A mutation-promotive role of nucleotide excision repair in cell cycle-arrested cell populations following UV irradiation

Growing attention is paid to the concept that mutations arising in stationary, non-proliferating cell populations considerably contribute to evolution, aging, and pathogenesis. If such mutations are beneficial to the affected cell, in the sense of allowing a restart of proliferation, they are called adaptive mutations. In order to identify cellular processes responsible for adaptive mutagenesis in eukaryotes, we study frameshift mutations occurring during auxotrophy-caused cell cycle arrest in the model organism Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Previous work has shown that an exposure of cells to UV irradiation during prolonged cell cycle arrest resulted in an increased incidence of mutations. In the present work, we determined the influence of defects in the nucleotide excision repair (NER) pathway on the incidence of UV-induced adaptive mutations in stationary cells. The mutation frequency was decreased in Rad16-deficient cells and further decreased in Rad16/Rad26 double-deficient cells. A knockout of the RAD14 gene, the ortholog of the human XPA gene, even resulted in a nearly complete abolishment of UV-induced mutagenesis in cell cycle-arrested cells. Thus, the NER pathway, responsible for a normally accurate repair of UV-induced DNA damage, paradoxically is required for the generation and/or fixation of UV-induced frameshift mutations specifically in non-replicating cells.     

Effects of the umuC36 mutation on ultraviolet-radiation-induced base-change and frameshift mutations in Escherichia coli

The effects of the umuC36 mutation on the induction of base-change and frameshift mutations were studied. An active umuC gene was necessary in either the uvr⁺ or uvr^? strains of Escherichia coli K12 for UV- and X-ray-induced mutations to His⁺, ColE^R and Spc^R, which are presumably base-change mutations, but it was not essential for ethyl methanesulphonate or N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine-induced His⁺ mutations. In contrast, only 1 out of 13 trp^? frameshift mutations examined was UV reversible, and the process of mutagenesis was umuC⁺-dependent, whereas a potent frameshift mutagen, ICR191, effectively induced Trp⁺ mutations in most of the strains regardless of the umu⁺ or umuC genetic background. These results suggest that base substitutions are a major mutational type derived from the umuC⁺-dependent pathway of error-prone repair.     

A rapid and simple method for the determination of base substitution and frameshift specificity of mutagens

A rapid method for the determination of mutagenic specificity has been developed which makes use of the ochre mutation (TAA) in the his-4 gene of Escherichiacoli. Reversion to His⁺ may occur by suppressor mutation (Type I) or by mutation within the his-4 gene (Type II). The Type I mutations may be further subdivided with respect to the type of suppressor mutation by their ability to suppress nonsense mutants of bacteriophage T4, thus allowing the identification of the responsible base substitution (Kato et al., 1980). The system has the ability to identify mutagens which produce A:T → G:C transitions since only Type II mutants can arise through this base substitution; and in fact, the system confirms the A:T → G:C specificity of the mutagen, N⁴-hydroxycytidine (Janion and Glickman, 1980) since only Type II mutants were induced by treatment with this base analogue.When this system was further tested with several additional mutagens, the results indicate that ethyl methanesulphonate, methyl nitrosourea and ethyl nitrosourea produce primarily Type I revertants which were primarily G:C → A:T transitions. UV-light, γ-rays, 4NQO and methyl methanesulphonate produced all types of base substitutions. The tester strain was further improved by introducing a series of sequenced trp^? frameshift mutations, thus allowing the simultaneous monitoring of frameshift and base-substitution mutations.     

Different UmuC requirements for generation of different kinds of UV-induced mutations in Escherichia coli

An Escherichia coli strain bearing the dnaQ49 mutation, which results in a defective s subunit of DNA polymerase III, and carrying the lexA71 mutation, which causes derepression of the SOS regulon, is totally unable to maintain high-copy-number plasmids containing the umuDC operon. The strain is also unable to maintain the pAN4 plasmid containing a partial deletion of the umuD gene but retaining the wild-type umuC gene. These results suggest that a high cellular level of UmuC is exceptionally harmful to the defective DNA polymerase III of the dnaQ49 mutant. We have used this finding as a basis for selection of new plasmid umuC mutants. The properties of two such mutants, bearing the umuC61 or umuC95 mutation, are described in detail. In the umuC122:: Tn 5 strain harbouring the mutant plasmids, UV-induced mutagenesis is severely decreased compared to that observed with the parental umuDC ⁺ plasmid. Interestingly, while the frequency of UV-induced GC → AT transitions is greatly reduced, the frequency of AT → TA transversions is not affected. Both mutant plasmids bear frameshift mutations within the same run of seven A residues present in umuC ⁺; in umuC61 the run is shortened to six A whereas in umuC95 is lengthened to eight A. We have found in both umuC61 and umuC95 that translation is partially restored to the proper reading frame. We propose that under conditions of limiting amounts of UmuC, the protein preferentially facilitates processing of only some kinds of UV-induced lesions.     

HSM6 gene is identical to PSY4 gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae yeasts

Previously, we isolated mutant yeasts Saccharomyces cerevisiae with an increased rate of spontaneous mutagenesis. Here, we studied the properties of HSM6 gene, the hsm6-1 mutation of which increased the frequency of UV-induced mutagenesis and decreased the level of UV-induced mitotic crossover at the region between the centromere and ADE2 gene. HSM6 gene was mapped on the left arm of chromosome II in the region where the PSY4 gene is located. The epistatic analysis has shown that the hsm6-1 mutation represents an allele of PSY4 gene. Sequencing of hsm6-1 mutant allele has revealed a frameshift mutation, which caused the Lys218Glu substitution and the generation of a stop codon in the next position. The interactions of hsm6-1 and rad52 mutations were epistatic. Our data show that the PSY4 gene plays a key role in the regulation of cell withdrawal from checkpoint induced by DNA disturbances.     

The c.42_52del11 Mutation in TPRN and Progressive Hearing Loss in a Family from Pakistan

The DFNB79 locus harbors TPRN mutations in which have been reported in a few families with deafness. Four frameshift mutations in TPRN have been described to cause severe or severe-to-profound hearing loss in Moroccan and Pakistani families, and a single frameshift mutation was associated with progressive hearing loss in deaf individuals in a Dutch family. We identified a Pakistani family in which the affected individuals were homozygous for a pathogenic mutation, c.42_52del11, in TPRN (p.G15Afs150X). In contrast to the previously reported individuals affected by the same mutation, hearing loss is likely to be progressive in this family. Thus the same mutation of TPRN can be associated with different thresholds of hearing as well as differences in the stability of the phenotype.     

Proceedings: Differential induction of chromosome aberrations in mammalian cell lines.

Mutagenesis was studied in repair- and recombination-deficient strains of Haemophilus influenzae after treatment with N-nitrosocarbaryl (NC). Three different strains of H. influenzae carrying mutations affecting excision-repair of UV-induced pyrimidine dimers exhibited normal repair of premutational lesions (as detected by decreased mutation yield resulting from post-treatment DNA synthesis delay) and normal nonreplicative mutation fixation. This indicates that neither of these phenomena are caused by the same repair mechanism that removes UV-induced pyrimidine dimers from the DNA.The recombination-deficient mutant rec1 is apparently deficient in the replication-dependent mode of NC-induced mutation fixation. This conclusion is based on the following results: (1) NC-induced mutagenesis is lower in the rec1 strain than in rec⁺ cells. (2) Repair of premutational lesions (which depends on the existence of replication-dependent mutation fixation for its detection) was not detected in the rec1 strain. (3) When nonreplicative mutation fixation and final mutation frequency were measured in the same experiment, about $\text{1}\text{4}$ to $\text{1}\text{3}$ of the final mutation yield could be accounted for by nonreplicative mutation fixation in the rec⁺ strain, whereas all of the mutation could be accounted for in the rec1 strain by the nonreplicative mutation fixation. (4) When mutation fixation in strain dna9 rec1 was followed at the permissive (36°) and nonpermissive (41°) temperatures, it became apparent that in the rec1 strain replication-dependent mutation fixation occurs at early times, but these newly fixed mutations are unstable and disappear at later times, leaving only the mutations fixed by the nonreplicative process.The rec1 strain exhibits normal repair of NC-induced single-strand breaks or alkali-labile bonds in the DNA labeled before treatment, but is slow in joining discontinuities present in DNA synthesized after treatment. The results are consistent with the idea that in NC-treated H. influenzae cells the replication-dependent mode of mutation fixation occurs by error-prone joining of interruptions present in the DNA synthesized after treatment. The possibility still exists, however, that during DNA replication mispairing occurs opposite certain alkylation-induced lesions and that mutations arising during replication of strain rec1 later disappear as a result of degradation of newly synthesized DNA, which is excessive in this strain.     

Asymmetric Effects of Deletions and Substitutions on High Negative Interference in Coliphage Lambda

Experiments have been performed to help clarify the role of nonhomologies in phage λ recombination. Three-factor crosses were carried out, and the frequencies of single and double recombinants in the two adjoining intervals were compared when the central marker was either a double point mutation (v1v3) or deletion (rex-cI deletion) or nonhomologous substitution (imm434). In all cases the lefthand marker was a bio substitution (Fec^- phenotype, which does not permit plating on recA^-), and the righthand marker was an amber mutation in gene O. Experiments were performed in all four possible arrangements of the central and rightward markers, while selecting for the Fec⁺ phenotype on the recA^- host. As anticipated, high negative interference (HNI) was observed with point mutations, but when the central marker was a substitution nonhomology, HNI was reduced about tenfold. Surprisingly, when the central marker was a simple deletion, a dramatic asymmetry in results was observed, with HNI being exhibited only when the central deletion marker was acquired by the double recombinant. These results indicate that under normal conditions (red⁺, gam⁺, rec⁺) and with noninhibited DNA replication, recombination in coliphage λ entails a highly asymmetric step that could be at the level of strand transfer or mismatch repair.     

Spontaneous and induced mutability or frameshift strains of Salmonella typhimurium carrying uvrB and polA mutations

Three strains Salmonella typhimurium carrying frameshift mutations affecting the histidine genes (hisC3076, hisD3052 and hisC207) showed increased sensitivity to mutagenesis by ICR-191 (as judged by measuring back mutation to prototrophy), if they were made deficient in excision repair by deleting the uvrB gene. One frameshift strain, hisC3076, also showed increased sensitivity to mutagenesis by ICR-191 when it carried either of two different polA alleles, whereas the hidD305 and hisD207 frameshifts reduced sensitivity to mutagenesis in the presence of these alleles. Studies of spontaneous back mutation to prototrophy revealed siginificant mutator effects of the polA1 mutation on reversion of the hisD3052 frameshift and of the polA3 mutation on reversion of the hisC3076 frameshift. Other smaller mutator effects of the polA alleles on reversion of the his mutations may also be present. In an attempt to explain the complex interactions between different polA alleles and different frameshift mutations, it is tentatively suggested that deletion frameshift may arise mainly during DNA replication, while addition frameshifts may arise mainly during post-replication repair.     

Induction of base-pair substitution and prameshift mutations in wild-type and repair-deficient strains of Salmonella typhimurium by the photodynamic action of methylene blue

Induction of back mutations to prototrophy by methylene blue (MB)-sensitized photodynamic (PD) treatment has been studied in wild-type and repair-deficient strains of Salmonella typhimurium carrying either the base-pair substitution mutation hisG46 or the frameshift mutation hisD3052. We found that reversion of the hisG46 mutation was increased in a strain carrying a uvrB deletion and decreased in a strain carrying a recA-type mutation. Reversion of the hisD3052 (frameshift) mutation, on the other hand, was decreased in both uvrB deletion and recA-type strains. The former results are consistent with the hypothesis that the majority of MB-sensitized PD-induced base-pair substitution mutations arise by a mechanism similar to that currently believed to be involved in UV mutagenesis. The latter results suggest that PD-induced frameshift mutations may arise in some other way, and two possible mechanisms involving sequential action of the excision repair and recombinational repair pathways are considered.     

Ultraviolet-induced framshift mutagenesis in Salmonella typhimurium: absence of an effect of mutation frequency decline

Enhanced yields of UV-induced back mutants to prototrophy are observed when irradiated cells of the Salmonella typhimurium frameshift strain LT2 hisC3076 (R46) are plated on defined medium containing broth (2.5%, v/v) rather than a trace (0.02 μg/ml) of the required nutrient (histidine). This broth effect is not abolished, and is in fact augmented, in an excision-deficient derivative of hisC3076 (R46) carrying the uvr-302 mutation. Since similar broth effects on UV-induced base-pair substitution mutagenesis have usually been attributed to inhibition of mutation frequency decline (MFD), and since MFD is in turn thought to reflect the activity of an intact excision-repair system, we sought to determine whether or not UV-induced premutational lesions leadinf to the production of frameshifts are susceptible to MFD. Results with the doubly auxotrophic strain LT2 hisC3076 leuA150 (pKM101) showed that in a population of cells actually undergoing MFD (as judged by a rapid loss of UV-induced reversions of the base-pair substitution marker leuA150), no concomitant loss of UV-induced reversions of the frameshift hisC3076 marker could be detected.     

Genetic control of AAF-induced mutagenesis at alternating GC sequences: An additional role for RecA

In a previous study, the forward mutation spectrum induced by the chemical carcinogen N-acetoxy-N-2-acetylaminofluorene was determined (Koffel-Schwartz et al. 1984). It was found that 90% of the induced mutations are frameshift mutations located within specific sequences (mutation hot spots). Two classes of mutation hot spots were found: (i) -1 frameshift mutations occurring within runs of guanines (i.e. GGGG----GGG; (ii) -2 frameshift mutations occurring within the NarI recognition sequence (GGCGCC----GGCC). In the present work, we further investigate the genetic requirements of these frameshift events by using specific reversion assays. Like UV-induced mutagenesis, frameshift mutations occurring within runs of G's (also referred to as the "slippage pathway") require the activated form of the RecA protein (RecA*). On the other hand, frameshift mutations occurring at the NarI site (the "NarI mutation pathway") require a LexA-controlled function(s) that is not UmuDC. The LexA-controlled gene(s) that is (are) involved in this pathway remain to be identified. Moreover, this pathway does not require RecA* for the proteolytic processing of a protein other than LexA (like the cleavage of UmuD in UV-induced mutagenesis). An "additional" role of RecA can be defined as follows: (i) The non-activated form of the RecA protein acts as an inhibitor in the NarI mutation pathway. (ii) This inhibition is relieved upon activation of RecA by UV irradiation of the bacteria. (iii) A recA deletion mutant is totally proficient in the NarI mutation pathway provided the SOS system is derepressed [lexA (Def) allele]. Therefore, RecA does not actively participate in the fixation of the mutation. A molecular model for this "additional" role of RecA is proposed.     

A Novel WRN Frameshift Mutation Identified by Multiplex Genetic Testing in a Family with Multiple Cases of Cancer

Next-generation sequencing technology allows simultaneous analysis of multiple susceptibility genes for clinical cancer genetics. In this study, multiplex genetic testing was conducted in a Chinese family with multiple cases of cancer to determine the variations in cancer predisposition genes. The family comprises a mother and her five daughters, of whom the mother and the eldest daughter have cancer and the secondary daughter died of cancer. We conducted multiplex genetic testing of 90 cancer susceptibility genes using the peripheral blood DNA of the mother and all five daughters. WRN frameshift mutation is considered a potential pathogenic variation according to the guidelines of the American College of Medical Genetics. A novel WRN frameshift mutation (p.N1370Tfs*23) was identified in the three cancer patients and in the youngest unaffected daughter. Other rare non-synonymous germline mutations were also detected in DICER and ELAC2. Functional mutations in WRN cause Werner syndrome, a human autosomal recessive disease characterized by premature aging and associated with genetic instability and increased cancer risk. Our results suggest that the WRN frameshift mutation is important in the surveillance of other members of this family, especially the youngest daughter, but the pathogenicity of the novel WRN frameshift mutation needs to be investigated further. Given its extensive use in clinical genetic screening, multiplex genetic testing is a promising tool in clinical cancer surveillance.     

De Novo Mutations in CHAMP1 Cause Intellectual Disability with Severe Speech Impairment

CHAMP1 encodes a protein with a function in kinetochore-microtubule attachment and in the regulation of chromosome segregation, both of which are known to be important for neurodevelopment. By trio whole-exome sequencing, we have identified de novo deleterious mutations in CHAMP1 in five unrelated individuals affected by intellectual disability with severe speech impairment, motor developmental delay, muscular hypotonia, and similar dysmorphic features including short philtrum and a tented upper and everted lover lip. In addition to two frameshift and one nonsense mutations, we found an identical nonsense mutation, c.1192C>T (p.Arg398^∗), in two affected individuals. All mutations, if resulting in a stable protein, are predicted to lead to the loss of the functionally important zinc-finger domains in the C terminus of the protein, which regulate CHAMP1 localization to chromosomes and the mitotic spindle, thereby providing a mechanistic understanding for their pathogenicity. We thus establish deleterious de novo mutations in CHAMP1 as a cause of intellectual disability.     

Ultraviolet Mutagenesis Studies of [psi], a Cytoplasmic Determinant of SACCHAROMYCES CEREVISIAE

UV mutagenesis was used to probe the molecular nature of [psi], a non-mitochondrial cytoplasmic determinant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae involved in the control of nonsense suppression. The UV-induced mutation from [psi⁺] to [psi^-] showed characteristics of forward nuclear gene mutation in terms of frequency, induction kinetics, occurrence of whole and sectored mutant clones and the effect of the stage in the growth cycle on mutation frequency. The involvement of pyrimidine dimers in the premutational lesion giving the [psi^-] mutation was demonstrated by photoreactivation. UV-induced damage to the [psi] genetic determinant was shown to be repaired by nuclear-coded repair enzymes that are responsible for the repair of nuclear DNA damage. UV-induced damage to mitochondrial DNA appeared to be, at least partly, under the control of different repair processes. The evidence obtained suggests that the [psi] determinant is DNA.     

Mutational Specificity of Ultraviolet Light in ESCHERICHIA COLI with and without the R Plasmid Pkm101

Plasmid pKM101 provides UV protection and increases the frequency of spontaneous and UV-induced mutations in Escherichia coli. By analyzing reversion patterns of defined trpA alleles, we showed that pKM101 altered the mutational specificity of UV-induced mutations. Certain UV-induced base-pair substitutions were strongly enhanced, while others were decreased in frequency in the presence of pKM101. This result suggests an interaction between cellular misrepair and an error-prone repair function(s) provided by pKM101. We have also examined UV mutational specificity in the absence of pKM101 and found the following: (1) UV preferentially enhances missense, as well as nonsense, intergenic suppressor mutations; (2) UV causes all possible base-pair substitutions as well as frameshift mutations; (3) G·C base pairs are more susceptible to UV mutagenesis than A·T base pairs at the same nucleotide positions; and (4) UV-induced mutations can occur at nucleotide positions that are not part of pyrimidine-pyrimidine sequences.     

Methyl Methanesulfonate Mutagenesis in Bacteriophage T4

MMS induces diverse rII mutations from a wild-type background in bacteriophage T4. About 56% are base pair substitutions, about 30% are frameshift mutations, and the remainder is a miscellaneous set of rapidly reverting or leaky mutants of unknown composition; but deletions were not detected. MMS-induced forward mutation is sharply reduced by the mutations px and y, which also reduce ultraviolet, photodynamic and γ-ray mutagenesis and increase killing by all of these agents. Thus, many of the mutations arise via the T4 WXY system. The induction of G:C → A:T transitions was detected even in a px or y background using sensitive reversion tests, and the few forward rII mutations that were induced from this background also behaved like transition mutations. Thus, some MMS-induced mutations arise independently of the WXY system, perhaps as a result of the (rather weak) ability of MMS to alkylate the O⁶ position of guanine.     

Adaptive amplification and point mutation are independent mechanisms: evidence for various stress-inducible mutation mechanisms

“Adaptive mutation” denotes a collection of processes in which cells respond to growth-limiting environments by producing compensatory mutants that grow well, apparently violating fundamental principles of evolution. In a well-studied model, starvation of stationary-phase lac⁻ Escherichia coli cells on lactose medium induces Lac⁺ revertants at higher frequencies than predicted by usual mutation models. These revertants carry either a compensatory frameshift mutation or a greater than 20-fold amplification of the leaky lac allele. A crucial distinction between alternative hypotheses for the mechanisms of adaptive mutation hinges on whether these amplification and frameshift mutation events are distinct, or whether amplification is a molecular intermediate, producing an intermediate cell type, in colonies on a pathway to frameshift mutation. The latter model allows the evolutionarily conservative idea of increased mutations (per cell) without increased mutation rate (by virtue of extra gene copies per cell), whereas the former requires an increase in mutation rate, potentially accelerating evolution. To resolve these models, we probed early events leading to rare adaptive mutations and report several results that show that amplification is not the precursor to frameshift mutation but rather is an independent adaptive outcome. (i) Using new high-resolution selection methods and stringent analysis of all cells in very young (micro)colonies (500–10,000 cells), we find that most mutant colonies contain no detectable lac-amplified cells, in contrast with previous reports. (ii) Analysis of nascent colonies, as young as the two-cell stage, revealed mutant Lac⁺ cells with no lac-amplified cells present. (iii) Stringent colony-fate experiments show that microcolonies of lac-amplified cells grow to form visible colonies of lac-amplified, not mutant, cells. (iv) Mutant cells do not overgrow lac-amplified cells in microcolonies fast enough to mask the lac-amplified cells. (v) lac-amplified cells are not SOS-induced, as was proposed to explain elevated mutation in a sequential model. (vi) Amplification, and not frameshift mutation, requires DNA polymerase I, demonstrating that mutation is separable from amplification, and also illuminating the amplification mechanism. We conclude that amplification and mutation are independent outcomes of adaptive genetic change. We suggest that the availability of alternative pathways for genetic/evolutionary adaptation and clonal expansion under stress may be exploited during processes ranging from the evolution of drug resistance to cancer progression.     

Frameshift mutagenesis by ultraviolet and gamma radiations in Salmonella: SOS inducibility and effects of DNA polymerase I

Ultraviolet (UV) and gamma-induced mutagenesis have been studied using a doubly auxotrophic strain of Salmonella typhimurium carrying the amber leuA150 mutation (which reverts by base-pair substitution) and the frameshift hisC3076 marker (which reverts by compensating frameshifts). In the initially constructed LT2 background, both markers were poorly revertible by UV and essentially non-revertible by gamma-radiation. A derivative of this strain carrying the mutation-enhancing plasmid pKM101 was however readily reverted by both UV and gamma, with either Leu+ (base substitution) or His+ (frameshift) revertants being observed on appropriate selective media. Photoreactivation experiments suggested that the lesions leading to formation of the two types of mutagenic event were similar if not identical. Support for this suggestion was obtained when it was found that yields of both types of UV-induced revertant were significantly increased in an excision-deficient background, while no revertants of either type were found in a recA background. Yields of gamma-induced revertants were not greatly altered in a uvrB background, but were also reduced to zero (for both markers) in the recA background. These results are consistent with what has previously been well-documented for UV and gamma-induced base-pair substitution mutagenesis, and serve to emphasize the similarities between base-pair substitution mutagenesis and frameshift mutagenesis by these agents. There are differences, however, since although UV-induced reversion of the leuA150 marker was little affected and gamma-induced reversion of leuA150 was somewhat reduced in the presence of a polA mutation (polA3), the yields of His+ frameshift revertants were significantly increased in the polA3 background following treatment with either UV or gamma. Thus while inducible DNA repair (SOS repair) appears to be involved in generating both types of mutational event following either UV- or gamma-irradiation, at some stage in the processing of premutational lesions the level (or type) of DNA polymerase I activity in the cell seems to have an important role in determining whether or not frameshifts or base-pair substitutions will be produced at a particular frequency.     

Effects of a tumor promoter and an anti-promoter on spontaneous and UV-induced 6-thioguanine-resistant mutations and sister-chromatid exchanges in V79 Chinese hamster cells

The effects of a tumor promoter 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) and/or an anti-promotor antipain (protease inhibitor) on spontaneous and ultraviolet-induced sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) and 6-thioguanine- resistant (6TG^r) recessive mutations were examined in V79 Chinese hamster cells in culture. TPA and/or antipain neither significantly altered base-line and UV-induced immediate SCE frequencies, nor decreased the level of delayed SCEs which persisted 6–7 days after irradiation. TPA and/or antipain appeared to enhance the recovery of UV-induced 6TG^r colonies at the plateau expression phase despite non-mutagenicity by themselves and unaltered metabolic co- operation. Thus, the results conceivably imply that the 6TG^r-recessive mutation expression, but not fixation, can be modulated at the cell level by the TPA and/or antipain. Our results, together with the recent results of Loveday and Latt, may argue against the notion that TPA enhances the antipain-suppressible SCEs as an index of mitotic recombination in relevance with a tumor-promotion mechanism.