Correlated fluorescence-atomic force microscopy of membrane domains: structure of fluorescence probes determines lipid localization

Coupling atomic force microscopy (AFM) with high-resolution fluorescence microscopy is an attractive means of identifying membrane domains by both physical topography and fluorescence. We have used this approach to study the ability of a suite of fluorescent molecules to probe domain structures in supported planar bilayers. These included BODIPY-labeled ganglioside, sphingomyelin, and three new cholesterol derivatives, as well as NBD-labeled phosphatidylcholine, sphingomyelin, and cholesterol. Interestingly, many fluorescent lipid probes, including derivatives of known raft-associated lipids, preferentially partitioned into topographical features consistent with nonraft domains. This suggests that the covalent attachment of a small fluorophore to a lipid molecule can abolish its ability to associate with rafts. In addition, the localization of one of the BODIPY-cholesterol derivatives was dependent on the lipid composition of the bilayer. These data suggest that conclusions about the identification of membrane domains in supported planar bilayers on the basis of fluorescent lipid probes alone must be interpreted with caution. The combination of AFM with fluorescence microscopy represents a more rigorous means of identifying lipid domains in supported bilayers.     

Single giant vesicle rupture events reveal multiple mechanisms of glass-supported bilayer formation

The formation of supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) on glass from giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) was studied using fluorescence microscopy. We show that GUV rupture occurs by at least four mechanisms, including 1), spontaneous rupture of isolated GUVs yielding almost heart-shaped bilayer patches (asymmetric rupture); 2), spontaneous rupture of isolated GUVs yielding circular bilayer patches (symmetric rupture); 3), induced rupture of an incoming vesicle when it contacts a planar bilayer edge; and 4), induced rupture of an adsorbed GUV when a nearby GUV spontaneously ruptures. In pathway 1, the dominant rupture pathway for isolated GUVs, GUVs deformed upon adsorption to the glass surface, and planar bilayer patch formation was initiated by rupture pore formation near the rim of the glass-bilayer interface. Expanding rupture pores led to planar bilayer formation in approximately 10-20 ms. Rupture probability per unit time depended on the average intrinsic curvature of the component lipids. The membrane leaflet adsorbed to the glass surface in planar bilayer patches originated from the outer leaflet of GUVs. Pathway 2 was rarely observed. We surmise that SLB formation is predominantly initiated by pathway 1 rupture events, and that rupture events occurring by pathways 3 and 4 dominate during later stages of SLB formation.     

AFM visualization of mobile influenza A M2 molecules in planar bilayers

We report the observation of influenza A M2 (M2) incorporated in a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) supported planar bilayer on mica, formed by use of a modified vesicle fusion method from proteoliposomes and visualized with contact mode atomic force microscopy. Incubation of proteoliposomes in a hyperosmotic solution and increased DPPC/M2 weight ratios improved supported planar bilayer formation by M2/DPPC proteoliposomes. M2's extra-bilayer domains were observed as particles estimated to protrude 1-1.5 nm above the bilayer surface and <4 nm in diameter. Particle density was 5-18% of the nominal tetramer density. Movement of observable M2 particles was independent of the probe tip. The mean lateral diffusion coefficient (D) of M2 was 4.4 +/- 1.0 x 10(-14) cm(2)/s. Eighty-two percent of observable particles were mobile on the observable timescale (D > 6 x 10(-15) cm(2)/s). Protein-protein interactions were also observed directly.     

Super-resolution Imaging of the Natural Killer Cell Immunological Synapse on a Glass-supported Planar Lipid Bilayer

The glass-supported planar lipid bilayer system has been utilized in a variety of disciplines. One of the most useful applications of this technique has been in the study of immunological synapse formation, due to the ability of the glass-supported planar lipid bilayers to mimic the surface of a target cell while forming a horizontal interface. The recent advances in super-resolution imaging have further allowed scientists to better view the fine details of synapse structure. In this study, one of these advanced techniques, stimulated emission depletion (STED), is utilized to study the structure of natural killer (NK) cell synapses on the supported lipid bilayer. Provided herein is an easy-to-follow protocol detailing: how to prepare raw synthetic phospholipids for use in synthesizing glass-supported bilayers; how to determine how densely protein of a given concentration occupies the bilayer''s attachment sites; how to construct a supported lipid bilayer containing antibodies against NK cell activating receptor CD16; and finally, how to image human NK cells on this bilayer using STED super-resolution microscopy, with a focus on distribution of perforin positive lytic granules and filamentous actin at NK synapses. Thus, combining the glass-supported planar lipid bilayer system with STED technique, we demonstrate the feasibility and application of this combined technique, as well as intracellular structures at NK immunological synapse with super-resolution.     

Lipid vesicle adsorption versus formation of planar bilayers on solid surfaces.

The absorption and spreading behavior of lipid vesicles composed of either palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC) or Escherichia coli lipid upon contact with a glass surface was examined by fluorescence measurements. Fluorescently labeled lipids were used to determine 1) the amount of lipid adsorbed at the surface, 2) the extent of fusion of the vesicles upon contact with the surface, 3) the ability of the adsorbed lipids to undergo lateral diffusion, and 4) the accessibility of the adsorbed lipids by external water soluble molecules. The results of these measurements indicate that POPC vesicles spread on the surface and form a supported planar bilayer, whereas E. coli lipid vesicles adsorb to the surface and form a supported vesicle layer. Supported planar bilayers were found to be permeable for small molecules, whereas supported vesicles were impermeable and thus represented immobilized, topologically separate compartments.     

Modeling success and failure of Langmuir-Blodgett transfer of phospholipid bilayers to silicon dioxide.

Formation of planar phospholipid bilayers on solid and porous substrates by Langmuir-Blodgett transfer of monolayers from the air-water interface could be of much greater utility if the process were not irreproducible and poorly understood. To that end the energetics of transferring two phospholipid monolayers to a hydrophilic surface has been examined. An approximate mathematical relationship is formulated that relates the surface pressure of the precursor monolayers to the tension within the bilayer created. Data are presented that demonstrate that bilayer transfer can be carried out reproducibly even with refractory phospholipids such as phosphatidylcholine, but only over a very narrow range of precursor monolayer surface pressures. This range is related to the lysis tension of the bilayer. The morphology of films formed within and below the successful range of surface pressures are examined by fluorescence microscopy, and the observed features are discussed in terms of the relationship above. These results provide practical guidelines for successful formation of lipid bilayers on hydrophilic surfaces; these guidelines should prove useful for research into the properties of biomembranes and for development of bilayer-based biosensors.     

Construction and structural analysis of tethered lipid bilayer containing photosynthetic antenna proteins for functional analysis

The construction and structural analysis of a tethered planar lipid bilayer containing bacterial photosynthetic membrane proteins, light-harvesting complex 2 (LH2), and light-harvesting core complex (LH1-RC) is described and establishes this system as an experimental platform for their functional analysis. The planar lipid bilayer containing LH2 and/or LH1-RC complexes was successfully formed on an avidin-immobilized coverglass via an avidin-biotin linkage. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) showed that a smooth continuous membrane was formed there. Lateral diffusion of these membrane proteins, observed by a fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), is discussed in terms of the membrane architecture. Energy transfer from LH2 to LH1-RC within the tethered membrane was observed by steady-state fluorescence spectroscopy, indicating that the tethered membrane can mimic the natural situation.     

Micrometer-sized supported lipid bilayer arrays for bacterial toxin binding studies through total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy

In this article, we present the use of micron-sized lipid domains, patterned onto planar substrates and within microfluidic channels, to assay the binding of bacterial toxins via total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy. The lipid domains were patterned using a polymer lift-off technique and consisted of ganglioside-populated distearoylphosphatidylcholine:cholesterol supported lipid bilayers (SLBs). Lipid patterns were formed on the substrates by vesicle fusion followed by polymer lift-off, which revealed micron-sized SLBs containing either ganglioside G(T1b) or G(M1). The ganglioside-populated SLB arrays were then exposed to either cholera toxin B subunit or tetanus toxin C fragment. Binding was assayed on planar substrates by total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy down to 100 pM concentration for cholera toxin subunit B and 10 nM for tetanus toxin fragment C. Apparent binding constants extracted from three different models applied to the binding curves suggest that binding of a protein to a lipid-based receptor is influenced by the microenvironment of the SLB and the substrate on which the bilayer is formed. Patterning of SLBs inside microfluidic channels also allowed the preparation of lipid domains with different compositions on a single device. Arrays within microfluidic channels were used to achieve segregation and selective binding from a binary mixture of the toxin fragments in one device. The binding and segregation within the microfluidic channels was assayed with epifluorescence as proof of concept. We propose that the method used for patterning the lipid microarrays on planar substrates and within microfluidic channels can be easily adapted to proteins or nucleic acids and can be used for biosensor applications and cell stimulation assays under different flow conditions.     

Vesicle diffusion close to a membrane: intermembrane interactions measured with fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

The protein machinery controlling membrane fusion (or fission) has been well studied; however, the role of vesicle diffusion near membranes in these critical processes remains unclear. We experimentally and theoretically investigated the dynamics of small vesicles (∼50 nm in diameter) that are diffusing near supported planar bilayers acting as “target” membranes. Using total internal reflection-fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, we examined the validity of theoretical analyses of vesicle-membrane interactions. Vesicles were hindered by hydrodynamic drag as a function of their proximity to the planar bilayer. The population distributions and diffusion kinetics of the vesicles were further affected by changing the ionic strength and pH of the buffer, as well as the lipid composition of the planar membrane. Effective surface charges on neutral bilayers were also analyzed by comparing experimental and theoretical data, and we show the possibility that vesicle dynamics can be modified by surface charge redistribution of the planar bilayer. Based on these results, we hypothesize that the dynamics of small vesicles, diffusing close to biomembranes, may be spatially restricted by altering local physiological conditions (e.g., salt concentration, lipid composition, and pH), which may represent an additional mechanism for controlling fusion (or fission) dynamics.     

Effects of membrane potential and sphingolipid structures on fusion of Semliki Forest virus

Cells expressing the E1 and E2 envelope proteins of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) were fused to voltage-clamped planar lipid bilayer membranes at low pH. Formation and evolution of fusion pores were electrically monitored by capacitance measurements, and membrane continuity was tracked by video fluorescence microscopy by including rhodamine-phosphatidylethanolamine in the bilayer. Fusion occurred without leakage for a negative potential applied to the trans side of the planar membrane. When a positive potential was applied, leakage was severe, obscuring the observation of any fusion. E1-mediated cell-cell fusion occurred without leakage for negative intracellular potentials but with substantial leakage for zero membrane potential. Thus, negative membrane potentials are generally required for nonleaky fusion. With planar bilayers as the target, the first fusion pore that formed almost always enlarged; pore flickering was a rare event. Similar to other target membranes, fusion required cholesterol and sphingolipids in the planar membrane. Sphingosine did not support fusion, but both ceramide, with even a minimal acyl chain (C(2)-ceramide), and lysosphingomyelin (lyso-SM) promoted fusion with the same kinetics. Thus, unrelated modifications to different parts of sphingosine yielded sphingolipids that supported fusion to the same degree. Fusion studies of pyrene-labeled SFV with cholesterol-containing liposomes showed that C(2)-ceramide supported fusion while lyso-SM did not, apparently due to its positive curvature effects. A model is proposed in which the hydroxyls of C-1 and C-3 as well as N of C-2 of the sphingosine backbone must orient so as to form multiple hydrogen bonds to amino acids of SFV E1 for fusion to proceed.     

Substrate-supported phospholipid membranes studied by surface plasmon resonance and surface plasmon fluorescence spectroscopy

Substrate-supported planar lipid bilayer membranes are attractive model cellular membranes for biotechnological applications such as biochips and sensors. However, reliable fabrication of the lipid membranes on solid surfaces still poses significant technological challenges. In this study, simultaneous surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and surface plasmon fluorescence spectroscopy (SPFS) measurements were applied to the monitoring of adsorption and subsequent reorganization of phospholipid vesicles on solid substrates. The fluorescence intensity of SPFS depends very sensitively on the distance between the gold substrate and the fluorophore because of the excitation energy transfer to gold. By utilizing this distance dependency, we could obtain information about the topography of the adsorbed membranes: Adsorbed vesicles could be clearly distinguished from planar bilayers due to the high fluorescence intensity. SPSF can also incorporate various analytical techniques to evaluate the physicochemical properties of the adsorbed membranes. As an example, we demonstrated that the lateral mobility of lipid molecules could be estimated by observing the recovery of fluorescence after photobleaching. Combined with the film thickness information obtained by SPR, SPR-SPFS proved to be a highly informative technique to monitor the lipid membrane assembly processes on solid substrates.     

In situ scanning probe microscopy studies of tetanus toxin-membrane interactions

Despite the considerable information available with regards to the structure of the clostridial neurotoxins, and their inherent threat as biological warfare agents, the mechanisms underpinning their interactions with and translocation through the cell membrane remain poorly understood. We report herein the results of an in situ scanning probe microscopy study of the interaction of tetanus toxin C-fragment (Tet C) with supported planar lipid bilayers containing the ganglioside receptor G(T1b). Our results show that Tet C preferentially binds to the surface of fluid phase domains within biphasic membranes containing G(T1b) and that with an extended incubation period these interactions lead to dramatic changes in the morphology of the lipid bilayer, including the formation of 40-80 nm diameter circular cavities. Combined atomic force microscopy/total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy experiments confirmed the presence of Tet C in the membrane after extended incubation. These morphological changes were found to be dependent upon the presence of G(T1b) and the solution pH.     

Video fluorescence microscopy studies of phospholipid vesicle fusion with a planar phospholipid membrane. Nature of membrane-membrane interactions and detection of release of contents

Video fluorescence microscopy was used to study adsorption and fusion of unilamellar phospholipid vesicles to solvent-free planar bilayer membranes. Large unilamellar vesicles (2-10 microns diam) were loaded with 200 mM of the membrane-impermeant fluorescent dye calcein. Vesicles were ejected from a pipette brought to within 10 microns of the planar membrane, thereby minimizing background fluorescence and diffusion times through the unstirred layer. Vesicle binding to the planar membrane reached a maximum at 20 mM calcium. The vesicles fused when they were osmotically swollen by dissipating a KCl gradient across the vesicular membrane with the channel-forming antibiotic nystatin or, alternatively, by making the cis compartment hyperosmotic. Osmotically induced ruptures appeared as bright flashes of light that lasted several video fields (each 1/60 s). Flashes of light, and therefore swelling, occurred only when channels were present in the vesicular membrane. The flashes were observed when nystatin was added to the cis compartment but not when added to the trans. This demonstrates that the vesicular and planar membranes remain individual bilayers in the region of contact, rather than melding into a single bilayer. Measurements of flash duration in the presence of cobalt (a quencher of calcein fluorescence) were used to determine the side of the planar membrane to which dye was released. In the presence of 20 mM calcium, 50% of the vesicle ruptures were found to result in fusion with the planar membrane. In 100 mM calcium, nearly 70% of the vesicle ruptures resulted in fusion. The methods of this study can be used to increase significantly the efficiency of reconstitution of channels into planar membranes by fusion techniques.     

Design of supported membranes tethered via metal-affinity ligand-receptor pairs

Model lipid layers are very promising in investigating the complex network of recognition, transport and signaling processes at membranes. We have developed a novel and generic approach to create supported lipid membranes tethered by metal-affinity binding. By self-assembly we have generated various interfaces that display histidine sequences (6xHis) via polymer spacers. These histidine-functionalized interfaces are designed to allow specific docking and fusion of vesicles containing metal-chelating lipids. By means of surface plasmon resonance and atomic force microscopy we analyzed the formation and subsequently the structure of these solid-supported membranes. Although the affinity constant of single ligand-receptor pairs is only in the micromolar range, very stable immobilization of these membranes was observed. This behavior can be explained by multivalent interactions resembling many features of cell adhesion. The process is highly specific, because vesicle docking and bilayer formation are strictly dependent on the presence of metal-affinity ligand-receptor pairs. The surface accessibility and geometry of these tethered membranes were probed by binding of histidine-tagged polypeptides. The supported membranes show adsorption kinetics and values similar to planar supported monolayers. Using various combinations of metal-chelating and histidine-tagged lipids or thiols these metal-affinity-tethered membranes should make a great impact on probing and eventually understanding the dynamic dialog of reconstituted membrane proteins.     

High-resolution AFM of membrane proteins directly incorporated at high density in planar lipid bilayer

The heterologous expression and purification of membrane proteins represent major limitations for their functional and structural analysis. Here we describe a new method of incorporation of transmembrane proteins in planar lipid bilayer starting from 1 pmol of solubilized proteins. The principle relies on the direct incorporation of solubilized proteins into a preformed planar lipid bilayer destabilized by dodecyl-beta-maltoside or dodecyl-beta-thiomaltoside, two detergents widely used in membrane biochemistry. Successful incorporations are reported at 20 degrees C and at 4 degrees C with three bacterial photosynthetic multi-subunit membrane proteins. Height measurements by atomic force microscopy (AFM) of the extramembraneous domains protruding from the bilayer demonstrate that proteins are unidirectionally incorporated within the lipid bilayer through their more hydrophobic domains. Proteins are incorporated at high density into the bilayer and on incubation diffuse and segregate into protein close-packing areas. The high protein density allows high-resolution AFM topographs to be recorded and protein subunits organization delineated. This approach provides an alternative experimental platform to the classical methods of two-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins for the structural analysis by AFM. Furthermore, the versatility and simplicity of the method are important intrinsic properties for the conception of biosensors and nanobiomaterials involving membrane proteins.     

Abeta42-peptide assembly on lipid bilayers

One of the major pathological features of Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the presence of extracellular amyloid plaques that are composed predominantly of the amyloid-beta peptide (Abeta). Diffuse plaques associated with AD are composed predominantly of Abeta42, whereas senile plaques contain both Abeta40 and Abeta42. Recently, it has been suggested that diffuse plaque formation is initiated as a plasma membrane-bound Abeta species and that Abeta42 is the critical component. In order to investigate this hypothesis, we have examined Abeta42-membrane interactions using in situ atomic force microscopy and fluorescence spectroscopy. Our studies demonstrate the association of Abeta42 with planar bilayers composed of total brain lipids, which results initially in peptide aggregation and then fibre formation. Modulation of the cholesterol content is correlated with the extent of Abeta42-assembly on the bilayer surface. Although Abeta42 was not visualized directly on cholesterol-depleted bilayers, fluorescence anisotropy and fluorimetry demonstrate Abeta42-induced membrane changes. Our results demonstrate that the composition of the lipid bilayer governs the outcome of Abeta interactions.     

Supported double membranes

Planar model membranes, like supported lipid bilayers and surface-tethered vesicles, have been proven to be useful tools for the investigation of complex biological functions in a significantly less complex membrane environment. In this study, we introduce a supported double membrane system that should be useful for studies that target biological processes in the proximity of two lipid bilayers such as the periplasm of bacteria and mitochondria or the small cleft between pre- and postsynaptic neuronal membranes. Large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) were tethered to a preformed supported bilayer by a biotin–streptavidin tether. We show from single particle tracking (SPT) experiments that these vesicle are mobile above the plane of the supported membrane. At higher concentrations, the tethered vesicles fuse to form a second continuous bilayer on top of the supported bilayer. The distance between the two bilayers was determined by fluorescence interference contrast (FLIC) microscopy to be between 16 and 24 nm. The lateral diffusion of labeled lipids in the second bilayer was very similar to that in supported membranes. SPT experiments with reconstituted syntaxin-1A show that the mobility of transmembrane proteins was not improved when compared with solid supported membranes.     

DNA-tethered membranes formed by giant vesicle rupture

We have developed a strategy for preparing tethered lipid bilayer membrane patches on solid surfaces by DNA hybridization. In this way, the tethered membrane patch is held at a controllable distance from the surface by varying the length of the DNA used. Two basic strategies are described. In the first, single-stranded DNA strands are immobilized by click chemistry to a silica surface, whose remaining surface is passivated to prevent direct assembly of a solid supported bilayer. Then giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) displaying the antisense strand, using a DNA–lipid conjugate developed in earlier work [Chan, Y.-H.M., van Lengerich, B., et al., 2008. Lipid-anchored DNA mediates vesicle fusion as observed by lipid and content mixing. Biointerphases 3 (2), FA17–FA21], are allowed to tether, spread and rupture to form tethered bilayer patches. In the second, a supported lipid bilayer displaying DNA using the DNA–lipid conjugate is first assembled on the surface. Then GUVs displaying the antisense strand are allowed to tether, spread and rupture to form tethered bilayer patches. The essential difference between these methods is that the tethering hybrid DNA is immobile in the first, while it is mobile in the second. Both strategies are successful; however, with mobile DNA hybrids as tethers, the patches are unstable, while in the first strategy stable patches can be formed. In the case of mobile tethers, if different length DNA hybrids are present, lateral segregation by length occurs and can be visualized by fluorescence interference contrast microscopy making this an interesting model for interactions that occur in cell junctions. In both cases, lipid mobility is high and there is a negligible immobile fraction. Thus, these architectures offer a flexible platform for the assembly of lipid bilayers at a well-defined distance from a solid support.     

Coexistence of a two-states organization for a cell-penetrating peptide in lipid bilayer

Primary amphipathic cell-penetrating peptides transport cargoes across cell membranes with high efficiency and low lytic activity. These primary amphipathic peptides were previously shown to form aggregates or supramolecular structures in mixed lipid-peptide monolayers, but their behavior in lipid bilayers remains to be characterized. Using atomic force microscopy, we have examined the interactions of P(alpha), a primary amphipathic cell-penetrating peptide which remains alpha-helical whatever the environment, with dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) bilayers. Addition of P(alpha) at concentrations up to 5 mol % markedly modified the supported bilayers topography. Long and thin filaments lying flat at the membrane surface coexisted with deeply embedded peptides which induced a local thinning of the bilayer. On the other hand, addition of P(alpha) only exerted very limited effects on the corresponding liposome's bilayer physical state, as estimated from differential scanning calorimetry and diphenylhexatriene fluorescence anisotropy experiments. The use of a gel-fluid phase separated supported bilayers made of a dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine mixture confirmed both the existence of long filaments, which at low peptide concentration were preferentially localized in the fluid phase domains and the membrane disorganizing effects of 5 mol % P(alpha). The simultaneous two-states organization of P(alpha), at the membrane surface and deeply embedded in the bilayer, may be involved in the transmembrane carrier function of this primary amphipathic peptide.     

Muscovite (mica) allows the characterisation of supported bilayers by ellipsometry and confocal fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

We demonstrate for the first time that ellipsometry and confocal fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) are complementary methods for the characterisation of supported planar phospholipid bilayers (SPBs) formed on mica, a mineral used in atomic force microscopy investigations of SPBs. Addition of small unilamellar vesicles containing 20% dioleoyl-phosphatidylserine (DOPS) and 80% dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DOPC) to an oxidised borosilicate surface, on the other hand, results in a planar lipid system characterised by lateral diffusion coefficients which are three time smaller than those obtained for SPBs. Moreover, seven labelled phospholipids were tested for their suitability in the FCS characterisation of vesicles as well as of SPBs.