Chromosome 4q35 haplotypes and DNA rearrangements segregating in affected subjects of 19 Italian families with facioscapulohumeral musculatur dystrophy (FSHD)

Four DNA markers on the distal long arm of chromosome 4 have been analyzed for their linkage to facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy locus (FSHD) in a series of 16 Italian families. We found that, in two families, the disease is not linked to the 4q35 markers, indicating the presence of genetic heterogeneity among Italian FSHD families. Linkage analysis in the remaining families supports the order cen-D4S171-D4S163-D4S139-D4S810-FSHD-qter, in agreement with the physical map from the literature. EcoRI digestion and hybridization with the distal marker p13E-11 (D4S810) detected DNA rearrangements in the affected members of both sporadic and familial cases of FSHD, with family-specific fragments ranging in size between 15 kb and 28 kb. In three sporadic FSHD cases, the appearance of a new small fragment not present in either parent was clearly associated with the development of FSHD disease. However, in the familial cases analyzed, we observed two recombinations between all four 4q35 markers and the disease locus in apparently normal subjects, leaving open the possibility of nonpenetrance of the FSHD mutation.

---

     

Evidence for heterogeneity in facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD)

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is a slowly progressive primary disease of muscle which is usually inherited as an autosomal dominant disorder. FSHD has been localized to the long arm of chromosome 4, specifically to the 4q3.5-qter region. Initially published linkage studies showed no evidence for heterogeneity in FSHD. In the present study we have examined individuals in seven FSHD families. Two-point lod scores show significant evidence for linkage for D4S163 (lod score 3.04 at recombination fraction .21) and D4S139 (lod score 3.84 at recombination fraction .20). D4S171 also gave a positive score (lod score 2.56 at recombination fraction .24). Significant evidence for heterogeneity was found for each of the three markers. Multipoint linkage analysis in this region resulted in a peak multipoint lod score of 6.47. The multipoint analysis supported the two-point studies with odds of 20:1 showing linkage and heterogeneity over linkage and homogeneity. Five of the seven families gave a posterior probability of >95% of being of the linked type, while two families appeared unlinked to this region of 4q (P < .01%). Individuals in the two unlinked families met the clinical criteria for the diagnosis of FSHD, including facial weakness, clavicular flattening, scapula winging, proximal muscle weakness, and myopathic changes on muscle biopsies without inflammatory or mitochondrial pathology. This study demonstrates genetic heterogeneity in FSHD and has important implications for both genetic counseling and the elucidation of the etiology of FSHD.     

Mapping of facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy gene to chromosome 4q35-qter by multipoint linkage analysis and in situ hybridization

We have recently assigned the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) gene to chromosome 4 by linkage to the microsatellite marker Mfd 22 (locus D4S171). We now report that D4S139, a VNTR locus, is much more closely linked to FSHD. Two-point linkage analysis between FSHD and D4S139 in nine informative families showed a maximum combined lod score (Z_max) of 17.28 at a recombination fraction θ of 0.027. Multipoint linkage analysis between FSHD and the loci D4S139 and D4S171 resulted in a peak lod score of 20.21 at 2.7 cM from D4S139. Due to the small number of recombinants found with D4S139, the position of the FSHD gene relative to that of D4S139 could not be established with certainty. D4S139 was mapped to chromosome 4q35-qter by in situ hybridization, thus firmly establishing the location of the FSHD gene in the subtelomeric region of chromosome 4q. One small family yielded a negative lod score for D4S139. In the other families no significant evidence for genetic heterogeneity was obtained. Studies of additional markers and new families will improve the map of the FSHD region, reveal possible genetic heterogeneity, and allow better diagnostic reliability.     

Mapping of facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy gene to chromosome 4q35-qter by multipoint linkage analysis and in situ hybridization

We have recently assigned the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) gene to chromome 4 by linkage to the microsatellite marker Mfd 22 (locus D4S171). We now report that D4S139, a VNTR locus, is much more closely linked to FSHD. Two-point linkage analysis between FSHD and D4S139 in nine informative families showed a maximum combined lod score (Zmax) of 17.28 at a recombination fraction theta of 0.027. Multipoint linkage analysis between FSHD and the loci D4S139 and D4S171 resulted in a peak lod score of 20.21 at 2.7 cM from D4S139. Due to the small number of recombinants found with D4S139, the position of the FSHD gene relative to that of D4S139 could not be established with certainty. D4S139 was mapped to chromosome 4q35-qter by in situ hybridization, thus firmly establishing the location of the FSHD gene in the subtelomeric region of chromosome 4q. One small family yielded a negative lod score for D4S139. In the other families no significant evidence for genetic heterogeneity was obtained. Studies of additional markers and new families will improve the map of the FSHD region, reveal possible genetic heterogeneity, and allow better diagnostic reliability.     

Mosaicism for the Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A duplication suggests somatic reversion

A female patient with clinical signs and symptoms of a demyelinating neuropathy was shown to have a duplication of the 1.5-Mb region on chromosome 17p11.2, typical of the great majority of cases of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A (CMT1A). However, analysis of DNA extracted from peripheral blood revealed a 2:2.4 instead of the usual 2:3 ratio between the 7.8- and 6.0-kb EcoRI fragments in the proximal and distal repetitive extragenic palindromic (REP) elements of CMT1A. Detection of a 3.2-kb EcoRI/SacI kb junction fragment with probe pLR7.8 confirmed the CMT1A duplication. The dosage of this junction fragment, compared with a 2.8-kb EcoRI/SacI fragment of the proximal REP elements of CMT1A, was 2:0.58 instead of the expected 2:1 dosage for heterozygous CMT1A duplications. We hypothesized that the lower dosages of these restriction fragments specific for the CMT1A duplication were due to mosaicism; this was confirmed by fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis with the D17S122-specific probe pVAW409R1. In peripheral blood lymphocytes the percentage of interphase nuclei with a duplication in 17p11.2 was 49%. In interphase nuclei extracted from buccal mucosa, hair-root cells or paraffin-embedded nervous tissue the duplication was detectable in 51%, 66% and 74%, respectively. This is the first report of mosaicism in a patient with a CMT1A duplication identified by three different and independent techniques. Received: 14 November 1995 / Revised: 13 February 1996     

The human skeletal muscle adenine nucleotide translocator gene maps to chromosome 4q35 in the region of the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy locus

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is a relatively common autosomal dominant neuromuscular disorder. The gene for FSHD has recently been assigned to chromosome 4q35. Although abnormal mitochondrial and biochemical changes have been observed in FSHD, the molecular defect is unknown. In addition to the FSHD gene, the human muscle adenine nucleotide translocator gene (ANT1) is located on chromosome 4. Interestingly, biochemical studies recently showed a possible defect of ANT1. In order to evaluate the potential role of ANT1 in the etiology of FSHD, the human ANT1 gene was isolated by cosmid cloning and localized to 4q35, in the region containing the FSHD gene. However, in situ hybridization and physical mapping of somatic cell hybrids localized the ANT1 gene proximal to the FSHD gene. In addition, a polymorphic CA-repeat 5 kb upsstream of the ANT1 gene was used as a marker in FSHD and Centre d'Etude du Polymorphisme Humain families to perform linkage analysis. These data together exclude ANT1 as the primary candidate gene for FSHD. The most likely order of the loci on chromosome 4q35 is cen-ANT1-D4S171-F11-D4S187-D4S163-D4S139-FSHD-tel.     

Linkage analyses of five chromosome 4 markers localizes the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) gene to distal 4q35

The genetic locus for facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) has been mapped to chromosome 4. We have examined linkage to five chromosome 4q DNA markers in 22 multigenerational FSHD families. Multipoint linkage analyses of the segregation of four markers in the FSHD families and in 40 multigenerational mapping families from the Centre d'Etude du Polymorphisme Humaine enabled these loci and FSHD to be placed in the following order: cen-D4S171-factor XI-D4S163-D4S139-FSHD-qter. One interval, D4S171-FSHD, showed significant sex-specific differences in recombination. Homogeneity tests supported linkage of FSHD to these 4q DNA markers in all of the families we studied. The position of FSHD is consistent with that generated by other groups as members of an international FSHD consortium.     

De novo facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy: frequent somatic mosaicism, sex-dependent phenotype, and the role of mitotic transchromosomal repeat interaction between chromosomes 4 and 10

Autosomal dominant facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is caused by deletion of most copies of the 3.3-kb subtelomeric D4Z4 repeat array on chromosome 4q. The molecular mechanisms behind the deletion and the high proportion of new mutations have remained elusive. We surveyed 35 de novo FSHD families and found somatic mosaicism in 40% of cases, in either the patient or an asymptomatic parent. Mosaic males were typically affected; mosaic females were more often the unaffected parent of a nonmosaic de novo patient. A genotypic-severity score, composed of the residual repeat size and the degree of somatic mosaicism, yields a consistent relationship with severity and age at onset of disease. Mosaic females had a higher proportion of somatic mosaicism than did mosaic males. The repeat deletion is significantly enhanced by supernumerary homologous repeat arrays. In 10% of normal chromosomes, 4-type repeat arrays are present on chromosome 10. In mosaic individuals, 4-type repeats on chromosome 10 are almost five times more frequent. The reverse configuration, also 10% in normal chromosomes, was not found, indicating that mutations may arise from transchromosomal interaction, to which the increase in 4-type repeat clusters is a predisposing factor. The somatic mosaicism suggests a mainly mitotic origin; mitotic interchromosomal gene conversion or translocation between fully homologous 4-type repeat arrays may be a major mechanism for FSHD mutations.     

Linkage localization of facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) in 4q35.

Fasioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) has recently been localized to 4q35. We have studied four families with FSHD. Linkage to the 4q35 probes D4S163, D4S139, and D4S171 was confirmed. We found no recombinants helpful in detailed localization of the FSHD gene. Two of our families include males with a rapidly progressive muscle disease that had been diagnosed, on the basis of clinical features, as Duchenne muscular dystrophy. One of these males is available for linkage study and shares the haplotype of his FSHD-affected aunt and cousin.     

Linkage studies in facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD)

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) has been localized to the 4q35-qter region of chromosome 4. Linkage analyses of two polymorphic markers from the region, D4S139 and D4S163, have been carried out using four large multigenerational FSHD families. The results indicate that both markers are closely linked to FSHD, with D4S139 being the closest proximal marker to FSHD.     

High proportion of new mutations and possible anticipation in Brazilian facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy families.

A gene responsible for facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) has been localized at 4q35. Subsequently, it was found that probe p13E-11 detects a polymorphic EcoRI fragment, usually > 28 kb, in normal individuals, whereas in sporadic and familial FSHD cases, an EcoRI fragment, usually < 28 kb, was found. Although these findings have been amply confirmed, several aspects are as yet either controversial or unsolved. In the present investigation, 34 Brazilian FSHD families were studied at the clinical and the molecular level for the following purposes: to assess the frequency of new mutations and their effect on estimates of biological fitness, to characterize FSHD-associated EcoRI fragments detected with probe p13E-11 in familial--as compared with isolated--FSHD cases, and to assess whether anticipation occurs in multigenerational families. Results from our study suggest that new mutations are apparently frequent for FSHD and may account for at least one-third of the cases, that somatic mosaicism may not be rare, and that biological fitness appeared to be reduced in FSHD, ranging from 0.6 to 0.82 by different estimates, with no difference in sexes. Interestingly, the size of the new EcoRI fragment is apparently smaller in more severely affected isolated patients. Moreover, the age at onset of clinical signs, as well as the age at ascertainment, in patients from multigenerational families suggests that anticipation occurs for FSHD in the majority of the families.     

Regional localization and molecular characterization of a DNA sequence on the long arm of chromosome 22

Summary A human genomic DNA fragment, p22hom13 (D22S16), was isolated from a chromosome 22-specific library. After elimination of repetitive sequences, a single copy BamHI-EcoRI fragment was subcloned into pTZ18. By using mouse/human somatic cell hybrids and in situ hybridization, the new DNA probe was mapped to chromosome 22q13-qter. Its application in the analysis of the distal part of chromosome 22 and its diagnostic use in translocations are discussed.     

Regional mapping of facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy gene on 4q35: Combined analysis of an international consortium

Members of an international consortium for linkage analysis of the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) gene have pooled data for joint analyses, in an attempt to determine the precise location of the FSHD gene and the order of four DNA markers on 4q35 region. Six laboratories determined a total of 3,078 genotypes in 65 families, consisting of a total of 504 affected subjects and 559 unaffected subjects. For each marker, a mean of 648 meioses were informative. D4S139 and D4S163 were identified as the closest linked markers to the FSHD locus, with 99% upper confidence intervals of recombination fractions of .08 and .10, respectively. We have used the CRI-MAP program to construct the most likely order of cen-D4S171-F11-D4S163-D4S139-FSHD-tel, with favorable odds of 10(8)-10(114) over all other orders except that in which F11 and D4S171 are reversed, for which the odds ratio was 191:1. With this order, the genetic map of this region extends 25.5 cM in males and 13.8 cM in females (averaging 19.5 cM for sexes combined); the sex difference was statistically significant (P = .0013). Comparison between families for the two-point and multipoint lod scores involving FSHD showed no evidence for heterogeneity of this disorder. However, after the completion of this analysis, one large family which might show heterogeneity was identified. In view of this and the fact that all of the linked markers reside on the same side of the FSHD locus, the clinical application of these markers is not recommended at this time.     

Contractions of D4Z4 on 4qB subtelomeres do not cause facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is associated with contractions of the D4Z4 repeat in the subtelomere of chromosome 4q. Two allelic variants of chromosome 4q (4qA and 4qB) exist in the region distal to D4Z4. Although both variants are almost equally frequent in the population, FSHD is associated exclusively with the 4qA allele. We identified three families with FSHD in which each proband carries two FSHD-sized alleles and is heterozygous for the 4qA/4qB polymorphism. Segregation analysis demonstrated that FSHD-sized 4qB alleles are not associated with disease, since these were present in unaffected family members. Thus, in addition to a contraction of D4Z4, additional cis-acting elements on 4qA may be required for the development of FSHD. Alternatively, 4qB subtelomeres may contain elements that prevent FSHD pathogenesis.     

Localization of a recessive gene for North American Indian childhood cirrhosis to chromosome region 16q22-and identification of a shared haplotype

North American Indian childhood cirrhosis (NAIC, or CIRH1A) is an isolated nonsyndromic form of familial cholestasis reported in Ojibway-Cree children and young adults in northwestern Quebec. The pattern of transmission is consistent with an autosomal recessive mode of inheritance. To map the NAIC locus, we performed a genomewide scan on three DNA pools of samples from 13 patients, 16 unaffected siblings, and 22 parents from five families. Analysis of 333 highly polymorphic markers revealed 3 markers with apparent excess allele sharing among affected individuals. Additional mapping identified a chromosome 16q segment shared by all affected individuals. When the program FASTLINK/LINKAGE was used and a completely penetrant autosomal recessive mode of inheritance was assumed, a maximum LOD score of 4.44 was observed for a recombination fraction of 0, with marker D16S3067. A five-marker haplotype (D16S3067, D16S752, D16S2624, D16S3025, and D16S3106) spanning 4.9 cM was shared by all patients. These results provide significant evidence of linkage for a candidate gene on chromosome 16q22.     

Hybridization analysis of D4Z4 repeat arrays linked to FSHD

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is an autosomal dominant disease involving shortening of D4Z4, an array of tandem 3.3-kb repeat units on chromosome 4. These arrays are in subtelomeric regions of 4q and 10q and have 1–100 units. FSHD is associated with an array of 1–10 units at 4q35. Unambiguous clinical diagnosis of FSHD depends on determining the array length at 4q35, usually with the array-adjacent p13E-11 probe after pulsed-field or linear gel electrophoresis. Complicating factors for molecular diagnosis of FSHD are the phenotypically neutral 10q D4Z4 arrays, cross-hybridizing sequences elsewhere in the genome, deletions including the genomic p13E-11 sequence and part of D4Z4, translocations between 4q and 10q D4Z4 arrays, and the extremely high G + C content of D4Z4 arrays (73%). In this study, we optimized conditions for molecular diagnosis of FSHD with a 1-kb D4Z4 subfragment probe after hybridization with p13E-11. We demonstrate that these hybridization conditions allow the identification of FSHD alleles with deletions of the genomic p13E-11 sequence and aid in determination of the nonpathogenic D4Z4 arrays at 10q. Furthermore, we show that the D4Z4-like sequences present elsewhere in the genome are not tandemly arranged, like those at 4q35 and 10q26.     

Equal proportions of affected cells in muscle and blood of a mosaic carrier of facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy

Autosomal dominant facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is associated with contractions of D4Z4 repeat on 4q35. It displays a remarkable inter- and intra-familial clinical variability ranging from severe phenotype to asymptomatic carriers. Mosaicism for the contracted FSHD-sized allele is a recurrent finding, but only DNA from lymphocytes had been studied. It is currently not known if mosaicism is unequally distributed between different tissues and if muscle is relatively spared for the presence of the disease allele in mosaic asymptomatic carriers of a disease allele. Here we compare DNA extracted from peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL), fibroblasts and muscle from a mosaic asymptomatic female carrier and mother of a FSHD patient. PFGE analysis showed a complex allelic segregation: two independent mitotic rearrangement episodes occurred, resulting in mosaicism for a contracted D4Z4 repeat on 4q35 in the mother and mosaicism for an expanded D4Z4 repeat on 10q26 in the affected daughter. The results show that the proportion of mosaicism in PBL and muscle were comparable, while in fibroblasts there was some variation in the mosaicism, which might be caused by culturing artefacts. This finding supports the hypothesis that a mitotic contraction of D4Z4 is an early embryonic event and indicates that the degree of mosaicism in PBL is representative for that of muscle.     

Cytogenetic and immuno-FISH analysis of the 4q subtelomeric region,which is associated with facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is caused by the shortening of a copy-number polymorphic array of 3.3 kb repeats (D4Z4) at one allelic 4q35.2 region. How this contraction of a subtelomeric tandem array causes FSHD is unknown but indirect evidence suggests that a short array has a cis effect on a distant gene or genes. It was hypothesized that the length of the D4Z4 array determines whether or not the array and a large proximal region are heterochromatic and thereby controls gene expression in cis. To test this, we used fluorescence in situ hybridization probes with FSHD and control myoblasts to characterize the distal portion of 4q35.2 with respect to the following: intense staining with the chromatin dye 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole; association with constitutively heterochromatic foci; extent of binding of heterochromatin protein 1; histone H3 methylation at lysine 9 and lysine 4; histone H4 lysine 8 acetylation; and replication timing within S-phase. Our results indicate that 4q35.2 does not resemble constitutive heterochromatin in FSHD or control myoblasts. Furthermore, in these analyses, the allelic 4q35.2 regions of FSHD myoblasts did not behave differently than those of control myoblasts. Other models for how D4Z4 array contraction causes long-distance regulation of gene expression in cis need to be tested.Communicated by S. Gerbi     

Specific Loss of Histone H3 Lysine 9 Trimethylation and HP1γ/Cohesin Binding at D4Z4 Repeats Is Associated with Facioscapulohumeral Dystrophy (FSHD)

Facioscapulohumeral dystrophy (FSHD) is an autosomal dominant muscular dystrophy in which no mutation of pathogenic gene(s) has been identified. Instead, the disease is, in most cases, genetically linked to a contraction in the number of 3.3 kb D4Z4 repeats on chromosome 4q. How contraction of the 4qter D4Z4 repeats causes muscular dystrophy is not understood. In addition, a smaller group of FSHD cases are not associated with D4Z4 repeat contraction (termed “phenotypic” FSHD), and their etiology remains undefined. We carried out chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis using D4Z4–specific PCR primers to examine the D4Z4 chromatin structure in normal and patient cells as well as in small interfering RNA (siRNA)–treated cells. We found that SUV39H1–mediated H3K9 trimethylation at D4Z4 seen in normal cells is lost in FSHD. Furthermore, the loss of this histone modification occurs not only at the contracted 4q D4Z4 allele, but also at the genetically intact D4Z4 alleles on both chromosomes 4q and 10q, providing the first evidence that the genetic change (contraction) of one 4qD4Z4 allele spreads its effect to other genomic regions. Importantly, this epigenetic change was also observed in the phenotypic FSHD cases with no D4Z4 contraction, but not in other types of muscular dystrophies tested. We found that HP1γ and cohesin are co-recruited to D4Z4 in an H3K9me3–dependent and cell type–specific manner, which is disrupted in FSHD. The results indicate that cohesin plays an active role in HP1 recruitment and is involved in cell type–specific D4Z4 chromatin regulation. Taken together, we identified the loss of both histone H3K9 trimethylation and HP1γ/cohesin binding at D4Z4 to be a faithful marker for the FSHD phenotype. Based on these results, we propose a new model in which the epigenetic change initiated at 4q D4Z4 spreads its effect to other genomic regions, which compromises muscle-specific gene regulation leading to FSHD pathogenesis.