Hydrogen exchange methods to study protein folding

The measurement of amino acid-resolved hydrogen exchange (HX) has provided the most detailed information so far available on the structure and properties of protein folding intermediates. Direct HX measurements can define the structure of tenuous molten globule forms that are generally inaccessible to the usual crystallographic and NMR methods (C. Redfield review in this issue). HX pulse labeling methods can specify the structure, stability and kinetics of folding intermediates that exist for less than 1 s during kinetic folding. Native state HX methods can detect and characterize folding intermediates that exist as infinitesimally populated high energy excited state forms under native conditions. The results obtained in these ways suggest principles that appear to explain the properties of partially folded intermediates and how they are organized into folding pathways. The application of these methods is detailed here.     

Hydrogen exchange in thermally denatured ribonuclease A

Hydrogen exchange has been used to test for the presence of nonrandom structure in thermally denatured ribonuclease A (RNase A). Quenched-flow methods and 2D 1H NMR spectroscopy were used to measure exchange rates for 36 backbone amide protons (NHs) at 65 degrees C and at pH* (uncorrected pH measured in D2O) values ranging from 1.5 to 3.8. The results show that exchange is approximately that predicted for a disordered polypeptide [Molday, R. S., Englander, S. W., & Kallen, R. G. (1972) Biochemistry 11, 150-158]; we thus are unable to detect any stable hydrogen-bonded structure in thermally denatured RNase A. Two observations suggest, however, that the predicted rates should be viewed with some caution. First, we discovered that one of the approximations made by Molday et al. (1972), that exchange for valine NHs is similar to that for alanine NHs, had to be modified; the exchange rates for valine NHs are about 4-fold slower. Second, the pH minima for exchange tend to fall at lower pH values than predicted, by as much as 0.45 pH units. These results are in accord with those of Roder and co-workers for bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor [see Table I in Roder, H., Wagner, G., & Wüthrich, K. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 7407-7411]. The origin of the disagreement between predicted and observed pH minima is unknown but may be the high net positive charge on these proteins at low pH. In common with some other thermally unfolded proteins, heat-denatured ribonuclease A shows a significant circular dichroism spectrum in the far-ultraviolet region [Labhardt, A. M. (1982) J. Mol. Biol. 157, 331-355].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Hydrogen exchange and the dynamic structure of proteins

Summary In native proteins, buried, labile protons undergo isotope exchange with solvent hydrogens, but the kinetics of exchange are markedly slower than in unfolded polypeptides. This indicates that, whereas buried protein atoms are shielded from solvent, the protein fluctuates around the time average structure and occasionally exposes buried sites to solvent. Generally, hydrogen exchange studies are designed to characterize the nature of the fluctuations between conformational substates, to monitor the shift in conformational equilibria among protein substates due to ligand binding or other factors, or to monitor the major cooperative denaturation transition. In this article, we review the recent reports of hydrogen exchange in proteins, focusing on recent advances in methodology, especially with regard to the implications of the results for the mechanism of hydrogen exchange in folded proteins.     

Hydrogen exchange in Pseudomonas cytochrome c-551.

Hydrogen exchange rates were measured or estimated for 75 amide protons in in ferrocytochrome c-551 from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (82 residues total) at neutral pH and 300 K. Rate constants span at least eight orders of magnitude. Rate constants or limiting estimates were determined by a combination of methods relying upon 1H-NMR spectroscopy, including the direct observation in one- or two-dimensional spectra of the decrease in proton intensity for samples dissolved in deuterium oxide, or, in a few favorable cases, saturation transfer from the solvent protic water. The heme ligand residues and the thioether bridge residues were slowly exchanging backbone amides, but the slowest exchanging backbone amides were found in two clusters. One was composed of Ile-48 and Lys-49 in the last turn of what is termed the 40's helix in the protein. The second was composed of Leu-74, Ala-75, Lys-76 and Val-78 in the C-terminal alpha helix.     

Hydrogen exchange of disordered proteins in Escherichia coli

A truly disordered protein lacks a stable fold and its backbone amide protons exchange with solvent at rates predicted from studies of unstructured peptides. We have measured the exchange rates of two model disordered proteins, FlgM and α-synuclein, in buffer and in Escherichia coli using the NMR experiment, SOLEXSY. The rates are similar in buffer and cells and are close to the rates predicted from data on small, unstructured peptides. This result indicates that true disorder can persist inside the crowded cellular interior and that weak interactions between proteins and macromolecules in cells do not necessarily affect intrinsic rates of exchange.     

Hydrogen exchange study of some polynucleotides and transfer RNA

The apparent disagreement between published transfer RNA hydrogen exchange results and the tRNA cloverleaf model, prompted a re-investigation of the relationship between hydrogen exchange data and nucleic acid structure. Hydrogen-tritium exchange experiments were carried out with samples of pure and mixed tRNA and with the synthetic polynucleotide bihelices: poly(rA) · poly(rU), poly(rI) · poly(rC), poly(rG) · poly(rC) and poly(dG) · poly (dC).     

Hydrogen exchange in native and alcohol forms of ubiquitin.

Ubiquitin adopts a non-native folded structure in 60% methanol solution at low pH. Two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (2D NMR) was used to measure the hydrogen-exchange rates of backbone amide protons of ubiquitin in both native and methanol forms, and to characterize the structure of ubiquitin in the methanol state. Protection factors (the ratios of experimentally determined exchange rates to the rates calculated for an unfolded polypeptide) for protons in the native form of ubiquitin range from less than 10 to greater than 10(5). Most of the protons that are protected from exchange are located in regions of hydrogen-bonded secondary structure. The most strongly protected backbone amide protons are those of residues comprising the hydrophobic core. Hydrogen exchange from ubiquitin in methanol solution was too rapid to measure directly by 2D NMR, so a labeling scheme was employed, in which exchange with solvent occurred while the protein was in methanol solution. Exchange was quenched by dilution with aqueous buffer after the desired labeling time, and proton occupancies were measured by 1H NMR of the native form of the protein. Protection factors for protons in the methanol form of ubiquitin range from 2.6 to 42, with all protected protons located in hydrogen-bonded structure in the native form. Again, the most strongly protected protons are those of residues in the hydrophobic core. Comparison of the patterns of the hydrogen-exchange rates in the native and methanol forms indicates that almost all of the native secondary structure persists in the methanol form, but that it is almost uniformly destabilized by 4-6 kcal/mol.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Hydrogen exchange demonstrates three domains in aldolase unfold sequentially.

Rabbit muscle aldolase is a homotetramer in which the subunits have a classical alpha/beta-barrel structure and Mr 39,212 Da. We have previously reported that aldolase incubated in 3 M urea has three unfolding domains distinguished by their different unfolding rates. The unfolding rates of these domains were determined from isotope patterns in the mass spectra of peptic fragments derived from aldolase incubated in 3 M urea and pulse labeled in (2)H2O. The present study extends this investigation to more thoroughly characterize the structures of these unfolding intermediates. Mass spectra of intact monomers had four envelopes of isotope peaks corresponding to four structural forms of aldolase. Analysis of the present results suggests that these structural forms consist of native aldolase and three forms that have one to three domains unfolded. The molecular masses of these four structural forms indicate that there are 107 residues in each of the three unfolding domains of aldolase. Present results also show that aldolase remains a tetramer in 4 M urea, even though hydrogen exchange and circular dichroism indicate that it has lost most of its secondary and tertiary structure. The abundances of unfolded domains, which were determined from mass spectra of either intact aldolase or its peptic fragments, were used to determine the abundances of specific, partially unfolded forms of aldolase. Kinetic modeling of the abundances of these structures suggests that these structures are formed sequentially as aldolase unfolds in urea.     

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange studies of native rabbit MM-CK dynamics

Creatine kinase (CK) isoenzymes catalyse the reversible transfer of a phosphoryl group from ATP onto creatine. This reaction plays a very important role in the regulation of intracellular ATP concentrations in excitable tissues. CK isoenzymes are highly resistant to proteases in native conditions. To appreciate localized backbone dynamics, kinetics of amide hydrogen exchange with deuterium was measured by pulse-labeling the dimeric cytosolic muscle CK isoenzyme. Upon exchange, the protein was digested with pepsin, and the deuterium content of the resulting peptides was determined by liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry (MS). The deuteration kinetics of 47 peptides identified by MS/MS and covering 96% of the CK backbone were analyzed. Four deuteration patterns have been recognized: The less deuterated peptides are located in the saddle-shaped core of CK, whereas most of the highly deuterated peptides are close to the surface and located around the entrance to the active site. Their exchange kinetics are discussed by comparison with the known secondary and tertiary structures of CK with the goal to reveal the conformational dynamics of the protein. Some of the observed dynamic motions may be linked to the conformational changes associated with substrate binding and catalytic mechanism.     

Hydrogen exchange kinetics of core peptide protons in Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor

The hydrogen isotope exchange kinetics of the 10 slowest exchanging resonances in the 1H NMR spectrum of Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor (SSI) have been determined at pH 7-11 and 30-60 degrees C. These resonances are assigned to peptide amide protons in the beta-sheet core that comprises the extensive protein-protein interface of the tightly bound SSI dimer. The core protons are atypical in that their exchange rates are orders of magnitude slower than those for all other SSI protons. When they do exchange at temperatures greater than 50 degrees C, they do so as a set and with a very high temperature coefficient. The pH dependence of the exchange rate constants is also atypical. Exchange rates are approximately first order in hydroxyl ion dependence at pH less than 8.5 and greater than 9.5 and pH independent between pH 8.5 and 9.5. The pH dependence and temperature dependence of the SSI proton exchange rates are interpreted by the two-process model [Woodward, C. K., & Hilton, B. D. (1980) Biophys. J. 32, 561-575]. The results suggest that in the average solution structure of SSI, an unusual mobility of secondary structural elements at the protein surface is, in a sense, compensated by an unusual rigidity and inaccessibility of the beta-sheet core at the dimer interface.     

Hydrogen exchange of lysozyme powders. Hydration dependence of internal motions

The rate of exchange of the labile hydrogens of lysozyme was measured by out-exchange of tritium from the protein in solution and from powder samples of varied hydration level, for pH 2, 3, 5, 7, and 10 at 25 degrees C. The dependence of exchange of powder samples on the level of hydration was the same for all pHs. Exchange increased strongly with increased hydration until reaching a rate of exchange that is constant above 0.15 g of H2O/g of protein (120 mol of H2O/mol of protein). This hydration level corresponds to coverage of less than half the protein surface with a monolayer of water. No additional hydrogen exchange was observed for protein powders with higher water content. Considered in conjunction with other lysozyme hydration data [Rupley, J. A., Gratton, E., & Careri, G. (1983) Trends Biochem. Sci. (Pers. Ed.) 8, 18-22], this observation indicates that internal protein dynamics are not strongly coupled to surface properties. The use of powder samples offers control of water activity through regulation of water vapor pressure. The dependence of the exchange rate on water activity was about fourth order. The order was pH independent and was constant from 114 to 8 mol of hydrogen remaining unexchanged/mol of lysozyme. These results indicate that the rate-determining step for protein hydrogen exchange is similar for all backbone amides and involves few water molecules. Powder samples were hydrated either by isopiestic equilibration, with a half-time for hydration of about 1 h, or by addition of solvent to rapidly reach final hydration. Samples hydrated slowly by isopiestic equilibration exhibited more exchange than was observed for samples of the same water content that had been hydrated rapidly by solvent addition. This difference can be explained by salt and pH effects on the nearly dry protein. Such effects would be expected to contribute more strongly during the isopiestic equilibration process. Solution hydrogen exchange measurements made for comparison with the powder measurements are in good agreement with published data. Rank order was proven the same for all pHs by solution pH jump experiments. The effect of ionic strength on hydrogen exchange was examined at pH 2 and pH 5 for protein solutions containing up to 1.0 M added salt. The influence of ionic strength was similar for both pHs and was complex in that the rate increased, but not monotonically, with increased ionic strength.     

Hydrogen exchange in nucleosides and nucleotides. Measurement of hydrogen exchange by stopped-flow and ultraviolet difference spectroscopy.

Time-dependent changes in the ultraviolet absorbance of the adenine chromophore are observed in the stopped-flow spectrophotometer when adenosine and its analogs are rapidly transferred from protium oxide to deuterium oxide. These absorbance changes are shown to result from hydrogen exchange in the exocyclic amino groups of the purine ribonucleosides by using derivatives of adenosine in which methyl groups replace exchangeable hydrogens and by showing that the general characteristics of hydrogen exchange in adenosine analogs agree with those found here. A study of the dependence of hydrogen-exchange rate constants on adenosine, AMP, and phosphate concentration showed there is a second-order dependence on AMP concentration which is primarily due to intermolecular catalysis by the phosphate group of the nucleotide. The deuterium oxide perturbation difference spectrum, obtained at equilibrium, was found to contain two components that result from blue shifts of the adenine chromophore absorbance: (1) a shift cause by the substitution of deuterium for protium in the ring (N1) nitrogen and exocyclic nitrogens, and (2) a shift associated with a change in the polarizability of the medium. Since the theory of solvent perturbation, which is used to measure the relative "exposure" of chromophores in macromolecules, assumes that the spectral shifts observed are solely due to (2) above, the use of deuterium oxide as a measure of chromophore exposure to perturbants the size of water must be reexamined.     

Hydrogen exchange kinetics of RNase A and the urea:TMAO paradigm

A key paradigm in the biology of adaptation holds that urea affects protein function by increasing the fluctuations of the native state, while trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) affects function in the opposite direction by decreasing the normal fluctuations of the native ensemble. Using urea and TMAO separately and together, hydrogen exchange (HX) studies on RNase A at pH* 6.35 were used to investigate the basic tenets of the urea:TMAO paradigm. TMAO (1 M) alone decreases HX rate constants of a select number of sites exchanging from the native ensemble, and low urea alone increases the rate constants of some of the same sites. Addition of TMAO to urea solutions containing RNase A also suppresses HX rate constants. The data show that urea and TMAO independently or in combination affect the dynamics of the native ensemble in opposing ways. The results provide evidence in support of the counteraction aspect of the urea:TMAO paradigm linking structural dynamics with protein function in urea-rich organs and organisms. RNase A is so resistant to urea denaturation at pH* 6.35 that even in the presence of 4.8 M urea, the native ensemble accounts for >99.5% of the protein. An essential test, devised to determine the HX mechanism of exchangeable protons, shows that over the 0-4.8 M urea concentration range nearly 80% of all observed sites convert from EX2 to EX1. The slow exchange sites are all EX1; they do not exhibit global exchange even at urea concentrations (5.8 M) well into the denaturation transition zone, and their energetically distinct activated complexes leading to exchange gives evidence of residual structure. Under these experimental conditions, the use of DeltaG(HX) as a basis for HX analysis of RNase A urea denaturation is invalid.