Developmental regulation of metabolites and low temperature tolerance in lines of crosses between spring and winter wheat

Low temperature (LT) tolerance in cereals needs developmental regulation of metabolites, a process which is associated with vernalization requirement. This study was initiated to investigate the relationships among stage of phenological development, final leaf number (FLN), the activities superoxide dismutase, catalase, guaiacol peroxidase, ascorbate peroxidase and polyphenol oxidase, the contents of proline, photosynthetic pigments, and hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) during vernalization and LT acclimation in spring and winter wheat. Six genotypes with different vernalization requirements were grown under greenhouse and field conditions. The spring-habit parent, “Pishtaz” and line 4021, rapidly entered the reproductive phase and had a limited capacities to LT acclimate. They also had the lowest antioxidative activities and accumulation of proline among genotypes. Lines 4002 and 4014, with a short vernalization requirement and higher FLN, remained in the early stages of phenological development longer and developed a higher level of LT tolerance and metabolites compared to spring habit genotypes. In contrast, the winter habit “Norstar” and line 4023 spent a longer time in the vegetative stage and accumulated higher levels of metabolites. Maximum LT tolerance and metabolite accumulations occurred near the vegetative/reproductive transition in all genotypes. The longer periods of vernalization and increased FLN that happened along with increased defense mechanisms and decreased damage indices (H₂O₂ content and LT₅₀) ensured LT tolerance in wheat. These results demonstrate that both genetic and environmental factors via developmental regulation of metabolites play important roles in creating LT tolerance in long mild winters of Iran. Significant correlations coefficients for many of the metabolites considered in this study and Lethal temperature 50 (LT₅₀) also suggest that they could be useful as indirect measures of plant LT tolerance potential in wheat breeding programs.     

Interactions among factors regulating phenological development and acclimation rate determine low-temperature tolerance in wheat

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Exposure to low temperatures (LT) produces innumerable changes in morphological, biochemical and physiological characteristics of plants, with the result that it has been difficult to separate cause and effect adjustments to LT. Phenotypic studies have shown that the LT-induced protective mechanisms in cereals are developmentally regulated and involve an acclimation process that can be stopped, reversed and restarted. The present study was initiated to separate the developmental factors determining duration from those responsible for rate of acclimation, to provide the opportunity for a more in depth analysis of the critical mechanisms that regulate LT tolerance in wheat (Triticum aestivum). METHODS: The non-hardy spring wheat cultivar 'Manitou' and the very cold-hardy winter wheat cultivar 'Norstar' were used to produce reciprocal near-isogenic lines (NILs) in which the vrn-A1 (winter) alleles of 'Norstar' were inserted into the non-hardy 'Manitou' genetic background and the Vrn-A1 (spring) alleles of 'Manitou' were inserted in the hardy 'Norstar' genetic background so that the effects of duration and rate of LT acclimation could be quantified. KEY RESULTS: Comparison of the acclimation curves of the NILs and their parents grown at 2, 6 and 10 degrees C established that the full expression of LT-induced genetic systems was revealed only under genotypically dependent optimum combinations of time and temperature. Both duration and rate of acclimation were found to contribute significantly to the 13.8 degrees C difference in lowest survival temperature between 'Norstar' and 'Manitou'. CONCLUSIONS: Duration of LT acclimation was dependent upon the rate of phenological development, which, in turn, was determined by acclimation temperatures and vernalization requirements. Rate of acclimation was faster for genotypes with the 'Norstar' genetic background but the ability to sustain a high rate of acclimation was dependent upon the length of the vegetative stage. Complex time/temperature relationships and unexplained genetic interactions indicated that detailed functional genomic or phenomic analyses of natural allelic variation will be required to identify the critical genetic components of a highly integrated system, which is regulated by environmentally responsive, complex pathways.     

Developmental Regulation of Low-temperature Tolerance in Winter Wheat

Vernalization and photoperiod genes have wide-ranging effectson the timing of gene expression in plants. The objectives ofthis study were to (1) determine if expression of low-temperature(LT) tolerance genes is developmentally regulated and (2) establishthe interrelationships among the developmental stages and LTtolerance gene expression. LT response curves were determinedfor three photoperiod-sensitive LT tolerant winter wheat (Triticumaestivum L. em Thell) genotypes acclimated at 4 °C under8 h short-day (SD) and 20 h long-day (LD) photoperiods from0 to 112 d. Also, three de-acclimation and re-acclimation cycleswere used that bridged the vegetative/reproductive transitionpoint for each LD and SD photoperiod treatment. A vernalizationperiod of 49 d at 4 °C was sufficient for all genotypesto reach vernalization saturation as measured by minimum finalleaf number (FLN) and confirmed by examination of shoot apicesdissected from crowns that had been de-acclimated at 20 °CLD. Before the vegetative/reproductive transition, both theLD- and SD-treated plants were able to re-acclimate to similarLT₅₀(temperature at which 50% of the plants are killed by LTstress) levels following de-acclimation at 20 °C. De-acclimationof LD plants after vernalization saturation resulted in rapidprogression to the reproductive phase and limited ability tore-acclimate. The comparative development of the SD (non-flowering-inductivephotoperiod) de-acclimated plants was greatly delayed relativeto LD plants, and this delay in development was reflected inthe ability of SD plants to re-acclimate to a lower temperature.These observations confirm the hypothesis that the point oftransition to the reproductive stage is pivotal in the expressionof LT tolerance genes, and the level and duration of LT acclimationare related to the stage of phenological development as regulatedby vernalization and photoperiod requirements. Copyright 2001Annals of Botany Company Triticum aestivum L., wheat, low-temperature tolerance, vernalization, photoperiod, phenological development     

Low-temperature tolerance and genetic potential in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.): response to photoperiod, vernalization, and plant development

It is frequently observed that winter habit types are more low-temperature (LT) tolerant than spring habit types. This raises the question of whether this is due to pleiotropic effects of the vernalization loci or to the linkage of LT-tolerance genes to these vernalization loci. Reciprocal near-isogenic lines (NILs) for alleles at the Vrn-A1 locus, Vrn-A1 and vrn-A1, determining spring and winter habit respectively, in two diverse genetic backgrounds of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) were used to separate the effects of vernalization, photoperiod, and development on identical, or near identical, genetic backgrounds. The vrn-A1 allele in the winter lines allowed full expression of genotype dependent LT tolerance potential. The winter allele (vrn-A1) in a very cold tolerant genetic background resulted in 11°C, or a 2.4-fold, greater LT tolerance compared to the spring allele. Similarly, the delay in development caused by short-day (SD) versus long-day (LD) photoperiod in the identical spring habit NIL resulted in an 8.5°C or 2.1-fold, increase in LT tolerance. The duration of time in early developmental stages was shown to underlie full expression of genetic LT-tolerance potential. Therefore, pleiotropic effects of the vernalization loci can explain the association of LT tolerance and winter habit irrespective of either the proposed closely linked Fr-A1 or the more distant Fr-A2 LT-tolerance QTLs. Plant development progressively reduced LT-acclimation ability, particularly after the main shoot meristem had advanced to the double ridge reproductive growth stage. The Vrn-1 genes, or other members of the flowering induction pathway, are discussed as possible candidates for involvement in LT-tolerance repression.     

Identification of quantitative trait loci and associated candidate genes for low-temperature tolerance in cold-hardy winter wheat

Low-temperature (LT) tolerance is an important economic trait in winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) that determines the plants’ ability to cope with below freezing temperatures. Essential elements of the LT tolerance mechanism are associated with the winter growth habit controlled by the vernalization loci (Vrn-1) on the group 5 chromosomes. To identify genomic regions, which in addition to vrn-1 determine the level of LT tolerance in hexaploid wheat, two doubled haploid (DH) mapping populations were produced using parents with winter growth habit (vrn-A1, vrn-B1, and vrn-D1) but showing different LT tolerance levels. A total of 107 DH lines were analyzed by genetic mapping to produce a consensus map of 2,873 cM. The LT tolerance levels for the Norstar (LT₅₀=−20.7°C) × Winter Manitou (LT₅₀=−14.3°C) mapping population ranged from −12.0 to −22.0°C. Single marker analysis and interval mapping of phenotyped lines revealed a major quantitative trait locus (QTL) on chromosome 5A and a weaker QTL on chromosome 1D. The 5A QTL located 46 cM proximal to the vrn-A1 locus explained 40% of the LT tolerance variance. Two C-repeat Binding Factor (CBF) genes expressed during cold acclimation in Norstar were located at the peak of the 5A QTL.     

Low-temperature acclimation of barley cultivars used as parents in mapping populations: response to photoperiod,vernalization and phenological development

Six barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) accessions, previously used as parents of mapping populations, were evaluated for characters potentially affecting the location of low-temperature (LT) tolerance QTLs. Three were of winter growth habit (Kompolti Korai, Nure, and Strider), one was facultative (Dicktoo) and two were spring (Morex and Tremois). Final leaf number (FLN) and LT₅₀ were determined at weekly intervals from 0 to 98 days of LT acclimation/vernalization under both long day (LD) and short day (SD) photoperiods. The point of vegetative/reproductive transition was determined from measurements of double ridge (DR) formation and FLN. With the exception of Nure, SD delayed development by increasing leaf production. Dicktoo was extremely SD sensitive lengthening its vegetative phase by more than 63 days relative to the LD photoperiod. SD had the opposite effect on Nure, causing an accelerating of flowering exhibiting the characteristic of ‘short day vernalization’. All accessions except Dicktoo and Kompolti Korai acclimated rapidly in the first 7 days of LT exposure, approaching their maximum LT tolerance in 14–21 days. Dicktoo and Kompolti Korai continued to slowly acclimate until reproductive transition. The results emphasize two important points: (1) the location of QTLs for LT tolerance, and as a consequence the identification of putative candidate genes, will be a function of the genotypes sampled, the experimental conditions used, and the quality of the phenotypic data and (2) the barley LT tolerance pathway reaches an early impediment relative to closely related more hardy members of the Triticeae such as wheat and rye.     

Vernalization-induced changes of the DNA methylation pattern in winter wheat.

Vernalization is a cold treatment that induces or accelerates flowering and insures that temperate-zone plants will not flower until after winter. There is evidence that vernalization results in DNA demethylation that induces flowering. Differences in DNA methylation can be determined using methylation-sensitive amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLPs). Methylation-sensitive AFLPs utilize restriction enzyme isoschizomers that are differentially sensitive to methylation, producing polymorphisms related to methylation differences as opposed to sequence differences. Near-isogenic lines (NILs) have been developed for spring vs. winter habit in wheat (Triticum aestivum) and allow for the study of a single vernalization locus. In this study, differences in the methylation pattern were determined for spring and winter NILs, as well as for unvernalized and vernalized individuals. Winter wheat was more highly methylated than spring wheat and methylation-related AFLPs were produced between winter and spring wheat. Changes in the methylation pattern were observed at the end of vernalization, one week after the end of vernalization, and four weeks after the end of vernalization of winter wheat. However, the most methylation differences were observed one week after removal of winter wheat from cold treatment. Our data suggest that there is not only a vernalization-induced demethylation related to flower induction, but there is also a more general and non-specific demethylation of sequences unrelated to flowering. Two methylation-related AFLPs induced by vernalization were shared among all of the winter NILs.     

Cold-induced changes of enzymes,proline, carbohydrates,and chlorophyll in wheat

Quantitative changes in total leaf soluble proteins, proline, carbohydrate content, chlorophyll fluorescence, guaiacol peroxidase (POD) and catalase (CAT) activities were determined in a less cold-hardy (LCH) spring cv. Kohdasht (LT₅₀ = −6°C), a semi cold-hardy (SCH) facultative cv. Azar 2 (LT₅₀ = −15°C), and a cold-hardy (CH) winter cv. Norstar (LT₅₀ = −26°C) of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) exposed to 4°C for 9 weeks. Seedlings were grown in a controlled growth room for 14 days at 20°C and then transferred to 4°C (experimental day 0) for 63 days (cold treatment); otherwise they were maintained continuously at 20°C (control treatment). The samples were harvested 0, 2, 21, 28, 42, and 63 days after exposure to 4°C. The results showed significant low temperature (LT)-induced accumulation of total soluble proteins, proline, and carbohydrates and elevation in activities of CAT and POD in leaves of SCH and CH winter cultivars rather than in LCH spring cultivar. In contrast, the chlorophyll fluorescence (F _v/F _m) declined during LT treatment irrespective of cultivar. The results suggest that developmental traits such as vernalization requirement of wheat affects on cold-tolerance expression system of plants.     

Relationships among vernalization, shoot apex development and frost tolerance in wheat

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Frost tolerance of wheat depends primarily upon a strong vernalization requirement, delaying the transition to the reproductive phase. The aim of the present study was to learn how saturation of the vernalization requirement and apical development stage are related to frost tolerance in wheat. METHODS: 'Mironovskaya 808', a winter variety with a long vernalization requirement, and 'Leguan', a spring variety without a vernalization requirement, were acclimated at 2 degrees C at different stages of development. Plant development (morphological stage of the shoot apex), vernalization requirement (days to heading) and frost tolerance (survival of the plants exposed to freezing conditions) were evaluated. KEY RESULTS: 'Mironovskaya 808' increased its frost tolerance more rapidly; it reached a higher level of tolerance and after a longer duration of acclimation at 2 degrees C than was found in 'Leguan'. The frost tolerance of 'Mironovskaya 808' decreased and its ability to re-acclimate a high tolerance was lost after saturation of its vernalization requirement, but before its shoot apex had reached the double-ridge stage. The frost tolerance of 'Leguan' decreased after the plants had reached the floret initiation stage. CONCLUSIONS: The results support the hypothesis that genes for vernalization requirement act as a master switch regulating the duration of low temperature induced frost tolerance. In winter wheat, due to a longer vegetative phase, frost tolerance is maintained for a longer time and at a higher level than in spring wheat. After the saturation of vernalization requirement, winter wheat (as in spring wheat) established only a low level of frost tolerance.     

The influence of temperature on plant development in a vernalization-requiring winter wheat: A 2-DE based proteomic investigation

In this work, proteomics was used to study the influence of both optimal and low temperatures on growth and development in a vernalization-requiring winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv Cheyenne) after prolonged times of treatment. For this purpose, plants were grown at optimal temperature (20°C) for 14 days (zero point) after which half were transferred to conditioned chambers kept at 4°C for a period of 63 days. Cold tolerance, as estimated from lethal temperatures (LT(50)), and phenological development, as measured by final leaf number (FLN) and shoot apex dissection, were determined. Proteomic analysis indicated a down-accumulation of several photosynthesis-related proteins and a concomitant increase in abundance of some Calvin cycle enzymes. A cold-induced accretion of soluble sugars and proline was observed as well. In parallel, an increase of proteolysis accomplished by an up-modulation of TCA cycle enzymes was also noticed, probably suggesting an efficient recycling of amino acids as energy source. Proteomic analysis of plants grown at optimal temperature allowed to specifically discriminate cold-induced proteins and highlight molecular processes driven by vernalization. Among identified proteins typically involved in vernalization responses and floral transition we observed a marked increase of wrab17, wcor18 and glycine-rich RNA-binding proteins.     

Characterization of freezing tolerance and vernalization in Vern-, a spring-type Brassica napus line derived from a winter cross

Exposure of winter brassicas to periods of low temperature decreases the transition required from vegetative to reproductive growth. This low-temperature exposure also results in the acquisition of freezing tolerance. To investigate the relationship between vernalization and freezing tolerance, homozygous microspore-derived (DH) lines were developed from reciprocal crosses between two winter cultivars of Brassica napus L., cv. Cascade and cv. Rebel. A resulting line, termed Vern-, expressed a high degree of freezing tolerance and was selected for study. Analysis of growth and development revealed that Vern- is a true spring type, having completely lost the vernalization requirement. Using markers previously mapped in B. rapa, it was concluded that Vern- inherited freezing-tolerance alleles from Cascade. With regard to vernalization and flowering time, Rebel, although traditionally classified as a winter type, carries spring alleles at the major and some of the minor loci. Vern- inherited these alleles from Rebel, in addition to one spring allele from Cascade. Thus, spring alleles from both parents were critical in establishing the spring phenotype observed in Vern-.     

Natural variation of barley vernalization requirements: implication of quantitative variation of winter growth habit as an adaptive trait in East Asia

In many temperate plant species, prolonged cold treatment, known as vernalization, is one of the most critical steps in the transition from the vegetative to the reproductive stage. In contrast to recent advances in understanding the molecular basis of vernalization in Arabidopsis non-vernalization mutants or the spring growth habits of cereal crops such as wheat and barley, natural variations in winter growth habits and their geographic distribution are poorly understood. We analyzed varietal variation and the geographic distribution of the degree of vernalization requirements in germplasms of domesticated barley and wild barley collections. We found a biased geographic distribution of vernalization requirements in domesticated barley: Western regions were strongly associated with a higher degree of spring growth habits, and the extreme winter growth habits were localized to Far Eastern regions including China, Korea and Japan. Both wild accessions and domesticated landraces, the regions of distribution of which overlapped each other, mainly belonged to the moderate class of winter growth habit. As a result of quantitative evaluations performed in this study, we provide evidence that the variation in the degree of winter growth habit in recombinant inbred lines was controlled by quantitative trait loci including three vernalization genes (VRN1, VRN2 and VRN3) that account for 37.9% of the variation in vernalization requirements, with unknown gene(s) explaining the remaining two-thirds of the variation. This evidence implied that the Far Eastern accessions might be a genetically differentiated group derived for an evolutionary reason, resulting in their greater tendency towards a winter growth habit.     

Discrete developmental roles for temperate cereal grass VERNALIZATION1/FRUITFULL-like genes in flowering competency and the transition to flowering

Members of the grass subfamily Pooideae are characterized by their adaptation to cool temperate climates. Vernalization is the process whereby flowering is accelerated in response to a prolonged period of cold. Winter cereals are tolerant of low temperatures and flower earlier with vernalization, whereas spring cultivars are intolerant of low temperatures and flower later with vernalization. In the pooid grasses wheat (Triticum monococcum, Triticum aestivum) and barley (Hordeum vulgare), vernalization responsiveness is determined by allelic variation at the VERNALIZATION1 (VRN1) and/or VRN2 loci. To determine whether VRN1, and its paralog FRUITFULL2 (FUL2), are involved in vernalization requirement across Pooideae, we determined expression profiles for multiple cultivars of oat (Avena sativa) and wheat with and without cold treatment. Our results demonstrate significant up-regulation of VRN1 expression in leaves of winter oat and wheat in response to vernalization; no treatment effect was found for spring or facultative growth habit oat and wheat. Similar cold-dependent patterns of leaf expression were found for FUL2 in winter oat, but not winter wheat, suggesting a redundant qualitative role for these genes in the quantitative induction of flowering competency of oat. These and other data support the hypothesis that VRN1 is a common regulator of vernalization responsiveness within the crown pooids. Finally, we found that up-regulation of VRN1 in vegetative meristems of oat was significantly later than in leaves. This suggests distinct and conserved roles for temperate cereal grass VRN1/FUL-like genes, first, in systemic signaling to induce flowering competency, and second, in meristems to activate genes involved in the floral transition.     

The Characterization and Geographical Distribution of the Genes Responsible for Vernalization Requirement in Chinese Bread Wheat

The frequency and distribution of the major vernalization requirement genes and their effects on growth habits were studied.Of the 551 bread wheat genotypes tested,seven allelic combinations of the three Vrn.1 genes were found to be responsible for the spring habit,three for the facultative habit and one for the winter habit.The three Vrn-1 genes behaved additively with the dominant allele of Vrn-A1 exerting the strongest effect.The allele combinations of the facultative genotypes and the discovery of spring genotypes with "winter" allele of Vrn-1 implied the presence of as yet unidentified alleles/genes for vernalization response.The dominant alleles of the three Vrn-1 genes were found in all ten ecological regions where wheat Is cultivated in China,with Vrn-D1 as the most common allele in nine and Vrn-A1 in one.The combination of vrn-A 1vrnB 1Vrn-D1 was the predominant genotype in seven of the regions.Compared with landraces,improved varieties contain a higher proportion of the spring type.This was attributed by a higher frequency of the dominant Vrn-A1 and Vrn-B1 alleles in the latter.Correlations between Vrn-1 allelic constitutions and heading date,spike length,plant type as well as cold tolerance were established.