Inspiratory muscle fatigue increases sympathetic vasomotor outflow and blood pressure during submaximal exercise

The purpose of this study was to elucidate the influence of inspiratory muscle fatigue on muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) and blood pressure (BP) response during submaximal exercise. We hypothesized that inspiratory muscle fatigue would elicit increases in sympathetic vasoconstrictor outflow and BP during dynamic leg exercise. The subjects carried out four submaximal exercise tests: two were maximal inspiratory pressure (PI(max)) tests and two were MSNA tests. In the PI(max) tests, the subjects performed two 10-min exercises at 40% peak oxygen uptake using a cycle ergometer in a semirecumbent position [spontaneous breathing for 5 min and with or without inspiratory resistive breathing for 5 min (breathing frequency: 60 breaths/min, inspiratory and expiratory times were each set at 0.5 s)]. Before and immediately after exercise, PI(max) was estimated. In MSNA tests, the subjects performed two 15-min exercises (spontaneous breathing for 5 min, with or without inspiratory resistive breathing for 5 min, and spontaneous breathing for 5 min). MSNA was recorded via microneurography of the right median nerve at the elbow. PI(max) decreased following exercise with resistive breathing, whereas no change was found without resistance. The time-dependent increase in MSNA burst frequency (BF) appeared during exercise with inspiratory resistive breathing, accompanied by an augmentation of diastolic BP (DBP) (with resistance: MSNA, BF +83.4%; DBP, +23.8%; without resistance: MSNA BF, +19.2%; DBP, -0.4%, from spontaneous breathing during exercise). These results suggest that inspiratory muscle fatigue induces increases in muscle sympathetic vasomotor outflow and BP during dynamic leg exercise at mild intensity.     

Effect of pressure assist on ventilation and respiratory mechanics in heavy exercise

To assess the effect of the normal respiratory resistive load on ventilation (VE) and respiratory motor output during exercise, we studied the effect of flow-proportional pressure assist (PA) (2.2 cmH2O.l-1.s) on various ventilatory parameters during progressive exercise to maximum in six healthy young men. We also measured dynamic lung compliance (Cdyn) and lung resistance (RL) and calculated the time course of respiratory muscle pressure (Pmus) during the breath in the assisted and unassisted states at a sustained exercise level corresponding to 70-80% of the subject's maximum O2 consumption. Unlike helium breathing, resistive PA had no effect on VE or any of its subdivisions partly as the result of an offsetting increase in RL (0.78 cmH2O.1-1.s) and partly to a reduction in Pmus. These results indicate that the normal resistive load does not constrain ventilation during heavy exercise. Furthermore, the increase in exercise ventilation observed with helium breathing, which is associated with much smaller degrees of resistive unloading (ca. -0.6 cmH2O.l-1.s), is likely the result of factors other than respiratory muscle unloading. The pattern of Pmus during exercise with and without unloading indicates that the use of P0.1 as an index of respiratory motor output under these conditions may result in misleading conclusions.     

Diaphragm fatigue induced by inspiratory resistive loading in spontaneously breathing rabbits

Diaphragmatic contractility was assessed in spontaneously breathing ketamine-anesthetized rabbits by measuring the strength of diaphragmatic contraction in response to bilateral supramaximal phrenic nerve stimulation at frequencies between 10 and 100 Hz. During 10-180 min of inspiratory resistive loading, contractility decreased by approximately 40%, and hypoxemia and both respiratory and lactic acidosis developed. After 10 min of recovery, both the response to high-frequency stimulation (100 Hz) and the arterial PO2 and PCO2 returned to base-line levels, whereas metabolic acidosis and reduced response to low-frequency stimulation (10-20 Hz) persisted. Similar levels of hypoxemia and respiratory acidosis in the absence of inspiratory resistive loading did not alter diaphragmatic contractility. We conclude that in anesthetized rabbits excessive inspiratory resistive loading results in partially reversible diaphragm fatigue of the high- and low-frequency types, accompanied by hypoventilation and lactic acidosis.     

Effect of Resistive Load on the Inspiratory Work and Power of Breathing during Exertion

The resistive work of breathing against an external load during inspiration (WR_I) was measured at the mouth, during sub-maximal exercise in healthy participants. This measure (which excludes the elastic work component) allows the relationship between resistive work and power, ventilation and exercise modality to be explored. A total of 45 adult participants with healthy lung function took part in a series of exercise protocols, in which the relationship between WR_I, power of breathing, PR_I and minute ventilation, were assessed during rest, while treadmill walking or ergometer cycling, over a range of exercise intensities (up to 150 Watts) and ventilation rates (up to 48 L min⁻¹) with applied constant resistive loads of 0.75 and 1.5 kPa.L.sec⁻¹. Resting WR_I was 0.12 JL⁻¹ and PR_I was 0.9 W. At each resistive load, independent of the breathing pattern or exercise mode, the WR_I increased in a linear fashion at 20 mJ per litre of , while PR_I increased exponentially. With increasing resistive load the work and power at any given increased exponentially. Calculation of the power to work ratio during loaded breathing suggests that loads above 1.5 kPa.L.sec⁻¹ make the work of resistive breathing become inhibitive at even a moderate (>30 L sec⁻¹). The relationship between work done and power generated while breathing against resistive loads is independent of the exercise mode (cycling or walking) and that ventilation is limited by the work required to breathe, rather than an inability to maintain or generate power.     

Vagal amplification of phrenic nerve activity at different levels of ventilation in spontaneously breathing cats

The vagal amplification of phrenic nerve activity (APHR) was studied as a function of minute ventilation (VE) in 12 spontaneously breathing, anaesthetized cats. Increasing levels of VE were obtained by repeated venous administrations of 2,4-dinitrophenol. The APHR was obtained from the ratio of the phrenic nerve activities in a normal and in an occluded breath. The APHR is thought to be mediated by slowly and/or rapidly adapting stretch receptors. Because airway CO2 may inhibit the discharge of these receptors, we also investigated the influence on APHR of adding 1% and 2% by volume of CO2 to inspired gas. The results showed that an increase in VE had no influence on APHR. The values of APHR ranged from 0.95 to 1.31 and were on average 1.08. Low levels of CO2 in inspired gas did not influence APHR. Our findings suggest that the vagal amplification of central inspiratory output as determined from phrenic nerve activity has a constant gain and it seems to play a relatively unimportant role in sustaining hyperpnoeic breathing.     

Bilateral phrenic stimulation: a simple technique to assess diaphragmatic fatigue in humans

Transdiaphragmatic pressure (Pdi) and the rate of relaxation of the diaphragm (tau) were measured at functional residual capacity (FRC) in six normal seated subjects during single-twitch stimulation of both phrenic nerves. The latter were stimulated supramaximally with needle electrodes with square-wave impulses of 0.1-ms duration at 1 Hz before and after diaphragmatic fatigue produced by resistive loaded breathing. Constancy of chest wall configuration was achieved by monitoring the diameter of the abdomen and the rib cage with a respiratory inductive plethysmograph system. During control the peak Pdi generated during the phrenic stimulation amounted to 34.4 +/- 4.2 (SE) cmH2O and represented in each subject a fixed fraction (17%) of its maximal transdiaphragmatic pressure. After diaphragmatic fatigue the peak Pdi decreased by an average of 45%, amounting to 18.1 +/- 2.7 cmH2O 5 min after the fatigue run, and tau increased from 55.2 +/- 9 ms during control to 77 +/- 8 ms 5 min after the fatigue run. The decrease in peak Pdi and the increase in tau observed after the fatigue run persisted throughout the 30 min of the recovery period studied, the peak Pdi amounting to 18.4 +/- 2.8 and 18.9 +/- 3.3 cmH2O and tau to 81.3 +/- 5.7 and 88.7 +/- 10 ms at 15 and 30 min after the end of the fatigue run, respectively. It is concluded that diaphragmatic fatigue can be detected in man by bilateral phrenic stimulation with needle electrodes without any discomfort for the subject and that the decrease in diaphragmatic strength after fatigue is long lasting.     

Cardiorespiratory interactions during resistive load breathing

The addition to the respiratory system of a resistive load results in breathing pattern changes and in negative intrathoracic pressure increases. The aim of this study was to use resistive load breathing as a stimulus to the cardiorespiratory interaction and to examine the extent of the changes in heart rate variability (HRV) and respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA) in relation to the breathing pattern changes. HRV and RSA were studied in seven healthy subjects where four resistive loads were applied in a random order during the breath and 8-min recording made in each condition. The HRV spectral power components were computed from the R-R interval sequences, and the RSA amplitude and phase were computed from the sinusoid fitting the instantaneous heart rate within each breath. Adding resistive loads resulted in 1) increasing respiratory period, 2) unchanging heart rate, and 3) increasing HRV and changing RSA characteristics. HRV and RSA characteristics are linearly correlated to the respiratory period. These modifications appear to be linked to load-induced changes in the respiratory period in each individual, because HRV and RSA characteristics are similar at a respiratory period obtained either by loading or by imposed frequency breathing. The present results are discussed with regard to the importance of the breathing cycle duration in these cardiorespiratory interactions, suggesting that these interactions may depend on the time necessary for activation and dissipation of neurotransmitters involved in RSA.     

Effects of inspiratory resistive load on respiratory control in hypercapnia and exercise

Eight healthy young men underwent two separate steady-state incremental exercise runs within the aerobic range on a treadmill with alternating periods of breathing with no load (NL) and with an inspiratory resistive load (IRL) of approximately 12 cmH2O.1-1.s. End-tidal PCO2 was maintained constant throughout each run at the eucapnic or a constant hypercapnic level by adding 0-5% CO2 to the inspired O2. Hypercapnia caused a steepening, as well as upward shift, relative to the corresponding eucapnic ventilation-CO2 output (VE - VCO2) relationship in NL and IRL. Compared with NL, the VE - VCO2 slope was depressed by IRL, more so in hypercapnic [-19.0 +/- 3.4 (SE) %] than in eucapnic exercise (-6.0 +/- 2.0%), despite a similar increase in the slope of the occlusion pressure at 100 ms - VCO2 (P100 - VCO2) relationship under both conditions. The steady-state hypercapnic ventilatory response at rest was markedly depressed by IRL (-22.6 +/- 7.5%), with little increase in P100 response. For a given inspiratory load, breathing pattern responses to separate or combined hypercapnia and exercise were similar. During IRL, VE was achieved by a greater tidal volume (VT) and inspiratory duty cycle (TI/TT) along with a lower mean inspiratory flow (VT/TI). The increase in TI/TT was solely because of a prolongation of inspiratory time (TI) with little change in expiratory duration for any given VT. The ventilatory and breathing pattern responses to IRL during CO2 inhalation and exercise are in favor of conservation of respiratory work.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Diaphragmatic function during hypoxemia: neonatal and developmental aspects

The effect of acute hypoxemia on diaphragmatic force output was studied in five young (age 4-8 days, wt 1.3-2.2 kg) and five older (age 16-19 days, wt 2.8-3.3 kg), anesthetized, spontaneously breathing piglets. Diaphragmatic force output was assessed by analysis of the transdiaphragmatic pressure (Pdi) generated during an occluded inspiratory effort, at end-expiratory lung volume, triggered by supramaximal transvenous stimulation of both phrenic nerves at frequencies of 20, 30, 50, and 100 Hz. During pressure measurements, the piglets were fitted with a rigid plaster cast covering the abdomen and lower third of the chest to ensure a consistency in diaphragmatic shortening during phrenic nerve stimulation. Pdi was measured under base-line conditions [inspired O2 fractional concentration (FIO2) = 0.50] and after 10 min of hypoxemia induced by breathing 12-14% FIO2. Pdi was significantly less than base line during acute hypoxemia at all frequencies of stimulation in both young and older piglets. The decline in the older piglets' Pdi during hypoxemia was significantly greater than that seen in younger piglets. We conclude that acute hypoxemia impairs the capacity of the developing piglet diaphragm to generate force. Furthermore, our data suggest that the young piglet is more resistant to the depressant effects of hypoxemia when compared to its older counterpart.     

Vagal afferents, diaphragm fatigue, and inspiratory resistance in anesthetized dogs

This study tests three hypotheses regarding mechanisms that produce rapid shallow breathing during a severe inspiratory resistive load (IRL): 1) an intact vagal afferent pathway is necessary; 2) diaphragm fatigue contributes to tachypnea; and 3) hypoxia may alter the pattern of respiration. We imposed a severe IRL on pentobarbital sodium-anesthetized dogs, followed by bilateral vagotomy, then by supplemental O2. IRL alone produced rapid shallow breathing associated with hypercapnia and hypoxia. After the vagotomy, the breathing pattern became slow and deep, restoring arterial PCO2 but not arterial PO2 toward the control values. Relief of hypoxia had no effect, and at no time was there any evidence of fatigue of the diaphragm as measured by the response to phrenic nerve stimulation. We conclude that an intact afferent vagal pathway is necessary for the tachypnea resulting from a severe IRL, neither hypoxia nor diaphragm fatigue played a role, and, although we cannot rule out stimulation of vagal afferents, the simplest explanation for the increased frequency in our experiments is increased respiratory drive due to hypercapnia.     

Altered breathing pattern elicited by stimulation of abdominal visceral afferents

The effect of stimulation of afferent mesenteric nerves on tidal volume (VT), phrenic nerve, and external intercostal muscle activities was studied in anesthetized spontaneously breathing cats. Both mechanical distension of the small intestine and electrical stimulation of the mesenteric nerves resulted in an initial inspiratory inhibition of VT followed by a gradual recovery above the prestimulus controls. Changes in VT were accompanied by a depression of phrenic nerve activity and an excitation of external intercostal muscle activity. During the recovery phase of VT, the amplitude of phrenic nerve activity returned only partially, whereas the activity of the external intercostal muscle was greater than the prestimulus controls. In a second group of experiments, brief tetanic stimulation at the beginning of inspiration led to a complete and maintained inhibition of phrenic nerve activity but with a simultaneous excitation of external intercostal muscle activity and without any change in VT; whereas expiratory stimulation caused a decrease in expiratory abdominal muscle activity, without changing the peak amplitude of phrenic nerve activity. The respiratory changes observed with distension of the small intestine were abolished after denervation of the mesenteric plexus. It is concluded that activation of the visceral afferents of the mesenteric region reflexly changes diaphragmatic breathing to intercostal breathing. It is assumed that such a type of breathing pattern may occur in pregnancy and in pathophysiological situations involving splanchnic viscera.     

Patterns of neural and muscular electrical activity in costal and crural portions of the diaphragm

To determine whether the central respiratory drives to costal and crural portions of the diaphragm differ from each other in response to chemical and mechanical feedbacks, activities of costal and crural branches of the phrenic nerve were recorded in decerebrate paralyzed cats, studied either with vagi intact and servo-ventilated in accordance with their phrenic nerve activity or vagotomized and ventilated conventionally. Costal and crural electromyograms (EMGs) were recorded in decerebrate spontaneously breathing cats. Hypercapnia and hypoxia resulted in significant increases in peak integrated costal, crural, and whole phrenic nerve activities when the vagi were either intact or cut. However, there were no consistent differences between costal and crural neural responses. Left crural EMG activity was increased significantly more than left costal EMG activity in response to hypercapnia and hypoxia. These results indicate that the central neural inputs to costal and crural portions of the diaphragm are similar in eupnea and in response to chemical and mechanical feedback in decerebrate paralyzed cats. The observed differences in EMG activities in spontaneously breathing animals must arise from modulation of central respiratory activity by mechanoreceptor feedback from respiratory muscles, likely the diaphragm itself.     

Phrenic motoneuron discharge during sustained inspiratory resistive loading

Iscoe, Steve. Phrenic motoneuron discharge duringsustained inspiratory resistive loading. J. Appl.Physiol. 81(5): 2260-2266, 1996.I determinedwhether prolonged inspiratory resistive loading (IRL) affects phrenicmotoneuron discharge, independent of changes in chemical drive. Inseven decerebrate spontaneously breathing cats, the discharge patternsof eight phrenic motoneurons from filaments of one phrenic nerve weremonitored, along with the global activity of the contralateral phrenicnerve, transdiaphragmatic pressure, and fractional end-tidalCO₂ levels. Discharge patterns during hyperoxic CO₂ rebreathingand breathing against an IRL (2,500-4,000cmH₂O ^· l^{1 ·} s)were compared. During IRL, transdiaphragmatic pressure increased andthen either plateaued or decreased. At the highest fractional end-tidalCO₂ common to both runs,instantaneous discharge frequencies in six motoneurons were greaterduring sustained IRL than during rebreathing, when compared at the sametime after the onset of inspiration. These increased dischargefrequencies suggest the presence of a load-induced nonchemical drive tophrenic motoneurons from unidentified source(s).

     

Effects of respiratory muscle unloading on exercise-induced diaphragm fatigue.

We previously compared the effects of increased respiratory muscle work during whole body exercise and at rest on diaphragmatic fatigue and showed that the amount of diaphragmatic force output required to cause fatigue was reduced significantly during exercise (Babcock et al., J Appl Physiol 78: 1710, 1995). In this study, we use positive-pressure proportional assist ventilation (PAV) to unload the respiratory muscles during exercise to determine the effects of respiratory muscle work, per se, on exercise-induced diaphragmatic fatigue. After 8-13 min of exercise to exhaustion under control conditions at 80-85% maximal oxygen consumption, bilateral phrenic nerve stimulation using single-twitch stimuli (1 Hz) and paired stimuli (10-100 Hz) showed that diaphragmatic pressure was reduced by 20-30% for up to 60 min after exercise. Usage of PAV during heavy exercise reduced the work of breathing by 40-50% and oxygen consumption by 10-15% below control. PAV prevented exercise-induced diaphragmatic fatigue as determined by bilateral phrenic nerve stimulation at all frequencies and times postexercise. Our study has confirmed that high- and low-frequency diaphragmatic fatigue result from heavy-intensity whole body exercise to exhaustion; furthermore, the data show that the workload endured by the respiratory muscles is a critical determinant of this exercise-induced diaphragmatic fatigue.     

Resistive loading and mechanisms regulating respiration

In experiments on anesthetized cats, switch on of additional inelastic respiration resistance (resistive load) produced, apart from slowing of the respiratory flows, an increase in the activity of motoneurons and inspiratory intrathoracic pressure. Bilateral vagotomy resulted in disappearance of resistive load-induced elevation of the phrenic nerve activity, but did not abolish the growth of the inspiratory effort. Analysis of the evidence obtained indicates that activation of phrenic motoneurons associated with increased respiration resistance is underlain by prolongation of the inspiratory phase that is consequent on relaxation of the inspiratory inhibition. It is suggested that, in addition to the mechanism depicted, the compensatory reaction to the resistive load involves, apart from diaphragm participation, other inspiratory muscles as well as enhanced contractions of respiratory muscles provided by the properties of muscular fiber.     

Detection of inspiratory resistive loads in double-lung transplant recipients.

The afferent pathways mediating respiratory load perception are still largely unknown. To assess the role of lung vagal afferents in respiratory sensation, detection of inspiratory resistive loads was compared between 10 double-lung transplant (DLT) recipients with normal lung function and 12 healthy control (Nor) subjects. Despite a similar unloaded and loaded breathing pattern, the DLT group had a significantly higher detection threshold (2.91 +/- 0.5 vs. 1.55 +/- 0.3 cmH(2)O. l(-1). s) and Weber fraction (0.50 +/- 0.1 vs. 0.30 +/- 0.1) compared with the Nor group. These results suggest that inspiratory resistive load detection occurs in the absence of vagal afferent feedback from the lung but that lung vagal afferents contribute to inspiratory resistive load detection response in humans. Lung vagal afferents are not essential to the regulation of resting breathing and load compensation responses.     

Phrenic afferents and ventilatory control at increased end-expiratory lung volumes in cats

The role of phrenic afferents in controlling inspiratory duration (TI) at elevated end-expiratory lung volume (EEV) has been studied in pentobarbital-anesthetized, spontaneously breathing cats with intact vagi. Responses to increases in EEV, induced by imposition of an expiratory threshold load (ETL) of 10 cmH2O, were monitored before and after section of cervical dorsal roots C3-C7. The immediate (first-breath) effect of application of ETL was a prolongation of both TI and expiratory duration (TE). After 10 min of breathing against the ETL, average TI returned to control values but TE remained prolonged. Abolishing feedback from the diaphragm did not affect these responses. When steady-state responses to ETL were compared with those elicited by inhalation of 5-6% CO2 in O2, changes in EEV had, on average, no independent effect on respiratory drive (rate of rise of integrated phrenic activity), although phrenic activity increased greatly in some cats despite little or no change in arterial partial pressure of CO2. These data indicate that diaphragmatic receptors do not contribute to either the immediate (first-breath) or steady-state responses of phrenic motoneurons to increases in EEV in intact cats.     

Diaphragmatic function during hypercapnia: neonatal and developmental aspects

The effect of acute hypercapnia on diaphragmatic force output was studied in 6 young (4-8 days) and 6 older (16-20 days) anesthetized, spontaneously breathing piglets. Diaphragmatic force output was assessed by analysis of the transdiaphragmatic pressure (Pdi) generated during phrenic nerve stimulation. Pdi was measured under base-line conditions (50% O2-50% N2) and after 10 min of hypercapnia induced by breathing 5, 10, or 15% CO2 balanced with N2 and 50% O2. Pdi was significantly less than base line during the 10 and 15% hypercapnic conditions in the young (P less than 0.05) but not the older piglets. End-expiratory lung volume was noted to decrease during 15% CO2 hypercapnia. Force output augmentation occurred at this lower end-expiratory lung volume and was significantly greater in the older piglet compared with its younger counterpart (P less than 0.05). When the effects of lung volume on Pdi were corrected for, there was no age-related difference in the response to 15% CO2 hypercapnia. We conclude that severe hypercapnia has a depressant effect on diaphragmatic force output in both young and older piglets, and a differential augmentation in diaphragmatic force-output gain occurs at lower end-expiratory lung volume between young and older piglets, with the greater output occurring in the more mature animal.     

Respiratory responses in reversible diaphragm paralysis

The effects of diaphragm paralysis on respiratory activity were assessed in 13 anesthetized, spontaneously breathing dogs studied in the supine position. Transient diaphragmatic paralysis was induced by bilateral phrenic nerve cooling. Respiratory activity was assessed from measurements of ventilation and from the moving time averages of electrical activity recorded from the intercostal muscles and the central end of the fifth cervical root of the phrenic nerve. The degree of diaphragm paralysis was evaluated from changes in transdiaphragmatic pressure and reflected in rib cage and abdominal displacements. Animals were studied both before and after vagotomy breathing O2, 3.5% CO2 in O2, or 7% CO2 in O2. In dogs with intact vagi, both peak and rate of rise of phrenic and inspiratory intercostal electrical activity increased progressively as transdiaphragmatic pressure fell. Tidal volume decreased and breathing frequency increased as a result of a shortening in expiratory time. Inspiratory time and ventilation were unchanged by diaphragm paralysis. These findings were the same whether O2 or CO2 in O2 was breathed. After vagotomy, no significant change in phrenic or inspiratory intercostal activity occurred with diaphragm paralysis in spite of increased arterial CO2 partial pressure. Ventilation and tidal volume decreased significantly, and respiratory timing was unchanged. These results suggest that mechanisms mediated by the vagus nerves account for the compensatory increase in respiratory electrical activity during transient diaphragm paralysis. That inspiratory time is unchanged by diaphragm paralysis whereas the rate or rise of phrenic nerve activity increases suggest that reflexes other than the Hering-Breuer reflex contribute to the increased respiratory response.     

Effect of inspiratory muscle fatigue on breathing pattern

Our aim was to determine whether inspiratory muscle fatigue changes breathing pattern and whether any changes seen occur before mechanical fatigue develops. Nine normal subjects breathed through a variable inspiratory resistance with a predetermined mouth pressure (Pm) during inspiration and a fixed ratio of inspiratory time to total breath duration. Breathing pattern after resistive breathing (recovery breathing pattern) was compared with breathing pattern at rest and during CO2 rebreathing (control breathing pattern) for each subject. Relative rapid shallow breathing was seen after mechanical fatigue and also in experiments with electromyogram evidence of diaphragmatic fatigue where Pm was maintained at the predetermined level during the period of resistive breathing. In contrast there was no significant difference between recovery and control breathing patterns when neither mechanical nor electromyogram fatigue was seen. It is suggested that breathing pattern after inspiratory muscle fatigue changes in order to minimize respiratory sensation.