Comparison of surface and hydrogel-based protein microchips

Protein microchips are designed for high-throughput evaluation of the concentrations and activities of various proteins. The rapid advance in microchip technology and a wide variety of existing techniques pose the problem of unified approach to the assessment and comparison of different platforms. Here we compare the characteristics of protein microchips developed for quantitative immunoassay with those of antibodies immobilized on glass surfaces and in hemispherical gel pads. Spotting concentrations of antibodies used for manufacturing of microchips of both types and concentrations of antigen in analyte solution were identical. We compared the efficiency of antibody immobilization, the intensity of fluorescence signals for both direct and sandwich-type immunoassays, and the reaction-diffusion kinetics of the formation of antibody-antigen complexes for surface and gel-based microchips. Our results demonstrate higher capacity and sensitivity for the hydrogel-based protein microchips, while fluorescence saturation kinetics for the two types of microarrays was comparable.     

Kinetics of hybridization on surface oligonucleotide microchips: theory, experiment, and comparison with hybridization on gel-based microchips

The optimal design of oligonucleotide microchips and efficient discrimination between perfect and mismatch duplexes strongly depend on the external transport of target DNA to the cells with immobilized probes as well as on respective association and dissociation rates at the duplex formation. In this paper we present the relevant theory for hybridization of DNA fragments with oligonucleotide probes immobilized in the cells on flat substrate. With minor modifications, our theory also is applicable to reaction-diffusion hybridization kinetics for the probes immobilized on the surface of microbeads immersed in hybridization solution. The main theoretical predictions are verified with control experiments. Besides that, we compared the characteristics of the surface and gel-based oligonucleotide microchips. The comparison was performed for the chips printed with the same pin robot, for the signals measured with the same devices and processed by the same technique, and for the same hybridization conditions. The sets of probe oligonucleotides and the concentrations of probes in respective solutions used for immobilization on each platform were identical as well. We found that, despite the slower hybridization kinetics, the fluorescence signals and mutation discrimination efficiency appeared to be higher for the gel-based microchips with respect to their surface counterparts even for the relatively short hybridization time about 0.5-1 hour. Both the divergence between signals for perfects and the difference in mutation discrimination efficiency for the counterpart platforms rapidly grow with incubation time. In particular, for hybridization during 3 h the signals for gel-based microchips surpassed their surface counterparts in 5-20 times, while the ratios of signals for perfect-mismatch pairs for gel microchips exceeded the corresponding ratios for surface microchips in 2-4 times. These effects may be attributed to the better immobilization efficiency and to the higher thermodynamic association constants for duplex formation within gel pads.     

Kinetics of hybridization on the oligonucleotide microchips with gel pads

The kinetics of hybridization on the oligonucleotide microchip with gel pads is studied both theoretically and experimentally. The monitoring of kinetics was performed with the measurements of fluorescence intensity produced by the labeled target oligonucleotides. As is shown, the hybridization time depends on the stability of the formed duplexes, the concentrations of target and probe oligonucleotides, and the diffusion of target oligonucleotides in solution and gel pad. The initial stage of hybridization is determined by the flow of target oligonucleotides from solution, then, followed by the diffusive propagation with approximately constant concentration of oligonucleotides at the boundary of gel pad and, finally, by the exponential saturation. The theoretical predictions of hybridization kinetics reveal a good correspondence with the experimental results and may be used for the choice of the optimal hybridization conditions. The possible applications of kinetic hybridization curves to the discrimination problems and assessment of diffusion coefficients in gel pads are briefly discussed. Finally, we discuss the relationships between the binding kinetics and the general functioning of biomolecular microchips.     

Quantitative immunoassay of biotoxins on hydrogel-based protein microchips

Three-dimensional gel-based microchips with immobilized proteins were used for quantitative immunoassay of a series of plant (ricin and viscumin) and bacterial (staphylococcal enterotoxin B, tetanus and diphtheria toxins, and lethal factor of anthrax) toxins. It was shown that different types of immunoassays (direct, competitive, and sandwich type) could be carried out on gel microchips. As shown by confocal microscope studies, antigen-antibody interactions involving the formation of tertiary antibody-antigen-antibody complex occur in the whole volume of microchip gel elements. Sandwich assay on microchips with immobilized antibodies provided the highest sensitivity of detection (0.1 ng/ml for ricin). Antibodies labeled with fluorescent dyes, horseradish peroxidase conjugates, or biotinylated antibodies with subsequent treatment with labeled avidin were used as developing antibodies. The results of immunoassays were recorded using fluorescence, chemiluminescence, or matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry directly from microchip gel elements. Gel microchips with immobilized capture antibodies were used to analyze the sample simultaneously for the presence of all six biotoxins with the same sensitivity as that for any single toxin.     

Discrimination between perfect and mismatched duplexes with oligonucleotide gel microchips: role of thermodynamic and kinetic effects during hybridization

The efficiency of discrimination between perfect and mismatched duplexes during hybridization on microchips depends on the concentrations of target DNA in solution and immobilized probes, buffer composition, and temperature of hybridization and is determined by both thermodynamic relationships and hybridization kinetics. In this work, optimal conditions of discrimination were studied using hybridization of fluorescently labeled target DNA with custom-made gel-based oligonucleotide microchips. The higher the concentration of immobilized probes and the higher the association constant, the higher the concentration of the formed duplexes and the stronger the corresponding fluorescence signal, but, simultaneously, the longer the time needed to reach equilibrium. Since mismatched duplexes hybridize faster than their perfect counterparts, perfect-to-mismatch signal ratio is lower in transient regime, and short hybridization times may hamper the detection of mutations. The saturation time can be shortened by decreasing the probe concentration or augmenting the gel porosity. This improves the detection of mutations in transient regime. It is shown that the decrease in the initial concentration of oligonucleotide probes by an order of magnitude causes only 1.5-2.5-fold decrease of fluorescence signals after hybridization of perfect duplexes for 3-12 h. At the same time, these conditions improve the discrimination between perfect and mismatched duplexes more than two-fold. A similar improvement may be obtained using an optimized dissociation procedure.     

Effects of external transport on discrimination between perfect and mismatch duplexes on gel-based oligonucleotide microchips

Using hydrogel-based oligonucleotide microchips developed previously for the choice of drugs during leukemia treatment and the other diseases, it is shown that the acceleration of external transport by mixing buffer solution with peristaltic pump not only enhances the observable fluorescence signals, but also improves significantly the discrimination between perfect and mismatch duplexes at the intermediate stage of hybridization on the oligonucleotide microchips. The discrimination efficiency for a given hybridization time grows monotonously with the frequency of flow pulsations. The mixing with frequency 10 Hz accelerates the hybridization rate approximately thrice and improves the discrimination efficiency 1.5-2.5 times higher for overnight hybridization. To study these effects, we have developed the special peristaltic pump mixing solution in a hybridization chamber of 35 mul in volume (area approximately 1 x 1 cm(2) and height 0.3 mm). We present also the brief theoretical summary for the interpretation and assessment of the observed experimental features.     

Effects of External Transport on Discrimination Between Perfect and Mismatch Duplexes on Gel-Based Oligonucleotide Microchips

Abstract

Using hydrogel-based oligonucleotide microchips developed previously for the choice of drugs during leukemia treatment and the other diseases, it is shown that the acceleration of external transport by mixing buffer solution with peristaltic pump not only enhances the observable fluorescence signals, but also improves significantly the discrimination between perfect and mismatch duplexes at the intermediate stage of hybridization on the oligonucleotide microchips. The discrimination efficiency for a given hybridization time grows monotonously with the frequency of flow pulsations. The mixing with frequency 10 Hz accelerates the hybridization rate approximately thrice and improves the discrimination efficiency 1.5–2.5 times higher for overnight hybridization. To study these effects, we have developed the special peristaltic pump mixing solution in a hybridization chamber of 35 μl in volume (area ~1 × 1 cm² and height 0.3 mm). We present also the brief theoretical summary for the interpretation and assessment of the observed experimental features.     

Manual Manufacturing of Oligonucleotide, DNA, and Protein Microchips

A simple procedure for manufacturing microchips containing various gel-immobilized compounds is described. A gel photopolymerization technique is introduced to produce micromatrices of polyacrylamide gel pads (25 × 25 × 20 μm and larger) separated by a hydrophobic glass surface. A pin device for the manual application of a compound in solution onto the activated polyacrylamide gel pad for immobilization is described. Oligonucleotide, DNA, and protein microchips have been produced by this method and tested by hybridization and immunoanalysis monitored with a fluorescence microscope. The effect of the lengths of the immobilized oligonucleotides and the hybridized RNA and DNA on hybridization of the oligonucleotide microchips was evaluated. This method can also be used for manufacturing microchips containing a variety of other compounds.     

Protein microchips: use for immunoassay and enzymatic reactions

Different proteins such as antibodies, antigens, and enzymes were immobilized within the 100 x 100 x 20-microm gel pads of protein microchips. A modified polyacrylamide gel has been developed to accommodate proteins of a size up to 400,000 daltons. Electrophoresis in the microchip reaction chamber speeded up antigen-antibody interactions within the gel. Protein microchips were used in immunoassays for detection of antigens or antibodies, as well as to carry out enzymatic reactions and to measure their kinetics in the absence or presence of an inhibitor. A protein microchip can be used several times in different immunoassays and enzymatic kinetic measurements.     

Biological Microchips with Hydrogel-Immobilized Nucleic Acids,Proteins, and Other Compounds: Properties and Applications in Genomics

The MAGIChip (MicroArrays of Gel-Immobilized Compounds on a chip) consists of an array of hydrophilic gel pads fixed on a hydrophobic glass surface. These pads of several picoliters to several nanoliters in volume contain gel-immobilized nucleic acids, proteins, and other compounds, as well as live cells. They are used to conduct chemical and enzymatic reactions with the immobilized compounds or samples bound to them. In the latter case, nucleic acid fragments can be hybridized, modified, and fractionated within the gel pads. The main procedures required to analyze nucleic acid sequences (PCR, detachment of primers and PCR-amplified products from a substrate, hybridization, ligation, and others) can be also performed within the microchip pads. A flexible, multipurpose, and inexpensive system has been developed to register the processes on a microchip. The system provides unique possibilities for research and biomedical applications, allowing one to register both equilibrium states and the course of reaction in real time. The system is applied to analyze both kinetic and thermodynamic characteristics of molecular interaction in the duplexes formed between nucleic acids and the probes immobilized within the microchip gel pads. Owing to the effect of stacking interaction of nucleic acids, the use of short oligonucleotides extends the possibilities of microchips for analysis of nucleic acid sequences, allowing one to employ the MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry to analyze the hybridization data. The specialized MAGIChips has been successfully applied to reveal single-nucleotide polymorphism of many biologically significant genes, to identify bacteria and viruses, to detect toxins and characterize the genes of pathogenic bacteria responsible for drug resistance, and to study translocations in the human genome. On the basis of the MAGIChip, protein microchips have been created, containing immobilized antibodies, antigens, enzymes, and many other substances, as well as microchips with gel-immobilized live cells.     

Biological microchips with hydrogel-immobilized nucleic acids,proteins, and other compounds: properties and applications in genomics

The MAGIChip (MicroArrays of Gel-Immobilized Compounds on a chip) consists of an array of hydrophilic gel pads fixed on a hydrophobic glass surface. These pads of several picoliters to several nanoliters in volume contain the gel-immobilized nucleic acids, proteins, and other compounds, as well as live cells. They are used to conduct chemical and enzymatic reactions with the immobilized compounds or samples bound to them. In the latter case, nucleic acid fragments can be hybridized, modified, and fractionated within the gel pads. The main procedures required to analyze nucleic acid sequences (PCR, detachment of primers and PCR-amplified products from a substrate, hybridization, ligation, and others) can be also performed within the microchip pads. A flexible, multipurpose, and inexpensive system has been developed to register the processes proceeding on a microchip. The system provides unique possibilities for research and biomedical applications, allowing one to register both equilibrium states and the course of reaction in real time. The system is applied to analyze both kinetic and thermodynamic characteristics of molecular interaction in the duplexes formed between nucleic acids and the probes immobilized within the microchip gel pads. Owing to the effect of stacking interaction of nucleic acids, the use of short oligonucleotides extends the possibilities of microchips for analysis of nucleic acid sequences, allowing one to employ the MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry to analyze the hybridization data. The specialized MAGIChips has been successfully applied to reveal single nucleotide polymorphism of many biologically significant genes, to identify bacteria and viruses, to detect toxins and characterize the genes of pathogenic bacteria responsible for drug resistance, and to study translocations in the human genome. On the basis of the MAGIChip, the protein microchips have been created, containing the immobilized antibodies, antigens, enzymes, and many other substances, as well as the microchips with the gel-immobilized live cells.     

Gel-Based Microchips: History and Prospects

The review describes the history of formation and development of the microchip technology and its role in the human genome project in Russia. The main accent was done on the three-dimensional gel-based microchips developed at the Center of Biological Microchips headed by A.D. Mirzabekov since 1988. The gel-based chips of the last generation, IMAGE chips (Immobilized Micro Array of Gel Elements), have a number of advantages over the previous models. The microchips are manufactured by photoinitiated copolymerization of gel components and immobilized molecules (DNA, proteins, and ligands). This ensures an even distribution of the immobilized probe throughout the microchip gel element with a high yield (about 50% for oligonucleotides). The use of methacrylamide as a main component of the polymerization mixture resulted in a substantial increase of gel porosity without affecting its mechanical properties and stability; this allowed one to work with the DNA fragments of up to 500 nt in length, as well as with quite large protein molecules. At present, the gel-based microchips are widely applied to solve different problems. The generic microchips containing a complete set of possible hexanucleotides are used to reveal the DNA motifs binding with different proteins and to study the DNA–protein interactions. The oligonucleotide microchips are a cheap and reliable diagnostic tool designed for mass application. Biochips have been developed for identification of the tuberculosis pathogen and its antibiotic-resistant forms; of orthopoxviruses, including the smallpox virus; of the anthrax pathogen; and chromosomal rearrangements in leukemia patients. The protein microchips can be adapted for further use in proteo-mics. Bacterial and yeast cells were also immobilized in the gel, maintaining their viability, which opens a wide potential for creating biosensors on the basis of microchips.     

Microchips based on three dimensional gel cells: history and perspective

The review describes the history of creation and development of the microchip technology and its role in the human genome project in Russia. The emphasis is placed on the three-dimensional gel-based microchips developed at the Center of Biological Microchips headed by A.D. Mirzabekov since 1988. The gel-based chips of the last generation, IMAGE chips (Immobilized Micro Array of Gel Elements), have a number of advantages over the previous versions. The microchips are manufactured by photo-initiated copolymerization of gel components and immobilized molecules (DNA, proteins, and ligands). This ensures an even distribution of the immobilized probe throughout the microchip gel element with a high yield (about 50% for oligonucleotides). The use of methacrylamide as a main component of the polymerization mixture resulted in a substantial increase of gel porosity without affecting its mechanical strength and stability, which allowed one to work with the DNA fragments of up to 500 nt in length, as well as with rather large protein molecules. At present, the gel-based microchips are widely applied to address different problems. The generic microchips containing a complete set of possible hexanucleotides are used to reveal the DNA motifs binding with different proteins and to study the DNA-protein interactions. The oligonucleotide microchips are a cheap and reliable tool of diagnostics designed for mass application. Biochips have been developed for identification of the tuberculosis pathogen and its antibiotic-resistant forms; for diagnostics of orthopoxviruses, including the smallpox virus; for diagnostics of the anthrax pathogen; and for identification of chromosomal rearrangements in leukemia patients. The protein microchips can be adapted for further use in proteomics. Bacterial and yeast cells were also immobilized in the gel, maintaining their viability, which open a wide potential for creation biosensors on the basis of microchips.     

Microarray of recombinant antibodies using a streptavidin sensor surface self-assembled onto a gold layer

We have developed a sensitive method for the detection of recombinant antibody-antigen interactions in a microarray format. The biochip sensor platform used in this study is based on an oriented streptavidin monolayer that provides a biological interface with well-defined surface architecture that dramatically reduces nonspecific binding interactions. All the antibody or antigen probes were biotinylated and coupled onto streptavidin-coated biochip surfaces (1 microL total volume). The detection limits for the immobilized probes on the microarray surface were 0.5 microgram/mL (200 fmol/spot) for the peptide antigen and 0.1 microgram/mL (3 fmol/spot) for the recombinant antibodies. Optimal concentrations for the detection of the Cy5-labeled protein target were in the range of 20 micrograms/mL. Protein microchips were used to measure antibody-antigen kinetics, to find optimal temperature conditions, and to establish the shelf life of recombinant antibodies immobilized on the streptavidin surface. For recombinant antibody fragments with a kDa of 10-100 nM, we have established an easy and direct immunoassay. In addition, we developed an indirect method for antibody detection with no need for expensive and time-consuming antibody purifications and modifications. Such a method was shown to be useful for large-scale screening of recombinant antibody fragments directly after their functional expression in bacteria. Our data demonstrate that recombinant antibody fragments are suitable components in the construction of antibody chips.     

Biophysical methods for biochip analysis. Use of wide field digital fluorescent microscopy

This paper discusses an issue on the development of biophysical methods for biochip analysis. A scheme and construction of a biochip analyzer based on wide-field digital fluorescence microscopy are described. The analyzer is designed to register images of biological microchips labeled with fluorescent dyes. The device developed is useful for high-sensitive throughput recording analyses by biochips after interaction of immobilized probes with fluorescently labeled sample molecules as well as it provides the higher rate of the analysis compared to laser scanning devices. With this analyzer a scope where biological microchips can be applied becomes wider, the development of new protocols of the analyses is possible and standard analyses run faster with the use of biochips, the expenses for the analysis performance can be reduced.     

Hydrogel-based protein microchips: manufacturing,properties, and applications

Here a simple, reproducible, and versatile method is described for manufacturing protein and ligand chips. The photo-induced copolymerization of acrylamide-based gel monomers with different probes (oligonucleotides, DNA, proteins, and low-molecular ligands) modified by the introduction of methacrylic groups takes place in drops on a glass or silicone surface. All probes are uniformly and chemically fixed with a high yield within the whole volume of hydrogel semispherical chip elements that are chemically attached to the surface. Purified enzymes, antibodies, antigens, and other proteins, as well as complex protein mixtures such as cell lysates, were immobilized on a chip. Avidin- and oligohistidine-tagged proteins can be immobilized within biotin- and Ni-nitrilotriacetic acid-modified gel elements. Most gel-immobilized proteins maintain their biological properties for at least six months. Fluorescence and chemiluminescence microscopy were used as efficient methods for the quantitative analysis of the microchips. Direct on-chip matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry was used for the qualitative identification of interacting molecules and to analyze tryptic peptides after the digestion of proteins in individual gel elements. We also demonstrate other useful properties of protein microchips and their application to proteomics and diagnostics.     

An RNA microchip containing immobilized oligoribonucleotides with protective groups at 2'-O-positions

To analyze RNA interactions with RNA binding molecules an RNA microchip containing immobilized oligoribonucleotides with protective groups [t-butyldimethylsilyl (tBDMS)] at 2'-O- positions was developed. The oligonucleotides were immobilized within three-dimensional (3-D) hydrogel pads fixed on a glass support. The protective groups preserved the oligoribonucleodes from degradation and were suitable to be removed directly on the microchip when needed, right before its use. These immobilized, deprotected oligoribonucleotides were tested for their interaction with afluorescently labeled oligodeoxyribonucleotide and analyzed for their availability to be cleaved enzymatically by the RNase binase. Stability of tBDMS-protected immobilized oligoribonucleotides after 2.5 years of storage as well as after direct RNase action was also tested. Melting curves of short RNA/DNA hybrids that had formed into gel pads of the microchip were found to exhibit clearly defined S-like shapes, with the melting temperatures in full accordance with those theoretically predicted for the same ionic strength. This approach, based on keeping the protective groups attached to oligoribonucleotides, can be applied for manufacturing any RNA microchips containing immobilized oligoribonucleotides, including microchips with two-dimensional (2-D) features. These RNA microchips can be used to measure thermodynamic parameters of RNA/RNA or RNA/DNA duplexes as well as to study ligand- or protein-RNA interactions.     

Biophysical methods for biochip analysis. Use of wide-field digital fluorescence microscopy

This paper discusses the development of biophysical methods for biochip analysis. A scheme and construction of a biochip analyzer based on wide-field digital fluorescence microscopy are described. The analyzer is designed to register images of biological microchips labeled with fluorescent dyes. The device developed is useful for high-sensitivity throughput recording of analyses with biochips after interaction of immobilized probes with fluorescently labeled sample molecules as well as it provides a higher rate of the analysis compared with laser scanning devices. With this analyzer, the scope where biological microchips can be applied becomes wider, development of new protocols of the analyses is possible and standard analyses run faster with the use of biochips, the expenses for performing routine analyses can be reduced.     

Modeling micropatterned antigen-antibody binding kinetics in a microfluidic chip

The reaction kinetics of antigen-antibody binding in the electrokinetically controlled microfluidic heterogeneous immunoassays has been investigated by numerical simulations. A two-dimensional computational model was employed to include the mass transport (convection and diffusion) and binding reaction between the antigen in the bulk flow and the immobilized antibody at the channel surface. The influence of the bulk velocity, the concentrations of the antibody and antigen, and the geometry of the microchips was studied for a variation of conditions and the guidance for designing of microfluidic immunoassay was provided. The model also shows that electrokinetically driven immunoassays have better reaction kinetics than pressure-driven ones, resulting from the plug-like velocity profile. Finally, a multi-patch immunoassay chip was analyzed and the reaction kinetics was optimized by rearranging the reaction patches at the channel surfaces.