Resistance to broomrape (Orobanche spp.) in sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) is temperature dependent

The effects of various temperature regimes in the range 29-17/21-9 degrees C day/night on each stage of the parasitism process of Orobanche cumana and O. aegyptiaca on sunflower were studied under controlled conditions in polyethylene bags. The response of the resistant sunflower variety 'Ambar' was expressed as the degeneration of the parasite tissues after its establishment in the plant roots, and this stage was found to be temperature dependent. The degeneration rate of Orobanche tubercles in the resistant sunflower variety was also found to be temperature dependent and was about five times as great as that in the sensitive variety in the highest temperature regime tested of 29/21 degrees C day/night. The ability to reject the parasite by causing its degeneration and death is the main factor that determines the resistance. As the temperature rises, more tubercles degenerate and die, that is the sunflower plant expresses higher levels of resistance.     

A new method for in-situ monitoring of the underground development of Orobanche cumana in sunflower (Helianthus annuus) with a mini-rhizotron

AIMS: To develop an in-situ, non-destructive method for observation and monitoring of the underground developmental stages of the root parasite Orobanche cumana. SCOPE: The parasitic weed Orobanche causes severe damage to vegetables and field crops. Most of the damage caused to the crops occurs during the underground, unobservable parasitism stage. Sunflower (Helianthus annuus 'Adi') plants were planted in soil that was artificially inoculated with O. cumana seeds. Clear Plexiglas mini-rhizotron plastic observation tubes were inserted into the soil. Seed germination, early stage of penetration, and formation of tubercles and spikes were observed non-destructively and were monitored throughout the growing season by mean of a mini-rhizotron camera. Use of this technology enabled the complete individual parasite life cycle from the very early development (including germination) to Orobanche shoot to be monitored. In addition, the effect of the systemic herbicide Cadre (imazapic) on the development of O. cumana was inspected and quantified. CONCLUSIONS: This novel methodology facilitates the in-situ study of major aspects of the host-parasite interaction and of parasite suppression, such as parasitism dynamics, parasite growth rate, and the effect of chemical treatments on the parasite.     

IAA production during germination of Orobanche spp. seeds

Broomrapes (Orobanche spp.) are parasitic plants, whose growth and development fully depend on the nutritional connection established between the parasite and the roots of the respective host plant. Phytohormones are known to play a role in establishing the specific Orobanche-host plant interaction. The first step in the interaction is seed germination triggered by a germination stimulant secreted by the host-plant roots. We quantified indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and abscisic acid (ABA) during the seed germination of tobacco broomrape (Orobanche ramosa) and sunflower broomrape (O. cumana). IAA was mainly released from Orobanche seeds in host-parasite interactions as compared to non-host-parasite interactions. Moreover, germinating seeds of O. ramosa released IAA as early as 24 h after the seeds were exposed to the germination stimulant, even before development of the germ tube. ABA levels remained unchanged during the germination of the parasites' seeds. The results presented here show that IAA production is probably part of a mechanism triggering germination upon the induction by the host factor, thus resulting in seed germination.     

Comparative studies on Orobanche cernua L. and O. cumana Wallr. (Orobanchaceae) in the Iberian Peninsula

The systematic treatment of Orobanche cumana Wallr. and O. cernua L. is controversial. Whereas some authors consider O. cumana as an infraspecific taxon of O. cernua , others treat it as a separate species. Furthermore, the nomenclature of the sunflower broomrape is unclear, and both names arc found without qualification in the literature. The objective of the present study has been to evaluate the distribution, morphology, and ecology of O. cernua and O. cumana in the Iberian Peninsula, as well as their seed oil fatty acid profile, which is a trait of great chemotaxonomic value. O. cernua was found parasitizing wild Compositac, mainly Artemisia spp., whereas O. cumana was exclusively found on cultivated sunflower. Both species clearly differ in morphological traits, especially plant height and build, length and structure of the inflorescence, corolla length and colour. Both species are characterized by contrasting seed oil fatty acid profiles, with high oleic acid concentration in O. cernua and high linoleic acid concentration in O. cumana. The evaluation of both taxa in the Iberian Peninsula gives additional support to those authors that treat them as separate species.     

Resistance to broomrape (Orobanche crenata) in faba bean (Vicia faba): cell wall changes associated with prehaustorial defensive mechanisms

Broomrapes (Orobanche spp.) are parasitic angiosperms, which attach to the roots of the hosts to take water and nutrients from them. No complete control measures are available to date, but breeding for resistance remains as one of the most feasible and environmentally friendly methods. However, the mechanisms governing the interaction between these parasites and the host are not yet well understood. We studied the cellular changes associated with the resistance to Orobanche crenata in faba bean as mechanisms involved or responsible for resistance. Two cultivars of faba bean, resistant and susceptible to O. crenata infection, were used. The evolution of the infection and the changes in the cell and tissue organisation and wall components of the host cells were followed and evaluated in both genotypes. Samples of compatible and incompatible interactions were fixed and sectioned, and specific cytochemical methods for different cell components were applied, results being analysed under light and epifluorescence microscopy. A higher proportion of O. crenata seedlings unable to penetrate the root was found on the resistant genotype. Reinforcement of cell walls by callose deposition hampers parasite penetration through the cortex. Lignification of endodermal cells prevents further penetration of the parasite into the central cylinder.     

Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) response to broomrape (Orobanche cernua Loefl.) parasitism: induced synthesis and excretion of 7-hydroxylated simple coumarins

The interaction of the parasitic plant Orobanche cernua with resistant and susceptible cultivars of Helianthus annuus L. was investigated. Using different bioassays to evaluate the early stages of the parasite life cycle (germination, attachment, penetration, and establishment), differences were observed between O. cernua-resistant and O. cernua-susceptible sunflower varieties. Germination of O. cernua seeds in the presence of resistant sunflower roots was approximately half that of germination in the presence of susceptible roots, and germinated seeds displayed enhanced browning symptoms. Parasite radicles or host-tissue around the contact point turned brown after O. cernua attachment to sunflower roots, especially in the resistant varieties. These observations suggested the possible accumulation of toxic compounds as a defence strategy in the resistant sunflower varieties. Sunflower 7-hydroxylated simple coumarins may play a defensive role against O. cernua parasitism by preventing successful germination, penetration and/or connection to the host vascular system. This hypothesis is supported by the following data: (i) coumarins inhibited the in vitro germination of O. cernua seeds induced by the strigol analogue GR(24) and caused a browning reaction in germinated seeds and (ii) resistant sunflowers accumulated higher levels of coumarins in roots and excreted greater amounts than susceptible varieties in response to O. cernua infection.     

Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) as suitable markers to study orobanche cumana genetic diversity

Orobanche cumana Wallr., an obligate root parasite of sunflower can cause severe damage to this crop. The genetic diversity obtained with random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) and amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) on two Orobanche populations were compared. Nei and Li distance matrices obtained with both methods among the two populations were correlated significantly according to Mantel's test and could partition the populations. The sampling variance of genetic distances within and among populations estimated using bootstrap procedure were not significantly different between the two techniques. The principal difference between the two techniques is that AFLP markers gave a higher degree of resolution for discriminating closely related germplasm than RAPD.     

New Rice for Africa (NERICA) cultivars exhibit different levels of post-attachment resistance against the parasitic weeds Striga hermonthica and Striga asiatica

Striga hermonthica and S. asiatica are root parasitic weeds that infect the major cereal crops of sub-Saharan Africa causing severe losses in yield. The interspecific upland NEw RICe for Africa (NERICA) cultivars are popular amongst subsistence farmers, but little is known about their post-attachment resistance against Striga. Here, we evaluate the post-attachment resistance levels of the NERICA cultivars and their parents against ecotypes of S. hermonthica and S.asiatica, characterize the phenotype of the resistance mechanisms and determine the effect of Striga on host biomass. Some NERICA cultivars showed good broad-spectrum resistance against several Striga ecotypes, whereas others showed intermediate resistance or were very susceptible. The phenotype of a resistant interaction was often characterized by an inability of the parasite to penetrate the endodermis. Moreover, some parasites formed only a few connections to the host xylem, grew slowly and remained small. The most resistant NERICA cultivars were least damaged by Striga, although even a small number of parasites caused a reduction in above-ground host biomass. The elucidation of the molecular genetic basis of the resistance mechanisms and tolerance would allow the development of cultivars with multiple, durable resistance for use in farmers' fields.     

Several Mechanisms are Involved in Resistance of Helianthus to Orobanche cumana Wallr.

Orobanche cumana(broomrape) poses a serious threat to sunflowercultivation in many countries since there is no effective methodof controlling the pathogen. It is known that wild species ofthe genusHelianthus show resistance to different pathogens.Our goal was to identify resistant wild species and derivedinterspecific hybrids (wild Helianthus x sunflower) and to characterizethe resistance mechanisms involved. After identification ofkey stages (germination, fixation, tubercule formation and development)in the resistance of Helianthus to O. cumana, several germplasmswere tested. Development of a hydroponic co-culture system allowedrapid screening of new Helianthus germplasms and a more accuratestudy of the resistance phenomenon. Several resistance mechanisms,such as cell wall deposition, vessel occlusion and broomrapecellular disorganization were demonstrated in the resistantsunflower genotype LR1 by histological observation of the host-parasiteinterface. In contrast, no reaction was observed in the susceptiblecultivated genotype 2603. H. debilis debilis(the wild parentof LR1) exhibited an encapsulation layer which prevented intrusionof the parasite into the cortex. Severe reduction in the rootand apex biomass of sunflower was observed in the susceptibleline (2603) indicating strong competition between broomrapeand sunflower sinks. This large loss of sunflower biomass wascompensated by broomrape biomass. In resistant genotypes LR1and 92B6, the effect of broomrape infestation on sunflower biomasswas much more limited.¹⁴CO₂radiolabelling showed differencesbetween resistant and susceptible sunflower genotypes in nutrientflux from the host to broomrape. Copyright 2001 Annals of BotanyCompany Carbon transfer, Helianthus, Orobanche cumana, resistance, sunflower     

The Differential Susceptibility of Vetch (Vicia spp.) to Orobanche aegyptiaca: Anatomical Studies

Vetches (Vicia spp .) are important forage legumes in the MiddleEast and Mediterranean regions. Most vetches are highly susceptibleto the root holoparasites Orobanche aegyptiaca and O. crenata,suffering severe quality and yield losses. However, purple vetch(V. atropurpurea) has shown good resistance to Orobanche. Microscopicstudies were performed to reveal anatomical differences of host-parasiteinteractions between susceptible and resistant vetch. SusceptibleV. sativa‘Yovel’ and resistant V. atropupurea‘Popany’were grown in association with O. aegyptiaca seeds, on glassmicrofibre sheets in a polyethylene-bag system. Whole root observationsusing stereoscopic microscopy detected necrotic lesions surroundingthe attachments of Orobanche radicles on resistant vetch roots.Hand-cut sections examined under the light microscope revealedthat in both susceptible and resistant vetch genotypes the Orobancheseeds germinated, attached and penetrated the host root epidermisand cortex. A reddish-brown secretion was observed in the apoplastat the interface between the parasite haustorium and the hosttissues, including the cell walls of the resistant vetch xylemvessels. Fixed and embedded sections observed under the lightmicroscope showed that in the susceptible genotype the parasitehaustorium penetrated through the endodermis into the host vascularcylinder, successfully forming a continuum with host vascularvessels. However, in the resistant genotype, the parasite haustoriumwas blocked at the root endodermis layer. The blockage was coupledwith secretion of unidentified material, thus preventing theparasite from establishing. These findings indicate that mechanicaland possibly chemical barriers are responsible for the hostdefence mechanism(s) conferring resistance of V. atropurpureato O. aegyptiaca. Copyright 2000 Annals of Botany Company Broomrape, Vicia atropurpurea, Vicia sativa, parasitic plants, plant resistance, tissue sections.     

Variability of interactions between barrel medic (Medicago truncatula) genotypes and Orobanche species

A number of broomrapes ( Orobanche spp.) are major threats for grain legumes in the Mediterranean area. Previous studies have shown very high levels of resistance to Orobanche crenata in Medicago truncatula with little variation among accessions hampering, therefore, its use for genetic analysis. In order to identify alternative systems for ulterior genetic and genomic analysis, we studied early stages of the interaction between M. truncatula accessions and a range of Orobanche species. We found significant differences in the induction of germination on Orobanche aegyptiaca , Orobanche foetida var. broteri , Orobanche minor , Orobanche nana and Orobanche ramosa seeds. Accessions also varied in the number of O. aegyptiaca , O. crenata , O. foetida var. broteri , O. nana and O. ramosa attachments supported. Applications of the synthetic germination stimulant GR24 increased the germination level of Orobanche cumana and O. minor . No attachments were observed for any of these species because of physical barriers typical of host resistance. On the contrary, increase of O. nana germination by GR24 led to an increase in number of attachments albeit the normal development of the nodules was stopped in a later stage. The genetic variation observed for induction of germination and subsequent attachment will be useful for isolating and characterising genes involved in early stages of Orobanche –host plant interaction and for the study of the biosynthetic pathways of production of germination stimulants.     

Host-parasite coevolution in a multilocus gene-for-gene system.

This paper examines a mathematical model for the coevolution of parasite virulence and host resistance under a multilocus gene-for-gene interaction. The degrees of parasite virulence and host resistance show coevolutionary cycles for sufficiently small costs of virulence and resistance. Besides these coevolutionary cycles of a longer period, multilocus genotype frequencies show complex fluctuations over shorter periods. All multilocus genotypes are maintained within host and parasite classes having the same number of resistant/virulent alleles and their frequencies fluctuate with approximately equally displaced phases. If either the cost of virulence or the number of resistance loci is larger then a threshold, the host maintains the static polymorphism of singly (or doubly or more, depending on the cost of resistance) resistant genotypes and the parasite remains universally avirulent. In other words, host polymorphism can prevent the invasion of any virulent strain in the parasite. Thus, although assuming an empirically common type of asymmetrical gene-for-gene interaction, both host and parasite populations can maintain polymorphism in each locus and retain complex fluctuations. Implications for the red queen hypothesis of the evolution of sex and the control of multiple drug resistance are discussed.     

Protein cross-linking, peroxidase and beta-1,3-endoglucanase involved in resistance of pea against Orobanche crenata

Root holoparasitic angiosperms, like Orobanche spp, completely lack chlorophyll and totally depend on their host for their supply of nutrients. O. crenata is a severe constraint to the cultivation of legumes and breeding for resistance remains the most economical, feasible, and environmentally friendly method of control. Due to the lack of resistance in commercial pea cultivars, the use of wild relatives for breeding is necessary, and an understanding of the mechanisms underlying host resistance is needed in order to improve screening for resistance in breeding programmes. Compatible and incompatible interactions between O. crenata and pea have been studied using cytochemical procedures. The parasite was stopped in the host cortex before reaching the central cylinder, and accumulation of H2O2, peroxidases, and callose were detected in neighbouring cells. Protein cross-linking in the host cell walls appears as the mechanism of defence, halting penetration of the parasite. In situ hybridization studies have also shown that a peroxidase and a beta-glucanase are differently expressed in cells of the resistant host (Pf651) near the penetration point. The role of these proteins in the resistance to O. crenata is discussed.     

Sunflower sesquiterpene lactone models induce Orobanche cumana seed germination

Six sunflower sesquiterpene lactone models which share structural features of the lactone rings of strigol and its synthetic analogues, the GR family, with different conformational flexibilities were tested as Orobanche cumana germination stimulants. Among them, parthenolide and 3,5-dihydroxydehydrocostus-lactone significantly increased O. cumana germination, presenting higher activity than GR-24, used as a standard in the germination bioassay. The effect of these two compounds is species-specific, showing no germination stimulant activity on other Orobanche spp. tested (O. crenata, O. ramosa and O. aegyptiaca). Data presented are discussed in terms of a structure-activity relationship.     

Histopathological Studies of Resistance of Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) to Downy Mildew (Plasmopara halstedii)

Histopathological studies of the infection of sunflower seedlings by downy mildew ( Plasmopara halstedii ) have shown that penetration of roots and the lower part of the hypocotyl occurs for both compatible combinations (suseptibility) and incompatible combinations (resistance). After penetrating susceptible genotypes, the parasite develops intercellular hyphae and intracellular haustoria, leading to systemic invasion. In contrast, in resistant plants, as soon as colonization develops, hypersensitive-like reactions occur in the parenchyma, with the appearance of necrotic zones surrounded by dividing cells. Growth of the parasite is strongly inhibited and most hyphae are blocked before they reach the cotyledonary node.     

Resistance of sunflower to the biotrophic oomycete Plasmopara halstedii is associated with a delayed hypersensitive response within the hypocotyls

The biotrophic oomycete Plasmopara halstedii is the causal agent of downy mildew in sunflower. It penetrates the roots of both susceptible and resistant sunflower lines and grows through the hypocotyls towards the upper part of the seedling. RT-PCR analysis has shown that resistance is associated with the activation of a hsr203J-like gene, which is a molecular marker of the hypersensitive reaction in tobacco. Activation of this gene was specifically observed during the incompatible interaction and coincided with cell collapse in the hypocotyls. This HR was also associated with the early and local activation of the NPR1 gene which is a key component in the establishment of the SAR. No such HR or a significant activation of the hsr203J-like gene were observed during the compatible combination. These results suggest that the resistance of sunflower to P. halstedii is associated with an HR which fails to halt the parasite. By contrast, this HR triggers a SAR which takes places in the upper part of the hypocotyls and eventually leads to the arrest of parasite growth. A model describing the resistance of plants to root-infecting oomycetes is proposed.     

Genetic variation in a host-parasite association: potential for coevolution and frequency-dependent selection

Abstract.— Models of host‐parasite coevolution assume the presence of genetic variation for host resistance and parasite infectivity, as well as genotype‐specific interactions. We used the freshwater crustacean Daphnia magna and its bacterial microparasite Pasteuria ramosa to study genetic variation for host susceptibility and parasite infectivity within each of two populations. We sought to answer the following questions: Do host clones differ in their susceptibility to parasite isolates? Do parasite isolates differ in their ability to infect different host clones? Are there host clone‐parasite isolate interactions? The analysis revealed considerable variation in both host resistance and parasite infectivity. There were significant host clone‐parasite isolate interactions, such that there was no single host clone that was superior to all other clones in the resistance to every parasite isolate. Likewise, there was no parasite isolate that was superior to all other isolates in infectivity to every host clone. This form of host clone‐parasite isolate interaction indicates the potential for coevolution based on frequency‐dependent selection. Infection success of original host clone‐parasite isolate combinations (i.e., those combinations that were isolated together) was significantly higher than infection success of novel host clone‐parasite isolate combinations (i.e., those combinations that were created in the laboratory). This finding is consistent with the idea that parasites track specific host genotypes under natural conditions. In addition, correspondence analysis revealed that some host clones, although distinguishable with neutral genetic markers, were susceptible to the same set of parasite isolates and thus probably shared resistance genes.     

The evolution of parasite virulence, superinfection, and host resistance

We analyze the evolutionary consequences of host resistance (the ability to decrease the probability of being infected by parasites) for the evolution of parasite virulence (the deleterious effect of a parasite on its host). When only single infections occur, host resistance does not affect the evolution of parasite virulence. However, when superinfections occur, resistance tends to decrease the evolutionarily stable (ES) level of parasite virulence. We first study a simple model in which the host does not coevolve with the parasite (i.e., the frequency of resistant hosts is independent of the parasite). We show that a higher proportion of resistant host decreases the ES level of parasite virulence. Higher levels of the efficiency of host resistance, however, do not always decrease the ES parasite virulence. The implications of these results for virulence management (evolutionary consequences of public health policies) are discussed. Second, we analyze the case where host resistance is allowed to coevolve with parasite virulence using the classical gene-for-gene (GFG) model of host-parasite interaction. It is shown that GFG coevolution leads to lower parasite virulence (in comparison with a fully susceptible host population). The model clarifies and relates the different components of the cost of parasitism: infectivity (ability to infect the host) and virulence (deleterious effect) in an evolutionary perspective.     

Interaction between Orobanche crenata and its host legumes: unsuccessful haustorial penetration and necrosis of the developing parasite

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Orobanche species represent major constraints to crop production in many parts of the world as they reduce yield and alter root/shoot allometry. Although much is known about the histology and effect of Orobanche spp. on susceptible hosts, less is known about the basis of host resistance to these parasites. In this work, histological aspects related to the resistance of some legumes to Orobanche crenata have been investigated in order to determine which types of resistance responses are involved in the unsuccessful penetration of O. crenata. METHODS: Samples of resistance reactions against O. crenata on different genotypes of resistant legumes were collected. The samples were fixed, sectioned and stained using different procedures. Sections were observed using a transmission light microscope and by epi-fluorescence. KEY RESULTS: Lignification of endodermal and pericycle host cells seems to prevent parasite intrusion into the root vascular cylinder at early infection stages. But in other cases, established tubercles became necrotic and died. Contrary to some previous studies, it was found that darkening at the infection site in these latter cases does not correspond to death of host tissues, but to the secretion of substances that fill the apoplast in the host-parasite interface and in much of the infected host tissues. The secretions block neighbouring host vessels. This may interfere with the nutrient flux between host and parasite, and may lead to necrosis and death of the developing parasite. CONCLUSIONS: The unsuccessful penetration of O. crenata seedlings into legume roots cannot be attributed to cell death in the host. It seems to be associated with lignification of host endodermis and pericycle cells at the penetration site. The accumulation of secretions at the infection site, may lead to the activation of xylem occlusion, another defence mechanism, which may cause further necrosis of established tubercles.     

HOST SPECIFICITY IN THE RED ALGAL PARASITES BOSTRYCHIOCOLAX AUSTRALIS AND DAWSONIOCOLAX BOSTRYCHIAE (CHOREOCOLACACEAE,RHODOPHYTA)1

The determinants of host specificity, which are poorly understood in red algal parasites, were studied in the red algal parasites Bostrychiocolax australis Zuccarello et West and Dawsoniocolax bostrychiae (Joly et Yamaguishi-Tomita) Joly et Yamaguishi-Tomita. Culture studies were performed to determine host range, sites of host resistance, and genetics of transmission of resistance. Both species parasitize Bostrychia radicans (Montagne) Montagne, whereas Bostrychiocolax australis also parasitizes Bostrychia moritziana (Sonder ex Kützing) J. Agardh and Stictosiphonia kelanensis (Grunow ex Post) R. J. King et Puttock. Isolates of B. radicans resistant to both parasites were found worldwide, often within the same population as susceptible isolates. On resistant Bostrychia species and isolates, specificity was manifested at three stages: 1) host penetration, in which the spore germ peg failed to penetrate the host cuticle/wall; 2) parasite–host cell fusion, in which the fusion cell died and the parasite died; and 3) growth, in which parasites grew but soon died; parasites rarely reproduced and infections did not continue in culture. Resistance to parasite infection was usually transmitted as a dominant trait and did not segregate as a single locus during meiosis. In certain crosses, transmission of resistance was non-mendelian.