Conversion of wild-type p53 core domain into a conformation that mimics a hot-spot mutant

The wild-type p53 protein can be driven into a conformation corresponding to that adopted by structural mutant forms by heterodimerization with a mutant subunit. To seek partially folded states of the wild-type p53 core domain (p53C) we used high hydrostatic pressure (HP) and subzero temperatures. Aggregation of the protein was observed in parallel with its pressure denaturation at 25 and 37 degrees C. However, when HP experiments were performed at 4 degrees C, the extent of denaturation and aggregation was significantly less pronounced. On the other hand, subzero temperatures under pressure led to cold denaturation and yielded a non-aggregated, alternative conformation of p53C. Nuclear magnetic resonance (1H15N-NMR) data showed that the alternative p53C conformation resembled that of the hot-spot oncogenic mutant R248Q. This alternative state was as susceptible to denaturation and aggregation as the mutant R248Q when subjected to HP at 25 degrees C. Together these data demonstrate that wild-type p53C adopts an alternative conformation with a mutant-like stability, consistent with the dominant-negative effect caused by many mutants. This alternative conformation is likely related to inactive forms that appear in vivo, usually driven by interaction with mutant proteins. Therefore, it can be a valuable target in the search for ways to interfere with protein misfolding and hence to prevent tumor development.     

Molecular evolution of the thermosensitive PAb1620 epitope of human p53 by DNA shuffling.

Conformational stability of the p53 protein is an absolute necessity for its physiological function as a tumor suppressor. Recent in vitro studies have shown that wild-type p53 is a highly temperature-sensitive protein at the structural and functional levels. Upon heat treatment at 37 degrees C, p53 loses its wild-type (PAb1620(+)) conformation and its ability to bind DNA, but can be stabilized by different classes of ligands. To further investigate the thermal instability of p53, we isolated p53 mutants resistant to heat denaturation. For this purpose, we applied a recently developed random mutagenesis technique called DNA shuffling and screened for p53 variants that could retain reactivity to the native conformation-specific anti-p53 antibody PAb1620 upon thermal treatment. After three rounds of mutagenesis and screening, mutants were isolated with the desired phenotype. The isolated mutants were translated in vitro in either Escherichia coli or rabbit reticulocyte lysate and characterized biochemically. Mutational analysis identified 20 amino acid residues in the core domain of p53 (amino acids 101-120) responsible for the thermostable phenotype. Furthermore, the thermostable mutants could partially protect the PAb1620(+) conformation of tumor-derived p53 mutants from thermal unfolding, providing a novel approach for restoration of wild-type structure and possibly function to a subset of p53 mutants in tumor cells.     

Change of conformation of the DNA-binding domain of p53 is the only key element for binding of and interference with p73

Xenopus p53 has biological and biochemical properties similar to those of human p53, except for optimal temperature. The frog protein is fully active at 30 degrees C and inactive at 37 degrees C, leading to a temperature-sensitive behavior similar to that of the human mutant p53Ala(143) and the murine mutant p53Val(135). Using hybrid proteins between human and Xenopus expressed from artificial p53 minigenes, we have been able to demonstrate that change of conformation of the DNA-binding domain is the major determinant of this heat sensitivity. It has been reported that some human tumor-derived p53 mutants can engage in a physical association with p73, thus inhibiting its transactivating properties. The mechanism of this association remains to be elucidated. The nature of the mutant p53 that can engage in this association also remains controversial. Using the unique opportunity of the temperature sensitivity of Xenopus p53, we demonstrate that binding of and interference with p73 require a change of conformation in the p53 protein. This interaction occurs through the DNA-binding domain of p53 only when it is in a denatured state. These results reinforce the notion that mutant p53 with a conformational change can act as a down-regulator of the p73 pathway in human cancer and could confer a selective advantage to the tumor.     

In vitro evolution of thermostable p53 variants

The tumor suppressor p53 is conformationally unstable at physiological temperature. Even the activated p53delta30 variant, which lacks the self-inhibiting carboxy terminal domain, has a half-life of only 8 min at 37 degrees C in vitro. We have developed a genetic approach to identify p53 variants that stabilize the active conformation. The human p53delta30 gene was randomly mutated, and the resulting library was expressed in Escherichia coli under conditions that apparently denatured the parental protein. Stable p53 variants were identified based on their ability to specifically bind a p53 consensus site. The initial thermostable variants were randomly recombined by DNA shuffling, and substitutions that were functionally additive or synergistic were identified in a second more stringent round of screening. The DNA binding activity of N239Y/N268D/E336V p53delta30 variant has a half-life of 100 min at 37 degrees C, 12 times longer than that of the parental protein. The thermostable variants should be more amenable to crystallographic studies and more effective in gene therapies than the wild-type protein.     

The amino-terminal functions of the simian virus 40 large T antigen are required to overcome wild-type p53-mediated growth arrest of cells.

High levels of the p53 tumor suppressor protein can block progression through the cell cycle. A model system for the study of the mechanism of action of wild-type p53 is a cell line (T64-7B) derived from rat embryo fibroblasts transformed by activated ras and a temperature-sensitive murine p53 gene. At 37 to 39 degrees C, the murine p53 protein is in a mutant conformation and the cells actively divide, whereas at 32 degrees C, the protein has a wild-type conformation and the cells arrest in the G1 phase of the cell cycle. Wild-type simian virus 40 large T antigen and a variety of T-antigen mutants were assayed for the ability to bypass the cell cycle block effected by the wild-type p53 protein to induce colony formation at 32 degrees C. The results indicate that two functions within the amino terminus of T antigen are essential to induce cell growth: (i) the ability to bind to the retinoblastoma protein, Rb, and (ii) the presence of a domain in the first exon that appears to interact with the cellular protein, p300. Thus, the cell cycle arrest triggered by wild-type p53 may be overcome by formation of a T-antigen complex with Rb, p300, or both that could then function to either remove p53-mediated negative growth regulatory signals or promote a positive cell growth signal. Surprisingly, T antigen-p53 complexes are not required to overcome the temperature-sensitive p53 block to the cell cycle in these cells. These data suggest that simian virus 40 T antigen associated with Rb, p300, or both proteins can communicate in a cell with the functions of the wild-type p53 protein.     

Thermodynamic effects of disulfide bond on thermal unfolding of the starch-binding domain of Aspergillus niger glucoamylase

The thermodynamic effects of the disulfide bond of the fragment protein of the starch-binding domain of Aspergillus niger glucoamylase was investigated by measuring the thermal unfolding of the wild-type protein and its two mutant forms, Cys3Gly/Cys98Gly and Cys3Ser/Cys98Ser. The circular dichroism spectra and the thermodynamic parameters of binding with beta-cyclodextrin at 25 degrees C suggested that the native structures of the three proteins are essentially the same. Differential scanning calorimetry of the thermal unfolding of the proteins showed that the unfolding temperature t1/2 of the two mutant proteins decreased by about 10 degrees C as compared to the wild-type protein at pH 7.0. At t1/2 of the wild-type protein (52.7 degrees C), the mutant proteins destabilized by about 10 kJ mol(-1) in terms of the Gibbs energy change. It was found that the mutant proteins were quite stabilized in terms of enthalpy, but that a higher entropy change overwhelmed the enthalpic effect, resulting in destabilization.     

Structural distortion of p53 by the mutation R249S and its rescue by a designed peptide: implications for "mutant conformation"

Missense mutations in the DNA-binding core domain of the tumour suppressor protein p53 are frequent in cancer. Many of them result in loss of native structure. The mutation R249S is one of the six most common cancer-associated p53 mutations ("hot-spots"). As it is highly frequent in hepatocellular carcinoma, its rescue is an important therapeutic target. We have used NMR techniques to study the structural effects of the R249S mutation. The overall fold of the core domain is retained in R249S, and it does not take up a denatured "mutant conformation". However, the beta-sandwich had increased flexibility and, according to changes in chemical shift, there was local distortion throughout the DNA-binding interface. It is likely that the R249S mutation resulted in an ensemble of native and native-like conformations in a dynamic equilibrium. The peptide FL-CDB3 that was designed to rescue mutants of p53 by binding specifically to its native structure was found to revert the chemical shifts of R249S back towards the wild-type values and so reverse the structural effects of mutation. We discuss the implications for a rescue strategy and also for the analysis of antibody-binding data.     

Conformational shifts propagate from the oligomerization domain of p53 to its tetrameric DNA binding domain and restore DNA binding to select p53 mutants.

p53 is a conformationally flexible sequence-specific DNA binding protein mutated in many human tumors. To understand why the mutant p53 proteins associated with human tumors fail to bind DNA, we mapped the DNA binding domain of wild-type p53 and examined its regulation by changes in the protein conformation. Using site-directed mutagenesis, residues 90-286 of mouse p53 were shown to form the sequence-specific DNA binding domain. Two highly conserved regions within this domain, regions IV and V, were implicated in contacting DNA. Wild-type p53 bound DNA as a tetramer, each subunit recognizing five nucleotides of the 20 nucleotide-long DNA site. Conformational shifts of the oligomerization domain propagated to the tetrameric DNA binding domain, regulating DNA binding activity, but did not affect the subunit stoichiometry of wild-type p53 oligomers. Interestingly, conformational shifts could also be propagated within certain p53 mutants, rescuing DNA binding. One of these mutants was the mouse equivalent of human histidine 273, which is frequently associated with human tumors.     

A fast method for predicting amino acid mutations that lead to unfolding

Amino acid mutation(s) that cause(s) partial or total unfolding of a protein can lead to disease states and failure to produce mutants. It is therefore very useful to be able to predict which mutations can retain the conformation of a wild-type protein and which mutations will lead to local or global unfolding of the protein. We have developed a fast and reasonably accurate method based on a backbone-dependent side-chain rotamer library to predict the (folded or unfolded) conformation of a protein upon mutation. This method has been tested on proteins whose wild-type 3D structures are known and whose mutant conformations have been experimentally characterized to be folded or unfolded. Furthermore, for the cases studied here, the predicted partially folded or denatured mutant conformation correlate with a decrease in the stability of the mutant relative to the wild-type protein. The key advantage of our method is that it is very fast and predicts locally or globally unfolded states fairly accurately. Hence, it may prove to be useful in designing site-directed mutagenesis, X-ray crystallography and drug design experiments as well as in free energy simulations by helping to ascertain whether a mutation will alter or retain the wild-type conformation.     

Reversible amyloid formation by the p53 tetramerization domain and a cancer-associated mutant

The tetramerization domain for wild-type p53 (p53tet-wt) and a p53 mutant, R337H (p53tet-R337H), associated with adrenocortical carcinoma (ACC) in children, can be converted from the soluble native state to amyloid-like fibrils under certain conditions. Circular dichroism, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and staining with Congo red and thioflavin T showed that p53tet-wt and p53tet-R337H adopt an alternative beta-sheet conformation (p53tet-wt-beta and p53tet-R337H-beta, respectively), characteristic of amyloid-like fibrils, when incubated at pH 4.0 and elevated temperatures. Electron micrographs showed that the alternative conformations for p53tet-wt (p53tet-wt-beta) and p53tet-R337H (p53tet-R337H-beta) were supramolecular structures best described as "molecular ribbons". FT-IR analysis demonstrated that the mechanism of amyloid-like fibril formation involved unfolding of the p53tet-wt beta-strands, followed by unfolding of the alpha-helices, followed finally by formation of beta-strand-containing structures that other methods showed were amyloid-like ribbons. The mutant, p53tet-R337H, had a significantly higher propensity to form amyloid-like fibrils. Both p53tet-wt (pH 4.0) and p53tet-R337H (pH 4.0 and 5.0), when incubated at room temperature (22 degrees C) for one month, were converted to molecular ribbons. In addition, p53tet-R337H, and not p53tet-wt, readily formed ribbons at pH 4.0 and 37 degrees C over 20 hours. Interestingly, unlike other amyloid-forming proteins, p53tet-wt-beta and p53tet-R337H-beta disassembled and refolded to the native tetramer conformation when the solution pH was raised from 4.0 to 8.5. Although fibril formation at pH 4.0 was concentration and temperature-dependent, fibril disassembly at pH 8.5 was independent of both. Finally, we propose that the significantly higher propensity of the mutant to form ribbons, compared to the wild-type, may provide a possible mechanism for the observed nuclear accumulation of p53 in ACC cells and other cancerous cells.     

p53 mutants without a functional tetramerisation domain are not oncogenic

p53 is altered in about 50 % of cancers. Most of the p53 mutants have lost the wild-type tumour suppressor activity but show oncogenic properties. The majority of the p53 alterations are missense mutations of residues located in its DNA binding domain (DBD). Only a few mutations concern residues in its tetramerisation domain (TD). However, the study of mutant proteins identified in tumors that do not form tetramers has shown that they have lost the wild-type activity like most of the p53 DBD mutants. Here, we show that two of such mutant proteins, Arg342Pro and Leu344Pro are not dominant negative and do not stimulate the expression of a reporter gene under the control of the multi-drug resistance gene-1 (MDR-1). This suggests that to be oncogenic, p53 mutants need to form tetramers. Accordingly, the dominant negative effect and the ability of a tetrameric mutant protein, Asp281Gly, to stimulate the MDR-1 promoter are abolished when its TD is rendered non-functional by the mutation of leucine 344 to a proline residue. These results suggest that mutations in the TD, are less selected in tumors than mutations in the DBD because they do not lead to oncogenic proteins.     

Tandem dimerization of the human p53 tetramerization domain stabilizes a primary dimer intermediate and dramatically enhances its oligomeric stability

Tetramerization of the human p53 tumor suppressor protein is required for its biological functions. However, cellular levels of p53 indicate that it exists predominantly in a monomeric state. Since the oligomerization of p53 involves the rate-limiting formation of a primary dimer intermediate, we engineered a covalently linked pair of human p53 tetramerization (p53tet) domains to generate a tandem dimer (p53tetTD) that minimizes the energetic requirements for forming the primary dimer. We demonstrate that p53tetTD self-assembles into an oligomeric structure equivalent to the wild-type p53tet tetramer and exhibits dramatically enhanced oligomeric stability. Specifically, the p53tetTD dimer exhibits an unfolding/dissociation equilibrium constant of 26 fM at 37 degrees C, or a million-fold increase in stability relative to the wild-type p53tet tetramer, and resists subunit exchange with monomeric p53tet. In addition, whereas the wild-type p53tet tetramer undergoes coupled (i.e. two-state) dissociation/unfolding to unfolded monomers, the p53tetTD dimer denatures via an intermediate that is detectable by differential scanning calorimetry but not CD spectroscopy, consistent with a folded p53tetTD monomer that is equivalent to the p53tet primary dimer. Given its oligomeric stability and resistance against hetero-oligomerization, dimerization of p53 constructs incorporating the tetramerization domain may yield functional constructs that may resist exchange with wild-type or mutant forms of p53.     

Change in oligomerization specificity of the p53 tetramerization domain by hydrophobic amino acid substitutions.

The tumor suppressor function of the wild-type p53 protein is transdominantly inhibited by tumor-derived mutant p53 proteins. Such transdominant inhibition limits the prospects for gene therapy approaches that aim to introduce wild-type p53 into cancer cells. The molecular mechanism for transdominant inhibition involves sequestration of wild-type p53 subunits into inactive wild-type/mutant hetero-tetramers. Thus, p53 proteins, whose oligomerization specificity is altered so they cannot interact with tumor-derived mutant p53, would escape transdominant inhibition. Aided by the known three-dimensional structure of the p53 tetramerization domain and by trial and error we designed a novel domain with seven amino acid substitutions in the hydrophobic core. A full-length p53 protein bearing this novel domain formed homo-tetramers and had tumor suppressor function, but did not hetero-oligomerize with tumor-derived mutant p53 and resisted transdominant inhibition. Thus, hydrophobic core residues influence the oligomerization specificity of the p53 tetramerization domain.     

Common conformational effects of p53 mutations

The tumor suppressor gene p53 has been identified as the most frequent target of genetic alterations in human cancers. Most of these mutations occur in highly conserved regions in the DNA-binding core domain of the p53 protein, suggesting that the amino acid residues in these regions are critical for maintaining normal p53 structure and function. We previously used molecular dynamics calculations to demonstrate that several amino acid substitutions in these regions that are induced by environmental carcinogens and found in human tumors produce certain common conformational changes in the mutant proteins that differ substantially from the wild-type structure. In order to determine whether these conformational changes are consistent for other p53 mutants, we have now used molecular dynamics to determine the structure of the DNA-binding core domain of seven other environmentally induced, cancer-related p53 mutants, namely His 175, Asp 245, Asn 245, Trp 248, Met 249, Ser 278, and Lys 286. The results indicate that all of these mutants differ substantially from the wild-type structure in certain discrete regions and that some of these conformational changes are similar for these mutants as well as those determined previously. The changes are also consistent with experimental evidence for alterations in structure in p53 mutants determined by epitope detectability using monoclonal antibodies directed against these regions of predicted conformational change.     

Hsp90 is essential for restoring cellular functions of temperature-sensitive p53 mutant protein but not for stabilization and activation of wild-type p53: implications for cancer therapy

Several signaling pathways that monitor the dynamic state of the cell converge on the tumor suppressor p53. The ability of p53 to process these signals and exert a dynamic downstream response in the form of cell cycle arrest and/or apoptosis is crucial for preventing tumor development. This p53 function is abrogated by p53 gene mutations leading to alteration of protein conformation. Hsp90 has been implicated in regulating both wild-type and mutant p53 conformations, and Hsp90 antagonists are effective for the therapy of some human tumors. Using cell lines that contain human tumor-derived temperature-sensitive p53 mutants we show that Hsp90 is required for both stabilization and reactivation of mutated p53 at the permissive temperature. A temperature decrease to 32 degrees C causes conversion to a protein conformation that is capable of inducing expression of MDM2, leading to reduction of reactivated p53 levels by negative feedback. Mutant reactivation is enhanced by simultaneous treatment with agents that stabilize the reactivated protein and is blocked by geldanamycin, a specific inhibitor of Hsp90 activity, indicating that Hsp90 antagonist therapy and therapies that act to reactivate mutant p53 will be incompatible. In contrast, Hsp90 is not required for maintaining wild-type p53 or for stabilizing wild-type p53 after treatment with chemotherapeutic agents, indicating that Hsp90 therapy might synergize with conventional therapies in patients with wild-type p53. Our data demonstrate the importance of the precise characterization of the interaction between p53 mutants and stress proteins, which may shed valuable information for fighting cancer via the p53 tumor suppressor pathway.