Site-directed mutants of RTP of Bacillus subtilis and the mechanism of replication fork arrest

DNA replication fork arrest during the termination phase of chromosome replication in Bacillus subtilis is brought about by the replication terminator protein (RTP) bound to specific DNA terminator sequences (Ter sites) distributed throughout the terminus region. An attractive suggestion by others was that crucial to the functioning of the RTP-Ter complex is a specific interaction between RTP positioned on the DNA and the helicase associated with the approaching replication fork. In support of this was the behaviour of two site-directed mutants of RTP. They appeared to bind Ter DNA normally but were ineffective in fork arrest as ascertained by in vitro Escherichia coli DnaB helicase and replication assays. We describe here a system for assessing the fork-arrest behaviour of RTP mutants in a bona fide in vivo assay in B. subtilis. One of the previously studied mutants, RTP.Y33N, was non-functional in fork arrest in vivo, as predicted. But through extensive analyses, this RTP mutant was shown to be severely defective in binding to Ter DNA, contrary to expectation. Taken in conjunction with recent findings on the other mutant (RTP.E30K), it is concluded that there is as yet no substantive evidence from the behaviour of RTP mutants to support the RTP-helicase interaction model for fork arrest. In an extension of the present work on RTP.Y33N, we determined the dissociation rates of complexes formed by wild-type (wt) RTP and another RTP mutant with various terminator sequences. The functional wtRTP-TerI complex was quite stable (half-life of 182 minutes), reminiscent of the great stability of the E. coli Tus-Ter complex. More significant were the exceptional stabilities of complexes comprising wtRTP and an RTP double-mutant (E39K.R42Q) bound to some particular terminator sequences. From the measurement of in vivo fork-arrest activities of the various complexes, it is concluded that the stability (half-life) of the whole RTP-Ter complex is not the overriding determinant of arrest, and that the RTP-Ter complex must be actively disrupted, or RTP removed, by the action of the approaching replication fork.     

A replication terminus located at or near a replication checkpoint of Bacillus subtilis functions independently of stringent control

We have examined a replication terminus (psiL1) located on the left arm of the chromosome of Bacillus subtilis and within the yxcC gene and at or near the left replication checkpoint that is activated under stringent conditions. The psiL1 sequence appears to bind to two dimers of the replication terminator protein (RTP) rather weakly and seems to possess overlapping core and auxiliary sites that have some sequence similarities with normal Ter sites. Surprisingly, the asymmetrical, isolated psiL1 site arrested replication forks in vivo in both orientations and independent of stringent control. In vitro, the sequence arrested DnaB helicase in both orientations, albeit more weakly than the normal Ter1 terminus. The key points of mechanistic interest that emerge from the present work are: (i) strong binding of a Ter (psiL1) sequence to RTP did not appear to be essential for fork arrest and (ii) polarity of fork arrest could not be correlated in this case with just symmetrical protein-DNA interaction at the core and auxiliary sites of psiL1. On the basis of the result it would appear that the weak RTP-L1Ter interaction cannot by itself account for fork arrest, thus suggesting a role for DnaB-RTP interaction.     

Mechanisms of polar arrest of a replication fork

A DNA replication terminator sequence blocks an approaching replication fork when the moving replisome approaches from just one direction. The mechanism underlying polar arrest has been debated for years, but recent work has helped to reveal how a replication fork is blocked in Escherichia coli . Early work suggested that asymmetric interaction between terminator protein and terminator DNA contributes to polar fork arrest. A later study demonstrated that if the terminator DNA is partially unwound, the resulting melted DNA could bind tightly to the terminator protein, suggesting a mechanism for polar arrest that involves a locked complex. However, recent evidence suggests that the terminator protein–DNA contacts are not sufficient for polar arrest in vivo . Furthermore, polar arrest of a replication fork still occurs in the absence of a locked complex between the terminator protein and DNA. In E. coli and Bacillus subtilis , the bound terminator protein makes protein–protein contacts with the replication fork helicase, and these contacts are critical in blocking progression of the advancing fork. Thus, we propose that interactions between the replication fork helicase and terminator protein are the primary mechanism for polar fork arrest in bacteria, and that this primary mechanism is modulated by asymmetric contacts between the terminator protein and its cognate DNA sequence. In yeast, terminator sequences are present in rDNA non-transcribed spacers and a region immediately preceding the mating type switch locus Mat1, and the mechanism of polar arrest at these regions is beginning to be elucidated.     

An asymmetric structure of the Bacillus subtilis replication terminator protein in complex with DNA

In Bacillus subtilis, the termination of DNA replication via polar fork arrest is effected by a specific protein:DNA complex formed between the replication terminator protein (RTP) and DNA terminator sites. We report the crystal structure of a replication terminator protein homologue (RTP.C110S) of B. subtilis in complex with the high affinity component of one of its cognate DNA termination sites, known as the TerI B-site, refined at 2.5 A resolution. The 21 bp RTP:DNA complex displays marked structural asymmetry in both the homodimeric protein and the DNA. This is in contrast to the previously reported complex formed with a symmetrical TerI B-site homologue. The induced asymmetry is consistent with the complex's solution properties as determined using NMR spectroscopy. Concomitant with this asymmetry is variation in the protein:DNA binding pattern for each of the subunits of the RTP homodimer. It is proposed that the asymmetric "wing" positions, as well as other asymmetrical features of the RTP:DNA complex, are critical for the cooperative binding that underlies the mechanism of polar fork arrest at the complete terminator site.     

A complex mechanism determines polarity of DNA replication fork arrest by the replication terminator complex of Bacillus subtilis

Two dimers of the replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis bind to a chromosomal DNA terminator site to effect polar replication fork arrest. Cooperative binding of the dimers to overlapping half-sites within the terminator is essential for arrest. It was suggested previously that polarity of fork arrest is the result of the RTP dimer at the blocking (proximal) side within the complex binding very tightly and the permissive-side RTP dimer binding relatively weakly. In order to investigate this "differential binding affinity" model, we have constructed a series of mutant terminators that contain half-sites of widely different RTP binding affinities in various combinations. Although there appeared to be a correlation between binding affinity at the proximal half-site and fork arrest efficiency in vivo for some terminators, several deviated significantly from this correlation. Some terminators exhibited greatly reduced binding cooperativity (and therefore have reduced affinity at each half-site) but were highly efficient in fork arrest, whereas one terminator had normal affinity over the proximal half-site, yet had low fork arrest efficiency. The results show clearly that there is no direct correlation between the RTP binding affinity (either within the full complex or at the proximal half-site within the full complex) and the efficiency of replication fork arrest in vivo. Thus, the differential binding affinity over the proximal and distal half-sites cannot be solely responsible for functional polarity of fork arrest. Furthermore, efficient fork arrest relies on features in addition to the tight binding of RTP to terminator DNA.     

Reorganization of terminator DNA upon binding replication terminator protein: implications for the functional replication fork arrest complex.

Termination of DNA replication in Bacillus subtilis involves the polar arrest of replication forks by a specific complex formed between the replication terminator protein (RTP) and DNA terminator sites. While determination of the crystal structure of RTP has facilitated our understanding of how a single RTP dimer interacts with terminator DNA, additional information is required in order to understand the assembly of a functional fork arrest complex, which requires an interaction between two RTP dimers and the terminator site. In this study, we show that the conformation of the major B.subtilis DNA terminator,TerI, becomes considerably distorted upon binding RTP. Binding of the first dimer of RTP to the B site of TerI causes the DNA to become slightly unwound and bent by approximately 40 degrees. Binding of a second dimer of RTP to the A site causes the bend angle to increase to approximately 60 degrees . We have used this new data to construct two plausible models that might explain how the ternary terminator complex can block DNA replication in a polar manner. In the first model, polarity of action is a consequence of the two RTP-DNA half-sites having different conformations. These different conformations result from different RTP-DNA contacts at each half-site (due to the intrinsic asymmetry of the terminator DNA), as well as interactions (direct or indirect) between the RTP dimers on the DNA. In the second model, polar fork arrest activity is a consequence of the different affinities of RTP for the A and B sites of the terminator DNA, modulated significantly by direct or indirect interactions between the RTP dimers.     

Protein–nucleoside contacts in the interaction between the replication terminator protein of Bacillus subtilis and the DNA terminator

The interaction between the DNA replication terminator, IRI, of Bacillus subtilis and its cognate replication terminator protein (RTP) has been examined by the technique of missing nucleoside interference (MNI). IRI contains two adjacent binding sites (A and B) for RTP dimers. The B site is proximal to the replication fork arrest site. The present results have shown that nucleoside contacts with RTP in the two sites are very different. There are more extensive contacts of nucleosides in both strands of the B site with RTP compared with the A site. The data also strongly suggest that filling by RTP of the B site occurs first and is needed for subsequent co-operative filling of an overlapping A site. The A site alone binds RTP poorly. The findings are consistent with interaction occurring between RTP dimers bound to adjacent sites of IRI, which would explain why RTP bound to the B site alone cannot cause replication fork arrest.     

Structural and functional analysis of a bipolar replication terminus. Implications for the origin of polarity of fork arrest

We have delineated the amino acid to nucleotide contacts made by two interacting dimers of the replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis with a novel naturally occurring bipolar replication terminus by converting RTP to a site-directed chemical nuclease and mapping its cleavage sites on the terminus. The data show a relatively symmetrical arrangement of the amino acid to base contacts, and a comparison of the bipolar contacts with that of a normal unipolar terminus suggests that the DNA-protein contacts play an important determinative role in generating polarity from structurally symmetrical RTP dimers. The amino acid to nucleotide contacts provided distance constraints that enabled us to build a three-dimensional model of the protein-DNA complex. The model is consistent with features of the bipolar Ter.RTP complex derived from mutational and cross-linking data. The bipolar terminus arrested Escherichia coli DNA replication and DnaB helicase and T7 RNA polymerase in vitro in both orientations. RTP arrested the unwinding of duplex DNA on the bipolar Ter DNA substrate regardless of the length of the duplex DNA. The latter result suggested further that the terminus arrested authentic DNA unwinding by the helicase rather than just translocation of helicase on DNA.     

Definition and polarity of action of DNA replication terminators in Bacillus subtilis.

The first stage in termination of chromosome replication in Bacillus subtilis involves arrest of the clockwise fork at the inverted repeat region (IRR), comprising the opposed IRI and IRII sequences, adjacent to the upstream region of the rtp gene, which encodes the replication terminator protein RTP. RTP binds to IRI and IRII. The ability of the IRR and its components to function as terminators, in conjunction with RTP, and their polarity of action have now been tested by the use of plasmids replicating in B. subtilis as unidirectional theta structures and into which potential terminator sequences were inserted in alternate orientations relative to fork movement. When the complete IRR was inserted into such plasmids and the new plasmids transferred into a B. subtilis strain overproducing RTP, it was able to block movement of a replication fork approaching from either direction. IRI and IRII were shown to function as polar terminators, each blocking movement of a fork when it approached from one particular direction but not the other. Furthermore, the polarity of action was in accordance with the IRR being able to operate as a replication fork trap. Thus, a fork approaching the IRR would pass through the first terminator encountered (IRI or IRII) and be halted by the second. The previously observed nonfunctioning of a particular orientation of chromosomal IRR as a fork arrest site probably reflects a limiting level of RTP in the cell. Interestingly, a 21 base-pair core sequence spanning a single RTP binding site within IRI (the 47 base-pair IRI contains 2 binding sites) was unable to arrest a fork approaching from either direction in the plasmid system. This suggests that both binding sites within an IR must be filled in order to function as an arrest site. It is possible that co-operative interaction between adjacent dimers within IRI or IRII provides the necessary conformation for causing fork arrest.     

Structure of the RTP-DNA complex and the mechanism of polar replication fork arrest

The coordinated termination of DNA replication is an important step in the life cycle of bacteria with circular chromosomes, but has only been defined at a molecular level in two systems to date. Here we report the structure of an engineered replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis in complex with a 21 base pair DNA by X-ray crystallography at 2.5 A resolution. We also use NMR spectroscopic titration techniques. This work reveals a novel DNA interaction involving a dimeric 'winged helix' domain protein that differs from predictions. While the two recognition helices of RTP are in close contact with the B-form DNA major grooves, the 'wings' and N-termini of RTP do not form intimate contacts with the DNA. This structure provides insight into the molecular basis of polar replication fork arrest based on a model of cooperative binding and differential binding affinities of RTP to the two adjacent binding sites in the complete terminator.     

Termination of DNA replication in vitro: requirement for stereospecific interaction between two dimers of the replication terminator protein of Bacillus subtilis and with the terminator site to elicit polar contrahelicase and fork impedance.

The termination of DNA replication at a sequence-specific replication terminus in Bacillus subtilis is catalyzed by a dimeric replication terminator protein (RTP) of subunit mol. wt 14,500. RTP has become an attractive protein with which to study the molecular mechanism of termination because its crystal structure has now been solved and the previous lack of an in vitro replication system has been largely overcome by our discovery that the protein terminates replication in vivo and in vitro in the well-studied Gram-negative Escherichia coli system. We have exploited the surrogate in vitro system to show that RTP acts as a polar contrahelicase to DnaB helicase of E. coli only when two RTP dimers are bound co-operatively to overlapping core and auxiliary sequences comprising the terminus. A core sequence by itself binds one dimer of RTP, but elicits no contrahelicase activity. Binding of two RTP dimers to a tandem head-to-tail core repeat also elicits no contrahelicase activity, thus suggesting that a specific stereochemical interaction between two RTP dimers and with the terminator site is essential for termination. RTP blocks unwinding of DNA substrates containing heteroduplex regions that include the terminus and are in the size range of approximately 50 to > 1000 bp in length. Thus, the protein blocks authentic helicase-catalyzed unwinding rather than just the translocation of the helicase on DNA.     

Functional specificity of the replication fork-arrest complexes of Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli: significant specificity for Tus-Ter functioning in E. coli

The Escherichia coli replication terminator TerB was inserted in its two alternate orientations into a Bacillus subtilis fork-arrest assay plasmid. After transferring these new plasmids into B. subtilis, which could overproduce the E. coli terminator protein Tus, it was shown that the E. coli Tus-TerB complex could cause polar replication fork arrest, albeit at a very low level, in B. subtilis. A new B. subtilis-E. coli shuttle plasmid was designed to allow the insertion of either the Terl (B. subtilis) or TerB (E. coli) terminator at the same site and in the active orientation in relation to the approaching replication fork generated in either organism. Fork-arrest assays for both terminator-containing plasmids replicating in both organisms which also produced saturating levels of either the B. subtilis terminator protein (RTP) or Tus were performed. The efficiency of the Tus-TerB complex in causing fork arrest was much higher in E. coli than in B. subtilis. The efficiency of the B. subtilis RTP-Terl complex was higher in B. subtilis than in E. coli, but the effect was significantly less. Evidently a specificity feature in E. coli operates to enhance appreciably the fork-arrest efficiency of a Tus-Ter complex. The specificity effect is of less significance for an RTP-Ter complex functioning in B. subtilis.     

Protein--protein interactions in the eubacterial replisome

Replication of genomic DNA is a universal process that proceeds in distinct stages, from initiation to elongation and finally to termination. Each stage involves multiple stable or transient interactions between protein subunits with functions that are more or less conserved in all organisms. In Escherichia coli, initiation of bidirectional replication at the origin (oriC) occurs through the concerted actions of the DnaA replication initiator protein, the hexameric DnaB helicase, the DnaC?helicase loading partner and the DnaG primase, leading to establishment of two replication forks. Elongation of RNA primers at each fork proceeds simultaneously on both strands by actions of the multimeric replicase, DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. The fork that arrives first in the terminus region is halted by its encounter with a correctly-oriented complex of the Tus replication terminator protein bound at one of several Ter sites, where it is trapped until the other fork arrives. We summarize current understanding of interactions among the various proteins that act in the different stages of replication of the chromosome of E. coli, and make some comparisons with the analogous proteins in Bacillus subtilis and the coliphages T4 and T7.     

The structure and function of the replication terminator protein of Bacillus subtilis: identification of the 'winged helix' DNA-binding domain.

The replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis impedes replication fork movement in a polar mode upon binding as two interacting dimers to each of the replication termini. The mode of interaction of RTP with the terminus DNA is of considerable mechanistic significance because the DNA-protein complex not only localizes the helicase-blocking activity to the terminus, but also generates functional asymmetry from structurally symmetric protein dimers. The functional asymmetry is manifested in the polar impedance of replication fork movement. Although the crystal structure of the apoprotein has been solved, hitherto there was no direct evidence as to which parts of RTP were in contact with the replication terminus. Here we have used a variety of approaches, including saturation mutagenesis, genetic selection for DNA-binding mutants, photo cross-linking, biochemical and functional characterizations of the mutant proteins, and X-ray crystallography, to identify the regions of RTP that are either in direct contact with or are located within 11 angstroms of the replication terminus. The data show that the unstructured N-terminal arm, the alpha3 helix and the beta2 strand are involved in DNA binding. The mapping of amino acids of RTP in contact with DNA, confirms a 'winged helix' DNA-binding motif.     

Replication fork arrest at relocated replication terminators on the Bacillus subtilis chromosome.

The replication terminus region of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome, comprising TerI and TerII plus the rtp gene (referred to as the terC region) was relocated to serC (257 degrees) and cym (10 degrees) on the anticlockwise- and clockwise-replicating segments of the chromosome, respectively. In both cases, it was found that only the orientation of the terC region that placed TerI in opposition to the approaching replication fork was functional in fork arrest. When TerII was opposed to the approaching fork, it was nonfunctional. These findings confirm and extend earlier work which involved relocations to only the clockwise-replicating segment, at metD (100 degrees) and pyr (139 degrees). In the present work, it was further shown that in the strain in which TerII was opposed to an approaching fork at metD, overproduction of the replication terminator protein (RTP) enabled TerII to function as an arrest site. Thus, chromosomal TerII is nonfunctional in arrest in vivo because of a limiting level of RTP. Marker frequency analysis showed that TerI at both cym and metD caused only transient arrest of a replication fork. Arrest appeared to be more severe in the latter situation and caused the two forks to meet at approximately 145 degrees (just outside or on the edge of the replication fork trap). The minimum pause time erected by TerI at metD was calculated to be approximately 40% of the time taken to complete a round of replication. This significant pause at metD caused the cells to become elongated, indicating that cell division was delayed. Further work is needed to establish the immediate cause of the delay in division.     

Effects of the bacteriophage T4 dda protein on DNA synthesis catalyzed by purified T4 replication proteins

The T4 bacteriophage dda protein is a DNA-dependent ATPase and DNA helicase that is the product of an apparently nonessential T4 gene. We have examined its effects on in vitro DNA synthesis catalyzed by a purified, multienzyme T4 DNA replication system. When DNA synthesis is catalyzed by the T4 DNA polymerase on a single-stranded DNA template, the addition of the dda protein is without effect whether or not other replication proteins are present. In contrast, on a double-stranded DNA template, where a mixture of the DNA polymerase, its accessory proteins, and the gene 32 protein is required, the dda protein greatly stimulates DNA synthesis. The dda protein exerts this effect by speeding up the rate of replication fork movement; in this respect, it acts identically with the other DNA helicase in the T4 replication system, the T4 gene 41 protein. However, whereas a 41 protein molecule remains bound to the same replication fork for a prolonged period, the dda protein seems to be continually dissociating from the replication fork and rebinding to it as the fork moves. Some gene 32 protein is required to observe DNA synthesis on a double-stranded DNA template, even in the presence of the dda protein. However, there is a direct competition between this helix-destabilizing protein and the dda protein for binding to single-stranded DNA, causing the rate of replication fork movement to decrease at a high ratio of gene 32 protein to dda protein. As shown elsewhere, the dda protein becomes absolutely required for in vitro DNA synthesis when E. coli RNA polymerase molecules are bound to the DNA template, because these molecules otherwise stop fork movement (Bedinger, P., Hochstrasser, M., Jongeneel, C.V., and Alberts, B. M. (1983) Cell 34, 115-123).     

Polar arrest of the simian virus 40 tumor antigen-mediated replication fork movement in vitro by the tus protein-terB complex of Escherichia coli.

The effect of the tus protein-terB sequence complex of Escherichia coli on the movement of the SV40 large tumor antigen (T antigen)-mediated replication fork during SV40 DNA replication in vitro has been examined. In the monopolymerase and dipolymerase systems, the tus protein-terB complex efficiently blocked the replication fork movement in a polar fashion, as observed in prokaryotic replication systems. With crude cytosolic extracts of HeLa cells, the same polarity of fork arrest was observed, but the block of replication fork movement was inefficient. These results indicate that the structure of the prokaryotic tus protein-terB complex allows it to block replication fork movement in an orientation-dependent manner. We also show that the tus protein-terB complex blocks the 3'----5' helicase action of T antigen in a polar fashion, using substrates comprised of single-stranded M13 DNA with either a 52-base pair (bp) or 29-bp duplex containing the terB sequence. The tus protein-terB complex formed on the 52-bp duplex was less effective than the complex formed on the 29-bp duplex in blocking the helicase action of T antigen. With the 52-bp duplex substrate, T antigen movement was only partially (30%) blocked by the tus protein-terB sequence complex in the active orientation, whereas the E. coli dnaB helicase moving 5'----3' was blocked more than 90% by the complex in the active orientation. However, with the shorter 29-bp duplex substrate, the complex blocked the T antigen helicase activity about 75%, whereas the dnaB helicase activity was completely blocked. Altogether, these results suggest that the T antigen helicase activity, when coupled to DNA replication, is more susceptible to arrest by the tus protein-terB complex than the T antigen functioning as a helicase alone.