Mechanism of c(4) photosynthesis: a model describing the inorganic carbon pool in bundle sheath cells

A theoretical model of the composition of the inorganic carbon pool generated in C₄ leaves during steady-state photosynthesis was derived. This model gives the concentrations of CO₂ and O₂ in the bundle sheath cells for any given net photosynthesis rate and inorganic carbon pool size. The model predicts a bundle sheath CO₂ concentration of 70 micromolar during steady state photosynthesis in a typical C₄ plant, and that about 13% of the inorganic carbon generated in bundle sheath cells would leak back to the mesophyll cells, predominantly as CO₂. Under these circumstances the flux of carbon through the C₄ acid cycle would have to exceed the net rate of CO₂ assimilation by 15.5%. With the calculated O₂ concentration of 0.44 millimolar, the potential photorespiratory CO₂ loss in bundle sheath cells would be about 3% of CO₂ assimilation. Among the factors having a critical influence on the above values are the permeability of bundle sheath chloroplasts to HCO₃⁻, the activity of carbonic anhydrase within these chloroplasts, the assumed stromal volume, and the permeability coefficients for CO₂ and O₂ diffusion across the interface between bundle sheath and mesophyll cells. The model suggests that as the net photosynthesis rate changes in C₄ plants, the level and distribution of the components of the inorganic carbon pool change in such a way that C₄ acid overcycling is maintained in an approximately constant ratio with respect to the net photosynthesis rate.     

Metabolite diffusion into bundle sheath cells from c(4) plants: relation to c(4) photosynthesis and plasmodesmatal function

The present studies provide the first measurements of the resistance to diffusive flux of metabolites between mesophyll and bundle sheath cells of C₄ plants. Species examined were Panicum miliaceum, Urochloa panicoides, Atriplex spongiosa, and Zea mays. Diffusive flux of metabolites into isolated bundle sheath cells was monitored by following their metabolic transformation. Evidence was obtained that the observed rapid fluxes occurred via functional plasmodesmata. Diffusion constants were determined from the rate of transformation of limiting concentrations of metabolites via cytosolic enzymes with high potential velocities and favorable equilibrium constants. Values on a leaf chlorophyll basis ranged between 1 and 5 micromoles per minute per milligram of chlorophyll per millimolar gradient depending on the molecular weight of the metabolite and the source of bundle sheath cells. Diffusion of metabolites into these cells was unaffected by a wide variety of compounds including respiratory inhibitors, monovalent and divalent cations, and plant hormones, but it was interrupted by treatments inducing cell plasmolysis. The molecular weight exclusion limit for permeation of compounds into bundle sheath cells was in the range of 850 to 900. These cells provide an ideal system for the quantitative study of plasmodesmatal function.     

Form of inorganic carbon involved as a product and as an inhibitor of c(4) Acid decarboxylases operating in c(4) photosynthesis

These studies demonstrated that CO₂ rather than HCO₃⁻ is the inorganic carbon metabolite produced by the C₄ acid decarboxylases involved in C₄ photosynthesis (chloroplast located NADP malic enzyme, mitochondrial NAD malic enzyme, and cytosolic phosphoenolpyruvate [PEP] carboxykinase). The effect of varying CO₂ or HCO₃⁻ as a substrate for the carboxylation reaction catalyzed by these enzymes or as inhibitors of the decarboxylation reaction was also determined. The K_mCO₂ was 1.1 millimolar for NADP malic enzyme and 2.5 millimolar for PEP carboxykinase. For these two enzymes the velocity in the carboxylating direction was substantially less than for the decarboxylating direction even with CO₂ concentrations at the upper end of the range of expected cellular levels. Activity of NAD malic enzyme in the carboxylating direction was undetectable. The decarboxylation reaction of all three enzymes was inhibited by added HCO₃⁻. For NADP malic enzyme CO₂ was shown to be the inhibitory species but PEP carboxykinase and NAD malic enzyme were apparently inhibited about equally by CO₂ and HCO₃⁻.     

On the mechanism of C4 photosynthesis intermediate exchange between Kranz mesophyll and bundle sheath cells in grasses

C₄ photosynthesis involves cell-to-cell exchange of photosyntheticintermediates between the Kranz mesophyll (KMS) and bundle sheath(BS) cells. This was believed to occur by simple diffusion throughplentiful plasmodesmatal (PD) connections between these celltypes. The model of C₄ intermediates’ transport was elaboratedover 30 years ago and was based on experimental data derivedfrom measurements at the time. The model assumed that plasmodesmataoccupied about 3% of the interface between the KMS and BS cellsand that the plasmodesmata structure did not restrict metabolitemovement. Recent advances in the knowledge of plasmodesmatalstructure put these assumptions into doubt, so a new model ispresented here taking the new anatomical details into account.If one assumes simple diffusion as the sole driving force, thencalculations based on the experimental data obtained for C₄grasses show that the gradients expected of C₄ intermediatesbetween KMS and BS cells are about three orders of magnitudehigher than experimentally estimated. In addition, if one takesinto account that the plasmodesmata microchannel diameter mightconstrict the movement of C₄ intermediates of comparable Stokes’radii, the differences in concentration of photosynthetic intermediatesbetween KMS and BS cells should be further increased. We believethat simple diffusion-driven transport of C₄ intermediates betweenKMS and BS cells through the plasmodesmatal microchannels isnot adequate to explain the C₄ metabolite exchange during C₄photosynthesis. Alternative mechanisms are proposed, involvingthe participation of desmotubule and/or active mechanisms aseither apoplasmic or vesicular transport. Key words: C₄ photosynthesis, grasses, modelling, plasmodesmata, symplasmic transport Received 10 October 2007; Revised 4 February 2008 Accepted 5 February 2008     

Regulation of levels of nuclear transcripts for C4 photosynthesis in bundle sheath and mesophyll cells of maize leaves

In vitro translation of polyA⁺ mRNAs isolated from purified maize bundle sheath and mesophyll cells results in the production of distinctive, cell-specific polypeptides. Immunoprecipitation experiments show that translatable polyA⁺ mRNAs for phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC), pyruvate orthophosphate dikinase (PPDK) and NADP-malate dehydrogenase (MDH) are prominent in mesophyll but not bundle sheath cells. On the contrary, those for sedoheptulose-1,7-bisphosphatase (SBP), fructose-1,6-bisphosphatase (FBP), NADP-malic enzyme (ME) and the small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase (RuBPC SS) are present only in bundle sheath cells. Moreover, polyA⁺ mRNAs encoding the 33 kD, 23 kD and 16 kD polypeptides of the oxygen-evolving complex (OE33, OE23 and OE16) and the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein of photosystem II (LHCP II) are much more abundant in mesophyll than in bundle sheath cells. Northern blot analyses with cDNA clones of PEPC, PPDK, ME, RuBPC SS, OE33, OE23, OE16 and LHCP II are consistent with the conclusion that the cell-specific expression of these genes is regulated at the RNA level. The RNA level differences are especially dramatic in dark-grown maize seedlings after illumination for 24 h.     

Photosynthetic activities of isolated bundle sheath cells in relation to differing mechanisms of C-4 pathway photosynthesis.

Photosynthetic activities of bundle sheath cell strands isolated from several C₄ pathway species were examined. These included species that decarboxylate C₄ acids via either NADP-malic enzyme (Zea mays, NADP-malic enzyme-type), NAD-malic enzyme (Atriplex spongiosa and Panicum miliaceum, NAD-malic enzyme-type) or phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (Chloris gayana and Panicum maximum, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-type). Preparations from each of these species fixed ¹⁴CO₂ at rates ranging between 1.2 and 3.5 μmol min^?1 mg^?1 of chlorophyll, with more than 90% of the ¹⁴C being assimilated into Calvin cycle intermediates. With added HCO₃^? the rate of light-dependent O₂ evolution ranged between 2 and 4 μmol min^?1 mg^?1 of chlorophyll for cells from NAD-malic enzyme-type and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-type species but with Z. mays cells there was no O₂ evolution detectable. Most of the ¹⁴CO₂ fixed by Z. mays cells provided with H¹⁴CO₃^? plus ribose 5-phosphate accumulated in the C-1 of 3-phosphoglycerate. However, 3-phosphoglycerate reduction was increased several fold when malate was also provided. Cells from all species rapidly decarboxylated C₄ acids under appropriate conditions, and the CO₂ released from the C-4 carboxyl was reassimilated via the Calvin cycle. Malate decarboxylation by Z. mays cells was dependent upon light and an endogenous or exogenous source of 3-phosphoglycerate. Bundle sheath cells of NAD-malic enzyme-type species rapidly decarboxylated [¹⁴C]malate when aspartate and 2-oxoglutarate were also provided, and [¹⁴C]aspartate was decarboxylated at similar rates when 2-oxoglutarate was added. Cells from phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-type species decarboxylated [¹⁴C]aspartate when 2-oxoglutarate was added and they also catalyzed a slower decarboxylation of malate. Cells from NAD-malic enzyme-type and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-type species evolved O₂ in the light when C₄ acids were added. These results are discussed in relation to proposed mechanisms for photosynthetic metabolism in the bundle sheath cells of species utilizing C₄ pathway photosynthesis.     

Low bundle sheath carbonic anhydrase is apparently essential for effective c(4) pathway operation

Bundle sheath cells from leaves of a variety of C₄ species contained little or no carbonic anhydrase activity. The proportion of total leaf carbonic anhydrase in extracts of bundle sheath cells closely reflected the apparent mesophyll cell contamination of bundle sheath cell extracts as measured by the proportion of the mesophyll cell marker enzymes phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase and pyruvate,Pi dikinase. Values of about 1% or less of the total leaf activity were obtained for all three enzymes. The recorded bundle sheath carbonic anhydrase activity was compared with a calculated upper limit of carbonic anhydrase activity that would still permit efficient functioning of the C₄ pathway; that is, a carbonic anhydrase level allowing a sufficiently high steady state [CO₂] to suppress photorespiration. Even before correcting for mesophyll cell contamination the activity in bundle sheath cell extracts was substantially less than the calculated upper limit of carbonic anhydrase activity consistent with effective C₄ function. The results accord with the notion that a deficiency of carbonic anhydrase in bundle sheath cells is vital for the efficient operation of the C₄ pathway.     

Estimation of diffusive resistance of bundle sheath cells to CO2 from modeling of C4 photosynthesis

This account is focused upon the early part of my career in order to illuminate the logistics and the culture of our science in the period 1936 to 1949. A roundabout path took me from a farm in Pennsylvania to a PhD under George Burr at Minnesota in 1939. In studying the photosynthetic competence of chlorophyll formed by the green alga Chlorella in darkness, I stumbled upon the phenomenon of photoinhibition. In a two-year postdoctorate at the Smithsonian Institution, I worked under E.D. McAlister. Our major accomplishment was in making simultaneous recordings of fluorescence and CO₂ uptake during the induction period. Variations in photosynthetic behavior of Chlorella led to a study of culture conditions and a recognition of the changing conditions which occur in batch cultures. A continuous culture apparatus (turbidostat) was developed as a means of attaining steady-state growth and production of uniform experimental material. I exploited the device in work at my first (and only) position at The University of Texas in 1941 and subsequent years. Study of the CO₂/O₂ gas exchange ratio led to the recognition of the important role of nitrate in the photosynthetic metabolism of algae. The account ends with the 1949 American Association for the Advancement of Science symposium.Invited and edited by Govindjee     

Aspartate stimulation of malate decarboxylation in Zea mays bundle sheath cells: possible role in regulation of C4 photosynthesis.

Aspartate stimulated by as much as three fold the rate of malate decarboxylation by Zea mays bundle sheath cells. Both the basal and aspartate stimulated rates of malate decarboxylation were light-dependent. Stimulation appeared to be due to aspartate as such, rather than depending on aspartate metabolism, and was due partly to a reduction in the malate concentration required for maximum decarboxylation and partly to an increased maximum velocity of decarboxylation. The extractable activities of NADP malic enzyme, glyceraldehyde phosphate dehydrogenase, and 3-phosphoglycerate kinase recoverable from cells were not increased by preincubating cells with aspartate, and aspartate did not affect the activity of these enzymes in cell-free extracts. It is suggested that aspartate may influence the transport of either malate into or pyruvate out of bundle sheath chloroplasts.     

Intracellular localization of certain photosynthetic enzymes in bundle sheath cells of plants possessing the C4 pathway of photosynthesis.

Bundle sheath cells were enzymatically isolated from representatives of three groups of C₄ plants: Zea mays (NADP malic enzyme type), Panicum miliaceum (NAD malic enzyme type), and Panicum maximum (phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxykinase type). Cellular organelles from bundle sheath homogenates were partially resolved by differential centrifugation and on isopycnic sucrose density gradients in order to study compartmentation of photosynthetic enzymes. A 48-h-dark pretreatment of the leaves allowed the isolation of relatively intact chloroplasts. Enzymes that decarboxylate C₄ acids and furnish CO₂ to the Calvin cycle are localized as follows: NADP malic enzyme, chloroplastic in Z. mays; NAD malic enzyme, mitochondrial in all three species; PEP carboxykinase, chloroplastic in P. maximum. The activity of NAD malic enzyme in the three species was in the order of P. miliaceum > P. maximum > Z. mays. There were high levels of aspartate and alanine aminotransferases in bundle sheath extracts of P. miliaceum and P. maximum and substantial activity in Z. mays. In all three species, aspartate aminotransferase was mitochondrial whereas alanine aminotransferase was cytoplasmic. Based on the activity and localization of certain enzymes, the concept for aspartate and malate as transport metabolites from mesophyll to bundle sheath cells in C₄ species of the three C₄ groups is discussed.     

Sensing of inorganic carbon limitation in Synechococcus PCC7942 is correlated with the size of the internal inorganic carbon pool and involves oxygen

Freshwater cyanobacteria are subjected to large seasonal fluctuations in the availability of nutrients, including inorganic carbon (Ci). We are interested in the regulation of the CO2-concentrating mechanism (CCM) in the model freshwater cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. strain PCC7942 in response to Ci limitation; however, the nature of Ci sensing is poorly understood. We monitored the expression of high-affinity Ci-transporter genes and the corresponding induction of a high-affinity CCM in Ci-limited wild-type cells and a number of CCM mutants. These genotypes were subjected to a variety of physiological and pharmacological treatments to assess whether Ci sensing might involve monitoring of fluctuations in the size of the internal Ci pool or, alternatively, the activity of the photorespiratory pathway. These modes of Ci sensing are congruent with previous results. We found that induction of a high-affinity CCM correlates most closely with a depletion of the internal Ci pool, but that full induction of this mechanism also requires some unresolved oxygen-dependent process.     

Differential positioning of chloroplasts in C4 mesophyll and bundle sheath cells

Chloroplast photorelocation movement is extensively studied in C₃ but not C₄ plants. C₄ plants have two types of photosynthetic cells: mesophyll and bundle sheath cells. Mesophyll chloroplasts are randomly distributed along cell walls, whereas bundle sheath chloroplasts are located close to the vascular tissues or mesophyll cells depending on the plant species. The cell-specific C₄ chloroplast arrangement is established during cell maturation, and is maintained throughout the life of the cell. However, only mesophyll chloroplasts can change their positions in response to environmental stresses. The migration pattern is unique to C₄ plants and differs from that of C₃ chloroplasts. in this mini-review, we highlight the cell-specific disposition of chloroplasts in C₄ plants and discuss the possible physiological significances.Key words: abscisic acid, aggregative movement, avoidance movement, blue light, bundle sheath cell, C₄ plant, chloroplast, cytoskeleton, environmental stress, mesophyll cellChloroplasts can change their intracellular positions to optimize photosynthetic activity and/or reduce photodamage occurring in response to light irradiation. On treating with high-intensity light, the chloroplasts move away from the light to minimize photodamage (avoidance response). Meanwhile, on irradiating with low-intensity light, they move toward the light source to maximize photosynthesis (accumulation response). These chloroplast-photorelocation movements are observed in a wide variety of plant species from green algae to seed plants,^1–3 although little attention has been paid to C₄ plants. There is a report stating that monocotyledonous C₄ plants showed changes in the light transmission of leaves in response to blue light,⁴ although the direction of migration of the chloroplasts is not described.C₄ plants have two types of photosynthetic cells: mesophyll (M) cells and bundle sheath (BS) cells, which have numerous well-developed chloroplasts. BS cells surround the vascular tissues, while M cells encircle the cylinders of the BS cells (Fig. 1). The C₄ dicarboxylate cycle of photosynthetic carbon assimilation is distributed between the two cell types, and acts as a CO₂ pump to concentrate CO₂ in the BS chloroplasts.^5,6 C₄ plants are divided into three subtypes on the basis of decarboxylating enzymes: NADP-malic enzyme (ME), NAD-ME and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase. Although the M chloroplasts of all C₄ species are randomly distributed along the cell walls, BS chloroplasts are located either in a centripetal (close to the vascular tissue) or in a centrifugal (close to M cells) position, depending on the species (Fig. 1A).⁷ Thus, C₄ M and BS cells have different systems for chloroplast positioning: an M cell-specific system for dispersing chloroplasts and a BS cell-specific system for holding chloroplasts in a centripetal or centrifugal disposition.Open in a separate windowFigure 1The intracellular arrangement of chloroplasts in finger millet (Eleusine coracana), an NAD-ME-type C₄ plant. (A) Light micrograph of a transverse section of a leaf blade from a control plant. Bundle sheath (BS) cells surround the vascular tissues, while mesophyll (M) cells encircle the cylinders of the BS cells. BS chloroplasts are well developed, and are located in a centripetal position, whereas M chloroplasts are randomly distributed along the cell walls. B, bundle sheath cell; M, mesophyll cell; V, vascular bundle. (B) Transverse section of a leaf blade from a drought-stressed plant. Most M chloroplasts are aggregatively distributed toward the BS side, while the centripetal arrangement of BS chloroplasts is unchanged. (C and D) Transverse sections of leaf segments irradiated with blue light of intensity 500 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹ with or without 30 µM ABA for 8 h (C and D, respectively). The adaxial side of each leaf section (upper side in the photograph) was illuminated. In the absence of ABA, M chloroplasts exhibited avoidance movement on the illuminated side and aggregative movement on the opposite side. In the presence of ABA, aggregative movement was observed on both sides. Scale bars = 50 µm.     

Differentiation of bundle sheath,mesophyll, and distinctive cells in the C4 grass Arundinella hirta (Poaceae)

The C₄ grass Arundinella hirta is characterized by unusual leaf blade anatomy: veins are widely spaced and files of bundle-sheath-like cells, the distinctive cells, form longitudinal strands that are not associated with vascular tissue. While distinctive cells (DCs) appear to function like bundle sheath cells (BSCs), they differ developmentally in two ways: they are derived from ground meristem rather than procambium and they are formed 1–2 plastochrons later. This study describes ultrastructural features of differentiating of BSCs, DCs, and associated mesophyll cells (MCs) during leaf development. BSCs and DCs differ from adjacent MCs by undergoing earlier cell enlargement, greater rates of chloroplast enlargement, reduction of chloroplast thylakoids at late stages of differentiation, more extensive starch formation, greater wall thickening, and deposition of a suberin lamella. The precocious delimitation of the bundle sheath layer is reflected in earlier BSC enlargement and vacuole growth. Derivation of DCs from ground meristem is correlated with late developmental changes in chloroplast size, wall thickness, and plasmodesmatal density. Despite these differences in timing of events, particularly at early stages, the development of the specialized structural features of BSCs and DCs is essentially similar. Thus, proximity to vascular tissue appears to be nonessential for the coordination and regulation of BSC- and MC-specific developmental events.     

Oxygen and electron flow in C4 photosynthesis: Mehler reaction, photorespiration and CO2 concentration in the bundle sheath

The photosynthetic linear electron transport rate in excess of that used for CO₂ reduction was evaluated in Sorghum bicolor Moench. [NADP-malic enzyme (ME)-type C₄ plant], Amaranthus cruentus L. (NAD-ME-type C₄ plant) and Helianthus annuus L. (C₃ plant) leaves at different CO₂ and O₂ concentrations. The electron transport rate (J _F) was calculated from fluorescence using the light partitioning factor (relative PSII cross-section) determined under conditions where excess electron transport was assumed to be negligible: low light intensities, 500 μmol CO₂ · mol⁻¹ and 2% O₂. Under high light intensities there was a large excess of J _F/4 at 10–100% O₂ in the C₃ plant due to photorespiration, but very little in sorghum and somewhat more in amaranth, showing that photorespiration is suppressed, more in the NADP-ME- and less in the NAD-ME-type species. It is concluded that when C₄ photosynthesis is limited by supply of atmospheric CO₂ to the C₄ cycle, the C₃ cycle becomes limited by regeneration of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate (RuBP) which in turn limits RuBP oxygenase activity and photorespiration. The rate of excess electron transport over that consumed for CO₂ fixation in C₄ plants was very sensitive to the presence of O₂ in the gas phase, rapidly increasing between 0.01 and 0.1% O₂, and at 2% O₂ it was about two-thirds of that at 21% O₂. This shows the importance of the Mehler O₂ reduction as an electron sink, compared with photorespiration in C₄ plants. However, the rate of the Mehler reaction is still too low to fully account for the extra ATP which is needed in C₄ photosynthesis. Received: 8 November 1997 / Accepted: 26 December 1997     

C4-acids as the source of carbon dioxide for calvin cycle photosynthesis by bundle sheath cells of the C4-pathway species Atriplex spongiosa

For one group of C₄ species we have proposed that the C₄ acid decarboxylation phase of C₄ photosynthesis proceeds via a NAD ‘malic’ enzyme located in bundle sheath mitochondria. The present studies with Atriplex spongiosa demonstrate the capacity of isolated mitochondria and bundle sheath cell strands to decarboxylate malate at rates commensurate with an integral role in photosynthesis. With bundle sheath cells, rates of H¹⁴CO₃^? fixation into Calvin cycle intermediates and evolution of O₂ when HCO₃^? was added, were above 2 μmoles/min/mg chlorophyll. Similar rates of O₂ evolution resulted from the addition of C₄ acids, and the C-4 carboxyl of malate was rapidly assimilated into photosynthetic intermediates and products.     

Photosynthesis in phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-type C4 plants: activity and role of mitochondria in bundle sheath cells

Mitochondria from bundle sheath cells of the phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-type C4 species Urochloa panicoides were shown to have metabolic properties consistent with a role in C4 photosynthesis predicted from earlier studies. The rate of O2 uptake in response to added malate plus ADP was at least five times the activity observed with NADH, glycine, or succinate. With malate plus ADP the O2 uptake rate averaged about 150 nmol O2 min-1 mg-1 protein, equivalent to about 0.6 mumol min-1 mg-1 of extracted chlorophyll. About half of this activity was apparently phosphorylation-linked with ADP/O2 ratios of about 4. Studies with electron transport inhibitors suggested that about 65% of this malate oxidation is cytochrome oxidase-terminated with a minor component mediated via the alternative oxidase. These mitochondria supported rapid rates of pyruvate production from malate and this activity was also stimulated by ADP but blocked by inhibitors of electron transport. Adding oxaloacetate increased pyruvate production but inhibited O2 uptake. The results were consistent with the notion that in this subgroup of C4 species mitochondrial-located NAD malic enzyme contributes substantially to total C4 acid decarboxylation. This enzyme is apparently also the primary source of NADH necessary to generate the ATP required for phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-mediated oxaloacetate decarboxylation.