Understanding the acid tolerance response of bifidobacteria

Aims: To investigate the effect of pH on the viability and the acid tolerance response (ATR) of bifidobacteria. Methods and Results: The impact of low pH on the viability of five species of bifidobacteria was examined under conditions of strict anaerobiosis. Although differences in the ability to resist the lethal effects of low pH were apparent among the species, cell viability could be improved by the provision of fermentable substrate during an acidic pH stress or through the use of stationary phase cells. While a stationary phase ATR was found to occur in two species of bifidobacteria, there was no adaptive response in exponential phase cells. Proteomic analysis of exponential phase Bifidobacterium longum subjected to a mild acid pre‐exposure (pH 4·5, 2 h) prior to an acid challenge revealed a substantial loss in the total number of cellular proteins. In contrast, proteomic analysis of stationary phase cells revealed an increased abundance of proteins associated with the general stress response as well as the β‐subunit of the F₀F₁‐ATPase, known to be important in bifidobacteria acid tolerance. Conclusion: Neither Bif. longum or Bifidobacterium breve possesses an inducible exponential phase ATR. Significance and Impact of the Study: These findings provide further insights into the impact of pH on the viability of bifidobacteria and may partially explain the loss in viability associated with their storage in acid foods.     

Changes in ffh, uvrA, groES and dnaK mRNA Abundance as a Function of Acid-Adaptation and Growth Phase in Bifidobacterium longum BBMN68 Isolated from Healthy Centenarians

The acid adaption is commonly used as a strategy to enhance the acid tolerance of bifidobacteria. However, the acid tolerance response (ATR) mechanism elicited by this method is unclear. Real-time relative-quantitative PCR was applied to analyze the changes in the expressions of ffh, uvrA, groES, and dnaK involved in the ATR after acid-adaptation in Bifidobacterium longum BBMN68 in different growth phases. BBMN68 was cultured at a constant neutral pH during the whole growth phase. Without acid-adaptation, the survival ratios at the lethal pH 3.0 were 0.25% and 17% in the exponential and stationary phases, respectively. The genes ffh, uvrA, groES, and dnaK were significantly higher in the stationary phase than in the exponential phase. The results indicated that although there was no acid stress, the acid tolerance of cells was elevated from the exponential phase into stationary phase. After acid-adaptation at pH 5.0 for 120 min, the survival ratios of BBMN68 in the exponential and stationary phases were increased to 2.5 and 31%, respectively. In the exponential phase, ffh, uvrA groES, and dnaK were significantly decreased after acid-adaptation. In the stationary phase, after acid-adaptation for 15, 60, and 120 min, the genes uvrA, groES, and dnaK were significantly decreased, whereas, ffh was significantly up-regulated at 15 min, and then suppressed at 60 and 120 min after acid-adaptation. The results represented that the ATR in B. longum was different from other bacteria, and ffh may be the transient acid gene.     

Lactococcus lactis and stress

It is now generally recognized that cell growth conditions in nature are often suboptimal compared to controlled conditions provided in the laboratory. Natural stresses like starvation and acidity are generated by cell growth itself. Other stresses like temperature or osmotic shock, or oxygen, are imposed by the environment. It is now clear that defense mechanisms to withstand different stresses must be present in all organisms. The exploration of stress responses in lactic acid bacteria has just begun. Several stress response genes have been revealed through homologies with known genes in other organisms. While stress response genes appear to be highly conserved, however, their regulation may not be. Thus, search of the regulation of stress response in lactic acid bacteria may reveal new regulatory circuits. The first part of this report addresses the available information on stress response in Lactococcus lactis.Acid stress response may be particularly important in lactic acid bacteria, whose growth and transition to stationary phase is accompanied by the production of lactic acid, which results in acidification of the media, arrest of cell multiplication, and possible cell death. The second part of this report will focus on progress made in acid stress response, particularly in L. lactis and on factors which may affect its regulation. Acid tolerance is presently under study in L. lactis. Our results with strain MG1363 show that it survives a lethal challenge at pH 4.0 if adapted briefly (5 to 15 minutes) at a pH between 4.5 and 6.5. Adaptation requires protein synthesis, indicating that acid conditions induce expression of newly synthesized genes. These results show that L. lactis possesses an inducible response to acid stress in exponential phase.To identify possible regulatory genes involved in acid stress response, we determined low pH conditions in which MG1363 is unable to grow, and selected at 37°C for transposition insertional mutants which were able to survive. About thirty mutants resistant to low pH conditions were characterized. The interrupted genes were identified by sequence homology with known genes. One insertion interrupts ahrC, the putative regulator of arginine metabolism; possibly, increased arginine catabolism in the mutant produces metabolites which increase the pH. Several other mutations putatively map at some step in the pathway of (p)ppGpp synthesis. Our results suggest that the stringent response pathway, which is involved in starvation and stationary phase survival, may also be implicated in acid pH tolerance.     

Day-to-night variations of cytoplasmic pH in a crassulacean acid metabolism plant

Summary In crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) large amounts of malic acid are redistributed between vacuole and cytoplasm in the course of night-to-day transitions. The corresponding changes of the cytoplasmic pH (pH_cyt) were monitored in mesophyll protoplasts from the CAM plantKalanchoe daigremontiana Hamet et Perrier by ratiometric fluorimetry with the fluorescent dye 2′,7′-bis-(2-carboxyethyl)-5-(and-6-)carboxyfluorescein as a pH_cyt indicator. At the beginning of the light phase, pH_cyt was slightly alkaline (about 7.5). It dropped during midday by about 0.3 pH units before recovering again in the late-day-to-early-dark phase. In the physiological context the variation in pH_cyt may be a component of CAM regulation. Due to its pH sensitivity, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase appears as a likely target enzyme. From monitoring ΔpH_cyt in response to loading the cytoplasm with the weak acid salt K-acetate a cytoplasmic H⁺-buffer capacity in the order of 65 mM H+ per pH unit was estimated at a pH_cyt of about 7.5. With this value, an acid load of the cytoplasm by about 10 mM malic acid can be estimated as the cause of the observed drop in pH_cyt. A diurnal oscillation in pH_cyt and a quantitatively similar cytoplasmic malic acid is predicted from an established mathematical model which allows simulation of the CAM dynamics. The similarity of model predictions and experimental data supports the view put forward in this model that a phase transition of the tonoplast is an essential functional element in CAM dynamics.     

Cytoplasmic membrane fluidity and fatty acid composition of Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans in response to pH stress

Strain variation in the acidophile Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans was examined as a product of membrane adaptation in response to pH stress. We tested the effects of sub and supra-optimal pH in two type strains and four strains isolated from acid mine drainage water around Sudbury, Ontario, Canada. Growth rate, membrane fluidity and phase, determined from the fluorescence polarization of 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene, and fatty acid profiles were compared. The effect of pH 1.5 was the most pronounced compared to the other pH values of 1.8, 3.1, and 3.5. Three different types of response to lower pH were observed, the first of which appeared to maintain cellular homeostasis more effectively. This adaptive mode included a decrease in membrane fluidity and concomitant depression of the phase transition in two distinct membrane lipid components. This was explained through the increase in saturated fatty acids (predominantly 16:0 and cyclopropane 19:0 w8c) with a concomitant decrease in 18:1 w7c fatty acid. The other strains also showed common adaptive mechanisms of specific fatty acid remodeling increasing the abundance of short-chain fatty acids. However, we suspect membrane permeability was compromised due to potential phase separation, which may interfere with energy transduction and viability at pH 1.5. We demonstrate that membrane physiology permits differentiating pH tolerance in strains of this extreme acidophile.     

Protective role of S-adenosyl-l-methionine against hydrochloric acid stress in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

S-adenosyl-l-methionine (AdoMet, 1 mM) protects the stationary phase cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae against the killing effect of acid (10 mM HCl, pH ∼ 2). Both the acid and the acid plus AdoMet treatment for 2 h increased the plasma membrane H⁺-ATPase activity; thereafter it decreased to the basal level. AdoMet partially recovered the intracellular pH (pH_in) that dropped in presence of acid. AdoMet treatment facilitated acid induced phospholipid biosynthesis as well as membrane proliferation, which was reflected in the cellular lipid composition.     

Determination of paromomycin in human plasma and urine by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography using 2,4-dinitrofluorobenzene derivatization

A sensitive high-performance liquid chromatographic method for the determination of paromomycin in human plasma and urine was developed. Paromomycin was quantitated following pre-column derivatization with 2,4-dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB). The chromatographic separation was carried out on a C₁₈ column at 50°C using a mobile phase consisting of 64% methanol in water adjusted to pH 3.0 with phosphoric acid. The eluents were monitored by UV detection at 350 nm. The linearity of response for paromomycin was demonstrated at concentrations from 0.5 to 50 μg/ml in plasma and 1 to 50 μg/ml in urine. The relative standard deviation of the assay procedure is less than 5%.     

Characterization of mutations in the PAS domain of the EvgS sensor kinase selected by laboratory evolution for acid resistance in Escherichia coli

Laboratory‐based evolution and whole‐genome sequencing can link genotype and phenotype. We used evolution of acid resistance in exponential phase Escherichia coli to study resistance to a lethal stress. Iterative selection at pH 2.5 generated five populations that were resistant to low pH in early exponential phase. Genome sequencing revealed multiple mutations, but the only gene mutated in all strains was evgS, part of a two‐component system that has already been implicated in acid resistance. All these mutations were in the cytoplasmic PAS domain of EvgS, and were shown to be solely responsible for the resistant phenotype, causing strong upregulation at neutral pH of genes normally induced by low pH. Resistance to pH 2.5 in these strains did not require the transporter GadC, or the sigma factor RpoS. We found that EvgS‐dependent constitutive acid resistance to pH 2.5 was retained in the absence of the regulators GadE or YdeO, but was lost if the oxidoreductase YdeP was also absent. A deletion in the periplasmic domain of EvgS abolished the response to low pH, but not the activity of the constitutive mutants. On the basis of these results we propose a model for how EvgS may become activated by low pH.     

The adaptive acid tolerance response in root nodule bacteria and Escherichia coli

Root nodule bacteria and Escherichia coli show an adaptive acid tolerance response when grown under mildly acidic conditions. This is defined in terms of the rate of cell death upon exposure to acid shock at pH 3.0 and expressed in terms of a decimal reduction time, D. The D values varied with the strain and the pH of the culture medium. Early exponential phase cells of three strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum (WU95, 3001 and WSM710) had D values of 1, 6 and 5 min respectively when grown at pH 7.0; and D values of 5, 20 and 12 min respectively when grown at pH 5.0. Exponential phase cells of Rhizobium tropici UMR1899, Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA110 and peanut Bradyrhizobium sp. NC92 were more tolerant with D values of 31, 35 and 42 min when grown at pH 7.0; and 56, 86 and 68 min when grown at pH 5.0. Cells of E. coli UB1301 in early exponential phase at pH 7.0 had a D value of 16 min, whereas at pH 5.0 it was 76 min. Stationary phase cells of R. leguminosarum and E. coli were more tolerant (D values usually 2 to 5-fold higher) than those in exponential phase. Cells of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii 3001 or E. coli UB1301 transferred from cultures at pH. 7.0 to medium at pH 5.0 grew immediately and induced the acid tolerance response within one generation. This was prevented by the addition of chloramphenicol. Acidadapted cells of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii WU95 and 3001; or E. coli UB1301, M3503 and M3504 were as sensitive to UV light as those grown at neutral pH.     

Selection method of pH conditions to establish Pseudomonas taetrolens physiological states and lactobionic acid production

Microbial physiological responses resulting from inappropriate bioprocessing conditions may have a marked impact on process performance within any fermentation system. The influence of different pH-control strategies on physiological status, microbial growth and lactobionic acid production from whey by Pseudomonas taetrolens during bioreactor cultivations has been investigated for the first time in this work. Both cellular behaviour and bioconversion efficiency from P. taetrolens were found to be negatively influenced by pH-control modes carried out at values lower than 6.0 and higher than 7.0. Production schemes were also influenced by the operational pH employed, with asynchronous production from damaged and metabolically active subpopulations at pH values lower than 6.0. Moreover, P. taetrolens showed reduced cellular proliferation and a subsequent delay in the onset of the production phase under acidic conditions (pH?<?6.0). Unlike cultivations performed at 6.5, both pH-shift and pH-stat cultivation strategies performed at pH values lower than 6.0 resulted in decreased lactobionic acid production. Whereas the cellular response showed a stress-induced physiological response under acidic conditions, healthy functional cells were predominant at medium operational pH values (6.5–7.0). P. taetrolens thus displayed a robust physiological status at initial pH value of 6.5, resulting in an enhanced bioconversion yield and lactobionic acid productivity (7- and 4-fold higher compared to those attained at initial pH values of 4.5 and 5.0, respectively). These results have shown that pH-control modes strongly affected both the physiological response of cells and the biological performance of P. taetrolens, providing key information for bio-production of lactobionic acid on an industrial scale.     

Uncoupling by Acetic Acid Limits Growth of and Acetogenesis by Clostridium thermoaceticum

When cells of the anaerobic thermophile Clostridium thermoaceticum grow in batch culture and homoferment glucose to acetic acid, the pH of the medium decreases until growth and then acid production cease, at about pH 5. We postulated that the end product of fermentation limits growth by acting as an uncoupling agent. Thus, when the pH of the medium is low, the cytoplasm of the cells becomes acidified below a tolerable pH. We have therefore measured the internal pH of growing cells and compared these values with those of nongrowing cells incubated in the absence of acetic acid. Growing cells maintained an interior about 0.6 pH units more alkaline than the exterior throughout most of batch growth (i.e., ΔpH = 0.6). We also measured the transmembrane electrical potential (ΔΨ), which decreased from 140 mV at pH 7 at the beginning of growth to 80 mV when the medium had reached pH 5. The proton motive force, therefore, was 155 mV at pH 7, decreasing to 120 mV at pH 5. When further fermentation acidified the medium below pH 5, both the ΔpH and the ΔΨ collapsed, indicating that these cells require an internal pH of at least 5.5 to 5.7. Cells harvested from stationary phase and suspended in citrate-phosphate buffer maintained a ΔpH of 1.5 at external pH 5.0. This ΔpH was dissipated by acetic acid (at the concentrations found in the growth medium) and other weak organic acids, as well as by ionophores and inhibitors of glycolysis and of the H⁺-ATPase. Nongrowing cells had a ΔΨ which ranged from about 116 mV at external pH 7 to about 55 mV at external pH 5 and which also was sensitive to ionophores. Since acetic acid, in its un-ionized form, diffuses passively across the cytoplasmic membrane, it effectively renders the membrane permeable to protons. It therefore seems unlikely that mutations at one or a few loci would result in C. thermoaceticum cells significantly more acetic acid tolerant than their parental type.     

Role of Listeria monocytogenes σB in Survival of Lethal Acidic Conditions and in the Acquired Acid Tolerance Response

The food-borne pathogen Listeria monocytogenes can acquire enhanced resistance to lethal acid conditions through multiple mechanisms. We investigated contributions of the stress-responsive alternative sigma factor, σ^B, which is encoded by sigB, to growth phase-dependent acid resistance (AR) and to the adaptive acid tolerance response in L. monocytogenes. At various points throughout growth, we compared the relative survival of L. monocytogenes wild-type and ΔsigB strains that had been exposed to either brain heart infusion (pH 2.5) or synthetic gastric fluid (pH 2.5) with and without prior acid adaptation. Under these conditions, survival of the ΔsigB strain was consistently lower than that of the wild-type strain throughout all phases of growth, ranging from 4 orders of magnitude less in mid-log phase to 2 orders of magnitude less in stationary phase. Survival of both ΔsigB and wild-type L. monocytogenes strains increased by 6 orders of magnitude upon entry into stationary phase, demonstrating that the L. monocytogenes growth phase-dependent AR mechanism is σ^B independent. σ^B-mediated contributions to acquired acid tolerance appear to be greatest in early logarithmic growth. Loss of a functional σ^B reduced the survival of L. monocytogenes at pH 2.5 to a greater extent in the presence of organic acid (100 mM acetic acid) than in the presence of inorganic acid alone (HCl), suggesting that L. monocytogenes protection against organic and inorganic acid may be mediated through different mechanisms. σ^B does not appear to contribute to pH_i homeostasis through regulation of net proton movement across the cell membrane or by regulation of pH_i buffering by the GAD system under the conditions examined in this study. In summary, a functional σ^B protein is necessary for full resistance of L. monocytogenes to lethal acid treatments.     

Negative chemotaxis inSpirochaeta aurantia

A repellent-gradient tube assay for negative chemotaxis inSpirochaeta aurantia was developed and used to demonstrate that acids, alcohols, and sulfide were effective chemorepellents. The threshold concentrations (the lowest concentration of a repellent that elicited a detectable response) for benzoic acid, salicylic acid, and butyric acid were 3×10^–5 M. For acetic acid, propionic acid,p-aminobenzoic acid, propanol, butanol, and sulfide, threshold concentrations were 10^–3 to 10^–4 M. For formic acid, glyoxylic acid, glycolic acid, lactic acid, malonic acid, succinic acid, fumaric acid, methanol, ethanol, ethanediol, and propanediol, threshold concentrations were 10^–2 to 10^–3 M. Compounds such as methylamine, ethanolamine, formaldehyde, benzene, toluene, phenol, indol, nickel, and various amino acids did not elicit a repellent response. The results of competition experiments suggest that the repellents identified are recognized by three distinct receptors: a weak acid receptor, an alcohol receptor, and a sulfide receptor. The repellent responses to weak acids were maximal at pH 5.5 and decreased with increasing pH, whereas the response to propanol was unaffected by pH over a range of 5.5–8.0. The demonstration of negative chemotaxis inS. aurantia and the identification of distinct classes of repellents will allow further experimentation directed at understanding chemosensory mechanisms in spirochetes.     

Acid and base resistance in Escherichia coli and Shigella flexneri: role of rpoS and growth pH.

Escherichia coli K-12 strains and Shigella flexneri grown to stationary phase can survive several hours at pH 2 to 3, which is considerably lower than the acid limit for growth (about pH 4.5). A 1.3-kb fragment cloned from S. flexneri conferred acid resistance on acid-sensitive E. coli HB101; sequence data identified the fragment as a homolog of rpoS, the growth phase-dependent sigma factor sigma 38. The clone also conferred acid resistance on S. flexneri rpoS::Tn10 but not on Salmonella typhimurium. E. coli and S. flexneri strains containing wild-type rpoS maintained greater internal pH in the face of a low external pH than strains lacking functional rpoS, but the ability to survive at low pH did not require maintenance of a high transmembrane pH difference. Aerobic stationary-phase cultures of E. coli MC4100 and S. flexneri 3136, grown initially at an external pH range of 5 to 8, were 100% acid resistant (surviving 2 h at pH 2.5). Aerobic log-phase cultures grown at pH 5.0 were acid resistant; survival decreased 10- to 100-fold as the pH of growth was increased to pH 8.0. Extended growth in log phase also decreased acid resistance substantially. Strains containing rpoS::Tn10 showed partial acid resistance when grown at pH 5 to stationary phase; log-phase cultures showed < 0.01% acid resistance. When grown anaerobically at low pH, however, the rpoS::Tn10 strains were acid resistant. E. coli MC4100 also showed resistance at alkaline pH outside the growth range (base resistance). Significant base resistance was observed up to pH 10.2. Base resistance was diminished by rpoS::Tn10 and by the presence of Na+. Base resistance was increased by an order of magnitude for stationary-phase cultures grown in moderate base (pH 8) compared with those grown in moderate acid (pH 5). Anaerobic growth partly restored base resistance in cultures grown at pH 5 but not in those grown at pH 8. Thus, both acid resistance and base resistance show dependence on growth pH and are regulated by rpoS under certain conditions. For acid resistance, and in part for base resistance, the rpoS requirement can be overcome by anaerobic growth in moderate acid.     

The Staphylococcus aureus Alternative Sigma Factor ςB Controls the Environmental Stress Response but Not Starvation Survival or Pathogenicity in a Mouse Abscess Model

The role of ς^B, an alternative sigma factor of Staphylococcus aureus, has been characterized in response to environmental stress, starvation-survival and recovery, and pathogenicity. ς^B was mainly expressed during the stationary phase of growth and was repressed by 1 M sodium chloride. A sigB insertionally inactivated mutant was created. In stress resistance studies, ς^B was shown to be involved in recovery from heat shock at 54°C and in acid and hydrogen peroxide resistance but not in resistance to ethanol or osmotic shock. Interestingly, S. aureus acquired increased acid resistance when preincubated at a sublethal pH 4 prior to exposure to a lethal pH 2. This acid-adaptive response resulting in tolerance was mediated via sigB. However, ς^B was not vital for the starvation-survival or recovery mechanisms. ς^B does not have a major role in the expression of the global regulator of virulence determinant biosynthesis, staphylococcal accessory regulator (sarA), the production of a number of representative virulence factors, and pathogenicity in a mouse subcutaneous abscess model. However, SarA upregulates sigB expression in a growth-phase-dependent manner. Thus, ς^B expression is linked to the processes controlling virulence determinant production. The role of ς^B as a major regulator of the stress response, but not of starvation-survival, is discussed.     

Influence of sulfates and operational parameters on volatile fatty acids concentration profile in acidogenic phase

Anaerobic treatment of distillery wastewaters containing high sulfate concentrations was carried out on a two-phase process. The acidogenic phase was operated so as to produce the more favourable intermediates for methanogenic bacteria coupled with maximum sulfate removal. Sulfate removal was directly affected by pH and dilution rate (D). The maximum sulfate removal and acetic acid production was achieved at pH 6.6 and D=0.035 h^–1. A linear relationship between acetic acid produced and sulfate removal was observed, indicating that acetic acid was mainly produced by sulfate reducing bacteria with important operational advantages. Higher concentrations of butyric acid were obtained at low pH values and high dilution rates.     

Study on solvent extraction of propionic acid from simulated discharged water in vitamin B12 production by anaerobic fermentation

The potential of recovering propionic acid from discharged water in vitamin B₁₂ production by anaerobic fermentation was investigated in this paper. A primary amine, N₁₉₂₃, was used as the extractant, kerosene as diluter and n-octanol as modifier. The influences of the content of N₁₉₂₃ in the organic phase, the phase ratio and the pH of aqueous phase on the extraction yield of propionic acid were studied. The organic phase composition with the volume ratio was proposed of N₁₉₂₃:kerosene:n-octanol as 45:35:20. Under conditions of the phase ratio (o/w) as 1:4, the pH of aqueous phase of 3.0 and after 5 min extraction, the extraction yield of propionic acid can be over 97%.