Analysis of differences between coomassie blue stain and silver stain procedures in polyacrylamide gels: conditions for the detection of calmodulin and troponin C

It is reported that the conditions used in some silver stain procedures can fail to detect calmodulin, troponin C, and other proteins with similar physical properties. Conditions are described that allow the reproducible detection of these proteins. Two phenomena are described: (1) lack of protein staining when treatment with glutaraldehyde is omitted from the protocol, and (2) loss of small proteins from the gel matrix during prolonged washing procedures. These data directly demonstrate that the use of some silver staining protocols can result in misleading data in biological studies and provide an explanation for at least one class of proteins of how silver staining and Coomassie blue staining of gels can give different results.     

Artifactual sulfation of silver-stained proteins: implications for the assignment of phosphorylation and sulfation sites

Sulfation and phosphorylation are post-translational modifications imparting an isobaric 80-Da addition on the side chain of serine, threonine, or tyrosine residues. These two post-translational modifications are often difficult to distinguish because of their similar MS fragmentation patterns. Targeted MS identification of these modifications in specific proteins commonly relies on their prior separation using gel electrophoresis and silver staining. In the present investigation, we report a potential pitfall in the interpretation of these modifications from silver-stained gels due to artifactual sulfation of serine, threonine, and tyrosine residues by sodium thiosulfate, a commonly used reagent that catalyzes the formation of metallic silver deposits onto proteins. Detailed MS analyses of gel-separated protein standards and Escherichia coli cell extracts indicated that several serine, threonine, and tyrosine residues were sulfated using silver staining protocols but not following Coomassie Blue staining. Sodium thiosulfate was identified as the reagent leading to this unexpected side reaction, and the degree of sulfation was correlated with increasing concentrations of thiosulfate up to 0.02%, which is typically used for silver staining. The significance of this artifact is discussed in the broader context of sulfation and phosphorylation site identification from in vivo and in vitro experiments.     

The mechanism of silver staining of proteins separated by SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

Gel based silver staining of proteins is thought to occur by selective reduction of silver ions to insoluble metallic silver at specific initiation sites in the vicinity of the protein molecules. Silver stained protein bands generally are dark brown or black with considerable variation in color intensity. The color variation has been attributed to diffractive scattering by silver grains of different sizes. Our experiments, however, demonstrate that color variation is due to the formation of silver chromate deposits that are incorporated into formalin fixed proteins. Understanding the mechanism of silver staining is essential for developing a method for protein quantification.     

微量蛋白检测中不同银染方法的比较与分析

随着生物化学技术的不断发展,作为检测SDS-聚丙烯酰胺凝胶电泳(SDS-PAGE)中微量蛋白的银染方法也在不断改进和发展.采用4种不同的银染方法检测不同含量的牛血清白蛋白,结果显示单纯的银染过程中如果使用戊二醛固定会使蛋白检出更快速灵敏,而结合考马斯亮蓝的复合银染则较单纯银染灵敏度提高了5～7个数量级.     

Silver stain for detecting 10-femtogram quantities of protein after polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

A rapid and highly sensitive silver stain and color stain were developed for visualizing proteins. The procedure is simple and the bands were clear. This silver stain detects 100 pg quantities of proteins. In order to stain quickly, sensitively, and sharply a protein matrix in a gel, the repeated shrinkage and swelling gel was developed with a hyper- and hypotonic solution to remove the sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) from SDS-protein complex and to generate influx of staining solution into the gel. We have found that the silver staining method with the repeated exposure to hyper- and hypotonic solution and a narrow well produced 10 fg order of proteins.     

Yet another improved silver staining method for the detection of proteins in polyacrylamide gels

Silver staining is very sensitive for detection of proteins in polyacrylamide gels and different procedures have been published. By combining and modifying some of the recipes, a very reproducible method, which is based upon staining with diamine complexes of silver, has been developed. The background staining is negligible and reduced silver does not precipitate on the gel surface. The technique works very well for sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in both homogeneous and in gradient gels as well as for two-dimensional (2-D) PAGE. It was possible to detect 1-10 ng of protein corresponding to approximately 50 pg/mm2, provided that a discontinuous buffer system was used, which gives sharp bands.     

A nondenaturing vertical isoelectric focusing polyacrylamide slab gel system suitable for silver staining and electrophoretic blotting

We have devised a nondenaturing vertical isoelectric focusing (IEF)-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) system which is amenable to silver staining and electroblotting. Apart from being accessible, inexpensive, and simple to use, this new methodology overcomes problems inherent in current IEF methods, for example, pH gradient drift, nonuniform cooling, restricted sample volume, and inability to perform electroblotting. Two photopolymerization gel formulas were derived: a 5% acrylamide formula using bisacrylamide (Bis) as the crosslinker and a 6% acrylamide formula using diallyltartdiamide (DATD) as the crosslinker. The 5% acrylamide Bis gel gave excellent resolution and separation of proteins whereas the 6% acrylamide DATD gel expanded slightly during silver staining, resulting in mild band distortions. At least 80 ng of protein per band could be detected by the silver staining protocol devised. Both the DATD and the Bis gels were suitable for electroblot transfer. Parameters to ensure the optimum conditions for reproducible, high resolution vertical IEF-PAGE are described. IEF-PAGE silver staining and electroblotting procedures and silver staining of the nitrocellulose electroblot procedures are also described. The advantages of this methodology over previously published methods are discussed.     

Carbon dioxide of air inhibits the formation of silver nanoparticles initiated by proteins in polyacrylamide gel and in solution

It was shown that the staining of proteins in polyacrylamide gel by silver is inhibited by contact with air of the ammonia complex with silver ions used at the first stage of detection. It was proved by experiments on the reduction of silver by ethanolamine from a complex with ethanolamine and by formaldehyde from a complex with ammonia that the formation of silver nanoparticles initiated by proteins is inhibited by air carbon dioxide. The participation of carbon dioxide in this process is discussed. It was found that even the breathing of an experimenter can induce variations in carbon dioxide concentration sufficient to adversely affect the reproducibility of the silver staining techniques. It was concluded that, for stable staining of proteins by silver in polyacrylamide gel, it is necessary to maintain a low concentration of carbon dioxide in air over the detection solutions.     

Two-dimensional gel electrophoretic resolution of the polypeptides of rat liver mitochondria and the outer membrane

The proteins of highly purified rat liver mitochondria were resolved by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and detected by staining with either Coomassie blue or silver. Approximately 250 polypeptides were detected with silver staining which is 2- to 3-times that observed with Coomassie blue. Silver staining was especially more effective than Coomassie blue for detecting polypeptides of less than 50 000 daltons. A two-dimensional gel pattern of rat liver microsomes was distinct from that of the mitochondria. The mitochondrial outer membrane was prepared from purified mitochondria either with digitonin or by swelling in a hypotonic medium. As assessed by marker enzymes, the latter method yielded a considerably purer outer membrane preparation (20-fold purification) than the former (2.6-fold purification). Approximately 50 polypeptides were observed in a two-dimensional gel (pH 3-10) of the highly purified outer membrane fraction. Three isoelectric forms of the pore (VDAC) protein were observed with pI values of 8.2, 7.8 and 7.1. Monoamine oxidase was identified as a polypeptide of Mr 60 000. About 50 polypeptides were also resolved in a reverse polarity non-equilibrium pH gradient electrophoresis gel of the outer membrane, pH 3-10, with at least six isoelectric forms of the VDAC protein observed under these conditions. The six isoforms of the VDAC protein were also observed in a non-equilibrium gel with 2 micrograms of the purified protein.     

About the mechanism of interference of silver staining with peptide mass spectrometry

The mechanism by which silver staining of proteins in polyacrylamide gels interferes with mass spectrometry of peptides produced by proteolysis has been investigated. It was demonstrated that this interference increases with time between silver staining and gel processing, although the silver image is constant. This suggested an important role of the formaldehyde used in silver staining development in this interference process. Consequently, a formaldehyde-free staining protocol has been devised, using carbohydrazide as the developing agent. This protocol showed much increased peptide coverage and retained the sensitivity of silver staining. These results were however obtained at the expense of an increased background in the stained gels and of a reduced staining homogeneity.     

A new silver staining apparatus and procedure for matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight analysis of proteins after two-dimensional electrophoresis

We report on a new silver stain especially developed for staining large gels (25 cm x 20 cm) from the Hoefer ISO-DALT system for matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight (MALDI-TOF) analysis of proteins. The staining protocol can be summarized as follows: the gels are sensitised in tetrathionate/potassium acetate solution and washed several times in distilled water. After impregnation with silver nitrate, the silver is reduced in the presence of potassium carbonate, thiosulphate and formaldehyde. The staining procedure is stopped with Tris/acetate after which the gels are rinsed and stored in water before spot picking for MALDI-TOF analysis is performed. This protocol has several advantages over existing ones. The gels are stained in a new apparatus that reduces gel handling to a minimum thus also reducing the contamination with keratins to a minimum. The development times in potassium carbonate are very long (up to 40 min) thus improving batch-to-batch reproducibility. Only the surface of the proteins is stained and the silver can be oxidized, thereafter MALDI-TOF can be performed with protein loads as little as 100 micrograms per gel.     

A comparison of silver staining methods for detecting proteins in ultrathin polyacrylamide gels on support film after isoelectric focusing

The application of silver staining methods to the detection of proteins on ultrathin isoelectric focusing gel systems requires the optimization of many steps in the procedure in order to obtain reproducible staining of proteins with acceptable levels of background. Three different methods which have been reported for detecting proteins by silver staining in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel systems were investigated. A major problem with staining ultrathin isoelectric focusing gels was found to be surface staining that was associated with gels cast on support films. A modification of the method of Poehling and Neuhoff (H.-M. Poehling and V. Neuhoff, 1981, Electrophoresis 2, 141-147) was found to give the best results.     

A comprehensive evaluation of imidazole‐zinc reverse stain for current proteomic researches

In this paper, we comprehensively evaluated the capability of imidazole‐zinc reverse stain (ZN) in comparative proteomics. Three commonly used protein gel staining methods, including silver (SN), SYPRO Ruby (SR), and CB stain were investigated alongside for comparison purpose. A transparency scanning procedure, which may deliver more even and contrasting gel images, was found best for documenting ZN stained gels. Our results showed that ZN was more sensitive than SN, SR, and CB. It may reveal as few as 1.8 ng of proteins in a gel. Moreover, ZN was found to provide a linear dynamic range of staining for revealing proteins up to 140 ng, and show an insignificant staining preference. To analyze a ZN stained 2‐D gel image that generally comprises an apparent but even background, the Melanie 4 software was found more suitable than others. Furthermore, ZN demonstrated an equivalent or better MS compatibility than the other three staining methods. Intense and comprehensive MS profiles were frequently observed for ZN stained gel spots. Approximate two‐third of ZN stained gel spots were successfully identified for protein identities. Taken together, our results suggest that the prompt, cost effective and versatile ZN is well suited for current proteomic researches.     

Proteome analysis of rat hippocampal neurons by multiple large gel two-dimensional electrophoresis

The goal of the present study was to detect as many protein spots as possible in mammalian cells using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE). For proteome analysis, it is of importance to reveal as many proteins as possible. A single standard 2-DE gel (pH 3-10, 18 cm x 20 cm, 13.5% gel) could detect 853 spots from proteins of cultured rat hippocampal neurons when visualized by silver staining. To increase the resolution of the separation and the number of detectable proteins by 2-DE, we utilized seven different narrow pH range immobilized pH gradients in the first dimension. In the second dimension, fourteen long SDS polyacrylamide gels were used: seven 7.5% gels for the separation of high molecular mass proteins (> or = 40 kDa) and seven 13.5% gels for the separation of low molecular mass proteins (< or = 40 kDa). Three hundred and sixty microg of proteins from cultured hippocampal neurons were loaded on to individual gels and visualized by silver staining. All 14 gel images were assembled into a 70 cm x 67 cm cybergel that contained 6677 protein spots, thereby indicating that the utilization of the present strategy led to a 783% increase in the number of detected spots in comparison to the standard procedure. Loading double the amount (720 microg) of proteins on to a 13.5% gel led to a 184% increase in the number of detected spots, thereby indicating that the present strategy has a potential to display more protein spots in the cybergels.     

Proteomic analysis of human biopsy samples by single two-dimensional electrophoresis: Coomassie,silver, mass spectrometry,and Western blotting

Proteomic analysis of myocardial tissue from patient populations is critical to our understanding of cardiac disease, but has been limited until now by the small size of biopsies (approximately 20-50 microg), and complicated by the difference in relative abundance of contractile proteins over other cellular components. Here we describe an approach to analysis of myocardial biopsies from patients undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery. First, individual biopsies are selectively extracted, producing subfractions that correspond to the contractile proteins and the cytosolic proteins. Two-dimensional electrophoresis separated proteins are detected by first staining with Coomassie blue then silver, to permit a wider range of accurate quantification. Western blotting of two-dimensional separated samples, to validate peptide mass fingerprinting data, previously required additional gel separations for transfer since staining protocols are not compatible with transfer to membranes or immunoblotting. An existing silver destaining protocol was adapted to allow removal of silver from a whole gel, followed by transfer and Western blotting. An existing Coomassie blue removal protocol was also adapted to permit Western blotting of gels stained with Coomassie blue and silver. Together, these techniques permit peptide mass fingerprinting concurrent with Western blotting of a single protein spot from a single biopsy, eliminating the need for repeated gel separations, and improving spot alignment between immunoblots and stained gels. In the end, this approach may allow a more complete characterization of protein changes in small human biopsies, and also reduce the number of repeated gel separations necessary for a standard proteomic analysis.     

A 250-kilodalton cellular protein is induced by progestins in two human breast cancer cell lines MCF7 and T47D

We have studied the effect of R5020, a synthetic progestin, on the biosynthesis of cellular proteins extracted from the MCF7 and T47D human breast cancer cells, using gel electrophoresis. R5020 stimulates the synthesis, as measured after [35S]-methionine labelling, and the accumulation, as shown by silver staining, of a protein of molecular weight approximately equal to 250,000. The increase of the labelled 250-kilodalton protein was rapid (3 hours) and after 3 days this protein represented approximately equal to 6% of the total cellular proteins (approximately equal to 1 microgram/150,000 cells). The induction of the 250-kilodalton protein was obtained by physiologically active concentrations of several progestins and high concentrations of 5 alpha-dihydrotestosterone but not by estradiol or dexamethasone. It was inhibited by R486 , a progestin antagonist, but not by flutamide, an androgen antagonist. These results indicate a mediation by the progesterone receptor. The 250-kilodalton protein appears to be an excellent probe to study in cell culture the mechanism of action of progestin on human cells.     

A method for rapid and sensitive negative staining of proteins in SDS‐PAGE using 2′,7′‐dichlorofluorescein

We report here a rapid and sensitive technique for negative visualization of protein in 1D and 2D SDS‐PAGE by using 2′, 7′‐dichlorofluorescein (DCF), which appeared as transparent and colorless bands in an opaque gel matrix background. For DCF stain, down to 0.1–0.2 ng protein could be easily visualized within 7 min by only two steps, and the staining is fourfold more sensitive than that of Eosin Y (EY) negative stain and glutaraldehyde (GA) silver stain, and eightfold more sensitive than that of the commonly used imidazole‐zinc (IZ) negative stain. Furthermore, DCF stain provided good reproducibility, linearity, and MS compatibility compared with those of IZ stain. In addition, the potential staining mechanism was investigated by colorimetric experiment and molecular docking, and the results demonstrated that the interaction between DCF and protein occurs mainly via van der waals force, electrostatic interaction, and hydrogen bonding.     

Preparation of colloidal gold for staining proteins electrotransferred onto nitrocellulose membranes

This paper describes a simple method of preparing colloidal gold for staining protein blots. Colloidal gold was prepared from 0.005 or 0.01% HAuCl4 by the addition of formalin as a reductant and potassium hydroxide. Staining of small cell carcinoma tissue extract blotted onto nitrocellulose membranes with this colloidal gold solution resulted in the appearance of a large number of clear wine-red bands. The sensitivity of gold staining was 60 times higher than that of Coomassie brilliant blue staining and almost comparable to that of silver staining of proteins in polyacrylamide gel. The sensitivity of this method was also satisfactory in comparison with that of enzyme immunoblotting. The colloidal gold prepared by this method is usable for routine work.     

一种改进的双向电泳染色方法

本文涉及了双向电泳过程中的染色方法,即先用考马斯亮蓝染色,将胶上可见蛋白切下再银染的方法。这种方法可最大限度的减少胶中蛋白质点的损失,不仅避免了单一用考马斯亮蓝染色由于灵敏度不高而导致的低丰度蛋白的损失,也避免了单一用银染而使高丰度的蛋白因染色过度导致的损失。同时两种传统的染色方法结合完美,形成的新方法经济实用。     

Study of human erythrocyte membrane proteins by 2-dimensional electrophoresis

Fractionation of human erythrocyte membrane proteins was performed using a modification of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis described by P. O'Farrel with isoelectric point plotted against molecular mass. All major erythrocyte proteins, including high molecular weight proteins, such as spectrin and band 3 protein, identified by one-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis, were visualized by silver staining of two-dimensional gels. All in all about 50 polypeptides were distinguished on two-dimensional electrophoretic patterns. Preliminary protein map was developed.