Utero-ovarian infection in aged B6C3F1 mice

An unusually high number of ovarian masses and cysts with purulent material were observed in the B6C3F1 mice on 2 year chemical carcinogenicity studies sponsored by the National Cancer Institute-National Toxicology Program. To determine possible etiology, some of these lesions were cultured for bacteria and a majority yielded Klebsiella sp. Necropsy records of 14,029 female mice in 91 chronic studies necropsied from 1979 to 1983 at six toxicology testing laboratories were reviewed to determine the incidence of lesions and distribution of this disease. Animals for these studies were obtained from barrier production colonies of six suppliers. The incidence of this lesion was low in animals less than 14 months of age, increased with age and reached a peak in 24-26 month old mice. Most animals having this lesion either died or were sacrificed in moribund condition, indicating that this is a life shortening disease of aged B6C3F1 mice. The incidence of lesions ranged from less than 1% to 70% in different chronic studies. There was a marked difference in the incidence in mice from different suppliers and the incidence rate was 2.6 to 15% depending on the source of the animals. The incidence of this lesion in some testing laboratories was several-fold higher than in others and ranged from 0.9 to 20%. The proportion of mice with this lesion was low in some laboratories irrespective of the source of the animals, whereas in other laboratories the incidence was several-fold higher with animals from some, but not all suppliers, indicating testing laboratory-supplier interaction.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Epidemiology of C57 black/6M mouse strain: statistical findings in a control population]

Non-linearity in age specific gompertzian rates regression versus age was observed in actuarial analysis of all causes of death, tumor incidence and tumor/tumor-host index in 503 male and 497 female control C57 Black/6M mice. The overall tumor incidence averaged 66.7% in males and 84.4% in females during a maximum lifespan of 1,300 days. In males as well as in females, time related incidence peaks were identified for lymphocytic lympho-sarcomas, reticulum cell sarcomas, histiocytic type and reticulum cell sarcomas of reticular type.     

Age-related non-tumorous lesions in SPF C57BL/6 mice with special reference to amyloidosis]

Non-tumorous pathological changes in C57BL/6 CrSlc mice, which were reared under a barrier system and died spontaneously, were examined. At 3 months intervals 125 to 209 mice were purchased at 4 weeks of age and raised for the supply of aged animals. A large portion of the mice were used for various experiments between 3 and 30 months of age, while not a small number died spontaneously and were autopsied. The major non-neoplastic lesion was amyloidosis, with incidence of 55.5% and 74.4% for the autopsied female and male, respectively. The organs involved were the liver, kidneys, spleen, adrenal glands, ileum, heart and lungs. Skin ulceration and its scar, cerebral vascular calcification, glomerulosclerosis and sepsis in both sexes, distension of the seminal vesicles in males, fibroblast growth of the adrenal glands in females were commonly found. Incidence of spontaneous neoplastic lesions was 69.7% and 55.1% for the female and male, respectively.     

Modification of physical movement in old C57BL/6 mice by DHEA and melatonin supplementation.

As old age results in reduced physical activity as well as less dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) and melatonin (MLT) production, low hormone levels may be a component of inactivity. Therefore, we studied the effects of DHEA and/or MLT supplementation on movement and resting in young and old female C57 black mice. Our results showed for the first time that old female C56BL/6 mice have significantly decreased physical activity. Their average speed and resting time were significantly higher than in young mice, whereas ambulatory time, distance traveled, and body movements when stationary (stereo time) were lower. DHEA supplementation significantly increased stereo time in old mice, while decreasing ambulatory time and distance traveled. MLT supplementation of old mice decreased average speed, resting time, and stereo time compared to untreated, old mice. Supplementation with MLT or DHEA, whose production is reduced in aging, restored physical activity levels in old mice. MLT also increased ambulatory time and distance traveled while reducing body movements of young mice.     

Ankylosis of hock joints in group caged male B6C3F1 mice

Enlarged hock joints were observed during 1983 in B6C3F1 mice of chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity studies sponsored by the National Toxicology Program (NTP). Subsequently, approximately 9,500 B6C3F1 mice on 32 NTP chemical toxicity and carcinogenicity studies were evaluated for this condition by clinical examination. Group caged male B6C3F1 mice had thickening and reduced mobility of the hock joints at prevalences of 1.2% up to 6 months of age; 23% at 6 to 12 months of age; and 62% at 13 to 26 months of age. Group caged female B6C3F1 mice had a prevalence of 2% or less. Histologically, affected mice had periarticular exostoses on the bones of the hock joints, with formation of bony bridges around joints and deposition of new bone in joint spaces, resulting in partial or complete ankylosis. Individually caged male and female B6C3F1 mice were not affected. The cause of the ankylosis was not determined, but its occurrence in the NTP studies has been reduced by individual caging.     

Osteosarcomas in BALB/c female mice

Osteosarcomas were found in 16 of 24,192 (0.066%) BALB/c female mice, 14 were in 21,816 (0.064%) 2-acetylaminofluorene-treated mice, and two were in 2,376 (0.084%) untreated controls. The osteosarcomas were classified into osteoblastic, fibroblastic, and mixed types. Seven of the osteosarcomas metastasized to the lungs. The osteosarcomas in control and 2-acetylaminofluorene-treated mice showed little or no difference in the incidence, type, size, or site of origin, indicating that 2-acetylaminofluorene did not affect the development of osteosarcomas in BALB/c female mice.U     

Carcinogenicity study of GSM and DCS wireless communication signals in B6C3F1 mice

The purpose of this study using a total of 1170 B6C3F1 mice was to detect and evaluate possible carcinogenic effects in mice exposed to radio-frequency-radiation (RFR) from Global System for Mobile Communication (GSM) and Digital Personal Communications System (DCS) handsets as emitted by handsets operating in the center of the communication band, that is, at 902 MHz (GSM) and 1747 MHz (DCS). Restrained mice were exposed for 2 h per day, 5 days per week over a period of 2 years to three different whole-body averaged specific absorption rate (SAR) levels of 0.4, 1.3, 4.0 mW/g bw (SAR), or were sham exposed. Regarding the organ-related tumor incidence, pairwise Fisher's test did not show any significant increase in the incidence of any particular tumor type in the RF exposed groups as compared to the sham exposed group. Interestingly, while the incidences of hepatocellular carcinomas were similar in EMF and sham exposed groups, in both studies the incidences of liver adenomas in males decreased with increasing dose levels; the incidences in the high dose groups were statistically significantly different from those in the sham exposed groups. Comparison to published tumor rates in untreated mice revealed that the observed tumor rates were within the range of historical control data. In conclusion, the present study produced no evidence that the exposure of male and female B6C3F1 mice to wireless GSM and DCS radio frequency signals at a whole body absorption rate of up to 4.0 W/kg resulted in any adverse health effect or had any cumulative influence on the incidence or severity of neoplastic and non-neoplastic background lesions, and thus the study did not provide any evidence of RF possessing a carcinogenic potential.     

Hereditary hydronephrosis in C57BL/KsJ mice.

We sought to determine if the incidence of renal hydronephrosis in male C57BL/KsJ mice increased with age and if grossly normal kidneys would develop hydronephrosis over time. Spontaneous hydronephrosis was found incidentally in 32% of 234 male C57BL/KsJ mice killed as pancreas donors for islet transplantation experiments. The incidence of hydronephrosis increased with age; the incidence was 15% in 6- to 8-week-old mice, 52% in 8- to 10-week-old mice and 63% in 11- to 15-week-old mice (P less than 0.001). Additional mice received islet isografts beneath the renal capsule. Only mice with grossly normal kidneys received islet grafts. These same kidneys were then re-examined when the graft recipients were killed at the end of the experiment and the incidence of hydronephrosis was determined. The conversion of normal kidneys to hydronephrotic kidneys increased with the time since islet transplantation. Kidneys re-examined less than 4 weeks since transplantation had only 5.8% new hydronephrosis, while those re-examined later than 4 weeks after transplantation had a new hydronephrosis incidence rate of 40% (P less than 0.001). Our findings suggest that hydronephrosis is hereditary but not congenital, that it develops rapidly, and that it can complicate experiments using this strain. This may also represent a useful new animal model of progressive hydronephrosis.     

Gender influences infectivity in C57BL/6 mice exposed to mouse minute virus

Two natural outbreaks of mouse minute virus (MMV) are described. Observations during management of the naturally infected colonies led to a study in which 4-wk-old C57BL/6NCr and C57BL/6Tac mice were inoculated oronasally with an immunosuppressive variant of MMV (MMVi), as were adult C57BL/6NCr lactating dams or their pups (age, 10 d). By day 28 postinoculation, 100% of the 4-wk-old male C57BL/6NCr and C57BL/6Tac mice, 56.2% of 4-wk-old C57BL/6NCr female and 62.5% of 4-wk-old C57BL/6Tac female mice, 100% of adult lactating C57BL/6NCr dams, and 100% of inoculated pups (10 d) had seroconverted. Serologically positive nursing dams did not infect their nursing pups. In contrast, when nursing pups were inoculated, 100% of their dams seroconverted by 28 d postinoculation. Only 1 of 4 facility sentinels (Tac:SW female mice) seroconverted to MMVi and none of the 4 research sentinels (Tac:SW female mice) seroconverted under a once-weekly bedding transfer program. Consequently, 4 new research Tac:SW sentinels of each gender (n = 8) were placed in known-positive cages at cage-change; 100% of the male mice but 0% of the females seroconverted by day 48. Study results suggest gender influences both infectivity and the ability to detect subclinical infections of MMVi. Other factors that may influence detection of MMV include mouse strain or stock, short shedding period, and prolonged time between cage changes. In light of the data from both the natural infections and the experimental cases, cessation of breeding likely will be beneficial when trying to eradicate this virus.     

A morphologic classification and incidence of alveolar-bronchiolar neoplasms in BALB/c female mice

Lungs from 505 (21.1%) of 2,397 untreated control female BALB/c mice examined at various age intervals up to 1,001 days contained alveolar-bronchiolar neoplasms. Tumors were evaluated for histomorphological type, degree of differentiation, and size. Most of the tumors (286 of 505 or 56% of those examined) were of the papillary type and 450 of 505 (89.1%) were well differentiated. The incidence of the solid type and the well differentiated tumors was highest in the smallest size group (less than 0.5 mm) while that of the papillary and mixed types and the moderately and poorly differentiated tumors was highest in the larger size groupings. One hundred twenty-seven of 131 (97%) of all solid tumors were well differentiated while a lower percentage of papillary and mixed types (86.7% and 85.2%, respectively) were well differentiated. The mean age of mice with tumors from each histomorphological type, degree of differentiation, and size grouping also was determined.     

Comparison of postnatal lung growth and development between C3H/HeJ and C57BL/6J mice.

Previous work by our group has demonstrated substantial differences in lung volume and morphometric parameters between inbred mice. Specifically, adult C3H/HeJ (C3) have a 50% larger lung volume and 30% greater mean linear intercept than C57BL/6J (B6) mice. Although much of lung development occurs postnatally in rodents, it is uncertain at what age the differences between these strains become manifest. In this study, we performed quasi-static pressure-volume curves and morphometric analysis on neonatal mice. Lungs from anesthetized mice were degassed in vivo using absorption of 100% O2. Pressure-volume curves were then recorded in situ. The lungs were then fixed by instillation of Zenker's solution at a constant transpulmonary pressure. The left lung from each animal was used for morphometric determination of mean air space chord length (Lma). We found that the lung volume of C3 mice was substantially greater than that of B6 mice at all ages. In contrast, there was no difference in Lma (62.7 microm in C3 and 58.5 microm in B6) of 3-day-old mice. With increasing age (8 days), there was a progressive decrease in the Lma of both strains, with the magnitude of the decrease in B6 Lma mice exceeding that of C3. C3 lung volume remained 50% larger. The combination of parenchymal architectural similarity with lung air volume differences and different rates of alveolar septation support the hypothesis that lung volume and alveolar dimensions are independently regulated.     

Age-related incidence of spontaneous tumors in SPF C57BL/6 and BDF1 mice]

Incidence of spontaneous tumors in C57BL/6 NCrj (CR), C5BL/6 CrSlc (SL) and B 6 Crj x DBA/2 NCrj F1 (BD) mice, which were reared under a barrier system and died natural death, were examined. Cohorts of mice in 200 to 300 each were purchased at 4 weeks of age and raised under SPF conditions. A large portion of the mice were used for various experiments between 3 and 30 months old while not a small number died before use and were autopsied. Median survival periods of the female and male were estimated at 697 and 680 days for CR, 764 and 806 days for SL and 866 and 929 days for BD, respectively. Incidence of spontaneous neoplastic lesions in the autopsied animals were 77.4% and 79.2% of 535 female and 590 male CR, 69.7% and 55.1% of 502 female and 463 male SL, and 75.8% and 78.0% of 298 female and 346 male BD, respectively. In CR, histiocytic sarcoma was the most predominant tumor, accounting for 72.1% of all tumors. In SL, malignant lymphoma was the most prevailing, forming 62.3%, and, in male BD, hepatocellular carcinoma was the most frequent, accounting for 41.8% of all tumors.     

Delayed anovulatory syndrome induced by estradiol in female C57BL/6J mice: age-like neuroendocrine, but not ovarian, impairments

These studies describe induction of a delayed anovulatory syndrome (DAS) by estradiol (E2) in female C57BL/6J mice. Six days after birth, female mice were injected s.c. with 0.1 micrograms estradiol benzoate or oil. Over 90% of the oil-injected controls exhibited estrous cycles from 2 to 9 mo of age. In contrast, 60% of the E2-injected mice exhibited estrous cycles at 2 mo of age but were acyclic by 9 mo; these mice were considered to have exhibited a DAS, and had longer cycles than controls. At 12 mo, ovarian impairments were assessed by examining 1) ovulation after s.c. injection of 5 IU human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG), and 2) estrous cycles after grafting into young (3-mo-old) hosts. Simultaneously, neuroendocrine impairments were assessed by examining 1) the surge of luteinizing hormone (LH) induced by E2 implants after ovariectomy, and 2) estrous cycles after receiving ovarian grafts from 3-mo-old mice. Ovaries from DAS and control mice ovulated equally in response to hCG. Ovaries from DAS mice grafted into young ovariectomized hosts supported 30% more cycles, of shorter period, compared with ovaries from control donors. However, the E2-induced LH surge was 50% smaller in DAS mice than in controls. Ovariectomized DAS hosts with ovarian grafts from young mice supported 70% fewer estrous cycles, of longer period, compared with ovariectomized control hosts with young grafts. We conclude that the E2-induced DAS in female mice is not due to ovarian impairments, but seems to result from neuroendocrine impairments.     

D-LEU-4]-OB3, a synthetic leptin agonist, improves hyperglycemic control in C57BL/6J ob/ob mice

We have recently shown that the activity of a synthetic peptide corresponding to amino acid residues 116-130 of secreted mouse leptin is contained in a restricted sequence at the amino terminus of the peptide, between residues 116-122 (Ser-Cys-Ser-Leu-Pro-Gln-Thr, OB3). Substitution of the Leu residue at position 4 of OB3 with its D-isomer ([D-Leu-4]-OB3) enhanced the ability of OB3 (1 mg/day, ip, 7 days) to reduce body weight gain, food and water intake, and serum glucose in female C57BL/6J ob/ob mice. In the present study, we have utilized a pair-feeding approach to demonstrate that the antihyperglycemic action of [D-Leu-4]-OB3 is not solely due to its effects on caloric intake. One group of female C57BL/6J ob/ob mice (n=6) was fed ad libitum, and two additional groups (n=6 per group) were allowed 3.0 g food/mouse daily, an amount previously determined to satisfy [D-Leu-4]-OB3-treated mice. At the end of the 7-day test period, vehicle-injected mice fed ad libitum were approximately 10% heavier than their initial body weights, while pair-fed mice injected with vehicle and [D-Leu-4]-OB3-treated mice lost 5% of their initial body weights. After 1 day of treatment, blood glucose was reduced by 20% in pair-fed vehicle-injected mice, and by 40% in mice given [D-Leu-4]-OB3. Food restriction reduced blood glucose throughout the 7-day study, but not to levels seen in wild-type nonobese C57BL/6J mice of the same sex and age. After 2 days of treatment with [D-Leu-4]-OB3, however, blood glucose was reduced to levels comparable to those seen in wild-type nonobese mice. [D-Leu-4]-OB3 also lowered serum insulin levels by 53% when compared to mice fed ad libitum. Neither pair-feeding nor [D-Leu-4]-OB3 treatment had any apparent effect on thermogenesis. These results suggest that [D-Leu-4]-OB3 exerts its effects on serum glucose not only by suppressing caloric intake, but also through a separate effect on glucose metabolism which may involve increased tissue sensitivity to insulin.     

Two types of chronic lead treatment in C57BL/6 mice: interaction with behavioural determinants of pain

The male C57BL/6 mice used in this study were the offspring either of untreated or lead treated (0.1% lead acetate (PbAc) instead of drinking water) parents. Offspring of lead treated parents were reared on 0.1% PbAc until weaning, and also given 0.5% PbAc to drink for 3 weeks prior to testing (Pb2 group). Offspring of untreated parents were either given 0.5% PbAc to drink (Pb1 group) or maintained on tap water throughout (Control group). Control (C) and lead treated mice were subdivided according to single- or group-housing; no confrontation ("unfought") or confrontation with a trained aggressor mouse ("defeated"). All the mice were then given a hot-plate pain test, in which paw-lick and escape latencies were recorded. In untreated mice, latencies were reduced after defeat. This effect was not seen in lead treated animals. Lead treatment increased latencies in most instances relative to the appropriate control group. The paw-lick latencies were less consistently affected than the escape latencies. Escape latencies, with one exception, were longer in the Pb2 group than in the Pb1 group. Treatment with naloxone of single-housed C and Pb2 was without effect, except for Pb2 treated undefeated mice: here, naloxone abolished the analgesic effect of lead treatment. Lead-induced analgesia is discussed in terms of central mechanisms of pain reception.     

Dietary manipulation of mammary tumor development in adult C3H/Bi mice

Chronic energy intake restriction (CEIR) in virgin female mice is one of the most effective ways of reducing significantly mammary adenocarcinoma in C3H/Bi mice, a strain which develops mammary adenocarcinoma associated with the murine mammary tumor virus spontaneously and at high incidence. In this study, the influence of chronic energy intake restriction imposed on fully mature (4- to 5-month-old), breeding female C3H/Bi mice was addressed, and the influence of energy intake where energy was derived largely from fat versus diets in which energy was derived largely from carbohydrates on tumor development and survival rate was investigated. The results show that chronic energy intake restriction can be delayed until full maturation and successful reproduction and still reduce significantly the incidence of mammary tumor development in this relatively short-lived strain of mice. Our findings demonstrate that the overriding dietary factor controlling mammary tumor development in these experiments in C3H/Bi mice was the level of energy intake, regardless of the primary source of energy (fat or carbohydrates).     

Effect of dietary restriction on estrous cyclicity and follicular reserves in aging C57BL/6J mice

Restricting the food intake of female mice by alternating days of feeding and fasting delayed the age-related loss of estrous cycling potential and retarded the rate of follicular depletion, as determined after reinstatement of ad libitum (AL) feeding. During the period of food restriction (FR; 3.5-10.5 mo), food intake and body weight were about 80% of AL values. Mice were acyclic and predominantly in a state of diestrus during FR, but after reinstatement of an AL diet at 10.5 mo all FR mice resumed cycling regularly. By contrast, 80% of AL controls had become acyclic by this age, and the cycles of the remaining mice were significantly longer than those of the reinstated FR mice. Follicular reserves of 12.5-mo-old FR mice were twice those of age-matched AL controls. Cycling performance of reinstated FR mice, measured by cycle length and the proportion of mice still cycling, was equivalent to that of AL mice when the latter were 2-5 mo younger. Ovarian age, measured by the size of the follicular reserve, was similarly retarded in FR mice. Based on these data and previous evidence that follicular depletion plays a major role in the cessation of cyclicity in this strain, we hypothesize that the delayed loss of estrous cyclicity in aging FR mice is mediated at least in part by the retarding effect of dietary restriction on the rate of follicular depletion.     

Taste solution preferences of C57BL/6J and 129X1/SvJ mice: influence of age, sex, and diet

To examine whether age influences taste solution preferences, we measured taste preferences of C57BL/6J and 129X1/SvJ mice given a series of 48-h 2-bottle tests with a choice between water and one of the following taste solutions: 2 mM saccharin, 5 mM citric acid, 30 microM quinine hydrochloride, 75 mM sodium chloride (NaCl), 10 mM inosine monophosphate (IMP), 50 mM calcium chloride (CaCl(2)), and 10% ethanol. We tested separate groups of male mice fed Teklad 8604 chow at ages 4, 6, 9, 12, 15, 20, 25, 30, 40, and 50 weeks and retested some of these mice at 54, 75, and 100 weeks and again at 125 weeks. Female mice fed chow were tested at ages 4, 12, 25, and 50 weeks and retested at 54, 75, 100, and 125 weeks. Male mice fed AIN-93G semisynthetic diet were tested at ages 4, 12, 25, and 50 weeks and retested at 54, 75, and 100 weeks. Concentration-response functions for each taste solution were collected from male and female mice fed chow aged 8 or 125 weeks. In general, the results showed that age had little effect on taste preferences. Exceptions included 1) a small increase in quinine hydrochloride preference between 54 and 125 weeks in mice of both strains and sexes, 2) a marked increase in NaCl preference between 4 and 12 weeks in female B6 mice, 3) a gradual decrease in IMP preference between 4 and 125 weeks in male and female 129 mice, 4) a marked decrease in CaCl(2) preference between 54 and 125 weeks in male and female 129 mice, and 5) a marked reduction in ethanol preference between 4 and 12 weeks in male B6 mice fed AIN-93G diet but not chow. These results show that over a wide range and with the exceptions noted, age contributes little to the variation in taste preferences observed in C57BL/6J and 129X1/SvJ mice.     

Helicobacter pylori and cholesterol gallstone formation in C57L/J mice: a prospective study

Recently, we demonstrated that cholesterol gallstone-prone C57L/J mice rarely develop gallstones unless they are infected with certain cholelithogenic enterohepatic Helicobacter species. Because the common gastric pathogen H. pylori has been identified in the hepatobiliary tree of cholesterol gallstone patients, we wanted to ascertain if H. pylori is cholelithogenic, by prospectively studying C57L infected mice fed a lithogenic diet. Weanling, Helicobacter spp.-free male C57L mice were either infected with H. pylori SS1 or sham dosed. Mice were then fed a lithogenic diet (1.0% cholesterol, 0.5% cholic acid, and 15% dairy triglycerides) for 8 wk. At 16 wk of age, mice were euthanatized, the biliary phenotype was analyzed microscopically, and tissues were analyzed histopathologically. H. pylori infection did not promote cholesterol monohydrate crystal formation (20% vs. 10%), sandy stone formation (0% for both), or true gallstone formation (20%) compared with uninfected mice fed the lithogenic diet (10%). Additionally, H. pylori failed to stimulate mucin gel accumulation in the gallbladder or alter gallbladder size compared with uninfected animals. H. pylori-infected C57L mice developed moderate to severe gastritis by 12 wk, and the lithogenic diet itself produced lesions in the forestomach, which were exacerbated by the infection. We conclude that H. pylori infection does not play any role in murine cholesterol gallstone formation. Nonetheless, the C57L mouse develops severe lesions of both the glandular and nonglandular stomach in response to H. pylori infection and the lithogenic diet, respectively.     

C57BL/6小鼠性别差异对髓鞘少突胶质糖蛋白诱导的实验性自身脑脊髓炎疾病的影响

多发性硬化是人类常见的中枢神经系统自身免疫性炎症致脱髓鞘疾病．流行病学研究发现,女性患者多于男性,其平均发病时间早于男性．实验性自身免疫性脑脊髓炎(EAE)与多发性硬化症有相似的临床症状和病理特征,是被广泛应用于人类疾病研究的动物模型．本实验利用髓鞘少突胶质糖蛋白MOG_33-35免疫C57BL/6小鼠建立EAE模型,观察29天．通过疾病评分发现雌雄小鼠在发病率、起病时间上均无明显差别,但雄鼠的发病症状明显比雌鼠严重．在其病理切片HE染色中观察到雄性小鼠中枢浸润的炎性细胞多于雌性小鼠,并且在LFB染色中同样观察到雄鼠脱髓鞘区域明显增大．对其发病高峰期中枢浸润细胞的染色分析时,可以发现雄性小鼠中浸润的CD4 T细胞及其亚群T_H-1和T_H-17细胞均有明显增加．这些都表明MOG_33-35免疫C57BL/6小鼠建立的EAE模型存在着性别差异的影响,这一发现为今后建立多发性硬化症的动物模型中动物性别的选择提供了一定的参考依据．