Efficient cleavage of pre-tRNAs by E. coli RNAse P RNA requires the 2'-hydroxyl of the ribose at the cleavage site.

RNAse P cleaves pre-tRNAs to liberate 5'-flanks and 5'-matured, 5'-phosphorylated tRNAs. It is not evident if the 2'-hydroxyls of the ribose moieties in the substrate are involved in the reaction. To study their influence in two different pre-tRNAs, we have modified specifically the 2'-hydroxyl groups at the cleavage site and in neighbouring positions. We have shown that these hydroxyls are important but not essential for the processing of these substrates by E. coli RNase P RNA (M1 RNA). The reduction in the catalytic efficiency was moderate for 2'-deoxy and severe for 2'-methoxy substitutions at the cleavage site. Additional effects of modifications in neighbouring positions were smaller. Based on our data we suggest that the modifications do not interfere with binding of the substrate, whereas they prevent an optimal steric arrangement for the hydrolysis reaction.     

RNase MRP and RNase P share a common substrate.

RNase MRP is a site-specific ribonucleoprotein endoribonuclease that processes RNA from the mammalian mitochondrial displacement loop containing region. RNase P is a site-specific ribonucleoprotein endoribonuclease that processes pre-tRNAs to generate their mature 5'-ends. A similar structure for the RNase P and RNase MRP RNAs and a common cleavage mechanism for RNase MRP and RNase P enzymes have been proposed. Experiments with protein synthesis antibiotics have shown that both RNase MRP and RNase P are inhibited by puromycin. We also show that E. coli RNase P cleaves the RNase MRP substrate, mouse mitochondrial primer RNA, exactly at a site that is cleaved by RNase MRP.     

Evidence that substrate-specific effects of C5 protein lead to uniformity in binding and catalysis by RNase P

The ribonucleoprotein enzyme RNase P processes all pre-tRNAs, yet some substrates apparently lack consensus elements for recognition. Here, we compare binding affinities and cleavage rates of Escherichia coli pre-tRNAs that exhibit the largest variation from consensus recognition sequences. These results reveal that the affinities of both consensus and nonconsensus substrates for the RNase P holoenzyme are essentially uniform. Comparative analyses of pre-tRNA and tRNA binding to the RNase P holoenzyme and P RNA alone reveal differential contributions of the protein subunit to 5' leader and tRNA affinity. Additionally, these studies reveal that uniform binding results from variations in the energetic contribution of the 5' leader, which serve to compensate for weaker tRNA interactions. Furthermore, kinetic analyses reveal uniformity in the rates of substrate cleavage that result from dramatic (> 900-fold) contributions of the protein subunit to catalysis for some nonconsensus pre-tRNAs. Together, these data suggest that an important biological function of RNase P protein is to offset differences in pre-tRNA structure such that binding and catalysis are uniform.     

The RNR motif of B. subtilis RNase P protein interacts with both PRNA and pre-tRNA to stabilize an active conformer

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) catalyzes the metal-dependent 5′ end maturation of precursor tRNAs (pre-tRNAs). In Bacteria, RNase P is composed of a catalytic RNA (PRNA) and a protein subunit (P protein) necessary for function in vivo. The P protein enhances pre-tRNA affinity, selectivity, and cleavage efficiency, as well as modulates the cation requirement for RNase P function. Bacterial P proteins share little sequence conservation although the protein structures are homologous. Here we combine site-directed mutagenesis, affinity measurements, and single turnover kinetics to demonstrate that two residues (R60 and R62) in the most highly conserved region of the P protein, the RNR motif (R60–R68 in Bacillus subtilis), stabilize PRNA complexes with both P protein (PRNA•P protein) and pre-tRNA (PRNA•P protein•pre-tRNA). Additionally, these data indicate that the RNR motif enhances a metal-stabilized conformational change in RNase P that accompanies substrate binding and is essential for efficient catalysis. Stabilization of this conformational change contributes to both the decreased metal requirement and the enhanced substrate recognition of the RNase P holoenzyme, illuminating the role of the most highly conserved region of P protein in the RNase P reaction pathway.     

Acquisition of novel catalytic activity by the M1 RNA ribozyme: the cost of molecular adaptation.

The ribonucleoprotein RNase P is a critical component of metabolism in all known organisms. In Escherichia coli, RNase P processes a vast array of substrates, including precursor-tRNAs and precursor 4. 5S RNA. In order to understand how such catalytic versatility is achieved and how novel catalytic activity can be acquired, we evolve the M1 RNA ribozyme (the catalytic component of E. coli RNase P) in vitro for cleavage of a DNA substrate. In so doing, we probe the consequences of enhancing catalytic activity on a novel substrate and investigate the cost this versatile enzyme pays for molecular adaptation. A total of 25 generations of in vitro evolution yield a population showing more than a 1000-fold increase in DNA substrate cleavage efficiency (kcat/KM) relative to wild-type M1 RNA. This enhancement is accompanied by a significant reduction in the ability of evolved ribozymes to process the ptRNA class of substrates but also a contrasting increase in activity on the p4.5S RNA class of substrates. This change in the catalytic versatility of the evolved ribozymes suggests that the acquired activity comes at the cost of substrate versatility, and indicates that E. coli RNase P catalytic flexibility is maintained in vivo by selection for the processing of multiple substrates. M1 RNA derivatives enhance cleavage of the DNA substrate by accelerating the catalytic step (kcat) of DNA cleavage, although overall processing efficiency is offset by reduced substrate binding. The enhanced ability to cleave a DNA substrate cannot be readily traced to any of the predominant mutations found in the evolved population, and must instead be due to multiple sequence changes dispersed throughout the molecule. This conclusion underscores the difficulty of correlating observed mutations with changes in catalytic behavior, even in simple biological catalysts for which three-dimensional models are available.     

Modification interference approach to detect ribose moieties important for the optimal activity of a ribozyme.

A new approach for modification interference studies is presented. It involves the use of phosphorothioates as a handle to analyze any desired base or sugar modification. This method was applied to identify ribose and phosphate moieties which could be important in the pre-tRNA recognition of E. coli RNase P RNA (M1 RNA). The utility of this technique was confirmed by detecting the inhibitory effect of a deoxyribose in the 5'-flank (position-1). This site was already known to interfere with RNase P cleavage, if modified. We have analyzed pre-tRNA(Tyr) and pre-tRNA(Phe) and found different interference patterns for both tRNAs. Two unpaired regions were involved in both pre-tRNAs. Phosphorothioates interfered at the transition between acceptor- and D-arms. The results with deoxythymidines in the T-loop indicated that deoxyribose moieties or the extra methyl group in thymidine could interfere with RNAse P cleavage. These data suggest that even in complete pre-tRNAs, only a few intact ribonucleotides are important in the substrate recognition by RNase P. We have demonstrated the potential of this new approach which offers many future applications in all fields involving nucleic acids, for example RNA processing, action of ribozymes, tRNA charging and studies related to DNA promoter recognition.     

Important 2'-hydroxyl groups in model substrates for M1 RNA, the catalytic RNA subunit of RNase P from Escherichia coli.

The role of 2'-hydroxyl groups in a model substrate for RNase P from Escherichia coli was studied using mixed DNA/RNA derivatives of such a substrate. The presence of the 2'-hydroxyl groups of nucleotides at positions -1 and -2 in the leader sequence and at position 1, as well as at the first C in the 3'-terminal CCA sequence, are important but not absolutely essential for efficient cleavage of the substrate by RNase P or its catalytic RNA subunit, M1 RNA. The 2'-hydroxyl groups in the substrate that are important for efficient cleavage also participate in the binding of Mg2+. An all-DNA external guide sequence (EGS) can efficiently render a potential substrate, derived from the model substrate, susceptible to cleavage by the enzyme or its catalytic RNA subunit. Furthermore, both DNA and RNA EGSs turn over during the reaction with RNase P in vitro. The identity of the nucleotide at position 1 in the substrate, the adjacent Mg(2+)-binding site in the leader sequence, and the junction of the single and double-stranded regions are the important elements in the recognition of model substrates, as well as in the identification of the sites of cleavage in those model substrates.     

Requirements for cleavage by a modified RNase P of a small model substrate.

M1 RNA, the catalytic RNA subunit of RNase P from Escherichia coli, has been covalently linked at its 3' terminus to oligonucleotides (guide sequences) that guide the enzyme to target RNAs through hybridization with the target sequences. These constructs (M1GS RNAs) have been used to determine some minimal features of model substrates. As few as 3 bp on the 3' side of the site of cleavage in a substrate complex and 1 nt on the 5' side are required for cleavage to occur. The cytosines in the 3' terminal CCA sequence of the model substrates are important for cleavage efficiency but not cleavage site selection. A purine (base-paired or not) at the 3' side of the cleavage site is important both for cleavage site selection and efficiency. M1GS RNAs provide both a simple system for characterization of the reaction governed by M1 RNA and a tool for gene therapy.     

Recognition of the 5' leader of pre-tRNA substrates by the active site of ribonuclease P

The bacterial tRNA processing enzyme ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein composed of a approximately 400 nucleotide RNA and a smaller protein subunit. It has been established that RNase P RNA contacts the mature tRNA portion of pre-tRNA substrates, whereas RNase P protein interacts with the 5' leader sequence. However, specific interactions with substrate nucleotides flanking the cleavage site have not previously been defined. Here we provide evidence for an interaction between a conserved adenosine, A248 in the Escherichia coli ribozyme, and N(-1), the substrate nucleotide immediately 5' of the cleavage site. Specifically, mutations at A248 result in miscleavage of substrates containing a 2' deoxy modification at N(-1). Compensatory mutations at N(-1) restore correct cleavage in both the RNA-alone and holoenzyme reactions, and also rescue defects in binding thermodynamics caused by A248 mutation. Analysis of pre-tRNA leader sequences in Bacteria and Archaea reveals a conserved preference for U at N(-1), suggesting that an interaction between A248 and N(-1) is common among RNase P enzymes. These results provide the first direct evidence for RNase P RNA interactions with the substrate cleavage site, and show that RNA and protein cooperate in leader sequence recognition.     

Protein cofactor-dependent acquisition of novel catalytic activity by the RNase P ribonucleoprotein of E. coli

Escherichia coli RNase P derivatives were evolved in vitro for DNA cleavage activity. Ribonucleoproteins sampled after ten generations of selection show a >400-fold increase in the first-order rate constant (k(cat)) on a DNA substrate, reflecting a significant improvement in the chemical cleavage step. This increase is offset by a reduction in substrate binding, as measured by K(M). We trace the catalytic enhancement to two ubiquitous A-->U sequence changes at positions 136 and 333 in the M1 RNA component, positions that are phylogenetically conserved in the Eubacteria. Furthermore, although the mutations are located in different folding domains of the catalytic RNA, the first in the substrate binding domain, the second near the catalytic core, their effect on catalytic activity is significantly influenced by the presence of the C5 protein. The activity of the evolved ribonucleoproteins on both pre-4.5 S RNA and on an RNA oligo substrate remain at wild-type levels. In contrast, improved DNA cleavage activity is accompanied by a 500-fold decrease in pre-tRNA cleavage efficiency (k(cat)/K(M)). The presence of the C5 component does not buffer this tradeoff in catalytic activities, despite the in vivo role played by the C5 protein in enhancing the substrate versatility of RNase P. The change at position 136, located in the J11/12 single-stranded region, likely alters the geometry of the pre-tRNA-binding cleft and may provide a functional explanation for the observed tradeoff. These results thus shed light both on structure/function relations in E. coli RNase P and on the crucial role of proteins in enhancing the catalytic repertoire of RNA.     

The methylation of one specific guanosine in a pre-tRNA prevents cleavage by RNase P and by the catalytic M1 RNA.

Several modified nucleosides were introduced during in vitro RNA synthesis into a pre-tRNA(Ser). The pre-tRNAs were used as substrates for RNase P enzymes. No effects were observed with biotin-8-ATP or [alpha-S]-GPT, whereas with m7GTP, the cleavage reaction was completely inhibited. Analysis of pre-tRNAs which contained m7G at various positions has revealed a single base at the 5'-end of the acceptor stem where this modification absolutely prevents cleavage by catalytic M1 RNA, eukaryotic and prokaryotic RNase P holoenzymes. These results suggest that a critical contact must be made between pre-tRNA substrate and enzyme/ribozyme or that the approach of the potential cleaving agent (a positive magnesium ion) is made impossible by the positive charge at N-7 of the guanosine. In addition, we have shown that a pre-tRNA containing only m7G's can still form a complex with M1 RNA in a gel retardation assay.     

Substrate shape specificity of E coli RNase P ribozyme is dependent on the concentration of magnesium ion

The bacterial RNase P ribozyme can accept a hairpin RNA with CCA-3' tag sequence as well as a cloverleaf pre-tRNA as substrate in vitro, but the details are not known. By switching tRNA structure using an antisense guide DNA technique, we examined the Escherichia coli RNase P ribozyme specificity for substrate RNA of a given shape. Analysis of the RNase P reaction with various concentrations of magnesium ion revealed that the ribozyme cleaved only the cloverleaf RNA at below 10 mM magnesium ion. At 10 mM magnesium ion or more, the ribozyme also cleaved a hairpin RNA with a CCA-3' tag sequence. At above 20 mM magnesium ion, cleavage site wobbling by the enzyme in tRNA-derived hairpin occurred, and the substrate specificity of the enzyme became broader. Additional studies using another hairpin substrate demonstrated the same tendency. Our data strongly suggest that raising the concentration of metal ion induces a conformational change in the RNA enzyme.     

Chloroplast ribonuclease P does not utilize the ribozyme-type pre-tRNA cleavage mechanism

The transfer RNA 5' maturation enzyme RNase P has been characterized in Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya. The purified enzyme from all three kingdoms is a ribonucleoprotein containing an essential RNA subunit; indeed, the RNA subunit of bacterial RNase P RNA is the sole catalytic component. In contrast, the RNase P activity isolated from spinach chloroplasts lacks an RNA component and appears to function as a catalytic protein. Nonetheless, the chloroplast enzyme recognizes a pre-tRNA substrate for E. coli RNase P and cleaves it as efficiently and precisely as does the bacterial enzyme. To ascertain whether there are differences in catalytic mechanism between an all-RNA and an all-protein RNase P, we took advantage of the fact that phosphodiester bond selection and hydrolysis by the E. coli RNase P ribozyme is directed by a Mg2+ ion coordinated to the nonbridging pro-Rp oxygen of the scissile bond, and is blocked by sulfur replacement of this oxygen. We therefore tested the ability of the chloroplast enzyme to process a precursor tRNA containing this sulfur substitution. Partially purified RNase P from spinach chloroplasts can accurately and efficiently process phosphorothioate-substituted pre-tRNAs; cleavage occurs exclusively at the thio-containing scissile bond. The enzymatic throughput is fivefold slower, consistent with a general chemical effect of the phosphorothioate substitution rather than with a metal coordination deficiency. The chloroplast RNase P reaction mechanism therefore does not involve a catalytic Mg2+ bonded to the pro-Rp phosphate oxygen, and hence is distinct from the mechanism of the bacterial ribozyme RNase P.     

Binding and cleavage of unstructured RNA by nuclear RNase P

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is an essential endoribonuclease for which the best-characterized function is processing the 5' leader of pre-tRNAs. Compared to bacterial RNase P, which contains a single small protein subunit and a large catalytic RNA subunit, eukaryotic nuclear RNase P is more complex, containing nine proteins and an RNA subunit in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Consistent with this, nuclear RNase P has been shown to possess unique RNA binding capabilities. To understand the unique molecular recognition of nuclear RNase P, the interaction of S. cerevisiae RNase P with single-stranded RNA was characterized. Unstructured, single-stranded RNA inhibits RNase P in a size-dependent manner, suggesting that multiple interactions are required for high affinity binding. Mixed-sequence RNAs from protein-coding regions also bind strongly to the RNase P holoenzyme. However, in contrast to poly(U) homopolymer RNA that is not cleaved, a variety of mixed-sequence RNAs have multiple preferential cleavage sites that do not correspond to identifiable consensus structures or sequences. In addition, pre-tRNA(Tyr), poly(U)(50) RNA, and mixed-sequence RNA cross-link with purified RNase P in the RNA subunit Rpr1 near the active site in "Conserved Region I," although the exact positions vary. Additional contacts between poly(U)(50) and the RNase P proteins Rpr2p and Pop4p were identified. We conclude that unstructured RNAs interact with multiple protein and RNA contacts near the RNase P RNA active site, but that cleavage depends on the nature of interaction with the active site.     

Catalysis by the RNA subunit of RNase P--a minireview

RNase P, an enzyme that contains both RNA and protein components, cleaves tRNA precursors to generate mature 5' termini. The catalytic activity of RNase P resides in the RNA component, with the protein cofactor affecting the rate of the cleavage reaction. The reaction is also influenced by the nature of the tRNA substrate.     

The bacterial ribonuclease P holoenzyme requires specific, conserved residues for efficient catalysis and substrate positioning

RNase P is an RNA-based enzyme primarily responsible for 5′-end pre-tRNA processing. A structure of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme in complex with tRNA^Phe revealed the structural basis for substrate recognition, identified the active site location, and showed how the protein component increases functionality. The active site includes at least two metal ions, a universal uridine (U52), and P RNA backbone moieties, but it is unclear whether an adjacent, bacterially conserved protein loop (residues 52–57) participates in catalysis. Here, mutagenesis combined with single-turnover reaction kinetics demonstrate that point mutations in this loop have either no or modest effects on catalytic efficiency. Similarly, amino acid changes in the ‘RNR’ region, which represent the most conserved region of bacterial RNase P proteins, exhibit negligible changes in catalytic efficiency. However, U52 and two bacterially conserved protein residues (F17 and R89) are essential for efficient Thermotoga maritima RNase P activity. The U52 nucleotide binds a metal ion at the active site, whereas F17 and R89 are positioned >20 Å from the cleavage site, probably making contacts with N₋₄ and N₋₅ nucleotides of the pre-tRNA 5′-leader. This suggests a synergistic coupling between transition state formation and substrate positioning via interactions with the leader.     

Protein-Precursor tRNA Contact Leads to Sequence-Specific Recognition of 5′ Leaders by Bacterial Ribonuclease P

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) catalyzes the cleavage of 5′ leader sequences from precursor tRNAs (pre-tRNAs). Previously, all known substrate nucleotide specificities in this system are derived from RNA-RNA interactions with the RNase P RNA subunit. Here, we demonstrate that pre-tRNA binding affinities for Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli RNase P are enhanced by sequence-specific contacts between the fourth pre-tRNA nucleotide on the 5′ side of the cleavage site (N(− 4)) and the RNase P protein (P protein) subunit. B. subtilis RNase P has a higher affinity for pre-tRNA with adenosine at N(− 4), and this binding preference is amplified at physiological divalent ion concentrations. Measurements of pre-tRNA-containing adenosine analogs at N(− 4) indicate that specificity arises from a combination of hydrogen bonding to the N6 exocyclic amine of adenosine and steric exclusion of the N2 amine of guanosine. Mutagenesis of B. subtilis P protein indicates that F20 and Y34 contribute to selectivity at N(− 4). The hydroxyl group of Y34 enhances selectivity, likely by forming a hydrogen bond with the N(− 4) nucleotide. The sequence preference of E. coli RNase P is diminished, showing a weak preference for adenosine and cytosine at N(− 4), consistent with the substitution of Leu for Y34 in the E. coli P protein. This is the first identification of a sequence-specific contact between P protein and pre-tRNA that contributes to molecular recognition of RNase P. Additionally, sequence analyses reveal that a greater-than-expected fraction of pre-tRNAs from both E. coli and B. subtilis contains a nucleotide at N(− 4) that enhances RNase P affinity. This observation suggests that specificity at N(− 4) contributes to substrate recognition in vivo. Furthermore, bioinformatic analyses suggest that sequence-specific contacts between the protein subunit and the leader sequences of pre-tRNAs may be common in bacterial RNase P and may lead to species-specific substrate recognition.     

Sequence changes in both flanking sequences of a pre-tRNA influence the cleavage specificity of RNase P.

The cleavage specificities of the RNase P holoenzymes from Escherichia coli and the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe and of the catalytic M1 RNA from E. coli were analyzed in 5'-processing experiments using a yeast serine pre-tRNA with mutations in both flanking sequences. The template DNAs were obtained by enzymatic reactions in vitro and transcribed with phage SP6 or T7 RNA polymerase. The various mutations did not alter the cleavage specificity of the yeast RNase P holoenzyme; cleavage always occurred predominantly at position G + 1, generating the typical seven base-pair acceptor stem. In contrast, the specificity of the prokaryotic RNase P activities, i.e. the catalytic M1 RNA and the RNase P holoenzyme from E. coli, was influenced by some of the mutated pre-tRNA substrates, which resulted in an unusual cleavage pattern, generating extended acceptor stems. The bases G - 1 and C + 73, forming the eighth base pair in these extended acceptor stems, were an important motif in promoting the unusual cleavage pattern. It was found only in some natural pre-tRNAs, including tRNA(SeCys) from E. coli, and tRNAs(His) from bacteria and chloroplasts. Also, the corresponding mature tRNAs in vivo contain an eight base pair acceptor stem. The presence of the CCA sequence at the 3' end of the tRNA moiety is known to enhance the cleavage efficiency with the catalytic M1 RNA. Surprisingly, the presence or absence of this sequence in two of our substrate mutants drastically altered the cleavage specificity of M1 RNA and of the E. coli holoenzyme, respectively. Possible reasons for the different cleavage specificities of the enzymes, the influence of sequence alterations and the importance of stacking forces in the acceptor stems are discussed.     

Modular construction for function of a ribonucleoprotein enzyme: the catalytic domain of Bacillus subtilis RNase P complexed with B. subtilis RNase P protein

The bacterial RNase P holoenzyme catalyzes the formation of the mature 5′-end of tRNAs and is composed of an RNA and a protein subunit. Among the two folding domains of the RNase P RNA, the catalytic domain (C-domain) contains the active site of this ribozyme. We investigated specific binding of the Bacillus subtilis C-domain with the B.subtilis RNase P protein and examined the catalytic activity of this C-domain–P protein complex. The C-domain forms a specific complex with the P protein with a binding constant of ~0.1 µM. The C-domain–P protein complex and the holoenzyme are equally efficient in cleaving single-stranded RNA (~0.9 min^–1 at pH 7.8) and substrates with a hairpin–loop 3′ to the cleavage site (~40 min^–1). The holoenzyme reaction is much more efficient with a pre-tRNA substrate, binding at least 100-fold better and cleaving 10–500 times more efficiently. These results demonstrate that the RNase P holoenzyme is functionally constructed in three parts. The catalytic domain alone contains the active site, but has little specificity and affinity for most substrates. The specificity and affinity for the substrate is generated by either the specificity domain of RNase P RNA binding to a T stem–loop-like hairpin or RNase P protein binding to a single-stranded RNA. This modular construction may be exploited to obtain RNase P-based ribonucleoprotein complexes with altered substrate specificity.