Molecular,biochemical and bioassay based evidence of lower allelopathic potential in genetically modified rice

This study examines allelopathic potential of genetically modified rice. The experiment was conducted on two isogenic lines Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) and non-Bacillus thuringiensis (non-Bt). Both isogenic lines have same allelopathic ability before insect feeding and after limited insect feeding (Spodoptera litura) non-Bt rice genotype demonstrates more allelopathic potential. The S. litura cannot feed Bt rice genotype. The role of shoot herbivory in allelopathic induction is further supported when Bt plants also exhibited higher allelopathic potential after insect regurgitant application to the damaged leaves. Allelopathic potential was assessed through several methods after treatments of mechanical damage, insect feeding and insect regurgitant application to damaged rice leaves. Rhizosphere soil and leaf leachates of non-Bt rice cultivar exhibited higher allelopathic potential on lettuce and barnyard grass after herbivore feeding. Enzyme activities (PAL and C4H) responsible for biosynthesis of phenolic compounds and their concentration were significantly higher in non-Bt plant after herbivore feeding and attain the same level in Bt plants after insect regurgitant application to damaged leaves. Similarly, genes (OsPAL and OsCYC1) responsible for biosynthesis of allelopathic compounds showed high expression in non-Bt plants after herbivore feeding. Our results indicate that herbivore feeding enhance rice allelopathic potential and no insect feeding as incase of Bt plants may reduce allelopathic potential of genetically modified rice.     

The chemical-mediated allelopathic interaction between rice and barnyard grass

Aims

The possible involvement of the chemical-mediated interaction in allelopathy between rice and barnyard grass was investigated.

Methods

Effcts of rice seedlings and rice root exudate on the alleloapthic activity of barnyard grass were determined and a key compound invovled in the allelopathic interaction between rice and barnyard grass was isolated.

Results

Allelopathic activity of barnyard grass was increased by the presence of rice seedlings. Rice root exudates also elevated the allelopahtic activity of barnyard grass. A key compound, which increased the allelopathic activity of barnyard grass, in the rice root exudates was isolated and determined as momilactone B. Momilactone B increased the allelopathic activity of barnyard grass at concentrations greater than 3 μM, and increasing the momilactone B concentration increased the activity.

Conclusions

Momilactone B is known to act as a potent rice allelochemical and to possess strong growth inhibitory activity against barnyard grass. The present research suggests that barnyard grass may response to the presence of neighboring rice by sensing momilactone B in rice root exudates and increase allelopathic activity. Thus, momilactone B may not only act as a rice allelochemical but also play an important role in rice-induced allelopathy of barnyard grass. The induced-allelopathy may provide a competitive advantage for barnyard grass through the growth inhibition of competing plant species including rice. Barnyard grass allelopathy may be one of the inducible defense mechanisms by chemical-mediated plant interaction between rice and barnyard grass. Rice allelopathy was also reported to be increased by the presence of barnyard grass through increasing production and secretion of momilactone B into surrounding environments. During the evolutional process, rice and barnyard grass may have developed the chemical cross talk to activate the defense mechanisms against some biotic stress conditions by detection of certain key compounds.     

Isolation and identification of a plant growth inhibitor from Tinospora tuberculata Beumee

Tinospora tuberculata Beumee has been used widely as a folk medicine and several bioactive compounds have been isolated. However, no herbicidal compound has been reported in this species. Therefore, we investigated the presence of phytotoxins in T. tuberculata. The aqueous methanol extracts of T. tuberculata inhibited the growth of roots and shoots of cress (Lepidum sativum L.), lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.), timothy (Phleum pratense L.) and barnyard grass (Echinochloa crus-galli (L.) Beauv.). The extract was then purified by several chromatographic runs with monitoring the inhibitory activity and the main phytotoxic substance was isolated. The chemical structure of the compound was determined by spectral data as syringin (4-[(1E)-3-Hydroxyprop-1-en-1-yl]-2,6-dimethoxyphenyl β-d-glucopyranoside). It inhibited the root and shoot growth of all test plant species at concentrations >10 µM. The concentrations required for 50 % inhibition of root and shoot growth of cress and lettuce ranged from 78.2 to 412 μM, and that of timothy and barnyard grass renged from 9.8 to 73.2 µM. Effectiveness of syringin on monocotyledonous (timothy and barnyard grass) plants was greater than that on dicotyledonous (cress and lettuce) plants. These results suggest that syringin may contribute to the allelopathic effect caused by the T. tuberculata extract.     

Barnyard grass-induced rice allelopathy and momilactone B

Here, we investigated chemical-mediated interaction between crop and weeds. Allelopathic activity of rice seedlings exhibited 5.3-6.3-fold increases when rice and barnyard grass seedlings were grown together, where there may be the competitive interference between rice and barnyard grass for nutrients. Barnyard grass is one of the most noxious weeds in rice cultivation. The momilactone B concentration in rice seedlings incubated with barnyard grass seedlings was 6.9-fold greater than that in rice seedlings incubated independently. Low nutrient growth conditions also increased allelopathic activity and momilactone B concentrations in rice seedlings. However, the increases in the low nutrient-induced allelopathic activity and momilactone B concentration were much lower than those in barnyard grass-induced allelopathic activity and momilactone B concentration. Root exudates of barnyard grass seedlings increased allelopathic activity and momilactone B concentration in rice seedlings at concentrations greater than 30 mg/L of the root exudates, and increasing the exudate concentration increased the activity and momilactone B concentration. Therefore, barnyard grass-induced allelopathic activity of rice seedlings may be caused not only by nutrient competition between two species, but also by components in barnyard grass root exudates. As momilactone B shows strong allelopathic activities, barnyard grass-induced allelopathic activity of rice may be due to the increased concentration of momilactone B in rice seedlings. The present research suggests that rice may respond to the presence of neighboring barnyard grass by sensing the components in barnyard grass root exudates and increasing allelopathic activity by production of elevated concentration of momilactone B. Thus, rice allelopathy may be one of the inducible defense mechanisms by chemical-mediated plant interaction between rice and barnyard grass, and the induced-allelopathy may provide a competitive advantage for rice through suppression of the growth of barnyard grass.     

Allelochemicals released by rice roots and residues in soil

A few rice (Oryza sativa L.) varieties or rice straw produce and release allelochemicals into soil in which interfere with the growth of neighboring or successive plants. Allelopathic rice PI312777 and Huagan-1 at their early growth stages released momilactone B, 3-isopropyl-5-acetoxycyclohexene-2-one-1, and 5,7,4′-trihydroxy-3′,5′-dimethoxyflavone into soil at phytotoxic levels, but non-allelopathic rice Huajingxian did not. Both allelopathic and non-allelopathic rice residues released momilactone B and lignin-related phenolic acids (p-hydroxybenzoic, p-coumaric, ferulic, syringic and vanillic acids) into the soil during residue decomposition to inhibit successive plants. The results indicated that allelochemicals involved in rice allelopathy from living and dead plants are substantially different. Interestingly, the concentrations of the allelochemicals released from the allelopathic rice seedlings in soil increased dramatically when they were surrounded with Echinochloa crus-galli. The concentrations of the allelochemicals were over 3-fold higher in the presence of E. crus-galli than in the absence of E. crus-galli. However, the same case did not occur in non-allelopathic Huajingxian seedlings surrounded with E. crus-galli. In addition to allelochemical exudation being promoted by the presence of E. crus-galli, allelopathic rice seedlings also increased allelochemical exudation in response to exudates of germinated E. crus-galli seeds or lepidimoide, an uronic acid derivative exuded from E. crus-galli seeds. These results imply that allelopathic rice seedlings can sense certain allelochemicals released by E. crus-galli into the soil, and respond by increased production of allelochemicals inhibitory to E. crus-galli. This study suggests that rice residues of both allelopathic and non-allelopathic varieties release similar concentrations and types of allelochemicals to inhibit successive plants. In contrast, living rice plants of certain allelopathic varieties appear to be able to detect the presence of interspecific neighbors and respond by increased allelochemicals.     

The relation between growth inhibition and secretion level of momilactone B from rice root

Abstract

The growth inhibitory activity of seven rice (Oryza sativa L.) cultivars and the secretion level of momilactone B from these rice cultivars were determined to understand chemical basis of the interaction of rice with other plant species. All rice cultivars inhibited the growth of hypocotyls and roots of lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) seedlings when the lettuce was grown together with the rice, and showed different range of the inhibitory activity. These results suggest that all rice cultivars may possess allelopathic activity and the activity may be cultivar dependent. Momilactone B, which is a potent growth inhibitor, was found in root exudates of all rice cultivars, and the momilactone B concentration was also cultivar-dependent. The allelopathic activity of each rice cultivar was closely correlated with momilactone B concentration in the root exudates. The present results suggest that rice cultivars possess various allelopathic activities and their allelopathic activity may depend on the secretion level of momilactone B. Therefore, momilactone B may play an important role in rice allelopathy and in the chemical interactions of rice with other plant species.     

Allelopathic Substance Exuded from a Serious Weed, Germinating Barnyard Grass (Echinochloa crus-galli L.), Roots

The allelopathy of a serious weed, barnyard grass (Echinochloa crus-galli L.), was investigated. Root exudates of young barnyard grass showed allelopathic effects and plant-selective activity and inhibited root elongation of all plants tested. With respect to shoot growth, the exudates did not show inhibition of barnyard grass only. The allelopathic substance was isolated and identified as p-hydroxymandelic acid by NMR. p-Hydroxymandelic acid strongly inhibited shoot growth and root elongation of all plants tested. The effects of three congeners of p-hydroxymandelic acid were tested on rice shoot growth. In the biological activity exhibited in rice, shoot growth was related to the hydroxyl groups. Received October 7, 1998; accepted March 29, 1999     

Influence of supplemental ultraviolet-B on indoleacetic acid and calmodulin in the leaves of rice (Oryza sativa L.)

IR68 and Dular rice cultivars were grown under ambient, 13.0 (simulating 20% ozone depletion) and 19.1 (simulating 40% ozone depletion) kJ m^-2 day^-1 of biologically effective ultraviolet-B (UV-B_BE) for 4 weeks. Plant height and leaf area were significantly reduced by supplemental UV-B_BE radiation. Greater reduction in leaf area than of plant height was observed. A decrease in indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) content and increase in peroxidase and IAA oxidase activities of UV-B treated plants in both cultivars were observed compared with ambient control. Calmodulin content also decreased after plants were treated with high supplemental UV-B for two weeks and medium UV-B treatment for four weeks. The results indicated that peroxidase and IAA oxidase activities in rice leaves were stimulated by supplemental UV-B, resulting in the destruction of IAA which in turn may cause inhibition of rice leaf growth. Although the mechanism is unclear, calmodulin is most likely involved in leaf growth.     

An allelopathic substance exuded from germinating watermelon seeds

When watermelon seeds were cultured in a Petri dish together with amaranth, barnyard grass, cockscomb, lettuce or tomato seeds, the shoot growth of amaranth and cockscomb was markedly promoted, whereas the shoot growth of lettuce and tomato was inhibited. The shoot growth of barnyard grass was not affected. These results suggest that plant-selective allelopathic substance(s) affecting the shoot growth of other plant seedlings were exuded from watermelon seeds. An allelopathic substance was isolated from the exudates of germinating watermelon seeds and identified as vanillic acid by its spectral analysis and Rf value on TLC. Vanillic acid promoted the shoot growth of cockscomb at the concentrations of 300 to 10 mg/l and that of amaranth at the concentrations of 30 to 3 mg/l, although the shoot growth of amaranth was inhibited by 300 mg/l of vanillic acid. The shoot growth of lettuce and tomato was inhibited at the concentrations higher than 30 mg/l by vanillic acid. However, the shoot growth of barnyard grass was not affected at the concentrations used. All these results suggest that vanillic acid may play as a major component of allelopathic substance(s), which shows plant-selective activity, in the exudates of germinating watermelon seeds.     

Allelopathy of rice (Oryza sativa L.) root exudates and its relations with Orobanche cumana Wallr. and Orobanche minor Sm. germination

Allelopathy has been considered not only as an environmentally friendly approach for weed control but also a potential reason causing autotoxicity in crop production. In this study, the responses of seeds of lettuce, wheat, rice, clover broomrape (CB), and sunflower broomrape (SB) to the root exudates of rice cultivars were studied. Lettuce germination was promoted by root exudates of Yliangyou 3218 and I-Kung-Pao. Wheat seedling growth was inhibited by all nine rice species. I-Kung-Pao and Ganxin 203 exerted greater autotoxicity than other cultivars. Yongyou 15 and I-Kung-Pao induced the highest germination rate of CB, while Yongyou 13, Zhongzao 22, and I-Kung-Pao induced the highest germination rate of SB. A significantly correlation was noted between germination-inducing ability on broomrape seeds and allelopathic effects on target plants. It is suggested that using broomrape seeds germination is a better receptor for the identification of rice allelopathic potential.     

Differential ozone sensitivity of rice cultivars as indicated by visible injury and grain yield

Surface ozone pollution may cause reductions in rice ( Oryza sativa L.) yield. Ozone sensitivity in rice cultivars is often evaluated based on visible leaf injury at an early growth stage. However, it is not clear whether reduction in grain yield is related to visible injury. Therefore, visible damage and grain yield reduction were examined in Japanese and Asian rice cultivars exposed to ozone. In experiment 1, 3-week-old rice seedlings were exposed to ozone (min.: 20 nl·l⁻¹, max.:120 nl·l⁻¹) for 12 h in open-top chambers (OTCs). Visible leaf injury was quantified according to a leaf bronzing score. In experiment 2, rice plants were exposed to ozone in OTCs throughout the cropping season until grain harvest. Daily mean ozone concentrations were maintained at 2, 23, 28, 42, and 57 nl·l⁻¹ with a regular diurnal pattern of exposure. After harvest, grain yield was determined. Based on visible injury to the uppermost fully expanded leaf, the indica cultivar 'Kasalath' was most tolerant, and the japonica cultivar 'Kirara 397' was most sensitive to ozone. However, grain yields for both 'Kasalath' and 'Kirara 397' were significantly decreased after ozone exposure. The indica cultivar 'Jothi' suffered severe injury after ozone exposure but had no reduction in grain yield. Therefore, ozone sensitivity of rice cultivars evaluated by visible injury did not coincide with that evaluated by the reductions in grain yield. These results suggest that mechanisms that induce acute leaf injury do not relate to chronic ozone toxicity that reduces yield.     

水稻和稗草共生土壤微生物生物量碳及酶活性的变化

以稻田稗草、化感水稻PI312777和普通水稻辽粳9为试材,研究了田间稗草和水稻1∶1共生条件下,土壤微生物生物量碳及脱氢酶、脲酶和转化酶活性的变化.结果表明：在稗草 的干扰下,化感水稻PI312777根区土壤微生物生物量碳含量比单作减少了 50.52％（P<0.01）,而行间土壤微生物生物量碳含量增加;普通水稻辽粳9根区土壤 微生物生物量碳含量比单作减少了38.99％（P<0.01）,但其行间土壤微生物生物量碳含量无明显变化.两个水稻品种根区土壤脱氢酶活性均被显著抑制（P<0.05）,下降率都在20％以上;PI312777根区土壤脲酶和转化酶活性均被显著促进（P<0.01）;而辽粳9根区土壤转化酶活性也被显著抑制（P<0.01）,但脲酶活性无明显变化.化感水稻根区土壤微生物生物量碳含量的显著减少及脲酶、转化酶活性的增加是其化感特性的表现,表明土壤微生物和酶均参与了水稻和稗草的种间作用,化感水稻具有抗稗草干扰的明显优势.     

Allelopathic effects of volatiles from some Cruciferae species on lettuce,barnyard grass and wheat growth

Exposure of germinating seeds of lettuce, barnyard grass and wheat to volatile substances released from pulverised leaves of some Cruciferae species resulted in delay of germination and reduction of overall growth.B. juncea andB. nigra volatiles were the most damaging to all of the tested species. It is suggested that degradation products of glucosinolates occuring in cruciferous plants caused this allelopathic action.     

Protein expression in accessions of Chinese onion with different allelopathic potentials under monocropping and intercropping systems

Protein expressions of Chinese onion accessions grown under monoculture and intercropped with cucumber were evaluated in pot experiments. Chinese onion accessions used were L04 (with weak allelopathic potential) and L06 (with strong allelopathic potential). Root proteins were separated by two-dimensional electrophoresis and the variable expressed protein spots were identified with MALDI-TOF-TOF mass spectrometer. Forty-seven identified proteins were classified into nine functional categories. Compared monocropping and intercropping, 31 identified variable protein spots were classified into energy metabolism (14 %), phenylpropanoid biosynthesis (28 %), organosulfur compounds biosynthesis (25 %), carbohydrate metabolism (10 %), fatty acid hydrogen peroxide metabolism (9 %), protein translation (3 %), other function (3 %), and no assigned function (9 %). Compared Chinese onion accessions of differing allelopathy potentials, 22 identified variable protein spots were classified into energy metabolism (18 %), phenylpropanoid biosynthesis (27 %), organosulfur compounds biosynthesis (23 %), carbohydrate metabolism (9 %), nucleosome component (4 %), other function (14 %), and no assigned function (5 %). The level of variable-expressed proteins involved in phenylpropanoid and organosulfur compounds biosynthesis significantly upregulated in treatments intercropped with cucumber. These results suggested that putative allelochemicals of Chinese onion were mainly produced by phenylpropanoid biosynthesis and organosulfur compounds biosynthesis pathway.     

茉莉酮酸甲酯对水稻化感物质的诱导效应

在室内和田间条件下 ,外源茉莉酮酸甲酯均能显著地诱导水稻化感物质的合成 ,而且这种诱导效应与施用茉莉酮酸甲酯的浓度和诱导时间显著相关。 0 .4 m mol/L浓度和处理后 4 8h,茉莉酮酸甲酯对水稻化感物质的诱导效应最强。同样 ,不同的水稻品种对茉莉酮酸甲酯的诱导响应也有显著差异。水稻化感品种 PI312 777和丰华占在茉莉酮酸甲酯的诱导下能很快合成大量的化感物质 ,而水稻非化感品种华粳籼的化感物质的含量虽也有所增加 ,但达不到能显示化感作用的浓度。进一步实验证明 :茉莉酮酸甲酯在处理 4 8h后虽能诱导水稻品种合成大量的化感物质 ,但这一诱导效应并不能长期维持。研究揭示 :水稻化感物质的合成可在外部因子的作用下动态变化 ,这对揭示和充分利用水稻的化感作用机制有重要意义。     

Impact of allelopathic rice seedlings on rhizospheric microbial populations and their functional diversity

Field performance of rice allelopathic potential is indirectly regulated by the microflora in the rhizosphere. The present study aimed to investigate the dynamics of microbial populations and their functional diversities in the seedling rhizospheres of rice cultivars with varied allelopathic activities by employing agar plate bioassay, fumigation and BIOLOG analysis. Rice cultivars significantly affected the microbial carbon content in their associated rhizospheric soil. The microbial carbon contents were ranked in a decreasing order as Iguape Cateto (441.0 mg·kg^–1) > IAC47 (389.7 mg·kg^–1) > PI312777 (333.2 mg·kg^–1) > Lemont (283.8 mg·kg^–1) with the nil-rice control soil of 129.3 mg·kg^–1. Similarly, the respiration rate of the soils was 1.404, 1.019, 0.671 and 0.488 μgC·g^–1· h^–1 for PI312777, Iguape Cateto, IAC47 and Lemont, respectively. The respiration rate was only 0.304 μ gC·g^–1·h^–1 for the control soil. The microbial flora in the rhizospheric soil of different rice cultivars was dominated by bacteria (58.4%–65.6%), followed by actinomycete (32.2%–39.4%) and fungi (2.2%–2.8%). BIOLOG analysis showed that the value of Average Well Color Development (AWCD) differed significantly among rice cultivars. It was always the highest in the rhizospheric soil of the strongly allelopathic rice cv. PI312777, and the lowest in the rhizospheric soil of the poorly allelopathic rice cv. Lemont. The AWCD value reached the maximum in all the sampled soils after 144 hours of incubation. The AWCD values from the rhizospheric soils of PI312777, IAC47, Iguape Cateto and Lemont were 1.89, 1.79, 1.60 and 1.43 times higher than that of the control soil. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) identified 3 principal component factors (PCF) in relation to carbon sources, accounting for 70.1%, 11.3% and 7.0% of the variation, respectively. 19 categories of carbon sources were significantly positively correlated to the 3 principal components. Phenolic acids, carbohydrates, amino acids and amides were significantly correlated to the principal component 1, phenolic acids, carbohydrates and fatty acids to the principal component 2, and carbohydrates and hydroxylic acids to the principal component 3. Amino acids and amides were the two main carbon sources separating the 3 principal component factors. In addition, the total microbial population in the rhizospheric soil was significantly positively correlated with AWCD, microbial biomass carbon, microbial respiration and Shannon index. There was a significantly positive correlation between the total microbial population and the inhibition rate (IR) on the root length of lettuce owing to the different allelopathic activities of the rice cultivars. These results suggest that changes in microbial population, activity and functional diversity in the rhizospheres are highly cultivar-dependent. These changes might play an important role in governing the rice allelopathic activity in the field.     

不同水层和密度条件下化感作用水稻对无芒稗的干扰控制作用

不同水层下水稻对无芒稗的干扰控制作用研究表明,水稻化感作用品种吓一跳、谷梅2号和中156对无芒稗的株高抑制作用比无化感作用品种秀水63和春江11呈显著性差异．随盆栽水稻密度增加,水稻对无芒稗的干扰控制作用加大．在每盆4株栽植密度下,水稻化感作用品种鸡早籼、谷梅2号显著抑制无芒稗植株株高;在每盆32株密度时,水稻化感作用品种吓一跳、PI312777、TN1等对受控无芒稗的干扰控制与无化感作用品种春江11相比,呈显著性水平．     

Assessment of Allelopathic Potential of Root Exudate of Rice Seedlings

To determine the allelopathic potential of root exudate from early developmental stage of rice (Oryza sativa L), 6-d-old seedlings of eight cultivars were grown with 3-d-old alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.), cress (Lepidium sativum L.) or lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) seedlings in Petri dishes under controlled condition. All rice cultivars (cv. Norin 8, Kamenoo, Nipponbare, Kinuhikari, Koshihikari, Sasanishiki, Yukihikari and Hinohikari) inhibited growth of roots, shoots and fresh mass of alfalfa, cress and lettuce seedlings. Effectiveness of cv. Koshihikari was the greatest and more than 60% inhibition was recorded in all bioassays, followed by that of cv. Norin 8 of which effectiveness was more than 40%.     

Analysis of gene expressions associated with increased allelopathy in rice (Oryza sativa L.) induced by exogenous salicylic acid

The defense characteristics of allelopathic rice accession PI312777 and its counterpart Lemont induced by exogenous salicylic acid (SA) to suppress troublesome weed barnyardgrass (BYG) were investigated using the methods of suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) and real-time fluorescence quantitative PCR (qRT-PCR). The results showed that exogenous SA could induce the allelopathic effect of rice on BYG and this inducible defense was SA dose-respondent and treatment time-dependent. PI312777 exhibited higher inhibitory effect than Lemont on BYG after treated with different concentrations of SA. The activities of cell protective enzymes including SOD, POD and CAT in the BYG plants co-cultured with PI312777 treated by SA were highly depressed compared with the control (co-cultured with rice without SA-treatment). Similar but lower depression on these enzymes except for CAT was also observed in the BYG plants when co-cultured with Lemont treated by SA. It is therefore suggested that allelopathic rice should be more sensitive than non-allelopathic rice to exogenous SA. Seventeen genes induced by SA were obtained by SSH analysis from PI312777. These genes encode receptor-kinase proteins, ubiquitin carrier proteins, proteins related to phenylpropanoid metabolism, antioxidant related proteins and some growth-mediating proteins. The differential expressions of these genes were validated in part by qRT-PCR in the two rice accessions. Our work elucidated that allelopathic rice possesses an active chemical defense and auto-detoxifying enzyme system such as the up-regulated enzymes involved in de novo biosynthesis of phenolic allelochemicals and the glutathione-S-transferase (GST) associated with xenobiotic detoxification.