Comparison of Signal and Bactec NR-660 blood culture systems

M. STEVENS, M.B. PRENTICE, R.A. SWANN, C.J. MITCHELL AND A. DONKIN. 1993. The Signal blood culture system was compared with the Bactec NR-660. A total of 1617 blood culture sets yielded 143 (8.8%) significant isolates; 113 (79.0%) were from positive bottles in both the Bactec and Signal systems. Twelve organisms (8.4%) were detected and isolated from the Signal system only and another 18 (12.6%) from the Bactec system only. Of these 18, five were Signal-positive but the organism was not recovered and four organisms were isolated from negative Signal bottles on terminal subculture. The time taken to detection for each system was similar; the Signal system detected 68% and the Bactec 63% of significant positives within 24 h. At 48 h Bactec detected 91% and the Signal 85%. A significantly-reduced number of bottles which gave a positive signal but were negative by microscopical and cultural methods was found, compared with previous reports. The 1 h incubation period prior to the insertion of the Signal growth indicator device was considered to be the cause of this reduction in the proportion of false positives.
Fifty-five percent (42/77) of the Bactec false positives were due to delta growth value. This is when there is an increase in the growth index of ≥ 15 without the positive threshold level of 30 being attained. This occurred in the anaerobic bottle on day 2 with 42 bottles. Another 40% (31/77) of the false positives had a growth value between the positive threshold of 30 and a value of 35.
Eighty (4.9%) of Bactec and 65 (4.0%) of Signal sets yielded clinically non-significant isolates. Although the yield of significant isolates for the two systems was similar, Signal failed to detect a small number of medically important organisms without subculture.     

Detection of volatile metabolites produced by bacterial growth in blood culture media by selected ion flow tube mass spectrometry (SIFT-MS)

To achieve faster bacteremia diagnosis, selected ion flow tube mass spectrometry (SIFT-MS) measured metabolic gases in the headspaces of BacT/ALERT blood culture bottles. Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Streptococcus pneumoniae, Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus and Neisseria meningitidis growth and trace gas patterns were detected from 10 colony forming units after 6 h.     

The Microflora of Hand Washed Milk Bottles

S ummary . The examination of a series of 713 milk bottles cleansed by hand washing at producer-retailer farm dairies showed that though nearly 60% attained satisfactory bacteriological standards, about 30% gave high colony counts (>600/bottle), while coli-aerogenes organisms were found in 17% and milk spoilage organisms in 25% of them. The microflora of efficiently cleansed bottles, with colony counts of <200/bottle, was dominated by micrococci and aerobic sporeforming rods. Only 3.7% of the 259 cultures from these bottles gave acid reactions in litmus milk in 72 h at 22°. Inefficiently cleansed bottles, with colony counts of >600/bottle, had quite a different type of microflora which was usually dominated by Gram negative rods (achromobacteria, nonfluorescent pseudomonads and flavobacteria). A much higher proportion (19%) of the 393 cultures from these bottles gave acid reactions in litmus milk.     

The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus,BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS

Detection and identification of anaerobic bacteria in blood cultures (BC) is a well-recognized challenge in clinical microbiology. We studied 100 clinical anaerobic BC isolates to evaluate the performance of BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus (BioMérieux), BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic (Becton Dickinson BioSciences) BC bottles in detection and time to detection (TTD) of anaerobic bacteria. BACTEC Lytic had higher detection rate (94/100, 94%) than BacT/ALERT FN Plus (80/100, 80%) (p<0.01) in the studied material. There was no significant difference in detection of anaerobic bacteria among the remaining bottle types. The 67 anaerobic bacteria that signalled positive in all four bottle types were analyzed to compare the time to detection (TTD) and isolates were directly identified by MALDI-TOF MS. There was a significant difference in TTD among the four bottle types (p<0.0001). The shortest median TTD was 18 h in BACTEC Lytic followed by BacT/ALERT FN (23.5 h), BACTEC Plus (27 h) and finally BacT/ALERT FN Plus (38 h) bottles. In contrast, MALDI-TOF MS performed similarly in all bottle types with accurate identification in 51/67 (76%) BacT/ALERT FN, 51/67 (76%) BacT/ALERT FN Plus, 53/67 (79%) BACTEC Plus and 50/67 (75%) BACTEC Lytic bottles. In conclusion, BACTEC Lytic bottles have significantly better detection rates and shorter TTD compared to the three other bottle types. The anaerobic BC bottles are equally suitable for direct MALDI-TOF MS for rapid and reliable identification of common anaerobic bacteria. Further clinical studies are warranted to investigate the performance of anaerobic BC bottles in detection of anaerobic bacteria and identification by direct MALDI-TOF MS.     

On-line monitoring of microbial volatile metabolites by proton transfer reaction-mass spectrometry

A method for analysis of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from microbial cultures was established using proton transfer reaction-mass spectrometry (PTR-MS). A newly developed sampling system was coupled to a PTR-MS instrument to allow on-line monitoring of VOCs in the dynamic headspaces of microbial cultures. The novel PTR-MS method was evaluated for four reference organisms: Escherichia coli, Shigella flexneri, Salmonella enterica, and Candida tropicalis. Headspace VOCs in sampling bottles containing actively growing cultures and uninoculated culture medium controls were sequentially analyzed by PTR-MS. Characteristic marker ions were found for certain microbial cultures: C. tropicalis could be identified by several unique markers compared with the other three organisms, and E. coli and S. enterica were distinguishable from each other and from S. flexneri by specific marker ions, demonstrating the potential of this method to differentiate between even closely related microorganisms. Although the temporal profiles of some VOCs were similar to the growth dynamics of the microbial cultures, most VOCs showed a different temporal profile, characterized by constant or decreasing VOC levels or by single or multiple peaks over 24 h of incubation. These findings strongly indicate that the temporal evolution of VOC emissions during growth must be considered if characterization or differentiation based on microbial VOC emissions is attempted. Our study may help to establish the analysis of VOCs by on-line PTR-MS as a routine method in microbiology and as a tool for monitoring environmental and biotechnological processes.     

Comparison of automated culture systems with a CFR/USP-compliant method for sterility testing of cell-therapy products

BACKGROUND: Although widely used, commercially available automated culture methods are not US Food and Drug Administration-approved for sterility testing of cell-therapy products. For cell-therapy products regulated under Section 351 of the Public Health Service Act, sterility testing must be performed by the methods described in 21 CFR 610.12 and USP <71> (CFR/USP method), or by methods demonstrated to be equivalent. METHODS: Two automated methods, BacT/Alert (BTA; bioMerieux) and Bactec (Becton Dickinson), were compared with the CFR/USP method. Representative mononuclear cell (MNC) products were formulated using six different product media. MNC product aliquots containing 10-50 x 10(6) cells in a 0.5 mL volume were seeded with organisms, and cultured for 14 days in aerobic and anaerobic bottles of each system. Ten different organisms at target concentrations of 10 and 50 colony-forming units (CFU) per bottle were tested. RESULTS: Positives were detected in a mean (range) of 72% (7-100%) of cultures for CFR/USP, 82% (0-100%) for BTA, and 93% (57-100%) for Bactec. For nine of the 10 organisms tested, overall detection rates for BTA and Bactec were equivalent to or higher than CFR/USP. Of the six product media tested, detection of organisms was impaired only by the medium containing multiple antibiotics: this occurred in all three systems. Both BTA and Bactec had shorter times to detection than the CFR/USP method, with overall means (ranges) of 87 (24-264) h for CFR/USP, 24 (12-54) h for BTA, and 33 (12-80) h for Bactec. Detection occurred consistently within 7 days for both BTA and Bactec, but not for CFR/USP. DISCUSSION: Both BTA and Bactec are superior to the CFR/USP method for overall detection and time to detection of organisms in MNC products suspended in commonly used media. These data support general use of either BTA or Bactec for sterility testing of a variety of cell-therapy products, and suggest that a 7-day culture period is sufficient to detect clinically relevant organisms. These results confirm the need for bacteriostasis and fungistasis testing of antibiotic-containing products, even when antibiotic-binding substances are used.     

Real-time detection of common microbial volatile organic compounds from medically important fungi by Selected Ion Flow Tube-Mass Spectrometry (SIFT-MS)

We describe a new method, Selected Ion Flow Tube-Mass Spectrometry (SIFT-MS) for the rapid and sensitive real-time detection and quantification of volatile organic compounds from medically important fungi, grown on a range of laboratory media. SIFT-MS utilises the chemical ionisation reactions of mass-selected ions to characterise volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that are produced as metabolites from fungi. This technique has the distinct advantage over others in that it readily detects low molecular weight, reactive volatiles, and allows for real-time, quantitative monitoring. The fungi examined in this study were Aspergillus flavus, Aspergillus fumigatus, Candida albicans, Mucor racemosus, Fusarium solani, and Cryptococcus neoformans grown on or in malt extract agar, Columbia agar, Sabouraud's dextrose agar, blood agar, and brain-heart infusion broth. Common metabolites (ethanol, methanol, acetone, acetaldehyde, methanethiol, and crotonaldehyde) were detected and quantified. We found the fingerprint of volatiles, in terms of presence and quantity of volatiles to be strongly dependent on the culture medium, both in terms of variety and quantity of volatiles produced, but may form the basis for species specific identification of medically important fungi.     

Effects of preincubation temperature on the detection of fastidious organisms in delayed-entry samples in the BacT/ALERT 3D blood culture system

This study evaluates the effect of preincubation on delayed-entry samples for fastidious organisms including the HACEK group, Streptococcus species, Neisseria meningitidis, Haemophilus species and Corynebacterium species for the BacT/ALERT 3D System (bioMérieux) using the FA (aerobic) medium.Bottles were inoculated with two different concentrations (0.5 McFarland and a 1:100,000 dilution) of each organism and either loaded into the system immediately or stored at 4 °C, room temperature (RT) or 37 °C for 24 hours (h) prior to loading.The detection rate (DR) was 92.5% for bottles loaded immediately for both concentrations with a mean time to detection (TTD) of 26.7 h (standard deviation (SD): 14.7 h) for the low concentration and 9.21 h (SD: 5.3 h) for the high concentration. Preincubation at 4 °C did not affect the DR for either of the two concentrations in comparison to no preincubation. The DR at RT was 90.0% for the low concentration and 83.6% for the high concentration. At 37 °C the DR was 76.3% and 66.3% for the low and the high concentrations respectively. The average TTD was inversely correlated with the preincubation temperature. An incubation of four days was sufficient, with the exception of Eikenella corrodens and Gemella sanguinis. The serotype of Streptococcus pneumoniae or Neisseria meningitidis did not influence the TTD. Kingella kingae remained undetected.For the retrieval of the above mentioned bacteria we recommend storage of bottles at room temperature. In case of erroneous storage at 37 °C subcultivation is advisable.All cases with a negative result on day four should be reevaluated and eventually new material for alternative diagnostic procedures should be retrieved.     

Clinical evaluation of polymerase chain reaction coupled with quantum dot fluorescence analysis in the identification of bacteria and yeasts in patients with suspected bloodstream infections

Bloodstream infections are serious and complex infectious diseases that often require a rapid diagnosis. Polymerase chain reaction coupled with quantum dot fluorescence analysis (PCR-QDFA) is a novel diagnostic technique. This study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic performance of PCR-QDFA for pathogen detection in patients with suspected bloodstream infections (BSIs). It evaluates 29 kinds of common pathogens (24 bacteria and 5 yeasts) from blood culture bottles. The results of PCR-QDFA identification and traditional microbial laboratory identification were compared, and the latter was used as the ‘gold standard’ to analyse the diagnostic performance of the PCR-QDFA. In total, 517 blood culture bottles were included in this study. The PCR-QDFA identified microorganisms in 368/422 (87.2%) samples with monomicrobial growth. For the pathogens on the PCR-QDFA list, the assay showed a higher sensitivity of 97.4% (368/378). When polymicrobial growth was analysed, the PCR-QDFA successfully detected 19/25 (76%) microorganisms on the PCR-QDFA list. In addition, 82/82 negative blood culture bottles also showed no pathogens by PCR-QDFA with a specificity of 100%. In conclusion, the PCR-QDFA assay could identify a majority of the common pathogens encountered in clinical practice, showing excellent diagnostic performance for pathogen detection in patients with suspected BSIs.     

Evaluation of blood culture bottles seeded with X-V factors for the detection of Neisseria meningitidis and Haemophilus influenzae

The purpose of this in vitro study was to determine the ability of seeded and not-seeded commercial pediatric blood culture bottles to support the growth of the most frequently responsible microorganisms for bacterial meningitides (Neisseria meningitidis, and Haemophilus influenzae). Tests have been carried out with an automated colorimetric pediatric blood culture system, BacTAlert, Organon Teknika. Bottles were inoculated with X-V factors and serial dilutions of the each bacterium in six times (10(1)-10(6) colony forming unit [CFU]/ml). The bottles, which were supplemented with X-V factors, proved to be effective and time to detection (TTD) was shorter than the un-seeded bottles (p0.05). Time difference between seeded and not-seeded bottles was getting greater at high dilutions of both bacteria. We consider that in presence of a few bacteria, the seeding of bottles with X-V factors is very critical obtaining N. meningitidis, and H. influenzae as the causative agents of meningitidis. The recovery rate of the microorganisms, which were isolated from cerebrospinal fluid by using the X-V factor-seeded blood culture bottles, is therefore higher than with the conventional culture methods.     

Roadmap to approval: use of an automated sterility test method as a lot release test for Carticel, autologous cultured chondrocytes

BACKGROUND: In February 2004, FDA approved a supplement to our biologics license for Carticel, autologous cultured chondrocytes, to use the BacT/ALERT microbial detection system as an alternative to the compendial sterility test for lot release. This article provides a roadmap to our approval process. The approval represents more than 4 years of development and validation studies comparing the Steritest compact system to the BacT/ALERT microbial detection system. METHODS: For this study, freshly cultured chondrocytes were prepared from a characterized cell bank. Microbial isolates were prepared from either American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) strains or from in-house contaminants. For each test condition, a suspension of chondrocyte cells and test organisms was inoculated into both aerobic media (SA standard adult culture bottles, FA FAN, tryptic soy broth) and anaerobic media (SN standard adult culture bottles, FN FAN, fluid thioglycollate media) and tested for sterility using the Steritest compact system (Millipore, Bedford, MA, USA) and the BacT/ALERT microbial detection system (bioMerieux, Durham, NC, USA). Negative control bottles were inoculated with chondrocytes and no microorganisms. All bottles were incubated for 14 days and read daily. Bacterial growth was determined by either visual examination of Steritest canisters or detection of a positive by the BacT/ALERT system. A gram stain and streak plate were used to confirm positive bottles and negative bottles after 14 days. RESULTS: The detection of a positive by either the Steritest compact system or the BacT/ALERT system was summarized for each organism in each validation study. Data generated from studies reducing the incubation temperature from 35 degrees C to 32 degrees C improved detection times in the automated method compared with the compendial method. Other improvements included the use of FAN aerobic and anaerobic media to absorb the gentamicin contained in the culture media of prepared chondrocyte samples. Chondrocytes alone did not generate positive results in either the compendial method or the automated method. DISCUSSION: Data from validation studies support the use of the BacT/ALERT microbial detection system as an alternative sterility test for Carticel.     

THE EVOLUTION OF FLORAL SCENT AND OLFACTORY PREFERENCES IN POLLINATORS: COEVOLUTION OR PRE‐EXISTING BIAS?

Coevolution is thought to be a major factor in shaping plant-pollinator interactions. Alternatively, plants may have evolved traits that fitted pre-existing preferences or morphologies in the pollinators. Here, we test these two scenarios in the plant family of Araceae and scarab beetles (Coleoptera, Scarabaeidae) as pollinators. We focused on floral volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and production/detection of VOCs by scarab beetles. We found phylogenetic structure in the production/detection of methoxylated aromatics in scarabs, but not plants. Within the plants, most of the compounds showed a well-supported pattern of correlated evolution with scarab-beetle pollination. In contrast, the scarabs showed no correlation between VOC production/detection and visitation to Araceae flowers, with the exception of the VOC skatole. Moreover, many VOCs were found in nonpollinating beetle groups (e.g., Melolonthinae) that are ancestors of pollinating scarabs. Importantly, none of the tested VOCs were found to have originated in pollinating taxa. Our analysis indicates a Jurassic origin of VOC production/detection in scarabs, but a Cretaceous/Paleocene origin of floral VOCs in plants. Therefore, we argue against coevolution, instead supporting the scenario of sequential evolution of floral VOCs in Araceae driven by pre-existing bias of pollinators.     

革兰阴性菌引起的血培养阳性标本直接细菌鉴定和药敏的应用

目的 评估血培养阳性标本直接细菌鉴定和药敏可行性.方法 将血培养瓶放入Bact/Alert 3D 60血培养系统进行培养筛选.选取78份含革兰阴性杆菌的阳性血培养瓶进行试验.抽取培养液,用BD真空分离管离心血细胞.在收集到足量菌液后,用VITEK-32革兰阴性菌鉴定药敏卡做直接鉴定药敏试验.用标准方法及亚培养后的鉴定药敏试验对直接鉴定药敏试验进行评估.结果 VITEK-32直接鉴定试验,78株中的74株(94.9％)准确鉴定,直接药敏试验标准符合率95.6％.KB法血标本直接药敏试验标准符合率96.2％,但微小错误率高于VITEK-32直接药敏法.结论 Bact/Alert血培养阳性标本直接VITEK-32细菌鉴定和药敏对革兰阴性菌是切实可行的,可大幅度缩短时间,为临床及时修正用药提供依据,具有较高的应用价值.     

Petrol exhaust pollution impairs honey bee learning and memory

Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) serve as important infochemicals, mediating several ecological interactions including herbivory and pollination. Atmospheric pollutants including traffic‐related air pollution may impair the detection of VOCs used by insects in insect–plant interactions. We investigated the indirect effect of petrol exhaust pollution on olfactory learning and memory (short and long term) in honey bees. Using appetitive olfactory conditioning, we trained bees to learn one of four floral VOC profiles; linalool, dipentene, myrcene and geranium. VOCs were unpolluted or polluted with exhaust collected from a petrol generator. Exhaust emissions included concentrations of CO (246.07 + 17 ppm), NO (20.50 + 6.90 ppb) and NO2 (20.93 + 0.05 ppb) consistent with those typically encountered in urban areas and near roads. Once bees had learnt the training VOC, we tested whether they could recognise that VOC 1 h, 24 h and 48 h post‐training. Bees took significantly longer to learn polluted VOCs and forgot them faster than unpolluted ones. We also tested the ‘masking’ potential of pollution on floral VOCs. Using gas chromatography mass spectroscopy we noted differences in the chemical profile of polluted versus unpolluted VOCs and tested whether bees could recognise polluted VOCs if trained using unpolluted ones. For several VOCs tested, bees could distinguish between polluted and unpolluted VOCs. Ultimately, our results show that air pollution changes the recognition and retention of floral VOCs by bees which may consequently impact foraging efficiency.     

“Salvage Microbiology”: Detection of Bacteria Directly from Clinical Specimens following Initiation of Antimicrobial Treatment

Background

PCR coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is a diagnostic approach that has demonstrated the capacity to detect pathogenic organisms from culture negative clinical samples after antibiotic treatment has been initiated. [1] We describe the application of PCR/ESI-MS for detection of bacteria in original patient specimens that were obtained after administration of antibiotic treatment in an open investigation analysis.

Methods

We prospectively identified cases of suspected bacterial infection in which cultures were not obtained until after the initiation of antimicrobial treatment. PCR/ESI-MS was performed on 76 clinical specimens that were submitted for conventional microbiology testing from 47 patients receiving antimicrobial treatment.

Findings

In our series, 72% (55/76) of cultures obtained following initiation of antimicrobial treatment were non-diagnostic (45 negative cultures; and 10 respiratory specimens with normal flora (5), yeast (4), or coagulase-negative staphylococcus (1)). PCR/ESR-MS detected organisms in 83% (39/47) of cases and 76% (58/76) of the specimens. Bacterial pathogens were detected by PCR/ESI-MS in 60% (27/45) of the specimens in which cultures were negative. Notably, in two cases of relapse of prosthetic knee infections in patients on chronic suppressive antibiotics, the previous organism was not recovered in tissue cultures taken during extraction of the infected knee prostheses, but was detected by PCR/ESI-MS.

Conclusion

Molecular methods that rely on nucleic acid amplification may offer a unique advantage in the detection of pathogens collected after initiation of antimicrobial treatment and may provide an opportunity to target antimicrobial therapy and “salvage” both individual treatment regimens as well as, in select cases, institutional antimicrobial stewardship efforts.     

Inactivation of fecal bacteria in drinking water by solar heating.

We report simulations of the thermal effect of strong equatorial sunshine on water samples contaminated with high populations of fecal coliforms. Water samples, heavily contaminated with a wild-type strain of Escherichia coli (starting population = 20 x 10(5) CFU/ml), are heated to those temperatures recorded for 2-liter samples stored in transparent plastic bottles and exposed to full Kenyan sunshine (maximum water temperature, 55 degrees C). The samples are completely disinfected within 7 h, and no viable E. coli organisms are detected at either the end of the experiment or a further 12 h later, showing that no bacterial recovery has occurred. The feasibility of employing solar disinfection for highly turbid, fecally contaminated water is discussed.     

Volatile metabolomic signature of bladder cancer cell lines based on gas chromatography–mass spectrometry

Introduction

Recent studies provide a convincing support that the presence of cancer cells in the body leads to the alteration of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) emanating from biological samples, particularly of those closely related with tumoral tissues. Thus, a great interest emerged for the study of cancer volatilome and subsequent attempts to confirm VOCs as potential diagnostic biomarkers.

Objectives

The aim of this study was to determine the volatile metabolomic signature of bladder cancer (BC) cell lines and provide an in vitro proof-of-principle that VOCs emanated into the extracellular medium may discriminate BC cells from normal bladder epithelial cells.

Methods

VOCs in the culture media of three BC cell lines (Scaber, J82, 5637) and one normal bladder cell line (SV-HUC-1) were extracted by headspace-solid phase microextraction and analysed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (HS-SPME/GC–MS). Two different pH (pH 2 and 7) were used for VOCs extraction to infer the best pH to be used in in vitro metabolomic studies.

Results

Multivariate analysis revealed a panel of volatile metabolites that discriminated cancerous from normal bladder cells, at both pHs, although a higher number of discriminative VOCs was obtained at neutral pH. Most of the altered metabolites were ketones and alkanes, which were generally increased in BC compared to normal cells, and alcohols, which were significantly decreased in BC cells. Among them, three metabolites, namely 2-pentadecanone, dodecanal and γ-dodecalactone (the latter only tentatively identified), stood out as particularly important metabolites and promising volatile biomarkers for BC detection. Furthermore, our results also showed the potential of VOCs in discriminating BC cell lines according to tumour grade and histological subtype.

Conclusions

We demonstrate that a GC–MS metabolomics-based approach for analysis of VOCs is a valuable strategy for identifying new and specific biomarkers that may improve BC diagnosis. Future studies should entail the validation of volatile signature found for BC cell lines in biofluids from BC patients.

     

Real time analysis of breath volatiles using SIFT-MS in cigarette smoking

The selected ion flow tube mass spectrometry (SIFT-MS) technique enables real time analysis of trace volatiles at ppb levels without preconcentration steps or chemical derivatization. Most previous studies of trace compounds on the breath were analyzed using gas chromatography where enhanced detection sensitivity was achieved by concentrating the breath using cryogenic or adsorption trapping techniques. In this paper, we have examined volatile organic substances, isoprene, acetone, ammonia and ethanol in breath before and after smoking a cigarette. It is interesting that isoprene levels increased in all the subjects after smoking one cigarette with a mean increase of 70%. The mean increase for acetone was found to be 22%. In contrast to isoprene, a decreasing ethanol level was observed in all the subjects except one with the negative mean decrease of 28%. Further SIFT-MS studies also have high-lighted some organic substances produced even by unburned cigarettes, US and New Zealand products. Certain US brands have shown much higher levels of volatile species than cigarettes produced in New Zealand.     

Determinants for nasal trigeminal detection of volatile organic compounds

We explored the influence of methodological and chemical parameters on the detection of nasal chemesthesis (i.e., trigeminal stimulation) evoked by volatile organic compounds (VOCs). To avoid odor biases, chemesthesis was probed via nasal pungency detection in anosmics and via nasal localization (i.e., lateralization) in normosmics, in both cases using forced-choice procedures. In the experiments with anosmics, 12 neat VOCs were selected based on previous reports of lack of chemesthetic response. Although none of the VOCs reached 100% detection, detectability and confidence of detection were higher when using a glass vessel system adapted with nosepieces to fit the nostrils tightly than when using wide-mouth glass jars. Half the stimuli were detected well above chance and half were not. When the latter were tested again after being heated to 37 degrees C, that is, body temperature (from room temperature, 23 degrees C), to increase their vapor concentration, only one, octane, significantly increased its detectability. Chemesthesis gauged with normosmics mirrored that with anosmics. Gas chromatography measurements showed that, even at 23 degrees C, the saturated vapor concentrations of the undetected stimuli, except vanillin, were well above the respective calculated nasal pungency threshold (NPT) from an equation that, in the past, had accurately described and predicted NPTs. We conclude that, except for octane and perhaps vanillin, the failure of the other four VOCs to precipitate nasal chemesthesis rests on a chemical-structural limitation, for example, the molecules lack a key property to fit a receptor pocket, rather than on a concentration limitation, for example, the vapor concentration is too low to reach a threshold value.     

Comparative life cycle assessment and social life cycle assessment of used polyethylene terephthalate (PET) bottles in Mauritius

Purpose

Improper disposal of used polyethylene terephthalate (PET) bottles constitute an eyesore to the environmental landscape and is a threat to the flourishing tourism industry in Mauritius. It is therefore imperative to determine a suitable disposal method of used PET bottles which not only has the least environmental load but at the same time has minimum harmful impacts on peoples employed in waste disposal companies. In this respect, the present study investigated and compared the environmental and social impacts of four selected disposal alternatives of used PET bottles.

Methods

Environmental impacts of the four disposal alternatives, namely: 100 % landfilling, 75 % incineration with energy recovery and 25 % landfilling, 40 % flake production (partial recycling) and 60 % landfilling and 75 % flake production and 25 % landfilling, were determined using ISO standardized life cycle assessment (ISO 14040:2006) and with the support of SimaPro 7.1 software. Social life cycle assessments were performed based on the UNEP/SETAC Guidelines for Social Life Cycle Assessment of products. Three stakeholder categories (worker, society and local community) and eight sub-category indicators (child labour, fair salary, forced labour, health and safety, social benefit/social security, discrimination, contribution to economic development and community engagement) were identified to be relevant to the study. A new method for aggregating and analysing the social inventory data is proposed and used to draw conclusions.

Results and discussion

Environmental life cycle assessment results indicated that highest environmental impacts occurred when used PET bottles were disposed by 100 % landfilling while disposal by 75 % flake production and 25 % landfilling gave the least environmental load. Social life cycle assessment results indicated that least social impacts occurred with 75 % flake production and 25 % landfilling. Thus both E-LCA and S-LCA rated 75 % flake production and 25 % landfilling to be the best disposal option.

Conclusions

Two dimensions of sustainability (environmental and social) when investigated using the Life Cycle Management tool, favoured scenario 4 (75 %?% flake production and 25 % landfilling) which is a partial recycling disposal route. One hundred percent landfilling was found out to be the worst scenario. The next step will be to explore the third pillar of sustainability, economic, and devise a method to integrate the three dimensions with a view to determine the sustainable disposal option of used PET bottles in Mauritius.