Probing the GTPase cycle with real-time NMR: GAP and GEF activities in cell extracts

The Ras superfamily of small GTPases is a large family of switch-like proteins that control diverse cellular functions, and their deregulation is associated with multiple disease processes. When bound to GTP they adopt a conformation that interacts with effector proteins, whereas the GDP-bound state is generally biologically inactive. GTPase activating proteins (GAPs) promote hydrolysis of GTP, thus impeding the biological activity of GTPases, whereas guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) promote exchange of GDP for GTP and activate GTPase proteins. A number of methods have been developed to assay GTPase nucleotide hydrolysis and exchange, as well as the activity of GAPs and GEFs. The kinetics of these reactions are often studied with purified proteins and fluorescent nucleotide analogs, which have been shown to non-specifically impact hydrolysis and exchange. Most GAPs and GEFs are large multidomain proteins subject to complex regulation that is challenging to reconstitute in vitro. In cells, the activities of full-length GAPs or GEFs are typically assayed indirectly on the basis of nucleotide loading of the cognate GTPase, or by exploiting their interaction with effector proteins. Here, we describe a recently developed real-time NMR method to assay kinetics of nucleotide exchange and hydrolysis reactions by direct monitoring of nucleotide-dependent structural changes in an isotopically labeled GTPase. The unambiguous readout of this method makes it possible to precisely measure GAP and GEF activities from extracts of mammalian cells, enabling studies of their catalytic and regulatory mechanisms. We present examples of NMR-based assays of full-length GAPs and GEFs overexpressed in mammalian cells.     

Phospholipids can switch the GTPase substrate preference of a GTPase-activating protein

The major cellular inhibitors of the small GTPases of the Ras superfamily are the GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs), which stimulate the intrinsic GTP hydrolyzing activity of GTPases, thereby inactivating them. The catalytic activity of several GAPs is reportedly inhibited or stimulated by various phospholipids and fatty acids in vitro, indicating a likely physiological role for lipids in regulating small GTPases. We find that the p190 RhoGAP, a potent GAP for the Rho and Rac GTPases, is similarly sensitive to phospholipids. Interestingly, however, several of the tested phospholipids were found to effectively inhibit the RhoGAP activity of p190 but stimulate its RacGAP activity. Thus, phospholipids have the ability to "switch" the GTPase substrate preference of a GAP, thereby providing a novel regulatory mechanism for the small GTPases.     

Real-time in vitro measurement of GTP hydrolysis

Small GTPases require an active GTPase activity to function correctly in their cellular environment. Mutation of key residues involved in this activity renders the GTPase defective and the small G-protein constitutively active (GTP-locked). The GTPase activity is also a target for GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs) which act to attenuate GTPase signalling by accelerating the conversion of bound GTP to bound GDP. The measurement of GTP hydrolysis in vitro can therefore provide information on the intrinsic activity of the small GTPase (e.g., mutated GTPase activity) as well as help define GAP specificity. Current methods to measure GTP hydrolysis in vitro utilise either radioactivity-based filter-binding assays or measurements of GDP:GTP:P(i) ratios by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Both provide timed snapshots of the current GTP-bound state, can be prone to experimental errors, and do not provide a real-time observation of GTP hydrolysis. The method we describe here utilises a fluorescently labelled, phosphate-binding protein (PBP), which scavenges for free inorganic phosphate (P(i)). On binding of a single P(i), a change of protein conformation is coupled to a 7-fold increase in fluorescence of the fluorophore. This method therefore permits real-time monitoring of GTPase activity, through measurement of P(i) production. This review describes the process of preparing and labelling the PBP with the MDCC fluorophore, as well as an example of its use in measuring the GTPase activity of small GTPases. We also discuss the pros and cons, and implications of the technique in comparison to the radioactive and HPLC method of measuring the GTPase activity.     

Rho-GTPase signaling drives melanoma cell plasticity

To investigate mechanisms that underlie different modes of tumor cell movement we have studied how regulation of the activity of the Rho family GTPases determines the mode of tumor cell movement. Guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) and GTPase accelerating proteins (GAPs) are key regulators of the activity of small GTPases with GEFs promoting activation to the GTP bound state and GAPs promoting inactivation by stimulating GTP hydrolysis. We identified two important signaling pathways regulating amoeboid and mesenchymal types of motility in melanoma. Here, we discuss our findings in the context of how specificity of Rho signaling is achieved by GEFs and GAPs.     

Developmental analysis of the torso-like phenotype in Drosophila produced by a maternal-effect locus

The segmental plan of the Drosophila embryo is already established at the blastoderm stage through the action of maternal effect genes which determine the polarity of the embryo and zygotically active genes involved in segmentation. We have analyzed the first example of a group of maternally acting genes which are necessary for establishing the developmental potential of the posterior 25% of the blastoderm. Females, homozygous for the X-linked maternal-effect mutation female sterile(1)Nasrat211 [fs(1)N211], produce embryos, characterized as torso-like, which lack all posterior endodermal derivatives as well as structures characteristic of abdominal segments 8 to 10. In addition, anterior endodermal derivatives are deficient and the absence of pharyngeal musculature causes a collapse of the cephalopharyngeal apparatus. The columnar blastoderm cell layer is defective at the posterior tip below the pole cells in these embryos. This defect, however, is presumably secondary to some abnormal feature of pole cell formation since in double mutants of fs(1)Nasrat211; tudor3 the blastoderm is normal but the embryos still show the torso-like phenotype. In situ hybridization with RNA probes derived from the fushi tarazu gene establishes that the cellular determination of the posterior blastoderm of embryos produced by fs(1)N211 is changed. This represents the first direct demonstration that a maternal-effect mutation alters the spatial distribution of a zygotic gene product involved in the segmental patterning of the embryo.     

Role of prenylation in the interaction of Rho-family small GTPases with GTPase activating proteins

The role of prenylation in the interaction of Rho-family small GTPases with their GTPase activating proteins (GAPs) was investigated. Prenylated and nonprenylated small GTPases were expressed in Sf9 insect cells and Escherichia coli, respectively. Nucleotide binding to and hydrolysis by prenylated and nonprenylated proteins were identical, but three major differences were observed in their reactions with GAPs. (1) Membrane-associated GAPs accelerate GTP hydrolysis only on prenylated Rac1 and RhoA, but they are inactive on the nonprenylated form of these proteins. The difference is independent of the presence of detergents. In contrast to Rac1 and RhoA, nonprenylated Cdc42 is able to interact with membrane-localized GAPs. (2) Full-length p50RhoGAP and p190RhoGAP react less intensely with nonprenylated Rac1 than with the prenylated protein, whereas no difference was observed in the reaction of isolated GAP domains of either p50RhoGAP or Bcr with the different types of Rac1. (3) Fluoride exerts a significant inhibitory effect only on the interaction of prenylated Rac1 with the isolated GAP domains of p50RhoGAP or Bcr. The effect of fluoride is not influenced by addition or chelation of Al(3+). This is the first detailed study demonstrating that prenylation of the small GTPase is an important factor in determining its reaction with GAPs. It is suggested that both intramolecular interactions and membrane targeting of GAP proteins represent potential mechanisms regulating Rac signaling.     

Characterization of a fast cycling ADP-ribosylation factor 6 mutant

Studies of GTPase function often employ expression of dominant negative or constitutively active mutants. Dominant negative mutants cannot bind GTP and thus cannot be activated. Constitutively active mutants cannot hydrolyze GTP and therefore accumulate a large pool of GTP-bound GTPase. These mutations block the normal cycle of GTP binding, hydrolysis, and release. Therefore, although the GTPase-deficient mutants are in the active conformation, they do not fully imitate all the actions of the GTPase. This is particularly true for the ADP-ribosylation factors (ARFs), GTPases that regulate vesicular trafficking events. In Ras and Rho GTPases replacement of phenylalanine 28 with a leucine residue produces a "fast cycling" mutant that can undergo spontaneous GTP-GDP exchange and retains the ability to hydrolyze GTP. Unfortunately this phenylalanine residue is not conserved in the ARF family of GTPases. Here we report the design and characterization of a novel activated mutant of ARF6, ARF6 T157A. In vitro studies show that ARF6 T157A can spontaneously bind and release GTP more quickly than the wild-type protein suggesting that it is a fast cycling mutant. This mutant has enhanced activity in vivo and induces cortical actin rearrangements in HeLa cells and enhanced motility in Madin-Darby canine kidney cells.     

DRhoGEF2 regulates actin organization and contractility in the Drosophila blastoderm embryo

Morphogenesis of the Drosophila melanogaster embryo is associated with a dynamic reorganization of the actin cytoskeleton that is mediated by small GTPases of the Rho family. Often, Rho1 controls different aspects of cytoskeletal function in parallel, requiring a complex level of regulation. We show that the guanine triphosphate (GTP) exchange factor DRhoGEF2 is apically localized in epithelial cells throughout embryogenesis. We demonstrate that DRhoGEF2, which has previously been shown to regulate cell shape changes during gastrulation, recruits Rho1 to actin rings and regulates actin distribution and actomyosin contractility during nuclear divisions, pole cell formation, and cellularization of syncytial blastoderm embryos. We propose that DRhoGEF2 activity coordinates contractile actomyosin forces throughout morphogenesis in Drosophila by regulating the association of myosin with actin to form contractile cables. Our results support the hypothesis that specific aspects of Rho1 function are regulated by specific GTP exchange factors.     

Fat facets interacts with vasa in the Drosophila pole plasm and protects it from degradation

Anterior-posterior patterning and germ cell specification in Drosophila requires the establishment, during oogenesis, of a specialized cytoplasmic region termed the pole plasm. Numerous RNAs and proteins accumulate to the pole plasm and assemble in polar granules. Translation of some of these RNAs is generally repressed and active only in pole plasm. Vasa (VAS) protein, an RNA helicase and a component of polar granules, is essential maternally for posterior patterning and germ cell specification, and VAS is a candidate translational activator in the pole plasm. VAS is stabilized within the pole plasm in that it is initially present throughout the entire embryo but strictly limited to the pole cells by the cellular blastoderm stage. hsp83 mRNA, which accumulates in the pole plasm through a stabilization-degradation mechanism, is another example. Here, we used a biochemical approach to identify proteins that copurify with VAS in crosslinked extracts. Prominent among these proteins was the ubiquitin-specific protease Fat facets (FAF), a pole plasm component [7], but one whose roles in posterior patterning and germ line specification have remained unclear. We present evidence that FAF interacts with VAS physically and reverses VAS ubiquitination, thereby stabilizing VAS in the pole plasm.     

Computational model explains high activity and rapid cycling of Rho GTPases within protein complexes

Formation of multiprotein complexes on cellular membranes is critically dependent on the cyclic activation of small GTPases. FRAP-based analyses demonstrate that within protein complexes, some small GTPases cycle nearly three orders of magnitude faster than they would spontaneously cycle in vitro. At the same time, experiments report concomitant excess of the activated, GTP-bound form of GTPases over their inactive form. Intuitively, high activity and rapid turnover are contradictory requirements. How the cells manage to maximize both remains poorly understood. Here, using GTPases of the Rab and Rho families as a prototype, we introduce a computational model of the GTPase cycle. We quantitatively investigate several plausible layouts of the cycling control module that consist of GEFs, GAPs, and GTPase effectors. We explain the existing experimental data and predict how the cycling of GTPases is controlled by the regulatory proteins in vivo. Our model explains distinct and separable roles that the activating GEFs and deactivating GAPs play in the GTPase cycling control. While the activity of GTPase is mainly defined by GEF, the turnover rate is a sole function of GAP. Maximization of the GTPase activity and turnover rate places conflicting requirements on the concentration of GAP. Therefore, to achieve a high activity and turnover rate at once, cells must carefully maintain concentrations of GEFs and GAPs within the optimal range. The values of these optimal concentrations indicate that efficient cycling can be achieved only within dense protein complexes typically assembled on the membrane surfaces. We show that the concentration requirement for GEF can be dramatically reduced by a GEF-activating GTPase effector that can also significantly boost the cycling efficiency. Interestingly, we find that the cycling regimes are only weakly dependent on the concentration of GTPase itself.     

Diversity and versatility of GTPase activating proteins for the p21rho subfamily of ras G proteins detected by a novel overlay assay.

The p21ras superfamily, involved in diverse processes including cell growth and intracellular trafficking, possesses intrinsic GTPase activity and cycles between GTP-bound active and GDP-bound quiescent states. This intrinsic activity, which results in down-regulation, is accelerated by GTPase activating proteins (GAPs). Other proteins regulating the GDP/GTP cycle include exchange proteins and dissociation inhibitors. The p21s rho, rac, and cdc42Hs constitute a subfamily implicated in cytoskeletal organization. BCR and n-chimaerin are prototypes of a new GAP family for these p21s. To investigate proteins modulating GTP hydrolysis of the three p21s, we developed a novel overlay assay applicable to tissue extracts. Diverse GAPs with different specificities were identified in all rat tissues. Brain contained rac1 GAPs of 45, 50, 85, 100, and 150 kDa. The p50 and p150 GAPs also act on rhoA and cdc42Hs and are ubiquitous, while the p45-GAP, n-chimaerin, is brain- and testis-specific and acts preferentially on rac1; the p100 GAP acts on both rac1 and cdc42Hs and is brain-specific. A new class of p21-interacting proteins was also identified. This diversity, versatility, and tissue specificity of GAPs may be required for fine control of the down-regulation of GTP-bound p21s and the suggested specific downstream effects of individual GAPs, which could involve "cross-talk" between GAPs and p21s.     

Identification of the catalytic domains and their functionally critical arginine residues of two yeast GTPase-activating proteins specific for Ypt/Rab transport GTPases.

Ypt/Rab proteins constitute the largest subfamily of the Ras superfamily of monomeric GTPases and are regulators of vesicular protein transport. Their slow intrinsic GTPase activity (10(-4)-10(-3) min(-1) at 30 degrees C) has to be accelerated to switch the active to the inactive conformation. We have identified the catalytic domain within the C-terminal halves of two yeast GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs), Gyp1p and Gyp7p, with specificity for Ypt/Rab GTPases. The catalytically active fragments of Gyp1p and Gyp7p were more active than the full-length proteins and accelerated the intrinsic GTP hydrolysis rates of their preferred substrates by factors of 4.5 x 10(4) and 7.8 x 10(5), respectively. The K(m) values for the Gyp1p and Gyp7p active fragments (143 and 42 microM, respectively) indicate that the affinities of those GAPs for their substrates are very low. The catalytic domains of Gyp1p and Gyp7p contain five invariant arginine residues; substitutions of only one of them (R343 in Gyp1p and R458 in the analogous position of Gyp7p) rendered the GAPs almost completely inactive. We suggest that Ypt/Rab-GAPs, like Ras- and Rho-GAPs, follow the same mode of action and provide a catalytic arginine ('arginine finger') in trans to accelerate the GTP hydrolysis rate of the transport GTPases.     

Regulation of dynamic polarity switching in bacteria by a Ras‐like G‐protein and its cognate GAP

The rod‐shaped cells of the bacterium Myxococcus xanthus move uni‐directionally and occasionally undergo reversals during which the leading/lagging polarity axis is inverted. Cellular reversals depend on pole‐to‐pole relocation of motility proteins that localize to the cell poles between reversals. We show that MglA is a Ras‐like G‐protein and acts as a nucleotide‐dependent molecular switch to regulate motility and that MglB represents a novel GTPase‐activating protein (GAP) family and is the cognate GAP of MglA. Between reversals, MglA/GTP is restricted to the leading and MglB to the lagging pole defining the leading/lagging polarity axis. For reversals, the Frz chemosensory system induces the relocation of MglA/GTP to the lagging pole causing an inversion of the leading/lagging polarity axis. MglA/GTP stimulates motility by establishing correct polarity of motility proteins between reversals and reversals by inducing their pole‐to‐pole relocation. Thus, the function of Ras‐like G‐proteins and their GAPs in regulating cell polarity is found not only in eukaryotes, but also conserved in bacteria.     

Real-time NMR Study of Three Small GTPases Reveals That Fluorescent 2��(3��)-O-(N-Methylanthraniloyl)-tagged Nucleotides Alter Hydrolysis and Exchange Kinetics

The Ras family of small GTPases control diverse signaling pathways through a conserved “switch” mechanism, which is turned on by binding of GTP and turned off by GTP hydrolysis to GDP. Full understanding of GTPase switch functions requires reliable, quantitative assays for nucleotide binding and hydrolysis. Fluorescently labeled guanine nucleotides, such as 2′(3′)-O-(N-methylanthraniloyl) (mant)-substituted GTP and GDP analogs, have been widely used to investigate the molecular properties of small GTPases, including Ras and Rho. Using a recently developed NMR method, we show that the kinetics of nucleotide hydrolysis and exchange by three small GTPases, alone and in the presence of their cognate GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs) and guanine nucleotide exchange factors, are affected by the presence of the fluorescent mant moiety. Intrinsic hydrolysis of mantGTP by Ras homolog enriched in brain (Rheb) is ∼10 times faster than that of GTP, whereas it is 3.4 times slower with RhoA. On the other hand, the mant tag inhibits TSC2GAP-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis by Rheb but promotes p120 RasGAP-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis by H-Ras. Guanine nucleotide exchange factor-catalyzed nucleotide exchange for both H-Ras and RhoA was inhibited by mant-substituted nucleotides, and the degree of inhibition depends highly on the GTPase and whether the assay measures association of mantGTP with, or dissociation of mantGDP from the GTPase. These results indicate that the mant moiety has significant and unpredictable effects on GTPase reaction kinetics and underscore the importance of validating its use in each assay.     

Proteins shifting from the cytoplasm into the nuclei during early embryogenesis of Drosophila melanogaster

Monoclonal antibodies have been used to study the distribution of several proteins in cleavage and blastoderm stages of Drosophila melanogaster. These antigens are known to be associated with hnRNA-containing particles in tissue culture cells. Protein blotting shows that they are present in the embryo 1 hr after egg deposition. A redistribution from the cytoplasm into the somatic nuclei can be observed during developmental stage $\text{12}\text{13}$, one stage prior to the formation of the cellular blastoderm. Yolk nuclei become stained by these antibodies at about the same time. The shift into pole cell nuclei, however, occurs $\text{1}\text{1}\text{2}$ hr later, during the migration of these cells into the posterior midgut rudiment.     

Detection of Rho GEF and GAP activity through a sensitive split luciferase assay system

Rho GTPases regulate the assembly of cellular actin structures and are activated by GEFs (guanine-nucleotide-exchange factors) and rendered inactive by GAPs (GTPase-activating proteins). Using the Rho GTPases Cdc42, Rac1 and RhoA, and the GTPase-binding portions of the effector proteins p21-activated kinase and Rhophilin1, we have developed split luciferase assays for detecting both GEF and GAP regulation of these GTPases. The system relies on purifying split luciferase fusion proteins of the GTPases and effectors from bacteria, and our results show that the assays replicate GEF and GAP specificities at nanomolar concentrations for several previously characterized Rho family GEFs (Dbl, Vav2, Trio and Asef) and GAPs [p190, Cdc42 GAP and PTPL1-associated RhoGAP]. The assay detected activities associated with purified recombinant GEFs and GAPs, cell lysates expressing exogenous proteins, and immunoprecipitates of endogenous Vav1 and p190. The results demonstrate that the split luciferase system provides an effective sensitive alternative to radioactivity-based assays for detecting GTPase regulatory protein activities and is adaptable to a variety of assay conditions.     

Eukaryotic translation initiation factor 5 (eIF5) acts as a classical GTPase-activator protein

GTP hydrolysis occurs at several specific stages during the initiation, elongation, and termination stages of mRNA translation. However, it is unclear how GTP hydrolysis occurs; it has previously been suggested to involve a GTPase active center in the ribosome, although proof for this is lacking. Alternatively, it could involve the translation factors themselves, e.g., be similar to the situation for small G in which the GTPase active site involves arginine residues contributed by a further protein termed a GTPase-activator protein (GAP). During translation initiation in eukaryotes, initiation factor eIF5 is required for hydrolysis of GTP bound to eIF2 (the protein which brings the initiator Met-tRNA(i) to the 40S subunit). Here we show that eIF5 displays the hallmarks of a classical GAP (e.g., RasGAP). Firstly, its interaction with eIF2 is enhanced by AlF(4)(-). Secondly, eIF5 possesses a conserved arginine (Arg15) which, like the "arginine fingers" of classical GAPs, is flanked by hydrophobic residues. Mutation of Arg15 to methionine abolishes the ability of eIF5 either to stimulate GTP hydrolysis or to support mRNA translation in vitro. Mutation studies suggest that a second conserved arginine (Arg48) also contributes to the GTPase active site of the eIF2.eIF5 complex. Our data thus show that eIF5 behaves as a classical GAP and that GTP hydrolysis during translation involves proteins extrinsic to the ribosome. Indeed, inspection of their sequences suggests that other translation factors may also act as GAPs.