On the significance of C3—C4 intermediate photosynthesis to the evolution of C4 photosynthesis

Abstract Evidence is drawn from previous studies to argue that C₃—C₄ intermediate plants are evolutionary intermediates, evolving from fully-expressed C₃ plants towards fully-expressed C₄ plants. On the basis of this conclusion, C₃—C₄ intermediates are examined to elucidate possible patterns that have been followed during the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis. An hypothesis is proposed that the initial step in C₄-evolution was the development of bundle-sheath metabolism that reduced apparent photorespiration by an efficient recycling of CO₂ using RuBP carboxylase. The CO₂-recycling mechanism appears to involve the differential compartmentation of glycine decarboxylase between mesophyll and bundle-sheath cells, such that most of the activity is in the bundlesheath cells. Subsequently, elevated phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxylase activities are proposed to have evolved as a means of enhancing the recycling of photorespired CO₂. As the activity of PEP carboxylase increased to higher values, other enzymes in the C₄-pathway are proposed to have increased in activity to facilitate the processing of the products of C₄-assimilation and provide PEP substrate to PEP carboxylase with greater efficiency. Initially, such a ‘C₄-cycle’ would not have been differentially compartmentalized between mesophyll and bundlesheath cells as is typical of fully-expressed C₄ plants. Such metabolism would have limited benefit in terms of concentrating CO₂ at RuBP carboxylase and, therefore, also be of little benefit for improving water- and nitrogen-use efficiencies. However, the development of such a limited C₄-cycle would have represented a preadaptation capable of evolving into the leaf biochemistry typical of fully-expressed C₄ plants. Thus, during the initial stages of C₄-evolution it is proposed that improvements in photorespiratory CO₂-loss and their influence on increasing the rate of net CO₂ assimilation per unit leaf area represented the evolutionary ‘driving-force’. Improved resourceuse efficiency resulting from an efficient CO₂-concentrating mechanism is proposed as the driving force during the later stages.     

C4 photosynthesis at low temperatures

Abstract. C₄ plants grown in optimum conditions are, by comparison to C₃, capable of higher maximum dry-matter yields and greater efficiencies of water and nitrogen use, yet they are rare outside the subtropics. Both latitudinal and altitudinal limits of C₄ distributions correlate most closely with a mean minimum temperature of 8-10°C during the period of active growth. The possibility that the C₄ process is inherently incapable of functioning at low temperatures is examined. The reversible effects of chilling on the quantum efficiency of C₄ photosynthesis and the functioning of the individual steps in the C₄ cycle are examined. Chilling also produces an irreversible loss of capacity to assimilate CO₂ which is directly proportional to the light received during chilling. It is suggested that the reversible reduction in capacity to assimilate CO₂ and the lack of an alternative pathway for the utilization of lightgenerated reducing power may make C₄ species more prone to chilling-dependent photoinhibition. Laboratory studies and limited field observations suggest that this damage would be most likely to occur during photosynthetic induction at the temperatures and light levels encountered on clear, cool mornings during the spring and early summer in cool climates. Even those C₄ species occurring naturally in cool climates do not appear fully capable of tolerating these conditions; indeed their growth patterns suggest that they may be adapted by avoiding 'rather than enduring' such conditions.     

The photosynthesis of young Panicum C4 leaves is not C3-like

Evidence is presented contrary to the suggestion that C₄ plants grow larger at elevated CO₂ because the C₄ pathway of young C₄ leaves has C₃-like characteristics, making their photosynthesis O₂ sensitive and responsive to high CO₂. We combined PAM fluorescence with gas exchange measurements to examine the O₂ dependence of photosynthesis in young and mature leaves of Panicum antidotale (C₄, NADP-ME) and P. coloratum (C₄, NAD-ME), at an intercellular CO₂ concentration of 5 Pa. P. laxum (C₃) was used for comparison. The young C₄ leaves had CO₂ and light response curves typical of C₄ photosynthesis. When the O₂ concentration was gradually increased between 2 and 40%, CO₂ assimilation rates (A) of both mature and young C₄ leaves were little affected, while the ratio of the quantum yield of photosystem II to that of CO₂ assimilation (Φ_PSII/Φ_CO2) increased more in young (up to 31%) than mature (up to 10%) C₄ leaves. A of C₃ leaves decreased by 1·3 and Φ_PSII/Φ_CO2 increased by 9-fold, over the same range of O₂ concentrations. Larger increases in electron transport requirements in young, relative to mature, C₄ leaves at low CO₂ are indicative of greater O₂ sensitivity of photorespiration. Photosynthesis modelling showed that young C₄ leaves have lower bundle sheath CO₂ concentration, brought about by higher bundle sheath conductance relative to the activity of the C₄ and C₃ cycles and/or lower ratio of activities of the C₄ to C₃ cycles.     

Comparative ecophysiology of C3 and C4 plants

Abstract. In this review we relate the physiological significance of C₄ photosynthesis to plant performance in nature. We begin with an examination of the physiological consequences of the C₄ pathway on photosynthesis, then discuss the ecophysiological performance of C₄ plants in contrasting environments. We then compare the performance of C₃ and C₄ plants when they occur together in similar habitats, and finally discuss the distribution of C₄ photosynthesis with respect to the physical environment, phylogeny, and life form.     

Utilization of O2 in the metabolic optimization of C4 photosynthesis

The combined effects of O₂ on net rates of photosynthesis, photosystem II activity, steady‐state pool size of key metabolites of photosynthetic metabolism in the C₄ pathway, C₃ pathway and C₂ photorespiratory cycle and on growth were evaluated in the C₄ species Amaranthus edulis and the C₃ species Flaveria pringlei. Increasing O₂ reduced net CO₂ assimilation in F. pringlei due to an increased flux of C through the photorespiratory pathway. However, in A. edulis increasing O₂ up to 5–10% stimulated photosynthesis. Analysis of the pool size of key metabolites in A. edulis suggests that while there is some O₂ dependent photorespiration, O₂ is required for maximizing C₄ cycle activity to concentrate CO₂ in bundle sheath cells. Therefore, the response of net photosynthesis to O₂ in C₄ plants may result from the balance of these two opposing effects. Under 21 versus 5% O₂, growth of A. edulis was stimulated about 30% whereas that of F. pringlei was inhibited about 40%.     

Models of carbon metabolism in C3-C4 intermediate plants as applied to the evolution of C4 photosynthesis

Abstract Models developed to explain the biphasic response of CO₂ compensation concentration to O₂ concentration and the C₃-like carbon isotope discrimination in C₃-C₄ intermediate species are used to characterize quantitatively the steps necessary in the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis. The evolutionary stages are indicated by model outputs, CO₂ compensation concentration and δ₁₃C value. The transition from intermediate plants to C₄ plants requires the complete formation of C₄ cycle capacity, expressed by the models as transition from C₄ cycle limitation by phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) regeneration rate to limitation by PEP carboxylase activity. Other steps refer to CO₂ leakage from bundle sheath cells, to further augmentations of C₄ cycle components, to the repression of ribulose-1,5-bisphos-phate carboxylase in the mesophyll cells, and to a decrease in the CO₂ affinity of the enzyme. Possibilities of extending the suggested approach to other physiological characteristics, and the adaptive significance of the steps envisaged, are discussed.     

C4 photosynthesis in a single C3 cell is theoretically inefficient but may ameliorate internal CO2 diffusion limitations of C3 leaves

Attempts are being made to introduce C₄ photosynthetic characteristics into C₃ crop plants by genetic manipulation. This research has focused on engineering single‐celled C₄‐type CO₂ concentrating mechanisms into C₃ plants such as rice. Herein the pros and cons of such approaches are discussed with a focus on CO₂ diffusion, utilizing a mathematical model of single‐cell C₄ photosynthesis. It is shown that a high bundle sheath resistance to CO₂ diffusion is an essential feature of energy‐efficient C₄ photosynthesis. The large chloroplast surface area appressed to the intercellular airspace in C₃ leaves generates low internal resistance to CO₂ diffusion, thereby limiting the energy efficiency of a single‐cell C₄ concentrating mechanism, which relies on concentrating CO₂ within chloroplasts of C₃ leaves. Nevertheless the model demonstrates that the drop in CO₂ partial pressure, pCO₂, that exists between intercellular airspace and chloroplasts in C₃ leaves at high photosynthetic rates, can be reversed under high irradiance when energy is not limiting. The model shows that this is particularly effective at lower intercellular pCO₂. Such a system may therefore be of benefit in water‐limited conditions when stomata are closed and low intercellular pCO₂ increases photorespiration.     

Carbonic anhydrase and C4 photosynthesis: a transgenic analysis

Carbonic anhydrase (CA, EC 4.2.1.1) catalyses the first reaction in the C₄ photosynthetic pathway, the conversion of atmospheric CO₂ to bicarbonate in the mesophyll cytosol. To examine the importance of the enzyme to the functioning of the C₄ photosynthetic pathway, Flaveria bidentis (L.) Kuntze, a C₄ dicot, was genetically transformed with an antisense construct in which the cDNA encoding a putative cytosolic CA (CA3) was placed under the control of a constitutive promoter. Some of the primary transformants had impaired CO₂ assimilation rates and required high CO₂ for growth. The T₁ progeny of four primary transformants were used to examine the quantitative relationship between leaf CA activity and CO₂ assimilation rate. CA activity was determined in leaf extracts with a mass spectrometric technique that measured the rate of ¹⁸O exchange from doubly labelled ¹³C¹⁸O₂. Steady‐state CO₂ assimilation rates were unaffected by a decrease in CA activity until CA activity was less than 20% of wild type when they decreased steeply. Transformants with less than 10% of wild‐type CA activity had very low CO₂ assimilation rates and grew poorly at ambient CO₂ partial pressure. Reduction in CA activity also increased the CO₂ partial pressure required to saturate CO₂ assimilation rates. The present data show that CA activity is essential for the functioning of the C₄ photosynthetic pathway.     

Oxygen sensitivity of C4 photosynthesis: evidence from gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence analyses with different C4 subtypes

Because photosynthetic rates in C₄ plants are the same at normal levels of O₂ (c, 20 kPa) and at c, 2 kPa O₂ (a conventional test for evaluating photorespiration in C₃ plants) it has been thought that C₄ photosynthesis is O₂ insensitive. However, we have found a dual effect of O₂ on the net rate of CO₂ assimilation among species representing all three C₄ subtypes from both monocots and dicots. The optimum O₂ partial pressure for C₄ photosynthesis at 30 °C, atmospheric CO₂ level, and half full sunlight (1000 μmol quanta m^?2 s^?1) was about 5–10 kPa. Photosynthesis was inhibited by O₂ below or above the optimum partial pressure. Decreasing CO₂ levels from ambient levels (32.6 Pa) to 9.3 Pa caused a substantial increase in the degree of inhibition of photosynthesis by supra-optimum levels of O₂ and a large decrease in the ratio of quantum yield of CO₂ fixation/quantum yield of photosystem II (PSII) measured by chlorophyll a fluorescence. Photosystem II activity, measured from chlorophyll a fluorescence analysis, was not inhibited at levels of O₂ that were above the optimum for CO₂ assimilation, which is consistent with a compensating, alternative electron How as net CO₂ assimilation is inhibited. At suboptimum levels of O₂, however, the inhibition of photosynthesis was paralleled by an inhibition of PSII quantum yield, increased state of reduction of quinone A, and decreased efficiency of open PSII centres. These results with different C₄ types suggest that inhibition of net CO₂ assimilation with increasing O₂ partial pressure above the optimum is associated with photorespiration, and that inhibition below the optimum O₂ may be caused by a reduced supply of ATP to the C₄ cycle as a result of inhibition of its production photochemically.     

Naturally low carbonic anhydrase activity in C4 and C3 plants limits discrimination against C18OO during photosynthesis

The ¹⁸O content of CO₂ is a powerful tracer of photosynthetic activity at the ecosystem and global scale. Due to oxygen exchange between CO₂ and ¹⁸O-enriched leaf water and retrodiffusion of most of this CO₂ back to the atmosphere, leaves effectively discriminate against ¹⁸O during photosynthesis. Discrimination against ¹⁸O ( Δ ¹⁸O) is expected to be lower in C₄ plants because of low c_i and hence low retrodiffusing CO₂ flux. C₄ plants also generally show lower levels of carbonic anhydrase (CA) activities than C₃ plants. Low CA may limit the extent of ¹⁸O exchange and further reduce Δ ¹⁸O. We investigated CO₂–H₂O isotopic equilibrium in plants with naturally low CA activity, including two C₄ (Zea mays, Sorghum bicolor) and one C₃ (Phragmites australis) species. The results confirmed experimentally the occurrence of low Δ ¹⁸O in C₄, as well as in some C₃, plants. Variations in CA activity and in the extent of CO₂–H₂O isotopic equilibrium ( θ _eq) estimated from on-line measurements of Δ ¹⁸O showed large range of 0–100% isotopic equilibrium ( θ _eq = 0–1). This was consistent with direct estimates based on assays of CA activity and measurements of CO₂ concentrations and residence times in the leaves. The results demonstrate the potential usefulness of Δ ¹⁸O as indicator of CA activity in vivo. Sensitivity tests indicated also that the impact of θ _eq < 1 (incomplete isotopic equilibrium) on ¹⁸O of atmospheric CO₂ can be similar for C₃ and C₄ plants and in both cases it increases with natural enrichment of ¹⁸O in leaf water.     

C4 characteristics of photosynthesis in the C3 alga Hydrodictyon africanum

Abstract Results obtained with Hydrodictyon africanum, and data from the literature, show that most green algae of the chlorophyte type (e.g. Chlorella, Chlamydomonas, Hydrodictyon) differ in their photosynthetic C fixation characteristics from most green algae of the charophyte type (e.g. Spirogyra, Chara) and from C₃ higher plants. The chlorophyte algae fix inorganic carbon by the photosynthetic carbon reduction cycle pathway, but have a low CO₂ compensation point in 250 μM O₂, a low inhibition of CO₂ fixation from 10 μM CO₂/250 μM O₂ when compared with 10 μM CO₂/zero O₂, and a low half-saturation constant for CO₂. These three characteristics are different from those of charophytes and C₃ higher plants, and resemble those of C₄ higher plants. It is suggested that these characteristics of chlorophyte algae are the result of a ‘CO₂ concentrating mechanism’ which increases the CO₂/O₂ ratio at the site of ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase action in a similar way to that achieved by the C₄?C₃ acid cycle in C₄ plants. In the chlorophyte algae, however, CO₂ concentration probably involves active HCO₃^? transport at the inner membrane of the chloroplast envelope. Active HCO₃^? transport can occur at the plasmalemma of charophyte algae and submerged aquatic higher plants as well as chlorophyte algae, so it is unlikely to explain the differences between the two groups of aquatic green plants. Differences in the properties of ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase, and differences in CO₂ production in the light, also seem inadequate to account for the different photosynthetic characteristics. The chlorophyte type of ‘C0₂ concentrating mechanism’ appears to be common in other classes of eukaryotic algae, and in cyanophytes. Some of the ‘advanced’ members of these eukaryotic algal classes (including the chlorophytes) may lack the mechanism, while some ‘primitive’ charophytes may retain the mechanism which their ancestors presumably possessed.     

Effect of nitrogen nutrition on photosynthesis and growth in C4Panicum species

Abstract. The growth and photosynthetic responses to high and low N nutrition were measured in 2 NADP-malic enzyme and 4 NAD-malic enzyme C₄ subtype Panicum species to evaluate whether differences in C₄ photosynthetic biochemistry result in differences in the N requirement for growth. All species had lower biomass production, photosynthesis rates, and shoot N concentrations at low N, and no consistent differences between the C₄ subtypes were apparent. The assimilation rates (biomass accumulated over the period of growth) for the NADP-malic enzyme species were higher than the NAD-malic enzyme species at high N but not at low N. When assimilation rates were evaluated on a shoot N basis a higher N-use-efficiency was found for the NADP-malic enzyme species at high N. Thus the NADP-malic enzyme Panicum species had a greater amount of growth for a given shoot N concentration, but only above a certain level of shoot N concentrations.     

Dorsoventral variations in dark chilling effects on photosynthesis and stomatal function in Paspalum dilatatum leaves

The effects of dark chilling on the leaf-side-specific regulation of photosynthesis were characterized in the C(4) grass Paspalum dilatatum. CO(2)- and light-response curves for photosynthesis and associated parameters were measured on whole leaves and on each leaf side independently under adaxial and abaxial illumination before and after plants were exposed to dark chilling for one or two consecutive nights. The stomata closed on the adaxial sides of the leaves under abaxial illumination and no CO(2) uptake could be detected on this surface. However, high rates of whole leaf photosynthesis were still observed because CO(2) assimilation rates were increased on the abaxial sides of the leaves under abaxial illumination. Under adaxial illumination both leaf surfaces contributed to the inhibition of whole leaf photosynthesis observed after one night of chilling. After two nights of chilling photosynthesis remained inhibited on the abaxial side of the leaf but the adaxial side had recovered, an effect related to increased maximal ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylation rates (V(cmax)) and enhanced maximal electron transport rates (J(max)). Under abaxial illumination, whole leaf photosynthesis was decreased only after the second night of chilling. The chilling-dependent inhibition of photosynthesis was located largely on the abaxial side of the leaf and was related to decreased V(cmax) and J(max), but not to the maximal phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase carboxylation rate (V(pmax)). Each side of the leaf therefore exhibits a unique sensitivity to stress and recovery. Side-specific responses to stress are related to differences in the control of enzyme and photosynthetic electron transport activities.     

Lack of C4 photosynthetic metabolism in ears of C3 cereals

There is continuing controversy over whether a degree of C₄ photosynthetic metabolism exists in ears of C₃ cereals. In this context, CO₂ exchange and the initial products of photosynthesis were examined in flag leaf blades and various ear parts of two durum wheat (Triticum durum Desf.) and two six-rowed barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) cultivars. Three weeks after anthesis, the CO₂ compensation concentration at 210 mmol mol^?1 O₂ in durum wheat and barley ear parts was similar to or greater than that in flag leaves. The O₂ dependence of the CO₂ compensation concentration in durum wheat ear parts, as well as in the flag leaf blade, was linear, as expected for C₃ photosynthesis. In a complementary experiment, intact and attached ears and flag leaf blades of barley and durum wheat were radio-labelled with ¹⁴CO₂ during a 10s pulse, and the initial products of fixation were studied in various parts of the ears (awns, glumes, inner bracts and grains) and in the flag leaf blade. All tissues assimilated CO₂ mainly by the Calvin (C₃) cycle, with little fixation of ¹⁴CO₂ into the C₄ acids malate and aspartate (about 10% or less). These collective data support the conclusion that in the ear parts of these C₃ cereals C₄ photosynthetic metabolism is nil.