CIRCADIAN RHYTHMS OF PERFORMANCE: NEW TRENDS

This brief review is concerned with how human performance efficiency changes as a function of time of day. It presents an overview of some of the research paradigms and conceptual models that have been used to investigate circadian performance rhythms. The influence of homeostatic and circadian processes on performance regulation is discussed. The review also briefly presents recent mathematical models of alertness that have been used to predict cognitive performance. Related topics such as interindividual differences and the postlunch dip are presented. (Chronobiology International, 17(6), 719–732, 2000)     

Combining theoretical and experimental approaches to understand the circadian clock

This review is intended as a summary of our work carried out as part of the German Research Association (DFG) Center Program on Circadian Rhythms. Over the last six years, our approach to understanding circadian systems combined theoretical and experimental tools, and Gonyaulax and Neurospora have proven ideal for these efforts. Both of these model organisms demonstrate that even simple circadian systems can have multiple light input pathways and more than one rhythm generator. They have both been used to elaborate basic circadian features in conjunction with formal models. The models introduce the “zeitnehmer,” i.e., a clock-regulated input pathway, to the conceptual framework of circadian systems, and proposes networks of individual feedbacks as the basis for circadian rhythmicity.     

Combining Theoretical and Experimental Approaches to Understand the Circadian Clock

This review is intended as a summary of our work carried out as part of the German Research Association (DFG) Center Program on Circadian Rhythms. Over the last six years, our approach to understanding circadian systems combined theoretical and experimental tools, and Gonyaulax and Neurospora have proven ideal for these efforts. Both of these model organisms demonstrate that even simple circadian systems can have multiple light input pathways and more than one rhythm generator. They have both been used to elaborate basic circadian features in conjunction with formal models. The models introduce the “zeitnehmer,” i.e., a clock‐regulated input pathway, to the conceptual framework of circadian systems, and proposes networks of individual feedbacks as the basis for circadian rhythmicity.     

Development and validation of computational models for mammalian circadian oscillators

Circadian rhythms are endogenous rhythms with a cycle length of approximately 24 h. Rhythmic production of specific proteins within pacemaker structures is the basis for these physiological and behavioral rhythms. Prior work on mathematical modeling of molecular circadian oscillators has focused on the fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster. Recently, great advances have been made in our understanding of the molecular basis of circadian rhythms in mammals. Mathematical models of the mammalian circadian oscillator are needed to piece together diverse data, predict experimental results, and help us understand the clock as a whole. Our objectives are to develop mathematical models of the mammalian circadian oscillator, generate and test predictions from these models, gather information on the parameters needed for model development, integrate the molecular model with an existing model of the influence of light and rhythmicity on human performance, and make models available in BioSpice so that they can be easily used by the general community. Two new mammalian models have been developed, and experimental data are summarized. These studies have the potential to lead to new strategies for resetting the circadian clock. Manipulations of the circadian clock can be used to optimize performance by promoting alertness and physiological synchronization.     

Picking out parallels: plant circadian clocks in context.

Molecular models have been described for the circadian clocks of representatives of several different taxa. Much of the work on the plant circadian system has been carried out using the thale cress, Arabidopsis thaliana, as a model. We discuss the roles of genes implicated in the plant circadian system, with special emphasis on Arabidopsis. Plants have an endogenous clock that regulates many aspects of circadian and photoperiodic behaviour. Despite the discovery of components that resemble those involved in the clocks of animals or fungi, no coherent model of the plant clock has yet been proposed. In this review, we aim to provide an overview of studies of the Arabidopsis circadian system. We shall compare these with results from different taxa and discuss them in the context of what is known about clocks in other organisms.     

Circadian rhythms of locomotor activity in Drosophila

Drosophila is by far the most advanced model to understand the complex biochemical interactions upon which circadian clocks rely. Most of the genes that have been characterized so far were isolated through genetic screens using the locomotor activity rhythms of the adults as a circadian output. In addition, new techniques are available to deregulate gene expression in specific cells, allowing to analyze the growing number of developmental genes that also play a role as clock genes. However, one of the major challenges in circadian biology remains to properly interpret complex behavioral data and use them to fuel molecular models. This review tries to describe the problems that clockwatchers have to face when using Drosophila activity rhythms to understand the multiple facets of circadian function.     

Methodological Issues in Studies of Rhythms in Human Performance

In this review various sources of measurement error are considered in the context of investigating rhythms in human performance. The reproducibility of performance in any exercise task is an important factor if rhythmic variations are to be detectable. Available physical performance tests range from simple efforts lasting only a couple of seconds to sustained endurance exercise. When measuring muscle strength, the options include static or dynamic actions, slow or fast movements, voluntary or electrically stimulated contractions and maximal force or maximal power output. For studies of circadian rhythms the researcher has to choose between using nychthemeral or controlled conditions, and the number of times a day to be used for observations, and to decide how to control for loss of sleep, diet and prior activity. The need to recover energy between tests has led research groups to employ diurnal rhythm models in preference to cosinor analysis of circadian designs. The use of male subjects has also been favoured due to difficulties of controlling for menstrual cycle phase. Nevertheless recent attention has been given to research models for investigating the effects of rhythmic variations in female steroid hormones and on interactions between circadian and circamensal rhythms. There are real challenges in exploring seasonal variations in human performance and in examining how the body adjusts after desynchronisation as occurs during nocturnal shift-work and travelling across multiple time zones. The methods adopted must accommodate flexibility between laboratory-based and field-studies depending on the context of the research questions being pursued.     

Methodological Issues in Studies of Rhythms in Human Performance

In this review various sources of measurement error are considered in the context of investigating rhythms in human performance. The reproducibility of performance in any exercise task is an important factor if rhythmic variations are to be detectable. Available physical performance tests range from simple efforts lasting only a couple of seconds to sustained endurance exercise. When measuring muscle strength, the options include static or dynamic actions, slow or fast movements, voluntary or electrically stimulated contractions and maximal force or maximal power output. For studies of circadian rhythms the researcher has to choose between using nychthemeral or controlled conditions, and the number of times a day to be used for observations, and to decide how to control for loss of sleep, diet and prior activity. The need to recover energy between tests has led research groups to employ diurnal rhythm models in preference to cosinor analysis of circadian designs. The use of male subjects has also been favoured due to difficulties of controlling for menstrual cycle phase. Nevertheless recent attention has been given to research models for investigating the effects of rhythmic variations in female steroid hormones and on interactions between circadian and circamensal rhythms. There are real challenges in exploring seasonal variations in human performance and in examining how the body adjusts after desynchronisation as occurs during nocturnal shift-work and travelling across multiple time zones. The methods adopted must accommodate flexibility between laboratory-based and field-studies depending on the context of the research questions being pursued.     

Monitoring of rest-activity rhythm in cancer patients paves the way for the adoption of patient-specific chronotherapeutic approach

The status and phases of the circadian timing system (CTS) can be ascertained through measuring several biological functions. Of those measurements, rest-activity rhythm is considered as a reliable circadian biomarker to evaluate the function of CTS among oncology population. Its amenable non-invasive monitoring over longitudinal time scale makes it more appropriate and convenient. Its use as reference rhythm for timing the medications is widely accepted in cancer and sleep clinics. Current mini review highlights the present knowledge on different actigraphy devices used for the measurement of circadian rest-activity rhythm. Further, this review presents recent data dealing with the status of circadian rest-activity rhythm in cancer patients and discusses its association with health-related patients’ quality of life. Application of this concept supports that the interventions with abilities to reverse CTS dysfunction in cancer patients might prolong their survival with improved and acceptable level of health-related quality of life.     

On mathematical modeling of circadian rhythms, performance, and alertness

Mathematical models of neurobehavioral performance and alertness have both basic science and practical applications. These models can be especially useful in predicting the effect of different sleep-wake schedules on human neurobehavioral objective performance and subjective alertness under many conditions. Several relevant models currently exist in the literature. In principle, the development and refinement of any mathematical model should be based on an explicit modeling methodology, such as the Box modeling paradigm, that formally defines the model structure and calculates the set of parameters. While most mathematical models of neurobehavioral performance and alertness include homeostatic, circadian, and sleep inertia components and their interactions, there may be fundamental differences in the equations included in these models. In part, these may be due to differences in the assumptions of the underlying physiology. Because the choice of model equations can have a dramatic influence on the results, it is necessary to consider these differences in assumptions when examining the results from a model and when comparing results across models. This article presents principles of mathematical modeling and examples of how such procedures can be applied to the development and refinement of mathematical models of neurobehavioral performance and alertness. This article also presents several methods of testing and comparing these models, suggests different uses of the models, and discusses problems with current models.     

哺乳动物似昼夜节律研究概要

本文参阅了50年代以来有关昼夜节律研究的重要著作,并根据近年来国内外发表的节律研究论文综合整理写成。     

The times they’re a-changing: Effects of circadian desynchronization on physiology and disease

Circadian rhythms are endogenous and need to be continuously entrained (synchronized) with the environment. Entrainment includes both coupling internal oscillators to external periodic changes as well as synchrony between the central clock and peripheral oscillators, which have been shown to exhibit different phases and resynchronization speed. Temporal desynchronization induces diverse physiological alterations that ultimately decrease quality of life and induces pathological situations. Indeed, there is a considerable amount of evidence regarding the deleterious effect of circadian dysfunction on overall health or on disease onset and progression, both in human studies and in animal models. In this review we discuss the general features of circadian entrainment and introduce diverse experimental models of desynchronization. In addition, we focus on metabolic, immune and cognitive alterations under situations of acute or chronic circadian desynchronization, as exemplified by jet-lag and shiftwork schedules. Moreover, such situations might lead to an enhanced susceptibility to diverse cancer types. Possible interventions (including light exposure, scheduled timing for meals and use of chronobiotics) are also discussed.     

Reciprocal interactions between circadian clocks and aging

Virtually, all biological processes in the body are modulated by an internal circadian clock which optimizes physiological and behavioral performance according to the changing demands of the external 24-h world. This circadian clock undergoes a number of age-related changes, at both the physiological and molecular levels. While these changes have been considered to be part of the normal aging process, there is increasing evidence that disruptions to the circadian system can substantially impact upon aging and these impacts will have clear health implications. Here we review the current data of how both the physiological and core molecular clocks change with age and how feedback from external cues may modulate the aging of the circadian system.     

Circadian rhythms vary over the growing season and correlate with fitness components

Circadian clocks have evolved independently in all three domains of life, suggesting that internal mechanisms of time‐keeping are adaptive in contemporary populations. However, the performance consequences of either discrete or quantitative clock variation have rarely been tested in field settings. Clock sensitivity of diverse segregating lines to the environment remains uncharacterized as do the statistical genetic parameters that determine evolutionary potential. In field studies with Arabidopsis thaliana, we found that major perturbations to circadian cycle length (referred to as clock period) via mutation reduce both survival and fecundity. Subtler adjustments via genomic introgression of naturally occurring alleles indicated that clock periods slightly >24 hr were adaptive, consistent with prior models describing how well the timing of biological processes is adjusted within a diurnal cycle (referred to as phase). In segregating recombinant inbred lines (RILs), circadian phase varied up to 2 hr across months of the growing season, and both period and phase expressed significant genetic variances. Performance metrics including developmental rate, size and fruit set were described by principal components (PC) analyses and circadian parameters correlated with the first PC, such that period lengths slightly >24 hr were associated with improved performance in multiple RIL sets. These experiments translate functional analyses of clock behaviour performed in controlled settings to natural ones, demonstrating that quantitative variation in circadian phase is highly responsive to seasonally variable abiotic factors. The results expand upon prior studies in controlled settings, showing that discrete and quantitative variation in clock phenotypes correlates with performance in nature.     

哺乳动物昼夜节律生物钟研究进展

昼夜节律生物钟是一种以近似24小时为周期的自主维持的振荡器,在分子水平上,该振荡器是一个由9个基因组成的转录翻译反馈环路系统。它能受外界环境影响重新设置节律,使自身机体活动处于最佳状态。除了进行自我调节外,生物钟基因还能通过调节代谢途径中特定基因表达而影响机体生理生化过程。在过去的几年里,借用遗传学和分子生物学工具,我们对哺乳动物昼夜节律生物钟的分子基础有了新的认识,本文综述了这一进展,并展望了它们在研究人的昼夜节律行为异常领域的前景。     

Evolutionary mechanisms underlying the functional divergence of duplicate genes involved in vertebrates' circadian rhythm pathway

Circadian rhythms, that are governed physiologically and behaviorally by endogenous clock, have been described in many species. Living organisms use this endogenous circadian clock to anticipate environmental transitions, perform activities at biologically advantageous times during the day, and undergo characteristic seasonal responses. Gene duplication is one of the most important mechanisms in the evolution of gene diversity. After duplication, one or both of duplicates can accumulate amino acid changes, thereby promoting functional divergence through the action of natural selection. The circadian system, like many other multigene families, has undergone this genetic revolution, and so circadian genes that are found in single copies in insects are duplicated in vertebrates. We analyzed six groups of genes involved in vertebrates' circadian rhythm pathway to find signatures of molecular evolutionary processes such as gene duplication, natural selection, recombination, and functional divergence. The obtained results, then, were used to determine what evolutionary forces have influenced the fates of duplicated genes of each group. We showed in this research that recombination has not been widespread during the evolution of circadian genes and that purifying selection has been the prominent natural pressure operating on circadian genes. We also showed that the evolution of circadian genes has been depended on gene duplication and functional divergence. Finally, we put forward models best describing the evolutionary fates of circadian duplicates.     

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii as a unicellular model for circadian rhythm analysis

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii has been used as an experimental model organism for circadian rhythm research for more than 30 yr. Some of the physiological rhythms of this alga are well established, and several clock mutants have been isolated. The cloning of clock genes from these mutant strains by positional cloning is under way and should give new insights into the mechanism of the circadian clock. In a spectacular space experiment, the question of the existence of an endogenous clock vs. an exogenous mechanism has been studied in this organism. With the emergence of molecular analysis of circadian rhythms in plants in 1985, a circadian gene expression pattern of several nuclear and chloroplast genes was detected. Evidence is now accumulating that shows circadian control at the translational level. In addition, the gating of the cell cycle by the circadian clock has been analyzed. This review focuses on the different aspects of circadian rhythm research in C. reinhardtii over the past 30 yr. The suitability of Chlamydomonas as a model system in chronobiology research and the adaptive significance of the observed rhythms will be discussed.     

Hierarchically coupled ultradian oscillators generating robust circadian rhythms

Ensembles of mutually coupled ultradian cellular oscillators have been proposed by a number of authors to explain the generation of circadian rhythms in mammals. Most mathematical models using many coupled oscillators predict that the output period should vary as the square root of the number of participating units, thus being inconsistent with the well-established experimental result that ablation of substantial parts of the suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN), the main circadian pacemaker in mammals, does not eliminate the overt circadian functions, which show no changes in the phases or periods of the rhythms. From these observations, we have developed a theoretical model that exhibits the robustness of the circadian clock to changes in the number of cells in the SCN, and that is readily adaptable to include the successful features of other known models of circadian regulation, such as the phase response curves and light resetting of the phase.     

Comparison of amplitude recovery dynamics of two limit cycle oscillator models of the human circadian pacemaker

At an organism level, the mammalian circadian pacemaker is a two-dimensional system. For these two dimensions, phase (relative timing) and amplitude of the circadian pacemaker are commonly used. Both the phase and the amplitude (A) of the human circadian pacemaker can be observed within multiple physiological measures--including plasma cortisol, plasma melatonin, and core body temperature (CBT)--all of which are also used as markers of the circadian system. Although most previous work has concentrated on changes in phase of the circadian system, critically timed light exposure can significantly reduce the amplitude of the pacemaker. The rate at which the amplitude recovers to its equilibrium level after reduction can have physiological significance. Two mathematical models that describe the phase and amplitude dynamics of the pacemaker have been reported. These models are essentially equivalent in predictions of phase and in predictions of amplitude recovery for small changes from an equilibrium value (A = 1), but are markedly different in the prediction of recovery rates when A < 0.6. To determine which dynamic model best describes the amplitude recovery observed in experimental data; both models were fit to CBT data using a maximum likelihood procedure and compared using Akaike's Information Criterion (AIC). For all subjects, the model with the lower recovery rate provided a better fit to data in terms of AIC, supporting evidence that the amplitude recovery of the endogenous pacemaker is slow at low amplitudes. Experiments derived from model predictions are proposed to test the influence of low amplitude recovery on the physiological and neurobehavioral functions.