What is happening to the monocotyledons?

An attempt is made to elucidate some of the more pronounced departures from traditional classifications in the book The families of the monocotyledons byDahlgren and collaborators, which embodies the latest opinions of the lateRolf Dahlgren on the subject. Consideration is given to the treatment of theLiliiflorae (especiallyLiliales andAsparagales) andBromeliiflorae, and to the theory offered for the origin of the monocots which identifies theDioscoreales as the most primitive order of the subclass.Dahlgren aimed at an eclectic classification (one based on a combination of similarity criteria and phylogenetic criteria) and the results of his use of cladistic methods (in association withF. N. Rasumssen) to supply the phylogenetic input are assessed. The resulting system itself is considered in the light of the distinction drawn byJ. S. L. Gilmour between natural and artificial classifications and their respective uses.Dedicated to the memory of JohnS. L. Gilmour.     

What is the best age to circumcise? A medical and ethical analysis

Circumcision is often claimed to be simpler, safer and more cost-effective when performed in the neonatal period as opposed to later in life, with a greater benefit-to-risk ratio. In the first part of this paper, we critically examine the evidence base for these claims, and find that it is not as robust as is commonly assumed. In the second part, we demonstrate that, even if one simply grants these claims for the sake of argument, it still does not follow that neonatal circumcision is ethically permissible absent urgent medical necessity. Based on a careful consideration of the relevant evidence, arguments and counterarguments, we conclude that medically unnecessary penile circumcision—like other medically unnecessary genital procedures, such as ‘cosmetic’ labiaplasty—should not be performed on individuals who are too young (or otherwise unable) to provide meaningful consent to the procedure.     

What is the status of reaction-diffusion theory thirty-four years after Turing?

Physicochemical explanations of phenomena are divisible into three classes: structure, equilibrium and kinetics. For the phenomena of biological development, many physical scientists have the preconception that the explanations must turn out to be principally kinetic. In this class of theory, reaction-diffusion is by far the most extensively developed, and is worthy of attention both for its own sake and because many of its features well exemplify the nature of the broader field of kinetic theory. Reaction-diffusion should be thought of as a class, rather than a species, of theory. This review addresses three aspects: first, the general nature of the two-morphogen interaction as first proposed by Turing and incorporated in many later models; second, the specifics of these later models and their probable relative scope; third, the current state of attempts to identify the chemical nature of morphogens. It is concluded that reaction-diffusion in particular, and kinetic theory in general, are now slowly emerging from the almost total neglect by biologists which reaction-diffusion suffered for its first 20 years.     

Resistance is useless?—Extensions to the game theory of kleptoparasitism

We extend the game theoretic model of kleptoparasitism introduced by Broom and Ruxton (1998, Behav. Ecol. 9, 397–403) in two ways: we allow for asymmetric contests, where the probability α of the challenger winning can take any value from 0 to 1; and we allow the handler to choose not to resist the challenge, but to immediately concede and relinquish its food to the challenger. We find, in general, three possible evolutionarily stable strategies—challenge-and-resist (Hawk), challenge-but-do-not-resist (Marauder) and do-not-challenge-but-resist (Retaliator). When α = 1/2, we find that Hawk and Marauder are the only ESS’s, in contrast to the result of the original model; we also find an overlap region, in parameter space, where two different ESS’s are possible, depending on initial conditions. For general α, we see that all three ESS are possible, depending on different values of the environmental parameters; however, as the average time of a contest over food becomes long, then the Marauder strategy becomes more and more prevalent. The model makes a potentially significant prediction about animal behaviour in the area of kleptoparasitism, that a searcher, when it meets a handler, will only decline to attack that handler when α < 1/2 i.e.when the defender is more likely to win. One possible converse of this statement, that a handler whose probability of success is greater than 1/2 should always resist a challenge, is not true.