Quantitative polysome analysis identifies limitations in bacterial cell-free protein synthesis

Cell-free protein synthesis (CFPS) is becoming increasingly used for protein production as yields increase and costs decrease. CFPS optimization efforts have focused primarily on energy supply and small molecule metabolism, though little is known about the protein synthesis machinery or what limits protein synthesis rates. Here, quantitative polysome profile analysis was used to characterize cell-free translation, thereby elucidating many kinetic parameters. The ribosome concentration in Escherichia coli-based CFPS reactions was 1.6 +/- 0.1 microM, with 72 +/- 4% actively translating at maximal protein synthesis rate. A translation elongation rate of 1.5 +/- 0.2 amino acids per second per ribosome and an initiation rate of 8.2 x 10(-9) +/- 0.3 x 10(-9) M/s, which correlates to, on average, one initiation every 60 +/- 9 s per mRNA, were determined. The measured CFPS initiation and elongation rates are an order of magnitude lower than the in vivo rates and further analysis identified elongation as the major limitation. Adding purified elongation factors (EFs) to CFPS reactions increased the ribosome elongation rate and protein synthesis rates and yields, as well as the translation initiation rate, indicating a possible coupling between initiation and elongation. Further examination of translation initiation in the cell-free system showed that the first initiation on an mRNA is slower than subsequent initiations. Our results demonstrate that polysome analysis is a valid tool to characterize cell-free translation and to identify limiting steps, that dilution of translation factors is a limitation of CFPS, and that CFPS is a useful platform for making novel observations about translation.     

An efficient in vitro translation system from mammalian cells lacking the translational inhibition caused by eIF2 phosphorylation

In vitro translation systems are used to investigate translational mechanisms and to synthesize proteins for characterization. Most available mammalian cell-free systems have reduced efficiency due to decreased translation initiation caused by phosphorylation of the initiation factor eIF2alpha on Ser51. We describe here a novel cell-free protein synthesis system using extracts from cultured mouse embryonic fibroblasts that are homozygous for the Ser51 to- Ala mutation in eIF2alpha (A/A cells). The translation efficiency of a capped and polyadenylated firefly luciferase mRNA in A/A cell extracts was 30-fold higher than in wild-type extracts. Protein synthesis in extracts from A/A cells was active for at least 2 h and generated up to 20 microg/mL of luciferase protein. Additionally, the A/A cell-free system faithfully recapitulated the selectivity of in vivo translation for mRNA features; translation was stimulated by a 5'-end cap (m7GpppN) and a 3'-end poly(A) tail in a synergistic manner. The system also showed similar efficiencies of cap-dependent and IRES-mediated translation (EMCV IRES). Significantly, the A/A cell-free system supported the post-translational modification of proteins, as shown by glycosylation of the HIV type-1 gp120 and cleavage of the signal peptide from beta-lactamase. We propose that cell-free systems from A/A cells can be a useful tool for investigating mechanisms of mammalian mRNA translation and for the production of recombinant proteins for molecular studies. In addition, cell-free systems from differentiated cells with the Ser51Ala mutation should provide a means for investigating cell type-specific features of protein synthesis.     

双抗体免疫沉淀法纯化牛生长激素poly(A)~+RNA的研究

我们用双抗体免疫沉淀法,从牛垂体多聚核糖体中分离出牛生长激素特异多聚核糖体,由此多聚核糖体纯化的牛生长激素Poly(A)~+RNA,可以在麦胚体外翻译系统中和兔网织红细胞体外翻译系统中促进~(14)C-亮氨酸的参入。合成的含~(14)-亮氨酸的翻译产物中有91％可以被牛生长激素抗体沉淀。用SDS-11％PAGE对翻译产物进行鉴定表明,翻译产物在25KD处呈一条放射自显影带,与报导的牛生长激素前体分子量相吻合。     

Stimulation of picornavirus replication by the poly(A) tail in a cell-free extract is largely independent of the poly(A) binding protein (PABP)

Picornavirus infectivity is dependent on the RNA poly(A) tail, which binds the poly(A) binding protein (PABP). PABP was reported to stimulate viral translation and RNA synthesis. Here, we studied encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV) and poliovirus (PV) genome expression in Krebs-2 and HeLa cell-free extracts that were drastically depleted of PABP (96%-99%). Although PABP depletion markedly diminished EMCV and PV internal ribosome entry site (IRES)-mediated translation of a polyadenylated luciferase mRNA, it displayed either no (EMCV) or slight (PV) deleterious effect on the translation of the full-length viral RNAs. Moreover, PABP-depleted extracts were fully competent in supporting EMCV and PV RNA replication and virus assembly. In contrast, removing the poly(A) tail from EMCV RNA dramatically reduced RNA synthesis and virus yields in cell-free reactions. The advantage conferred by the poly(A) tail to EMCV synthesis was more pronounced in untreated than in nuclease-treated extract, indicating that endogenous cellular mRNAs compete with the viral RNA for a component(s) of the RNA replication machinery. These results suggest that the poly(A) tail functions in picornavirus replication largely independent of PABP.     

The 3'' untranslated region of satellite tobacco necrosis virus RNA stimulates translation in vitro.

The RNA of satellite tobacco necrosis virus (STNV) is a monocistronic messenger that lacks both a 5' cap structure and a 3' poly(A) tail. We show that in a cell-free translation system derived from wheat germ, STNV RNA lacking the 600-nucleotide trailer is translated an order of magnitude less efficiently than full-size RNA. Deletion analyses positioned the translational enhancer domain (TED) within a conserved hairpin structure immediately downstream from the coat protein cistron. TED enhances translation when fused to a heterologous mRNA, but the level of enhancement depends on the nature of the 5' untranslated sequence and is maximal in combination with the STNV leader. The STNV leader and TED have two regions of complementarity. One of the complementary regions in TED resembles picornavirus box A, which is involved in cap-independent translation but which is located upstream of the coding region.     

Intrinsically Unstructured Sequences in the mRNA 3ʹ UTR Reduce the Ability of Poly(A) Tail to Enhance Translation

The 5? cap and 3? poly(A) tail of mRNA are known to synergistically stimulate translation initiation via the formation of the cap?eIF4E?eIF4G?PABP?poly(A) complex. Most mRNA sequences have an intrinsic propensity to fold into extensive intramolecular secondary structures that result in short end-to-end distances. The inherent compactness of mRNAs might stabilize the cap?eIF4E?eIF4G?PABP?poly(A) complex and enhance cap-poly(A) translational synergy. Here, we test this hypothesis by introducing intrinsically unstructured sequences into the 5? or 3? UTRs of model mRNAs. We found that the introduction of unstructured sequences into the 3? UTR, but not the 5? UTR, decreases mRNA translation in cell-free wheat germ and yeast extracts without affecting mRNA stability. The observed reduction in protein synthesis results from the diminished ability of the poly(A) tail to stimulate translation. These results suggest that base pair formation by the 3? UTR enhances the cap-poly(A) synergy in translation initiation.     

Autoregulation of poly(A)-binding protein synthesis in vitro.

The poly(A)-binding protein (PABP), in a complex with the 3'poly(A) tail of eukaryotic mRNAs, plays important roles in the control of translation and message stability. All known examples of PABP mRNAs contain an extensive A-rich sequence in their 5' untranslated regions. Studies in mammalian cells undergoing growth stimulation or terminal differentiation indicate that PABP expression is regulated at the translational level. Here we examine the hypothesis that synthesis of the PABP is autogenously controlled. We show that the endogenous inactive PABP mRNA in rabbit reticulocytes can be specifically stimulated by addition of low concentrations of poly(A) and that this stimulation is also observed with in vitro transcribed human PABP mRNA. By deleting the A-rich region from the leader of human PABP mRNA and adding it upstream of the initiator AUG in a reporter mRNA we show that the adenylate tract is sufficient and necessary for mRNA repression and poly(A)-mediated activation in the reticulocyte cell-free system. UV cross-linking experiments demonstrate that the leader adenylate tract binds PABP. Furthermore, addition of recombinant GST-PABP to the cell-free system represses translation of mRNAs containing the A-rich sequence in their 5'UTR, but has no effect on control mRNA. We thus conclude that in vitro PABP binding to the A-rich sequence in the 5' UTR of PABP mRNA represses its own synthesis.     

Protein prenylation in an insect cell-free protein synthesis system and identification of products by mass spectrometry

To evaluate the ability of an insect cell-free protein synthesis system to carry out proper protein prenylation, several CAIX (X indicates any C-terminal amino acid) sequences were introduced into the C-terminus of truncated human gelsolin (tGelsolin). Tryptic digests of these mutant proteins were analyzed by MALDI-TOF MS and MALDI-quadrupole-IT-TOF MS. The results indicated that the insect cell-free protein synthesis system possesses both farnesyltransferase (FTase) and geranylgeranyltransferase (GGTase) I, as is the case of the rabbit reticulocyte lysate system. The C-terminal amino acid sequence requirements for protein prenylation in this system showed high similarity to those observed in rat prenyltransferases. In the case of rhoC, which is a natural geranylgeranylated protein, it was found that it could serve as a substrate for both prenyltransferases in the presence of either farnesyl or geranylgeranyl pyrophosphate, whereas geranylgeranylation was only observed when both prenyl pyrophosphates were added to the in vitro translation reaction mixture. Thus, a combination of the cell-free protein synthesis system with MS is an effective strategy to analyze protein prenylation.     

鲮鱼垂体Poly(A)~+RNA的分离和纯化及其生物活性鉴定

本文利用快速保温法分离纯化了鲮鱼垂体Poly(A)~+RNA,并首次在北农大“白粒146号”小麦麦胚体系中进行了体外翻译活性测定,对鲮鱼Poly(A)~+RNA其最适镁离子浓度为1.7mmol/L,最适Poly(A)~+RNA浓度为0.12μg/50mL,但钾离子浓度及预保温对蛋白质的合成影响不大。实验结果表明鲮鱼垂体Poly(A)~+RNA的体外蛋白翻译活性达对照组的22倍。由于改进了方法,简化了操作程序,因此使鲮鱼垂体Poly(A)~+RNA的翻译活性大大提高了。     

Separation and characterization of low-molecular-weight nuclear RNA species that inhibit cell-free protein synthesis

Various RNA fractions were isolated from nuclei of 12-day lactating rat mammary glands and examined for their ability to inhibit cell-free protein synthesis. Although total nuclear RNA was generally inactive, material contained in the poly(A)⁺ nuclear RNA fraction and the low-molecular-weight RNA derived from total nuclear RNA by sucrose gradient centrifugation, inhibited the translation of several mRNAs but not poly(U) or poly(A). Separation of the small nuclear RNAs by preparative polyacrylamide-urea gel electrophoresis allowed the identification of at least three active inhibitor RNA species. These differed both with respect to their ability to inhibit protein synthesis, and in their mechanism of action. While two of the RNA species inhibited elongation the other inhibited initiation of protein synthesis.     

Energizing cell-free protein synthesis with glucose metabolism

In traditional cell-free protein synthesis reactions, the energy source (typically phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) or creatine phosphate) is the most expensive substrate. However, for most biotechnology applications glucose is the preferred commercial substrate. Previous attempts to use glucose in cell-free protein synthesis reactions have been unsuccessful. We have now developed a cell-free protein synthesis reaction where PEP is replaced by either glucose or glucose-6-phosphate (G6P) as the energy source, thus allowing these reactions to compete more effectively with in vivo protein production technologies. We demonstrate high protein yields in a simple batch-format reaction through pH control and alleviation of phosphate limitation. G6P reactions can produce high protein levels ( approximately 700 microg/mL of chloramphenical acetyl transferase (CAT)) when pH is stabilized through replacement of the HEPES buffer with Bis-Tris. Protein synthesis with glucose as an energy source is also possible, and CAT yields of approximately 550 mug/mL are seen when both 10 mM phosphate is added to alleviate phosphate limitations and the Bis-Tris buffer concentration is increased to stabilize pH. By following radioactivity from [U-(14)C]-glucose, we find that glucose is primarily metabolized to the anaerobic products, acetate and lactate. The ability to use glucose as an energy source in cell-free reactions is important not only for inexpensive ATP generation during protein synthesis, but also as an example of how complex biological systems can be understood and exploited through cell-free biology.     

Regeneration of adenosine triphosphate from glycolytic intermediates for cell-free protein synthesis.

A new approach for adenosine triphosphate (ATP) regeneration in a cell-free protein synthesis system is described. We first show that pyruvate can be used as a secondary energy source to replace or supplement the conventional secondary energy source, phosphoenol pyruvate (PEP). We also report that glucose-6-phosphate, an earlier intermediate of the glycolytic pathway, can be used for ATP regeneration. These new methods provide more stable maintenance of ATP concentration during protein synthesis. Because pyruvate and glucose-6-phosphate are the first and last intermediates of the glycolytic pathway, respectively, the results also suggest the possibility of using any glycolytic intermediate, or even glucose, for ATP regeneration in a cell-free protein synthesis system. As a result, the methods described provide cell-free protein synthesis with greater flexibility and cost efficiency.     

Cell-free synthesis of phytochrome apoprotein

A single polypeptide is immunospecifically precipitated by monospecific antiphytochrome from the total translation products of both wheat-germ and rabbit-reticulocyte cell-free protein synthesizing systems programmed with oat (Avena sativa L.) poly(A) RNA. The mobility of this polypeptide is slightly lower on sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis than that of immunoaffinity-purified, 118 kdalton phytochrome and corresponds to an apparent molecular weight of 124 kdalton. Evidence against the possibility that this mobility difference results from intracellular processing of the 124-kdalton protein is provided by extraction of freeze-dried tissue directly into boiling SDS-containing buffer. This procedure yields a phytochrome species with a mobility on SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis indistinguishable from that of the in-vitro translation product. Together the data indicate that the phytochrome polypeptide is synthesized in its mature form in the cell but is subject to modification to a form with lower apparent molecular weight during immunopurification.Abbreviations IgG immunoglobulin G - PAGE polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate     

Simultaneous expression and maturation of the iron-sulfur protein ferredoxin in a cell-free system

The model iron-sulfur (Fe-S) protein ferredoxin (Fd) from Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 has been simultaneously produced and matured in a cell-free production system. After 6 h of incubation at 37 degrees C, Fd accumulated to >450 microg/mL. Essentially all was soluble, and 85% was active. Production and maturation of the protein in the cell-free system were found to be dependent in a coupled manner on the concentration of the supplemented iron and sulfur sources, ferrous ammonium sulfate and cysteine, respectively. The recombinant expression of ISC helper proteins during cell extract preparation did not increase cell-free Fd accumulation or activity, although the efficiency of iron and cysteine utilization increased. Fd maturation was independent of protein production rate, and proceeded at a constant rate throughout the period of active translation. In addition, incubation of denatured apo Fd with cell-free reaction components resulted in recovery of Fd activity, supporting the interpretation that maturation mechanisms did not act co-translationally. Incubation at 28 degrees C increased total and active protein accumulation, but decreased the ratio of active to total Fd produced. In summary, the high product yields and folding efficiency make the cell-free system described here an attractive platform for the study of Fe-S protein production and maturation. The system enables both small-volume, high throughput investigations as well as larger scale production. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of directed, high-yield production and maturation of an Fe-S protein in a cell-free system.     

L protease from foot and mouth disease virus confers eIF2-independent translation for mRNAs bearing picornavirus IRES

The leader protease (L^pro) from foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) has the ability to cleave eIF4G, leading to a blockade of cellular protein synthesis. In contrast to previous reports, our present findings demonstrate that FMDV L^pro is able to increase translation driven by FMDV IRES. Additionally, inactivation of eIF2 subsequent to phosphorylation induced by arsenite or thapsigargin in BHK cells blocks protein synthesis directed by FMDV IRES, whereas in the presence of L^pro, significant translation is found under these conditions. This phenomenon was also observed in cell-free systems after induction of eIF2 phosphorylation by addition of poly(I:C).     

Studies of translatable mRNA for rabbit C-reactive protein.

C-reactive protein (CRP) mRNA was assayed by cell-free translation of poly(A)-containing liver RNA isolated both from rabbits stimulated to undergo the acute-phase response and from unstimulated control rabbits. No CRP-related translation products were identified until the denaturant methylmercury hydroxide (CH3HgOH) was added to the RNA before cell-free translation. In the presence of the denaturant, a 24000-Da translation product was synthesized which was immunochemically identifiable as the CRP primary translation product. It is likely that rabbit CRP mRNA can form a stable intramolecular duplex which interferes with its translatability in vitro. The 24000-Da CH3HgOH-facilitated cell-free translation product was not detected in poly(A)-containing liver RNA from unstimulated animals, indicating that the concentration of translatable CRP mRNA was dramatically induced during the acute-phase response. On the basis of absorption experiments, the 24000-Da CRP primary translation product was immunochemically more closely related to denatured CRP than to native CRP.