Functional heterogeneity in allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones. II. Development of syngeneic cytotoxicity in the absence of specific antigenic stimulation

Two out of four long-term murine allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones tested could develop high levels of cytotoxicity against syngeneic target cells when cultured under appropriate conditions. All CTL clones maintained strict allospecificity so long as they were cultured with both appropriate allogeneic stimulator cells and growth factor (supernatant from secondary mixed lymphocyte cultures). In two of the clones, syngeneic reactivity rapidly developed when the allogeneic stimulator cells were replaced with syngeneic or third party stimulator cells, and when the supernatant from EL4 thymoma cells stimulated with phorbol ester was used as growth factor. In addition to killing the appropriate allogeneic target, clones with syngeneic reactivity could kill both syngeneic C57BL/6 targets and H-2-congenic BALB.B targets but not third party unrelated targets, suggesting that the self structure recognized was coded for within the major histocompatibility complex. Such clones did not kill the natural killer (NK) target YAC. The results obtained from cold target inhibition and from subcloning at limiting dilution of clones with syngeneic reactivity suggested that both allogeneic and syngeneic reactivity could be expressed by the same individual cell in the CTL clone. The specificity for syngeneic H-2 as opposed to third party H-2 and NK-sensitive target cells, and the observation that both allospecific and syngeneic killing could be partially blocked by anti-Lyt-2 antibody treatment of the CTL, strongly suggested that different recognition structures are involved in CTL-mediated syngeneic cytotoxicity and NK cytotoxicity.     

Influence of interferon on the functional expression of natural killer target structures of murine lymphoma cells

Murine lymphoma cells (YAC-1), induced by Moloney leukemia virus, nontreated (YAC) or pretreated in vitro with interferon (YAC-IF), were tested for their susceptibility to natural killer (NK)-mediated cytolysis. In line with previous reports YAC-IF were less susceptible to NK lysis than YAC cells. In cold competition assay, YAC-IF inhibited cytotoxicity to a lesser extent than YAC lymphoma when labeled target YAC cells were used. However, when radioactive YAC-IF cells were used as targets, cold competition attained with both YAC and YAC-IF was essentially the same. Furthermore, effector splenocytes, depleted of NK effector cells through immunoabsorption on YAC monolayer, were inactive against both YAC and YAC-IF targets. On the other hand, effector lymphocytes, absorbed on YAC-IF monolayer, retained NK activity against YAC cells but not against YAC-IF targets. These results are compatible with the hypothesis that interferon (IF) modulates negatively a subset of "interferon-susceptible" (IFS) NK target structure(s) (TS) of YAC cells, which would then express membrane determinants not functionally present on YAC-IF cells. On the other hand YAC and YAC-IF cells share "interferon-resistant" (IFR) TS not affected by pretreatment with IF. In order to test whether IFS X TS and IFR X TS are present on the same cell or clonally distributed, YAC cells were cloned and tested for NK susceptibility following IF pretreatment. The results did not support the hypothesis of a clonal distribution of both IFS X TS and IFR X TS since IF pretreatment of all clones, obtained by limiting dilution, resulted in a net impairment of target susceptibility to NK effector cells.     

Functional characterization of LFA-1 antigens in the interaction of human NK clones and target cells

In the present studies we analyzed the role of LFA-1 antigens in the interaction between NK clones and target cells. The use of various cloned NK cell lines allowed us to analyze homogeneous populations of NK cells which ordinarily comprise only a small fraction of peripheral blood lymphocytes and are extremely heterogeneous with respect to phenotype and specificity. Indirect immunofluorescence with monoclonal antibodies against the alpha (MHM24) and beta (MHM23) chains of the LFA-1 antigen revealed similar patterns of positive reactivity with all NK clones. Both monoclonal antibodies exerted a significant blocking effect on NK cytotoxicity against target cells such as Molt-4 and CEM, whereas the inhibition was very weak against other targets such as K562 and HSB cells. Additive blocking effects were seen when both monoclonal antibodies MHM23 and MHM24 were added to the cytotoxicity assays. When we compared the inhibitory effect of MHM23 and MHM24 on uncultured peripheral blood NK cells and IL 2-activated NK cells, inhibition of cytotoxicity also was found to be primarily dependent on the individual target cells. Thus, the inhibitory activity of anti-LFA-1 antibody was shown to be independent of the phenotypic and functional heterogeneity of the NK clones, activated NK cells, and unstimulated NK cells utilized in these studies. These blocking effects were found to be independent of the LFA-1 antigen expression on the target cell membrane and inhibition occurred only when antibody was bound to the effector cells. Comparison of the effects of anti-LFA-1, anti-T3, and anti-clonotypic antibodies against a Ti-like structure of different NK clones with a mature T cell phenotype demonstrated that each of these antibodies acts on the effector cells in an independent and additive fashion. However, unlike T3 and NKTa antigen, LFA-1 antigen expression is not modulated by cell surface interaction with antibodies specific for this molecule.     

Analysis of the murine lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell phenomenon: dissection of effectors and progenitors into NK- and T-like cells

Murine as well as human lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells have been reported to have several characteristics of T lymphocytes and to be clearly distinct from natural killer (NK) cells. The present study of murine LAK cells showed that cytotoxic cells generated in the presence of interleukin 2 IL 2 were heterogeneous with respect to cell surface markers of progenitor as well as effector cells. Negative selection of cells with antibodies and complement or positive selection by fluorescence-activated cell sorting unequivocally showed that LAK effector cells consisted of at least two clearly distinct populations, the relative contribution of which was dependent on donor organ and target cells studied. Approximately 40% of the cytotoxic activity of spleen-derived effector cells active against the NK-resistant targets EL-4 or MCA-5 was eliminated by treatment with antibodies to the NK-markers asialo-GM1 and NK 1 (NK-LAK). Approximately 60% of cytotoxic activity was associated with cells expressing the T cell marker Lyt-2, lacked NK 1, and was lacking or expressed only small amounts asialo-GM1 (T-LAK). The NK-LAK cells were of greater importance for the cytotoxic activity against the standard NK target YAC-1, although T-LAK cells also excerted significant cytotoxicity against this cell line. Limiting dilution analysis estimated that the minimal frequency of precursors developing into cells with cytotoxic activity against EL-4 was 1/6700 in spleen and 1/4200 in peripheral blood. The frequency of cells developing into cytotoxic effectors against YAC-1 cells was 1/3700 and 1/1450 in spleen and peripheral blood, respectively. Depletion of progenitor cells from spleen or peripheral blood expressing NK 1 or Lyt-2 by treating the cells with antibodies to these structures and complement indicated that NK-1-expressing cells were the dominating progenitor of the LAK cells irrespective of target cells used. Culture of murine lymphoid cells from spleen or peripheral blood with high concentrations of IL 2 results in the emergence of two different killer cell populations with phenotypic similarities to NK and T cells, respectively, both being able to kill targets resistant to resting NK cells. In contrast to numerous earlier reports, we concluded that LAK cells are heterogeneous with respect to surface markers, with a major population of LAK cells apparently representing IL 2-activated cells expressing cell surface markers associated with NK cells.     

Natural killer (NK) cells as a responder to interleukin 2 (IL 2). II. IL 2-induced interferon gamma production

In the accompanying paper, we showed that natural killer (NK) cells were a major population in the naive spleens of normal mice that responded directly to a T cell growth factor, interleukin 2 (IL 2), and clonally replicated without other stimulating agents. The cloned cells growing in IL 2 showed a potent NK activity against several NK targets without addition of an NK-activating agent, interferon (IFN). In the present study, therefore, we examined whether these cloned NK cells on their own produced IFN. It was found that all NK clones growing in IL 2 produced IFN in the culture fluids. The titers of IFN produced in the IL 2-containing media correlated well with the number of growing cells. With the culture in the absence of IL 2, neither cell growth nor IFN production could be detected. Addition of Con A into the culture in the IL 2-free media showed no IFN production. The antiserum neutralizing IFN alpha and IFN beta failed to significantly neutralize IFN produced by NK clones. Treatment with either a pH of 2.0 or antiserum neutralizing mouse IFN gamma resulted in a marked reduction of IL 2-induced NK IFN, indicating that a major part of IFN produced was IFN gamma. These results indicate that IL 2 stimulates NK clones to proliferate, accompanied by IFN gamma production. The results also show that an NK clone, when stimulated with Sendai virus, produced a type 1 IFN (IFN alpha and/or IFN beta), suggesting that murine NK cells can produce both type 1 (alpha and/or beta) and type 2 (gamma) IFN, depending on inducers.     

Interferon-beta and recombinant IL 2 can both enhance, but by different pathways, the nonspecific cytolytic potential of T3- natural killer cell-derived clones rather than that of T3+ clones

We studied the enhancement of cytolytic activity of T3- natural killer cell-derived clones, of T3+ T cell activated killer (AK) clones, and of fresh peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) by various crude and recombinant interferon (r-IFN) as well as IL 2 preparations. It was found that IFN-beta had the highest cytotoxicity inducing potency as compared to crude or r-IFN-alpha or -gamma preparations. This enhancement was blocked by anti-IFN-beta antibodies but not by anti-IFN-gamma antibodies. IL 2 also strongly enhances cytolytic activity in cloned T3- killer cells that express the IL 2 receptors as determined with the anti-Tac monoclonal antibody (MAb) at concentrations of IL 2 (25 U/ml) which induced one-half of the maximal proliferation capacity in human T cells and murine CTLL cells. For enhancement of cytolytic activity in fresh NK cells, a much higher concentration of IL 2 is required. In addition, the enhancement of cytolytic activity by r-IL 2 but not that by IFN-beta can be reduced by anti-Tac MAb, suggesting that the IL 2 receptor is involved in the enhancement by IL 2, but not by IFN. Both IFN-beta and IL 2 were able to enhance (over threefold) the cytolytic activity of T3- cloned killer cells against a variety of tumor target cell types. Another remarkable observation was that K562 cells, the most commonly used target cell for determining NK cell cytolytic activity, are not the most suitable targets to assess enhancement of nonspecific lytic activity as compared to Daudi or lung tumor-derived cell lines. No enhancement of anti-body-dependent cellular cytotoxicity was observed. Finally, the effects of these biological response modifiers were much more pronounced on "fresh" and cloned T3- natural killer cell-derived than on T3+-activated killer mature T cell-derived clones.     

A murine thymocyte clone expressing gamma delta T cell receptor mediates natural killer-like cytolytic function and TH1-like lymphokine production

The murine CD4- CD8- (double negative, DN) thymocyte cell line and clones expressing T cell receptor gamma delta chains in association with CD3 complex have been established and characterized. This line and a representative clone (DN7.12.11) which appear to derive from the minor population of CD3+ DN thymocytes can be stimulated to proliferate and to produce lymphokines by anti-CD3 or anti-Thy-1 antibodies or calcium ionophore plus phorbol ester. Autocrine proliferation is dependent on binding of interleukin (IL)2 to functional IL2 receptor. Upon stimulation, these cells produce IL2 and IFN-gamma but not IL4, resembling conventional CD4+ TH1 cells in this regard. The cloned line also mediates spontaneous cytolysis against a variety of tumor targets without regard for the presence of conventional major histocompatibility complex molecules on the target cell surface. Blocking and modulation experiments suggest that target recognition by the gamma delta/CD3 complex is not involved in the spontaneous lysis, resembling natural killer (NK) cells. The results suggest that gamma delta +DN T cells are able to have mature functions such as NK-like cytotoxicity and lymphokine secretion as peripheral gamma delta +T cells. They also provide a possible role of gamma delta + DN thymocytes in establishing a intrathymic environment for differentiation and selection of alpha beta-expressing T cells.     

Characteristics of human NK clones: target specificity and phenotype

Clones derived from purified human large granular lymphocytes (LGL) of three different donors were expanded in culture medium supplemented with interleukin 2 (IL 2). Their cytotoxic activity was tested in a 51Cr-release cytotoxicity assay against a panel of three to five NK-susceptible tumor cell lines. Of 196 LGL clones tested, only 44 (22.4%) displayed significant cytotoxic activity. A heterogeneous pattern of reactivity was seen; 26 clones (59%) killed all the targets within the panel tested, whereas 18 clones (41%) had a more restricted specificity. Among these 18 clones, 12 lysed only one target (K562, six clones; ADCC, three clones; Daudi, two clones; MOLT-4, one clone), whereas the other six killed two different targets (ADCC and A1ab, one clone; K562 and MOLT-4, five clones). Clones derived from LGL preselected for positive reactivity with the monoclonal antibodies (MoAb) alpha OKM1, alpha OKT10 and alpha B73.1 also demonstrated either broad or restricted patterns of cytotoxicity. The LGL reactive with MoAb alpha B73.1 gave a high percentage of cytotoxic clones. Phenotype analysis showed that clones could express both antigens associated with T cells (i.e., OKT3, OKT4, and OKT8) and antigens shared by LGL (i.e., OKM1, OKT10, and B73.1). The pattern of surface markers varied considerably among the clones; however, no clear correlation between the pattern of antigenic phenotype and cytotoxic activity was seen. These data show that clones derives from purified preparations of LGL present different functional and antigenic characteristics, and support the hypothesis that the heterogeneity of the entire NK population is attributable, at least in part, to a mixture of clones that vary substantially in their target specificities and phenotypes.     

The partial isolation of subcellular MHC products which are recognized by alloimmune T lymphocytes

H-2 antigens from three murine tumor-cell lines (YAC, EL-4 and P815) were solubilized with triton X-100 and separated by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Proteins were eluted from gel slices and assayed for inhibition by a target-effector binding (TBC) assay. Fractions inhibiting alloimmune T cells also contained serologically detectable H-2 molecules as judged by a complement-dependent microcytotoxicity-inhibition assay. Fractions containing Moloney cell-surface antigen (MCSA), gp 71, or p30 did not inhibit alloimmune TBC. H-2 antigens were selective for T cells since they failed to inhibit binding of natural killer (NK) cells to NK-sensitive targets, whereas, in the reciprocal experiment, the NK target antigens inhibited NK cells but not alloimmune T cell binding to intact targets. Cross inhibition tests in the T-cell system revealed that the H-2 molecules maintained their specific antigenic structure. These observations suggest that it will be possible to characterize further those parts of the subcellular H-2 preparations reacting with distinct killer T-cell clones.     

The partial isolation of subcellular MHC products which are recognized by alloimmune T lymphocytes

H-2 antigens from three murine tumor-cell lines (YAC, EL-4 and P815) were solubilized with triton X-100 and separated by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Proteins were eluted from gel slices and assayed for inhibition by a target-effector binding (TBC) assay. Fractions inhibiting alloimmune T cells also contained serologically detectable H-2 molecules as judged by a complement-dependent microcytotoxicity-inhibition assay. Fractions containing Moloney cell-surface antigen (MCSA), gp 71, or p30 did not inhibit alloimmune TBC. H-2 antigens were selective for T cells since they failed to inhibit binding of natural killer (NK) cells to NK-sensitive targets, whereas, in the reciprocal experiment, the NK target antigens inhibited NK cells but not alloimmune T cell binding to intact targets. Cross inhibition tests in the T-cell system revealed that the H-2 molecules maintained their specific antigenic structure. These observations suggest that it will be possible to characterize further those parts of the subcellular H-2 preparations reacting with distinct killer T-cell clones.     

Properties and characterization of a rat spleen cell-derived factor that induces resistance to natural killer cell lysis in YAC lymphoma cells

Supernatants of Con A-stimulated rat spleen cell cultures contain a factor that induces relative resistance to NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity in the YAC cell line, a line that is otherwise highly susceptible to murine NK cell-mediated lysis. This NK-lysis resistance-inducing factor (LRIF) has a Mr of 12,600 Da, as determined by gel filtration chromatography, and an isoelectric pH of 4.8. NK-LRIF is heat labile and is de-activated by treatment with proteolytic enzymes. Unlike immune-IFN (IFN-gamma), NK-LRIF is not inactivated by pH 2 treatment, and antibodies capable of neutralizing IFN-alpha and IFN-gamma do not abrogate the effect of NK-LRIF. Highly purified IL-2 preparations lack NK-LRIF activity. NK-LRIF does not induce a general resistance to lysis in YAC cells, because control and NK-LRIF-treated YAC cells were equally susceptible to alloimmune cytotoxic T cells. YAC cells treated with NK-LRIF showed a marked enhancement (5- to 10-fold) in the expression of class I MHC Ag. This observation supports the proposition that the NK susceptibility of target cells could be inversely related to the expression of class I MHC Ag.     

Interleukin 3 enhanced interleukin 2-dependent maturation of NK progenitor cells in bone marrow from mice with severe combined immunodeficiency

Human recombinant interleukin 2 (IL 2) and highly purified murine interleukin 3 (IL 3) were tested for their ability to generate NK activity in bone marrow cells from mice with severe combined immunodeficiency. IL 2 alone could dose dependently induce NK activity in marrow cells as determined by cytotoxicity against YAC-1 target cells. It was demonstrated that IL 3 had dual effects on the generation of NK activity in this culture system. The addition of IL 3 resulted in inhibition of NK cell activity seen at high concentrations of IL 2. In contrast, when IL 3 was added together with low concentrations of IL 2, the generation of NK cells as judged by cytotoxicity assay as well as the appearance of cells with NK phenotypes was markedly augmented. In some experiments, mice were treated with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) to eliminate relatively differentiated NK precursors from bone marrow cells. It was noted that the residual immature marrow cells from 5-FU-treated mice showed little NK activity even after the culture with high concentrations of IL 2. Importantly, IL 3 could induce the generation of NK activity from 5-FU-treated marrow cells in the presence of IL 2. Kinetic studies indicated that NK activity was appreciably generated from 5-FU-treated marrow cells when preincubated with IL 3 at least for 12 hr and subsequently cultured with IL 2. The cells bearing IL 2 receptors appeared in 5-FU-treated marrow cells, even though cultured only with IL 3, which implied that IL 3 could support the development of very primitive NK cells from IL 2-unresponsive to IL 2-responsive states. These results suggested that IL 3 might play a crucial role for the IL 2-induced generation of NK cells in bone marrow through promoting the expression of IL 2R on NK progenitor cells.     

Enhanced lysis of herpes simplex virus type 1-infected mouse cell lines by NC and NK effectors

Spontaneously cytotoxic murine lymphocytes lysed certain cell types infected by herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) better than uninfected cells. The levels of virus-directed lysis varied widely from target to target, and we found that differences in virus-directed lytic efficiency could be attributed both to the characteristics of HSV-1 replication in the different targets and to the subgroup of natural effector cells which mediated lysis. Although HSV-1 adsorbed to the surface of all the target cells, those in which the virus replicated more efficiently were lysed to a greater extent. As targets, we used cell lines that, when uninfected, were spontaneously lysed by NK cells (YAC-1) or by NC cells (WEHI-164). We also used a fibroblastoid cell line (M50) and a monocytic tumor line (PU51R), which were not spontaneously killed. Using complement-mediated elimination of Qa-5-positive or asialo-GM1-positive NK cells to distinguish NK from NC activity, we found that NK cells lysed HSV-1-infected YAC cells better than uninfected cells, and an NC-like activity selectively lysed HSV-1-infected WEHI cells. In addition, we showed that both NK and NC cytotoxicities contributed to the lysis against the HSV-1-infected fibroblastoid line, M50, but the infected PU51R cells were killed by only NK effectors. These findings were consistent with the results of experiments performed to define the role of interferon in induction of virus-augmented cytolysis. Increased lysis of YAC-HSV and PU51R-HSV was entirely due to interferon activation and was completely abolished by performing the 51Cr-release assay in the presence of anti-interferon serum. Because NC activity was not augmented by interferon, virus-enhanced NC lysis of M50-HSV and WEHI-HSV was not due to this nonspecific mechanism. Together, our data show that HSV-1 infection of NK/NC targets induces increased cytotoxicity, but the effector cell responsible for lysis is determined by the uninfected target, or by an interaction between the virus and target cell, rather than by a viral determinant alone.     

NK-like cytotoxicity of allospecific gamma delta TCR+ T cell clones]

We recently generated a series of human alloantigen-specific, CD3+, gamma delta- TCR+ clones by stimulating CD3+, CD4-, CD8- T cells from normal individuals with allogeneic lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL). These clones display cytotoxic activity against their specific stimulators but not against irrelevant LCL. Most but not all of these clones express the NK cell associated marker, CD57, and kill NK-sensitive targets such as the K562 and Molt 4 lines, but not NK-resistant line, Raji. Gamma delta clones which lacked expression of CD57 had no detectable NK activity. The allospecific cytotoxicity of CD57+ and CD57- clones was inhibited by mAb to CD3 or the TCR delta- chain. In contrast, the NK-like activity of the CD57+ clones was enhanced by these antibodies over a wide range of antibody concentration. An HLA class I framework-specific mAb had no effect on NK-like cytolysis but did inhibit allospecific killing, suggesting that the target structures on the surface of allospecific and NK-sensitive cells are distinct. The receptors utilized by the gamma delta- TCR+ clones to recognize NK-sensitive and allospecific targets are also distinct, since killing of NK-sensitive targets was blocked by the presence of cold (unlabeled) NK-sensitive cells but not by cold allospecific targets, whereas allospecific cytolysis was inhibited by cold allospecific targets but not by NK-sensitive cells. We conclude that some CD3+, TCR- gamma delta+ clones exhibit NK-like as well as allospecific killing and that these two activities are mediated by distinct receptor-ligand interactions.     

Generation of cytotoxic cells from murine bone marrow by human recombinant IL 2

Murine bone marrow (BM) cells were cultured in recombinant IL 2 (rIL 2) and interferon-alpha, -beta, and -gamma, and cytotoxic activity against YAC cells was determined in a 4-hr 51Cr-release assay. rIL 2 at 20 U/ml was the only lymphokine that consistently induced significant cytotoxic activity within 3 days of culture, peaking around 5 to 7 days. The cytotoxic cells generated are heterogeneous, consisting of at least two populations of cells: a) NK-1+, Qa-5+, AsGm-1+ Thy-1+/-, Lyt-2- cells, similar to natural killer (NK) cells, and b) NK-1-, Qa-5+, AsGm-1+ Thy-1+, Lyt-2+ cells, similar to cytotoxic T lymphocytes. The precursor/accessory cells of these BM cytolytic cells maintained in 20 U/ml of rIL 2 were Qa-2+, Qa-5+, Thy-1+/-, AsGM-1+/-, and NK-1+/- but Lyt-2-. They also lysed NK-resistant targets, P815 and BW5147, and the antigenic phenotypes of these cells were similar to those that lysed YAC cells. These studies indicate that IL 2 alone is adequate to generate cytotoxic activity from BM and that these cytotoxic cells were similar to splenic NK cells.     

Natural killer (NK)-like cytotoxic activity of allospecific T cell receptor-gamma,delta+ T cell clones. Distinct receptor-ligand interactions mediate NK-like and allospecific cytotoxicity

We recently generated a series of human alloantigen-specific, CD3+,TCR-gamma,delta+ clones by stimulating CD3+,CD4-,CD8- T cells from normal individuals with allogeneic lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL). As reported previously, these clones display cytotoxic activity against their specific stimulators but not against irrelevant LCL. Further studies of these and other TCR-gamma,delta+ clones, described in this report, indicate that most but not all of these clones express the NK cell associated marker, NKH-1 or Leu-19, and kill NK-sensitive targets such as the K562 and Molt 4 lines, but not an irrelevant LCL or NK-resistant line, Raji. TCR-gamma,delta+ clones which lacked expression of Leu-19 lysed their allospecific targets but had no detectable NK activity. The allospecific cytotoxicity of Leu-19+ and Leu-19- clones was inhibited by mAb to CD3 or the TCR delta-chain. In contrast, the NK-like activity of the Leu-19+ clones was enhanced by these antibodies over a wide range of antibody concentration. Although mAb to LFA-1 markedly inhibited both the allospecific and NK-like activity of these clones, an HLA class I framework specific mAb (W6/32) had no effect on NK-like cytolysis but did inhibit allospecific killing, suggesting that the target structures on the surface of allospecific and NK-sensitive cells are distinct. The receptors utilized by the TCR-gamma,delta+ clones to recognize NK-sensitive and allospecific targets are also distinct, since killing of NK-sensitive targets was blocked by the presence of cold (unlabeled) NK-sensitive cells but not by cold allospecific targets, whereas allospecific cytolysis was inhibited by cold allospecific targets but not by NK-sensitive cells. We conclude that some CD3+,TCR-gamma,delta+ clones exhibit NK-like as well as allospecific killing and that these two activities are mediated by distinct receptor-ligand interactions.     

Enhanced lytic susceptibility of Ha-ras transformants after oncogene induction is specific to activated NK cells

C3H 10T1/2 mouse fibroblasts were transfected with a plasmid vector composed of EJ, the mutated c-Ha-ras, and a metallothionein promotor that induced amplified ras expression when activated by culture in the presence of zinc. Experiments were conducted to compare the effect of induction on killing by activated natural killer (NK) cells, cytotoxic T lymphocytes, activated macrophages, and antibody plus complement. The only effector that recognized increased ras expression and exhibited high-inducible cytolysis was an activated NK cell. The effectors from spleen were poly I.C. boostable, Lyt-1.1 negative, NK 1.2 positive, and asialo GM1 positive. Spleen cells from T cell-deficient nude mice, but not NK-deficient beige mice, exhibited high levels of killing activity, and experiments with NK cell clones demonstrated that these lines were also highly cytolytic and killed Ha-ras transfectants in parallel to YAC. Transfection of the same fibroblast line with c-myc did not alter the level of activated NK sensitivity. Cold target competition experiments revealed that Ha-ras-transfected and non-transfected 10T1/2 fibroblasts competed equally for lysis of either YAC or Ha-ras transfectants. Rat-1 fibroblasts did not compete, but gained this capacity when transformed with the v-Ki-ras oncogene but not v-fps. These data suggest that Ha-ras acts in target cells at a post-binding step, whereas Ki-ras may affect expression of target-effector binding structures. The findings that activated NK cell lysis may be specifically influenced by ras expression support a role for NK cells in host surveillance against early neoplastic changes.     

Propagation of mouse cytotoxic clones with characteristics of natural killer (NK) cells

Splenocytes obtained from normal mice (BALB/c nude, BALB/c, C₃H, C57Bl/6) and from mice bearing lung or pulmonary carcinomas were propagated for 1–12 months in the presence of crude or mitogen-depleted T-cell growth factor (TCGF). Clones from several TCGF-propagated lymphoid cell lines were established by limiting dilution or the soft agar techniques. All the cultured lines and the majority of the clonal populations derived from them exhibited strong cytotoxic activity in vitro (⁵¹Cr release assay) toward a variety of syngeneic and allogeneic tumor target cells, both freshly obtained and passaged in culture, and both lymphoid and solid in origin, and including targets usually resistant to fresh NK cells. Considerable cytotoxic activity was also observed with several rat and human cultured tumor lines. Only low cytotoxic activity was detected against normal lymphoid mouse cells. Cloned populations generally exhibited more restricted target cytotoxicity than the parental cultured lines, and the pattern of reactivity varied among the clones. Of the clones tested for surface markers, all were positive for Thy 1.2, T200, and asialo GM1 and had strong binding to peanut agglutinin (PNA), all had undetectable receptors for IgG or IgM, and some were positive for Lyt 2. The cytotoxic activity was augmented by pretreatment of the effector cells with interferon and inhibited by the presence of mannose or galactose during the assay. Several clones were capable of mediating antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity and lectin-induced cellular cytotoxicity (LICC), and produced relatively large quantities of interferon and lymphotoxinlike material. The findings indicated continuous culturing in TCGF of previously antigen-nonstimulated mouse lymphocytes selects for the growth of at least two distinct populations with activated NK activity, one reacting preferentially with lymphoid tumor target cells (designated CNK-L), and the second reacting effectively with both lymphoid and solid tumor targets (designated CNK-SL). Both populations have several features of both T lymphocytes and NK cells.     

Characteristics of the killing mechanism of human natural killer cells against hepatocellular carcinoma cell lines HepG2 and Hep3B

Purpose Unlike normal hepatocytes, most hepatocellular carcinomas (HCCs) are quite resistant to death receptor-mediated apoptosis when the cell surface death receptor is cross linked with either agonistic antibodies or soluble death ligand proteins in vitro. The resistance might play an essential role in the escape from the host immune surveillance; however, it has not been directly demonstrated that HCCs are actually resistant to natural killer (NK) cell-mediated death. Therefore, this study investigated the molecular mechanism of NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity against the HCCs, HepG2, and Hep3B, using two distinct cytotoxic assays: a 4-h ⁵¹Cr-release assay and a 2-h [³H] thymidine release assay which selectively measures the extent of necrotic and apoptotic target cell death, respectively.Methods Most of the target cells exhibited marked morphologic changes when they were co-incubated with the NK cells, and the NK cytotoxicity against these HCCs was comparable to that against K562, a NK-sensitive leukemia cell line, when the cytotoxicity was assessed by a 4-h ⁵¹Cr release assay.Results The NK cells also induced significant apoptotic cell death in the Hep3B targets, but not in the HepG2 targets, when the cytotoxicity was assessed by a 2-h [³H]-thymidine release assay. In agreement with these results, procaspase-3 was activated in the Hep3B targets, but not in the HepG2 targets. Interestingly, mildly fixed NK cells had no detectable activity in the 4-h ⁵¹Cr release assay against both HepG2 and Hep3B targets, while they were similarly effective as the untreated NK cells in the 2-h [³H]-thymidine release assay, suggesting that the level of apoptotic cell death of the Hep3B targets is granule independent and might be primarily mediated by the death ligands of the NK cells.Conclusion This study found that a tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL)/TRAIL receptor interaction is involved in the NK cell-mediated apoptotic death of the Hep3B targets, but a Fas/Fas ligand (FasL) interaction is not.     

Interleukin 2 dependence of human natural killer (NK) cell activity

When purified populations of human natural killer (NK) cells were tested for cytotoxic activity in the presence of partially purified preparations of human interleukin 2 (IL 2), a definite, dose-dependent linear increase in reactivity was observed. To determine whether such augmentation by IL 2 might reflect an important aspect of the physiologic regulation of NK activity, we examined the effects of monoclonal antibodies against human IL 2 on spontaneous NK activity. The presence of such antibodies during the 4-hr cytotoxicity assay resulted in significant inhibition of NK activity, and when the NK cells were pretreated for 16 to 20 hr with anti-IL 2, little or no activity remained. These data suggest that the spontaneous cytotoxic activity of NK cells is dependent on their continued exposure to IL 2. The reduction in NK activity resulting from treatment with anti-IL 2 could be at least partially restored by exposure to only low amounts of partially purified IL 2. These data have provided the basis for formulating a novel model of NK cell activation.