Structural Analysis of the Inhibition of Cdk4 and Cdk6 by p16INK4a through Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Abstract

Cyclin-dependent kinases 4, 6 and 2 (Cdk4/6/2), are proteins that lead progression through the G1-S transition, a step strictly regulated in the process of cell proliferation. The p16^INK4a tumor suppressor, whose expression is inhibited in a high number of cancers, binds to Cdk4/6 and inhibits phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein, forcing cells to remain in the G1 phase and therefore, arresting cell division. Accordingly, the design of small compounds mimicking the inhibition of p16^INK4a appears to be a promising way to treat cancer. In order to get some insight into the key interactions governing recognition between different cyclin-dependent kinases and the p16^INK4a tumor suppressor, the present work reports the results of molecular dynamics simulations of both, the Cdk6-p16^INK4a complex and the Cdk4-p16^INK4a complex, respectively at 300 K. Most of the key interactions observed, were already anticipated in the analysis of the crystal structure of Cdk6-p16^INK4a. However, a few different features found out from the analysis of these calculations provide a better understanding of the role of the T-loop conformation, a fragment of Cdks, and the way the ATP binding-site is distorted upon binding of p16^INK4a.     

Phosphorylation of p16INK4A correlates with Cdk4 association

Progression through the eukaryotic cell cycle is driven by the activity of cyclin-dependent kinases. The cyclin D-dependent kinase Cdk4 promotes progression through the G(1) phase of the cell cycle and is deregulated in many human tumors. The tumor suppressor protein p16(INK4A) (p16) forms a complex with Cdk4 and inhibits kinase activity. Here we report that p16 is phosphorylated, and the phosphorylated form of p16 is preferentially associated with Cdk4 in normal human fibroblasts. We mapped phosphorylation sites on exogenously overexpressed p16 to serines 7, 8, 140, and 152 and found that endogenous p16 associated with Cdk4 is phosphorylated at serine 152. All mapped phosphorylation sites lie outside of the conserved kinase-binding domain of p16 but in regions of the protein affected by mutations in familial and sporadic cancer. Our results suggest a novel regulation of p16 activity.     

Lack of cyclin D-Cdk complexes in Rb-negative cells correlates with high levels of p16INK4/MTS1 tumour suppressor gene product.

D-type cyclins, in association with the cyclin-dependent kinases Cdk4 or Cdk6, regulate events in the G1 phase of the cell cycle and may contribute to the phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma gene product (Rb). However, in cells in which the function of Rb has been compromised, either by naturally arising mutations or through binding to proteins encoded by DNA tumour viruses, Cdk4 and Cdk6 are not associated with D cyclins. Instead, both kinases form binary complexes with a stable 16 kDa protein (p16) encoded by the putative tumour suppressor gene INK4/MTS1 on human chromosome 9p21. Here we show an inverse correlation between Rb status and the expression of p16. Since Rb-negative cells express high levels of p16, we suggest that in these cells p16 competes with D cyclins for binding to Cdk4 and Cdk6 and prevents formation of active complexes. In line with these predictions, DNA tumour virus oncoproteins do not disrupt cyclin D1-Cdk4 complexes in cells lacking p16.     

p16INK4a Peptide mimetics identified via virtual screening

The transition from G1 to S phase in the cell cycle is highly regulated by Cdk4 and Cdk6, which in turn is inhibited by the tumor suppressor p16^INK4a. Replacement of lost p16^INK4a activity in cancer cells via gene therapy has worked in vivo to decrease tumor progression; however, practical issues limit gene therapy applications at this time. Here, we report the discovery of compounds that inhibit Cdk4 and Cdk6 activity. The NMR structure of a peptide that exhibits p16^INK4a activity was solved and combined with known functional data to generate a pharmacophore that was used to mine the NCI chemical database. The hits were filtered utilizing the program Qikprop. Four compounds were subsequently shown to inhibit Cdk4 and/or Cdk6 with IC₅₀ in the μM range. These compounds form lead compounds upon which further cell cycle inhibitors can be developed.     

Design and characterization of a hyperstable p16INK4a that restores Cdk4 binding activity when combined with oncogenic mutations

Cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p16(INK4a) is the founding member of the INK4 family of tumor suppressors capable of arresting mammalian cell division. Missense mutations in the p16(INK4a) gene (INK4a/CDKN2A/MTS1) are strongly linked to several types of human cancer. These mutations are evenly distributed throughout this small, ankyrin repeat protein and the majority of them disrupt the native secondary and/or tertiary structure, leading to protein unfolding, aggregation and loss of function. We report here the use of multiple stabilizing substitutions to increase the stability of p16(INK4a) and furthermore, to restore Cdk4 binding activity of several defective, cancer-related mutant proteins. Stabilizing substitutions were predicted using four different techniques. The three most effective substitutions were combined to create a hyperstable p16(INK4a) variant that is 1.4 kcal/mol more stable than wild-type. This engineered construct is monomeric in solution with wild-type-like secondary and tertiary structure and cyclin-dependent kinase 4 binding activity. Interestingly, these hyperstable substitutions, when combined with oncogenic mutations R24P, P81L or V126D, can significantly restore Cdk4 binding activity, despite the divergent features of each destabilizing mutation. Extensive biophysical studies indicate that the hyperstable substitutions enhance the binding activity of mutant p16 through several different mechanisms, including an increased amount of secondary structure and thermostability, reduction in exposed hydrophobic surface(s) and/or a reduced tendency to aggregate. This apparent global suppressor effect suggests that increasing the thermodynamic stability of p16 can be used as a general strategy to restore the biological activity to defective mutants of this important tumor suppressor protein.     

Multifaceted regulation of cell cycle progression by estrogen: regulation of Cdk inhibitors and Cdc25A independent of cyclin D1-Cdk4 function

Estrogens induce proliferation of estrogen receptor (ER)-positive MCF-7 breast cancer cells by stimulating G(1)/S transition associated with increased cyclin D1 expression, activation of cyclin-dependent kinases (Cdks), and phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein (pRb). We have utilized blockade of cyclin D1-Cdk4 complex formation through adenovirus-mediated expression of p16(INK4a) to demonstrate that estrogen regulates Cdk inhibitor expression and expression of the Cdk-activating phosphatase Cdc25A independent of cyclin D1-Cdk4 function and cell cycle progression. Expression of p16(INK4a) inhibited G(1)/S transition induced in MCF-7 cells by 17-beta-estradiol (E(2)) with associated inhibition of both Cdk4- and Cdk2-associated kinase activities. Inhibition of Cdk2 activity was associated with delayed removal of Cdk-inhibitory activity in early G(1) and decreased cyclin A expression. Cdk-inhibitory activity and expression of both p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1) was decreased, however, in both control and p16(INK4a)-expressing cells 20 h after estrogen treatment. Expression of Cdc25A mRNA and protein was induced by E(2) in control and p16(INK4a)-expressing MCF-7 cells; however, functional activity of Cdc25A was inhibited in cells expressing p16(INK4a). Inhibition of Cdc25A activity in p16(INK4a)-expressing cells was associated with depressed Cdk2 activity and was reversed in vivo and in vitro by active Cdk2. Transfection of MCF-7 cells with a dominant-negative Cdk2 construct inhibited the E(2)-dependent activation of ectopic Cdc25A. Supporting a role for Cdc25A in estrogen action, antisense CDC25A oligonucleotides inhibited estrogen-induced Cdk2 activation and DNA synthesis. In addition, inactive cyclin E-Cdk2 complexes from p16(INK4a)-expressing, estrogen-treated cells were activated in vitro by treatment with recombinant Cdc25A and in vivo in cells overexpressing Cdc25A. The results demonstrate that functional association of cyclin D1-Cdk4 complexes is required for Cdk2 activation in MCF-7 cells and that Cdk2 activity is, in turn, required for the in vivo activation of Cdc25A. These studies establish Cdc25A as a growth-promoting target of estrogen action and further indicate that estrogens independently regulate multiple components of the cell cycle machinery, including expression of p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1).     

Cellular response to oncogenic ras involves induction of the Cdk4 and Cdk6 inhibitor p15(INK4b)

The cell cycle inhibitor p15(INK4b) is frequently inactivated by homozygous deletion together with p16(INK4a) and p19(ARF) in some types of tumors. Although the tumor suppressor capability of p15(INK4b) is still questioned, it has been found to be specifically inactivated by hypermethylation in hematopoietic malignancies in the absence of p16(INK4a) alterations. Here we show that, in vitro, p15(INK4b) is a strong inhibitor of cellular transformation by Ras. Surprisingly, p15(INK4b) is induced in cultured cells by oncogenic Ras to an extent similar to that of p16(INK4a), and their expression is associated with premature G(1) arrest and senescence. Ras-dependent induction of these two INK4 genes is mediated mainly by the Raf-Mek-Erk pathway. Studies with activated and dominant negative forms of Ras effectors indicate that the Raf-Mek-Erk pathway is essential for induction of both the p15(INK4b) and p16(INK4a) promoters, although other Ras effector pathways can collaborate, giving rise to a stronger response. Our results indicate that p15(INK4b), by itself, is able to stop cell transformation by Ras and other oncogenes such as Rgr (a new oncogene member of the Ral-GDS family, whose action is mediated through Ras). In fact, embryonic fibroblasts isolated from p15(INK4b) knockout mice are susceptible to transformation by the Ras or Rgr oncogene whereas wild-type embryonic fibroblasts are not. Similarly, p15(INK4b)-deficient mouse embryo fibroblasts are more sensitive than wild-type cells to transformation by a combination of the Rgr and E1A oncogenes. The cell cycle inhibitor p15(INK4b) is therefore involved, at least in some cell types, in the tumor suppressor activity triggered after inappropriate oncogenic Ras activation in the cell.     

Induced expression of p16(INK4a) inhibits both CDK4- and CDK2-associated kinase activity by reassortment of cyclin-CDK-inhibitor complexes

To investigate the mode of action of the p16(INK4a) tumor suppressor protein, we have established U2-OS cells in which the expression of p16(INK4a) can be regulated by addition or removal of isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside. As expected, induction of p16(INK4a) results in a G1 cell cycle arrest by inhibiting phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein (pRb) by the cyclin-dependent kinases CDK4 and CDK6. However, induction of p16(INK4a) also causes marked inhibition of CDK2 activity. In the case of cyclin E-CDK2, this is brought about by reassortment of cyclin, CDK, and CDK-inhibitor complexes, particularly those involving p27(KIP1). Size fractionation of the cellular lysates reveals that a substantial proportion of CDK4 participates in active kinase complexes of around 200 kDa. Upon induction of p16(INK4a), this complex is partly dissociated, and the majority of CDK4 is found in lower-molecular-weight fractions consistent with the formation of a binary complex with p16(INK4a). Sequestration of CDK4 by p16(INK4a) allows cyclin D1 to associate increasingly with CDK2, without affecting its interactions with the CIP/KIP inhibitors. Thus, upon the induction of p16(INK4a), p27(KIP1) appears to switch its allegiance from CDK4 to CDK2, and the accompanying reassortment of components leads to the inhibition of cyclin E-CDK2 by p27(KIP1) and p21(CIP1). Significantly, p16(INK4a) itself does not appear to form higher-order complexes, and the overwhelming majority remains either free or forms binary associations with CDK4 and CDK6.     

Reducing CDK4/6-p16(INK4a) interface. Computational alanine scanning of a peptide bound to CDK6 protein

The tumor suppressor gene p16INK4a is commonly found altered in numerous and different types of cancer. The encoded protein arrests cell cycle in G1 phase by binding to CDK4 and CDK6, inhibiting their kinase function. In 1995, a 20-residue peptide, extracted from p16INK4a protein sequence, was discovered that retains the cell cycle inhibition properties of the endogenous tumor suppressor. However, its structure has not been determined yet. In this article, the features of a theoretical structure of the peptide bound to CDK6 are reported. The complex was modeled from CDK6-p16INK4a X-ray crystal structure and through molecular dynamics. Final structure was assessed by comparing computed binding free energy changes, when single-alanine substitutions were brought about on the peptide, to experimental data. Better concordance was obtained when including a high level of solvation effects. Solute-solvent vdW energy and electrostatic energy between solute and first shells of water, computed through a force field and considering explicit waters, were also to be included to achieve reasonably good concordance between theoretical and experimental data.     

Cdk4 activation is dependent on the subunit rearrangement in the complexes

Although several factors have been implicated in the regulation of Cdk4 activity, little is known regarding the contributions of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors (CKIs) in Cdk4 activation in the mid G1 phase. Using a mouse macrophage cell line (Bac1.2F5), we found that most of Cdk4 bound to p15 when cells were in a quiescent state. Following CSF-1 stimulation, Cdk4 bound to cyclin D1 and then to p21, concomitant with the dissociation of p15 from the complexes. The activation of Cdk4 correlated well with p21 binding to the complexes, and the majority of active Cdk4 complexes contained p21. During regeneration of mouse liver after partial hepatectomy, Cdk4 activity coincided precisely with ternary complex formation of cyclin D1/Cdk4/p21. Using the baculovirus expression system, we succeeded in reconstituting a capacity for Cdk4 activation in insect cells, forming an active cyclin D1/Cdk4/p21 ternary complex. Taken together, it is suggested that p21 and cyclin D1 act cooperatively as activators of Cdk4 through the release of CKIs of the INK4 family.     

Inhibition of cyclin-dependent kinase 4 (Cdk4) by fascaplysin, a marine natural product

Small chemical molecules that interfere with biological proteins could be useful for gaining insight into the complex biochemical processes in mammalian cells. Cdk4 is a key protein whose activity is required not only for emergence of cells from quiescence but also at the G1/S transition in the cell cycle and which is misregulated in 60-70% of human cancers. We set out to identify chemical inhibitors of Cdk4 and discovered that, in vitro, fascaplysin specifically inhibited Cdk4. Molecular modelling based on the crystal structure of Cdk2 suggests that fascaplysin inhibits Cdk4 by binding to the ATP pocket of the kinase. Treatment of tumour (p16(-), pRb(+)) and normal (p16(+), pRb(+)) cell lines with fascaplysin caused G1 arrest and prevented pRb phosphorylation at sites implicated as being specific for Cdk4 kinase. Fascaplysin will therefore prove to be a useful tool in studying the consequence of Cdk4 inhibition, especially in cells containing inactivated p16.     

The physiology of p16INK4A-mediated G1 proliferative arrest

Phosphorylation of the product of the retinoblastoma susceptibility gene (Rb) physiologically inactivates its growth-suppressive properties. Rb phosphorylation is mediated by cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs), whose activity is enhanced by cyclins and inhibited by CDK inhibitors. p16^INK4A is a member of a family of inhibitors specific for CDK4 and CDK6. p16^INK4A is deleted and inactivated in a wide variety of human malignancies, including familial melanomas and pancreatic carcinoma syndromes, indicating that it is an authentic human tumor suppressor. Although one mechanism for its tumor suppression may be prevention of Rb phosphorylation, thereby causing G1 arrest, many normal cell types express p16^INK4A, and are still able to traverse the cell cycle. In a search for other mechanisms, we have found that p16^INK4A is required for p53-independent G1 arrest in response to DNA-damaging agents, including topoisomerase I and II inhibitors. Thus, like other tumor suppressors, p16^INK4A plays an essential role in a DNA-damage checkpoint that leads to cell cycle arrest.     

The atr protein kinase controls UV-dependent upregulation of p16INK4A through inhibition of Skp2-related polyubiquitination/degradation

The tumor suppressor p16(INK4A), a phosphoprotein that exists in human cells under both phosphorylated and nonphosphorylated forms, plays crucial roles during the cellular response to UV light. However, it is still unclear how this protein is activated in response to this carcinogenic agent. We have shown here that UVC upregulates p16(INK4A) and the phosphorylated form of the protein at the 4 serine sites; Ser-7, Ser-8, Ser-140, and Ser-152. This accumulation of p16(INK4A) occurred through increasing the stability of both forms of the protein. Importantly, phospho-p16(INK4A) showed much higher stability, and UV treatment strongly increased its level in absence of de novo protein synthesis. Furthermore, we have shown that the UV-dependent upregulation of both forms of p16(INK4A) is under the control of the protein kinase Atr, which suppresses their UVC-dependent proteasomal degradation. Interestingly, although this degradation is ubiquitin-related for p16(INK4A) through the Skp2 ubiquitin ligase protein, it is ubiquitin-independent for the phosphorylated form. In addition, we present clear evidence that Skp2 is upregulated in ATR-deficient cells, leading to the downregulation of the p27(Kip1) protein in response to UVC light. Moreover, we have shown a preferential association of endogeneous phospho-p16(INK4A) with Cdk4. This association increased following UV-treatment mainly for p16(INK4A) phosphorylated at Ser-140 and Ser-152. Besides, we have shown that Atr regulates UV-related p16/Cdk4-dependent and -independent phosphorylation of pRB and G1 cell cycle delay. Together, these results indicate that p16(INK4A) and p27(Kip1) are key targets in the Atr-dependent signaling pathway in response to UV damage.     

Limited overlapping roles of P15(INK4b) and P18(INK4c) cell cycle inhibitors in proliferation and tumorigenesis

Entry of quiescent cells into the cell cycle is driven by the cyclin D-dependent kinases Cdk4 and Cdk6. These kinases are negatively regulated by the INK4 cell cycle inhibitors. We report the generation of mice defective in P15(INK4b) and P18(INK4c). Ablation of these genes, either alone or in combination, does not abrogate cell contact inhibition or senescence of mouse embryo fibroblasts in culture. However, loss of P15(INK4b), but not of P18(INK4c), confers proliferative advantage to these cells and makes them more sensitive to transformation by H-ras oncogenes. In vivo, ablation of P15(INK4b) and P18(INK4c) genes results in lymphoproliferative disorders and tumor formation. Mice lacking P18(INK4c) have deregulated epithelial cell growth leading to the formation of cysts, mostly in the cortical region of the kidneys and the mammary epithelium. Loss of both P15(INK4b) and P18(INK4c) does not result in significantly distinct phenotypic manifestations except for the appearance of cysts in additional tissues. These results indicate that P15(INK4b) and P18(IKN4c) are tumor suppressor proteins that act in different cellular lineages and/or pathways with limited compensatory roles.     

INK4 proteins, a family of mammalian CDK inhibitors with novel biological functions

The cyclin D-Cdk4-6/INK4/Rb/E2F pathway plays a key role in controlling cell growth by integrating multiple mitogenic and antimitogenic stimuli. The members of INK4 family, comprising p16(INK4a), p15(INK4b), p18(INK4c), and p19(INK4d), block the progression of the cell cycle by binding to either Cdk4 or Cdk6 and inhibiting the action of cyclin D. These INK4 proteins share a similar structure dominated by several ankyrin repeats. Although they appear to be structurally redundant and equally potent as inhibitors, the INK4 family members are differentially expressed during mouse development. The striking diversity in the pattern of expression of INK4 genes suggested that this family of cell cycle inhibitors might have cell lineage-specific or tissue-specific functions. The INK4 proteins are commonly lost or inactivated by mutations in diverse types of cancer, and they represent established or candidate tumor suppressors. Apart from their capacity to arrest cells in the G1-phase of the cell cycle they have been shown to participate in an increasing number of cellular processes. Given their emerging roles in fundamental physiological as well as pathological processes, it is interesting to explore the diverse roles for the individual INK4 family members in different functions other than cell cycle regulation. Extensive studies, over the past few years, uncover the involvement of INK4 proteins in senescence, apoptosis, DNA repair, and multistep oncogenesis. We will focus the discussion here on these unexpected issues.     

Identification of a conserved sequence motif that promotes Cdc37 and cyclin D1 binding to Cdk4

Cdc37 is a molecular chaperone that is important for the stability and activity of several protein kinases, including Cdk4 and Raf1. We first determined, using in vitro assays, that Cdc37 binds to the amino-terminal lobe of Cdk4. Subsequent mutagenesis revealed that Gly-15 (G15A) and Gly-18 (G18A) were critical for Cdc37-Cdk4 complex formation. Gly-15 and Gly-18 of Cdk4 are within the conserved Gly-X-Gly-X-X-Gly motif that is required for ATP binding to the kinase. Mutation of either glycine at the equivalent positions of Raf1 (G358A and G361A) also inhibited Cdc37 binding to Raf1. Replacing another conserved residue critical for ATP binding and kinase activity, Lys-35 (K35A), reduced Cdc37-Cdk4 complex formation but to a lesser extent. The interaction of Cdk4 with Cdc37 in vitro was not sensitive to changes in ATP levels. Cell-based assays indicated that Cdk4(G15A) and Cdk4(G18A) were present at the same level as wild type Cdk4. Equivalent amounts of p16 bound to Cdk4(G15A) and Cdk4(G18A) relative to wild type Cdk4, suggesting that Cdk4(G15A) and Cdk4(G18A) adopt significant tertiary structure. However, in contrast to wild type Cdk4, Cdk4(G15A), and Cdk4(G18A) had greatly reduced binding of cyclin D1, Cdc37, and Hsp90. Importantly, overexpression of Cdc37 not only stimulated cyclin D1 binding to wild type Cdk4 but also restored its binding to Cdk4(G15A). Under the same conditions, p16 binding to wild type Cdk4 was suppressed. Our findings show that the interaction of Cdc37 with its client protein kinases requires amino acid residues within a motif that is present in many protein kinases.     

Interplay between the p53 tumor suppressor protein family and Cdk5

Cyclin-dependent kinases (Cdks) play a key role in orchestrating the coordination of cell cycle progression in proliferating cells. The escape from the proper, control of the cell cycle by the upregulation of cyclins or aberrant activation of Cdks leads to malignant transformation. In quiescent cells and/or terminally differentiated cells, the expression pattern and activity of Cdks is altered. In postmitotic neurons, expression of mitotic kinases is downregulated, whereas Cdk5 expression becomes upregulated. Similarly to other Cdks, free Cdk5 displays no enzymatic activity and requires complex formation with a specific regulatory subunit. Two activators of Cdk5 have been identified. p35 and its isoform p39 bind to, and thereby activate, Cdk5. Unlike mitotic kinases, Cdk5 does not require activating phosphorylation within the T-loop. Because p35 is a short-lived protein, the p35/Cdk5 complexes are unstable. The stability of the p35 protein is regulated by its Cdk5-mediated phosphorylation of p35. Activated p35/Cdk5 kinase phosphorylates numerous physiological targets. The proper phosphorylation of the most important substrates, such as τ protein and neurofilament H, is essential for the correct regulation of the cytoskeletal organization, thereby regulating cell adhesion, motility, and synaptic plasticity. Moreover, Cdk5 regulates the activity of the p53 tumor suppressor via phosphorylation. p53 is upregulated in multiple neuronal death paradigms, including hypoxia, ischemia, and excitotoxicity, and plays a key role in the induction of apoptosis. On the other hand, an abnormally high expression and elevated activity of Cdk5 was observed in neurodegenerative diseases, suggesting the application of Cdk inhibitors for their therapy. Considering the action of some Cdk inhibitors on the expression and activity of the p53 protein, their therapeutic efficacy must be carefully evaluated.