Selective suppression of allotype expression induced in vitro: maintenance of suppression following adoptive transfer

The question of the ultimate fate of lymphocytes subjected to treatment with anti-allotype antibody (Ab) has been investigated by means of an adoptive transfer system that uses noninbred rabbits matched for major histocompatibility antigens and mismatched for allotype. Suppression of b4 immunoglobulin (Ig) production was induced by incubating lymphocytes from b4b5 rabbits with anti-b4 in culture. Transfer of b4-suppressed cells to newborn recipients of allotype b6b6 resulted in stable chimerism of mixed donor-recipient allotypes, in which b4 Ig production remained suppressed. In recipients of non-Ab-treated cells, b4 Ig production predominated over b5, as had been the case in the intact donor. No evidence for stimulation of b4 Ig synthesis was seen, even when lymphocytes and serum from 1-week-old recipients were examined. When lymphoid cells of antigen-primed b4b5 donors were treated with anti-b4 in vitro and transferred, Ab production of the b4 type was specifically suppressed, with compensatory over-production by Ab-forming cells of the b5 type. The results reported here indicate that although anti-allotype Ab is not directly cytotoxic, a significant proportion of the b4-committed cells were irreversibly inactivated as a result of Ab pulse treatment.     

In vitro allotype suppression of spleen cells from immunized rabbits

We tested whether rabbit immune lymphocytes could be suppressed by anti-allotype antibody (Ab) in vitro as shown for normal lymphocytes. Spleen cells (SpC) from rabbits heterozygous at the b locus (b⁴b⁵) of immunoglobulin (Ig) κ chains were treated with IgG preparations of anti-b4 or anti-b5 Ab in vitro for 24 hr (day 1). After this treatment, the SpC were washed and recultured in medium to day 5. The secreted b4- and b5-Ig were quantitated by a radioimmunoassay. SpC from rabbits injected once with sheep red blood cells (SRBC) were allotype-suppressed. Thus, these SpC treated with anti-b4 Ab secreted normal amounts of b5-Ig but secreted much lower amounts of b4-Ig. Similarly, SpC treated with anti-b5 Ab secreted normal amounts of b4-Ig but secreted no detectable b5-Ig. In contrast, SpC from rabbits injected several times with SRBC (hyperimmunized) could not be allotype-suppressed. Hence, the susceptibility of primary immune cells and the resistance of hyperimmune cells to suppression appear to depend on the stage of B-lymphocyte differentiation, presumably because of loss of surface Ig or perhaps because of other changes in the cells as they differentiate during the immune response.     

Suppression of rabbit lymphocyte functions by antibodies specific for allotypic membrane determinants

Regulation of immunoglobulin synthesis and secretion was analyzed by exposing spleen cells of b4b4 rabbits to anti-b4 for 24 hr in culture. As noted previously, no lymphocytes with membrane-bound b4 were found immediately after pulse treatment, but substantial regeneration of membrane Ig (mIg) occurred on further culture in antibody-free medium. Splenocytes cultured either in the presence or absence of anti-b4 showed a marked loss of Ig-secreting cells (ISC) after 24 hr in culture but recovered and exhibited peak numbers of ISC on Day 2. However, ISC formation in cultures of antibody-treated cells was significantly suppressed and thereafter declined at a more rapid rate than in control cultures. Polyclonal B cell activators from Nocardia and from gram-negative bacteria stimulated ISC formation in cultures of normal spleen cells, but responsiveness to these activators was depressed following antibody treatment. Antibody-induced suppression of Ig synthesis was attributed to interference with differentiation of B lymphocytes to the secretory stage.     

In vitro immunoglobulin allotype synthesis by spleen cells of heterozygous rabbits. Specific suppression by anti-allotype antibody

The production of immunoglobulin (Ig) bearing the b4 and b5 allotypic markers by b⁴b⁵ heterozygous spleen cells cultured in vitro was assessed by means of a sensitive and reproducible radioimmunoassay. Ig synthesis was demonstrated by the increasing amounts of the b4 and b5 allotypes appearing with time in the supernatant fluids. To determine the effect of anti-b4 or anti-b5 antibody on the synthesis of the b4 and b5 allotypes, spleen cells from b⁴b⁵ heterozygous rabbits were incubated for 24 hr in the presence of anti-b4 or anti-b5 and then washed and cultured for an additional 4 days. Anti-b4 suppressed the production of the b4 allotype with no effect on b5 production, whereas anti-b5 suppressed the production of b5 allotype with no effect on b4 production. This suppression of allotype synthesis in vitro presumably results from an antigen-antibody reaction occurring on the surface of lymphoid cells by a mechanism which may be similar to that which brings about allotype suppression in vivo for fetal and newborn rabbits.     

Allelic allotype inclusion and exclusion among rabbit Ig-bearing lymphocytes of peripheral blood and lymphoid organs

Mononuclear cells isolated from peripheral blood, appendix, sacculus rotundus, mesenteric lymph nodes, and spleen of b⁴b⁵ heterozygous rabbits were examined for surface Ig allotypes of the b locus. Ig allotype-bearing cells were detected as cells binding erythrocytes or bacteria coated with monospecific anti-b4 or anti-b5 antibody (Ab). Rosetting the cells with Ab-coated erythrocytes indicated that many peripheral blood lymphocytes, but relatively few appendix cells, bore both the b4 and b5 allotypes. Lymphocytes bearing both the b4 and b5 allotypes were also detected by incubating the cells with a mixture of Escherichia coli coated with anti-b4 Ab and Gaffkya tetragena coated with anti-b5 Ab. The percentage of Ig-positive lymphocytes binding both bacteria was 22–31% in the peripheral blood, 4–6% in the appendix, 3–5% in the sacculus rotundus, 4–10% in the mesenteric lymph nodes, and 5% in the spleen. Thus, the percentage of double-bearing lymphocytes was higher in the blood than in the appendix, sacculus rotundus, mesenteric lymph nodes, or spleen. The b4b5-bearing cells in the blood were not cells with adsorbed cytophilic Ab, since these cells still bore both the b4 and b5 allotypes after pronase digestion and Ig regeneration. These double-bearing lymphocytes, i.e., cells exhibiting allelic allotype inclusion, are probably less differentiated cells.     

Ontogeny of B lymphocytes. I. In vitro appearance of Ig-bearing lymphocytes

During the immediate postnatal period, a striking increase in the fraction and number of splenic lymphocytes which bear easily detectable surface immunoglobulin (Ig) occurs in BALB/c and CDF₁ mice. Thus, in mice < 8 hr of age, approximately 4% of splenic lymphoid cells bear surface Ig whereas 17% of splenic lymphocytes of mice 24 hr of age are positive for surface Ig. This increase in Ig-bearing lymphocytes can be obtained in vitro. Thus, cultures of spleen or liver cells from neonatal mice display a substantial increase in the percent and in the absolute number of cells with easily detectable surface Ig. The in vitro increase in Ig-bearing cells is largely inhibited by mitomycin C or puromycin treatment of neonatal cells. Interestingly, pretreatment of these cells with anti-κ antibody, with or without complement, inhibited the increase in Ig-bearing cells. These results indicate that a substantial portion of Ig-bearing lymphoid cells present at 24 hr of age derive from cells already present in the spleens and livers of neonatal mice. Many of these “precursor” cells appear to bear some surface Ig.     

Reaginic antibody formation in the mouse. IX. Enhancement of suppressor and helper cell activities of primed spleen cells.

Attempts were made to increase the activity of suppressor cells in vitro. Antigen-specific suppressor cells were induced by i.v. injections of urea-denatured ovalbumin (UD-OA) into OA-primed mice. Nonadherent splenic lymphocytes from the UD-OA-treated mice were incubated at 37 degrees C for 24 hr with either OA or OA-bearing macrophages and lymphocytes harvested from the culture were examined for the ability to suppress primary anti-hapten antibody response on nonirradiated mice to DNP-OA. The results showed that the suppressive activity of the lymphocytes increased after culture of the cells with OA or OA-bearing macrophages. Similar results were obtained when nylon column-purified T cell-rich fraction of the lymphocytes were similarly cultured. The suppressive activity was associated with theta-bearing lymphocytes and was specific for OA. Suppressor cells were not induced by the culture of OA-primed lymphocytes with OA. The helper function of splenic lymphocytes from both UD-OA-treated mice and OA-primed mice was enhanced by the culture of the cells with OA-bearing macrophages but not by culture with OA in the absence of macrophages.     

A comparison of murine hepatic accessory cells and splenic dendritic cells

Accessory cells are required for proliferation and antibody synthesis of B lymphocytes and proliferation of T lymphocytes in primary immune responses in vitro. The obligatory cells derived from the spleen are referred to as dendritic cells. Accessory cells were isolated from normal adult livers which were functionally interchangeable with splenic DC. Both hepatic accessory cells (AC) and splenic DC adhere firmly to plastic culture dishes or wells within 2 hr; but hepatic AC, unlike splenic DC, do not detach during 22 hr additional incubation. Hepatic AC, unlike splenic DC, are not lysed or inactivated by monoclonal antibody 33D1 and C'. Hepatic AC and splenic DC are similarly sensitive to irradiation in vivo and insensitive to irradiation in vitro. Hepatic AC are separated with cells which are predominantly phagocytic and FcR+ and contain nonspecific esterase. Both hepatic AC and splenic DC are suppressed or eliminated by activation of NK cells in vivo, a phenomenon prevented by prior elimination of NK cells.     

Induction of plasma cell differentiation of human fetal lymphocytes: evidence for functional immaturity of T and B cells.

Resembling the in vitro antibody response of the newborn cultures of cord blood lymphocytes stimulated with pokeweed mitogen (PWM) generated fewer plasma cells (PC) than comparable adult lymphocyte cultures and the response was almost exclusively of the IgM class. We investigated the cellular basis of this difference by preparing mixed cultures of newborn T or B lymphocytes with adult B or T cells. Substitution of adult for newborn T cells enhanced the response of newborn B cells, particularly of the IgG and IgA classes. The response of second trimester fetal spleen cells was also increased by adult T cells, although no IgA PC appeared. Conversely, adult B cells generated fewer PC particularly of the IgG and IgA classes when cultured with newborn T cells. The relatively poor IgA and IgG responses of newborn cells seems partially but not entirely due to deficiency of T cell helper function. Suppressor activity of newborn T cells was investigated by adding excess unrelated newborn or adult T cells to adult T + B cells: adult T cells improved the response whereas newborn T cells were variably suppressive. The results indicate that newborn T cells, although capable of helper function, are balanced toward suppression.     

Enhancement of lymphocyte dependent antibody cytotoxicity by anti allotype serum.

Anti-allotype b4 and anti-allotype a3 antibody as well as heterologous anti-rabbit IgG enhanced the lymphocyte-dependent antibody cytotoxicity, in a system using chicken red blood cells (ChRBC) coated with rabbit anti-ChRBC antibody ($\text{a}\text{3}\text{a}\text{3}$, $\text{b}\text{4}\text{b}\text{5}$) as target cells and rabbit lymphocytes ($\text{a}\text{3}\text{a}\text{3}$, $\text{b}\text{4}\text{b}\text{5}$). No enhancement was observed with anti-allotype b6 antiserum, nor with heterologous anti-rabbit IgM, IgA, and Fc antibodies. Cytotoxicity mediated by spleen, bone marrow, and thymus lymphocytes was enhanced by anti-allotype antibody. The enhancement of cytotoxicity by anti-allotype antibody cannot be attributed to lymphocyte proliferation but is more likely related to the formation of an additional bridge between effector cell and target cell.     

Macromolecular insoluble cold globulin (MICG): a novel protein from mouse lymphocytes. IV. Evidence for the plasma membrane distribution of MICG.

Macromolecular insoluble cold globulin is a glycoprotein synthesized predominantly by T lymphocytes in the mouse. The present report details experiments demonstrating the plasma membrane distribution of MICG on T lymphocytes. By utilizing immunofluorescent techniques it was shown that MICG was located in the external cell surface of 98% of thymic lymphocytes and 60% of splenic lymphocytes. Furthermore, in spleen cells, it was demonstrated that T cells and not B cells were surface MICG positive. Antibody to MICG was able to cap all of the immunofluorescent-positive (60%) spleen cells. In contrast, anti-MICG antibody did not induce cap formation on thymus cells. Only when dilute solutions of antibody were used did MICG cap on the thymus cells. Employing limited proteolysis of thymus and spleen cells MICG was shown to be regenerated on the surface of T cells with a half-life of 3.5 hr. The distribution and cell surface characteristics of MICG are discussed in terms of a "receptor-like" function for this protein.     

Leu-1+ (CD5+) B cells. A major lymphoid subpopulation in human fetal spleen: phenotypic and functional studies

Examination of the cell surface phenotype of fetal splenic lymphocytes demonstrated a major, novel subpopulation of B cells that co-express Leu-1 (CD5) in addition to B cell differentiation antigens (Leu-1+ B cells). These cells are similar to some conventional B cells in that they express HLA-DR, Leu-12, and B1, as well as both immunoglobulin (Ig) M and IgD. They comprise 40 to 60% of total splenic B cells in the fetus but are infrequent in fetal liver and adult spleen. Fetal Leu-1+ B cells do not respond to pokeweed mitogen with either proliferation or Ig secretion, and in contrast to the murine counterpart, Ly-1 B cells, they do not constitutively produce Ig. Leu-1+ B cells were incapable of augmenting Ig production of Leu-1- B cells when suboptimal numbers of T cells were present; however, they did require the presence of T cells to secrete antibody. They do not cap either the CD5 protein or surface Ig. These cells are a unique subpopulation of fetal splenic B cells that do not function as conventional B cells. Their role in the humoral immune response is unknown. They may represent the normal stage of B cell development, which is reflected in the phenotype of B cell CLL cells.     

Generation in vivo of non-T suppressor cells with the use of anti-allotype antibody

Anti-Igh-1b antiserum induced allotype-specific suppression of adult mouse spleen cells in an adoptive transfer system. Suppression of Igh-1b anti-sheep red blood cell plaque-forming cells was measured as late as 4 wk after the injection of allotype heterozygous (Igha/b) spleen cells, antiserum, and sheep red blood cells. Suppression was maintained on retransfer of the allotype-suppressed spleen cells to further irradiated recipients in the absence of additional exogenous anti-allotype antibody. Mixing experiments were performed to test the putative inhibitory effects of allotype-suppressed spleen cells from the first adoptive transfer (stage I) on the antibody response of normal spleen cells in a second adoptive transfer (stage II). No suppression was observed by using unfractionated stage I spleen cells. In contrast, when these allotype-suppressed spleen cells were depleted of T cells, they strongly inhibited the antibody production of admixed normal spleen cells in stage II. This inhibitory activity of antibody-induced stage I spleen cells was directed primarily toward the target allotype, but some suppression of the Igh-1a plaque-forming cell response and total IgG production also occurred. Although removal of adherent cells did not affect the inhibitory activity of allotype-suppressed spleen cells from stage I, removal of Ig+ cells completely abrogated the inhibitory activity. These results suggest that antibody-induced regulatory B cells may play a role in maintaining long term allotype suppression.     

Failure of B lymphocytes in human blood to regenerate surface immunoglobulin after its removal by antibody.

In culture, human blood B cells regenerated surface IgM and IgD after their removal by a brief treatment with pronase. In contrast, surface Ig was poorly reexpressed after interaction with specific antibody. Both classes of surface Ig were suppressed after treatment with antibody specific for only one. B lymphocytes from spleen and tonsils regenerated surface Ig after treatment with either pronase or anti-Ig. We suggest that the particular sensitivity of circulating B cells to anti-Ig-surface Ig interaction may be reflection of their state of maturation.     

Antigen-specific suppression of the in vitro cytotoxic response by a soluble factor produced by Corynebacterium parvum-induced allospecific suppressor cells

The adjuvant Corynebacterium parvum, when administered intravenously during an ongoing alloimmunization, induces alloantigen-specific splenic suppressor cells which inhibit primary and secondary in vitro sensitizations. We have previously shown that these cells produce a soluble suppressor factor in culture. We now further characterize this factor and its mechanism of action. Release of this suppressive factor is dependent upon specific restimulation of the splenic suppressor cell with the sensitizing alloantigen for 24-48 hr in culture. The suppressor factor inhibits primary, but not secondary, in vitro sensitizations in an antigen-specific, genetically unrestricted manner. The suppressive activity is not absorbed by passage through immunoadsorbent columns containing anti-mouse immunoglobulin. The factor does not lyse tumor cells bearing the sensitizing alloantigen. Delay in addition to primary cultures of as little as 4 hr after culture initiation leads to loss of suppressive activity, suggesting that this antigen-specific allosuppressor factor inhibits an early step in the sensitization of precursor cytotoxic T lymphocytes.     

Selection of antibody repertoires by anti-idiotypes can occur at multiple steps of B cell differentiation

These experiments were designed to evaluate whether alterations in Id expression after anti-Id treatments result from direct modulation of Id-producing B cells, and whether idiotypic selection operates in bone marrow or spleen B cells. By using the NPb Id model, we have studied the functional behavior of isolated LPS-reactive B cells transferred from B6 mice into histocompatible LPS-NR B10.Cr hosts and primed with LPS conjugates of anti-Id antibodies. We have found that previous anti-idiotypic manipulation of host mice by neonatal administration of suppressive doses of Ac 38 antibodies, or adult injection of enhancing doses of Ac 146 antibodies, modulated the T cell-independent Id response of either immature bone marrow or mature splenic responding cells, transferred from normal, untreated donors. These results are interpreted to suggest that selection of antibody repertoires by anti-Id may occur at multiple steps of B cell differentiation.     

A suppressor cell which interferes with antiallotype stimulated DNA synthesis of rabbit B cells

Responsiveness of rabbit spleen cells to anti-allotype antibody was measured in terms of increased thymidine incorporation. Incorporation was enhanced after removal of cells which had ingested or had adhered to magnetic particles. B lymphocytes, prepared from spleen cells by the removal of adherent cells and of RTLA bearing T cells, were more responsive to anti-allotype antibody than were the original spleen suspensions. This increase could not be explained by enrichment in B cells. It was concluded that an adherent cell suppressed B cell transformation. The addition of 2-mercaptoethanol to the cell cultures stimulated with mitogen augmented the incorporation of thymidine. Adherent cells interfered with 2-mercaptoethanol potentiation in the response to anti-allotype antibody but not in the response to Con A. Fractionation of spleen cells, over glass bead columns, yielded nonadherent and adherent cell populations. The responsiveness of nonadherent cells to anti-allotype induced thymidine incorporation was two to six times that of unfractionated cells. The responsiveness of nonadherent cells to stimulation by anti-allotype antibody was reduced after addition of adherent cells. Findings were discussed in terms of the inhibitory role played by adherent cells on anti-allotype antibody induced responsiveness of rabbit B cells and of the possible participation of a third cell type which functions as a promotor of mitogenic T cell stimulation.     

Reversal of immunosuppression induced with plasma of malarious rats by supplemented complement

Suppression of antibody producing splenic lymphocytes by plasma from rats infected with Plasmodium chabaudi malaria was confirmed. Suppressive activity was found in plasma drawn on the sixth, seventh and eighth day of infection. It was temporally associated with anemia, elevated levels of soluble immune complex, reduced titers of lytic complement and elevated titers of immunoconglutinin (IK) in the plasma. Heat inactivation of the plasma to destroy complement and removal of IK by absorption did not reduce the suppressive activity. Incubating the plasma-treated lymphocytes with normal rat complement largely, but not completely, reversed the suppressive action. Soluble immune complexes prepared from bovine serum albumin (BSA) and antiBSA (BSA-antiBSA) alexinated complex (BSA-antiBSA-C') and immunoconglutinated complex (BSA-antiBSA-C'-IK) each suppressed the capacity of splenic lymphocytes from rats immunized with sheep blood cells to produce hemolytic Jerne plaques. Incubating the complex-treated cells with fresh complement largely reversed the suppressive activity. It is suggested that the suppressed responses of lymphocytes from malarious animals to antigens or mitogens, reported by others, may have been in part induced by complexes in blood of the animals, and that antibody producing cells might also have been suppressed. Since suppressive activity was not influenced by complement inactivation, but was reversed when plasma-treated cells were incubated with fresh complement, it is suggested that the hypocomplementemic state of suppressive plasma may have contributed to immunosuppression.     

Tolerance induction in resting memory B cells specific for a protein antigen.

Resting memory B lymphocytes specific for the model protein Ag cytochrome c have been shown to be susceptible to tolerance induction in in vitro splenic fragment cultures. This induction of nonresponsiveness is dependent upon the strength of the interaction between surface Ig and specific Ag, where concentration, valency, affinity, and time of exposure all appear to be important factors, as is the case for tolerance induction in immature or primary B cells. The induction of nonresponsivenes in greater than 80% of Ag-specific memory B cells was achieved by incubation with 1 microM cytochrome polymer for 24 h in the absence of T cell help. Not only were memory B cells unresponsive to specific Ag, they were also unable to become activated through nonspecific uptake and presentation of an Ag to which T cells have been primed, demonstrating that the induction of nonresponsiveness involves more than a modulation or blockade of surface Ig receptors. Although soluble factors collected from activated T cells failed to prevent memory B cells from becoming nonresponsive after surface Ig cross-linking, the direct activation of T cells within splenic fragment cultures did partially inhibit tolerance induction in splenic fragment memory B cells. In addition, the induction of tolerance was partially blocked by protein tyrosine kinase inhibitors, suggesting a physiologic change within the B cells associated with the state of nonresponsiveness and resulting from tyrosine-specific phosphorylation.     

Appearance of lymphocyte surface markers and functional responses in neonatal and young rabbit spleens

We examined spleen cells from newborn to 1-month-old rabbits for easily detectable surface immunoglobulin, complement receptors, and for in vitro proliferative responsiveness to anti-immunoglobulin antisera and several mitogens. From birth through the first month of life about 15% of the cells from rabbit spleens had easily detectable surface immunoglobulin while about 45% had C3 receptors. In adults as many as 77% of the spleen cells had easily detectable surface Ig but the proportion with C3 receptors remained about 45%. The proliferative response to anti-allotype antisera was present at birth, and was at adult levels by 1 month of age. The proliferative response to pokeweed mitogen was low when cells were obtained during the first week of life but was comparable in magnitude to the response of adult cells by 2 weeks of age. In vitro responsiveness to concanavalin A was present at low levels at birth and increased sharply during the first week. We did not observe significant stimulation of spleen cells from neonatal to 4-week-old rabbits by lipopolysaccharide from Salmonella typhosa. Our data suggest that lymphocyte surface markers and functional responses appear asynchronously in spleen cells of developing rabbits.