Escherichia coli integration host factor bends the DNA at the ends of IS1 and in an insertion hotspot with multiple IHF binding sites.

The integration host factor of Escherichia coli (IHF) is a small, histone-like protein which participates in the integration of bacteriophage lambda into the E. coli chromosome and in a number of regulatory processes. Our recent footprinting analysis has shown that IHF binds specifically to the ends of the transposable element IS1, as well as to several sites within a short segment of the plasmid pBR322. We have extended our studies of the binding of the IHF molecule to these sites in vitro using a gel retardation assay. We report here that IHF bends the DNA upon binding, as judged from the strong cyclic dependence of the protein-induced mobility shift on the position of the binding site. Using cloned, synthetic ends of IS1 as substrates, we have found that some mutations within the conserved bases of the IHF consensus binding sequence abolish binding, and that alterations of the flanking sequences can greatly reduce IHF binding. The presence of multiple IHF sites on a single DNA fragment increases binding very little, indicating that IHF does not bind cooperatively in this complex. We discuss the possibility that DNA bending is related to the role IHF plays in forming and stabilizing nucleoprotein complexes, and suggest that bending at the IHF sites may be important to its diverse effects in the cell.     

DNA sequence and structure: direct and indirect recognition in protein-DNA binding

MOTIVATION: Direct recognition, or direct readout, of DNA bases by a DNA-binding protein involves amino acids that interact directly with features specific to each base. Experimental evidence also shows that in many cases the protein achieves partial sequence specificity by indirect recognition, i.e., by recognizing structural properties of the DNA. (1) Could threading a DNA sequence onto a crystal structure of bound DNA help explain the indirect recognition component of sequence specificity? (2) Might the resulting pure-structure computational motif manifest itself in familiar sequence-based computational motifs? RESULTS: The starting structure motif was a crystal structure of DNA bound to the integration host factor protein (IHF) of E. coli. IHF is known to exhibit both direct and indirect recognition of its binding sites. (1) Threading DNA sequences onto the crystal structure showed statistically significant partial separation of 60 IHF binding sites from random and intragenic sequences and was positively correlated with binding affinity. (2) The crystal structure was shown to be equivalent to a linear Markov network, and so, to a joint probability distribution over sequences, computable in linear time. It was transformed algorithmically into several common pure-sequence representations, including (a) small sets of short exact strings, (b) weight matrices, (c) consensus regular patterns, (d) multiple sequence alignments, and (e) phylogenetic trees. In all cases the pure-sequence motifs retained statistically significant partial separation of the IHF binding sites from random and intragenic sequences. Most exhibited positive correlation with binding affinity. The multiple alignment showed some conserved columns, and the phylogenetic tree partially mixed low-energy sequences with IHF binding sites but separated high-energy sequences. The conclusion is that deformation energy explains part of indirect recognition, which explains part of IHF sequence-specific binding.     

Specific and nonspecific interactions of integration host factor with oligo DNAs as revealed by circular dichroism spectroscopy and filter binding assay.

Binding specificity of integration host factor (IHF) to oligo DNAs has been studied by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy and filter binding experiment. CD difference spectra of IHF-DNA complexes demonstrated that a conformational change in DNA was induced by binding of IHF when DNA had a consensus sequence for the binding sites of IHF, but that such conformational change was not observed for consensus DNA 20 mer as well as nonconsensus DNA 45 mer. Dissociation constants for IHF-DNA complexes determined by filter binding assay showed that IHF has indeed stronger affinity to DNA with the consensus binding site than to nonconsensus DNA, but the difference in its affinity between consensus and nonconsensus DNAs was rather small, 3.4-fold. It was, therefore, concluded that the flanking regions of the consensus sequence are important for the specific binding of IHF and that its binding specificity is well characterized by the induced conformational change in DNA rather than by dissociation constants for IHF-DNA complexes.     

In vitro interactions of the histone-like protein IHF with the algD promoter, a critical site for control of mucoidy in Pseudomonas aeruginosa.

The ability of the histone-like element Integration Host Factor (IHF) to interact with the algD promoter was investigated. IHF from Escherichia coli was found to bind to the algD promoter and to form multiple protein-DNA complexes in gel mobility shift DNA binding assay. The highest affinity binding site for IHF was mapped by DNaseI footprinting analysis. This site spanned nucleotides -50 to -85 relative to the algD mRNA start site and overlapped a sequence matching the IHF consensus sequence WATCAANNNNTTR in 12 out of 13 base pairs. Previous studies have shown that deletion of sequences including a portion of this site adversely affects algD promoter activity. IHF binding to the algD promoter induced DNA bending. Western blot analysis with antibodies against E. coli IHF detected a cross-reactive protein of a similar molecular mass in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, suggesting the presence of an analogous factor in this organism.     

Determining the DNA sequence elements required for binding integration host factor to two different target sites.

Binding sites for the Escherichia coli protein integration host factor (IHF) include a set of conserved bases that can be summarized by the consensus sequence WATCAANNNNTTR (W is dA or dT, R is dA or dG, and N is any nucleotide). However, additional 5'-proximal bases, whose common feature is a high dA+dT content, are also thought to be required for binding at some sites. We examine the relative contribution of these two sequence elements to IHF binding to the H' and H1 sites in attP of bacteriophage lambda by using the bacteriophage P22-based challenge-phage system. IHF was unable to act as a repressor in the challenge-phage assay at H' sites containing the core consensus element but lacking the dA+dT-rich element. This indicates that both elements are required for IHF to bind to the H' site. In contrast, the core consensus determinant alone is sufficient for IHF binding to the H1 site, which lacks an upstream dA+dT-rich region. Fifty mutants that decreased or eliminated IHF binding to the H1 site were isolated. Sequence analysis showed changes in the bases in the core consensus element only, further indicating that this determinant is sufficient for IHF binding to the H1 site. We found that placement of a dA+dT-rich element upstream of the H1 core consensus element significantly increased the affinity, suggesting that the presence of a dA+dT-rich element enhances IHF binding.     

In Vitro Selection of Integration Host Factor Binding Sites

Integration host factor (IHF) is a bacterial protein that binds and severely bends a specific DNA target. IHF binding sites are approximately 30 to 35 bp long and are apparently divided into two domains. While the 3' domain is conserved, the 5' domain is degenerate but is typically AT rich. As a result of physical constraints that IHF must impose on DNA in order to bind, it is believed that this 5' domain must possess structural characteristics conducive for both binding and bending with little regard for specific contacts between the protein and the DNA. We have examined the sequence requirements of the 5' binding domain of the IHF binding target. Using a SELEX procedure, we randomized and selected variants of a natural IHF site. We then analyzed these variants to determine how the 5' binding domain affects the structure, affinity, and function of an IHF-DNA complex in a native system. Despite finding individual sequences that varied over 100-fold in affinity for IHF, we found no apparent correlation between affinity and function.     

Mapping the transition state for DNA bending by IHF

How DNA-bending proteins recognize their specific sites on DNA remains elusive, particularly for proteins that use indirect readout, which relies on sequence-dependent variations in DNA flexibility/bendability. The question remains as to whether the protein bends the DNA (protein-induced bending) or, alternatively, "prebent" DNA conformations are thermally accessible, which the protein captures to form the specific complex (conformational capture). To distinguish between these mechanisms requires characterization of reaction intermediates and, in particular, snapshots of the transition state along the recognition pathway. We present such a snapshot, from measurements of DNA bending dynamics in complex with Escherichia coli integration host factor (IHF), an architectural protein that bends specific sites on λ-DNA in a U-turn by creating two sharp kinks in DNA. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurements in response to laser temperature-jump perturbation monitor DNA bending. We find that nicks or mismatches that enhance DNA flexibility at the site of the kinks show 3- to 4-fold increase in DNA bending rates that reflect a 4- to 11-fold increase in binding affinities, while sequence modifications away from the kink sites, as well as mutations in IHF designed to destabilize the complex, have negligible effect on DNA bending rates despite >250-fold decrease in binding affinities. These results support the scenario that the bottleneck in the recognition step for IHF is spontaneous kinking of cognate DNA to adopt a partially prebent conformation and point to conformational capture as the underlying mechanism of initial recognition, with additional protein-induced bending occurring after the transition state.     

Searching for and predicting the activity of sites for DNA binding proteins: compilation and analysis of the binding sites for Escherichia coli integration host factor (IHF).

An analysis of the sequence information contained in a compilation of published binding sites for E. coli integration host factor (IHF) was performed. The sequences of twenty-seven IHF sites were aligned; the base occurrences at each position, the information content, and an extended consensus sequence were obtained for the IHF site. The base occurrences at each position of the IHF site were used with a program written for the Apple Macintosh computers in order to determine the similarity scores for published IHF sites. A linear correlation was found to exist between the logarithm of IHF binding and functional data (relative free energies) and similarity scores for two groups of IHF sites. The MacTargsearch program and its potential usefulness in searching for other sites and predicting their relative activities is discussed.     

The P1 plasmid partition complex at parS. The influence of Escherichia coli integration host factor and of substrate topology

The P1 ParB protein is required for active partition and thus stable inheritance of the plasmid prophage. ParB and the Escherichia coli protein integration host factor (IHF) participate in the assembly of a partition complex at the centromere-like site parS. In this report the role of IHF in the formation of the partition complex has been explored. First, ParB protein was purified for these studies, which revealed that ParB forms a dimer in solution. Next, the IHF binding site was mapped to a 29-base pair region within parS, including the sequence TAACTGACTGTTT (which differs from the IHF consensus in two positions). IHF induced a strong bend in the DNA at its binding site. Versions of parS which have lost or damaged the IHF binding site bound ParB with greatly reduced affinity in vitro and in vivo. Measurements of binding constants showed that IHF increased ParB affinity for the wild-type parS site by about 10,000-fold. Finally, DNA supercoiling improved ParB binding in the presence of IHF but not in its absence. These observations led to the proposal that IHF and superhelicity assist ParB by promoting its precise positioning at parS, a spatial arrangement that results in a high affinity of ParB for parS.     

HU and IHF, two homologous histone-like proteins of Escherichia coli, form different protein-DNA complexes with short DNA fragments.

Using the gel retardation technique we have studied the protein-DNA complexes formed between HU--the major histone-like protein of Escherichia coli--and short DNA fragments. We show that several HU heterodimers bind DNA in a regularly spaced fashion with each heterodimer occupying about 9 base pairs. The alpha 2 and beta 2 HU homodimers form the same structure as the alpha beta heterodimer on double stranded DNA. However when compared to the heterodimer, they bind single stranded DNA with higher affinity. We also show that HU and the Integration Host Factor of E. coli (IHF) form different structures with the same DNA fragments. Moreover, HU seems to enhance the DNA-binding capacity of IHF to a DNA fragment which does not contain its consensus sequence.     

DNA deformation energy as an indirect recognition mechanism in protein-DNA interactions

Proteins that bind to specific locations in genomic DNA control many basic cellular functions. Proteins detect their binding sites using both direct and indirect recognition mechanisms. Deformation energy, which models the energy required to bend DNA from its native shape to its shape when bound to a protein, has been shown to be an indirect recognition mechanism for one particular protein, integration host factor (IHF). This work extends the analysis of deformation to two other DNA-binding proteins, CRP and SRF, and two endonucleases, I-Crel and I-Ppol. Known binding sites for all five proteins showed statistically significant differences in mean deformation energy as compared to random sequences. Binding sites for the three DNA-binding proteins and one of the endonucleases had mean deformation energies lower than random sequences. Binding sites for I-Ppol had mean deformation energy higher than random sequences. Classifiers that were trained using the deformation energy at each base pair step showed good cross-validated accuracy when classifying unseen sequences as binders or nonbinders. These results support DNA deformation energy as an indirect recognition mechanism across a wider range of DNA-binding proteins. Deformation energy may also have a predictive capacity for the underlying catalytic mechanism of DNA-binding enzymes     

Pressure dissociation of integration host factor-DNA complexes reveals flexibility-dependent structural variation at the protein-DNA interface

E. coli Integration host factor (IHF) condenses the bacterial nucleoid by wrapping DNA. Previously, we showed that DNA flexibility compensates for structural characteristics of the four consensus recognition elements associated with specific binding (Aeling et al., J. Biol. Chem. 281, 39236–39248, 2006). If elements are missing, high-affinity binding occurs only if DNA deformation energy is low. In contrast, if all elements are present, net binding energy is unaffected by deformation energy. We tested two hypotheses for this observation: in complexes containing all elements, (1) stiff DNA sequences are less bent upon binding IHF than flexible ones; or (2) DNA sequences with differing flexibility have interactions with IHF that compensate for unfavorable deformation energy. Time-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) shows that global topologies are indistinguishable for three complexes with oligonucleotides of different flexibility. However, pressure perturbation shows that the volume change upon binding is smaller with increasing flexibility. We interpret these results in the context of Record and coworker's model for IHF binding (J. Mol. Biol. 310, 379–401, 2001). We propose that the volume changes reflect differences in hydration that arise from structural variation at IHF–DNA interfaces while the resulting energetic compensation maintains the same net binding energy.     

Building the bacterial orisome: high‐affinity DnaA recognition plays a role in setting the conformation of oriC DNA

During assembly of the E. coli pre‐replicative complex (pre‐RC), initiator DnaA oligomers are nucleated from three widely separated high‐affinity DnaA recognition sites in oriC. Oligomer assembly is then guided by low‐affinity DnaA recognition sites, but is also regulated by a switch‐like conformational change in oriC mediated by sequential binding of two DNA bending proteins, Fis and IHF, serving as inhibitor and activator respectively. Although their recognition sites are separated by up to 90 bp, Fis represses IHF binding and weak DnaA interactions until accumulating DnaA displaces Fis from oriC. It remains unclear whether high‐affinity DnaA binding plays any role in Fis repression at a distance and it is also not known whether all high‐affinity DnaA recognition sites play an equivalent role in oligomer formation. To examine these issues, we developed origin‐selective recombineering methods to mutate E. coli chromosomal oriC. We found that, although oligomers were assembled in the absence of any individual high‐affinity DnaA binding site, loss of DnaA binding at peripheral sites eliminated Fis repression, and made binding of both Fis and IHF essential. We propose a model in which interaction of DnaA molecules at high‐affinity sites regulates oriC DNA conformation.     

Gal repressosome contains an antiparallel DNA loop

Gal repressosome assembly and repression of the gal operon in Escherichia coli occurs when two dimeric GalR proteins and the histone-like HU protein bind to cognate sites causing DNA looping. Structure-based genetic analysis defined the GalR surfaces interacting to form a stacked, V-shaped, tetrameric structure. Stereochemical models of the four possible DNA loops compatible with the GalR tetramer configuration were constructed using the sequence-dependent structural parameters of the interoperator DNA and conformation changes caused by GalR and asymmetric HU binding. Evaluation of their DNA elastic energies gave unambiguous preference to a loop structure in which the two gal operators adopt an antiparallel orientation causing undertwisting of DNA.     

DNA bending and twisting properties of integration host factor determined by DNA cyclization

The binding of many proteins to DNA is profoundly affected by DNA bending, twisting, and supercoiling. When protein binding alters DNA conformation, interaction between inherent and induced DNA conformation can affect protein binding affinity and specificity. Integration host factor (IHF), a sequence-specific, DNA-binding protein of Escherichia coli, strongly bends the DNA upon binding. To assess the influence of inherent DNA bending on IHF binding, we took advantage of the high degree of natural static curvature associated with an IHF site on a 163-bp minicircle and measured the binding affinity of IHF for its recognition site contained on this DNA in both circular and linear form. IHF showed a higher affinity for the circular form of the DNA when compared to the linear form. In addition, the presence of IHF during DNA cyclization changed the topology of cyclization products and their ability to bind IHF, consistent with IHF untwisting DNA. These results show that inherent DNA conformation anisotropy is an important determinant of IHF binding affinity and suggests a mechanism for modulation of IHF activity by local DNA conformation.     

Physical Organization of DNA by Multiple Non-Specific DNA-Binding Modes of Integration Host Factor (IHF)

The integration host factor (IHF) is an abundant nucleoid-associated protein and an essential co-factor for phage λ site-specific recombination and gene regulation in E. coli. Introduction of a sharp DNA kink at specific cognate sites is critical for these functions. Interestingly, the intracellular concentration of IHF is much higher than the concentration needed for site-specific interactions, suggesting that non-specific binding of IHF to DNA plays a role in the physical organization of bacterial chromatin. However, it is unclear how non-specific DNA association contributes to DNA organization. By using a combination of single DNA manipulation and atomic force microscopy imaging methods, we show here that distinct modes of non-specific DNA binding of IHF result in complex global DNA conformations. Changes in KCl and IHF concentrations, as well as tension applied to DNA, dramatically influence the degree of DNA-bending. In addition, IHF can crosslink DNA into a highly compact DNA meshwork that is observed in the presence of magnesium at low concentration of monovalent ions and high IHF-DNA stoichiometries. Our findings provide important insights into how IHF contributes to bacterial chromatin organization, gene regulation, and biofilm formation.     

IHF and HU stimulate assembly of pre-replication complexes at Escherichia coli oriC by two different mechanisms

Pre-replication complexes (pre-RC) assemble on replication origins and unwind DNA in the presence of chromatin proteins. As components of Escherichia coli pre-RC, two histone-like proteins HU and IHF (integration host factor), stimulate initiator DnaA-catalysed unwinding of the chromosomal replication origin, oriC. Using in vivo footprint analysis just before DNA synthesis initiates, we detect IHF binding coincident with a shift of DnaA to weaker central oriC sites. Integration host factor redistributed pre-bound DnaA to identical sites in vitro. HU did not redistribute DnaA, but suppressed binding specifically at I3. These results suggest that different pathways mediated by bacterial chromatin proteins exist to regulate pre-RC assembly and unwind oriC.