Mechanisms of colicin binding and transport through outer membrane porins

To kill Escherichia coli, toxic proteins, called colicins, pass through the permeability barrier created by the outer membrane (OM) of the bacterial cell envelope. We consider a variety of different colicins, including A, B, D, E1, E3, Ia, M and N, that penetrate through the porins OmpF, FepA, BtuB, Cir and FhuA, to subsequently interact with a few targets in the periplasm, including TolA, TolB, TolC and TonB. We review the mechanisms, demonstrated and postulated, by which such toxins enter bacterial cells, from the initial binding stage on the cell surface to the internalization reaction through the OM bilayer. Our discussions endeavor to answer two main questions: what is the origin of colicin-binding affinity and specificity, and after adsorption to OM porins, do colicin polypeptides translocate through porin channels, or enter by another, currently unknown pathway?     

Protein-translocating outer membrane porins of Gram-negative bacteria

Five families of outer membrane porins that function in protein secretion in Gram-negative bacteria are currently recognized. In this report, these five porin families are analyzed from structural and phylogenetic standpoints. They are the fimbrial usher protein (FUP), outer membrane factor (OMF), autotransporter (AT), two-partner secretion (TPS) and outer membrane secretin (Secretin) families. All members of these families in the current databases were identified, and all full-length homologues were multiply aligned for structural and phylogenetic analyses. The organismal distribution of homologues in each family proved to be unique with some families being restricted to proteobacteria and others being widespread in other bacterial kingdoms as well as eukaryotes. The compositions of and size differences between subfamilies provide evidence for specific orthologous relationships, which agree with available functional information and intra-subfamily phylogeny. The results reveal that horizontal transfer of genes encoding these proteins between phylogenetically distant organisms has been exceptionally rare although transfer within select bacterial kingdoms may have occurred. The resultant in silico analyses are correlated with available experimental evidence to formulate models relevant to the structures and evolutionary origins of these proteins.     

Origami in the outer membrane: the transmembrane arrangement of mitochondrial porins.

Voltage-dependent anion-selective channels (VDAC), also known as mitochondrial porins, are key regulators of metabolite flow across the mitochondrial outer membrane. Porins from a wide variety of organisms share remarkably similar electrophysiological properties, in spite of considerable sequence dissimilarity, indicating that they share a common structure. Based on primary sequence considerations, analogy with bacterial porins, and circular dichroism analysis, it is agreed that VDAC spans the outer membrane as a beta-barrel. However, the residues that form the antiparallel beta-strands comprising this barrel remain unknown. Various predictive methods, largely based on the known structures of bacterial beta-barrels, have been applied to the primary sequences of VDAC. Refinement and confirmation of these predictions have developed through numerous investigations of wild-type and variant porins, both in mitochondria and in artificial membranes. These experiments have involved VDAC from several sources, precluding the generation of a unified model. Herein, using the Neurospora VDAC sequence as a template, the published structural information and predictions have been reassessed to delineate a model that satisfies most of the available data.     

Nonspecific porins of the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria: Structure and functions

The structure and functional properties of nonspecific porins (β-structured integral proteins of the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria) are overviewed. The characteristic features of porin spatial structure related to the principles of β-barrel construction and pore geometry are considered. The data concerning nonspecific diffusion of low-molecular substances and dynamic behavior of porin channels dependent on the distribution of charged amino acid residues in different structural domains of the porin molecule are presented. The methods and approaches used in the study of functional activity of porins are surveyed. The data on modulation of pore-forming activity of these proteins by external factors and membrane components are considered separately.     

Identification of three porins in the outer membrane of Bacteroides fragilis

Abstract Four outer membrane proteins were purified to homogeneity from isolated outer membranes of Bacteroides fragilis ; three ( M _r 51000, 92000 and 125 000) had pore-forming activity in reconstituted liposomes as determined by swelling assay. Membrane vesicles containing the M _rmr 55 000 outer membrane protein showed no detectable pore-forming activity. The three B. fragilis porins formed pores that allowed the penetration of uncharged saccharides of M _r lower than 340–400, even though the efficiency of solute diffusion showed slight differences. The diffusion rates of glucose through the porins appeared to be lower than those through Escherichia coli porins.     

Role of lysines in ion selectivity of bacterial outer membrane porins

The epsilon-amino groups of available lysine residues of the OmpC, OmpF and PhoE porin proteins of Escherichia coli and of the protein P porin of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, were modified by the bulky reagent trinitrobenzenesulphonic acid. Approximately 78% of the lysines of the anion-selective protein P and PhoE porins were modified whereas only 40-50% of the lysines of the cation selective OmpF and OmpC porins were altered. After modification, the three E. coli porins had very similar high selectivities for cations over anions, in contrast to the native porins which varied 86-fold in ion selectivity. Despite the large size of the trinitrophenyl group attached to modified lysines (i.e., a disc of approx. 0.86 nm diameter X 0.36 nm high) relative to the reported size of the constrictions of the E. coli porins (1.0-1.2 nm diameter), only the anion-selective PhoE porin was substantially blocked after trinitrophenylation. The protein P porin channel was relatively unaffected by trinitrophenylation, in contrast to previous data showing dramatic effects of acetylation of lysines on protein P conductance and selectivity. This favoured a model in which the critical lysines involved in anion binding by protein P were present in a constriction of the channel that was too small for trinitrobenzenesulphonic acid to enter. Overall, the data suggest that both the number and relative position of charged lysines are major determinants of ion selectivity.     

Mechanisms of transport of p-borono-phenylalanine through the cell membrane in vitro

The mechanisms of transport of p-(dihydroxyboryl)-phenylalanine (BPA) through the cell membrane were investigated in vitro, evaluating especially the systems responsible for the transport of neutral amino acids as potential carriers for BPA. Rat 9L gliosarcoma cells and Chinese hamster V79 cells were exposed to BPA under controlled conditions and in a defined medium that was free of amino acids. The time course of (10)B (delivered by BPA) uptake and efflux was measured under different conditions. To analyze the intracellular boron content, direct-current plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (DCP-AES) was used after separating the cells from extracellular boron in the cell medium using an oil filtration technique. The dependence of factors such as cell type, temperature, composition and concentration of amino acids and specific substrates for amino acid transport systems in the culture medium or in intracellular compartments on BPA uptake and efflux were studied. The results of this study support the hypothesis that BPA is transported by the L system and that transport can be further stimulated by amino acids preaccumulated in the cell by either the L or A amino acid transport system. Copyright [bj54] by Radiation Research Society     

Determination of ion permeability through the channels made of porins from the outer membrane ofSalmonella typhimurium in lipid bilayer membranes

Summary The three types of porin (matrix-proteins) fromSalmonella typhimurium with molecular weights of 38,000, 39,000 and 40,000 were reconstituted with lipid bilayer membranes either as a trimer or as an oligomer (complex I). The specific conductance of the membranes increased several orders of magnitude after the addition of the porins into the aqueous phase bathing the membranes. A linear relationship between protein concentration in the aqueous phase and membrane conductance was found. In the case of lower protein concentrations (10^–12 m), the conductance increased in a stepwise fashion with a single conductance increment of 2.3 nS in 1m KCl. For a given salt the conductance increment was found to be largely independent of the particular porin (38 K, 39K or 40 K) and on the state of aggregation, although porin oligomers showed an up to 10 times smaller conductance increase in macroscopic conductance measurements. The conductance pathway has an ohmic current voltage characteristic and a poor selectivity for different alkali ions. Further information on the structure of the pores formed by the different porins fromSalmonella was obtained from the selectivity for various ions. From the permeability of the pore for large ions (Tris⁺, glucosamine⁺, Hepes^–_ a minimum pore diameter of 0.8 nm is estimated. This value is in agreement with the size of the pore as calculated from the conductance data for 1m KCl (1.4 nm for a pore length of 7.5 nm). The pore diameter may well account for the sugar permeability which has been found in reconstituted vesicles. The findings reported here are consistent with the assumption that the different porins form large aqueous channels in the lipid bilayer membranes and that the single condutance unit is a trimer. In addition, it is suggested that one trimer contains only one pore rather than a bundle of pores.     

Mechanism of sugar transport through the sugar-specific LamB channel ofEscherichia coli outer membrane

Summary Lipid bilayer experiments were performed with the sugar-specific LamB (maltoporin) channel ofEscherichia coli outer membrane. Single-channel analysis of the conductance steps caused by LamB showed that there was a linear relationship between the salt concentration in the aqueous phase and the channel conductance, indicating only small or no binding between the ions and the channel interior. The total or the partial blockage of the ion movement through the LamB channel was not dependent on the ion concentration in the aqueous phase. Both results allowed the investigation of the sugar binding in more detail, and the stability constants of the binding of a large variety of sugars to the binding site inside the channel were calculated from titration experiments of the membrane conductance with the sugars. The channel was highly cation selective, both in the presence and absence of sugars, which may be explained by the existence of carbonyl groups inside the channel. These carbonyl groups may also be involved in the sugar binding via hydrogen bonds. The kinetics of the sugar transport through the LamB channel were estimated relative to maltose by assuming a simple one-site, two-barrier model from the relative rates of permeation taken from M. Luckey and H. Nikaido (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 77:165–171 (1980a)) and the stability constants for the sugar binding given in this study.     

Mechanism of ion transport through the anion-selective channel of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa outer membrane

Protein P trimers isolated and purified from Pseudomonas aeruginosa outer membrane were reconstituted in planar lipid bilayer membranes from diphytanoyl phosphatidylcholine. The protein trimers formed highly anion-specific channels with an average single channel conductance of 160 pS in 0.1 M Cl solution. A variety of different nonvalent anions were found to be permeable through the channel, which suggests a channel diameter between 0.5 and 0.7 nm. The selectivity for the halides followed the Eisenman sequence AVI (without At-). The ion transport through the protein P channel could be explained reasonably well by a one-site, two-barrier model. The stability constant of the binding of Cl- to the site was 20 M-1 at neutral pH. The binding of anions to the site was pH dependent, which suggested that several charges are involved in the closely spaced selectivity filter. Permeability ratios for different anions as calculated from bi-ionic potentials showed agreement with corresponding ratios of single channel conductances. The protein P channels were not voltage-gated and had lifetimes of the order of several minutes. The current-voltage curves were linear for membrane potentials up to 150 mV, which suggested that Nernst-Planck-type barriers rather than Eyring barriers were involved in the movement of anions through the protein P channel.     

Effect on solute size on diffusion rates through the transmembrane pores of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

Nutrients usually cross the outer membrane of Escherichia coli by diffusion through water-filled channels surrounded by a specific class of protein, porins. In this study, the rates of diffusion of hydrophilic nonelectrolytes, mostly sugars and sugar alcohols, through the porin channels were determined in two systems, (a) vesicles reconstituted from phospholipids and purified porin and (b) intact cells of mutant strains that produce many fewer porin molecules than wild-type strains. The diffusion rates were strongly affected by the size of the solute, even when the size was well within the "exclusion limit" of the channel. In both systems, hexoses and hexose disaccharides diffused through the channel at rates 50-80% and 2-4%, respectively, of that of a pentose, arabinose. Application of the Renkin equation to these data led to the estimate that the pore radius is approximately 0.6 nm, if the pore is assumed to be a hollow cylinder. The results of the study also show that the permeability of the outer membrane of the wild-type E. coli cell to glucose and lactose can be explained by the presence of porin channels, that a significant fraction of these channels must be functional or "open" under our conditions of growth, and that even 10(5) channels per cell could become limiting when E. coli tries to grow at a maximal rate on low concentrations of slowly penetrating solutes, such as disaccharides.     

Identification of porins in the outer membrane of Pseudomonas aeruginosa that form small diffusion pores

The purified outer membrane proteins of Pseudomonas aeruginosa were reconstituted with phosphatidylcholine and dicetylphosphate into membrane vesicles, and these were tested by the liposome swelling method for the diffusion of saccharides with different Mr. Proteins C (Mr, 70,000), D (Mr, 46,000), and E (Mr, 43,000) were found to confer the monosaccharide-permeable pores in the reconstituted liposome membranes. The membrane vesicles containing proteins F (Mr, 34,000), G (Mr, 25,000), or H (Mr, 19,000) showed no detectable pore-forming activity. The pores formed by proteins C, D, or E appeared to be smaller than that formed by the Escherichia coli porins. The size of the solutes that permeated through the newly identified porins is similar to that through the intact and purified outer membrane of P. aeruginosa (Yoneyama, H., and Nakae, T. (1986) Eur. J. Biochem. 157, 33-38; Yoshihara, E., Gotoh, N., and Nakae, T. (1988) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 156, 470-476).     

Purification and characterization of two kinds of porins from the Enterobacter cloacae outer membrane.

Two major outer membrane proteins of Enterobacter cloacae 206 were purified and identified as porins by using reconstituted vesicles. The 37-kilodalton porin forms a channel with a radius of 0.6 nm, which prefers positively charged substances to negatively charged ones, whereas the 39- to 40-kilodalton porin forms a larger channel with a radius of 0.8 nm, which has weaker selectivity for electric charges.     

Mechanisms of equinatoxin II-induced transport through the membrane of a giant phospholipid vesicle

Protein equinatoxin II from sea anemone Actinia equina L. was used to form pores in phospholipid membranes. We studied the effect of these pores on the net transmembrane transport of sucrose and glucose by observing single giant (cell-size) vesicles under the phase contrast microscope. Sugar composition in the vesicle was determined by measuring the width of the halo, which appears around the vesicle in the phase contrast image. The transport of sugars was induced when a vesicle, filled with the sucrose solution, was transferred into the isomolar environment of a glucose solution with added equinatoxin II. Typically, a vesicle grew to a critical size, then the membrane broke by bursting and the vesicle shrank, started to grow again, and the whole process was repeated. The consecutive membrane breaks occurred in the same spot. The observed behavior was interpreted by the diffusion flow of the glucose molecules through the equinatoxin II-induced pores and the consequent increase of the vesicle water content. The burst relaxed the critically strained membrane, which then apparently resealed. A mathematical model of the described behavior was developed and was used to obtain the equinatoxin II-induced membrane permeability for the glucose molecules. Its dependence on the equinatoxin II concentration is in agreement with the previous reports.