (kb) EcoRI-D fragment from the 41-kb Bacteroides fragilis plasmid pBF4, and RSF1010, an IncQ E. coli plasmid. pE5-2 was mobilized by R751, an IncP E. coli plasmid, between E. coli strains with a frequency of 5 X 10(-2) to 3.8 X 10(-1) transconjugants per recipient. R751 also mobilized pE5-2 from E. coli donors to Bacteroides uniformis 0061RT and Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron 5482 with a frequency of 0.9 X 10(-6) to 2.5 X 10(-6). The Bacteroides transconjugants contained only pE5-2 and were resistant to clindamycin and erythromycin. Thus, the gene for clindamycin and erythromycin resistance must be located within the Eco RI-D fragment of BF4. A second recombinant plasmid, pSS-2, which contained 33 kb of pBF4 (including the EcoRI-D fragment and contiguous regions) could also be mobilized by R751 between E. coli strains. In some transconjugants, a 5.5-kb (+/- 0.3 kb) segment of the pBF4 portion of pSS2 was inserted into one of several sites on R751. In some other transconjugants this same 5.5-kb segment was integrated into the E. coli chromosome. This segment could transfer a second time onto R751. Transfer was RecA independent. The transferred segment included the entire EcoRI-D fragment, and thus the clindamycin-erythromycin resistance determinant, from pBF4.     

Homology between clindamycin resistance plasmids in Bacteroides

Two different species of clindamycin-resistant Bacteroides were isolated from the same infection. One isolate contained a single 15-kb plasmid (pCP1) which encoded transferable clindamycin resistance. pCP1 appears similar to the Bacteroides clindamycin resistance plasmid pBFTM10 isolated independently by F.P. Tally, D.R. Snydman, M.J. Shimell, and M.H. Malamy (1982, J. Bacteriol. 151, 686-691). The second strain had a 10-kb plasmid (pCP2) but did not transfer resistance. DNA hybridization studies revealed that pCP1 shares a 5-kb region of homology with the B. fragilis R plasmid pBF4 studied by R.A. Welch and F.L. Macrina (1981, J. Bacteriol. 145, 867-872). This region in both plasmids was shown to be bounded by homologous direct repeats and contains the putative clindamycin resistance determinant. pCP1 and pCP2 were found to share extensive homology but sequences homologous to the clindamycin resistance region were missing from pCP2 and found instead in the whole cell DNA of the host strain. These results identify a transposon-like structure on Bacteroides clindamycin resistance plasmids.     

Transposition of Tn4551 in Bacteroides fragilis: identification and properties of a new transposon from Bacteroides spp.

Tn4551, a clindamycin resistance (Ccr) transposon from the R plasmid pBI136, was cloned onto an Escherichia coli-Bacteroides shuttle vector which could replicate normally in E. coli but was maintained unstably in Bacteroides fragilis. To aid in cloning and to ensure maintenance of Tn4551 in E. coli, a kanamycin resistance determinant (Kmr) was inserted in the transposon. The transposon-bearing shuttle vector pFD197 was transformed into B. fragilis 638, and putative insertions of Tn4551::Kmr were identified by screening for resistance to clindamycin and plasmid content. Southern hybridization analyses were used to verify integration of the transposon in the B. fragilis chromosome, and the frequency of insertion was estimated at 7.8 X 10(-5) events per generation. In 57% of the isolates tested a second integration event also occurred. This second insertion apparently involved just a single copy of the 1.2-kilobase repeat sequence which flanks the transposon. In addition, Tn4551::Kmr appeared to function as a transposon in E. coli. Evidence for this was obtained by the isolation of transposon insertions into the bacteriophage P1 genome. Finally, the transposon vector, pFD197, could be mobilized to other B. fragilis strains in which transposition was detected. Mobilization from the strain 638 background was via a conjugation like process, but occurred in the absence of known conjugative elements or other detectable plasmids. This result suggested the presence of a host-encoded transfer system in this B. fragilis strain.     

Mobilization of Bacteroides plasmids by Bacteroides conjugal elements.

A 4.2-kilobase cryptic Bacteroides plasmid, pB8-51, is found in several colonic Bacteroides species. To determine whether pB8-51 is mobilized by any of the known Bacteroides conjugal elements, we constructed an Escherichia coli-Bacteroides shuttle vector, pVAL-1, which contains pB8-51. We constructed Bacteroides uniformis 0061 derivatives which carry pVAL-1 and various Bacteroides conjugal elements. The Bacteroides conjugal elements tested were six conjugal tetracycline resistance (Tcr) elements (which appear to be chromosomal), i.e., Tcr ERL, Tcr V479, Tcr Emr ERL, Tcr Emr 12256, Tcr Emr DOT, and Tcr Emr CEST, and the conjugal erythromycin resistance (Emr) plasmid pBF4. These Tcr conjugal elements have not been extensively characterized, except for Tcr ERL. All six Tcr elements tested mobilized pVAL-1 at high frequency (10(-3) to 10(-5)) from one Bacteroides strain to another or from a Bacteroides strain to E. coli. Pregrowth of the donors (containing one of the Tcr elements and pVAL-1) in 1 microgram of tetracycline per ml enhanced the transfer of pVAL-1 by 20- to 10,000-fold, depending on which Tcr element was present in the donor. An Ems derivative of pBF4 (pBF4 delta E2) mobilized pVAL-1 from one Bacteroides strain to another at a frequency of 10(-4) but did not mobilize pVAL-1 from a Bacteroides strain to E. coli as efficiently. Thus the Tcr conjugal elements and pBF4 recognize a mobilization region on pB8-51.     

Hybridization studies reveal homologies between pBF4 and pBFTM10, Two clindamycin-erythromycin resistance transfer plasmids of Bacteroides fragilis

Two clindamycin-erythromycin resistance transfer factors of Bacteroides fragilis, pBF4 and pBFTM10, were analyzed for regions of DNA homology. Although the plasmids were derived from different clinical isolates of B. fragilis and have different sizes, they showed homology in the clindamycin-erythromycin resistance region; no homology could be detected outside of this region.     

Tn4400, a compound transposon isolated from Bacteroides fragilis, functions in Escherichia coli.

Transfer factor pBFTM10, isolated from the obligate anaerobic bacterium Bacteroides fragilis, carries a clindamycin resistance determinant which we have suggested is part of a transposable element. DNA homologous to this determinant is found in many Clnr Bacteroides isolates, either in the chromosome or on plasmids. We have now established that Ccr resides on a transposon, Tn4400. In addition to the Ccr determinant that functions under anaerobic conditions in B. fragilis, Tn4400 also carries a determinant for tetracycline resistance (Tcr) which only functions in Escherichia coli under aerobic conditions. The presence of Tn4400 on pBFTM10 does not confer tetracycline resistance on B. fragilis cells containing it. DNA from pBFTM10 was cloned in E. coli, with pDG5 as the cloning vector, to form pGAT500. Using a mobilization assay involving pGAT500 and an F factor derivative, pOX38, we determined that a 5.6-kilobase region of pBFTM10 DNA was capable of mediating replicon fusion and transposition. Most of the mobilization products resulted from inverse transposition reactions, while some were the result of true cointegrate formation. Analysis of the cointegrate molecules showed that three were formed by the action of one of the ends of Tn4400 (IS4400), and one was formed by the action of the whole element (Tn4400). The cointegrate molecule carrying intact copies of Tn4400 at the junction of the two plasmids could resolve to yield an unaltered donor plasmid (pGAT500) and a conjugal plasmid containing a copy of Tn4400 or a copy of one insertion sequence element (pOX38::Tn4400 or pOX38::IS4400). Thus, Tn4400 is a compound transposon containing active insertion sequence elements as directly repeated sequences at its ends.     

Tn4351 transposes in Bacteroides spp. and mediates the integration of plasmid R751 into the Bacteroides chromosome.

The gene for resistance to erythromycin and clindamycin, which is carried on the conjugative Bacteroides plasmid, pBF4, has been shown previously to be part of an element (Tn4351) that transposes in Escherichia coli. We have now introduced Tn4351 into Bacteroides uniformis 0061 on the following two suicide vectors: (i) the broad-host-range IncP plasmid R751 (R751::Tn4351) and (ii) pSS-2, a chimeric plasmid which contains 33 kilobases of pBF4 (including Tn4351) cloned into the IncQ plasmid RSF1010 and which is mobilized by R751. When E. coli HB101, carrying either R751::Tn4351 or R751 and pSS-2, was mated with B. uniformis under aerobic conditions, Emr transconjugants were detected at a frequency of 10(-6) to 10(-5) (R751::Tn4351) or 10(-8) to 10(-6) (R751 and pSS-2). In matings involving pSS-2, all Emr transconjugants contained simple insertions of Tn4351 in the chromosome, whereas in matings involving R751::Tn4351, about half of the Emr transconjugants had R751 cointegrated with Tn4351 in the chromosome. Of the Emr transconjugants, 13% were auxotrophs. Bacteroides spp. which had R751 cointegrated with Tn4351 in the chromosome did not transfer R751 or Tn4351 to E. coli HB101 or to isogenic B. uniformis, nor did the intergrated R751 mobilize pE5-2, an E. coli-Bacteroides shuttle vector that contains a transfer origin that is recognized by R751.     

Family of shuttle vectors for ruminal Bacteroides

A family of shuttle plasmids was constructed for genetic transformation of Escherichia coli and of ruminal Bacteroides strains AR20 and AR29. Plasmids were based on the replicon from Bacteroides plasmid pBI191 and were designed for studies of chromosomal integration (pBA), for the identification and study of Bacteroides gene promoters (pPPR) and for the expression of heterologous genes in Bacteroides (pBAC). Electroporation efficiency of Bacteroides was up to 10(5) transformants/microg plasmid, depending on the source of the DNA. The largest plasmid, pBA, was maintained at approximately 8 copies per cell in AR20 and did not measurably alter in vitro growth of transformed cells. In the current work, pBA did not integrate into the chromosomes of AR20 or AR29. The ability of plasmid pPPR to select promoter sequences was demonstrated by removal and replacement of promoters that activate the clindamycin resistance gene. The suitability of pBAC for expression of heterologous genes was demonstrated by expression of the Moraxella species fluoroacetate dehalogenase gene H1 to give intracellular activity of 7 nmol fluoride released/min/mg soluble protein in AR20 and 4 nmol/min/mg in AR29. Spontaneous loss of pBAC under non-selective conditions was 0.11-0.165% per generation, significantly less than loss of the native Bacteroides plasmid pBI191, which was lost at 0.53% per generation.     

Genetic and molecular analysis of pIP417 and pIP419: Bacteroides plasmids encoding 5-nitroimidazole resistance.

This report describes a genetic and molecular analysis of two transferable Bacteroides plasmids, pIP417 and pIP419, which carry genetic determinants conferring low-level resistance to 5-nitroimidazoles. The restriction endonuclease cleavage sites for each plasmid were localized. The NiR genetic determinants of pIP417 and pIP419 plasmids have been cloned into the Bacteroides cloning vector pBI191 (C.J. Smith, J. Bacteriol. 164, 294-301, 1985) as PvuII and Sau3A fragments, respectively. Both inserts had different restriction sites and did not cross-hybridize by Southern blot analysis. Genetic data obtained by cloning into pBI191 clearly show that the PvuII-generated fragments A (Rep) and B (Mob) of pIP417 are involved in plasmid replication and transfer, respectively. Although encoding resistance to the same antibiotic, both plasmids appeared different with regard to the 5-nitroimidazole resistance and replication genetic determinants. However, they share a homology in a region involved, at least in one case, in plasmid transfer. Considering the spontaneous high level of resistance to 5-nitroimidazole in Escherichia coli, this work, based on direct gene cloning into Bacteroides, demonstrates the value of such an approach.     

Transferable lincosamide-macrolide resistance in Bacteroides.

Inter- and intraspecies transfer of resistance to clindamycin, lincomycin, and erythromycin in the strict anaerobe, Bacteroides, is described. This lincosamide-macrolide resistance was found to be specified by a 27 × 10⁶-dalton plasmid, designated pBF4, originally identified in a clinical Bacteroides fragilis isolate. Transfer of this plasmid to a strain of Bacteroides uniformis was demonstrated to occur by a deoxyribonuclease insensitive process which required cell-to-cell contact. Chloroform sterilized donor cell supernatants or filtrates of donor cells did not mediate resistance transfer. Transfer of the antibiotic resistance and pBF4 plasmid deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) were always coincident. Drug resistant progeny recovered from such matings were able to transfer the pBF4 plasmid and its associated resistance markers to a suitable B.fragilis recipient strain. Compared to interspecies matings, resistance transfer was 100- to 1000-fold greater between isogenic donor and recipient strains, suggesting the possibility of a host controlled restriction-modification system.     

DNA-DNA homology among lactose- and sucrose-fermenting transconjugants from Lactococcus lactis strains exhibiting reduced bacteriophage sensitivity.

DNA-DNA homology between a reduced bacteriophage sensitivity (Rbs+) probe and DNA from both Rbs+ and Rbs- Lactococcus lactis strains was examined. Homology was detected between the probe and five plasmids (pCI750, pCC34, pEB56, pNP2, and pJS88) isolated from lactose-positive Rbs+ transconjugants and between the probe and genomic DNA of a sucrose-positive Rbs+ transconjugant. Additionally, hybridizations conducted between the probe and plasmids reported to encode abortive bacteriophage infection indicated homology with pTR2030 but not with pBF61 and pGBK17. The results suggest that a common genetic determinant(s) may be present in a variety of lactococcal plasmids coding for Rbs+.     

DNA-DNA homology among lactose- and sucrose-fermenting transconjugants from Lactococcus lactis strains exhibiting reduced bacteriophage sensitivity

DNA-DNA homology between a reduced bacteriophage sensitivity (Rbs+) probe and DNA from both Rbs+ and Rbs- Lactococcus lactis strains was examined. Homology was detected between the probe and five plasmids (pCI750, pCC34, pEB56, pNP2, and pJS88) isolated from lactose-positive Rbs+ transconjugants and between the probe and genomic DNA of a sucrose-positive Rbs+ transconjugant. Additionally, hybridizations conducted between the probe and plasmids reported to encode abortive bacteriophage infection indicated homology with pTR2030 but not with pBF61 and pGBK17. The results suggest that a common genetic determinant(s) may be present in a variety of lactococcal plasmids coding for Rbs+.     

Complete nucleotide sequence of insertion element IS4351 from Bacteroides fragilis.

The nucleotide sequence and genetic analyses of one of the directly repeated sequences flanking the macrolide-lincosamide-streptogramin B drug resistance determinant, ermF, from the Bacteroides fragilis R plasmid, pBF4, suggested that this region is an insertion sequence (IS) element. This 1,155-base-pair element contained partially matched (20 of 25 base pairs) terminal-inverted repeats, overlapping, anti-parallel open reading frames, and nine promoterlike sequences, including three that were oriented outward. Analysis of this sequence revealed no significant nucleotide homology to 13 other known IS elements. Inasmuch as Southern blot hybridization analysis detected homologous sequences in chromosomal DNA and its G+C content (42 mol%) was similar to that of B. fragilis, the data suggested that this element is of Bacteroides origin. Transposition promoted by this element was demonstrated in recA E. coli. Recombinants were recovered by selecting for the activation of a promoterless chloramphenicol resistance gene on the plasmid pDH5110 and were characterized by restriction endonuclease mapping and Southern blot hybridization. We propose that this IS element be designated IS4351.     

Plasmid transformation of Bacteroides spp. by electroporation

Transformation of Bacteroides spp. with a variety of plasmid DNAs was accomplished using electroporation. The standard transformation assay system used to deduce the optimal electroporation parameters employed a 50-to 100-fold concentrated cell suspension of mid-logarithmic phase Bacteroides fragilis strain 638 and the 5.4-kb clindamycin resistance (Ccr) vector, pBI191. A variety of electroporation buffers were used successfully in transformation experiments but of these, 1 mM MgCl2 in 10% glycerol was superior. The incorporation of MgCl2 was essential for optimum viability prior to electroporation and for optimum transformation. Transformants were routinely obtained using 5-ms pulses over a range of field strengths from 5 to 12.5 kV/cm, with a maximum of greater than 10(6) micrograms-1 DNA at 12.5 kV/cm. The number of transformants increased linearly with respect to DNA concentration over the range 0.01-2 micrograms tested. Recovery of transformants required an expression period of up to 2.5 h following exposure to the electric field. This period, however, was dependent on the antibiotic resistance marker used for selection of transformants, with a significantly shorter incubation required when chloramphenicol rather than clindamycin was used in the selective medium. The effect of the DNA source on transformation was tested using the shuttle vector pFD288. Plasmid DNA isolated from Bacteroides uniformis, Bacteroides ovatus, or Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron transformed B. fragilis 638 at frequencies 7.5- to 12.5-fold less than those observed for controls with homologous DNA. Further reductions were seen with Escherichia coli purified pFD288, which transformed at 1000-fold lower frequencies. Finally, using homologous pFD288 or pBI191 isolated from strain 638, several strains of B. fragilis, B. uniformis, and B. ovatus were transformed successfully without modification of the standard assay system. Two strains each of B. thetaiotaomicron and Bacteroides ruminicola were not transformed using the methods described here.