Stability of ColE1-like and pBR322-like plasmids in Escherichia coli

The average copy number, the level of ampicillin resistance conferred by one plasmid, and the degree of plasmid multimerization were determined for several ColE1-like and pBR322-like plasmids. From the results obtained, the variance of the units of partition corresponding to each plasmid studied was calculated. Experimentally determined plasmid stability was compared with that calculated using the variance of the units of partition and the ratio between the generation times of plasmid-free and of plasmid-carrying cells, assuming that the units of partition are distributed randomly between daughter cells. Stability of the pBR322-like plasmids present mainly as monomers in the bacterial host was consistent with random partitioning, whereas pBR322-like plasmids, present mainly as dimers, and the ColE1-like plasmid showed greater stability than that predicted with random partitioning at cell division.     

The site-specific deletion in plasmid pBR322

The formation of a deletion derivative of plasmid pBR322, designated pBR322 delta 1, was observed during cloning of various eukaryotic DNAs, when the BamHI site of the plasmid vector was used for construction of the recombinant molecules. The restriction analysis of six independently isolated pBR322 delta 1 plasmids allowed establishment of their complete identity. Similar deletion derivatives were also formed as a result of transformation of Escherichia coli cells by the linear form of vector pBR322 produced by BamHI cleavage, but not by SalI or HindIII. The endpoints of the deletion in one of the pBR322 delta 1 plasmids occurred at positions 375 and 16666 bp from the EcoRI site, as determined by sequence analysis. Formation of pBR322 delta 1 is most probably due to site-specific recombination between the sequence in the 1666-1670 bp region and the BamHI end of the linear pBR322 molecule. THe deletion was not controlled by the recA system of the host bacteria.     

Effects of genes exerting growth inhibition and plasmid stability on plasmid maintenance.

Plasmid stabilization mediated by the parA+ and parB+ genes of the R1 plasmid and the ccd+ and sop+ genes of the F plasmid was tested on a mini-R1 plasmid and a pBR322 plasmid derivative. The mini-R1 plasmid is thought to be unstably inherited owing to a low copy number and to random segregation of the plasmid at cell division, whereas cells harboring the pBR322 derivative used in this work are lost through competition with plasmid-free cells, mainly as a result of the shorter generation time of cells without plasmids. The pBR322 derivative carries a fusion between part of the atp operon of Escherichia coli and the bacteriophage lambda pR promoter, and the cI857 repressor gene. The insertion of sop+ from the F plasmid or parB+ from the R1 plasmid reduced the loss frequency by a factor of 10(3) for the pBR322 derivative and by at least a factor of 10(2) for the mini-R1 plasmid. Insertion of parA+ from the R1 plasmid decreased the loss frequency of the pBR322 derivative by a factor of 10 and that of the mini-R1 plasmid by a factor of 50. When ccd+ from the F plasmid was inserted, the loss frequency of the pBR322 derivative was decreased by a factor of 10, but it had only a marginal effect on the stability of the mini-R1 plasmid. In no case was any significant structural instability of the plasmids observed.     

Maintenance of some ColE1-type plasmids in chemostat culture

Summary When cells carrying the plasmids RP1, pDS4101 (a ColK derivative) or pDS1109 (a ColE1 derivative) were maintained in chemostat culture in the absence of antibiotic selection, plasmid-free segregants were not detected after 120 generations of nutrient-limited growth. By contrast, plasmid-free segregants of pMB9- and pBR322-containing cells arose after approximately 30 generations, irrespective of the host genetic background. However, even though pDS1109 was maintained its copy-number fell five-fold during 80 generations of limited growth. It is suggested that loss of pBR322 occurs following a similar copy-number decrease which results in defective segregation of the plasmid to daughter host cells. This defective segregation was not complemented in trans by either RP1 or pDS4101.     

The presence of the region on pBR322 that encodes resistance to tetracycline is responsible for high levels of plasmid DNA knotting in Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I deletion mutant.

Plasmid pBR322 DNA isolated from Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I deletion mutant DM800 is estimated to contain about 10% of the knotted forms (Shishido et al., 1987). These knotted DNA species were shown to have the same primary structure as usual, unknotted pBR322 DNA. Analysis of the knotting level of deletion, insertion and sequence-rearranged derivatives of pBR322 in DM800 showed that the presence of the region on pBR322 encoding resistance to tetracycline (tet) is required for high levels of plasmid knotting. When the entire tet region is present in a native orientation, the level of knotting is highest. Inactivating the tet promoter is manifested by a middle level of knotting. For deletion derivatives lacking various portions of the tet region, the level of knotting ranges from lowest to high depending on the site and length of the tet gene remaining. Inverting the orientation of tet region on the pBR322 genome results in a middle level of knotting. Deleting the ampicillin-resistance (bla)gene outside of its second promoter does not affect the level of knotting, if the entire tet gene remains. A possible mechanism of regulation of plasmid knotting is discussed.     

Selective retention of recombinant plasmids coding for human insulin

Plasmids may be lost from Escherichia coli K-12 hosts that are cultured without selection for plasmid retention. This is particularly true for chimeric plasmids that incorporate genes for human insulin into vectors derived from pBR322. The cIts857 gene of bacteriophage lambda was inserted into the bla gene of the human-insulin-coding plasmids, pIA7 delta 4 delta 1, pIB7 delta 4 delta 1 and pHI7 delta 4 delta 1, generating the new plasmids pPR17, pPR18 and pPR19, respectively, which produced the thermosensitive lambda repressor. The cI gene was downstream from the pM and pbla promoters, so that it may have been expressed from either or both promoters. Separate E. coli K-12 RV308 host strains containing the new recombinants were lysogenized with the repressor-defective bacteriophage lambda cI90. Loss of the plasmid from the lysogens causes concomitant loss of the lambda repressor and cell death, because the prophage is induced to enter the lytic growth cycle. The system effectively forces retention of the plasmid in all viable cells in the culture.     

Increased transformation ability of Escherichia coli strains carrying the plasmid pLD4

The effect of resident plasmid pLD4, a derivative of plasmid Hly241, on transformability of the host bacteria cells has been studied. Plasmid pLD4 was transferred into the different strains of E. coli subsequently transformed by the DNA of plasmids pBR322, pBR325, pAL-R2, pMB9. The majority of strains harbouring pLD4 obtain the increased ability to be transformed as compared with the ability of isogenic plasmidless strains. The similar but less expressed effect was conferred by the plasmid Hly241. Another hemolytic plasmid Hly195 and its derivatives, carrying the different transposons, as well as plasmid F' tet Hly did not increase the transformability of host bacteria. The optimal parameters for transformation of the strains harbouring pLD4 and plasmidless strains coincide, but the number of competent cells is considerably higher for plasmid containing strains, due to preliminary results.     

New runaway-replication-plasmid cloning vectors and suppression of runaway replication by novobiocin

Two new cloning vectors (pBEU28 and pBEU50) with temperature-controlled runaway-replication properties are described. pBEU28 is similar to aphA+ (KanR) plasmid pBEU2 but lacks a 1.8-kb duplication which is responsible for plasmid instability. pBEU50 is an analog of pBR313 and pBR322 in that it carries bla+(AmpR), which can be used for selection, and tet+(TetR) which can be inactivated by cloning at HindIII and BamHI restriction sites. Sublethal concentrations of novobiocin were exploited to suppress runaway replication and to restore the viability of the plasmid carriers. By this method copB deletion mutants of two temperature-controlled, conditional runaway-replication plasmids were detected and isolated. The unconditional runaway-replication property of these plasmids leads us to hypothesize that there are at least two controls of plasmid R1 copy number and that the copB-dependent control is temperature-sensitive in the conditional runaway replication mutants. The novobiocin suppression of the runaway replication permitted us to clone dnaN+ on pBEU28 and to identify its presence at 42 degrees C with a dnaN59 transformation recipient which was temperature-sensitive due to a defect in the dnaN gene.     

Absolute and relative QPCR quantification of plasmid copy number in Escherichia coli

Real-time QPCR based methods for determination of plasmid copy number in recombinant Escherichia coli cultures are presented. Two compatible methods based on absolute and relative analyses were tested with recombinant E. coli DH5alpha harboring pBR322, which is a common bacterial cloning vector. The separate detection of the plasmid and the host chromosomal DNA was achieved using two separate primer sets, specific for the plasmid beta-lactamase gene (bla) and for the chromosomal d-1-deoxyxylulose 5-phosphate synthase gene (dxs), respectively. Since both bla and dxs are single-copy genes of pBR322 and E. coli chromosomal DNA, respectively, the plasmid copy number can be determined as the copy ratio of bla to dxs. These methods were successfully applied to determine the plasmid copy number of pBR322 of E. coli host cells. The results of the absolute and relative analyses were identical and highly reproducible with coefficient of variation (CV) values of 2.8-3.9% and 4.7-5.4%, respectively. The results corresponded to the previously reported values of pBR322 copy number within E. coli host cells, 15-20. The methods introduced in this study are convenient to perform and cost-effective compared to the traditionally used Southern blot method. The primer sets designed in this study can be used to determine plasmid copy number of any recombinant E. coli with a plasmid vector having bla gene.     

Role of the rom protein in copy number control of plasmid pBR322 at different growth rates in Escherichia coli K-12

The copy number per cell mass of plasmid pBR322 and a rom- derivative was measured as a function of generation time. In fast growing cells the copy number per cell mass was virtually identical for rom+ and rom- derivatives. However, the copy number of pBR322 only increased 3- to 4-fold from a 20- to 80-min generation time, whereas the copy number of the rom- derivative increased 7- to 10-fold. The copy number stayed constant for the rom+ and rom- plasmids at generation times longer than 80-100 min. Thus, the presence of the rom gene decreased the copy number of plasmid pBR322 in slowly growing cells at least 2-fold when compared with the rom- plasmid. To study the effect of the rom gene in trans we cloned the gene into the compatible P15A-derived rom- plasmid pACYC184. In cells carrying both pACYC184 rom+ and pBR322 rom- the presence of the rom gene in trans had little effect on the copy number of pBR322 rom- at fast growth, but it decreased its copy number at slow growth to the same level as found for pBR322, i.e., complemented the pBR322 rom- plasmid. The pACYC184 plasmid and its rom+ derivatives showed copy numbers similar to those of pBR322 rom- and pBR322 itself, respectively, at fast and slow growth. We conclude that the rom gene product-the Rom protein-is an important element in copy number control of ColE1-type plasmids especially in slowly growing cells.     

Incompatibility mutants of IncFII plasmid NR1 and their effect on replication control

DNA from the replication control region of plasmid NR1 or of the Inc- copy mutant pRR12 was cloned into a pBR322 vector plasmid. These pBR322 derivatives were mutagenized in vitro with hydroxylamine and transformed into Escherichia coli cells that harbored either NR1 or pRR12. After selection for the newly introduced pBR322 derivatives only, those cells which retained the unselected resident NR1 or pRR12 plasmids were examined further. By this process, 134 plasmids with Inc- mutations in the cloned NR1 or pRR12 DNA were obtained. These mutants fell into 11 classes. Two of the classes had plasmids with deletions or insertions in the NR1 DNA and were not examined further. Plasmids with apparent point mutations were classified by examining (i) their ability to reconstitute a functional NR1-derived replicon (Rep+ or Rep-), (ii) the copy numbers of the Rep+ reconstituted replicons, (iii) the cross-reactivity of incompatability among the various mutant classes and parental plasmids, and (iv) the trans effects of the mutants on the copy number and stable inheritance of a coresident plasmid.     

Enhanced plasmid maintenance in a CSTR upon square-wave oscillations in the dilution rate

Summary The effects of forced square-wave perturbations in the dilution rate on plasmid maintenance and gene expression of a population ofEscherichia coli K12 strain carrying the vector plasmid pBR322 grown in a chemostat with a non-selective medium were studied. It was observed that in the control experiments, where the dilution rates were kept constant, the percentage of plasmid-containing cells decreased after a period of time. Eventually, the culture was displaced by the plasmid-free cells. However, when the cells were exposed to forced oscillations in the dilution rate, the reactor culture was able to maintain a mixed population of plasmid-free and plasmid-containing cells for a longer period of time. The above observation seems to be independent of the source of the host cells. That is, the same results were obtained when the plasmid-free cells were generated from the culture itself due to defective partitioning of the plasmids or introduced externally.     

Maintenance of pBR322-derived plasmids without functional RNAI

pBR322-derived plasmids that lack the bla gene and 40% of the gene for the replication inhibitor, RNAI, have been constructed. Since the RNAI gene totally overlaps with the gene for the replication primer, RNAII, this primer is similarly defective and also lacks its normal promoter. The primer is presumed to by synthesized either from the counter-tet promoter (plasmid pCL59) or from an inserted lacUV5 promoter (plasmid pCL59-65). Based mainly on the observation that the plasmid Rom protein, which normally assists in the RNAI/RNAII interaction, has no effect on the replication of the RNAI/RNAII-defective plasmids, we suggest that the defective RNAI is not functional while the defective RNAII primer, although less efficient, still allows plasmid replication. The defective plasmids are fully compatible with the intact parent plasmid, indicating that they do not share a common control of replication. In the absence of antibiotics, the bacteria lose the defective plasmid, beginning after 80 generations; under the same conditions, the parent plasmid is retained even after 140 generations. During exponential growth of their host, the number of defective plasmids in a culture increases exponentially with a doubling time either smaller or greater than that of the host cell growth, depending on the growth medium and, in the case of pCL59-65, on the presence or absence of lac inducer IPTG. As a result of these differences in host cell growth and plasmid replication, the plasmids are either gradually diluted out or their copy number continually increases. This shows that, without RNAI, plasmid replication is uncoupled from the host cell growth and not, as usual, adjusted to it. It also implies that the RNAI mechanism is the only means of replication control for ColE1-type plasmids that senses and adjusts the copy number; limiting host factors cannot provide a back-up control to stabilize copy numbers.     

Homologous recombination and mutagenesis of gamma-irradiated plasmid DNA in Escherichia coli host cells

Plasmid DNA was used to study gamma-radiation-induced recombination and mutagenesis in Escherichia coli host cells. Plasmid pBRP1, a derivative of pBR322 containing the lac operon of E. coli, was irradiated with 60Co gamma rays prior to transformation into E. coli strains of different recA and lac genotypes. Plasmid-chromosome recombination was assayed in lacY1 host cells, whereas plasmid mutagenesis was assayed in delta lac host cells lacking chromosomal sequences homologous to the plasmid. Both recombinant and mutant plasmids were identified by the phenotypic changes in lactose utilization, and confirmed by restriction analysis of isolated plasmids. Plasmid-chromosome recombination was induced to high levels (about 20% of survivors at 700 Gy) and was dependent on the host recA gene. Plasmid mutagenesis occurred at lower levels (about 1.5% of survivors at 600 Gy) and was relatively independent of the recA gene. Plasmid survival was unaffected by the presence or absence of host recA mutations or the potential for plasmid-chromosome recombination.     

The use of a partition locus to increase stability of tryptophan-operon-bearing plasmids in Escherichia coli

The stability of different derivatives of plasmid vectors pBR322 and pACYC184 carrying the tryptophan operon of Escherichia coli was monitored in various media. It was found that in the absence of any special selective pressure, all plasmids were lost from the culture. The stability varied depending both on the orientation of the inserted tryptophan fragment and the growth media used. The pBR322::trp+ plasmids were lost at an average frequency of 0.3 to 0.8% per cell generation, while the pACYC184::trp+ plasmid was lost at a rate higher than 5%. In all cases the whole plasmid was lost at a rate higher than 5%. In all cases the whole plasmid was lost, indicating a high stability of the plasmid::cloned DNA as such. To increase the stability of the cloning vectors, the partition locus of plasmid pSC101 was added to both the pBR322::trp+ and pACYC184::trp+ plasmids. The addition of this gene increased the replicon stability at least 3- to 10-fold, with the pBR322::trp+-par+ plasmids being the most stable. Also in this case, the stability was dependent on the plasmid type and on the growth medium. In no case was there a discoordinate loss of the antibiotic-resistance and tryptophan genes from the vectors.     

Large-scale preparation of ribulosebisphosphate carboxylase from a recombinant system in Escherichia coli characterized by extreme plasmid instability

An ampicillin-resistant, RecA- strain of Escherichia coli (HB101) harboring the multicopy pBR322 plasmid containing the structural gene for ribulosebisphosphate carboxylase from Rhodospirillum rubrum was used to prepare large quantities of the carboxylase protein. This recombinant system was characterized by extreme plasmid instability, which resulted in part from the 1.7-fold faster growth rate of plasmid-free cells and in part from very rapid rates of plasmid segregation. The plasmid-containing organisms produced and excreted a large amount of beta-lactamase activity, with the result that ampicillin selection could only be maintained for a very short period of time, after which the plasmid-containing (carboxylase-producing) cells were overgrown by plasmid-free cells. The instability was so severe that even isolated colonies prepared on ampicillin-containing plates were impure and contained plasmid-free cells. Nevertheless, large quantities of carboxylase protein could be obtained from this system by using a highly dilute inoculum which allows selection of ampicillin-resistant (carboxylase-producing) organisms for a sufficient period of time so that the period of growth under nonselective conditions was minimized, and cells harvested at high cell densities contained large amounts of the carboxylase protein. In the present instance, 300-liter fermentations were initiated with a 0.3-microliter inoculum of freshly grown cells. After 20 h of growth in rich medium containing ampicillin, the harvested cells contained 74 g of ribulosebisphosphate carboxylase protein (average of two separate cultures). These results are discussed in terms of the general nature of plasmid instability and protocols available to minimize the effects of such instability.     

Investigation of the effect of growth environment on the stability of low-copy-number plasmids in Escherichia coli

The stability of a low-copy-number plasmid, pHSG415, in Escherichia coli, was investigated in batch and continuous culture. The plasmid was unstable in batch culture, but was significantly stabilized by growth in continuous culture with phosphate, nitrogen or potassium limitation. However, the plasmid was very unstable when grown in continuous culture with sulphate limitation. These results contrast with those obtained with multicopy plasmids such as pBR322, which is particularly unstable in carbon- or phosphate-limited continuous culture. The effect of growth rate on the stability of E. coli(pHSG415) grown in continuous culture with glucose limitation was also investigated. The plasmid was significantly more stable in cells grown at higher growth rates. The segregational instability (R) of the plasmid and the difference in growth rate between plasmid-free and plasmid-bearing cells (dmu) were calculated for each condition using the method of Cooper et al. (accompanying paper: Journal of General Microbiology 133, 1871-1880). It was found that the primary cause of the loss of pHSG415 from the cell population was the segregational instability of the plasmid.