Protein folding coupled to DNA binding in the catalytic domain of bacteriophage lambda integrase detected by mass spectrometry

Bacteriophage lambda integrase (lambda-Int) is the prototypical member of a large family of enzymes that catalyze site-specific DNA recombination via single-strand cleavage and the formation of a Holliday junction intermediate. Crystallographic and biochemical evidence indicate that substantial conformational change (i.e., folding) in the catalytic domain of the protein is required for substrate recognition and catalysis. We have examined the solution conformation of the catalytic domain (C170) in the absence and presence of a cognate "half-site" DNA oligonucleotide by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, and circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy. The distribution of ions in the positive ion electrospray mass spectrum of the free protein reveals the presence of three distinct species in solution, one corresponding to the folded protein, one to the unfolded protein, and one to a dimer. In the presence of DNA, ions are observed only for the protein-DNA complex and the folded form of the free protein. We therefore conclude that DNA binding stabilizes the global fold of the protein in a manner that is consistent with folding-coupled target recognition as a mechanism to control site-specific recombination. Furthermore, we find that inspection of the charge state distribution of ions in electrospray mass spectra provides a quick and effective means to identify conformational heterogeneity of proteins in solution and to investigate dynamic protein-nucleic acid interactions.     

DNA recognition via mutual-induced fit by the core-binding domain of bacteriophage lambda integrase

Bacteriophage lambda integrase (lambda-Int), a phage-encoded DNA recombinase, cleaves its substrate DNA to facilitate the formation and later resolution of a Holliday junction intermediate during recombination. The core-binding and catalytic domains of lambda-Int constitute a bipartite enzyme that mediates site-specific DNA cleavage through their interactions with opposite sides of the recognition sequence. Despite minimal direct contact between the domains, the core-binding domain has been shown to facilitate site-specific DNA cleavage when provided in trans, indicating that it plays a role beyond enhancing binding affinity. Biophysical characterization of the core-binding domain and its interactions with DNA reveal that the domain is poorly structured in its free form and folds upon binding to DNA. Folding of the protein is accompanied by induced-fit structural changes in the DNA ligand. These data support a model by which the core-binding domain plays a catalytic role by reshaping the substrate DNA for effective cleavage by the catalytic domain.     

Active-site assembly and mode of DNA cleavage by Flp recombinase during full-site recombination.

A combination of half-site substrates and step arrest mutants of Flp, a site-specific recombinase of the integrase family, had earlier revealed the following features of the half-site recombination reaction. (i) The Flp active site is assembled by sharing of catalytic residues from at least two monomers of the protein. (ii) A Flp monomer does not cleave the half site to which it is bound (DNA cleavage in cis); rather, it cleaves a half site bound by a second Flp monomer (DNA cleavage in trans). For the lambda integrase (Int protein), the prototype member of the Int family, catalytic complementation between two active-site mutants has been observed in reactions with a suicide attL substrate. By analogy with Flp, this observation is strongly suggestive of a shared active site and of trans DNA cleavage. However, reactions with linear suicide attB substrates and synthetic Holliday junctions are more compatible with cis than with trans DNA cleavage. These Int results either argue against a common mode of active-site assembly within the Int family or challenge the validity of Flp half sites as mimics of the normal full-site substrates. We devised a strategy to assay catalytic complementation between Flp monomers in full sites. We found that the full-site reaction follows the shared active-site paradigm and the trans mode of DNA cleavage. These results suggest that within the Int family, a unitary chemical mechanism of recombination is achieved by more than one mode of physical interaction among the recombinase monomers.     

Wild-type Flp recombinase cleaves DNA in trans.

Site-specific recombinases of the Integrase family utilize a common chemical mechanism to break DNA strands during recombination. A conserved Arg-His-Arg triad activates the scissile phosphodiester bond, and an active-site tyrosine provides the nucleophile to effect DNA cleavage. Is the tyrosine residue for the cleavage event derived from the same recombinase monomer which provides the RHR triad (DNA cleavage in cis), or are the triad and tyrosine derived from two separate monomers (cleavage in trans)? Do all members of the family follow the same cleavage rule, cis or trans? Solution studies and available structural data have provided conflicting answers. Experimental results with the Flp recombinase which strongly support trans cleavage have been derived either by pairing two catalytic mutants of Flp or by pairing wild-type Flp and a catalytic mutant. The inclusion of the mutant has raised new concerns, especially because of the apparent contradictions in their cleavage modes posed by other Int family members. Here we test the cleavage mode of Flp using an experimental design which excludes the use of the mutant protein, and show that the outcome is still only trans DNA cleavage.     

Dissecting the resolution reaction of lambda integrase using suicide Holliday junction substrates.

A reciprocal strand exchange between two DNA helices generates the crossed-strand intermediate, or Holliday junction, which is common to many pathways of homologous and site-specific recombination. The Int family of recombinases are unique in their ability to both make and resolve Holliday junctions. Previous experiments utilizing 'synthetic' att site Holliday junctions to study the mechanisms associated with the cleavage, transfer and ligation of DNA strands have been confined to studying reciprocal strand exchanges (a pair of temporally overlapping strand cleavages). To circumvent this limitation, we have designed synthetic suicide Holliday junctions that make it possible to monitor individual DNA strand cleavage events. These substrates contain a pre-existing nick in the vicinity of the Int binding site; when Int introduces a second nick into these substrates, the 5'OH nucleophile required for ligation (in either the forward or reverse reaction) is lost by diffusion, thus trapping the covalent protein-DNA intermediate. The results indicate that resolution (involving two partner Ints) is stimulated by additional 'cross-core' Ints as a result of enhanced cleavage rates, and not as a result of enhanced co-ordination of cleavage. Several models for the role of the 'cross-core' Ints during resolution are discussed, as well as the usefulness of these substrates for studying additional aspects of the Holliday junction resolution reaction.     

Catalytic residues of gamma delta resolvase act in cis.

The resolvase protein of the gamma delta transposon is a site-specific recombinase that acts by a concerted break-and-join mechanism. To analyse the role of individual resolvase subunits in DNA strand cleavage, we have directed the binding of catalytic mutants to specific recombination crossover sites or half-sites. Our results demonstrate that the resolvase subunit bound at the half-site proximal to each scissile phosphodiester bond provides the Ser10 nucleophile and Arg8, Arg68 and Arg71 residues essential for cleavage and covalent attachment to the DNA. Several other residues near the presumptive active site are also shown to act in cis. Double-strand cleavage at one crossover site can proceed independently of cleavage at the other site, although interactions between the resolvase dimers bound at the two crossover sites remain essential. An appropriately oriented heterodimer of active and inactive protomers can in most cases mediate either a 'top' or 'bottom' single-strand cleavage, suggesting that there is no obligatory order of strand cleavages. Top-strand cleavage is associated with the topoisomerase I activity of resolvase, suggesting that a functional asymmetry may be imposed on the crossover site by the structure of the active synapse.     

DNA recognition, strand selectivity, and cleavage mode during integrase family site-specific recombination

We have probed the association of Flp recombinase with its DNA target using protein footprinting assays. The results are consistent with the domain organization of the Flp protein and with the general features of the protein-DNA interactions revealed by the crystal structures of the recombination intermediates formed by Cre, the Flp-related recombinase. The similarity in the organization of the Flp and Cre target sites and in their recognition by the respective recombinases implies that the overall DNA-protein geometry during strand cleavage in the two systems must also be similar. Within the functional recombinase dimer, it is the interaction between two recombinase monomers bound on either side of the strand exchange region (or spacer) that provides the allosteric activation of a single active site. Whereas Cre utilizes the cleavage nucleophile (the active site tyrosine) in cis, Flp utilizes it in trans (one monomer donating the tyrosine to its partner). By using synthetic Cre and Flp DNA substrates that are geometrically restricted in similar ways, we have mapped the positioning of the active and inactive tyrosine residues during cis and trans cleavage events. We find that, for a fixed substrate geometry, Flp and Cre cleave the labile phosphodiester bond at the same spacer end, not at opposite ends. Our results provide a model that accommodates local heterogeneities in peptide orientations in the two systems while preserving the global functional architecture of the reaction complex.     

Crystal structures of RNase H bound to an RNA/DNA hybrid: substrate specificity and metal-dependent catalysis

RNase H belongs to a nucleotidyl-transferase superfamily, which includes transposase, retroviral integrase, Holliday junction resolvase, and RISC nuclease Argonaute. We report the crystal structures of RNase H complexed with an RNA/DNA hybrid and a mechanism for substrate recognition and two-metal-ion-dependent catalysis. RNase H specifically recognizes the A form RNA strand and the B form DNA strand. Structure comparisons lead us to predict the catalytic residues of Argonaute and conclude that two-metal-ion catalysis is a general feature of the superfamily. In nucleases, the two metal ions are asymmetrically coordinated and have distinct roles in activating the nucleophile and stabilizing the transition state. In transposases, they are symmetrically coordinated and exchange roles to alternately activate a water and a 3'-OH for successive strand cleavage and transfer by a ping-pong mechanism.     

Switching catalytic activity in the XerCD site-specific recombination machine.

The tyrosine family site-specific recombinases, XerCD, function in the conversion of circular dimer replicons to monomers. In the recombining complex that contains two synapsed recombination sites and two molecules each of XerC and XerD, the DNA strand-exchange reactions are separated in time and space. XerC initiates recombination to form a Holliday junction intermediate, which undergoes a conformational change to provide a substrate for strand exchange by XerD. XerCD are two-domain proteins, whose C-terminal domains contain all of the catalytic residues. We show that XerC or XerD variants lacking their N-terminal domains are active in recombination when combined with their wild-type partner. Nevertheless, the normal pattern of catalysis is dramatically altered; strand exchange by the recombinase variant is stimulated, while that by the wild-type partner recombinase is impaired. The primary determinants for the mutant phenotype reside in the region of alpha-helix B of XerD. We propose that altered interactions within the recombining heterotetramer lead to changes in the relative concentrations of the two alternative Holliday junction substrates that are recombined by XerC or XerD, respectively.     

DNA recombination and RNA cleavage activities of the Flp protein: roles of two histidine residues in the orientation and activation of the nucleophile for strand cleavage.

Using a combination of DNA and hybrid DNA-RNA substrates, we have analyzed the mechanism of phosphoryl transfer by the Flp site-specific recombinase in three different reactions: DNA strand breakage and joining, and two types of RNA cleavage activities. These reactions were then used to characterize Flp variants altered at His309 and His345, amino acid residues that are in close proximity to two key catalytic residues (Arg308 and Tyr343). These histidine residues are important for strand cutting by Tyr343, the active-site nucleophile of Flp, but neither residue contributes to the type II RNA cleavage activity or to the strand-joining reaction in a pre-cleaved substrate. Strand cleavage reactions using small, diffusible nucleophiles indicate that this histidine pair contributes to the correct positioning and activation of Tyr343 within the shared active site of Flp. The implications of these results are evaluated against the recently solved crystal structure of Flp in association with a Holliday junction.     

Resolution of tethered antiparallel and parallel holliday junctions by the Flp site-specific recombinase

Members of the integrase family site-specific recombinases (also called the tyrosine family) bring about recombination in two steps by exchanging pairs of single strands at a time. The product of the first exchange reaction is a four-way DNA junction, the Holliday intermediate. The conformational dynamics by which the recombination complex "isomerizes" from the Holliday-forming to the Holliday-resolving mode are not well understood. Experiments with the lambda Int and Escherichia coli XerC/XerD systems imply that the strand configurations at the branch point of the protein-free junction dictate the resolution mode in the protein-bound junction. We have examined the question of strand bias during resolution for the Flp system by using a series of synthetic Holliday junctions that are conformationally constrained by local sequences or by strand tethering. We have not observed a strong resolution bias in favor of the strands designed to assume the "crossed" configuration within the unbound junction. The resolution patterns with antiparallel junctions in a variety of substrate contexts reveal either parity in strand choice, or only modest disparity. On the other hand, the highly biased resolutions observed in the case of tethered parallel junctions can be explained by the non-equivalence in protein occupancy of the DNA arms of these substrates and/or inefficient conversion of cleavage events to recombinants at the tethered ends.     

A conserved nuclease domain in the archaeal Holliday junction resolving enzyme Hjc

Holliday junction resolving enzymes are ubiquitous proteins that function in the pathway of homologous recombination, catalyzing the rearrangement and repair of DNA. They are metal ion-dependent endonucleases with strong structural specificity for branched DNA species. Whereas the eukaryotic nuclear enzyme remains unknown, an archaeal Holliday junction resolving enzyme, Hjc, has recently been identified. We demonstrate that Hjc manipulates the global structure of the Holliday junction into a 2-fold symmetric X shape, with local disruption of base pairing around the point of cleavage that occurs in a region of duplex DNA 3' to the point of strand exchange. Primary and secondary structural analysis reveals the presence of a conserved catalytic metal ion binding domain in Hjc that has been identified previously in several restriction enzymes. The roles of catalytic residues conserved within this domain have been confirmed by site-directed mutagenesis. This is the first example of this domain in an archaeal enzyme of known function as well as the first in a Holliday junction resolving enzyme.     

Interactions of RadB, a DNA repair protein in archaea, with DNA and ATP

The RecA family of recombinases (RecA, Rad51, RadA and UvsX) catalyse strand-exchange between homologous DNA molecules by utilising conserved DNA-binding modules and a common core ATPase domain. RadB was identified in archaea as a Rad51-like protein on the basis of conserved ATPase sequences. However, RadB does not catalyse strand exchange and does not turn over ATP efficiently. RadB does bind DNA, and here we report a triplet of residues (Lys-His-Arg) that is highly conserved at the RadB C terminus, and is crucial for DNA binding. This is consistent with the motif forming a "basic patch" of highly conserved residues identified in an atomic structure of RadB from Thermococcus kodakaraensis. As the triplet motif is conserved at the C terminus of XRCC2 also, a mammalian Rad51-paralogue, we present a phylogenetic analysis that clarifies the relationship between RadB, Rad51-paralogues and recombinases. We investigate interactions between RadB and ATP using genetics and biochemistry; ATP binding by RadB is needed to promote survival of Haloferax volcanii after UV irradiation, and ATP, but not other NTPs, induces pronounced conformational change in RadB. This is the first genetic analysis of radB, and establishes its importance for maintaining genome stability in archaea. ATP-induced conformational change in RadB may explain previous reports that RadB controls Holliday junction resolution by Hjc, depending on the presence or the absence of ATP.     

Architecture of the hin synaptic complex during recombination: the recombinase subunits translocate with the DNA strands

Most site-specific recombinases can be grouped into two mechanistically distinct families. Whereas tyrosine recombinases exchange DNA strands through a Holliday intermediate, serine recombinases such as Hin generate double-strand breaks in each recombining partner. Here, site-directed protein crosslinking is used to elucidate the configuration of protein subunits and DNA within the Hin synaptic complex and to follow the movement of protein subunits during DNA strand exchange. Our results show that the protein interface mediating synapsis is localized to a region within the catalytic domains, thereby positioning the DNA strands on the outside of the Hin tetrameric complex. Unexpected crosslinks between residues within the dimerization helices provide evidence for a conformational change that accompanies DNA cleavage. We demonstrate that the Hin subunits, which are linked to the cleaved DNA ends by serine-phosphodiester bonds, translocate between synapsed dimers to exchange the DNA strands.     

Trans complementation of variant Cre proteins for defects in cleavage and synapsis

The Cre recombinase is a member of the integrase family of conservative site-specific recombinases. These proteins share five conserved catalytic residues, one of which is a tyrosine that acts as the nucleophile to attack the scissile phosphodiester bond in the DNA target. Recombination by the Cre recombinase takes place in a supramolecular structure called a synapse that consists of four molecules of Cre bound to two DNA target sequences called lox sites. The synapse is held together by an intricate network of protein-protein interactions. They bend the two sites into square planar structure that resembles a Holliday intermediate. We have studied three mutant Cre proteins that appear to have defects in synapsis (Cre A36V, Cre T41F, and Cre G314R). We found that they were unable to carry out strand cleavage but that cleavage occurred if they were mixed with a cleavage-defective Cre protein that lacks the catalytic nucleophilic tyrosine residue. The three variant proteins could also be complemented for the formation of a novel structure ("complexV"), which may be a cleaved synaptic intermediate. We suggest that these three mutant proteins have a defect in DNA bending and discuss the relationship between bending, synapsis, and cleavage.     

Analysis of conserved basic residues associated with DNA binding (Arg69) and catalysis (Lys76) by the RusA holliday junction resolvase

Holliday junctions are key intermediates in both homologous recombination and DNA repair, and are also formed from replication forks stalled at lesions in the template strands. Their resolution is critical for chromosome segregation and cell viability, and is mediated by a class of small, homodimeric endonucleases that bind the structure and cleave the DNA. All the enzymes studied require divalent metal ions for strand cleavage and their active centres are characterised by conserved aspartate/glutamate residues that provide ligands for metal binding. Sequence alignments reveal that they also contain a number of conserved basic residues. We used site-directed mutagenesis to investigate such residues in the RusA resolvase. RusA is a 120 amino acid residue polypeptide that can be activated in Escherichia coli to promote recombination and repair in the absence of the Ruv proteins. The RuvA, RuvB and RuvC proteins form a complex on Holliday junction DNA that drives coupled branch migration (RuvAB) and resolution (RuvC) reactions. In contrast to RuvC, the RusA resolvase does not interact directly with a branch migration motor, which simplifies analysis of its resolution activity. Catalysis depends on three highly conserved acidic residues (Asp70, Asp72 and Asp91) that define the catalytic centre. We show that Lys76, which is invariant in RusA sequences, is essential for catalysis, but not for DNA binding, and that an invariant asparagine residue (Asn73) is required for optimal activity. Analysis of DNA binding revealed that RusA may interact with one face of an open junction before manipulating its conformation in the presence of Mg(2+) as part of the catalytic process. A well-conserved arginine residue (Arg69) is linked with this critical stage. These findings provide the first insights into the roles played by basic residues in DNA binding and catalysis by a Holliday junction resolvase.     

Major groove interactions of vaccinia Topo I provide specificity by optimally positioning the covalent phosphotyrosine linkage

Vaccinia DNA topoisomerase (vTopo) is a prototypic eukaryotic type I topoisomerase that shows high specificity for nucleophilic substitution at a single phosphodiester linkage in the pentapyrimidine recognition sequence 5'-(C/T)+5 C+4 C+3 T+2 T+1 p / N(-1). This reaction involves reversible transesterification where the active site tyrosine of the enzyme and a 5'-hydroxyl nucleophile of DNA compete for attack at the phosphoryl group. The finite lifetime of the covalent phosphotyrosine adduct allows the enzyme to relax multiple supercoils by rotation of the 5'-OH strand before the DNA backbone is religated. To dissect the nature of the unique sequence specificity, subtle modifications to the major groove of the GGGAA 5'-sequence of the nonscissile strand were introduced and their effects on each step of the catalytic cycle were measured. Although these modifications had no effect on noncovalent DNA binding (K(D)) or the rate of reversible DNA cleavage (k(cl)), significant decreases in the cleavage equilibrium (K(cl) = k(cl)/k(r)) arising from increased rates of 5'-hydroxyl attack (k(r)) at the phosphotyrosine linkage were observed. These data and other findings support a model in which major groove interactions are used to position the phosphotyrosine linkage relative to the mobile 5'-hydroxyl nucleophile. In the absence of native sequence interactions, the phosphotyrosine has a higher probability of encountering the 5'-hydroxyl nucleophile, leading to an enhanced rate of ligation and a diminished equilibrium constant for cleavage. By this unusual specificity mechanism, the enzyme prevents formation of stable covalent adducts at nonconsensus sites in genomic DNA.     

Electrostatic Suppression Allows Tyrosine Site-specific Recombination in the Absence of a Conserved Catalytic Arginine

The active site of the tyrosine family site-specific recombinase Flp contains a conserved catalytic pentad that includes two arginine residues, Arg-191 and Arg-308. Both arginines are essential for the transesterification steps of strand cleavage and strand joining in DNA substrates containing a phosphate group at the scissile position. During strand cleavage, the active site tyrosine supplies the nucleophile to form a covalent 3′-phosphotyrosyl intermediate. The 5′-hydroxyl group produced by cleavage provides the nucleophile to re-form a 3′-5′ phosphodiester bond in a recombinant DNA strand. In previous work we showed that substitution of the scissile phosphate (P) by the charge neutral methylphosphonate (MeP) makes Arg-308 dispensable during the catalytic activation of the MeP diester bond. However, in the Flp(R308A) reaction, water out-competes the tyrosine nucleophile (Tyr-343) to cause direct hydrolysis of the MeP diester bond. We now report that for MeP activation Arg-191 is also not required. In contrast to Flp(R308A), Flp(R191A) primarily mediates normal cleavage by Tyr-343 but also exhibits a weaker direct hydrolytic activity. The cleaved MeP-tyrosyl intermediate formed by Flp(R191A) can be targeted for nucleophilic attack by a 5′-hydroxyl or water and channeled toward strand joining or hydrolysis, respectively. In collaboration with wild type Flp, Flp(R191A) promotes strand exchange between MeP- and P-DNA partners. Loss of a catalytically crucial positively charged side chain can thus be suppressed by a compensatory modification in the DNA substrate that neutralizes the negative charge on the scissile phosphate.     

Effects of Holliday junction position on Xer-mediated recombination in vitro.

Site-specific recombination mediated by XerC and XerD functions in the segregation of circular replicons in Escherichia coli. A key feature of most models of recombination for the family of recombinases to which XerC and XerD belong is that a Holliday junction forms at the position of the first pair of recombinase-mediated strand exchanges and then branch migrates 6-8 bp to the position of the second pair of strand exchanges. We have tested this hypothesis for Xer recombination by studying the effects of junction position on XerC-mediated strand exchange in vitro. Recombination of synthetic Holliday junction substrates in which junction mobility was constrained to a region extending over or removed away from the normal cleavage and exchange point was analysed. All substrates undergo strand cleavage at the normal position. We infer that the Holliday junction need not be at this position during strand cleavage and exchange. With substrates in which the Holliday junction is constrained to a region away from the XerC-mediated cleavage point, strand exchange generates products with the predicted mispaired bases.     

Dissection of the regional roles of the archaeal Holliday junction resolvase Hjc by structural and mutational analyses.

Hjc is an archaeal DNA endonuclease, which resolves the Holliday junction in the presence of divalent metals. Combined with mutational analyses, the x-ray structure of the Pyrococcus furiosus Hjc crystal grown in the presence of ammonium sulfate revealed a positively charged interface, rich in conserved basic residues, and the catalytic center (Nishino, T., Komori, K., Tsuchiya, D., Ishino, Y., and Morikawa, K. (2001) Structure 9, 197-T204). This structural study also suggested that the N-terminal segment and some loops of Hjc play crucial roles in the cleavage of DNA. However, a structural view of the interaction between these regions and DNA remains elusive. To clarify the regional roles of Hjc in the recognition of the Holliday junction, further structural and biochemical analyses were carried out. A new crystal form of Hjc was obtained from a polyethylene glycol solution in the absence of ammonium sulfate, and its structure has been determined at 2.16-A resolution. A comparison of the two crystal structures has revealed that the N-terminal segment undergoes a serious conformational change. The site-directed mutagenesis of the sulfate-binding site within the segment caused a dramatic decrease in the junction binding, but the mutant was still capable of cleaving DNA with a 20-fold lower efficiency. The kinetic analysis of Hjc-Holliday junction interaction indicated that mutations in the N-terminal segment greatly increased the dissociation rate constants of the Hjc-Holliday junction complex, explaining the decreased stability of the complex. This segment is also responsible for the disruption of base pairs near the junction center, through specific interactions with them. Taken together, these results imply that, in addition to the secondary effects of two basic loops, the flexible N-terminal segment plays predominant roles in the recognition of DNA conformation near the crossover and in correct positioning of the cleavage site to the catalytic center of the Hjc resolvase.