Energy conservation and uncoupling in mitochondria

Energy conservation and uncoupling in mitochondria are examined in the light of three important new findings: (a) Studies with the photoaffinity-labeling uncoupler 2-azido-4-nitrophenol have shown that mitochondria contain a specific uncoupler binding site (apparently a polypeptide of M_r = 30,000 ± 10%). (b) This site fractionates into an enzyme complex (complex V), which is capable of oligomycin- and uncoupler-sensitive ATP-Pi exchange. It is absent from electron transfer complexes I, III, and IV, which represent segments of the respiratory chain containing coupling sites 1, 2, and 3, respectively. (c) Trinitrophenol is a membrane-impermeable uncoupler (uncouples submitochondrial particles, but not mitochondria) and a poor protonophore. There is an excellent correlation between the uncoupling potencies and the affinities of uncouplers for the mitochondrial uncoupler-binding site. There is no correlation between uncoupling potency and protonophoric activity of uncouplers when a membrane-permeable uncoupler is compared with a membrane-impermeable one.     

Photoaffinity labeling of uncoupler binding sites on mitochondrial membrane

³H 2-azido-4-nitrophenol, a photoactive uncoupler, has been synthesized, and its uncoupling action on oxidative phosphorylation and its binding to the mitochondrial membrane have been studied. The uncoupler bound covalently to the mitochondrial membrane on photoirradiation was 3–4 times that bound reversibly in the absence of light. When irradiation was carried out in the presence of serum albumin, covalent binding was significantly depressed. The pattern of loss of ATP-P_i' exchange activity with increasing amounts of the uncoupler suggests that serum albumin prevents the binding of the uncoupler to the functional sites as well. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of photoaffinity labeled submitochondrial particles in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate revealed that a 9000 dalton peptide bound high levels of uncoupler. Other proteins in the molecular weight range of 20,000–40,000 and 55,000 were also labeled. Photolysis in the presence of serum albumin or ATP decreased the covalent binding of the uncoupler to all the proteins, but particularly to the 20,000 dalton component. Soluble ATPase and the mitochondrial proteolipid purified from labeled mitochondria showed the presence of label.Abbreviations NPA 2-azido-4-nitrophenol - DNP 2,4-dinitrophenol - DCCD N, N¹-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide - AE particles=bovine heart submitochondrial particles prepared by treatment with NH₄OH and EDTA at pH 8.8 - RCI respiratory control index - BSA bovine serum albumin     

Interaction of uncouplers with the mitochondrial membrane: a high-affinity binding site

2-Nitro-4-azidocarbonylcyanide phenylhydrazone (N₃CCP), a potent water-soluble uncoupler at pH 6–8, was used to determine the nature of binding of the uncoupler to the mitochondrial membrane. Equilibrium binding studies with N₃CCP showed that isolated pigeon heart mitochondria contain 1.6 ± 0.3 high-affinity binding sites per cytochrome a. Several different types of chemical uncouplers were also found to bind to the same high-affinity site as evidenced by their observed competition with N₃CCP. The potassium ionophore valinomycin and the respiratory inhibitor antimycin A did not affect uncoupler binding to the high-affinity sites nor did active respiration of the mitochondria. The number of high-affinity binding sites was essentially unchanged by extraction of 80% of the mitochondrial phospholipids. The ability of the uncouplers to bind to the high-affinity binding sites is proportional to the uncoupler activities. These data support the idea that the high-affinity binding sites of mitochondria are protein(s) which are involved in the coupling reactions of oxidative phosphorylation and that uncoupler bound at these sites is responsible for the uncoupling activity.     

Unique action of a modified weakly acidic uncoupler without an acidic group, methylated SF 6847, as an inhibitor of oxidative phosphorylation with no uncoupling activity: possible identity of uncoupler binding protein

The potent weakly acidic uncoupler SF 6847 was modified by methylation of its phenolic OH group, and the effect of the resulting derivative, with no acid-dissociable group, on oxidative phosphorylation in rat liver mitochondria was examined. The methylated SF 6847 did not induce uncoupling at up to 40 microM, while SF 6847 uncoupled oxidative phosphorylation completely at about 20 nM, indicating that the acid-dissociable group is essential for uncoupling. The O-methylated SF 6847 at 20 microM did, however, inhibit state 3 respiration of mitochondria, although it did not inhibit electron-flow through the respiratory chain, ATPase activated by weakly acidic uncouplers or Pi-ATP exchange. At the same concentration, it also inhibited ATP synthesis in submitochondrial particles. These features are different from those of known inhibitors of oxidative phosphorylation. Thus, O-methylated SF 6847 is a unique inhibitor of oxidative phosphorylation. The possible identity of the uncoupler binding protein is discussed on the basis of these results.     

Anion and amine uptake and uncoupling in submitochondrial particles.

1. Unlike chloroplasts, submitochondrial particles are not uncoupled by nigericin + KCl or NH4Cl. Also the uncoupling effect of lipophilic anions is largely independent of the addition of weak bases. 2. Low concentrations of permeant anions cause a shift of the steady-state energy level rather than a cycle of energy utilization. The degree of inhibition of ATP synthesis by tetraphenylboron is larger than required for the uptake of the anion. 3. Lipophilic anions such as bromthymolblue, bromcresolpurple, and 8-anilino-1-napthalene sulphonate cause a pH-independent, 50% uncoupling in submitochondrial particles at concentrations of 3, 30 and 30 muM, respectively. The passive interaction of bromthymolblue and bromcresolpurple appears as a pH-dependent distribution between two pHases. ATP causes a pH-independent slight shift in the anion distribution, with negligible anion accumulation. 4. Addition of amines to energized submitochondrial particles results in two types of effects; uptake of amines and uncoupling. While in chloroplasts amine uptake and uncoupling are closely associated, this is not the case in submitochondrial particles. The uncoupling effect is observed only with lipophilic and not with hydrophilic amines, and the degree of uncoupling increases with the lipophilicity of the amines. The amine uptake, on the other hand, is accompanied by negligible uncoupling. 5. While the uptake of amines is dependent on the presence of non-permeant anions, such as Cl-, the uncoupling effect is independent of Cl-. Furthermore the amine uncoupling is markedly enhanced by lipophilic anions. 6. The view is discussed that the uncoupling effect of lipophilic anions and lipophilic amines in submitochondrial particles is due to a catalytic energy dissipation rather than to a stoichiometry energy utilization. The molecular mechanism of uncoupling presumably involves a cycling of charges after a perturbation of the membrane structure.     

Phloretin - an uncoupler and an inhibitor of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation

The effect of phloretin on respiration by isolated mitochondria and submitochondrial particles was studied. In submitochondrial particles, both NADH- and succinate-dependent respiration was inhibited by phloretin. 50% maximum inhibition was reached at phloretin concentrations of 0.1 mM (NADH oxidation) and 0.7 mM (succinate oxidation). In isolated mitochondria, phloretin inhibited glutamate oxidation in both State 3 and State 4; 50% maximum inhibition occurred at about 30 microM. Succinate oxidation is inhibited in State 3 by phloretin, inhibition being half its maximum value at 0.5 mM, but in State 4 it is stimulated about 2-fold by phloretin at a concentration of 0.6 mM. Ascorbate oxidation is stimulated in both State 3 and State 4, maximum stimulation being equal to that obtained with an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation. Under all circumstances, phloretin lowered the transmembrane electrical potential difference in isolated mitochondria. These results are discussed in terms of mosaic non-equilibrium thermodynamics. We conclude that phloretin is both an uncoupler and an inhibitor of oxidative phosphorylation.     

ATP-driven transhydrogenase provides an example of delocalized chemiosmotic coupling in reconstituted vesicles and in submitochondrial particles

The mechanism of coupling between mitochondrial ATPase (EC 3.6.1.3) and nicotinamide nucleotide transhydrogenase (EC 1.6.1.1) was studied in reconstituted liposomes containing both purified enzymes and compared with their behavior in submitochondrial particles. In order to investigate the mode of coupling between the transhydrogenase and the ATPase by the double-inhibitor and inhibitor-uncoupler methods, suitable inhibitors of transhydrogenase and ATPase were selected. Phenylarsine oxide and A3'-O-(3-(N-(4-azido-2-nitrophenyl)amino)propionyl)-NAD+ were used as transhydrogenase inhibitors, whereas of the various ATPase inhibitors tested aurovertin was found to be the most convenient. The inhibition of the ATP-driven transhydrogenase activity was proportional to the inhibition of both the ATPase and the transhydrogenase. Inhibitor-uncoupler titrations showed an increased sensitivity of the coupled reaction towards carbonyl cyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone (FCCP)--an uncoupler that preferentially uncouples localized interactions, according to Herweijer et al. (Biochim. Biophys. Acta 849 (1986) 276-287)--when the primary pump was partially inhibited. However, when the secondary pump was partially inhibited the sensitivity towards FCCP remained unchanged. Similar results were obtained with submitochondrial particles. These results are in contrast to those obtained previously with the ATP-driven reverse electron flow. In addition, the amount of uncoupler required for uncoupling of the ATP-driven transhydrogenase was found to be similar to that required for the stimulation of the ATPase activity, both in reconstituted vesicles and in submitochondrial particles. Uncoupling of reversed electron flow to NAD+ required much less uncoupler. On the basis of these results, it is proposed that, in agreement with the chemiosmotic model, the interaction between ATPase and transhydrogenase in reconstituted vesicles as well as in submitochondrial particles occurs through the delta mu H+. In contrast, the energy transfer between ATPase and NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase appears to occur via a more direct interaction, according to the above-mentioned results by Herweijer et al.     

The use of aurovertin to determine the F1 content of submitochondrial particles and the ATPase complex

(1) The concentration of aurovertin-binding sites calculated from fluorimetric titrations of submitochondrial particles is equal to the F₁ concentration, calculated from the concentration of F₁-binding sites in stripped particles.(2) Direct binding experiments show that the fluorescence enhancement of aurovertin bound to submitochondrial particles and the isolated ATPase complex is less (or absent) at higher concentrations than at lower concentrations. The binding data can be described by ‘specific’ and ‘non-specific’ binding. The concentration of the ‘specific’ sites is twice that derived from fluorimetric titrations.(3) After dissociation of the bound F₁ with LiCl, fluorimetric titrations with aurovertin yield linear Scatchard plots. The fluorescence enhancement and K_D are equal to those of the β-subunit-aurovertin complex. The concentration of β-subunits is double the concentration of F₁.(4) It is concluded that both for submitochondrial particles and the isolated ATPase complex the most reliable and simple way to determine the F₁ content is to dissociate the F₁ with LiCl, spin down the insoluble material and titrate the supernatant (containing free β-subunit) with aurovertin.     

Uncoupler-inhibitor titrations of ATP-driven reverse electron transfer in isolated rat-liver mitochondria

Uncoupler-inhibitor titrations of ATP-driven reverse electron transfer across the first site of the respiratory chain were performed in isolated rat-liver mitochondria, and the experimental results were compared with the predictions of a simple delocalized chemiosmotic mechanism. The rates of ATP hydrolysis (Jp) and reverse electron transfer (-J0) were measured at different uncoupler (S-13) concentrations, either in the absence or in the presence of rotenone. When the rates -J0 and Jp measured at different uncoupler concentrations were expressed as percentages of the activity at zero uncoupler concentration, it was found that the efficiency of S-13 to uncouple the reverse electron transfer and to stimulate ATP hydrolysis was not significantly changed upon partial inhibition with rotenone. These results are in contrast with data from a study of uncoupler-inhibitor titrations in submitochondrial particles published previously, in which a higher effectiveness of several uncouplers to inhibit ATP-driven reverse electron transfer was observed in the presence of rotenone.     

Energy-dependent accumulation of the uncoupler picrate and proton flux in submitochondrial particles

In the presence of ATP and oxidizable substrate, submitochondrial particles accumulate up to 7 nmol of picrate/mg of protein. Half of this value is reached at 5 μM picrate in the medium, and maximal energy-dependent accumulation occurs at 25 μM picrate. Mitochondrial proton fluxes calculated under such conditions are 0.80 and 1.08 pmol H⁺/cm²·sec at 10 μM and 25 μM picrate, respectively. These values are similar to those reported for state 4, and are therefore not large enough for uncoupling by picrate through proton translocation. The energy-dependent spectral response of oxonol VI is reversed to 50 % by 40 μM picrate, suggesting that abolishment of membrane potential is responsible for uncoupling of submitochondrial particles by picrate.     

Proton translocation in membranes of submitochondrial particles]

Effect of an electrophilous inhibitor, chlorophenacyl, on energy-dependent functions of submitochondrial particles is studied. Chlorophenacyl at concentrations up to 1 mM is found practically not to affect the generation of membrane potential under NADH and succinate oxidation and ATP hydrolysis and to be a strong inhibitor of oxidative phosphorylation and reverse electron transport. The mechanism of the inhibition of energy-dependent functions of submitochondrial particles with chlorophenacyl is different from that of electron transport inhibitor, energy transport inhibitors and classical uncoupling agents--protonophors. The data obtained are suggested to be due to the existence of two ways of proton translocation in submitochondrial particle membrane, phosphorylating and non-phosphorylating, the effect of chlorophenacyl being directed on phosphorylating way only.     

Energy-dependent transformation of the catalytic activities of the mitochondrial F0 x F1-ATP synthase

The ADP(Mg2+)-deactivated, azide-trapped F0 x F1-ATPase of coupled submitochondrial particles is capable of ATP synthesis being incapable of ATP hydrolysis and ATP-dependent delta muH+ generation [FEBS Lett. (1995) 366, 29-32]. This puzzling phenomenon was studied further. No ATPase activity of the submitochondrial particles catalyzing succinate-supported oxidative phosphorylation in the presence of azide was observed when ATP was added to the assay mixture after an uncoupler. Rapid ATP hydrolysis was detected in the same system when ATP followed by an uncoupler was added. Less than 5% of the original ATPase activity was seen when the reaction (assayed with ATP-regenerating system) was initiated by the addition of ATP to the azide-trapped coupled particles oxidizing succinate either in the presence or in the absence of the uncoupler. High ATP hydrolytic activity was revealed when the reaction was started by the simultaneous addition of the ATP plus uncoupler to the particles generating delta muH+. The energy-dependent conversion of the enzyme into latent uncoupler-activated ATPase was prevented by free ADP (Ki approximately 20 microM) and was greatly enhanced after multiple turnovers in oxidative phosphorylation. The results suggest that the catalytic properties of F0 x F1 are delta muH+-dependent which is in accord with our hypothesis on different conformational states of the enzyme participating in ATP synthesis or hydrolysis.     

Uncoupling effect of fatty acids on heart muscle mitochondria and submitochondrial particles.

The effect of ATP/ADP-antiporter inhibitors on palmitate-induced uncoupling was studied in heart muscle mitochondria and inside-out submitochondrial particles. In both systems palmitate is found to decrease the respiration-generated membrane potential. In mitochondria, this effect is specifically abolished by carboxyatractylate (CAtr) a non-penetrating inhibitor of antiporter. In submitochondrial particles, CAtr does not abolish the palmitate-induced potential decrease. At the same time, bongkrekic acid, a penetrating inhibitor of the antiporter, suppresses the palmitate effect on the potential both in mitochondria and particles. Palmitoyl-CoA which is known to inhibit the antiporter in mitochondria as well as in particles decreases the palmitate uncoupling efficiency in both these systems. These data are in agreement with the hypothesis that the ATP/ADP-antiporter is involved in the action of free fatty acids as natural uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation.     

The reconstitution of the mitochondrial energy-linked transhydrogenase.

Complex I (NADH-ubiquinone reductase) catalyzes pyridine nucleotide transhydrogenase at rates several fold higher than those found in submitochondrial particles from bovine heart. An ATP-dependent reduction of NADP⁺ by NADH was demonstrated after combination of Complex I with phospholipids, hydrophobic proteins derived from bovine heart mitochondria, and mitochondrial ATPase (F₁)¹. The reaction was inhibited by oligomycin, uncoupling agents and low concentrations of Triton X-100.     

The effects of partial uncoupling upon the kinetics of ATP synthesis by vesicles from Paracoccus denitrificans and by bovine heart submitochondrial particles. Implications for the mechanism of the proton-translocating ATP synthase

1. Reduction in the magnitude of the respiration-dependent protonmotive force (proton electrochemical gradient in mV) of vesicles from Paracoccus denitrificans, and of submitochondrial particles, has been found to be paralleled small increases in S50% values for both ADP and Pi. For example, reduction of the protonmotive force of P. denitrificans vesicles from 145 mV to 110 mV was accompanied by an increase of S50% (ADP) from 8 microM to 18 microM, and an increase of S50% (Pi) from 0.33 mM to 1.4 mM. This result was obtained with partial uncoupling quantities of both carbonyl-cyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone and of the synergistic combination of nigericin plus valinomycin in the presence of K+. In view of the similar effects of these two different methods of uncoupling it is concluded that the changes in S50% were a consequence of the diminished protonmotive force acting on the ATP synthase rather than of a secondary, direct interaction of the uncouplers with the enzyme. Changes in S50% rather than Km are described because under several sets of conditions double-reciprocal plots were nonlinear. 2. For equivalent attenuations in the rate of ATP synthesis by submitochondrial particles, 2,4-dinitrophenol caused much larger increases in S50% (ATP) than did carbonylcyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone. Therefore it is concluded that the effect of 2,4-dinitrophenol was primarily a consequence of its previously recognized direct interaction with the F1 segment of the mitochondrial ATPase. The concentration range of 2,4-dinitrophenol that raised S50% (ADP) is similar to that which weakens the binding of ADP to a particular type of site on the purified F1 sector of ATP synthase. This correlation is consistent with such a site having a catalytic role during ATP synthesis. 3. A titration of the rate of ATP synthesis by vesicles of P. denitrificans with increasing quantities of carbonylcyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone showed that the initial titres of the uncoupler caused large decreases in the rate of ATP synthesis for relatively small attenuations in the protonmotive force. Thus the initial 20 mV drop in the protonmotive force was accompanied by a reduction of more than 65% in the rate of ATP synthesis. Over the lowest range of values of protonmotive force that drove detectable rates of ATP synthesis however, the dependence of the rate was a less steep function of the protonmotive force. A plot of the logarithm of the rate of ATP synthesis against protonmotive force reveals a biphasic relationship. There does not appear to be a 'threshold' value of the protonmotive force below which ATP synthesis is blocked by kinetic factors. 4. The relationships of the protonmotive force with S50% values and with the rate of ATP synthesis (at near saturating concentrations of ADP and Pi) are discussed in relation to possible mechanisms for the coupling of proton translocation to ATP synthesis.     

On the mechanism of action of alkylguanidines in oxidative phosphorylation: their action on soluble F1.

Octylguanidine inhibits the adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) activity of bovine heart submitochondrial particles and soluble F₁. The characteristics of the inhibition as a function of octylguanidine and Mg²⁺ concentrations and pH are very similar in submitochondrial particles and soluble F₁. Only those guanidines that possess an alkyl chain of more than six carbons inhibit the ATPase activity of submitochondrial particles and F₁. The inhibiting action of octylguanidine on F₁ is fully reversible. Octylguanidine prevents the cold-induced inactivation of F₁ at concentrations similar to those that inhibit ATPase activity. Guanidines that inhibit ATPase activity also prevent the cold-induced inactivations of F₁.     

Cation requirement for the reconstitution of oligomycin-sensitive ATPase by means of soluble F1-ATPase and F1-depleted submitochondrial particles

Bovine heart submitochondrial particles depleted of F₁ by treatment with urea (‘F₁-depleted particles’) were incubated with soluble F₁-ATPase. The binding of F₁ to the particles and the concomitant conferral of oligomycin sensitivity on the ATPase activity required the presence of cations in the incubation medium. NH⁺₄, K⁺, Rb⁺, Cs⁺, Na⁺ and Li⁺ promoted reconstitution maximally at 40–74 mM, guanidinium⁺ and Tris⁺ at 20–30 mM, and Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ at 3–5 mM. The particles exhibited a negative ζ-potential, as determined by microelectrophoresis, and this was neutralized by mono- and divalent cations in the same concentration range as that needed to promote F₁ binding and reconstitution of oligomycin-sensitive ATPase. It is concluded that the cations act by neutralizing negative charges on the membrane surface, mainly negatively charged phospholipids. These results are discussed in relation to earlier findings reported in the literature with F₁-depleted thylakoid membranes and with submitochondrial particles depleted of both F₁ and the coupling proteins F₆ and oligomycin sensitivity-conferring protein.     

The binding of uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation to rat-liver mitochondria

The binding of different uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation to rat-liver mitochondria was measured. At pH 7.2 and about 0.7 mg mitochondrial protein/ml the percentage bound of the uncoupler added was 84% for 2,3,4,5,6-pentachlorophenol (PCP), 40% for carbonyl cyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone (FCCP), 35% for 4,5,6,7-tetrachloro-2-trifluoromethylbenzimidazole (TTFB), 4% for α′,α′-bis (hexafluoroacetonyl)acetone (1799), and less than 4% for 2,4-dinitrophenol. These percentages are constant up to amounts of uncoupler added several times the one needed for maximal uncoupling. The values found for FCCP and TTFB are in contradiction to the proposed stoichiometric interaction of uncouplers with the coupling sites of the mitochondrial membrane.From titration experiments of the rate of O₂ uptake by rat-liver mitochondria in State 4 as a function of the uncoupler concentration in the presence of albumin or of different types of liposomes the conclusion is drawn that the negative surface charge of the mitochondrial phospholipids may be an important parameter in determining the binding of anionic uncouplers to rat-liver mitochondria.     

A short-chain alkyl derivative of Rhodamine 19 acts as a mild uncoupler of mitochondria and a neuroprotector

Limited uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation is known to be beneficial in various laboratory models of diseases. The search for cationic uncouplers is promising as their protonophorous effect is self-limiting because these uncouplers lower membrane potential which is the driving force for their accumulation in mitochondria. In this work, the penetrating cation Rhodamine 19 butyl ester (C₄R1) was found to decrease membrane potential and to stimulate respiration of mitochondria, appearing to be a stronger uncoupler than its more hydrophobic analog Rhodamine 19 dodecyl ester (C₁₂R1). Surprisingly, C₁₂R1 increased H⁺ conductance of artificial bilayer lipid membranes or induced mitochondria swelling in potassium acetate with valinomycin at concentrations lower than C₄R1. This paradox might be explained by involvement of mitochondrial proteins in the uncoupling action of C₄R1. In experiments with HeLa cells, C₄R1 rapidly and selectively accumulated in mitochondria and stimulated oligomycin-sensitive respiration as a mild uncoupler. C₄R1 was effective in preventing oxidative stress induced by brain ischemia and reperfusion in rats: it suppressed stroke-induced brain swelling and prevented the decline in neurological status more effectively than C₁₂R1. Thus, C₄R1 seems to be a promising example of a mild uncoupler efficient in treatment of brain pathologies related to oxidative stress.     

Antibiotic inhibitors of mitochondrial ATP synthesis.

Fourteen antibiotics have been found to inhibit oxidative phosphorylation and uncoupler-stimulated adenosinetriphosphatase in mitochondria. Four different types of binding sites for these inhibitors have been found. The first (1) binds aurovertin to purified MF1 ATPase in the stoichiometric ratio of two aurovertin molecules per molecule of ATPase. Site II is the locus for efrapeptin (A23871) and may be a catalytic site on purified ATPase. The remaining two sites have been demonstrated only in mitochondria or submitochondrial particles when the APTase is bound to other membrane components. Oligomycin, venturiciden, venturicidin X and ossamycin probably all bind at site III. Leucinostatin (A20668) binds at site IV. At low concentrations, this antibiotic acts like oligomycin; at higher concentrations it uncouples oxidative phosphorylation. Venturicidin appears to prevent leucinostation from binding at site IV for it allows uncoupling to occur at very low concentrations of the latter antibiotic. Venturicidin aglycone, which is a more effective inhibitor than its parent compound, does not exert this effect. It is concluded that sites III and IV are in juxtaposition and that when venturicidin binds at site III its sugar moiety projects into the area of site IV to prevent leucinostation from binding at its inhibitory site.