Förster Resonance Energy Transfer — An approach to visualize the spatiotemporal regulation of macromolecular complex formation and compartmentalized cell signaling

Background

Signaling messengers and effector proteins provide an orchestrated molecular machinery to relay extracellular signals to the inside of cells and thereby facilitate distinct cellular behaviors. Formations of intracellular macromolecular complexes and segregation of signaling cascades dynamically regulate the flow of a biological process.

Scope of review

In this review, we provide an overview of the development and application of FRET technology in monitoring cyclic nucleotide-dependent signalings and protein complexes associated with these signalings in real time and space with brief mention of other important signaling messengers and effector proteins involved in compartmentalized signaling.

Major conclusions

The preciseness, rapidity and specificity of cellular responses indicate restricted alterations of signaling messengers, particularly in subcellular compartments rather than globally. Not only the physical confinement and selective depletion, but also the intra- and inter-molecular interactions of signaling effectors modulate the direction of signal transduction in a compartmentalized fashion. To understand the finer details of various intracellular signaling cascades and crosstalk between proteins and other effectors, it is important to visualize these processes in live cells. Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) has been established as a useful tool to do this, even with its inherent limitations.

General significance

FRET technology remains as an effective tool for unraveling the complex organization and distribution of various endogenous signaling proteins, as well as the spatiotemporal dynamics of second messengers inside a single cell to distinguish the heterogeneity of cell signaling under normal physiological conditions and during pathological events.     

Operational description of microsystems formation in prebiological molecular evolution

A theoretical analogue of microsystems formation in prebiological molecular evolution, known, for instance, as microspheres of Fox and marigranules of Yanagawa and Egami, is presented for a model solution system of polyamino acids in which the polymerization due to peptide bond synthesis is initially not in a complete balance with the hydrolysis. The homogeneous solution of polyamino acids, which is in a nonequilibrium state in the sense that a complete balance among all the participating reactions has not yet been established, is unstable against forming microscopic compartments of locally condensed peptide bond linkages. It also follows that both the accumulation of polyamino acids and the number of peptide bond linkages inside the localized microsystems increase with time so long as the solution remains in a nonequilibrium state lacking the balance between the polymerization and the hydrolysis. The phase separation of microsystems from the homogeneous solution of polyamino acids is just a representation of the unidirectional dynamic process that any reaction system, which initially lacks a complete balance among all the participating reactions, evolves toward a goal, if any, at which an equilibrium balancing of reactions be finally established.     

Why just eat in,when you can also eat out?

The current working definition of autophagy is the following: all processes in which intracellular material is degraded within the lysosome/vacuole and where the macromolecular constituents are recycled. There are several ways to classify the different types of autophagy. For example, we can separate autophagy into two primary types, based on the initial site of cargo sequestration. In particular, during microautophagy and chaperone-mediated autophagy, uptake occurs directly at the limiting membrane of the lysosome or vacuole. In contrast, macroautophagy—whether selective or nonselective—and endosomal microautophagy involve sequestration within an autophagosome or an omegasome, or late endosomes/multivesicular bodies, respectively; the key point being that in these types of autophagy the initial sequestration event does not occur at the limiting membrane of the degradative organelle. In any case, the cargo is ultimately delivered into the lysosome or vacuole lumen for subsequent degradation. Thus, I think most autophagy researchers view the degradative organelle as the ultimate destination of the pathway. Indeed, this fits with the general concept that organelles allow reactions to be compartmentalized. With regard to the lysosome or vacuole, this also confers a level of safety by keeping the lytic contents away from the remainder of the cell. If we are willing to slightly modify our definition of autophagy, with a focus on “degradation of a cell’s own components through the lysosomal/vacuolar machinery,” we can include a newly documented process, programmed nuclear destruction (PND).     

How can quantum mechanics of material evolution be possible?: Symmetry and symmetry-breaking in protobiological evolution

Material self-assembly as a self-organizing process is always accompanied by symmetry-breaking in the material configuration. Self-sequencing of amino acids during their thermal polymerization has lost a certain property of permutation symmetry that was observed in the mixture of free amino acids. The evolutionary precursor state is more symmetrical about its internal material configuration and more degenerate due to the multitude of the indistinguishable individuals. The evolution proceeds in the direction along which the degeneracy in the internal states dissolves owing to the symmetry-breaking originating in material flow equilibrium of open material aggregates. Protobiological information is latent in the material system which is highly symmetrical and highly degenerate in its internal states. Evolution of matter is an endogenous process in which the earlier symmetric property is lost and less degenerate states are approached. Quantum-mechanically, the generation of protobiological information is due to the symmetry-breaking of the Hamiltonian originating in the interaction with the exterior through material flow, in contrast to the Schrödinger equation which preserves a symmetry and the associated invariants.     

Development of structural organization of protein-synthesizing machinery from prokaryotes to eukaryotes

Though the mechanisms of protein biosynthesis are similar in the cells of prokaryotes and eukaryotes, the eukaryotic translational machinery in the cell is arranged more intricately. One of the most striking characteristic features of the eukaryotic translational machinery is that the eukaryotic proteins involved in the translational process, such as initiation factors, elongation factors and aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, in contrast to their prokaryotic analogs, possess a non-specific affinity for RNA. Due to the RNA-binding ability, these eukaryotic proteins can be compartmentalized on polyribosomes. In addition to the proteins of the translational apparatus, several other eukaryotic RNA-binding proteins can be also compartmentalized on polyribosomes; these proteins include glycolytic enzymes, steroid hormone receptors and intermediate filament proteins. Thus, the eukaryotic polyribosome is an element of the cytoplasmic labile structure on which various proteins can be compartmentalized and, consequently, different biochemical pathways can be integrated.     

On the origin of the genetic code and the stability of the translation apparatus

An “error theory” is developed which can be applied to determine the stability of a macromolecular translation machinery which reproduces itself. It is shown that the overall effects of a multitude of possible error versions of macromolecules can be treated statistically, and that such a statistical approach is of considerable usefulness in the theoretical treatment of complex macromolecular systems. The theory is developed within the context of a detailed treatment of the “frozen accident” hypothesis for the origin of the genetic code. A model is described which permits some thermodynamic characterization of the components involved in the code nucleation. The model also proves useful in resolving a stability “paradox” described by Orgel, which relates to the translation stability in present-day organisms and mechanisms of ageing. It indicates that any experimentally found decrease in translation accuracy with age is probably not due to an inherent instability in the translation apparatus. Relevant experiments are suggested.     

Infection of skin fibroblasts in animals with different levels of sensitivity to Leishmania infantum and Leishmania mexicana (Kinetoplastida: Trypanosomatidae)

Infection and multiplication of Leishmania infantum and L. mexicana inside of skin fibroblasts from hamsters, mice and rats was achieved. This process was demonstrated either by counting parasites inside the stained cells or by electronic microscopy studies. In addition multiplication rate differences in the cells from these rodent species were determined, for L. infantum as well as for L. mexicana. Parasite development in hamsters and mice fibroblasts was evident but there was not multiplication in rat cells showing that apparently they are refractory to Leishmania infection. These results suggest that the parasite affinity for each animal, as well as any intracellular environment resistance, could involve genetic factors in the parasite multiplication. On the other hand, presence of amastigote multiplication inside of parasitophorus vacuole, showed by electronic microscopy images, probes a true parasite transformation. Therefore it is suggested that fibroblasts could work as host cells for parasite survival and permanency in the infected animals.     

Macromolecular mimicry

Some proteins have been shown to mimic the overall shape and structure of nucleic acids. For some of the proteins involved in translating the genetic information into proteins on the ribosome particle, there are indications that such observations of macromolecular mimicry even extend to similarity in interaction with and function on the ribosome. A small number of structural results obtained outside the protein biosynthesis machinery could indicate that the concept of macromolecular mimicry between proteins and nucleic acids is more general. The implications for the function and evolution of protein biosynthesis are discussed.     

Nutrient Uptake by Protocells: A Liposome Model System

Over the past decade, several liposome-basedmodels for protocells have been developed. Forexample, liposome systems composed of polymeraseenzymes encapsulated with their substrates havedemonstrated that complex compartmentalized reactionscan be carried out under conditions in which polymericproducts are protected from degradation by hydrolyticenzymes present in the external medium. However, suchsystems do not have nutrient uptake mechanisms, whichwould be essential for primitive cells lacking thehighly evolved nutrient transport processes present inall contemporary cells. In this report, we explorepassive diffusion of solutes across lipid bilayers asone possible uptake mechanism. We have establishedconditions under which ionic substrates as large asATP can permeate bilayers at rates capable ofsupplying an encapsulated template-dependent RNApolymerase. Furthermore, while allowing the permeationof monomer substrates such as ATP, bilayer vesiclesselectively retained polymerization products as smallas dimers and as large as a transfer RNA. Theseobservations demonstrate that passive diffusion couldbe used by the earliest forms of cellular life fortransport of important nutrients such as amino acids,phosphate, and phosphorylated organic solutes.     

An inventory of the bacterial macromolecular components and their spatial organization

Formerly regarded as small 'bags' of nucleic acids with randomly diffusing enzymes, bacteria are organized by a sophisticated and tightly regulated molecular machinery. Here, we review qualitative and quantitative data on the intracellular organization of bacteria and provide a detailed inventory of macromolecular structures such as the divisome, the degradosome and the bacterial 'nucleolus'. We discuss how these metabolically active structures manage the spatial organization of the cell and how macromolecular crowding influences them. We present for the first time a visualization program, lifeexplorer, that can be used to study the interplay between metabolism and spatial organization of a prokaryotic cell.     

Origin of life: A hypothesis for the origin of adaptor-mediated ordered synthesis of proteins and an explanation for the choice of terminating codons in the genetic code

Life can be defined as a system of self-sustained chemical processes springing from the ordered synthesis of proteins directed by nucleic acids. To the notoriously difficult problem of the origin of this basic process of nucleic acid-directed protein synthesis, we give a solution of molecular interactions between pentanucleotides and amino acids. A particular conformation of a pentanucleotide forms a double sided template, with its ‘inside’ capable of nestling an amino acid while the ‘outside’ acts as an adaptor to a ‘codon’ triplet on long-chain nucleic acids. This serves as a primitive decoding system. An important aspect of our postulate is that a dynamic interaction is triggered, by this decoding system, through which amino acids are brought to juxtaposition facilitating peptide bond formation. Almost all the important and unique features of contemporary protein-synthesizing machinery are seen to be a direct and natural consequence of our postulate. The emergence of the termination codons also fits in, as a natural consequence of this molecular mechanism.     

Herpes Simplex Virus Types 1 and 2 Completely Help Adenovirus-Associated Virus Replication

In addition to adenoviruses, which are capable of completely helping adenovirus-associated virus (AAV) multiplication, only herpesviruses are known to provide any AAV helper activity, but this activity has been thought to be partial (i.e., AAV DNA, RNA, and protein syntheses are induced, but infectious particles are not assembled). In this study, however, we show that herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) and type 2 (HSV-2) are in fact complete AAV helpers and that AAV type 2 (AAV2) infectivity yields can approach those obtained when coinfections are carried out with a helper adenovirus. AAV helper activity was demonstrated in KB cells with two HSV-1 strains (11124 and 17MP) and an HSV-2 strain (HG52). Each herpesvirus supported AAV2 multiplication with comparable efficiency. AAV2 multiplication was similarly efficient in HSV-1 coinfections of HeLa cells, whereas lower yields were obtained in HEp-2 and primary human embryonic kidney cells. HSV-1 also supported AAV1 multiplication in HeLa cells but, at corresponding multiplicities of infection, AAV1 grew less efficiently than AAV2. Comparisons of the time courses of AAV2 DNA, RNA, and protein syntheses after coinfection with either adenovirus type 5 or HSV-1 revealed that, in each case, the onset of synthesis and attainment of maximal synthesis rate occurred earlier in coinfections with HSV-1. These findings demonstrate the linkage of AAV macromolecular synthesis to an event(s) in the helper virus cycle. Aside from this temporal association, helper-related differences in AAV macromolecular synthesis were not apparent.     

PHA stimulation of human lymphocytes during amino acid deprivation. Protein,RNA and DNA synthesis

Resting lymphocytes are in the G₀ phase of the cell cycle. Upon activation by PHA, they progress into G₁ with accompanying increased protein and RNA synthesis, initiate DNA synthesis and divide. We have studied the kinetics of inhibition of macromolecular synthesis during activation in the absence of single amino acids. Three types of kinetics are observed. In the absence of tryptophan or isoleucine, stimulated lymphocytes show a normal increase in protein and RNA synthesis during the first 30 hours of stimulation, initiate DNA synthesis but are subsequently inhibited. In phenylalanine-deficient medium, no DNA synthesis occurs in spite of a slight increase in protein synthesis. No increase in macromolecular synthesis is observed in medium lacking any one of the other essential amino acids (eg: lysine). Our results indicate that the kinetics of macromolecular synthesis in tryptophan-deficient medium is the result of a limited reserve of protein-bound tryptophan which becomes exhausted after 30 hours. On the other hand, delayed inhibition of synthesis in isoleucine-deficient medium probably reflects an initially low requirement for this amino acid followed by inhibition of the synthesis of isoleucine-rich proteins involved in some late event of stimulation. Partial deprivation of lysine results in kinetics of protein synthesis similar to that in tryptophan- or isoleucine-deficient media. The results indicate that the kinetics of macromolecular synthesis during activation of lymphocytes in the absence of an essential amino acid is a function of the quantitative requirement for that amino acid, at a given time during stimulation. Upon replacement of lysine, lymphocytes inhibited by lysine deficiency begin RNA and protein synthesis immediately and at a rate faster than that of unstimulated cultures to which PHA is added. They also initiate DNA synthesis earlier and therefore, are closer to the S phase than resting lymphocytes. It is concluded that lymphocytes stimulated in the absence of lysine are activated even though no overall increase in macromolecular synthesis is observed. Furthermore, the kinetics of DNA synthesis following reversal of inhibition by phenylalanine suggests that lymphocytes stimulated during phenylalanine deprivation become arrested at most six hours before S. These results indicate that amino acid deficiencies lead to arrest of activated lymphocytes at various stages of stimulation, depending on how stringent these deficiencies are.     

Partial ischemia and proteinuria during isolated kidney perfusion is accompanied by the release of vascular [35S]heparan sulfate

The isolated kidney perfused with modified Krebs-Henseleit buffer with amino acids yields heavy proteinuria associated with reduced ATP levels characteristic of partial ischemia. These conditions are associated with a similar perfusion time dependent release of degraded vascular [35S]heparan sulfate proteoglycan into the perfusate solution which included a 60% loss of [35S]macromolecular material from the glomerulus after 2h of perfusion. Small amounts of [35S]macromolecular material were found in the urine and lymph. These results demonstrate that partial ischemia promotes a specific response in the overall renal vasculature, probably involving oxygen reactive metabolites, that results in the preferential release of heparan sulphate from the basement membrane and endothelial cells on the luminal side of the capillary wall.     

Cell-free protein synthesis: the state of the art

Cell-free protein synthesis harnesses the synthetic power of biology, programming the ribosomal translational machinery of the cell to create macromolecular products. Like PCR, which uses cellular replication machinery to create a DNA amplifier, cell-free protein synthesis is emerging as a transformative technology with broad applications in protein engineering, biopharmaceutical development, and post-genomic research. By breaking free from the constraints of cell-based systems, it takes the next step towards synthetic biology. Recent advances in reconstituted cell-free protein synthesis (Protein synthesis Using Recombinant Elements expression systems) are creating new opportunities to tailor the reactions for specialized applications including in vitro protein evolution, printing protein microarrays, isotopic labeling, and incorporating nonnatural amino acids.     

Modulation of alternative pre-mRNA splicing in vivo by pinin

Pre-mRNA splicing occurs in a large macromolecular RNA-protein complex called the spliceosome. The major components of the spliceosome include snRNP and SR proteins. We have previously identified an SR-like protein, pinin (pnn), which is localized not only in nuclear speckles but also at desmosomes. The nuclear localization of pnn is a dynamic process because pnn can be found not only with SR proteins in nuclear speckles but also in enlarged speckles following treatment of cells with RNA polymerase II inhibitors, DRB, and alpha-amanitin. Using adenovirus E1A and chimeric calcitonin/dhfr construct as a splicing reporter minigene in combination with cellular cotransfection, we found that pnn regulates alternative 5(') and 3(') splicing by decreasing the use of distal splice sites. Regulation of 5(') splice site choice was also observed for RNPS1, a general splicing activator that interacts with pnn in nuclear speckles. The regulatory ability of pnn in alternative 5(') splicing, however, was not dependent on RNPS1 and a pnn mutant, lacking the N-terminal 167 amino acids, behaved like a dominant negative species, inhibiting E1A splicing when applied in splicing assays. These results provide direct evidence that pnn functions as a splicing regulator which participates itself directly in splicing reaction or indirectly via other components of splicing machinery.     

Involvement of an “all-or-none event” in the triggering of chromosome segregation and of S phase in procaryotic and eucaryotic cells

A structural model of the triggering of mitosis is described. It is proposed that the number of structural effectors varies discontinuously both just before mitosis through an “all-or-none event” and during the mitotic process itself. The effector persists from mitosis to mitosis, but is not active in G2 due to the polymerization of soluble monomers. The “all-or-none event” which triggers mitosis is postulated to involve the doubling of the number of the structural effectors which are then temporarily in an active state, thus initiating mitosis. The subsequent segregation during mitosis of the active structural effectors to the two dividing nuclei allows the initiation of S phase as soon as the chromosomal replicative machinery is ready.     

A window of opportunity: timing protein degradation by trimming of sugars and ubiquitins

Of the many post-translational modifications of proteins, ubiquitination and N-glycosylation stand out because they are polymeric additions. In contrast to single-unit modifications, the fate of the modified protein is determined by the dynamic equilibrium of polymerization versus depolymerization, rather than by the initial addition itself. Notably, it is the trimming of sugar chains and elongation of polyubiquitin that target the protein to degradation. Recent research suggests that, for each process, special receptors recognize chains that reach an appropriate length and commit the conjugated substrate for proteasomal disposal. We propose that the 'magic numbers' are loss of at least three mannose residues from the initial chain, or extension to at least four ubiquitins. Although these processes are compartmentalized to either side of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane, some proteins are sequentially subjected to both because they transverse this membrane for ER-associated degradation.     

Reactivity of triglycerides and fatty acids of rapeseed oil in supercritical alcohols

A catalyst-free biodiesel production method with supercritical methanol has been developed that allows a simple process and high yield because of simultaneous transesterification of triglycerides and methyl esterification of fatty acids. From these lines of evidence, we expected that similar results would be attained with the use of various alcohols by the supercritical treatment. However, it still remains unclear which type of reaction, transesterification or alkyl esterification, is faster. This parameter would be important in designing the optimum reaction conditions of the supercritical alcohol method. Therefore, we studied the effect of transesterification of triglycerides and esterification of fatty acids in rapeseed oil. Reaction temperature was set at 300 degrees C, and methanol, ethanol, 1-propanol, 1-butanol or 1-octanol was used as the reactant. The results showed that transesterification of triglycerides (rapeseed oil) was slower in reaction rates than alkyl esterification of fatty acids for any of the alcohols employed. Furthermore, saturated fatty acids such as palmitic and stearic acids had slightly lower reactivity than that of the unsaturated fatty acids; oleic, linoleic and linolenic.