In vitro assessment of the toxicity of metal compounds

A review of in vitro mutagenesis assessment of metal compounds in mammalian and nonmammalian test systems has been compiled. Prokaryotic assays are ineffective or inconsistent in their detection of most metals as mutagens, with the notable exception of hexavalent chromium. Mammalian assay systems appear to be similarly inappropriate for the screening of metal compounds based upon the limited number of studies that have employed those compounds having known carcinogenic activity. Although of limited value as screening tests for the detection of potentially carcinogenic metal compounds, the well-characterized in vitro mutagenesis systems may prove to be of significant value as a means to elucidate mechanisms of metal genotoxicity.     

Studies on DNA repair in early spermatid stages of male mice after in vivo treatment with methyl-, ethyl-, propyl-, and isopropyl methanesulfonate.

In vivo DNA repair occurring in early spermatid stages of the mouse has been studied with four mutagens that are chemical homologs: MMS, EMS, PMS and IMS. Using the well-studied sequence of events that occurs during spermatogenesis and spermiogenesis in the mouse, aatids was measured by the unscheduled incorporation of [3H]dT into these germ cells which were recovered from the caudal epididymides 16 days after chemical treatment. Purification of the caudal sperm DNA at this time verified that the [3H]dT was incorporated into the DNA. For each chemical mutagen a study was made on the level of DNA repair occurring in early spermatids as a function of the administered, in vivo dose. Within experimental errors, all four chemicals produced a linear increase in DNA repair in early spermatids with increasing dose. Only the highest dose of MMS (100 mg/kg) produced a greater repair response than expected for a linear curve. At equimolar doses the most effective chemical in inducing DNA repair was MMS, followed by EMS, IMS and PMS. When testicular injections of [3H]dT were given at the same time as the intraperitoneal injections of the mutagens, the amount of unscheduled incorporation of [3H]dT into the DNA of early spermatids was maximized. Since [3H]dT has been shown to be available for incorporation into germ-cell DNA for only approximately 1 h after injection, all four mutagens must reach the DNA of early spermatids and begin producing "repairable" lesions within 1 h after treatment. The amount of DNA repair occurring at later times after chemical treatment of early spermatids was studied by testicular injections of [3H]dT 1/2, 1, 2 and 3 days after chemical treatment. Repair was still occurring in the early spermatids at 3 days post-treatment; this repair is most likely a manifestation of the finite rate of the repair process rather than resulting from newly alkylated DNA. For MMS and EMS there was a rapid decrease in the level of DNA repair in the first 1/2 day following treatment. This was followed by a much slower, exponential decrease in the level of repair out to 3 days post-treatment. The curves suggest that the amount of repair is proportional to the number of repairable lesions still present in the DNA. For PMS and IMS the level of repair decreases rapidly in the first 1/2 day after treatment and thereafter remains relatively constant through 3 days post-treatment. With all four mutagens, DNA repair in early spermatids was detectable at doses 5 to 10 times lower than those required to observe other genetic end points such as dominant lethals, translocations and specific-locus mutations in any germ-cell stage. The sensitivity of detection of in vivo DNA repair in the germ cells of male mice makes such a system a useful adjunct to other genetic tests for studying chemical mutagenesis in mammals.     

Chemical induction of streptomycin-resistant mutations in Escherichia coli. Dose and mutagenic effects of dichlorvos and methyl methanesulfonate

A procedure for the quantitative determination of induced streptomycin-resistant mutants in E. coli was applied to study and compare mutation induction by the organophosphate dichlorvos and by methyl methanesulfonate (MMS). Both compounds increased the frequency of mutants even under conditions where no inactivation of cell was observed. Mutation induction by these agents as a function of both concentration and exposure time was measured. The dose-response curves found with both mutagens were non-linear; atp higher doses more mutants were induced per unit dose than at lower doses. Possible relationships between dose-effect curves and the chemical nature of alkylating mutagenic agents are discussed.     

Unscheduled DNA synthesis in spermatogenic cells of mice treated in vivo with the indirect alkylating agents cyclophosphamide and mitomen

Cyclophosphamide (CPA) and mitomen (DMO) are chemical mutagens that require metabolic activation to produce their biological effect. We have used an in vivo UDS assay in various meiotic and postmeiotic germ-cell stages of male mice to study DNA repair after treatment with these chemicals. EMS, a compound requiring no metabolic activation, was also used for comparative purposes.CPA and DMO induced UDS in meiotic through early-to-midspermatid stages, but no UDS was detected in late spermatids and mature sperm. While EMS produced a maximum UDS response in the germ cells immediately after treatment, CPA and DMO did not produce a maximum response until ～0.5 to 1 h after injection. This delay is attributed to the time required for CPA and DMO to be enzymatically vonverted active alkylating metabolites.Unlike the results found with EMS, mutation frequencies (dominant lethals, translocations, specific-locus mutations) following CPA treatment are not noticeably reduced in germ-cell stages in which UDS occurred. In the case of DMO, mutations are induced only in mature spermatozoa, and these germ-cell stages represent only a fraction of those in which no UDS is detected. The results with CPA and DMO thus still leave unclear the relationship between DNA repair and the differential spermatogenic response of mice to genetic damage.     

Fetal anomalies produced subsequent to treatment of zygotes with ethylene oxide or ethyl methanesulfonate are not likely due to the usual genetic causes

Earlier studies in this laboratory revealed that ethylene oxide (EtO) or ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) induced high frequencies of midgestation and late fetal deaths,and of malformations among some of the surviving fetuses, when female mice were exposed at the time of fertilization of their eggs or during the early pronuclear stage of the zygote. Effects of the two mutagens are virtually identical. Thus, in investigating the mechanisms responsible for the dramatic effects in the early pronuclear zygotes, the two compounds were used interchangeably in the experiments. First, a reciprocal zygote-transfer study was conducted in order to determine whether the effect is directly on the zygotes or indirectly through maternal toxicity. And second, cytogenetic analyses of pronuclear metaphases, early cleavage embryos, and midgestation fetuses were carried out.

The zygote transplantation experiment rules out maternal toxicity as a factor in the fetal maldevelopment. Together with the strict stage specificity observed in the earlier studies, this result points to a genetic cause for the abnormalities. However, the cytogenetic studies failed to show structural or numerical chromosome aberrations. Since intragenic base changes and deletions may also be ruled out, it appears that the lesions in question induced in zygotes by the two mutagens are different from conventional ones and, therefore, could be a novel one in experimental mammalian mutagenesis. Alternatively, the mechanism could invlve a non-mutational ‘imprinting’ process that caused changes in gene expression.     

Carcinogenic aging

In ours and other studies, data have been obtained testifying to the fact that, under the action of various classes of chemical carcinogenic agents (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, nitrous compouds, aromatic amines), other mutagens, ionizing radiation, extremely low frequency (50 Hz), electromagnetic fields (EMFs), constant illumination, and smoking, in the basic homeostatic systems of an organism (nervous, endocrine, immune, and energy homeostasis) premature hormonal, and metabolic shifts occur similar to those arising during physiological aging. These shifts create favorable conditions for the promotion and progression stages of carcinogenesis. The use of genetically modified animals (mutant, transgenic, or knockout) opens new possibilities for analyzing the role of individual genes in the interrelationships between processes of natural and accelerated, by environmental factors, aging. For genetically modified mice with phenotypic signs of accelerated aging, as a rule, the frequency of new-growth development increases, then for animals with decelerated aging, an increase in the latent period of tumor development and/or a decrease in the frequency of their appearance is noted. The application of geroprotectors under conditions of increased risk of accelerated aging resulting genetically or from adverse environmental factors (carcinogens, mutagens, peculiarities in diet) can be a first line prevention against cancer.     

X-rays, microwaves and vinyl chloride monomer: their clastogenic and aneugenic activity, using the micronucleus assay on human lymphocytes.

Chromosome aberration assays, sister-chromatid exchange techniques and micronucleus assays are commonly used methods for biomonitoring genetic material damaged by chemical or physical agents. On the other hand, their aneugenic activity, which can lead to hypoploidy and may also be associated with carcinogenesis, has not been thoroughly investigated. In our study we chose the micronucleus assay with a new mathematical approach to separate clastogenic from aneugenic activity of three well-known mutagens (vinyl chloride monomer, X-rays and microwaves) on the genome of human somatic cells. The comparison of frequencies of size distribution of micronuclei in the lymphocytes of humans exposed to each of these three mutagens showed that X-rays and microwaves were preferentially clastogens while vinyl chloride monomer showed aneugenic activity as well. Microwaves possess some mutagenic characteristics typical of chemical mutagens.     

Specific-locus mutations induced in eukaryotes (especially mammalian cells) by radiation and chemicals: a perspective

In the course of discovering the first mutagen (X-rays) just over 60 years ago, Herman J. Muller asked whether X-rays induced single-gene mutations and/or chromosomal (multiple-gene) mutations. To a large extent, his question has set the agenda for mutagenesis research ever since. We explore historically the answers to this question, with special emphasis on recent developments in the field of mammalian cell mutagenesis. Studies indicate that ionizing radiation and many chemical mutagens/carcinogens induce both gene and chromosomal mutations; however, only certain genetic systems permit the recovery and analysis of both classes of mutations. Few chemical mutagens induce only gene mutations in mammalian cells; instead, most mutagens appear to induce both classes of mutations, with chromosomal mutations (especially multilocus deletions) predominating at high doses. These results have implications regarding the mechanisms of mutagenesis, the role of chromosomal mutations in carcinogenesis and hereditary disease, and the type of data required for risk assessment of physical and chemical mutagens/carcinogens.     

Detection of antigenically active mutant HGPRT after mutagenesis with Simian virus 40.

BCNU and 10 related chloroethylnitrosoureas were tested for their ability to induce sex-linked recessive lethals in Drosophila spermatozoa. All chloroethyl-nitrosoureas tested were potent mutagens.Among the substances with one chloroethylnitrosourea group, chlorozotocin, BCNU and methanesulfonyloxyethyl chloroethylnitrosourea exhibited the strongest mutagenic effects. Two hydroxyalkyl chloroethylnitrosoureas behaved as potent mutagens too, although the mutation frequencies obtained were one order of magnitude lower relative to the other substances.Among the compounds with two chloroethylnitrosourea groups, bisCNU-ethane and bisCNU-diphenylmethane were most active. When the interconnecting polymethylene chain was elongated from 2 methylene groups (bisCNU-ethane) to 6 methylene groups (bisCNU-hexane), the mutagenic activity decreased by a factor of 2. The mutagenic activity of polymethylene bischloroethylnitrosoureas with connecting chains of intermediate length was not different from bisCNU-hexane.Differences in mutagenic activity were supposed to reflect different concentrations reaching the target cells, possibly in part as a result of differences in transportability of the substances.     

Strategies and testing methods for identifying mutagenic risks

The evolution of testing strategies and methods for identification of mutagenic agents is discussed, beginning with the concern over potential health and population effects of chemical mutagens in the late 1940s that led to the development of regulatory guidelines for mutagenicity testing in the 1970s and 1980s. Efforts to achieve international harmonization of mutagenicity testing guidelines are summarized, and current issues and needs in the field are discussed, including the need for quantitative methods of mutagenic risk assessment, dose-response thresholds, indirect mechanisms of mutagenicity, and the predictivity of mutagenicity assays for carcinogenicity in vivo. Speculation is offered about the future of mutagenicity testing, including possible near-term changes in standard test batteries and the longer-term roles of expression profiling of damage-response genes, in vivo mutagenicity testing methods, and models that better account for differences in metabolism between humans and laboratory model systems.     

The complete nucleotide sequence of Chinese hamster (Cricetulus griseus) mitochondrial DNA.

Mammalian mitochondria contain their own approximately 16.5 kb circular genome. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) encodes for a subset of the proteins involved in the electron transport chain and depletion or mutation of the sequence is implicated in a number of human disease processes. The recent finding is that mitochondrial damage mediates genotoxicity after exposure to chemical carcinogens has focused attention on the role of mtDNA mutations in the development of cancer. Although the entire genome has been sequenced for a number of mammals, only a small fraction of the mtDNA sequence is available for hamsters. We have obtained here the entire 16,284 bp sequence of the Chinese hamster mitochondrial genome, which will enable detailed analysis of mtDNA mutations caused by exposure to mutagens in hamster-derived cell lines.     

Micronucleus test and bone-marrow chromosome analysis: A comparison of 2 methods in vivo for evaluating chemically induced chromosomal alterations

The sensitivities of 2 cytogenetic tests, chromosome analysis and the micronucleus test, were compared by using mice exposed to the substances methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), mitomycin C (MC) and procarbazine (Natulan®). The lowest dose at which a significant effect could be observed in bone-marrow cells of mice was determined. Both test systems proved equally sensitive for MC and procarbazine. Doses as low as 0.16 mg of MC per kg and 3.12 mg of Natulan® per kg significantly increased both the aberration rates and the micronucleus rates above those of the controls. In contrast, after exposure to MMS, chromosomal aberrations were elevated above control levels at 5 mg/kg, and the micronucleus rate differed significantly from that of the controls after a dose of 10 mg/kg. With the present protocol and sample size one can conclude that the micronucleus test is generally comparable in sensitivity to the chromosome analysis. However, the MMS data indicate that there might be chemicals for which the resolution of the chromosome analysis is higher.

When the mutagens were given in 2 single i.p. injections separated by 24 h, the polychromatic erythrocytes were analyzed for the presence of micronuclei 6 or 24 h after the second injection. The double treatment did not increase the micronucleus rates above the single-treatment results at either sampling interval.     

Genetic analysis of X-linked mutagen-sensitive mutants of Drosophila melanogaster

Mutants at 2 new loci which control mutagen-sensitivity are described. Mutants at both loci are female-sterile and are hypersensitive to killing by MMS; neither increases the frequency of sex-linked recessive lethals. A screen of previously described female-sterile and meotic mutants has revealed that a number of these are also sensitive to mutagens. In addition, several new mutants have been identified on the basis of sensitivity to either HN2 or MMS. An anlysis of complementation data suggests that all of the X-linked genes controlling sensitivity to MMS may now have been identified. Among the new mei-41 alleles are mutants which show verly little meiotic nondisjunction or loss. Cytogenetic mapping of previously known mutants is also described. The mutants mus(1)104^D1 and mei-41^D5 are located in th eregion 14B13±?14D1,2 on the polytene chromosome map, and they map very close to each other genetically. Cytogenetically mus(1)101^D1 is between salivary chromosome bands 12A6,7 and 12D3, mus(1)103^D1 is between bands 12A1,2 and 12A6,7, and mus(1)-109^A1 is in section 8F3-9A2.     

Noncoding sequences of the eukaryotic genome as an additional protection of genes from chemical mutagens

A quantitative model was developed that detects a new function of noncoding sequences in the eukaryotic genome, namely, the protection of coding sequences from chemical (mainly endogenous) mutagens. It was shown that, under common ecological conditions, the number of nucleotides damaged by mutagens in coding sequences of the genome is inversely proportional to the size of their noncoding counterparts. Noncoding sequences can differently protect single genetic loci from chemical mutagens by the formation of specific spatial structures of the protected loci in the interphase nuclei. The significant differences in genome sizes between species (paradox C) can be explained by different contributions of noncoding sequences to the total effect of genome protection from endogenous chemical mutagens.     

Whole embryo culture, teratogenesis, and the estimation of teratologic risk

Mammalian whole-embryo culture systems are now widely used and have proved useful in many studies of normal and abnormal development. The main advantages of these systems are that they allow precise control of experimental conditions and can often provide information unobtainable from in vivo studies; the main disadvantages are the rather short period of embryonic development that can be supported in culture and the present restriction of the techniques to very few species. The possibility of using whole-embryo culture systems for screening for new teratogenic agents remains controversial, but there are indications that the systems may have more potential in this area than has sometimes been supposed.     

Tradescantia stamen-hair system as an excellent botanical tester of mutagenicity: its responses to ionizing radiations and chemical mutagens, and some synergistic effects found.

The stamen-hair system of Tradescantia heterozygous for flower color (blue/pink, the pink color being recessive) is an excellent botanical tester of mutagenicity. It is especially useful for detection of the genetic effects of both ionizing radiations and chemical mutagens at the low levels of exposure to which the human population may actually be exposed. This system exhibits a high accuracy in laboratory experiments, and is also applicable for in situ monitoring in the environment. The use of the Tradescantia stamen-hair system is inexpensive and requires only a short training time. Simplified scoring methods which endorse a high statistical accuracy have newly been developed to score larger samples of pink somatic mutations. In the present paper, the most widely used clones, methods for their cultivation, and use in a variety of experiments with radiations and chemical mutagens are also reviewed.     

Metronidazole (Flagyl): lack of induction of sister-chromatid exchanges in CHO-K1 cells

328 X-linked recessive lethal mutations induced in late spermatids by hycanthone methanesulfonate were tested for coverage by duplications that comprised, in total, about 24% of the euchromatic X chromosome; 78 lethals appeared to be covered. Crossover localization tests of a random sample of 38 non-covered lethals revealed 4 chromosomes carrying a lethal within a duplicated segment. Lethals localized to a particular region were crossed to reference deficiencies and single-locus mutations, and inter se, to ascertain their genetic extent. The proportion of multi-locus deletions among these 78 covered and 4 non-covered lethals was 3/48, 1/10 and 13/24 for the distal, medial and proximal regions, respectively. A storage period of 9 days did not noticeably influence these proportions. In the sample of 38 non-covered lethals, and among 17 of the covered single-site lethals, 4 cases of strong crossover suppression were detected. Comparison of these results with data obtained with other mutagens suggests that induction of multi-locus deletions, and possibly of other types of chromosome rearrangement, could in part depend on other mechanisms than those acting in the formation of translocations and chromosome loss. For the purpose of mutagen testing, these findings imply that, in Drosophila, results in the regular genetic tests for chromosome breakage events do not always accurately predict the capacity of a mutagen to induce multi-locus deletions. This is of importance since transmissible multi-locus deletions have been considered a significant source of genetic damage in man.     

DNA single-strand breaks,double-strand breaks,and crosslinks in rat testicular germ cells: Measurements of their formation and repair by alkaline and neutral filter elution

This work describes a neutral and alkaline elution method for measuring DNA single-strand breaks (SSBs), DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), and DNA-DNA crosslinks in rat testicular germ cells after treatments in vivo or in vitro with both chemical mutagens and gamma-irradiation. The methods depend upon the isolation of testicular germ cells by collagenase and trypsin digestion, followed by filtration and centrifugation. ¹³⁷Cs irradiation induced both DNA SSBs and DSBs in germ cells held on ice in vitro. Irradiation of the whole animal indicated that both types of DNA breaks are induced in vivo and can be repaired. A number of germ cell mutagens induced either DNA SSBs, DSBs, or cross-links after in vivo and in vitro dosing. These chemicals included methyl methane sulfonate, ethyl methane sulfonate, ethyl nitrosurea, dibromochlorpropane, ethylene dibromide, triethylene melamine, and mitomycin C. These results suggest that the blood-testes barrier is relatively ineffective for these mutagens, which may explain in part their in vivo mutagenic potency.This assay should be a useful screen for detecting chemical attack upon male germ-cell DNA and thus, it should help in the assessment of the mutagenic risk of chemicals. In addition, this approach can be used to study the processes of SSB, DSB, and crosslink repair in DNA of male germ cells, either from all stages or specific stages of development.Abbreviations DBCP dibromochlorpropane - DSB(s) DNA double-strand break(s) - EDB ethylene dibromide - EMS ethyl methane sulfonate - ENU ethyl nitrosurea - MC mitomycin C - MMS methyl methane sulfonate - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate - SSB (s) DNA single-strand break(s) - TEM triethylene melamine - UDS unscheduled DNA synthesis     

Antimutagenicity of secondary metabolites from higher plants.

Higher plants contain both mutagens and antimutagens and are susceptible to mutagenesis but screening programs for detection of antimutagenesis rarely employ higher plant systems. Short-term bacterial and mammalian tissue culture systems are the norm. Using modified screening tests for detecting antimutagenic agents, higher plants have been shown to contain a variety of structurally novel antimutagenic agents. Systematic bioassay-directed methodology resulted in the isolation in pure form and biological and chemical characterization of the responsible individual active components from various plants. The methodology in use is illustrated by the isolation of cinnamic acid, cinnamyl cinnamate and cinnamyl ricinoleate as the active constituents of the classic medicinal plant product, Styrax asiatica. The methods which may be used to reveal structure-activity relationships and to explore putative molecular modes of action are illustrated with excerpts from the same study.     

Strange goings-on in the mouse germ line

It is a conventional paradigm that mutagens lead to changes in nucleotide sequence when the cell attempts to repair or replicate lesions in DNA (such as adducts or strand breaks) that have been produced by the mutagens or their metabolites. The resulting changes are located at (or very near) the sites of the initial damage. This is the underlying theory behind mutational spectra work, but how general is it in vivo? Work with ionising radiation has shown that there are interesting things going on in the mouse germ line that do not fall within the conventional paradigm. Mutations occur at certain sites remote from initial DNA damage and in greater than expected number. Bryn Bridges discusses some recent papers on mutational changes in the germ line of mice following exposure to chemical mutagens that suggest that such phenomena may not be confined to radiation.