Illegitimate recombination is a major evolutionary mechanism for initiating size variation in plant resistance genes

Current models for the evolution of plant disease resistance (R) genes are based on mechanisms such as unequal crossing-over, gene conversion and point mutations as sources for genetic variability and the generation of new specificities. Size variation in leucine-rich repeat (LRR) domains was previously mainly attributed to unequal crossing-over or template slippage between LRR units. Our analysis of 112 R genes and R gene analogs (RGAs) from 16 different gene lineages from monocots and dicots showed that individual LRR units are mostly too divergent to allow unequal crossing-over. We found that illegitimate recombination (IR) is the major mechanism that generates quasi-random duplications within the LRR domain. These initial duplications are required as seeds for subsequent unequal crossing-over events which cause the observed rapid increase or decrease in LRR repeat numbers. Ten of the 16 gene lineages studied contained such duplications, and in four of them the duplications served as a template for subsequent repeat amplification. Our analysis of Pm3-like genes from rice and three wheat species showed that such events can be traced back more than 50 million years. Thus, IR represents a major new evolutionary mechanism that is essential for the generation of molecular diversity in evolution of RGAs.     

Unequal crossing-over in Escherichia coli

Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes in the process of DNA replication in Escherichia coli leads to the formation of tandem duplications, thus enhancing the activity of certain genes. In conjugational matings between genetically marked E. coli strains, unequal crossing-over leads to the formation of heterozygous tandem duplications. Studying these duplications as model systems allowed the conclusion that unequal crossing-over between direct DNA repeats of sister chromosomes is the main pathway of the formation of selected recombinants in E. coli strains carrying duplications. This was inferred from the data on the segregation of homozygous diploid recombinants by heterozygous duplications. Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes occurs as adaptive exchange providing the survival of the greater part of bacterial cells on a selective medium. The known phenomenon of adaptive mutagenesis may also be a consequence of unequal exchanges at the level of DNA mononucleotide repeats.     

Unequal crossing-over in Escherichia coli

Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes in the process of DNA replication in Escherichia coli leads to the formation of tandem duplications, thus enhancing the activity of certain genes. In conjugational matings between genetically marked E. coli strains, unequal crossing-over leads to the formation of heterozygous tandem duplications. Studying these duplications as model systems allowed the conclusion that unequal crossing-over between direct DNA repeats of sister chromosomes is the main pathway of the formation of selected recombinants in E. coli strains carrying duplications. This was inferred from the data on the segregation of homozygous diploid recombinants by heterozygous duplications. Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes occurs as adaptive exchange providing the survival of the greater part of bacterial cells on a selective medium. The known phenomenon of adaptive mutagenesis may also be a consequence of unequal exchanges at the level of DNA mononucleotide repeats.     

A model of evolution for accumulating genetic information

By taking into account recent knowledge of multigene families and other repetitive DNA sequences, a model of evolution by gene duplication for accumulating genetic information is studied. Genetic information is defined as the sum of distinct functions that the gene family can perform. A coefficient, "genetic diversity" is defined and used in this study, that is highly correlated with genetic information. Initially, a multigene family with a few gene copies is assumed, and natural selection starts to work on this gene family to increase genetic diversity contained in the gene family. As an important mechanism, unequal crossing-over is incorporated. Together with mutation, it is responsible for supplying genetic variability among individuals for selection to work. A specific model, in which individuals with less genetic diversity are selectively disadvantageous, has been studied in detail. Through approximate theoretical analysis and extensive Monte Carlo studies, it has been shown that the system is an extremely efficient way to accumulate genetic information. For attaining one gene, the genetic load is much smaller under this model than under the traditional model of natural selection. The model may be applied to the process of origin of multigene families with diverse copy members such as those of immunoglobulin or cytochrome P450. In general, the process of creating new genes by duplication might be somewhere between the present and the traditional models.     

Natural Genetic Transformation Generates a Population of Merodiploids in Streptococcus pneumoniae

Partial duplication of genetic material is prevalent in eukaryotes and provides potential for evolution of new traits. Prokaryotes, which are generally haploid in nature, can evolve new genes by partial chromosome duplication, known as merodiploidy. Little is known about merodiploid formation during genetic exchange processes, although merodiploids have been serendipitously observed in early studies of bacterial transformation. Natural bacterial transformation involves internalization of exogenous donor DNA and its subsequent integration into the recipient genome by homology. It contributes to the remarkable plasticity of the human pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae through intra and interspecies genetic exchange. We report that lethal cassette transformation produced merodiploids possessing both intact and cassette-inactivated copies of the essential target gene, bordered by repeats (R) corresponding to incomplete copies of IS861. We show that merodiploidy is transiently stimulated by transformation, and only requires uptake of a ∼3-kb DNA fragment partly repeated in the chromosome. We propose and validate a model for merodiploid formation, providing evidence that tandem-duplication (TD) formation involves unequal crossing-over resulting from alternative pairing and interchromatid integration of R. This unequal crossing-over produces a chromosome dimer, resolution of which generates a chromosome with the TD and an abortive chromosome lacking the duplicated region. We document occurrence of TDs ranging from ∼100 to ∼900 kb in size at various chromosomal locations, including by self-transformation (transformation with recipient chromosomal DNA). We show that self-transformation produces a population containing many different merodiploid cells. Merodiploidy provides opportunities for evolution of new genetic traits via alteration of duplicated genes, unrestricted by functional selective pressure. Transient stimulation of a varied population of merodiploids by transformation, which can be triggered by stresses such as antibiotic treatment in S. pneumoniae, reinforces the plasticity potential of this bacterium and transformable species generally.     

Genomic expansion of the Bov-A2 retroposon relating to phylogeny and breed management

Bov-A2 is a retroposon that is widely distributed among the genomes of ruminants (e.g., cow, deer, giraffe, pronghorn, musk deer, and chevrotain). This retroposon is composed of two monomers, called Bov-A units, which are joined by a linker sequence. The structure and origin of Bov-A2 has been well characterized but a genome-level exploration of this retroposon has not been implemented. In this study we performed an extensive search for Bov-A2 using all available genome sequence data on Bos taurus. We found unique Bov-A2-derived sequences that were longer than Bov-A2 due to amplification of three to six Bov-A units arranged in tandem. Detailed analysis of these elongated Bov-A2-derived sequences revealed that they originated through unequal crossing-over of Bov-A2. We found a large number of these elongated Bov-A2-derived sequences in cattle genomes, indicating that unequal crossing-over of Bov-A2 occurred very frequently. We found that this type of elongation is not observed in wild bovine and is therefore specific to the domesticated cattle genome. Furthermore, at specific loci, the number of Bov-A units was also polymorphic between alleles, implying that the elongation of Bov-A units might have occurred very recently. For these reasons, we speculate that genomic instability in bovine genomes can lead to extensive unequal crossing-over of Bov-A2 and levels of polymorphism might be generated in part by repeated outbreeding.     

Tandem-repetitive noncoding DNA: forms and forces

A model of sequence-dependent, unequal crossing-over and gene amplification (slippage replication) has been stimulated in order to account for various structural features of tandemly repeated DNA sequences. It is shown that DNA whose sequence is not maintained by natural selection will exhibit repetitive patterns over a wide range of recombination rates as a result of the interaction of unequal crossing-over and slippage replication, processes that depend on sequence similarity. At high crossing-over frequencies, the nucleotide patterns generated in the simulations are simple and highly regular, with short, nearly identical sequences repeated in tandem. Decreasing recombination rates increase the tendency to longer and more-complex repeat units. Periodicities have been observed down to very low recombination rates (one or more orders of magnitude lower than mutation rate). At such low rates, most of the sequences contain repeats which have an extensive substructure and a high degree of heterogeneity among each other; often higher-order structures are superimposed on a tandem array. These results are compared with various structural properties of tandemly repeated DNAs known from eukaryotes, the spectrum ranging from simple-sequence DNAs, particularly the hypervariable mini-satellites, to the classical satellite DNAs, located in chromosomal regions of low recombination, e.g., heterochromatin.     

Role of gene duplication in evolution

It is now known that many multigene and supergene families exist in eukaryote genomes: multigene families with uniform copy members like genes for ribosomal RNA, those with variable members like immunoglobulin genes, and supergene families such as those for various growth factor and hormone receptors. Many such examples indicate that gene duplication and subsequent differentiation are extremely important for organismal evolution. In particular, gene duplication could well have been the primary mechanism for the evolution of complexity in higher organisms. Population genetic models for the origin of gene families with diverse functions are presented, in which natural selection favors those genomes with more useful mutants in duplicated genes. Since any gene has a certain probability of degenerating by mutation, success versus failure in acquiring a new gene by duplication may be expressed as the ratio of probabilities of spreading of useful versus detrimental mutations in redundant gene copies. Also examined are the effects of gene duplication on evolution by compensatory advantageous mutations. Results of the analyses show that both natural selection and random drift are important for the origin of gene families. In addition, interaction between molecular mechanisms such as unequal crossing-over and gene conversion, and selection or drift is found to have a large effect on evolution by gene duplication.     

Rat kappa-chain J-segment genes: two recent gene duplications separate rat and mouse

We have cloned DNA segments containing the Jk genes from LOUVAIN rat liver, and have determined their nucleotide sequence. Seven readily identifiable Jk-coding regions (six expressible) are evident in the rat, compared with five in the mouse (four expressible). The two additional J segments in the rat appear to be the result of two sequential gene duplications occurring since the divergence of rats and mice. The first involved a homologous but unequal crossing-over in a 14 bp region spanning the 3' end of the coding region of J1 and J2. The second involved a crossing-over following unequal pairing of the two newly duplicated regions. We propose that the probability of a second duplication was greatly increased following the first as a result of the increased target for unequal pairing (370 bp of good homology versus 27 bp in the original pairing). Comparisons of rat and mouse J genes show a surprisingly high degree of sequence conservation, both inside and outside the coding regions, similar to the pattern we reported previously for the kappa constant-region gene. This provides additional evidence that constraints exist on the nucleotide sequences of these genes independent of the function of the encoded proteins.     

Multiple origins of the human glycophorin Sta gene. Identification of hot spots for independent unequal homologous recombinations.

Human glycophorin Sta (HGpSta), one of the structural variants of erythrocyte membrane sialoglycoproteins, is encoded by a delta-alpha hybrid gene that arose from a single unequal crossover between the parent HGpB(delta) and HGpA(alpha) genes. We report here the identification of two new HGpSta genes (type A and type B) in four unrelated Sta heterozygotes from two ethnic groups. These Sta genes represent distinct genetic isoforms that differ from the previously reported Sta gene (type C) in the location of crossing-over sites. Comparison of nucleotide sequences among HGpB(delta), HGpA(alpha), and HGpSta type A genes revealed that the delta-alpha unequal crossover for the Sta type A gene occurred 110-246 base pairs downstream from pseudoexon III. In the crossing-over site of this Sta gene, an AT-rich sequence lying 3' to a nonameric palindrome was found to be highly similar to the lambda phage attachment site, att B, in inverted orientation. In the Sta type B gene, the delta-alpha crossing-over point was localized to an AG-rich sequence that is 302-490 base pairs downstream from pseudoexon III. Multiple lambda chi-like elements were identified at the crossover boundaries and within the breakpoint of this Sta gene. These results suggest strongly that recurrent and independent unequal recombination events have occurred in the formation of multiple Sta genes and that particular genomic sequences are important in defining the recombination sites for these homology-driven processes.     

On simple repeated GATCA sequences in animal genomes: a critical reappraisal

Simple tandemly organized GATCA sequences occurred in all eukaryotic genomes investigated. The amount and organization of individual GATCA sequences or derivatives thereof vary considerably in animal DNAs and can be assessed by simple but specific hybridization procedures with chemically pure oligonucleotide probes. In several animal species, including humans, GATCA sequences show extensive polymorphism, thus allowing individual-specific "DNA fingerprints." In selected rodents the sex-chromosomal organization of GATCA sequences is being studied extensively, revealing rapid evolutionary changes. In addition, insight can be expected into the sequences involved in obligatory meiotic crossing over between the X and Y chromosomes, into unequal crossing-over events, and into the linkage of GATCA elements to male-specific as well as to male-determining genes on the Y chromosome. The exact provenance of GATCA sequences in present-day eukaryotes cannot be pinpointed, but evolutionary conservation and several modes of de novo generation are discussed. Among these are unequal recombination, slipped strand mispairing, and other unspecified mechanisms. The latter include inherent properties that are responsible for the "selfish" or "ignorant" nature of simple repeats. Expression, if any, of GATCA sequences is critical to the overall significance of these ubiquitously interspersed simple repeats.     

Molecular analysis of a hybrid gene encoding human glycophorin variant Miltenberger V-like molecule

The genomic structure of a human glycophorin variant, Miltenberger class V-like molecule (MiV*), was examined. Southern blot analysis of total genomic DNA revealed that the 5' half of the MiV* gene derived from glycophorin A (GPA) gene whereas the 3' half derived from glycophorin B (GPB) gene. This structure is reciprocal to another glycophorin variant, Sta, which has a GPB-GPA hybrid structure. The genomic sequences around the crossing-over point were amplified by polymerase chain reaction, and the sequences were determined. Comparison of the nucleotide sequences of the GPA, GPB, and MiV* genes indicates that the crossing-over point is located in the region around the 3' end of intron 3 of the GPA gene. This place is different from the crossing-over point for Sta, which was found to be highly homologous to that for haptoglobin-related genes. However, the nucleotide sequences within the presumptive crossing-over point for the MiV* gene were found to be homologous in a reverse orientation to the crossing-over point proposed for haptoglobin-related genes. These results suggest strongly that homologous recombination through unequal crossing over can be facilitated by specific genomic elements such as those in common for formation of MiV*, Sta, and haptoglobin-related genes. The present study also localized the gene of the third glycophorin, GPE, at chromosome 4, q31.1 band, the same locus as for the GPA and GPB genes. The results indicate that GPE was not involved in generating MiV* or Sta hybrid gene despite the fact that it is localized adjacent to the GPA and GPB genes.     

Pulsed-field electrophoresis screening for immunoglobulin heavy-chain constant-region (IGHC) multigene deletions and duplications.

Genome regions containing multiple copies of homologous genes, such as the immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy-chain constant-region (IGHC) locus, are often unstable and give rise to duplicated and deleted haplotypes. Analysis of such processes is fundamental to understanding the mechanisms of evolution of multigene families. In the IGHC region, a number of single and multiple gene deletions, derived from either unequal crossing-over or looping-out excision, have been described. To study these haplotypes at the population level, a simple and efficient method for preparing large numbers of DNA samples suitable for pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) analysis was set up, and a sample of 110 blood donors was screened. Deletions were found to be frequent, as expected on the basis of previous serological surveys for homozygotes. Furthermore, a number of multigene duplications, never identified before, were detected. The total frequency of individuals bearing rearranged IGHC haplotypes was 10%. The genes involved in these deletions and duplications were assessed by densitometric analysis of standard Southern blots hybridized with several IGHC probes; two types of deletion and two types of duplication could thus be characterized. These data provide further evidence of the instability of the IGHC locus and demonstrate that unequal crossing-over is the most likely origin of rearranged IGHC haplotypes; they also suggest that such recombination events may be relatively frequent. Moreover, the simplicity and effectiveness of the large-scale PFGE screening approach will be of great help in the study of multigene families and of other loci involved in aberrant recombinations.     

Evolving disease resistance genes

Defenses against most specialized plant pathogens are often initiated by a plant disease resistance gene. Plant genomes encode several classes of genes that can function as resistance genes. Many of the mechanisms that drive the molecular evolution of these genes are now becoming clear. The processes that contribute to the diversity of R genes include tandem and segmental gene duplications, recombination, unequal crossing-over, point mutations, and diversifying selection. Diversity within populations is maintained by balancing selection. Analyses of whole-genome sequences have and will continue to provide new insight into the dynamics of resistance gene evolution.     

Genetic and biochemical consequences of thymidylate stress

We have examined the genetic and biochemical consequences of thymidylate stress in haploid and diploid strains of the simple eukaryote Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Bakers' yeast). Previously we reported that inhibition of dTMP biosynthesis causes "thymineless death" and is highly recombinagenic, but apparently not mutagenic, at the nuclear level; however, it is mutagenic for mitochondria. Concurrent provision of dTMP abolishes these effects. Conversely, excess dTMP is highly mutagenic for nuclear genes. It is likely that DNA strand breaks are responsible for the recombinagenic effects of thymidylate deprivation; such breaks could be produced by reiterative uracil incorporation and excision in DNA repair patches. In our experiments, thymidylate stress was produced both by starving dTMP auxotrophs for the required nucleotide and also by blocking de novo synthesis of thymidylate by various antimetabolites. We found that the antifolate methotrexate is a potent inducer of mitotic recombination (both gene conversion and mitotic crossing-over). This suggests that the gene amplification associated with methotrexate resistance in mammalian cells could arise, in part, by unequal sister-chromatid exchange induced by thymidylate stress. In addition, several sulfa drugs, which impede de novo folate biosynthesis, also have considerable recombinagenic activity.     

Unequal crossing-over within the B duplication of Drosophila melanogaster: a molecular analysis.

The B mutation is associated with a tandem duplication of 16A1-16A7. It is unstable, mutating to wild type and to a more extreme form at a frequency of one in 1000 to 3000. The reversion to wild type is associated with the loss of one copy of the duplication, whereas the mutation to extreme B is associated with a triplication of the region. The instability of B has been attributed to unequal crossing-over between the two copies of the duplication. Recent molecular data show that there is a transposable element, B104, between the two copies of the duplication and support the hypothesis that this element generated the duplication via a recombination event. These data suggest that unequal crossing-over within the duplication may not be the cause of the instability of B. Instead, the instability may be caused by a recombination event involving the B104 element. This issue was addressed using probes for the DNA on either side of the B104 element at the B breakpoint. All of the data indicate that the B104 element is not involved in the instability of B and support the original unequal crossing-over model.     

Modularity, noise, and natural selection

Most biological systems are formed by component parts that are to some degree interrelated. Groups of parts that are more associated among themselves and are relatively autonomous from others are called modules. One of the consequences of modularity is that biological systems usually present an unequal distribution of the genetic variation among traits. Estimating the covariance matrix that describes these systems is a difficult problem due to a number of factors such as poor sample sizes and measurement errors. We show that this problem will be exacerbated whenever matrix inversion is required, as in directional selection reconstruction analysis. We explore the consequences of varying degrees of modularity and signal-to-noise ratio on selection reconstruction. We then present and test the efficiency of available methods for controlling noise in matrix estimates. In our simulations, controlling matrices for noise vastly improves the reconstruction of selection gradients. We also perform an analysis of selection gradients reconstruction over a New World Monkeys skull database to illustrate the impact of noise on such analyses. Noise-controlled estimates render far more plausible interpretations that are in full agreement with previous results.     

Gene conversion and the evolution of three leucine-rich repeat gene families in Arabidopsis thaliana

The high number of duplicated genes in plant genomes provides a potential template for gene conversion and unequal crossing-over. Within a gene family these two processes can render all members homogeneous or generate diversity by reassorting variants among paralogs. The latter is especially feasible in families where gene diversity confers a selective advantage and thus conversion events are likely to be retained. Consequently, the most complete record of gene conversion is expected to be most evident in gene families commonly subjected to positive selection. Here, we describe the extent and characteristics of gene conversion and unequal crossing-over in the coding and noncoding regions of nucleotide-binding site leucine-rich repeat (NBS-LRR), receptor-like kinases (RLK), and receptor-like proteins (RLP) in the plant Arabidopsis thaliana. Members of these three gene families are associated with disease resistance and their pathogen-recognition domain is a documented target of positive selection. Our bioinformatic approach to study the major family features that may influence gene conversion revealed that in these families there is a significant association between the occurrence of gene conversion and high levels of sequence similarity, close physical clustering, gene orientation, and recombination rate. We discuss these results in the context of the overlap between gene conversion and positive selection during the evolutionary expansion of the NBS-LRR, RLK, and RLP gene families.     

The Prader-Willi syndrome and the Angelman syndrome

The Prader-Willi syndrome and the Angelman syndrome are characterised by a complex clinical and behavioural phenotype resulting from loss of paternal or maternal expression, respectively, of genes located on the human chromosome 15q11-13. Different molecular mechanisms leading to this imbalance have been identified, including microdeletions, intragenic mutations, uniparental disomy and imprinting centre defects. Low copy repeat gene clusters are known to flank the 15q11-13 microdeletion. They predispose to unequal crossing-over events resulting in the deletion. Involvement of multiple disease genes is strongly suspected and traditional positional cloning techniques as well as animal models are used to identify the involved genes. In this review we include the present state of art and a delineation of future approach to study the candidate genes in these two syndromes.