Lymphocyte function in experimental African trypanosomiasis. IV. Immunosuppression and suppressor cells in the athymic nu/nu mouse

The role of T cells in the development and expression of antigen-nonspecific immunosuppression in experimental African trypanosomiasis was addressed. Nude ($\text{nu}\text{nu}$) C57BL/ 6 NIH mice and their thymus-bearing ($\text{nu}\text{+}$) littermates were infected with Trypanosoma rhodesiense and examined for suppression of splenic B-cell responses in vitro to the mitogen LPS. All animals developed splenic unresponsiveness to LPS. Further, both nu/nu and nu/ + infected mice displayed suppressor cell activity in their spleen cell populations upon transfer to normal uninfected mouse spleen cell cultures. On the basis of these findings we suggest that both the generalized immunosuppression and the development of suppressor cell activity in the spleens of mice infected with T. rhodesiense are T-independent processes.     

Trypanosoma cruzi: Responses by cells from infected mice to alloantigens

In unidirectional mixed lymphocyte cultures containing (as responders, stimulators, or regulators) spleen cells from mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi, alloantigen responses were less than in cultures containing normal spleen cells only. Depletion of plastic adherent cells from infected spleen cells (stimulators or regulators) reversed their inhibitory effect on normal spleen cells (responders); removal of adherent responder cells and/or B lymphocytes did not alter the low alloantigen responses of normal spleen cells (stimulated by infected spleen cells) or infected spleen cells (stimulated by normal spleen cells). Infected spleen cells were effective in regulating mixed lymphocyte cultures only when added at the initiation of the culture. Serum from infected mice suppressed mixed lymphocyte cultures containing responder spleen cells syngeneic to the serum donor if added up to 24 hr after initiation of cultures, whereas the “suppressor serum” had to be present at the initiation of cultures when responder cells were allogeneic to the serum donor. Cultures of infected spleen cells (whole or macrophage enriched) produced a factor which was suppressive when added to mixed lymphocyte cultures containing syngeneic responder cells at initiation. It is proposed that the serum suppressor substance regulates cell-mediated immune responses directly by suppressing the response-potential of cells and indirectly by triggering the release of a factor from adherent splenic cells which induces a hyporesponsive state in T lymphocytes.     

Lymphocyte function in experimental African trypanosomiasis. VII. Loss of antigen-nonspecific suppressor-T-cell activity

The extent of immunosuppression occurring in mice infected with the pathogenic African trypanosomes was studied. Spleen cells from Trypanosoma rhodesiense-infected C57BL/6J mice were tested for antigen-nonspecific suppressor-T-cell (Ts) activity after concanavalin A (Con A) treatment in vitro. After exposure to Con A, control and infected mouse spleen cells were added to responder spleen cell cultures stimulated with sheep erythrocytes (SRBC). Assays for the resultant plaque-forming cell responses to SRBC revealed that antigen-nonspecific Ts activity was lost during the first week of infection. Changes in infected mouse T-cell subpopulations, including a terminal loss of Lyt 2.2+ cells, accompanied but did not precede the demonstrable loss of Ts function. Splenic suppressor macrophages which arise during infections with T. rhodesiense also did not seem to be associated with the loss of antigen-nonspecific Ts activity. It is concluded that the generalized immunosuppression associated with experimental African trypanosomiasis extends to the mitogen-induced Ts population.     

Immunosuppression by spleen cells from Moloney leukemia. Comparison of the suppressive effect on antibody response and on mitogen-induced response.

The inhibitory effect of cells from leukemic spleens on the immune functions of normal lymphocytes was studied. Suppressor cells were obtained as the nonadherent fraction (NA) from splenic tumors of mice infected with MuLV-Moloney. This fraction (NA MuLV- M) contained less than 10% membrane Ig-positive (Ig+) cells, 45 to 60% theta-positive cells (theta+) and 40 to 50% naught cells (theta-, Ig-). Similarly prepared fractions from normal control spleens (NAc) containing 75 to 90% theta+cells and less than 10% Ig+ and naught cells were utilized in control cultures. Addition of the NA MuLV- M cells into cultures (Marbrook system) of normal spleen cells with sheep red blood cells suppressed the specific antibody response determined by the number of hemolytic plaque forming cells (PFC). The PFC response was significantly suppressed at a suppressor cell to responder cell ratio of 1:100, and was completely abolished at a ratio of 1:10 or higher. The control NAc fraction showed some inhibitory effect only at high suppressor to responder ratios (1:2 or 1:1). In contrast, the suppressive effect of NAMuLV-M on mitogen-induced 3H-thymidine incorporation in normal B and T cells was much weaker. Very little, if any, suppression occurred at the ratio of 1:100 or 1:10, however, about 50% decrease in DNA synthesis was observed at the ratio 1:2 or 1:1. On the basis of this differential suppressive effect, it is suggested that leukemic spleen cells can suppress the function of immunocompetent cells by more than one mechanism.     

The evolution of immunosuppressive cell populations in experimental mycobacterial infection.

Immunosuppressor activity of considerable potency and complexity was generated during the course of chronic, progressive infection of C3H/Anf mice by Mycobacterium lepraemurium. From the 5th through 10th week after inoculation, spleen cells from infected mice mildly but reproducibly suppressed the direct plaque-forming cell response of normal spleen cell cultures to sheep erythrocytes. Suppression at this stage of infection was mediated by cells with macrophage-like characteristics. A marked increase in splenic suppressor activity at 10 to 11 weeks was associated with the appearance of a second suppressor cell subpopulation composed of T lymphocytes. The appearance of these cells was closely related in time to the onset of rapid splenic enlargement and a loss of cutaneous delayed type hypersensitivity to antigens of M. lepraemurium in mice at 10 to 11 weeks of infection. Suppressor cells were not present in peripheral lymph nodes until terminal infection at 22 to 25 weeks. Suppressor spleen cells depressed the T-dependent antibody response most severely, but there was also a direct effect upon B cells as shown by moderate suppression of responses to TNP-LPS and DNP-Ficoll. Spleen cells from 14-week-infected mice generated a soluble suppressor factor(s) that induces depression of moderate severity, however, the immunosuppression by intact cells was far greater.     

Macrophage-mediated suppression of con A-induced IL-2 production in spleen cells from syphilitic rabbits

Blast transformation studies have indicated a diminished T cell response in spleen cell preparations from rabbits infected with Treponema pallidum. IL-2 synthesis by T lymphocytes is required for proliferation of these cells. Thus, Con A-induced IL-2 generation was measured in syphilitic animals infected for 9 to 14 days. IL-2 production in the infected rabbits was only one-half that observed for uninfected rabbits. This marked decrease in IL-2 was not caused by decreased IL-1 secretion by adherent cells from infected animals because similar levels were found in both infected and uninfected splenic cultures. This decrease was also not caused by an increase in infected spleen cell adsorption of IL-2; similar numbers of receptors for this IL were present in Con A-stimulated infected and uninfected splenic preparations. The inhibited IL-2 production in infected spleen cells was reversed upon removal of the adherent cells and also elevated upon addition of indomethacin to the cultures. PGE levels were also elevated in splenic cultures from infected animals. Finally, IL-2 synthesis, when evaluated at various days postinfection, showed that at 4 days, splenic cells generated twice as much IL-2 as uninfected cells. At 9 to 14 days, IL-2 levels were dramatically decreased (50% lower than that observed in uninfected cultures), and suppression of IL-2 by adherent cells was observed as late as 35 days post-infection. We propose that premature down regulation (suppression) of IL-2 secretion is mediated by adherent cells via a cyclo-oxygenase product, most likely PGE. These results may explain why most, but not all, treponemes are cleared during infection, and why the secondary manifestations of the disease occur.     

Lymphocyte function in experimental African trypanosomiasis. III. Loss of lymph node cell responsiveness

The relationship between immunosuppression and suppressor cell activity in the lymphoid organs of animals with experimental African trypanosomiasis has been examined further. In the present study we measure the primary in vitro PFC response to SRBC by spleen and lymph node cells from Trypanosoma rhodesiense infected or drug-cured C57BL/6 mice. Passive transfer experiments with this culture system tested for the presence or absence of suppressor cells. We demonstrate that infected mice exhibit immunosuppression in the spleen cell population several weeks before becoming suppressed at the level of the lymph node cell populations. Although suppressor cells are present in immunosuppressed spleen cell populations, suppression of lymph node cell responsiveness was not attributable to suppressor cells detectable withi, lymph nodes. After Berenil treatment of terminally infected mice immunocompetence was restored gradually, first to the lymph node cells and subsequently to the spleen cell population. Recovery of spleen cell responsiveness was attributable to the loss of detectable suppressor cell activity within spleens. These results demonstrate that there is anatomical restriction of the suppressor cell population to trypanosome-infected mouse spleen and that loss of immunocompetence in the lymph nodes may be due to factors unrelated to suppressor cell effects.     

Immunoregulation in experimental schistosomiasis: III. Role of macrophages in soluble egg antigen-induced chronic spleen cell augmentation of baseline lymphocyte reactivity

Spleen cells from mice infected for 20 weeks with Schistosoma mansoni, exposed in vitro to soluble schistosomal egg antigens (SEA), treated with mitomycin C (Mc), and cocultured with syngeneic responder spleen cells increased the baseline proliferation of the otherwise unstimulated responder cells in cocultures. The role of macrophages in this “spontaneous” thymidine incorporation was studied directly by removal of macrophages on Sephadex G-10 columns. Removal of esterase-positive, Sephadex G-10-adherent cells (macrophages) greatly reduced the amount of SEA-induced, chronically infected spleen cell-mediated stimulation observed in cocultures. It also reduced an elevated background of spontaneous DNA synthesis seen with control cultures of spleen cells from infected animals. Depletion of T lymphocytes from chronic spleen cell populations by treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 serum and complement prior to exposure to SEA partially abrogated the augmentation effect. Comparison of these results with mitogen (concanavalin A)induced spleen cell-mediated stimulation (which is elevated, rather than reduced, by macrophage removal) and with known alterations in splenic T- and B-lymphocyte ratios in chronic murine Schistosomiasis suggests that antigen-stimulated, chronically infected splenic macrophage-de-pendent baseline augmentation may depend on specific T-lymphocyte-derived lymphokine induction. These results may reflect a general mechanism whereby animals harboring a persistent, chronic infection can respond quickly to a second or challenge infection or a flareup of the primary infection.     

Suppression of cytotoxic lymphocyte responses in vitro by soluble products of alloantigen-activated spleen cells.

Suppression of in vitro cytotoxic lymphocyte (CL) responses was mediated by soluble factor(s) produced when in vivo alloantigen-activated suppressor cells were re-exposed to alloantigen in vitro. Elaboration of suppressor factor (SF) was T cell dependent and was optimal 7 days after alloantigen injection. Suppressor factor failed to inhibit CL generation when alloantigen-primed cells rather than normal spleen cells were used as responders. Moreover, SF added at day 3 of incubation rather than at culture initiation was also ineffective, suggesting that suppression probably occurs during antigen induction or early differentiation. Additionally, suppression was abrogated by the presence of 2-mercaptoethanol. Studies combining SF and CL responder cells from a variety of H-2 disparate mouse sdrains revealed that suppression of CL responses: 1) was not alloantigen specific; 2) did not require H-2 homology between responder and suppressor strains; and 3) could not be demonstrated with CBA/J mice. Although CBA/J CL responses were not suppressed by any SF preparation, allo-sensitized CBA/J spleen cells did elaborate SF that inhibited BALB/c CL responses.     

Activation and mechanism of action of suppressor macrophages

Intravenous administration of Corynebacterium parvum to alloimmunized mice activates splenic suppressor macrophages that effectively curtail primary and secondary generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) in vitro. CTL generation was significantly inhibited in suppressed primary cultures by Day 3, the earliest time point that activity is first detected in control cultures. Suppressor macrophages had to be present during the first 24–48 hr of culture to effectively curtail the generation of CTLs. However, if suppressor macrophages were reactivated by 48-hr in vitro culture and then added to primary sensitizations that had been initiated 48 hr previously, they were capable of significant suppression. Suppressor cells produced a soluble factor that mediated the inhibition of CTL generation. The production or action of this factor could not be counteracted by indomethacin.     

Macrophage-mediated suppression of immune responses in Toxoplasma-infected mice. I. Inhibition of proliferation of lymphocytes in primary antibody responses

The suppressor cells induced by Toxoplasma infection were shown to be macrophages, since they adhered to plastic, and their suppressive activity in anti-sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) antibody responses was abrogated by treatment with silica or carrageenan, which are selectively cytotoxic for macrophages. The suppressor macrophages strongly inhibited the uptake of tritiated thymidine ( [3H]TdR) by normal mouse spleen cells in the responses to SRBC and Toxoplasma antigens. Supernatant fluids from the suppressor macrophages could not passively transfer the suppressive effect on anti-SRBC antibody responses. Furthermore, when the suppressor macrophages were isolated by a cell-impermeable membrane from normal mouse spleen cells, the antibody responses of normal spleen cells were not suppressed. These results indicate that suppression of antibody responses in Toxoplasma-infected mice is caused by an inhibitory effect of the suppressor macrophages upon proliferation of lymphocytes via direct contact with responder target cells. The suppressive effect of the macrophages was not counteracted by indomethacin, a potent inhibitor of prostaglandin synthesis, or catalase, a catabolic enzyme for hydrogen peroxide (H2O2).     

Suppression of the mitogen-stimulated blastogenic response during reticuloendotheliosis virus-induced tumorigenesis: investigations into the mechanism of action of the suppressor.

Splenic lymphocytes from chickens infected with reticuloendotheliosis virus (REV) are suppressed in their ability to undergo PHA-induced blastogenesis. This suppression can be detected within 72 hr after virus injection and requires active viral infection since i.p. or i.v. injection of UV-inactivated REV does not result in inhibition of the blastogenic response. Suppressor cells from the spleens of REV-infected birds severely inhibit the ability of spleen cells from uninfected chickens to respond to PHA at a ratio of 1:20, suggesting that each suppressor cell may be capable of suppressing more than one target cell. Contact between suppressor and target cells is required for the rapid inhibition of the normal PHA response. The suppressive mechanism is cytostatic in nature, and apparently of host origin since neither REV, nor REV-infected (or transformed) cells mediate the suppression. The ability of the suppressor cells to impair the blastogenic response of spleen cells is sensitive to trypsin, suggesting that an inhibitory protein is exposed on the surface of the suppressor cells.     

Cooperation between mouse T-cell subpopulations in the cell-mediated response to a natural poxvirus pathogen.

Irradiated CBA anti-DBA/2 cells (10⁶ cells/culture) suppressed the production of effector cells in cultures containing 10⁷ unprimed CBA (responder) and 10⁶ irradiated DBA/2 (stimulator) spleen cells per culture. The suppressive element was cellular and suppression was specific for the stimulating antigen. The suppressive activity resided in the cytotoxic cell population in that both suppressive and cytotoxic activities were found in cells of the same size range, predominantly in T-cells, were produced in response to similar doses of stimulator antigen, and were produced with the same time course following establishment of first sensitization cultures. Eventual suppression correlated with the cytotoxic activity introduced into second sensitization cultures by suppressor cells. The short-term cytotoxic activity and suppressor activity were both highly radioresistant. These studies indicate that the suppressor cells formed in an in vitro mixed lymphocyte culture are cytotoxic to stimulator cells.     

Age restriction in antigen-specific immunosuppression

Age-related alterations of antigen-specific T cell-mediated suppression have been examined in the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl (NP) system. Inducer suppressor T cells (Tsi) were activated in mice at the age of 3 mo (young) or 18 mo (old) by i.v. injection of NP-conjugated syngeneic spleen cells (SC). Spleen cells from the NP-SC-injected mice were subcultured in vitro with spleen cells from normal young or old mice to generate transducer suppressor T cells (Tst). Four days later subcultured cells were added to responder cell cultures 1 day before the PFC assays to trigger effector suppressor T cells (Tse). Responder cell cultures, containing NP-conjugated horse red blood cells (HRBC) and spleen cells from HRBC-primed young or old mice, were assayed on day 4 for anti-NP and anti-HRBC PFC. Suppression was found to be antigen specific and age restricted. NP-specific suppressor cells are easily induced in subculture if the Tsi and Tst cell populations are both derived from young or old mice. Conversely, if Tsi cells from young or old mice are subcultured with Tst cells from mice of a different age, suppression of the anti-NP PFC response is hardly observed. Age restriction was also found to operate in the interactions between subcultured and responder cell populations, indicating that age-matching is required for effective triggering of Tse cells by Tst cells. These results altogether suggest that aging may affect the recognition repertoire expressed in suppressor T cell subsets. Moreover, the finding that suppression is less efficient when exerted on responder spleen cells from old than from young mice provides an explanation for the increased frequency of autoimmune disorders in aging.     

Trypanosoma cruzi-induced suppressor substance III. Activation of suppressor cells

Serum from mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi (SSS) is known to interact with normal spleen cells to induce an immunosuppressed condition and activate splenic suppressor cells. The induction of immunosuppression by SSS was shown to be independent of, and precede the activation of, suppressor cells. Suppressor-cell activation, however, was demonstrable only after the induction of immunosuppression. Furthermore, mice that were given two aliquots of SSS at different intervals of time, exhibited suppression of humoral responses of similar duration and magnitude, regardless of the SSS transfer regimen, whereas both the length and degree of suppressor-cell activity was critically dependent on the interval of time between SSS transfers. SSS interacted with spleen cells via a trypsin-sensitive membrane site which was regenerable within a 4- to 5-hr period, yet the suppressive effects of SSS on spleen cells following interaction was resistant to treatment with trypsin. The interaction between SSS and spleen cells during brief adsorption protocols leads to immunosuppression only because extensive washing of SSS-treated spleen cells did not reverse the immunosuppression process, but did prevent the development of detectable suppressor cells. The phenomenon of suppressor-cell activation was further distinguished from immunosuppression in that supernates from culture of spleen cells derived from SSS-treated mice or T. cruzi-infected contained a factor that activated suppressor cells, but did not directly induce a state of suppression in the responding cell population.     

Lymphocyte function in experimental African trypanosomiasis. VIII. Loss of suppressor T cell function in lymph nodes

The immunosuppression that occurs in mice experimentally infected with African trypanosomiasis has been examined further. In the present study we have examined lymph node cells from Trypanosoma rhodesiense-infected C57Bl/6J mice for the ability to produce mitogen induced antigen-nonspecific suppressor T cells (Ts). Inguinal, mesenteric, and brachial lymph node cells were harvested from uninfected control mice and from mice at different periods of infection. These cells were cultured with or without concanavalin A (Con A) for 48 hr to induce Ts activity. After stimulation, the control and infected lymph node cells were passed over Sephadex G-10 columns to remove suppressor macrophages that arise during the infection from Con A-induced Ts. The column passed cells were then added to normal mouse responder spleen cells in a primary in vitro antibody response culture system with sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) as antigen. The resultant plaque-forming cell responses to SRBC indicated that Ts function was not induced in infected lymph node cell populations. However, early in the infection, a stimulatory signal was provided by both the untreated and Con A-treated infected lymph node cells, which was lost in the terminal stage. Determinations of T cell subpopulations revealed that the infected Lyt 2.2-bearing subpopulation was not significantly altered from normal controls. We conclude that T. rhodesense infected mice fail to mount normal lymph node cell antigen nonspecific Ts responses and that this loss of activity may be due to an intrinsic dysfunction in the suppressor T cell population.     

Suppressor cells in mice infected with Trypanosoma brucei.

Within 2 to 3 days of infection with Trypanosoma brucei strain S42, the ability of spleen cells from infected CBA mice to mount a primary in vitro antibody response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) is profoundly reduced, and suppressor cells are generated as detected by cell mixture experiments. Suppressor cell activity lies in the T and adherent cell compartments of spleens from infected mice, but not in the B cell compartment, although antibody responses to a thymus-independent antigen, DNP-Ficoll, are significantly reduced. Suppression of antibody responses of normal spleen cells depends on viable cells from infected mice. The trypanosome, itself, plays no direct role in suppression, and we have ruled out the possibility of antigenic competition as a mechanism of suppression. Our data is consistent with the model of suppressor T cells induced by concanavalin A mitogenesis. We hypothesize that trypanosome antigens may directly stimulate T cells with the concomitant release of factors with affinity for macrophage surfaces thus becoming suppressive for T and B cell responses.     

The induction of nonspecific T suppressor lymphocytes by prostaglandin E1

Suppressor cell activity is induced by the addition of prostaglandin E₁ to normal mouse spleen cells (NSC). When this population is added to fresh NSC, it suppresses the primary in vitro antibody response to DNP-LPS. This suppressor cell induction requires a brain-associated thy-1 antigen-bearing cell. No role for a nylon-wool-adherent cell could be demonstrated. Suppression occurs in the absence of T cells in the responding population. The addition of indomethacin to prevent endogenous synthesis of prostaglandins suggests that prostaglandininduced suppressor activity does not require further prostaglandin synthesis in the suppressor population but does require such synthesis in the responding population.     

Proliferative and cytotoxic immune functions in aging mice. IV. Effects of suppressor cell populations from aged and young mice

The changes with age in three splenic suppressor cell populations were studied in C57BL/6 mice. Allospecific Ts cells and nonspecific non-T suppressor cells were both generated in vitro in allogeneic MLC. The presence of "pre-existing" suppressor cells in fresh spleen cells from normal mice was examined. Suppressor cell activities were assayed for their ability to suppress proliferation in a fresh allogeneic MLC after treatment to prevent their own proliferation. The ability to generate both specific and nonspecific suppressor cells decreased with age, whereas pre-existing suppressor cells were detected in spleens from the majority of the aged animals but not in spleens from young animals. The decrease in suppressor cell activity was not due to any requirement for age matching between donors of suppressor and target cells. The specific and nonspecific MLC-generated suppressor cells inhibited both the proliferative response in the assay MLC and the generation of cytotoxic cells. The pre-existing suppressor cells only suppressed the proliferative response and not the generation of cytotoxic cells. The changes seen with age in these suppressor cell populations suggest that the ability to generate suppression (both allospecific and nonspecific) to newly encountered Ag declines with age, whereas a resident splenic suppressor cell population accumulates over the lifetime of the animals.     

Abnormal activation and loss of suppressor T cells in the spontaneously hypertensive rat.

Suppressor T cell function in the spontaneously hypertensive rat (SHR) and normotensive Wistar Kyoto (WKY) rats was analyzed using syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (SMLR) and concanavalin A (Con A) activation. A depressed SMLR was found in adult SHR but not in adult WKY. IL-2 synthesized by SHR was 40-fold lower than that of WKY, and the suppressor T cells generated in the SMLR were incapable of suppressing IgG synthesis. Precursors of cells that can be activated by Con A to become functional suppressor cells are reduced in adult SHR. Supernatant fluids derived from Con A-activated spleen cells from adult SHR failed to significantly inhibit IgG synthesis by cultures of syngeneic spleen cells compared to supernatant fluids from young SHR or WKY Con A-activated spleen cells. However, spleen cells from both adult SHR and WKY proliferated strongly and released equivalent amounts of IL-2 in response to Con A. Addition of exogenous IL-2 to the SMLR cultures in vitro restored the ability of SHR T cells to respond in the SMLR, with generation of cells capable of suppressing IgG synthesis. Administration of SHR with IL-2 in vivo also restored the suppressor T cell function in the SMLR. These results suggest a defective suppressor T cell activation and loss of suppressor T cell activity as the SHR age.