Influence of amino acid starvation on guanosine 5''-diphosphate 3''-diphosphate basal-level synthesis in Escherichia coli.

We observed that the synthesis of basal-level guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp) in both relA mutants and relA+ relC strains of Escherichia coli decreased in response to amino acid limitation and that this was accompanied by an increase in ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis. Addition of the required amino acid to starved cultures of relaxed bacteria resulted in the resumption of ppGpp synthesis and a concomitant decrease in RNA production. Our results indicate that relA mutants retain a stringent factor-independent ribosomal mechanism for basal-level ppGpp synthesis. They also suggest that in relA+ bacteria, stringent factor-mediated ppGpp synthesis and the production of basal-level ppGpp are mutually exclusive. These findings substantiate the hypothesis that there are two functionally discrete mechanisms for ppGpp synthesis in E. coli. Through these studies we have also obtained new evidence which indicates that ppGpp serves as a modulator of RNA synthesis during balanced growth as well as under conditions of nutritional downshift and starvation.     

Role of peptide chain elongation factor G in guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate synthesis.

In a wild-type strain (relA+) of Escherichia coli, starvation of amino acid led to an immediate cessation of the synthesis of stable ribonucleic acids, together with the accumulation of an unusual nucleotide, guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate, commonly known as ppGpp. This compound also accumulated during heat shock. When temperature-sensitive protein synthesis elongation factor G (EF-G) was introduced into E. coli NF859, a relA+ strain, the synthesis of ppGpp was reduced to approximately one-half that of wild-type EF-G+ cells at a nonpermissive temperature of 40 degrees C. Furthermore, fusidic acid, an inhibitor of protein synthesis which specifically inactivates EF-G, prevented any accumulation of ppGpp during the heat shock. We suggest that a functional EF-G protein is necessary for ppGpp accumulation under temperature shift conditions, possibly by mediating changes in the function of another protein, the relA gene product. However, EF-G is probably not required for the synthesis of ppGpp during the stringent response, since its inactivation did not prevent ppGpp accumulation during amino acid starvation.     

Relaxed mutants of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

When Escherichia coli cells are treated with either polymixin or gramicidin at concentrations that block protein and RNA synthesis, they accumulate a significant amount of guanosine tetraphosphate ppGpp. Such accumulation occurs in stringent (relA+) as well as in relaxed (relA) strains and no guanosine pentaphosphate pppGpp is then detected within the cells. These observations suggest that polypeptide antibiotics elicit ppGpp formation through a mechanism different from the stringent control system triggered by amino acid starvation of bacteria. Experiments based on tetracycline action indicate, moreover, that the accumulation of ppGpp under polymixin or gramicidin treatment is connected with a strong restriction of the degradation rate of this nucleotide.     

Role of protein synthesis in the survival of carbon-starved Escherichia coli K-12.

In a typical Escherichia coli K-12 culture starved for glucose, 50% of the cells lose viability in ca. 6 days (Reeve et al., J. Bacteriol. 157:758-763, 1984). Inhibition of protein synthesis by chloramphenicol resulted in a more rapid loss of viability in glucose-starved E. coli K-12 cultures. The more chloramphenicol added (i.e., the more protein synthesis was inhibited) and the earlier during starvation it was added, the greater was its effect on culture viability. Chloramphenicol was found to have the same effect on a relA strain as on an isogenic relA+ strain of E. coli. Addition of the amino acid analogs S-2-aminoethylcysteine, 7-azatryptophan, and p-fluorophenylalanine to carbon-starved cultures to induce synthesis of abnormal proteins had an effect on viability similar to that observed when 50 micrograms of chloramphenicol per ml was added at zero time for starvation. Both chloramphenicol and the amino acid analogs had delayed effects on viability, compared with their effects on synthesis of normal proteins. The need for protein synthesis did not arise from cryptic growth, since no cryptic growth of the starving cells was observed under the conditions used. From these and previous results obtained from work with peptidase-deficient mutants of E. coli K-12 and Salmonella typhimurium LT2 (Reeve et al., J. Bacteriol. 157:758-763, 1984), we concluded that a number of survival-related proteins are synthesized by E. coli K-12 cells as a response to carbon starvation. These proteins are largely synthesized during the early hours of starvation, but their continued activity is required for long-term survival.     

Residual guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate synthetic activity of relA null mutants can be eliminated by spoT null mutations

It was known previously that 1) the relA gene of Escherichia coli encodes an enzyme capable of guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp) synthesis, 2) an uncharacterized source of ppGpp synthesis exists in relA null strains, and 3) cellular degradation of ppGpp is mainly due to a manganese-dependent ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase encoded by the spoT gene. Here, the effects of spoT gene insertions and deletions are compared with analogous alterations in neighboring genes in the spo operon and found to be lethal in relA+ strains as well as slower growing in relAl backgrounds than delta relA hosts. Cells with null alleles in both the relA and spoT genes are found no longer to accumulate ppGpp after glucose exhaustion or after chelation of manganese ions by picolinic acid addition; the inability to form ppGpp is reversed by a minimal spoT gene on a multicopy plasmid. Strains apparently lacking ppGpp show a complex phenotype including auxotrophy for several amino acids and morphological alterations. We propose that the SpoT protein can either catalyze or control the alternative pathway of ppGpp synthesis in addition to its known role as a (p)ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase. We favor the possibility that the SpoT protein is a bifunctional enzyme capable of catalyzing either ppGpp synthesis or degradation.     

Role of the spoT gene product and manganese ion in the metabolism of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate in Escherichia coli.

Addition of divalent ion chelating agents picolinic acid, 1,10-phenanthroline, or quinoline-2-carboxylic acid to wild type, relA, or relX, but not spoT strains of Escherichia coli increases the levels of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp). Poorly chelating analogs of these agents and a larger and more highly charged chelating agent, ethylene glycol bis(beta-amino-ethyl ether) N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid are ineffective. Mn2+ reverses the increase in ppGpp. The increase in ppGpp in wild type cells can be explained by an inhibition of degradation. In spoT cells the response is more complex; ppGpp does not increase although degradation is completely inhibited. The lack of increase in spoT cells suggests a role for spoT in synthesis of ppGpp in addition to its known role in degradation. Growth of both spoT+ and spoT cells is inhibited following chelator addition. This suggests that growth inhibition is through a mechanism not directly involving ppGpp. The results of this study provide evidence in intact cells for a role for Mn2+ and the spoT gene product in ppGpp degradation, and provide further evidence for an involvement of spoT and possibly divalent ions in ppGpp synthesis.     

Accumulation of ppGpp in a relA mutant of Escherichia coli during amino acid starvation

In Escherichia coli, amino acid starvation triggers the rapid synthesis of two guanosine polyphosphates, pppGpp and ppGpp (the 3'-pyrophosphates of GTP and GDP, respectively). Determination of the turnover rate of the ppGpp pool indicated that during serine deprivation, as opposed to other amino acid starvations, the rate of ppGpp degradation is dramatically decreased. This results in a slow but significant accumulation of this regulatory nucleotide in a relA mutant during serine starvation. Similar ppGpp accumulation can be seen during serine starvation in different serine auxotrophic mutants carrying different relA alleles. On the other hand, no ppGpp accumulation is induced in various relaxed strains by serine hydroxamate treatment.     

Characterization of the relA1 mutation and a comparison of relA1 with new relA null alleles in Escherichia coli

The most widely studied "relaxed" mutant of the relA locus, the relA1 allele, is shown here to consist of an IS2 insertion between the 85th and 86th codons of the otherwise wild-type relA structural gene, which normally encodes a 743-amino acid (84 kDa) protein. The RelA protein is a ribosome-dependent ATP:GTP (GDP) pyrophosphoryltransferase that is activated during the stringent response to amino acid starvation and thereby occasions the accumulation of guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp). We propose that the IS2 insertion functionally splits the RelA protein into two (alpha and beta) peptide fragments which can complement each other in trans to yield residual ppGpp synthetic activity; neither fragment shows this activity when expressed alone. Cell strains with a single copy relA null allele show physiological behavior that is much the same as relA1 mutant strains. Both relA1 and relA null strains accumulate ppGpp during glucose starvation and do not accumulate ppGpp during the stringent response. The presence of ppGpp in verifiable relA null strains is interpreted as unequivocal evidence for an alternate route of ppGpp synthesis that exists in addition to the relA-dependent reaction.     

Correlation between RNA synthesis and basal level guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate in relaxed mutants of Escherichia coli

Through the use of a new nucleotide extraction procedure, we had previously shown that relaxed mutants of Escherichia coli exhibit a unique response to amino acid starvation (Lagosky, P. A., and Chang, F. N. (1980) J. Bacteriol. 144, 499-508). The basal level amounts of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp) in both relA and phenotypically relaxed relA+ rplK (relC) strains were shown to decrease at the onset of amino acid limitation and to remain severely depressed throughout the course of the starvation. Upon resupplementation of amino acid-starved relaxed mutants, the production of ppGpp resumes and results in the temporary overaccumulation of this nucleotide beyond its original basal level amount. We now show that the basal level ppGpp content of relaxed bacteria, as well as its subsequent fluctuations in response to amino acid starvation, is inversely correlated with the initial rates of RNA synthesis in these strains. The ability of ppGpp to control the rate of protein synthesis in relA mutants was also examined. It was observed that ppGpp had no apparent direct effect on the initial rates of protein synthesis in relA mutants. The constant inverse correlation which exists between ppGpp content in relA mutants, and their rates of RNa synthesis provide evidence which indicates that basal level ppGpp synthesis has definite physiological significance. It also suggests that the synthesis of basal level ppGpp might be an absolute requirement needed for normal bacterial growth.     

Stringent control during carbon starvation of marine Vibrio sp. strain S14: molecular cloning, nucleotide sequence, and deletion of the relA gene.

In order to evaluate the role of the stringent response in starvation adaptations of the marine Vibrio sp. strain S14, we have cloned the relA gene and generated relaxed mutants of this organism. The Vibrio relA gene was selected from a chromosomal DNA library by complementation of an Escherichia coli delta relA strain. The nucleotide sequence contains a 743-codon open reading frame that encodes a polypeptide that is identical in length and highly homologous to the E. coli RelA protein. The amino acid sequences are 64% identical, and they share some completely conserved regions. A delta relA::kan allele was generated by replacing 53% of the open reading frame with a kanamycin resistance gene. The Vibrio relA mutants displayed a relaxed control of RNA synthesis and failed to accumulate ppGpp during amino acid limitation. During carbon and energy starvation, a relA-dependent burst of ppGpp synthesis concomitant with carbon source depletion and growth arrest was observed. Also, in the absence of the relA gene, there was an accumulation of ppGpp during carbon starvation, but this was slower and smaller than that which occurred in the stringent strains, and it was preceded by a marked decrease in the [ATP]/[ADP] ratio. In both the wild-type and the relaxed strains, carbon source depletion caused an immediate decrease in the size of the GTP pool and a block of net RNA accumulation. The relA mutation did not affect long-term survival or the development of resistance against heat, ethanol, and oxidative stress during carbon starvation of Vibrio sp. strain S14.     

RelA-independent (p)ppGpp accumulation and heat shock protein induction after salt stress in Bacillus subtilis

Abstract Sodium chloride treatment triggered the accumulation of (p)ppGpp in the Bacillus subtilis relA ⁺ strain IS58 as well as in its relaxed counterpart IS56 . Besides this relA -independent (p)ppGpp induction the GTP and ATP pools decreased dramatically.
In previous papers we found a direct correlation between (p)ppGpp accumulation and stress protein induction. In B. subtilis relA the (p)ppGpp accumulation was accompanied by the induction of general stress proteins whose synthesis rates were also enhanced by heat stress, amino acid limitation or oxygen starvation. Specific heat shock proteins were not induced by salt stress.
We suggest that these general stress proteins are induced under non-growing conditions in general.     

Control of rRNA and tRNA syntheses in Escherichia coli by guanosine tetraphosphate

The expression of stable RNA (rRNA and tRNA) genes and the concentration of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) were measured in an isogenic pair of relA+ and relA derivatives of Escherichia coli B/r. The cells were either growing exponentially at different rates or subject to amino acid starvation when they were measured. The specific stable RNA gene activity (rs/rt, the rate of rRNA and tRNA synthesis relative to the total instantaneous rate of RNA synthesis) was found to decrease from 1.0 at a ppGpp concentration of 0 (extrapolated value) to 0.24 at saturating concentrations of ppGpp (above 100 pmoles per optical density at 460 nm unit of cell mass). The same relationship between the rs/rt ratio and ppGpp concentration was obtained independent of the physiological state of the bacteria (i.e., independent of the growth rate or of amino acid starvation) and independent of the relA allele. It can be concluded that ppGpp is an effector for stable RNA gene control and that stable RNA genes are not controlled by factors other than the ppGpp-mediated system. The results were shown to be qualitatively and quantitatively consistent with data on in vitro rRNA gene control by ppGpp, and they were interpreted in the light of reported ideas derived from those in vitro experiments.     

Delayed-relaxed response explained by hyperactivation of RelE

Escherichia coli encodes two rel loci, both of which contribute to the control of synthesis of macromolecules during amino acid starvation. The product of relA (ppGpp synthetase I) is responsible for the synthesis of guanosine tetraphosphate, ppGpp, the signal molecule that exerts stringent control of stable RNA synthesis. The second rel locus, relBE, was identified by mutations in relB that confer a so-called 'delayed-relaxed response' characterized by continued RNA synthesis after a lag period of approximately 10 min after the onset of amino acid starvation. We show here that the delayed-relaxed response is a consequence of hyperactivation of RelE. As in wild-type cells, [ppGpp] increased sharply in relB101 relE cells after the onset of starvation, but returned rapidly to the prestarvation level. RelE is a global inhibitor of translation that is neutralized by RelB by direct protein-protein interaction. Lon protease activates RelE during amino acid starvation by degradation of RelB. We found that mutations in relB that conferred the delayed-relaxed phenotype destabilized RelB. Such mutations confer severe RelE-dependent inhibition of translation during amino acid starvation, indicating hyperactivation of RelE. Hyperactivation of RelE during amino acid starvation was shown directly by measurement of RelE-mediated cleavage of tmRNA. The RelE-mediated shutdown of translation terminated amino acid consumption and explains the rapid restoration of the ppGpp level observed in relB mutant cells. Restoration of the prestarvation level of ppGpp, in turn, allows for the resumption of stable RNA synthesis seen during the delayed-relaxed response.     

Studies on the turnover of endogenous choline-containing phospholipids of cultured neuroblastoma cells

The effects of two polypeptide antibiotics, polymixin B and gramicidin S, on the intracellular pool size and turnover of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) were analyzed in stringent (relA+) and relaxed (relA) strains of Escherichia coli. When either one of these two drugs was added to stringent bacteria cultures at a final concentration that blocked protein and RNA synthesis, ppGpp was found to accumulate. Under similar conditions of inhibition of macromolecular synthesis, ppGpp also appeared to accumulate in relaxed bacteria. Moreover, in either type of strain, no significant accumulation of guanosine pentaphosphate (pppGpp) could be detected upon drug treatment. It was, therefore, concluded that polymixin and gramicidin elicit ppGpp accumulation through a mechanism independent of the relA gene product and, consequently, quite distinct from the stringent control system triggered by amino acid starvation. Further experiments performed by using tetracycline as an inhibitor of ppGpp synthesis, showed that the increase in the level of this nucleotide induced by drug action was due, in fact, to a strong restriction of its degradation rate.     

The suppression of defective translation by ppGpp and its role in the stringent response.

Amino acid starvation is shown to decrease the fidelity of translation in E. coli. When proteins are analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, missense errors are detected as an unusual heterogeneity in their isoelectric points, while premature termination of protein synthesis can be recognized by a decreased relative rate of synthesis of higher molecular weight proteins and by the the accumulation of a complex group of new small polypeptides. The types of translational errors observed are amino acid-specific. For example, starvation of a rel- strain for histidine produces severe isoelectric point heterogeneity with little evidence of premature termination, while starvation for leucine has little effect on the isoelectric points, but produces a drastic decrease in the average molecular weight of the newly synthesized protein. These differences suggest codon-specific errors in reading the genetic code. In these rel- cells, the effect of amino acid starvation on the rates of synthesis of complete individual proteins is both protein- and amino acid-specific. For example, ribosomal protein L7/12, which lacks histidine, is made at a higher level during histidine starvation than during isoleucine or leucine starvation. This suggests that in rel- cells, the modulation of gene expression caused by the lack of a particular amino acid is, at least in part, a function of the abundance of that amino acid in particular proteins-that is, the response of rel- cells to starvation is consistent with the theory that the inhibition of protein synthesis and the accompanying increase in error frequency both result from low levels of the correct substrate. In marked contrast, virtually no starvation-induced translational errors are detected in a rel+ strain, and the response is not amino acid-specific. Varoius data strongly imply that in this rel+ strain, essentially all the changes caused by starvation are due to the accumulation of ppGpp, which independently reduces protein synthesis, thereby suppressing all the direct effects of amino acid limitation seen in rel- strains (where ppGpp does not accumulate upon starvation). A model is presented which describes how ppGpp might suppress the direct effects of starvation and avoid the loss of translational fidelity. In addition, the direct and specific effects of ppGpp on gene expression are examined independently of amino acid starvation.     

Role of guanosine tetraphosphate in gene expression and the survival of glucose or seryl-tRNA starved cells of Escherichia coli K12

The concentration of guanosine 3′,5′-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp) increases in bacteria in response to amino acid or carbon/energy source starvation. An Escherichia coli K12 ΔrelAΔspoT mutant lacking the ability to synthesize ppGpp lost viability at an increased rate during both glucose and seryl-tRNA starvation. Also, the deleterious effect of chloramphenicol on starved wild-type cells could be overcome by inducing expression of RelA from a plasmid carrying the relA gene transcribed from a tac promoter, prior to starvation and chloramphenicol treatment. As demonstrated by two dimensional gel electrophoresis, this induction of the RelA protein resulted in global alterations in gene expression including increased synthesis of some rpoS-dependent proteins. The ΔrelAΔspoT mutant maintained high expression of several ribosomal proteins during starvation and appeared to exhibit significantly decreased translational fidelity, as demonstrated by an unusual heterogeneity in the isoelectric point of several proteins and the failure to express higher molecular weight proteins during starvation. Moreover, both rpoS-dependent and independent genes failed to exhibit increased expression in the mutant. It is suggested that the deleterious effects on the cells of the relA, spoT deletions are not due solely to the inability of these cells to induce the sigma factor σ^s, but also to deficiencies in translational fidelity and failure to exert classical stringent regulation.     

Charging levels of four tRNA species in Escherichia coli Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains during amino acid starvation: a simple model for the effect of ppGpp on translational accuracy

Escherichia coli strains mutated in the relA gene lack the ability to produce ppGpp during amino acid starvation. One consequence of this deficiency is a tenfold increase in misincorporation at starved codons compared to the wild-type. Previous work had shown that the charging levels of tRNAs were the same in Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains and reduced, at most, two- to fivefold in both strains during starvation. The present reinvestigation of the charging levels of tRNA(2)(Arg), tRNA(1)(Thr), tRNA(1)(Leu) and tRNA(His) during starvation of isogenic Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains showed that starvation reduced charging levels tenfold to 40-fold. This reduction corresponds much better with the decreased rate of protein synthesis during starvation than that reported earlier. The determination of the charging levels of tRNA(2)(Arg) and tRNA(1)(Thr) during starvation were accurate enough to demonstrate that charging levels were at least fivefold lower in the Rel(-) strain compared to the Rel(+) strain. Together with other data from the literature, these new data suggest a simple model in which mis-incorporation increases as the substrate availability decreases and that ppGpp has no direct effect on enhancing translational accuracy at the ribosome.     

Induction of cat-86 by chloramphenicol and amino acid starvation in relaxed mutants of Bacillus subtilis

The chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene cat-86 is induced through a mechanism that is a variation of classical attenuation. Induction results from the destabilization of an RNA stem-loop that normally sequesters the cat-86 ribosome-binding site. Destabilization of the stem-loop is due to the stalling of a ribosome in the leader region of cat-86 mRNA at a position that places the A site of the stalled ribosome at leader codon 6. Two events can stall ribosomes at the correct location to induce cat-86 translation: addition of chloramphenicol to cells and starvation of cells for the amino acid specified by leader codon 6. Induction by amino acid starvation is an anomaly because translation of the cat-86 coding sequence requires all 20 amino acids. To explain this apparent contradiction we postulated that amino acid starvation triggers intracellular proteolysis, thereby providing levels of the deprived amino acid sufficient for cat-86 translation. Here we show that a mutation in relA, the structural gene for stringent factor, blocks intracellular proteolysis that is normally triggered by amino acid starvation. The relA mutation also blocks induction of cat-86 by amino acid starvation, but the mutation does not interfere with chloramphenicol induction. Induction by amino acid starvation can be demonstrated in relA mutant cells if the depleted amino acid is restored at very low levels (e.g., 2 micrograms/ml). A mutation in relC, which may be the gene for ribosomal protein L11, blocks induction of cat-86 by either chloramphenicol or amino acid starvation. We believe this effect is due to a structural alteration of the ribosome resulting from the relC mutation and not to the relaxed phenotype of the cells.