Processivity and Velocity for Motors Stepping on Periodic Tracks

Processive molecular motors enable cargo transportation by assembling into dimers capable of taking several consecutive steps along a cytoskeletal filament. In the well-accepted hand-over-hand stepping mechanism, the trailing motor detaches from the track and binds the filament again in the leading position. This requires fuel consumption in the form of ATP hydrolysis and coordination of the catalytic cycles between the leading and the trailing heads. Alternate stepping pathways also exist, including inchworm-like movements, backward steps, and foot stomps. Whether all the pathways are coupled to ATP hydrolysis remains to be determined. Here, to establish the principles governing the dynamics of processive movement, we present a theoretical framework that includes all of the alternative stepping mechanisms. Our theory bridges the gap between the elemental rates describing the biochemical and structural transitions in each head and the experimentally measurable quantities such as velocity, processivity, and probability of backward stepping. Our results, obtained under the assumption that the track is periodic and infinite, provide expressions that hold regardless of the topology of the network connecting the intermediate states, and are therefore capable of describing the function of any molecular motor. We apply the theory to myosin VI, a motor that takes frequent backward steps and moves forward with a combination of hand-over-hand and inchworm-like steps. Our model quantitatively reproduces various observables of myosin VI motility reported by four experimental groups. The theory is used to predict the gating mechanism, the pathway for backward stepping, and the energy consumption as a function of ATP concentration.     

Entropy rectifies the Brownian steps of kinesin

Kinesin is a stepping motor that successively produces forward and backward 8-nm steps along microtubules. Under physiological conditions, the steps powering kinesin's motility are biased in one direction and drive various biological motile processes. The physical mechanism underlying the unidirectional bias of the kinesin steps is not fully understood. Here we explored the mechanical kinetics and thermodynamics of forward and backward kinesin steps by analyzing their temperature and load dependence. Results show that the frequency asymmetry between forward and backward steps is produced by entropy. Furthermore, the magnitude of the entropic asymmetry is 6 k(B)T, more than three times greater than expected from a current model, in which a mechanical conformational change within the kinesin molecular structure directly biases the kinesin steps forward. We propose that the stepping direction of kinesin is preferably caused by an entropy asymmetry resulting from the compatibility between the kinesin and microtubule interaction based on their polar structures.     

Spontaneous Detachment of the Leading Head Contributes to Myosin VI Backward Steps

Myosin VI is an ATP driven molecular motor that normally takes forward and processive steps on actin filaments, but also on occasion stochastic backward steps. While a number of models have attempted to explain the backwards steps, none offer an acceptable mechanism for their existence. We therefore performed single molecule imaging of myosin VI and calculated the stepping rates of forward and backward steps at the single molecule level. The forward stepping rate was proportional to the ATP concentration, whereas the backward stepping rate was independent. Using these data, we proposed that spontaneous detachment of the leading head is uncoupled from ATP binding and is responsible for the backward steps of myosin VI.     

Single-molecule analysis of dynein processivity and stepping behavior

Cytoplasmic dynein, the 1.2 MDa motor driving minus-end-directed motility, has been reported to move processively along microtubules, but its mechanism of motility remains poorly understood. Here, using S. cerevisiae to produce recombinant dynein with a chemically controlled dimerization switch, we show by structural and single-molecule analysis that processivity requires two dynein motor domains but not dynein's tail domain or any associated subunits. Dynein advances most frequently in 8 nm steps, although longer as well as side and backward steps are observed. Individual motor domains show a different stepping pattern, which is best explained by the two motor domains shuffling in an alternating manner between rear and forward positions. Our results suggest that cytoplasmic dynein moves processively through the coordination of its two motor domains, but its variable step size and direction suggest a considerable diffusional component to its step, which differs from Kinesin-1 and is more akin to myosin VI.     

Steps in the Bacterial Flagellar Motor

The bacterial flagellar motor is a highly efficient rotary machine used by many bacteria to propel themselves. It has recently been shown that at low speeds its rotation proceeds in steps. Here we propose a simple physical model, based on the storage of energy in protein springs, that accounts for this stepping behavior as a random walk in a tilted corrugated potential that combines torque and contact forces. We argue that the absolute angular position of the rotor is crucial for understanding step properties and show this hypothesis to be consistent with the available data, in particular the observation that backward steps are smaller on average than forward steps. We also predict a sublinear speed versus torque relationship for fixed load at low torque, and a peak in rotor diffusion as a function of torque. Our model provides a comprehensive framework for understanding and analyzing stepping behavior in the bacterial flagellar motor and proposes novel, testable predictions. More broadly, the storage of energy in protein springs by the flagellar motor may provide useful general insights into the design of highly efficient molecular machines.     

Three phase model of the processive motor protein kinesin

Kinesin is a stepping motor that successively produces forward and backward 8-nm steps along microtubules. Under physiological conditions, the steps powering kinesin's motility are biased in one direction and drive various biological motile processes. So far, the physical mechanism underlying the unidirectional bias of the kinesin is not fully understood. Recently, Martin Bier have provided a stepper model [Martin Bier, 2003, Processive motor protein as an overdamped Brownian stepper, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 148104], in which the stepping cycle of kinesin includes two distinguished phases: (i) a power stroke phase and (ii) a ratcheted diffusion phase which is characterized as a "random diffusional search". At saturating ATP level, this model can fit the experimental results accurately. In this paper, we'll provide a modified Brownian stepper model, in which the dependence of ATP concentration is considered. In our model, the stepping cycle of kinesin is distinguished into three phases: an ATP-binding phase, a power stroke phase and a ratcheted diffusion phase. This modified model can reconstruct most of the experimental results accurately.     

Dwell time symmetry in random walks and molecular motors

The statistics of steps and dwell times in reversible molecular motors differ from those of cycle completion in enzyme kinetics. The reason is that a step is only one of several transitions in the mechanochemical cycle. As a result, theoretical results for cycle completion in enzyme kinetics do not apply to stepping data. To allow correct parameter estimation, and to guide data analysis and experiment design, a theoretical treatment is needed that takes this observation into account. In this article, we model the distribution of dwell times and number of forward and backward steps using first passage processes, based on the assumption that forward and backward steps correspond to different directions of the same transition. We extend recent results for systems with a single cycle and consider the full dwell time distributions as well as models with multiple pathways, detectable substeps, and detachments. Our main results are a symmetry relation for the dwell time distributions in reversible motors, and a relation between certain relative step frequencies and the free energy per cycle. We demonstrate our results by analyzing recent stepping data for a bacterial flagellar motor, and discuss the implications for the efficiency and reversibility of the force-generating subunits.     

How Cytoplasmic Dynein Couples ATP Hydrolysis Cycle to Diverse Stepping Motions: Kinetic Modeling

Cytoplasmic dynein is a two-headed molecular motor that moves to the minus end of a microtubule by ATP hydrolysis free energy. By employing its two heads (motor domains), cytoplasmic dynein exhibits various bipedal stepping motions: inchworm and hand-over-hand motions, as well as nonalternating steps of one head. However, the molecular basis to achieve such diverse stepping manners remains unclear because of the lack of an experimental method to observe stepping and the ATPase reaction of dynein simultaneously. Here, we propose a kinetic model for bipedal motions of cytoplasmic dynein and perform Gillespie Monte Carlo simulations that qualitatively reproduce most experimental data obtained to date. The model represents the status of each motor domain as five states according to conformation and nucleotide- and microtubule-binding conditions of the domain. In addition, the relative positions of the two domains were approximated by three discrete states. Accompanied by ATP hydrolysis cycles, the model dynein stochastically and processively moved forward in multiple steps via diverse pathways, including inchworm and hand-over-hand motions, similarly to experimental data. The model reproduced key experimental motility-related properties, including velocity and run length, as functions of the ATP concentration and external force, therefore providing a plausible explanation of how dynein achieves various stepping manners with explicit characterization of nucleotide states. Our model highlights the uniqueness of dynein in the coupling of ATPase with its movement during both inchworm and hand-over-hand stepping.     

Force-induced bidirectional stepping of cytoplasmic dynein

Cytoplasmic dynein is a minus-end-directed microtubule motor whose mechanism of movement remains poorly understood. Here, we use optical tweezers to examine the force-dependent stepping behavior of yeast cytoplasmic dynein. We find that dynein primarily advances in 8 nm increments but takes other sized steps (4-24 nm) as well. An opposing force induces more frequent backward stepping by dynein, and the motor walks backward toward the microtubule plus end at loads above its stall force of 7 pN. Remarkably, in the absence of ATP, dynein steps processively along microtubules under an external load, with less force required for minus-end- than for plus-end-directed movement. This nucleotide-independent walking reveals that force alone can drive repetitive microtubule detachment-attachment cycles of dynein's motor domains. These results suggest a model for how dynein's two motor domains coordinate their activities during normal processive motility and provide new clues for understanding dynein-based motility in living cells.     

Stepping behavior of two-headed kinesin motors

The stepping behavior of the dimeric kinesin is studied by using our model based on previous biochemical, X-ray crystallography and cryo-electron microscopy studies. It is shown that, when a Pi is released from the trailing head, a forward step is made under a backward load smaller than the stall force; while when a Pi is released from the leading head, no stepping is made under a forward load or no load, and a backward step is made under a backward load. The forward stepping time, i.e., the time from the release of Pi in the trailing head to the binding of the ADP head to next binding site, is much smaller than the dwell time even under the backward load near the stall force. Thus the movement velocity of the kinesin dimer can be considered to be only dependent on ATPase rates of the two heads. The duration of the rising phase, i.e., the actual time taken by the ADP head to transit from the trailing to leading positions, is on the time scale of microseconds under any backward load smaller than the stall force. This is consistent with available experimental results.     

Stepping behavior of two-headed kinesin motors

The stepping behavior of the dimeric kinesin is studied by using our model based on previous biochemical, X-ray crystallography and cryo-electron microscopy studies. It is shown that, when a Pi is released from the trailing head, a forward step is made under a backward load smaller than the stall force; while when a Pi is released from the leading head, no stepping is made under a forward load or no load, and a backward step is made under a backward load. The forward stepping time, i.e., the time from the release of Pi in the trailing head to the binding of the ADP head to next binding site, is much smaller than the dwell time even under the backward load near the stall force. Thus the movement velocity of the kinesin dimer can be considered to be only dependent on ATPase rates of the two heads. The duration of the rising phase, i.e., the actual time taken by the ADP head to transit from the trailing to leading positions, is on the time scale of microseconds under any backward load smaller than the stall force. This is consistent with available experimental results.     

Walking motion of an overdamped active particle in a ratchet potential

An active particle can convert its internal energy into mechanical work. We study a generalized energy-depot model of an overdamped active particle in a ratchet potential. Using well-known biological parameters for kinesin-1 and modeling ATP influx as a pulsed energy supply, we apply our model to the molecular motor system. We find that our simple model can capture the essential properties of the kinesin motor such as forward stepping, stalling, backward stepping, dependence on ATP concentration, and stall force. Our model might be quite universal in the sense that it is able to describe dynamics of various types of motors as long as realistic parameters for each motor species are adopted.     

Dynamics of the bacterial flagellar motor: the effects of stator compliance, back steps, temperature, and rotational asymmetry

The rotation of a bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is driven by multiple stators tethered to the cell wall. Here, we extend a recently proposed power-stroke model to study the BFM dynamics under different biophysical conditions. Our model explains several key experimental observations and reveals their underlying mechanisms. 1), The observed independence of the speed at low load on the number of stators is explained by a force-dependent stepping mechanism that is independent of the strength of the stator tethering spring. Conversely, without force-dependent stepping, an unrealistically weak stator spring is required. 2), Our model with back-stepping naturally explains the observed absence of a barrier to backward rotation. Using the same set of parameters, it also explains BFM behaviors in the high-speed negative-torque regime. 3), From the measured temperature dependence of the maximum speed, our model shows that stator-stepping is a thermally activated process with an energy barrier. 4), The recently observed asymmetry in the torque-speed curve between counterclockwise- and clockwise-rotating BFMs can be quantitatively explained by the asymmetry in the stator-rotor interaction potentials, i.e., a quasilinear form for the counterclockwise motor and a quadratic form for the clockwise motor.     

Fast backward steps and detachment of single kinesin molecules measured under a wide range of loads

To understand force generation under a wide range of loads, the stepping of single kinesin molecules was measured at loads from −20 to 42 pN by optical tweezers with high temporal resolution. The optical trap has been improved to halve positional noise and increase bandwidth by using 200-nm beads. The step size of the forward and backward steps was 8.2 nm even over a wide range of loads. Histograms of the dwell times of backward steps and detachment fit well to two independent exponential equations with fast (~0.4 ms) and slow (>3 ms) time constants, indicating the existence of a fast step in addition to the conventional slow step. The dwell times of the fast steps were almost independent of the load and ATP concentration, while those of the slow backward steps and detachment depended on those. We constructed the kinetic model to explain the fast and slow steps under a wide range of loads.     

Unconstrained steps of myosin VI appear longest among known molecular motors

Myosin VI is a two-headed molecular motor that moves along an actin filament in the direction opposite to most other myosins. Previously, a single myosin VI molecule has been shown to proceed with steps that are large compared to its neck size: either it walks by somehow extending its neck or one head slides along actin for a long distance before the other head lands. To inquire into these and other possible mechanism of motility, we suspended an actin filament between two plastic beads, and let a single myosin VI molecule carrying a bead duplex move along the actin. This configuration, unlike previous studies, allows unconstrained rotation of myosin VI around the right-handed double helix of actin. Myosin VI moved almost straight or as a right-handed spiral with a pitch of several micrometers, indicating that the molecule walks with strides slightly longer than the actin helical repeat of 36 nm. The large steps without much rotation suggest kinesin-type walking with extended and flexible necks, but how to move forward with flexible necks, even under a backward load, is not clear. As an answer, we propose that a conformational change in the lifted head would facilitate landing on a forward, rather than backward, site. This mechanism may underlie stepping of all two-headed molecular motors including kinesin and myosin V.     

Single molecule processes on the stepwise movement of ATP-driven molecular motors

Movement is a fundamental characteristic of all living things. This biogenic function that is attributed to the molecular motors such as kinesin, dynein and myosin. Molecular motors generate forces by using chemical energy derived from the hydrolysis reaction of ATP molecules. Despite a large number of studies on this topic, the chemomechanical energy transduction mechanism is still unsolved. In this study, we have investigated the chemomechanical coupling of the ATPase cycle to the mechanical events of the molecular motor kinesin using single molecule detection (SMD) techniques. The SMD techniques allowed to detection of the movement of single kinesin molecules along a microtubule and showed that kinesin steps mainly in the forward direction, but occasionally in the backward. The stepping direction is determined by a certain load-dependent process, on which the stochastic behavior is well characterized by Feynman's thermal ratchet model. The driving force of the stepwise movement is essentially Brownian motion, but it is biased in the forward direction by using the free energy released from the hydrolysis of ATP.     

Mapping the classical cross-bridge theory and backward steps in a three bead laser trap setup

According to the cross-bridge theory (Huxley, 1957) [1], the interaction between myosin and actin is governed by a deterministic process where the myosin molecule pulls the actin filament in one specific direction only. However, studies on single myosin-actin interactions produced displacements of actin not only in the preferred but also in the opposite direction. This phenomenon is typically referred to as backward steps by the myosin head. Molloy et al. (1995) [2] speculated that these backward steps are not caused by the molecular interactions of actin with myosin but are an artifact of the Brownian motion associated with these molecular level experiments. The aim of this study was to investigate, whether a theoretical model can support Molloy’s speculation. We therefore developed a theoretical model of actin-myosin based muscle contraction that was strictly based on Huxley’s assumption of one stepping direction only, but incorporated Brownian motion, as observed in single cross-bridge-actin interactions. The mathematical model is based on Langevin equations describing the classical three-bead laser trap setup and uses a novel semi-analytical approach to study the percentage of backward steps. We analyzed the effects of different initial actin attachment site distribution and laser trap stiffness on the ratio of forward to backward steps. Our results demonstrate that backward steps and the classical cross-bridge theory are perfectly compatible in a three-bead laser trap setup.     

Experimental modification of stepping course in spontaneously initiated locomotor behavior in the crayfish Procambarus clarkii Girard

The stepping course in spontaneously initiated walking of crayfish was quantitatively analyzed using a spherical treadmill system. In complete darkness, some animals stepped either forward or backward at random whereas others showed individually a consistent tendency of stepping in a specific direction although no external sensory cue was provided. The tendency was statistically significant and invariable for at least 6-8 h. When a light stimulus was present in front of the animal, the stepping course tended to be backward or curved forward to avoid the stimulus. Either in complete darkness or in the presence of a light stimulus, the animal's tendency to step in a specific direction could be modified experimentally by applying electrical stimulation to a part of the animal body upon stepping in the preferred direction. The newly acquired tendency of stepping direction could be retained for 6 h and modified again by a similar procedure of electric stimulation. Both before and after modification of the stepping course tendency, animals seldom changed their stepping direction once the walking was initiated. These findings suggest that the stepping course in spontaneously initiated walking is significantly affected by animal's previous experience and could be predetermined at the onset of walking.     

Load and Pi control flux through the branched kinetic cycle of myosin V

Myosin V is a processive actin-based motor protein that takes multiple 36-nm steps to deliver intracellular cargo to its destination. In the laser trap, applied load slows myosin V heavy meromyosin stepping and increases the probability of backsteps. In the presence of 40 mm phosphate (P(i)), both forward and backward steps become less load-dependent. From these data, we infer that P(i) release commits myosin V to undergo a highly load-dependent transition from a state in which ADP is bound to both heads and its lead head trapped in a pre-powerstroke conformation. Increasing the residence time in this state by applying load increases the probability of backstepping or detachment. The kinetics of detachment indicate that myosin V can detach from actin at two distinct points in the cycle, one of which is turned off by the presence of P(i). We propose a branched kinetic model to explain these data. Our model includes P(i) release prior to the most load-dependent step in the cycle, implying that P(i) release and load both act as checkpoints that control the flux through two parallel pathways.